How the US Stole Hawaii

[@Jimmy_Widders_Hunt]

“When the missionaries came to Africa they had the Bible and we had the land. They said "Let us pray." We closed our eyes. When we opened them we had the Bible and they had the land.”-- Desmond Tutu.

[@sunnysied713]

Westerners were interacting with Native Hawaiians for 40 years BEFORE any missionaries arrived to Hawai'i. Lol. Westerners who migrated to Hawai'i and became denizens, citizens and royal subjects of the Hawaiian Kingdom. They bought and leased land legally.

[@ashokbobade9257]

@@sunnysied713 just like native American were slaughtered

[@sunnysied713]

@@ashokbobade9257 The U.S. didn't slaughter Native Hawaiians. The history of Native Hawaiians is very different from Native Americans.

[@xyrox8248]

😎😎

[@theredman9151]

@@sunnysied713 No but they stole their land and was willing to slaughter them if need be

[@anunaykumar9736]

" They came to our lands and had bibles in their hands and when they went we had the bibles and they had the land "

[@kartik.chauhan]

Quite typical for European descendants...

[@shaikhasker]

Typical from another Arab faith also

[@kartik.chauhan]

@@shaikhasker Quite hypocritical of US and Europe to shut them down tho

[@JTMog]

Imagine if an Indian youtuber made a video saying "India stole a land" everyone knows how that'll go, ahhem "boycott" ahem "antinational"

[@kartik.chauhan]

@@JTMog Crowd gonna barge into that lads house, make him apologize on camera and then if he's lucky not kill him... Meanwhile Indian media will take out his and his family's whole history and claim he was sponsored by terrorist organisations.

[@kidatanakafan]

"Jesus Sugar Americans" is probably the best term ever

[@hosank]

right?

[@johnnyharris]

that's my highly technical historical term. 😆

[@cyberpokey]

Only it makes them sound wholesome and sweet when they are clearly not.

[@jackiguess]

johnny, can you please pin this comment?

[@-Anjel]

Aren't they the ones still running the US?

[@carlosocintron]

Thanks!

[@gmunz3643]

US: *colonizes entire country* US 100 years later: "sorry we stole your country" US immediately after: "it's still ours tho."

[@rocketblogs2874]

Ikr like bruh if ur gonna apologize at least give them their independence back.

[@neozeon2567]

G Munz Countries of Europeans empires colonized the half the world and they never apologizes

[@TheThekoopalings]

neo zeon at least they have the countries back

[@XxKagarwaxX]

@@neozeon2567 and they actually did numerous times. Not all but a bunch did

[@neozeon2567]

Kevin countries of former colonies are still affected & suffering from Europeans colonialism and still waiting for reparations and they only gained independent after genocidal wars from their former Europeans masters during the late 20s century

[@aerophy2894]

You can really tell that the US inherited some british traits... Edit: Call me CIA, cus I be starting conflicts in the comment section.

[@sunnysied713]

Such as?

[@dennisschwartzentruber3204]

@@sunnysied713 /You can't see the connections...study history much ?

[@sunnysied713]

@@dennisschwartzentruber3204 I know a lot about Hawaiian history. How was the U.S. like the British in Hawai'i? It's a pretty simple question.

[@ziggy6060]

@@sunnysied713 How on Earth did this go over your head?

[@sunnysied713]

@@ziggy6060 Do you know how it didn't go over my head?😏 Let me make it easier for you to understand... Did Kamehameha conquer and unify the islands on his own? No, he needed great help from westerners (British and Americans). Did the United States or Great Britain declare or claim Hawai'i as a colony? No. Did kanaka, westerners and asians build the country together? Yes, every step of the way. Were the westerners and asians denizens, citizens and royal subjects of Hawai'i? Yes. Did the westerners and asians live, work, pay taxes and support the Hawaiian Kingdom? Yes, the haole had a long history with Hawai'i from 1778 through 1893. Was the Hawaiian Kingdom a multiethnic, multicultural and multinational society? Yes. Did the Hawaiian Kingdom request protectorate status or annexation from other countries? Yes. King Kamehameha wanted to make Hawai'i a British protectorate (1800s). King Kamehameha III wanted to make Hawai'i a U.S. protectorate (1851) and later requested annexation by the U.S. (1854). King Kalākaua wanted to become a Japanese protectorate (1881). Did the United States 'steal' Hawai'i? No, the U.S. declined an annexation request in 1851 and 1893. The Republic of Hawaii requested annexation in 1898 (five years after the monarchy's overthrow) and the U.S. accepted. If the U.S. were greedy, landgrabbing colonialists, then why didn't they grab Hawai'i sooner? They weren't. Did the United States overthrow the Monarchy? No, the Morgan Report exonerated the U.S. soldiers and agents of any involvement in the Revolution of 1893. I suggest you look at the Committee of Safety and the Honolulu Rifles. There were 1,100 - 1,600 angry hawaiians who overthrew Queen Lili'uokalani after she attempted an illegal and unconstitutional power grab. Some Hawaiians wanted to maintain the monarchy, some wanted a republic and some wanted annexation. Was Hawai'i an American colony? No, it was a country that got annexed by the U.S. after the Revolution of 1893 led to the creation of a provisional government and later the Republic of Hawaii. The rebels had control of the government and requested annexation. Did some colonists object to secession from the British Empire? Yes. Did some Texans object to annexation? Yes. Did some Californians object annexation? Yes. Did some kanaka object to Kamehameha's conquest of Hawai'i? Yes. Does it matter? No, the government decides what happens with the territory. There's no requirement for public referendum or plebiscite. Did Native Hawaiians wanted Statehood? Yes, Native Hawaiian activists lobbied hard for Statehood. In 1919, Prince Kūhio even wrote the first Statehood Bill. Did 93% of Hawaiian voters choose statehood? Yes. Did the hawaiians receive all the same rights as Americans? Yes. The Organic Act of 1900 gave Hawaiians U.S. citizenship and the Statehood Act of 1959 gave them representation in Congress and the right to vote in federal elections. See, the U.S. didn't 'steal' Hawai'i.😉

[@xcrazyghostx9566]

You should do a video about Puerto Rico. The Us government tried “Americanizing” the people here and they put Gag laws and many horrible things.

[@quiks11ver]

Please

[@nelissarocas7286]

Same thing here in the Philippines. 🤷‍♀️

[@LIZLISA137]

also guam!!!

[@marisolnewell]

yess do Puerto Rico!!! Also itll be great seeing other videos on other US "territories" (colonies). People dont even know that Guam, Northern Mariana Islands etc are part of the US

[@jimgood1949]

Puerto Rico should demand independence.

[@wihlke]

The almost complete loss of the Hawaiian language is one of the biggest losses (to me as a language lover). It would be interesting to hear more about the system of government Hawaii had in place before the Americans came.

[@seanimal_555]

same here in our country. this colonizers fucking up our culture coz of their supremacist bullshit.

[@francois9747]

I hope you've dived into austronesian languages as a language lover. You will go bananas.

[@emmaswann5255]

Lol it IS lost

[@justjoaoo]

Yesss, I'm trying to learn hawaiian right now all because when I really liked Hawaii, I found out the language was going extinct. I think it's like a small tiny role I'm playing in reviving the language

[@dougkelley2781]

In my view Hawaiian is the most beautiful language on earth. Do some searches on Hawaiian language and music. There is a lot of effort now to preserve and reestablish the language. Hopefully it will take.

[@shangerdanger]

Great video. It's crazy how few people know about this. They see Hawai'i as just a place to vacation. The exploitation continues from 100s of years ago to today

[@ConradLihilihi]

This video barely scratches the surface. If you’d like to really learn about Hawai’i, watch this Smithsonian docuseries kzbin.info/www/bejne/d2mlYXxngc2Una8

[@Dreadlock1227]

Aloha Look, I get what you’re saying, but at this point, there’s generations of non Hawaiians that call Hawaii home. I’m a haole, but I was born and raised in Hawaii, as was my mom, grandparents and great grandparents. My family has been here since WW1, and as much as the history of Hawaii and the subjugation of its people breaks my heart, especially knowing that my ancestors likely participated in it in some way or another, it’s still my home and always will be. All I can do is respect the land and culture and try my best to right some of the wrongs of the past.

[@kaptenlemper]

@@Dreadlock1227 or, y'know, start petitioning for an independent Hawaiian state.

[@TheWcarD]

If it wasn't us it would be owned by Japan now.

[@TheWcarD]

@@Dreadlock1227 Bet you are glad Japan doesn't own it.

[@dobresambrat]

The censoring of how Hawaii was really taken is a perfect example of "History is written by the victor"

[@watermelooneboi8465]

"and here i was thinking we had won"

[@gaiusjuliuscaesar4256]

The history has not been censored. Go literally anywhere and you will see the true story. We do not hide let alone censor our history.

[@gaiusjuliuscaesar4256]

@Hell Razor To say that it is not taught in any American high school is a dangerous assumption. You are classifying "any and all" as public high schools, which have a lower standard of education and aren't so good about giving the full story. However private and charter schools do a much better job at teaching the full story. The same is true in Germany from my experience.

[@gaiusjuliuscaesar4256]

@Hell Razor We did not genocide the Hawaiians. We committed very few war crimes during WW2 in comparison to the USSR or the British Empire, and the majority of them were against German Pilots or Soldiers, people who deserved what they received. Besides, in comparison with other historical events, the annexation of Hawaii and the treatment of natives are not very important in US history, it isn't worth teaching it. Also, curriculum varies from state to state, and it can also vary from school to school, just for your information.

