How many STARS can Fit inside each STAR | 3D

[@hexum9449]

Can you do this video again using only our sun?

[@REDSIDEofficial]

Believe me, it’s impossible for a 3D Software to calculate billions of dynamics spheres, i would love to make this possible. The limit number is around 5,000 spheres, if i use beyond this the program will crash immediately 💀

[@ahmetsubakan5198]

@@REDSIDEofficial which software do you use?

[@ChrisS-nj3ye]

@@REDSIDEofficial Somebody needs a PC upgrade... joking.

[@farmasinema]

​@@REDSIDEofficialyou didn't have to calculate billions of dynamic sphere you know.

[@REDSIDEofficial]

@@ahmetsubakan5198 Unreal Engine 5.1 for scene and render, the dynamics are made in C4D with rigid body, and then exported to unreal engine as alembic.

[@cyclonicleo]

Honestly, I think using the mass of our own Sun would've worked better, just to give an idea of the sheer scale of some of these stars.

[@Akbari93]

Agreed

[@yogeshavl]

Absolutely

[@cleaneraz09]

Totally agree, this was my first thought. See conparison of different scale is too hard to follow up

[@julius6103]

At least the last one should have been filled a second time with suns

[@geemanbmw]

Agreed keep it simple stay on track 👣

[@drysoup6964]

if anyone is wondering, the reason they couldn’t animate the scale of our sun for bigger stars is because the 3D software isn’t capable of rendering that many spheres. Most softwares only can do like 5,000 sphere, and besides, it would basically just look like liquid if they could render that much.

[@KiloBravo90]

Well put, at least someone is paying attention to the "fine" details.

[@playtogertherendles]

3d🎉🎉🎉

[@MidnightMiik]

I like the animation and sound design. I kind of wish that it would’ve just used solar masses instead of much larger stars. It’s hard to keep in mind how many solar masses make up whatever star. Plus the Sun is an excellent point of reference.

[@carbonstar9091]

The issue with that is that this is not showing mass. It's showing volume. The volumetric size of a star does not necessary mean it has a huge amount of mass. The maximum mass for a star is probably 150-250 solar masses. So if you mean use solar volumes. Then yes. By the end it would pretty much appear as liquid though.

[@flamingkillermc2806]

🤓

[@cubertmiso]

@@carbonstar9091 hmm yes. both would be good. and sense of scale. it feels to me at least that the person making these, while being excellent, have distanced himself from the awe of the scale with all that 3D work

[@AussieBall_Animations]

@@flamingkillermc2806 so now just being smart means you’re a pesky nerd

[@AussieBall_Animations]

Because of the fact you’re using different stars makes it impossible to compare it with earth to these. But apart from that the animation is so smooth! Keep it up :)

[@EnlightenedMathGuy]

U just can't compare earth to this its impossible.

[@00chla50]

Nice animation. But i have no idea what the scale of anything is since the reference changes in 5 seconds.

[@cactusheart9632]

This would've been much better with our sun as the reference. The scale changing and notation is confusing without proper explanation at first.

[@tanic2]

around 1:25 there is a rendering error if you look closely if not then slow down

[@NanobanaKinako]

VV Chepei is completely forgotten in many star size comparison videos.

[@isaacquesada9296]

I just love all your animation, believe don’t give up, you will became famous ❤

[@REDSIDEofficial]

Thank you 😊

[@Saddest_Boi_In_The_West]

Awesome. I think having the main ratio of Sun-StarA, A-B, B-C, etc. on the side as permanents would be really beneficial, because I know it's impossible to put the Sun in every animation (too many entities). That way there is always a reference, at least mathematically, of the ratio of size to our Sun.

[@cadman2300]

For anyone who's curious, a quasi-star is a hypothetical type of ultra-massive star that would only have existed in the first 1-2 billion years of the universe when all matter was closer together. Unlike modern stars that are powered by nuclear fusion, a quasi-star would be powered by matter falling into a blackhole at the center, which is why they're also called blackhole stars.