[@gaiusjuliuscaesar4256]

@Hell Razor I do not prove this point exactly, I did research on my own time, here it is: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allied_war_crimes_during_World_War_II#United_Kingdom The list of British and Soviet war crimes is far longer than that of American War crimes, and most American War crimes were against the German soldiers and pilots, as well as concentration camp wardens. Look it up anywhere and you will see that the was no Hawaii Genocide. I even used a VPN to relocate myself to Palau, and there is NOTHING saying that there was a Hawaiian genocide. You clearly made this up for the purposes of proving a point. I believe that YOU are the one that needs to go learn real history. The United States does not teach us to be slaves that obey the system. If that was true, there would be no progressive people like Democrats, whose whole ideology is based off of challenging the system as it is. I do question the system, for instance why do certain classes need to be taught to students? Like Language Arts. It is quite useless to know this if you want to be something like a surgeon or construction worker, etc. Perhaps you should educate yourself first before you insult my education. You are seeing false history, and history that never happened. You are the true failure of the system here, not me.

[@meostyles]

The Dole company was also behind some of the US military occupations in Central American 'banana-republics' (Nicaragua, Guatemala etc.)

[@ritadecassia279]

That’s why this part of Central America is so unstable. Because whom rules this country are this banana’s company, whom help dictatorship to keep in power, so that they can do whatever they want. For profit. And yet they USA is complaining because this people are running away from their country to the USA to escape poverty and criminality.

[@RowOfMushyTiT]

Banana republics are not bad, if you deal in, eh, bananas...

[@kenster8270]

Was it? I thought Chiquita was involved

[@patricktaw2435]

Ken I thought it was a bunch of companies. United fruit company, dole, Chiquita and the US government.

[@CarlosRodriguez-st6oi]

My family is from Colombia and the United Fruit company with the help of the U.S government orchestrated a massacre in which many colombian workers were killed just because they wanted dignified working conditions.

[@Autumnisms]

Thank you so much for making this video, as a Hawaiian… we’re happy to see that people are trying to properly educate what really happened to Hawaii and our people.

[@2x4tigerbear77]

It sure didn't talk about how Queen Lili'uokalani was plotting to cancel the constitution and create a new one to increase the power of her monarchy. That was unlawful and against the constitution of the time. This video didn't talk about how the Kingdom of Hawaii consisted of many different people and cultures. And it definitely didn't talk about the power struggle between Native Hawaiian elitists, royalists, immigrants, republicanists, etc. It didn't talk about the corruption of Kalākaua or Hawaii's numerous political, economic and other problems. In short, this video was propaganda, loaded with misrepresentation and omissions from history. Mostly lies and distortions.

[@redsoil2495]

@@2x4tigerbear77 It’s ironic you accuse Harris of omitting history when you literally did just that. While it’s true Liliuokalani was trying to make a new constitution, that was because she wanted to reverse the effects of the Bayonet Constitution. The BC basically forced the king to give much of his power to all these corrupt pro-American plantation owners (who were responsible for exploiting thousands of Asian laborers, some of whom were my ancestors).

[@mickcutter]

Your own people sold you out

[@naychiv9325]

Yes sir! That's why I say FREE HAWAII!

[@naychiv9325]

@@2x4tigerbear77 Whities go home! Free the Hawaiians! Free Guam! Free Puerto Rico! Free the Indians!

[@zeffery101]

Americans now: We can't have immigrants coming and taking over our economy Also Americans: Goes to island as immigrants and takes over the economy

[@yaakovbennett]

You say that as if it was the same people doing both

[@grafikar5114]

@@yaakovbennett same country at least

[@huh2726]

A Majority of Americans are of European descent so if they don't want to have immigrants in their country they should just unexist or flocking back to Europe by the millions

[@kaptenlemper]

@@yaakovbennett the wealth and prosperity enjoyed by Americans today is in part sourced from the unlawful occupation, annexation and exploitation of Hawaii. So yeah, still holds.

[@griffisjm]

@@kaptenlemper you say that as if hawaii is 50% of americas economy! LOL!! Im quite sure the USA could easily exist without a few islands full of progressive Democrats in the middle of the Pacific Ocean.

[@Ambigious]

Bill Clinton: Sorry we stole your land Native hawaii: Oh so we are getting it back, or atleast protection for our sacred locations? Bill Clinton: Oh lol, no

[@MrHistory269]

Yea as a Native Hawaiian nobody gives sht about his apology it meant nothing to us

[@sdshakazulu4268]

Who owes you an apology?

[@Ambigious]

Kalani Volkoff Watch the video

[@sdshakazulu4268]

Here’s what I’m saying. The Hawaiians were waring against each other stealing each others land, killing each other. Until Kamehameha United the islands. So what if my ansestors were on the loosing side becoming slaves to kamehameha?.. this is the way of the world. So who to blame. Some Hawaiian people know that no man can own the land. It is not yours to own. If you can own the land, you could own the sky and sea as well.

[@Ambigious]

Kalani Volkoff What I am commenting about was the fact that Clinton made an apology, acknowledging the fact that what the US did was horrible, but instead of actually doing something about it, he continues to allow, for example, futher damaging sacred sites. Meaning that the apology wasnt at all an apology, just using the american past for his own benefit.

[@alyssiatucker4406]

As someone who has lived in Hawai'i their whole life, I can tell you that the culture is one of the most amazing parts of living here. If you have ever been to Hawai'i (and I mean really been, like full Johnny style, immersing yourself in the culture and not just staying at a resort) then you know how loving and kind and incredible the people here are. My family used to run a Bed and Breakfast before the recent lava flow took out our home, and this was by far the most common reason people stated for wanting to return someday. With the recent protests on the Mauna, and ongoing struggle to keep sacred lands safe on Kaho'olawe, Pōhakuloa, and many many more places, it has created a way for the entire world to see how hurt and outraged Native Hawaiians are by everything the US has done to them. While they are some of the most resilient people I have ever known, it is hard. It is really really hard to see how the government doesn't care much about giving the people what they want. In a way, it is similar to what is happening in the BLM protests right now, as higher ups are giving people supplemental things, but not really what they want. A great example is the state that Kaho'olawe was left in when it was returned to the Hawaiian people. The island was supposed to be completely cleared of ordnance left by the US Navy. They were given 10 years, and get this, 400 million dollars. They only cleared 75% of the island, and many parts are still left highly dangerous to this day. Not to mention, the water table was literally broken. There is no fresh water on Kaho'olawe because the Navy put enough TNT on it to simulate an atomic bomb. That's not a joke, that was actually their intention. So after some ranting, I hope you learned something. The Hawaiian people are over being stomped on by the US. Period. P.S. this was written by a 15 year old so don't say "but I'm too young to worry about things like this" because you aren't!! Learn about the world and the place that you live! Also sorry for making this comment so long there is a lot to say about this topic.

[@kevinlee9444]

You make more sense as a fifteen year old than most adults do these days. Speak up! 🤙

[@imperialchimpanzee122]

Kaho'olawe was technically made uninhabitable or at least barren because of goats. But yes, those bombs are awful. Unexploded ordnance is not fun. My parents were from Laos, the most bombed country in the world (because the ho chi mihn trail was built there). There are numerous times where kids today are maimed because of the bombs. Maybe it's just me, but I can't say the culture in hawaii is perfect or even all that loving, depending on who you are. There is blatant racism that is unspoken in Hawaii (can you guess?). People there seem to care little about education and are politically lazy. I don't know which island your from though as culture does differ slightly.

[@ConradLihilihi]

If you’d like to learn more, here’s a Smithsonian doc that does an amazing job filling in the holes and taking us through the events leading to the overthrow. kzbin.info/www/bejne/d2mlYXxngc2Una8

[@ConradLihilihi]

Imperial Chimpanzee if you’d like to learn about how Hawai’i goes from the most literate nation in the world with an incredibly politically active population to “caring little about education and lazy politically” you should should watch this docuseries kzbin.info/www/bejne/d2mlYXxngc2Una8

[@josemanuelmurguia8970]

Too much text but yes!

[@julianhendrix]

As someone born in Hawaii and raised there for a period of my life, I think that this was a perfect description and also this is the reason why my family does not buy dole pineapples

[@xtripx4273]

I will never buy dole stuff again.

[@julianhendrix]

@@xtripx4273 good thank you palala

[@alexhando8541]

No-one: America: Looks like you need sum *freedom* son! Hawaii: But we are already a *democratic nation* America: *DID I ASK FOR YOU OPINION?!* (Edit: I've checked and during the time of the coup d'etat, the Kingdom of Hawaii was a constitutional monarchy, similar to that of post-WW2 Japan as its constitution was a written one, unlike that of the UK. It's Prime Minister was elected by the people and he held the ultimate power rather than the monarch, who was head of state, but acted as a ceremonial figurehead of the country.)

[@kallenmurphy]

My g, they weren't democratic before, they were a patriarch. They had a king. But they were peaceful

[@zachbrannigan3184]

They were a monarchy before, not a democracy

[@xKuukkelix]

@@kallenmurphy not really a patriarchy if they also had a queen. It's just a monarchy

[@brukernavn142]

@@xKuukkelix and monarchy is not democratic

[@someonesch4361]

@@brukernavn142 neither is US oligarchy

[@takiranayaki7870]

"I like your Christ but I don't like you christians, you christians are so unlike your Christ." - Ghandi

[@rizpahcardoza4817]

I think you mean Gandhi, sorry didn't mean to offend you. But Ghandi means two different things in Indian regional languages namely- Dirty(in Hindi) and mad (in Gujarati). But other than that, I agree with your comment

[@RajPatel-pb7oo]

@@rizpahcardoza4817 Gaandi means Mad for Girls. Gaando means Mad for Men in Gujarati. Gandhi is Mahatma Gandhi search who is. Gandu or Gandharu ( a silent) means dirty things or unclean. Small changes in pronounce makes a huge difference in Gujarati language.