[@realsizeview]

This doesnt make much sense to me. First its difficult to imagine these being big when they're placed on Earth, and then theres different suns used to fill the sphere 🥴😵‍💫

[@DreadEnder]

Ok without units the numbers are arbitrary, the first star, 728, is that 728 solar masses/radii or can you fit 728 of that star into sol? Edit: ok I get it now, because Jo523-1403 and Proxima Centauri are smaller than the sun you put those inside the sun, then after that for Vega you put the sun inside of it because it is larger. Great! It would have been more scientifically useful to put the sun into all stars larger than it for a constant variable.

[@daarko09051997]

You know what would be a cool video ? If you would animate a video of how the POV of us would look like when we would see a person, from bigger planets than ours, who are as big compared to their planet as we to planet earth

[@emir_cello]

I love it. I wouldn't ask you to make all comparisons with the sun as it will be so incredibly small towards the end of the video. Apart from the long hours of creating this animation, I think we as viewers also need to keep our imagination sharp. The environment around them is already enough to provide the perspective. It is beautiful. Well thought and done. Bravo!

[@datablux]

😂No sabia que habian tantas esferas del dragón 😂😂😂😂😂

[@Italy_Balls]

How I compare in your video?

[@Cineinsaner]

didnt understand this video so much but really good animation

[@hpfusion8842]

Considering how big our sun is compared to earth...i cant even fathom how large some of those even are

[@thebatman6201]

Especially since the scale seems to take place on a planet big enough to hold them all? A skyscraper moves in front of a larger star at one point in the video.. super confusing

[@KRATOS7514]

did you know that the presence in dc or toaa marvel can change size as big as the universe or even better the multiverse and even bigger

[@Beserker2311]

Do you do the animations yourself? If yes then bro you are amazing

[@_NAM3L355_]

I actually thought a comparison would be done at the end using suns, just to make the sheer size of these stars more relatable or understandable by the viewers. Good animation nonetheless.

[@DevKukadia]

That sound is so satisfying when the suns/stars spawn

[@DreadEnder]

YESSSSSS YOU ADDED THE QUASI STAR!!! THANK YOU! I’m a little confused on why you added a lot of the larger stars back into the quasi star much larger than they actually are, I’m assuming that would be their hypergiant phase however as far as we know all of those stars are already in their hypergiant phase so they wouldn’t become any larger or at least not much

[@DreadEnder]

@@LesGrossman_69 uhhh what?

[@DreadEnder]

@@LesGrossman_69 I don’t understand?

[@DreadEnder]

@@LesGrossman_69 I don’t speak Finnish or whatever this is

[@DreadEnder]

@@LesGrossman_69 it’s not exactly a conversation

[@DreadEnder]

@@LesGrossman_69 uhh what? You’ve been saying nonsense! Literally not even words in any language other than Finnish which you claim it isn’t. Also I’d you seriously type sigh? And I don’t like my own comments, I didn’t know that was even a thing!

[@viniciusnoyoutube]

Solar mass all the time and a galaxy on the background or space.

[@r4res502]

You are really a genius animator. Keep it up 👌

[@n.underthesun]

Just so you know. The largest star is 5 billion times larger than our sun. That makes us non-existing.

[@TheKyleBrah]

This video can hard for us to comprehend when not always using reference points we somewhat understand, like our Sun's size. (And even then, its actual size can be hard to comprehend as is!) That said, I do understand that rendering all those Suns for the later stars would have been impossible, or would take literal hours, if not days, to render as you aren't Pixar. But perhaps in a future video, you can use a star that holds approximately 1'000 Suns. (I'm aware that a 1'000 can still be a beach to render.) That way, you can then start using this "Star A" as our "1'000 Suns" reference. Repeat by finding "Star B," which is 1'000 Star A's, and therefore, "1'000'000 Suns," and so on. Would be great if you can do this. But otherwise, thanks for this fantastic video!

[@Mosiah12]

Could you a video about One Piece ?

[@DreadEnder]

Huh, I’ve seen planets inside stars and other planets but not stars inside other stars! ( obviously we’ve soon solar masses and solar radii but no animations) so this is really cool!