[@rizpahcardoza4817]

@@RajPatel-pb7oo duly noted, I spoke from what I remember. Not a Gujarati, but a little from what I remember. But Ghandi does mean dirty, but hi i guess we are missing the point here😅.

[@davel7037]

Lol he didn't say that

[@rizpahcardoza4817]

@@davel7037 he actually did, of course the comment words it a little differently, but he did.

[@jos7006]

US: *violent takeover of Hawaiian territory* 100 years later US: “i’m sorrrryyyy… we good?”

[@pierceplaysstudios245]

I mean yeah but what else should we do?

[@jos7006]

@@pierceplaysstudios245 if you steal someone’s bike, and they catch you, what should you do?

[@pierceplaysstudios245]

@@jos7006 probably make up an excuse for why I took it

[@SmashGhost]

@@pierceplaysstudios245 GIVE. IT. BACK.

[@pierceplaysstudios245]

@@SmashGhost HELL. NO.

[@skyval6359]

Queen Liliuokalani was a gifted composer and every once in awhile I hear a beautiful little melody on the classical music station and it usually melts my heart , they are so sweet and beautiful . Aloha Oe is her composition too and it will make you cry . Love her .

[@dougkelley2781]

You are perhaps referring to “The Queen’s Prayer,” which she wrote while under house arrest, expressing hope that her niece, the Princess Ka’iulani, would be able to lead her people. It makes me weep every time I hear it.

[@sebibalbi]

Hawaii: exists us government: hippity hoppity this Is now our property

[@seanbrummfield448]

Britain: I'm proud of you my son!!!

[@kaen_tqk3918]

Nobody: America: *looks like somebody needs some JESUS*

[@owencity77]

in return, I'll take your land

[@Kangroo11]

nice comment

[@begejekan1244]

That's basically most of Europe as well, I guess they take after their colonizers lol

[@TheLaXandro]

And clocks and guns too

[@jaykesner4610]

Actually the Hawaiian kingdom abolished their old religion willingly in order to become more westernized which left the door wide open for missionaries to come here and push their religion.

[@rohan34]

Indigenous peoples all over the world have struggled a lot against imperialism. It is painful.

[@Killinemkid]

The wheel will turn

[@rRaiyan2]

Rohan ????

[@rRaiyan2]

Hey I can read Assamese : D

[@mysterious7215]

@@rRaiyan2 Yes

[@user-zp1dv4yh5e]

Leon Trotsky really you know Axomiya!!

[@ForTheOmnissiah]

Being a born and raised southern American, Hawaiians fighting to keep their culture alive and continuing the fight is absolute awesome to see. NEVER give up, and fight the state! You have a beautiful heritage, and it must live on.

[@TimBarnard]

....and what heritage are you fighting to keep....?

[@MCreedon34]

You know what culture they're talking about... ​@@TimBarnard

[@noahbowie5985]

Nobody: Britain: *Hey Hawaii, you need a flag!!*

[@DenDave_]

They already had one, the Hawaiiens merely adopted the british flag as part of their own original flag.

[@James-ip8xs]

Speaking to Hawaiins when visiting, I was shocked how many didn't even know why or care why they had the Union Jack in their State flag.

[@KingdomEnfilade]

The British have always been excellent flag-allocators.

[@shangerdanger]

Hae Hawai'i (Hawaiian flag) was inspired by the allegiance to Britain. They acknowledged Hawai'i sovereignty along with many other countries of the world. The flag was kept as the state flag.

[@shangerdanger]

@@James-ip8xs that's part of history being erased here and replaced with US history

[@fargoflagrant7796]

today we're gonna talk about the US' tropical island colony Puerto Rico: :D no, not that one Puerto Rico: :c Guam: hello Northern Marianas: what's up guys American Samoa: *snaps family picture* Chagos: ... oh great so we're just gonna keep pretending like I don't exist

[@blockbust3r822]

So underrated comment

[@satoshiketchump]

Chagos is British Overseas Territory

[@JasonBournee]

@@satoshiketchump Sure, but you need to read up more on why the British hold this particular Archipelago.

[@satoshiketchump]

@@JasonBournee I know

[@admina.r.9727]

satoshiketchump Diego garcia was sold (illegally and secretly) to the us..

[@kawizzle]

It’s so enlightening to see the history of my culture displayed accurately and succinctly for the new Information Age.. although just 10 mins long, I’m in tears just as you reach your conclusion and ad-read. Thank you for making this video, I appreciate your channel and content.

[@AmandeepSingh-te5zk]

Yeah ..its great. So you still sprak hawai language?

[@sidjtd]

This video was super shallow. I have no issue with the video crapping all over the US and it revealing the sad take over of Hawaii, but this is like a propaganda 10 minute primer that is also scripted In a way to manipulate your emotions into one direction. It’s not meant to be educational besides for people who literally knew nothing about Hawaii, but it may be worse since it kinda dumbs down Hawaii’s insanely Rich history. Hawaii is suffering but Hawaii is not just a helpless victim. Hawaii is a key character in the world. It’s the only Indigenous “American” language to be growing in use. It’s struggles are real. But so is historical struggle. Where Hawaii needs to be right now is hard to say. But I think it can be achieved. I don’t know how exaclty

[@shushunk00]

See its normal every powerful group in any region tries to control in whatever way they can but the European rulers were global oppressors and rest of the rulers un asia and south america africa were local oppressors and usa and canada was amalgamation of European in aplace which has more resources land to operate and they did the same what their separate rulers from europe did global expansion and ruling and business ,every country where caucasian were born or taken over a new land and never left are far more richer than any other countries (where the resources and people were exploited for the benefit of the settlers and they left the regions with almost everything nothing to spare for the locals) So in present day we call them developed and developing countries respectively. Btw this is not a hate sort of comment i wrote this cuz u said u were emotional for a small region they are in a condition where living standard are much higher than that of any developing countries has.

[@xstoofpeer]

@@sidjtd Wtf are you trying to say? He literally said that Hawaiian culture is still thriving even despite US colonization

[@ConradLihilihi]

This is barely this history. Watched this Smithsonian doc for more detail. kzbin.info/www/bejne/d2mlYXxngc2Una8

[@kkperu6375]

@Johnny Harris, as a Native Hawaiian, mahalo for making this video. Because the Hawaiian Language (we know it as Olelo) was outlawed in schools, and due to increasing pressures to become westernized and so called "normal," we lost alot of the cultural nuances that connects us to the ancient version of our native language. The most authentic Hawaiian you will hear is that spoken by a kupuna (elder) who is fluent (which is rare), or by someone born and raised on Niihau (also rare). It's similar Tahitian and Samoan. The language taught in Hawaiian language immersive schools is much different, and is not the same as the ancient tongue which has been an unfortunate result of the language-shaming in the early 1900s. Because Hawaiians did not write, we only passed on knowledge by story telling and by doing, we lost alot of our culture. I'm nearly 40 and have only just started learning things that my ancestors did, which is sad when you think about it. We've had to struggle to piece back together incomplete pieces of our culture so that we can revitalize our people, but it's a process and arguably we lost much of our ancient knowledge. It's only through those stubborn ones like those who kept practicing the old ways like Hula or crafts, or traditional fishing who keep the cultural flame alive for us try and move the ball forward one yard at a time (painstakingly). How shame right? We have to reinvent our culture in a way and connect the dots. With all of that said, besides the over-tourism, the biggest slap in our face these days is when people of non-native blood name their children Hawaiian names: those are our names and they cannot begin to understand the vast meanings which each name (long or short) has. We consider it disrespectful and most names have multiple meanings, including negative ones.

[@MichaelPrimacio-hj1vy]

Aloha Johnny it is good that the haole want a Hawaiian name. They going help us restore what their ancestors tried to erase.

[@whoisharo4689]

Americans: "why are you speaking in that language in MY state?"

[@34103070674978532046]

No ka mea like pū ka ʻōlelo Hawaiʻi i ka ʻōlelo Haole

[@thelivingdead1728]

@trosky677 You STFU

[@kcggaming5138]

Poor gdp and just look at the other Polynesian islands they would have about a couple millions.

[@davidstevens3371]

No need to call anybody a haole! I was born on Oahu lived in makaha, I have much respect for the Hawaiian people.

[@34103070674978532046]

@@davidstevens3371 E kamipulu, ā hoka! No laila: ʻo ʻŌlelo Haole ka inoa no English Language. A hui hou kāua, mālama pono.

[@wego808]

As a native Hawaiian, Mahalo for telling our story. We are still fighting to be recognized like Native Americans. Yes we voted to become a state but talking with people from that time they said they had to make a choice between being slaves or becoming a state. We took the lesser of the evil.

[@sunnysied713]

The Hawaiian Kingdom country was built by kanaka, westerners and asians. It was a country and nothing like a Native American tribe. The Territory of Hawai'i wasn't slave-like. Lol. Many native hawaiian activists lobbied hard for statehood because they wanted the full benefits of being a State (such as Representatives, Senators, Presidential Election, federal money, etc). In 1919, Prince Kūhio even wrote the first Statehood Bill.

[@sunnysied713]

@Noel Noel White boy? Lol. You don't know my ohana. Hawai'i is free. Most of us love being part of the United States. Also, if people are going to learn about our history, then they should learn about all of it - not just some victim mentality propaganda. History isn't simple, cut-and-dry, black-and-white. I encourage everyone to research, verify and confirm everything that they read, see and hear.

[@vtron9832]

As a Puerto Rican, I feel you and hopefully we will learn from your people’s hardships and not become a US state.

[@Tyso808]

@@sunnysied713 I mean the U.S banned are language. Most people don't know it now. Banned hula. We barley have land. Molokai is like a is like one of the only places where Hawaiians can go to sense they tallest building is only three stories. A lot of country and only two towns.

[@sunnysied713]

@@Tyso808 The U.S./Republic of Hawaii/Provisional Government didn't ban the Hawaiian language. The Hawaiian Kingdom enacted an education policy that highly favored English before the overthrow of the monarchy in 1893. King Kamehameha IV stated in His Majesty's Speech at the Opening of the Legislature (1855): "To foster education and widen every channel that leads to knowledge, is one of our most imperative duties... It is of the highest importance, in my opinion, that education in the English language should become more general, for it is my firm conviction that unless my subjects become educated in this tongue, their hope of intellectual progress, and of meeting the foreigners on terms of equality, is a vain one." King Kamehameha IV stated in His Majesty's Speech at the Opening of the Legislature (1856) that he was satisfied with the Board of Education's progress on English instruction "It is particularly gratifying to know that instruction in the English language is prosecuted with so much success among my native subjects. I recommend you to make as liberal a provision for the support of this class of schools as the state of my Treasury will admit." And this *Hawaiian Kingdom Policy* was very successful in adopting the English language as the main language of education and instruction. 1881: 66% English, 33% Hawaiian 1887: 84% English,16% Hawaiian 1892: 95% English, 5% Hawaiian 1896: 97% English, 3% Hawaiian The U.S. didn't ban hula. Hula was banned by Queen Ka'ahumanu in 1830 (because nudity was frowned upon by Christians), but most people didn't listen. Hula was still practiced privately and even publicly practiced, but with clothes. It was a loose 'ban'. In 1874, King Kalākau welcomed hula officially back into the palace. Land was always a problem. Before the Hawaiian Kingdom existed, the ali'i classes owned and controlled all the land. The maka'āinana were just feudal serfs. During the Hawaiian Kingdom, the ali'i and wealthy people still owned most of the land. The Great Māhele was a land policy failure. Now, the same problems exist. The U.S. didn't create a land problem... BUT they can definitely make things better.

[@elay4023]

Most of American formation can be chopped up to “We were friends until we realized they had LAND”

[@LiveDieTrolling]

Most of America was colonized by the french, biritsh and spanish long before America was even a country. Only Oregon, Washinton and British Columbia was considered colonized at the time.

[@uncleaddie]

You just summed up the every country's history of expansion.

[@Isaakspijanez]

I fear what America will do to Puerto Rico 🇵🇷

[@MattiBlume]

@@Isaakspijanez What do you mean "will" do? It has long been done.

[@jonirojonironin5353]

@@uncleaddie Ummm no. The Philippines for example, had no history of expansion. The Pacific Island nations also have no history of expansion. There are many countries without a stain in their histories. But most of these countries are "militarily" weak. So if you see a country with a strong military like the USA, you can be sure that it has a stain in its history, a dark history full of violence and unethical practices.

[@DrAuthorite1]

FINNALLY! SOMEONE FINALLY.. Finally tells us about this.. thank you, sooo much for doing it.

[@eddevlin72]

we feel u Hawaii, sincerely Ireland.

[@johnniewaiker6203]

Really? when I talk about colonialism people always tell me to get over it and don't care about it because the Irish also were enslaved and colonised but they don't talk about it. If you feel this why are your people always use Irish people to oppress minorities?

[@vstanfor]

@@johnniewaiker6203 don't believe them when they tell you that. My mom is from Ireland and when I talk about colonialism she sometimes gives me the same BS, even when I say it's not the same because Ireland has independence. But the biggest part that's BS is anyone saying that Irish people are "over it." My Irish grandfather hated the British government until he died. Even my mom - I told her about something I learned in class the other day about a judge from 100 years ago who was against Irish independence and I still have to learn about him today and my mom went on a rant immediately and said "don't get me started." Then I said "oh I thought you were over it?" My mom only ever brings up being "over" things with Ireland as soon as I try to talk about colonialism in other places - she's not actually over it, it's just she doesn't have to deal with it anymore because she doesn't live there and Ireland has independence because people like her grandfather fought for it. She just doesn't want to acknowledge that she's like the British now colonizing other people. So don't believe anyone who try and use Irish history to shut down discussions of colonialism. And especially if anyone thinks Ireland is "over it," they should learn a little bit more about Northern Ireland including decades of bombs that went off there....

[@neilsumanda1538]

how u feel Philippines?..

[@andreaguirre9592]

@@vstanfor she is colonizing? Excuse me but what countries are being colonized by Ireland nowadays?

[@andreaguirre9592]

@@johnniewaiker6203 what people are you refering to? He is talking about Irish people! Don’t get confused.

[@stalman]

But those 3D maps! 🤯

[@ConradLihilihi]

This video barely scratches the surface. If you’d like to really learn about Hawai’i, watch this Smithsonian docuseries kzbin.info/www/bejne/d2mlYXxngc2Una8

[@MrJoJI]

World map texture applied to a heightmap on a 3d terrain.

[@nordinator89]

@@MrJoJI any Idea about how to do it VIDEO ANIMATION? i know about 3D map generator plugin for photoshop but i don"t know how to animate it.

[@sleepy0098]

@@nordinator89 use blender, and it's free

[@tiggeesong]

@@ConradLihilihi Bruv, uncool

[@MikSrf723]

Hawaiian people hating on white Americans makes a lot more sense now.

[@walnutship6740]

@Basically I'm Schlorping that how pain is the innocent havent or doesnt stop the past from doing the bad things again

[@walnutship6740]

@Basically I'm Schlorping i not and those who do aren't the good guys this is to remeber and challange the past and present

[@justinantonius2823]

I live on Maui and the amount of hawaiian homestead land is pitiful state should give 10 times that at minimum it's their land no hawaiian should be homeless in Hawaii it's a disgrace

[@choncha23]

@@cringestudiozz Hawaiians don’t even like Mexicans. I was at Ewa beach one night by myself depressed as shit missing my family. I joined the Army and I missed home. The waves reminded me of California. Some Hawaiians came up to me and told me to leave. I was dumbfounded by their aggressive demeanor. I argued with them until I finally left. I was just a sad dude enjoying the waves. I’m going to start telling Hawaiians to go back to Hawaii whenever I see them on the mainland. I’ll be honest, I freaking hate Hawaii. Tourism paints a pretty picture and Hollywood does too. I will never want to step foot on any island in Hawaii.

[@noodle7725]

@@cringestudiozz nobody said you should forget, but rather stop hating an entire race because of some people

[@emilylee9894]

James Michener's historical novel, Hawaii, is a long, thorough yet palatable & enlightening journey through Hawaiian history.

[@shammendraeshwar433]

usa be like:- hipity hopity this land is now my property.

[@sunnysied713]

kamehameha be like: fee fi fo fum, you're islands belong to my king-dom ;)

[@knightf8648]

This is how great nations are built. Not every country is pathetic pacifist fool like India which instead gaining more, even ceded it's territory.

[@l.f.c9973]

How his father taught him

[@deeqam.9023]

@@knightf8648 and that mentality is why humans are a plague to this earth.

[@cringyalienguy9787]

that joke hasn't been funny since last year

[@saracortes5231]

"these Jesus, sugar, americans" 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@ibrahimkhatib1554]

As a Palestinian, this is what Israel ( backed up by the US and UK ) have done to us. They stole our land, culture and killed millions of Palestinians that are indigenous to the land. It continues to happen today as Israel is illegally planning to occupy more land from Palestine. For all the zionists who will be replying, the conflict was never about Jewish / Christians / Muslims, all these religions lived peacefully together for centuries but Isreal used Judaism as an excuse much like those " wannabe Christians " that went to Hawaii.

[@unclesam5230]

ALL RELIGION IS THE OPIUM OF THE MASSES!!!!!

[@cambrondavis3492]

I love how there’s a lot of British ppl in here talking shit about America’s history acting like there so innocent 🙈

[@MissNayNay]

THANK YOU! It was they who started the take over of powers across the world. England is the father of the United States, so they have no moral leg to stand on when it comes to criticizing America for imperialism that they invented. I am not saying that I approve. Hawaii was a sovereign, monarchical nation that was unjustifiable usurped by America. But if there are any British people in this comment section who are trying to use this horrible incidence of imperialism as another example to hate America, I think perhaps they better shut their lips. They don't get to have this one. Maybe go and ask China and India how they feel about the British before they start pointing fingers at us.