[@poshmoguls9887]

How big is the planet they’re filming this on???? That’s what I’m wondering…. 😂

[@Abrold]

on Earth

[@zeddfarooq4678]

It was a little bit difficult to remember the sizes, please fix the comparison object it would be much easier to get an idea.

[@painauchocolate2395]

Beautiful video… but the scale is somewhat lost for those without knowledge of the stars. Hardly anybody knows even that 1M earths fit in the sun!

[@galactus21]

very satisfying watching this video, thank you!

[@Solarwhale32]

good video agian

[@Abrold]

And the crazy thing is that the Most Common Type of Stars in the Universe are Red dwarfs stars which is way smaller than our sun its take up about 85% of numbers of stars in the entire universe yet our sun is just a medium size average star

[@manishranamagar7073]

Awesome video mate👍❤️

[@TrollJuicer420]

This Is What I've Been Waiting For

[@truthhurts9241]

Thanks for that, now I feel even more insignificant than I did 4 minutes ago. Lovely work though, I really enjoy your videos. Regards...

[@MeowO_O]

So much energy in the universe and here we are paying 20 cents per kwh... If only we could harness 100% energy of Centuri we'd have no power problems for millions of years!

[@MeowO_O]

@@amolbhole23 No. If our electric spaceships want to open wormholes in the future, the sun wouldn't be enough!

[@KameronWilliamsMusicPage]

So the Quasi Star fits 296 Betelgeuse Stars 1 Betelgeuse Star fits 1136 Rigel Stars 1 Rigel Star fits 8 Arcturus Stars 1 Arcturus Star fits 497 Vega Stars 1 Vega Star fits 8 Suns By this logic, 1 Quasi Star would fit 10,695,630,848 Suns. 1 Sun can fit 1.3 million Earths, so 1 Quasi star would fit 13,904,320,102,400,000 Earths.

[@Abrold]

thats so big!

[@ErenxYeager]

What software do you use bro?

[@andrewjenery1783]

Going by this, many stars would engulf the Solar System many times over.

[@TheJustUsLeague]

Should have used a planet in our system for size scale/comparison.

[@trevorjohnson2168]

How long did this take to render??

[@DarthCrow]

Nice animation

[@natureloving66]

I am compelled by ur editing to subscribe u ❣️❣️

[@jsmariani4180]

I like the inclusion of buildings, you know, just for scale.

[@imeogo6524]

WHAT A GREAT IDEA TO EXPLAIN IN DETAILS WOW ✨

[@rezaahdi100]

What is your software?

[@hoople212]

I did a little bit of math, and if our sun was a hydrogen atom (140 picometers) the VY Canis Majoris (second last one, see reason below) would be .19 millimeters or the thickness of cardstock paper... If the sun was the size of a grape (1.5 cm) the VY Canis Majoris would be about 21 kilometers... Thats wild. Have fun with that knowledge! (the Quasi star doesn't exist, its hypothesized to have existed at the beginning of the universe).

[@Abrold]

Cap So Cap How the Hell is 1000 time radi makes star 21 km when sun is just 1.5 cm

[@heut4384]

What if, we're wrong about each star of the size? ....and may be the big ones where actually closest to us and then, they're actually not big at all? And what if, all stars are the same size??

[@bogiesontracks]

Such creative videos you’ve on this channel. Just subscribed!

[@tupera1]

What an amazing creator Jehovah is!!!

[@Ollied]

A bit confusing the follow, but still an amazing video, thank you

[@randomyoutubeenjoyer6010]

Nobody:minecraft mob spawner

[@src6339]

I assume that these are all being packed into spheres for transit to the galaxy construction area...

[@side-fish]

It's like cheeseballs inside a sphere 😮

[@LittleSkepticalButStillSmart]

Imagine how many 2MASS J0523-1403's could fit inside a quasi star

[@IvanShel]

You made it by Unity?

[@IRRIRed]

Wow nice video

[@MZ-bl6wg]

It should have stuck with how many earths, when it started shifting to how many stars , most people lose any grasp of an idea of how big it is. At least with the earth they can try to comprehend the earths size and then multiply that but 75% of these used other stars so it lost its “wow” factor early in the video .

[@nPcDrone]

I expected something different. Thought you were going to do something like put Ariana Grande, Taylor Swift, and Nicole Kidman inside of Kristy Alley

[@Pinkoshaberibunny]

STARCEPTION!

[@wotreplays777]

Сумасшедшие размеры звёзд🤯

[@roxaslight7503]

Kinda wondering if you accounted for the empty space between each star. If you did great, but you kept them as spheres as you show it, there is plenty of empty space in-between each of them and this representation is inaccurate. There is quite a bit more volume that could fit more stars...

[@katelee670]

Just wow that's sick

[@alitlweird]

some stars are smaller than a lot of buildings. Some are only slightly larger.

[@TizoRami]

Everyone here saying to have used the sun, you need a computer and a graphics card that can sustain large amount of processing power. I highly doubt a computer is able to show 5000 suns anything more it will crash

[@waseempatel353]

How large are the buildings in the background?

[@decract]

I love how the sun is smaller than human if we compare to the city

[@Perktube1]

So all the peace stars at the end are the same, right?

[@raphapam07]

the two first stars, are the only one smaller than the sun?

[@HumbertoTheRookieTrucker]

This is one of the channels that have the must nice graphics

[@punguseki]

Those are some tall ass buildings in the background

[@DamiSmart]

1:14 IT TURNS OUT IT ALWAYS STARTS. WITH SUPERGIANTS

[@soupedenuit]

The snow on those mountains in the back should be melted by now.

[@ofmane3008]

Wow i expected uy scuti to be bigger

[@ZoranDekic]

After new (well, not so new anymore) measurements, UY Scuti radii have been actually reduced below VY Canis Majoris.

[@sonne30poland30]

the reference point should always be the sun... when the reference point changes to other stars, the viewer starts to get lost !!!

[@Khanza132]

Fact that we're just a dust

[@keepsmiling5937]

1000 Arctus into pistol 😌

[@Narrativerse]

Excuse me, but how did you calculate the sphere packing density?

[@funkymundda3623]

i told him

[@Narrativerse]

@@funkymundda3623 ???

[@funkymundda3623]

@@Narrativerse nothing just kidding

[@andrefarfan4372]

Nice

[@kasemahasema]

10000 Stars

[@user-fb4hk5ix6c]

Later,the background is mountain

[@IntimateRush]

Could you do size comparison to the earth the size of a grain of salt?

[@Kbmzomi]

What about the small gaps in between, we gonna ignore those?

[@BootCampSpecimen]

You’re right. But also you’re over thinking it. It’s just how many beans can fit in a jar concept. We don’t need to melt beans to fill the gaps.

[@Narrativerse]

They aren't ignoring them. You can fit 13.1 Suns into Vega (by volume conversion), yet the animation says 8. So the gap is accounted.

[@khc8800]

It’s not clear in the beginning what the yellow balls are. Why the size of a motorcycle helmet? Then what are the slightly bigger red balls filling the same size sphere?

[@entropybear5847]

No-one wants to talk about how big that terrestrial planet is?

[@SohamiaEmpire1212]

So the quasi star is 17 times the mass of Stephenson 2-18

[@coled9566]

i like you

[@ChuHsiangLin]

How many earth fits in 2-18 ?

[@Dark_side9999]

Didn't know that all these sun can fit in the earth

[@spider-off8896]

Make opm size comparation

[@jairon_2518]

So this is taking in count the distribution, just as the atomic packing factor? I mean, spheres inside other spheres packing factor

[@rockerspoint6727]

Can you tell how you do this

[@rockerspoint6727]

Hi thanks for the gift by the way I have messaged on the number now what to do next

[@pande_kejos]

next please only sun

[@efremvanone3305]

Bro I have a TikTok channel where I post your videos by mentioning and tagging you, does that bother you? you make crazy videos!

[@dineshbouddh6315]

Fun fact:pistol star is the heaviest star IN the milky way