[@fatherfred3946]

'Anglos caused most of the world's problems' (David Cameron, British Prime Minister, 2010-2016). Anglo clans practiced centuries-long Slavery; from Caribbean to North & South America, by wiping out indigenous Native people originally living there, by replacing them with millions of slaves brought from Africa, by enslaving them and living off on their blood and sweat. Isn't it shocking to learn that Anglo invaded nine out of ten nations, all but 22 nations in the whole wide world ? Moreover, Anglo practiced centuries-long Colonialism in over 50 nations, by living off on their blood and sweat, as well as on those bountiful lands for natural mineral resources, which were essentials requirement for industrial revolution. Anglo still Colonized many parts of the world, including two vast bountiful Continents; North America and Australia Continents. Among the five main Anglo nations; Britain, USA, Canada, Australia and New Zealand, all but Britain is looted from others. A website with 4 million views says it all at, blog.chinadaily.com.cn/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=1795128

[@baule4475]

both are murderers just UK started it

[@gutsjoestar7450]

well British are mad, they lost a war against some unloyal british cause the american revolutionary war is englishmen vs english men

[@mr.brazilian5167]

@Luís Fernando Torres bruuh

[@DJ-vh9ib]

Thankyou Johny, for such wonderful content.

[@bambooman44]

being Native Hawaiian and watching this from my bedroom in the continental US because I was priced out of my hometown hits hard, I was emotional from the first ten seconds. thank you for informing the world.

[@mayainverse9429]

that wouldn't change no matter who "owned" land there. even if it was native hawaiians who owned all the comercial/tourist locations it wouldn't be you. Bill Gates being a white billionare does not in anyway benefit other white people. races do not own wealth or land individuals do.

[@The.Hawaiian.Kingdom]

We miss you. We love you & we always will. We hope you are able to come HOME soon.

[@Revealthereal_]

Black people can relate. I feel my identity is so lost I can only cling to a color. I hate cruel colonialism and white washing! It’s okay to be proud of your skin! Whether in Mexico they speak Spanish from their oppressors in Spain. Brazilians speak Portuguese from their oppressors in Portugal. The Haitians speak French! The Fujians, New Zealanders, Australians etc etc!!!! Across cultures darker people suffer most, why! Because they don’t want you to realize your strength is like a wild horse. Don’t let them keep your spirit caged like a tamed horse! “Injustice anywhere is injustice everywhere!” - MLK Jr. We need to fight back against the brainwashing /white washing media that teaches us to hate our skin!

[@mayainverse9429]

@@Revealthereal_ you are more than welcome to go back to a culture of cannibalism witch doctor medical care and raping children because it cures aids. do you even realize everyone who even speaks xyz language most likely if you go back far enough came from a different culture. i speak english now by my close ancensors were not english but german. have I been oppressed because I speak a new language.

[@MA-gn5nl]

Going by your username, is Kaneohe your homeland? It’s devastating when Native Hawaiians can’t even afford to live on their own rightful land. So many of my Native Hawaiian friends moved to the mainland, especially to Las Vegas area. What is Hawaii without the Native people and their culture there? I look at the recent Kakaako/Ward theater area’s gentrification and can’t help but feel sad seeing so little local businesses/people and lots of foreign and mainland US folks buying the high rise condos as their summer homes/second homes. It reminds me a lot of New Zealand’s housing situation. I have to remind myself I’m technically in Hawaii when I walk through the new Whole Foods there. It is vastly different from the Kakaako I remember..from the Kakaako the Native Hawaiians and their ancestors remember…Driving through Laie I see plenny “keep Hawaii Hawaiian” and “keep the country country” signs.. Rightfully so..it’s emotional and so complex; the damage done to Hawaii is irreversible

[@soundlyawake]

a much different history than my 5th grade state report on hawaii your videos are *chef’s kiss*

[@imperialchimpanzee122]

not unless you had school in Hawaii XD. Glad to know we learned some real history.

[@ConradLihilihi]

This video barely scratches the surface. If you’d like to really learn about Hawai’i, watch this Smithsonian docuseries kzbin.info/www/bejne/d2mlYXxngc2Una8

[@ConradLihilihi]

Imperial Chimpanzee a little more but trust me, we didn’t learn much more growing up in Hawai’i. If you’d like to really learn about Hawai’i’s history, watch this Smithsonian docuseries kzbin.info/www/bejne/d2mlYXxngc2Una8

[@aipaIV]

Don't feel bad! They don't even teach this to US in school. Our Hawaiian History class has very minimal information on our true history of our ancestors. Most of us Hawaiians are slowly learning ALL our REAL history only now!

[@FDboto]

@@imperialchimpanzee122 I learned about Hawaiian history a total of 6 times and gave a little less of a shit each time

[@marouane53]

One person Vox. Amazing video

[@leadwipe]

Amazing? It's not accurate history. The US Gov't did not 'agree' with the overthrow of the Hawaiian monarchy and 'revolutionaries' were ordered by Cleveland to return the Islands to the Monarchy. They ignored him and formed a Republic.

[@pakelika100]

@@leadwipe the US government deliberately sent John Stevens to the Hawaiian Kingdom to be its Minister Extraordinary and Plentipotentiary to that country, to facilitate revolution and annexation. If you can, get a hold of a copy of Lorrin Thurston's Memoirs of the Hawaiian Revolution, or Tom Coffman's Nation Within: The History of the Occupation of Hawaii. Thurston is a primary source/witness who conspired with US Minister Stevens to overthrow the Hawaiian government. In May, 1892 he, Thurston, went to Washington DC to ascertain the Harrison administration's attitude towards overthrowing the Hawaiian government and annexing Hawaii. He was very encouraged by Harrison's message to him. Coffman's book is meticulously researched from primary and verifiable secondary sources and is annotated with source citations.

[@pakelika100]

@@leadwipe not an accurate account of history? The US government did not approve of the overthrow of the Hawaiian government? What is your authoritative and verifiable source for your saying that? Is that source primary documentation or a primary witness? Is that source in agreement with other primary documents or witnesses? Is it a source that has researched from those resources? What are your qualifications, and, or credentials that one may check out and verify, that anyone should believe you, since you cite no source or qualification for your statement; or are you merely stating your personal and unqualified opinion? While it's true that Cleveland did tell the Dole gang to step down, your preceding statement calls into question your sources and qualification.

[@pakelika100]

@@charityalvin6665 is that the only way to reach him? I don't use Instagram

[@josephleonard6695]

Even better than Vox. No political correctness, no bias. Just facts.

[@CityRD]

Bad Bunny Song - What Happened to Hawaii got me here☝🏽☺️💯

[@mohammadshahidhusaini2464]

it's strange that Christian missionaries went to preach about GOD but when injustices were done against the Natives they became silent and forgot what they preached.

[@phav1832]

You need to broaden your research a bit . . . there were plenty of Christians who fought for the rights of Native Americans (look up John Wesley) and Christians were Abolitionists who literally laid down their lives to abolish slavery. Don't just swallow all this anti-American propaganda that most everyone on this blog was weaned on.

[@mohammadshahidhusaini2464]

@@phav1832 but in the case of Hawaii did any Christian missionary supported the Native...?

[@aheisanraveendran3686]

Paul Havig And plenty of Christian that didn’t to say theirs a few good apples in an tree of bad apples. Don’t get me wrong people that helped shouldn’t be forgotten but the Vatican Church sided with the U.S and Canada by Installing Residential Schools and converting slaves

[@thenotoriousgoob]

Mohammad Shahid Husaini welcome to religion it’s always been like that across the entire planet for all of time.

[@reyinterlude]

@@thenotoriousgoob its not....

[@pancake7408]

I visited Hawaii (specifically Maui) last July. I was completely unaware of the history at the time, but seeing American building styles carving the land felt almost disgusting. The natives can't even afford to stay in their own homes, and thus you can often find them on the streets. I loved Hawaii, but damn, the US really did screw them over and if you aren't completely ignorant, you can see it down every street. Even if American rule is no longer a thing in the future, the damage we have done is irreversible.

[@JohnDoe-qf1ji]

very based actions by the US

[@pancake7408]

@@JohnDoe-qf1ji wdym? imperialism is based?

[@Revealthereal_]

Black people can relate. I feel my identity is so lost I can only cling to a color. I hate cruel colonialism and white washing! It’s okay to be proud of your skin! Whether in Mexico they speak Spanish from their oppressors in Spain. Brazilians speak Portuguese from their oppressors in Portugal. The Haitians speak French! The Fujians, New Zealanders, Australians etc etc!!!! Across cultures darker people suffer most, why! Because they don’t want you to realize your strength is like a wild horse. Don’t let them keep your spirit caged like a tamed horse! “Injustice anywhere is injustice everywhere!” - MLK Jr. We need to fight back against the brainwashing /white washing media that teaches us to hate our skin!

[@simzyboi8551]

@@Revealthereal_ calm down mate were all the same africans conquered and ruled over other africans asians have done the same thing etc etc I know it sucks white people used black people has slaves but news flash buddy white people used other white people has slaves to black people used black people has slaves people need to quit playing victim cause its just stirring up more racism and its getting pretty ridiculous

[@yeetfeet731]

Guam has been toyed around with with so many foreign powers for so long. Spain, America, Japan. We lost our traditional dance and history due to colonialism of the Spanish (the other islands make fun of us for that ;-;), we lost our lands for the making of military bases for the Americans, and you probably already know what the Japanese did to us during WW2. We aren't islands in a sea, we are a sea of Islands called Oceania (I stole that one off another comment, hehe) who've endured similar hardships and history. We are Familia, Ohana, Aiga, Baalma from ways back

[@TolarRay]

this is a masterpiece - it's like a podcast piece but complemented by genius map animations. great job

[@Smiley-of2jh]

US: "I promise we are not interested in imperialism." Also the US:

[@jtvideos2992]

They left out the part when they introduced to the natives venereal diseases.

[@Delgen1951]

that would have come form the brits, sailors and free love and all that.

[@hjs9td]

You can thank the Caribbeans for giving it to the Europeans 400 years earlier. Globalization was slow back then.

[@here_we_go_again2571]

That happened everywhere in the Americas and Oceania. Africa/Eurasia was one big petri dish of disease (It will probably happen if space aliens come to earth)

[@here_we_go_again2571]

@ luh luh Pilit na Pilit Types of "pox" (veneral disease) as well as skin diseases existed in both the Old and New Worlds. After 1492 the New World versions traveled to Europe. The Afro-Eurasia varities travelled to the New World. Oceania may have had fewer diseases than the Americas; but those people also had less resistance (due to millennia of isolation) than those in the mainlands of the Americas

[@here_we_go_again2571]

@being gay is not normal Human sacrifice occurred in Hawaii. (I'm not so sure about the young girls being thrown into the volcanoes; but human sacrifice of that type would have been rare since the natives did not go up to the crater when it was errupting.) "Human sacrifices were performed in Hawaii as late as the 19th century. It may have served as a way for elite members of the island to help maintain their control over the population. Europeans who visited the island recorded the practice, with one famous painting showing a person being clubbed to death while lying on a rock. " Reference: www.livescience.com/59514-cultures-that-practiced-human-sacrifice/2.html

[@usebrain6198]

i'm from hawaii, props to you for pronouncing the names correctly XD

[@matt1sullivan318]

Do you think Hawaii should be independent? Sorry I’m late.

[@usebrain6198]

@@matt1sullivan318 nah i'm not about that movement because i'm not "hawaiian". despite being born and raised here i don't have any hawaiian blood so it doesn't concern me.

[@matt1sullivan318]

@@usebrain6198 igu. How widespread is the movement btw? Do you think it’ll ever catch on, or is it exclusive to native Hawaiians? It’s not like secession is legal in the US anyway, but I’m just curious.

[@usebrain6198]

@@matt1sullivan318 i think it's exclusive to native hawaiians, but when you say movement i don't think like picket forks going up to the gov halls and demanding their island back. it's more so fuck the "haoles" and what not which is basically your common racism. but honestly i don't see much of that now a days. we do though have hawaiian immersion schools which is basically a program for people that have hawaiian blood in them that want's to learn the hawaiian language and history and all that good shit.

[@usebrain6198]

@@matt1sullivan318 we do have "Hawaiian sovereignty movement" you should check that out when you have time.

[@breakingmad2645]

“Aloha’oe” was written by Queen Lili as a goodbye-apology to her people after signing

[@sunnysied713]

Aloha 'Oe was written BEFORE the Revolution of 1893. Lol

[@BabySonicGT]

I read somewhere in a comment section that one of the queen of Hawaii’s song was used in spongebob He said something like that

[@RobD-jq7ry]

@@BabySonicGT it was in a Pokémon pilot. Thats what I heard.

[@Grayman58]

That song is one of my favorites very very moving and sad..

[@evb1601]

Thank you so much Johnny for the research and thus, the education you give us. I have learned so much!

[@sunnysied713]

His research is terrible. He omitted or misrepresented so many details. Johnny Harris is an activists and propagandist, not a historian who cares about objective and unbiased discussion of historical events.

[@sunnysied713]

@John Freddy We can talk about any part of Hawaii's history. We have to look at ALL perspectives to understand the real history. That way, we can remain objective and fair. History isn't simple, cut and dry and black and white. It's often complex and messy.

[@mochammadnaufalseptifiandi]

Hawaii: in peace America: *WE SHALL FREE THE WORLD*

[@dreadpiraterobertsii4420]

Darth Sidious well let me tell you about a little place called England (Scotland, whales) Ireland Iceland Japan Taiwan New Zealand (I’m not going to include tiny nations or dominions ie Faroe Islands, Greenland, falklands)

[@endermasa9451]

@@dreadpiraterobertsii4420 you're right except england scotland and wales together is the island of great britain but ye good point

[@dreadpiraterobertsii4420]

EnderMasa the idea that islands can’t be strong and prosperous is silly

[@despairgaming6669]

@Darth Sidious most probably by sanctions, you don't buy from me ~sanctions. You don't sell to me~ sanctions. You don't agree with me~ sanctions.

[@MrHistory269]

Hawai’i: But we were already free!

[@abec8211]

Now they call us “immigrants” and a “burden”

[@victoriaharry9105]

I wonder

[@MariaSilva-hv5dw]

Democrats run your city ...democrats run your state ...GOD wins! Q+

[@premiercconstruction]

Abe Castillo you sound like a Moran. Ohhh you are a Moran. Are you a sad little victim??? Enjoy your life and all that has been given to you!

[@contorta960]

@@premiercconstruction it's "moron" dude.

[@nicholaslamendola6512]

Immigrants are important but a very large amount of immigrants are reliant on the government which is not god

[@alsavini]

I’m native hawaiian and just wanted to say thank you for telling our story on your channel. It means so so much.

[@Solly12345-h]

Most Hawaiians are mixed with western blood,not a pure race anymore

[@keikialoha8626]

I just wish he got the details correct. Lots of inaccuracies in his video. I’m part Hawaiian too and often do talks on Hawaiian history. We can not account for our history accurately without explaining the accurate Flag symbolism and Queen Kaahumanu’s embrace of the missionaries.

[@FDboto]

Well as nice as it is I'm proud to be an American

[@jw4277]

@@Solly12345-h yeah its pretty rare to find a 100% native hawaiian person anymore.

[@joshuabarnes4617]

I wish I could meet you, I think you must be lovely. From oklahoma thank you

[@alohaandchillohana]

I'm descended from the royalty of Maui. My grandfather was leader of Hawaii for 40 years, Gabby Pahinui. The fire in Maui is GENOCIDE.

[@NerdyHawaiian]

As someone who has a degree in Hawaiian History and teaches the subject, I can easily say you did a really good job. I know your video couldn’t be too long but you really covered some of the main points. There’s also so much more to this that makes it even more insane. But I really did like your video.

[@sunnysied713]

I agree, there was a great deal of historical information that was intentionally omitted and withheld to push a slanted, personal narrative. It's insane. The revolution of January 17, 1893 was caused by Queen Liliuokalani's attempt to prorogate the legislature, unilaterally create a new constitution (without the constitutional power to do so), promulgate this new constitution with a sudden declaration (surprise!) and use the military to suppress any opposition to her power grab. On January 14, she was ready to sign and proclaim the new laws. She wrote to Blount that the "members of the diplomatic corps had been invited; also the members of the supreme bench and members of the legislature, besides a committee of the Hui Kalaiaina." She also told Blount that she instructed her guards and military to be ready to suppress any challenge (riots, rebellion, etc) from her opposition: "They assured me they would be ready, and I gave strict injunctions of secrecy." The Queen had been secretly plotting a revolution to overthrow the government and reestablish an absolute monarchy. Then everyone found about her 'secret' plan. Everything went downhill fast for her. People weren't going to curtsy, sit idly and let her smile and wave as she led a revolution. Her opposition mobilized, organized and overthrew her with their own revolution. And the rest is history. Like I said, Queen Lili instigated her own overthrow, despite the advice of her own cabinet and supporters. She was an inexperienced, naive leader who thought she could make sweeping (illegal) changes via royal proclamation. Governor Cleghorn was a royalist, ally and _brother-in-law_ of Queen Liliuokalani. He was angry and disappointed by her plot to overthrow the government and failure to listen to counsel. On January 28, 1893, he wrote "I have never given the Queen anything but good advice. If she had followed my advice, she would have been firm on the throne, and Hawaiian Independence safe, but she has turned out a very stubborn woman and was not satisfied to Reign but wished to Rule." Queen Lili kicked a hornets nest and was stung by her own arrogance. She cost the country its independence. American Minister Stevens was following the instructions of his predecessor, Minister Miller, who received instructions from the Secretary of State of the first _President Cleveland_ Administration. Cleveland was president during the Bayonet Constitution of 1887. Secretary of State Thomas F. Bayard sent written instructions to then American Minister George W. Merrill that if another revolution happens in Hawaii, then they must protect American commerce, lives and property. Bayard clearly stated that, "the assistance of the officers of our Government vessels, if found necessary, will therefore be promptly afforded to promote the reign of law and respect for orderly government in Hawaii."After the revolution that lead to the Bayonet Constitution, _British_ Minister Wodehouse requested that the Americans keep a warship docked in Hawaiian port in case another revolution happened. In July 1889, there was a rebellion and Merrill ordered the deployment of marines and sailors to protect Americans. John L. Stevens (had replaced Merrill) and followed those official instructions during the overthrow of 1893. The American soldiers were peacekeepers who didn't participate in any government building raids, patrol the streets, fire any shots or provide any material support to the insurgents. Often, the Americans would land, come ashore and practice military drills (prior to the overthrow). During the 1893 revolution, the soldiers marched past Iolani Palace, lowered their flags to show neutrality and saluted the Queen. These are hardly aggressive actions. The Americans then remained in their bunkers and did absolutely nothing because no violence broke out against American interests. There was no invasion or military occupation. The monarchy was overthrown by a homegrown coup of 1,100-1,600 insurgents (who were citizens and royal subjects), Queen Liliuokalani surrendered and abdicated her power WITHOUT fighting to defend her country from internal, domestic threats, which was her constitutional duty as a monarch.

[@ashutoshkumardixit5657]

They have also manipulated the history regarding red indians, took their children away from them

[@Dm-dk9zp]

@@sunnysied713 Very interesting, thank you

[@WatanabeNoTsuna.]

@@sunnysied713 That is a load of bullshit trying to pass the US as saviors of Hawaii, instead of the usurpers they are!

[@IrishGrenade187]

Cool pointless degree. Would you still be Hawaiian without the US or would you be Japanese?

[@theodorintfp3318]

Imagine a former colony starting it’s own imperialism.

[@iamk4474]

Like israel

[@ashutoshanand1573]

And authenticate it through democratic institutions

[@sunnysied713]

The Marquesians were the FIRST aboriginal settlers of Hawai'i. Then the Tahitians came, took over all the islands, instituted a feudal caste system and oppressed the maka'āinana with harsh kapu religous law. The chiefdoms fought for centuries over land and power until... Kamehameha waged a 20 year war campaign with 12,000 warriors and 1,000 war canoes to conquer all the island chiefdoms. He STOLE all the āina, mana and wealth for HIS _Kingdom_ of *Hawai'i.* He was a warlord and an imperialist. His aumakua was the god of war, Kū. And wage war he did. There's a very good reason why the island chain is called _Hawai'i_ and the Big Island is also called _Hawai'i._ ;) The haole have never fought any wars with Hawai'i or the kanaka maoli. Hawai'i was never a colony. Lol.

[@pakelika100]

@@sunnysied713 Kauai was not conquered by Paiea(Kamehameha I) When he engaged with an opposing military force in mortal combat, and won, you call that stealing? So by your logic, military science, taught at each of the US service academies, is the science of theft. If your logic is pursued relentlessly, then the English colonists/insurgents stole the colonies from Britain in their war of rebellion from 1775-1781. Just consistently applying your logic. The country that resulted from this theft subsequently engaged in imperialistic wars of expansion across the continent against Mexico and the aboriginal people, resulting in more theft. Next, they stole land from Spain, the Philippines, Colombia, Germany, Italy, Japan, Hawaii. Or do you exempt them from your logic for some peculiar reason?

[@sunnysied713]

@@pakelika100 Kamehameha steamrolled the islands and threatened Kauai. Kauai yielded because of intimidation. Later, Kaumualii (who was the former mo'i) tried to form an alliance with _Russia_ to liberate his kingdom. The Russians built several forts, but the plan was abandoned (failed) after Kaumualii found out that 1) the Russians didn't have the backing of the Tsar and 2) Kamehameha wasn't happy with what was going on there ;)

[@oyidzire]

Sooo early its almost frightening. That being said, 10 seconds in and I love this video. There's so much depth in this history that can't just be captured verbally or through text, so I appreciate Johnny for the fantastic visuals. Thank you

[@Mike322UNGA]

Loved it brother.!!❤❤

[@sahra228]

americans : revolution from the british ! colonizing is not right ! “no taxation without rEprSeNtaTiOn” americans: proceeds to do the same and worse for years on end the logic 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@anujmchitale]

The bigotry, you meant.

[@whorfianism4981]

“nO tAxAtIoN wItHoUt RePrEsEnTaTiOn” Meanwhile, Washington DC.

[@Alan-ww8vi]

This American hypocrisy lives on today. Why do you think the world hates those muppets?

[@HuszOG]

Just end this madness. Jorgensen 2020

[@Matt-wl5io]

Tell me which state/territory is being taxed by the federal government while not being represented in Congress.

[@coolbreeze4066]

As a Native American, I feel for the true people of Hawaii

[@shrek22]

I notice your are utilizing modern technology by posting and by ur profile pic, would u rather love without modern tech or keep bitching about the past? Answer is obvious to everyone but u.

[@latgalitis8305]

@@shrek22 he isn't a primitivist like I am, say the same to the Jews, "move on kiddo, it's been a while!", ok, it's been a while since 9/11 too, so stop crying about it, ok Anglo?

[@omohamed702]

@@shrek22 Now Imagine the West without the Middle east, East Asia and Africa :)

[@shrek22]

@@latgalitis8305 what r u talking about. Its totally diff. We still welcome ppl from the very culture the extremist were from.

[@shrek22]

we welcome other cultures. Hawaii doesn't. U missed my entire point. The "west" is a mix of every culture.

[@Hephzibah624]

they went from promoting Jesus to promoting diabetes

[@smokeylebear1062]

😂

[@LatimOnek]

They weren’t even promoting Him the right way😂😂😂

[@NVangN]

Sugar doesn't cause diabetes directly. It only does so indirectly by being additional calories that turn into fat, which can then block receptors so insulin can't enter the cells, which in turn increases the concentration of glucose in the blood

[@blueskin7377]

Jajajajaa jajaja 👍

[@sandeepbehera3381]

@@NVangN yes, true Sugar doesn't cause diabetes rather it's better to say diabetic patients should not eat lot of sugar

[@Post_Stall_Maneuver]

It's interesting how many mainlanders have only a vague idea of this when this first appears in Hawaii's state curriculum as early as *4th grade.*

[@sunnysied713]

Of course it's going to appear earlier in Hawaiian schools... because it's Hawaiian History. That being said, this video is full of historical inaccuracies, half truths and propaganda.

[@jackryan1648]

I love how white Americans shout at non white Americans "go back to your own country" when some of those non white Americans their families have been in the states for hundreds of years, those white American ancestors are foreigners aswell and the only natives r the native Indians

[@stevehensley7731]

The only natives of America aren’t the American Indians. Read. Expand your knowledge. Most structures believed to be built by Indians weren’t. Interviews with the occupants found that almost all structures were here when they arrived. The mound builders of central Arkansas didn’t build the mounds. They were there when they arrived. . The Vikings were here as early as 1000BC

[@stevehensley7731]

1000AD correction

[@robertmadison4611]

So what do you think it means when they say "go back to your country"? Do you think they are saying it to all non-whites, just because they are not white? Do you think such jingoism is only based on race?

[@0ctalpus]

Idk who youre dealing with but you get so much shit in this woke culture that its not worth it to even be an asshole like that,

[@stevehensley7731]

wildhorse891 Caucasians "white people" and brown people and black people all had army's. They didn't have a whole lot to do after building an empire so they attacked other smaller villages and towns, took whatever they wanted and told them they would now be paying for protection against the enemy they feared the most, the tax man. This is what they did to show power and control. If you were weak you died if you were strong you would be spared and forced to join the group in the battles , for your life. By the way, do you have any idea what kind of timeline you are talking about when you say the white European Armys acquired said stolen property from the Indigenous people? Do you have any perspective on the number of people that made up the indigenous population. I'll tell you because had you known you wouldn't have said something that stupid. 60,000,000., That's the population of indigenous people around 1492. Now, do you know how long it was fought for? I'll tell you that too. Over 400 years. So, you and the rest of the uneducated bozos should research what you think is true before you type gibberish. If you believe the land was taken by a slap fight and celebrated with a turkey dinner you are a fool. If you believe that the Caucasian settlers "white people " suffered no casualties, again hundreds of thousands died on both sides and to the victor goes the booty.

[@felipemilian4000]

American imperialism at its finest. Funny how the us school system barely teaches this story (and that of the other territories) in schools.

[@kappaspinning4832]

That is how you clear your name, do all the barbaric things you want and just hide the facts to your next generations, wait few decades and even if they somehow ended knowing the truth, they won't give a fuck anymore. Like now days no ones gives a fuck that USA helped nazis scientist to escape they trial for the war crimes in exchange for the nazi tech. Or all the wars they provoque in midest are for money and none of them are actually for "national security" or "freeing the people".

[@AndresRodriguez-be6rm]

yes, this is also one of the reasons great number of US people don’t know Puerto Ricans are part of US and treat them like Mexicans just because we are bilingual.

[@matthewgibbs6886]

@@AndresRodriguez-be6rm no offense but the pr's i served with weren't bilingual the couldn't speak english or spanish worth a sht. im guessing the all came from the same town the one where everyone talks with marbles in their mouths.

[@AndresRodriguez-be6rm]

MATTHEW GIBBS Not offended, like in a lot of countries, theres always the ignorant ones, maybe that was the type of Puerto Rican you meet, but those are the ignorant exceptions... Every country, or island has a couple of those.

[@LiveDieTrolling]

They do, you just didn't take a University History clearly

[@Anesha12]

OMG if you do my home state Alaska next Ill lose it. What was done to the indigenous population (and continues to this day) needs to be known by EVERYONE.

[@ahyaok100]

You mean how Russia sold something that wasn't even theirs? Yeah, lots of that kind of stuff has happened.

[@safe-keeper1042]

Agreed.

[@thefatbob3710]

HAH PATHETIC NATIVES WILL ALWAYS LOSE TO THE AMAZING SLAVS 🇷🇺 number one

[@MrSilk13642]

@@ahyaok100 Indigenous people don't own land that they can't control.

[@bradavon]

@@ahyaok100 or how they wanted to sell it to the British but they weren't interested.

[@Moviebro]

“An insatiable desire for control” Everything changes, everything stays the same.

[@esteevent]

Hawai’i was not a “disconnected country.” If you’d learn about Hawai’i way before the foreigners arrived, you’d see how rich they were. Hawai’i was among the most literate nation in the world. The ‘Iolani Palace had electricity and telephones before the White House. The Kingdom of Hawai’i had everything they ever needed. This video made it seem like Hawai’i needed help, which is entirely false. It may be unintentional, but the audience may view the annexation reasonable.

[@thereGoMapo]

The whole self-imposed superiority is a common white supremacist tactic to justify their actions. They set up this imaginary hierarchy to justify white/european colonization and oppress indigenous people. This imaginary hierarchy is reinforced in society today in laws, police, housing, wealth, media etc. etc.

[@BlurredCulture]

thereGoMapo one group invented advanced tech and used it to subjugate a group that did not create advanced tech. White Supremacy comes from the fact Europeans believed they were superior do to the lack of other cultures producing advanced tech at the rate of European peoples. There would be no colonization via Europeans if other cultures were more advanced. The Aztec’s tech was more advanced then the other native Americans so they conquered them. Then the Spanish came with even more advanced tech and conquered the Aztec with the help of the natives who were conquered by the Aztec. World wide this is the story with all cultures. Europeans just created tech and culture far more advanced then anyone else.

[@thereGoMapo]

​@@BlurredCulture They upheld their rational thought, used it as a metric judge entire cultures, and weaponized it. Yes they were advanced in rational thinking but they didn't have the emotional intelligence to wield it. Now we are all becoming aware of their atrocities.

[@Taladar2003]

@@hsekimoto4252 While others might also have overthrown governments unjustly the US has a history of staging coups (some successful, some not) in their own interest somewhere in the world every few years pretty much ever since they took over Hawaii. See Stephen Kinzer's book Overthrow or en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_regime_change for details.

[@missmymama1140]

@@BlurredCulture i find it funny how people come up with all this pseudohistorical nonsense about pre-colonial paradises

[@lilyraimey3499]

Bruh. I’ve been eating Dole this hole time and supporting a crooked empire, nooooo.

[@andrewsky59]

Switch to eating pineapple slice holes and take the profit away from Dole!

[@Sir-Ulrich-Von-Liechtenstein]

me too I was today years old

[@___-yy8ud]

Trump 2020

[@monstersamator5288]

Pineaple for you..hhh

[@yequene]

I had the exact same thought

[@TheFirstGroover]

One of the most satisfying intros ever. The details, the colours, the 3d maps, the footage video and the photos all editing together. You deserve your own tv show.

[@ninimoulder366]

OMG What a Miracle I found you in KZbin I Love All the News and I can't wait for more. Thank You. 😊

[@jazlux6126]

as a person from hawaiian descent, i show my appreciation towards you for spreading this information. in hawaii we learn about hawaii’s history and a lot of that class speaks on how we were forced into colonization

[@sunnysied713]

The U.S. didn't colonize Hawai'i. This video was full of historical inaccuracies, half truths and propaganda.

[@IloveTS13haha]

@@sunnysied713 really?

[@sunnysied713]

@@IloveTS13haha Yup. Always independently research, verify and confirm what you read, see and hear. History isn't simple, cut-and-dry, black-and-white.

[@puidemare2337]

@@sunnysied713 And you claim to know the "truth?" Do you have generations of family who lived through those times and pass on the knowledge to you? Or are you reading from sources that are written from a foreigner's perspective? Have you read anything in the Hawaiian language regarding the history? Have you spoken with Hawaiian elders who have knowledge of the times?

[@coronatoday5290]

@@sunnysied713 hahaha even our holy country exist cause of native genocide

[@vonPandov]

Hawaii: exists US: *It's free real estate*

[@alapakeheanu4776]

Is it really free if you no titles?

[@unclesam5230]

@@alapakeheanu4776 it’s a meme

[@jauipop]

Don’t we love how America now loves to lecture the rest of the world when it comes to human rights and not taking over other people’s land?

[@shifa444]

the hypocrisy 💀

[@blainebauer6165]

If only countries with no colonial past are allowed to object to present human rights abuses, that will be a pretty powerless group

[@abduljaleelkhan1449]

The USA hasn't changed much in what it does earlier it used to occupy foreign land now it supports countries like Israel that occupy foreign land

[@Go4Broke247]

The best colonizer

[@japhetawa2389]

@MichT you do know that the reason America was able to make those inventions in the first place is by sucking the resources of these countries, right?

[@wudaobygu]

Thank you for sharing this is so great

[@Retly_Ai]

I actually didn’t know this and I’m an American. I’ve lived in Hawaii while stationed at the naval base for 4 years. And every local I’ve met and been friends with never accused America as an evil overlord, but I can’t help but feel bad now. Hawaiian natives are extremely good people and they deserve better.

[@lilinoe1285]

Jason Sparks do you stay in the military area of the islands cause almost every body I know has a strong disliking of the US

[@Retly_Ai]

Lilinoe I did not, I’ve been to each island and visited many places. If you choose to hate me for serving my country go ahead, but from what I’ve gained from Hawaii is friendship bc I’m not a prick as I’m assuming you think I am, But you do you boo boo

[@L._.A-06]

Jason Sparks I mean we don’t like the US and it’s government but we won’t hate you just for being American since we technically are too

[@loyalbot7353]

I have lived in Hawaii my whole life and not all but most people I know will treat you like shit if your white so ya

[@Forlfir]

It's sad that people don't learn about Hawaii's history. The US has fucked up soooo many countries

[@TheMauisbest]

From a Hawaiian Living On the island of maui.. I mahalo you for telling our story🤙🤙🤙 I am a tour guide Here on island.. And I myself share this story because most people don't know.. And when I share what happen After you answer a million questions of how could that be my country wouldn't do that.. Some folks create a weird vibe specially for the ones who don't understand.. See knowledge is power and when one feels that they have no knowledge of this most people go into defence... it's funny because they are the one who asked a question on when Hawaii became a state in how did it become... then go on to say...oh aren't you folks so lucky the US took over and it goes into a whole thing this put me in a position where I feel like I have the right to defend my people and my place of home so anyway..... So the next time someone asks me a question i will just refer to this very video... Thank you for all of the facts an photos.. This will let me take a step out of the situation and the information will be there easily for them to understand and hopefully here forward I will never be put in another uncomfortable situation to do with this subject... So once again a sincere Mahalo🤙🤙🤙🤙

[@annemiura7767]

I think it’s a good idea to refer the visitors to this video. In fact when I was watching it I thought to myself that this would be a good video to explain things in a way that most haoles would understand. There’s a lot more to Hawai’i history and the overthrow but this does a good job of touching on the main points. BTW, thank you for taking time to explain Hawai’i to our visitors, even if some of them get defensive, you are giving the others the gift of your knowledge and experience. Aloha.

[@steveTGO]

This is the story of EVERY square inch of Earth, some land annexed by the U.S. and many other annexed by a different world power at one time. This is how people have done things since the very beginning of time, get over it!!!!

[@decidrophob]

@@steveTGO Well, what you are saying is probably true. But at least, I think it is worth letting the American tourists know the fact instead of leaving them ignorant. Many British, as far as my impression goes, still naively believe in the concept of the "Commonwealth" for instance.

[@steveTGO]

@@winterlilikoi1899 - The beginning of time??? You mean like the Polynesians from the Marquesas Islands who migrated to Hawaii and now call themselves Hawaiian? The same people who fought and fought and fought with each other until the self proclaimed King, Kamehameha conquered the other separate groups, against their will? I am more than over it, there isn't anything they can do to effectively change that they are the 50th U.S. State, America isn't looking for their permission, if they rise up violently, they will be dealt with violently. I should really be telling YOU, to get over it ... Hawaii is the Property of the United States, like it or not!!!!!

[@hotmessjess3390]

@TheMauisbest, may I suggest the book “Unfamiliar Fishes” by Sarah Vowell. The audiobook is also great. It is really fun history of Hawaii that acknowledges the fucked up colonialism and the beauty of the culture.

[@Yasinburak1992]

Britain watching this: hehe he’s making me proud

[@coolperson4582]

Britain is firm allies with the US this is 2020 not 170somebullshit 😂

[@nahlene1973]

@@coolperson4582 it looks like you didn't get his sarcasm 🤣

[@kevray]

Spain watching Mexico get destroyed in the Mexican-American war: “My son, what has happened to you 😭😭”

[@alizo3]

😂😂

[@N3K0553]

At least British was better

[@sunnysied713]

Just a public service announcement for all my ohana. For everyone who don't know what they don't know. *Annexation.* After 128 years, there hasn't been a single United States or International Court decision that has declared that Hawai'i was 'occupied' or annexed 'illegally'. There is no United States or International Law of 1898 that declares a treaty _(and only a treaty)_ can be used for annexation of foreign land. The U.S. has aquired foreign land in many different ways, which shows that joint resolution was part of established customs and norms. ✔ The Republic of Hawaii requested to be annexed by the United States. The Hawaiian legislature unanimously agreed to annexation and passed their Treaty of Annexation. ✔ On the U.S. side, the President wanted annexation, and two-thirds of the Senate AND two-thirds of the House of Representatives voted for annexation by passing the Newlands Resolution. Since both Houses ratified the Resolution with a TWO-THIRDS majority, it exceeds the criteria of Treaty. ✔ The Treaty of Annexation (Hawaii) and the Newlands Resolution (United States) are two documents, related and in agreement with one another with a common intent to bind both parties in a _BILATERAL_ agreement. This met the legal requirement for a mutually, acceptable agreement. Moreover, Hawai'i and the United States abided by this agreement and behaved accordingly. That further reinforces the agreement because it shows common acceptance and practice. They defined the treaty and followed it. ✔ The U.S. Senate Committee on Foreign Relations delivered the Morgan Report on February 26, 1894, which refuted the Blount Report and exonerated the actions of the U.S. military. No other congressional report has refuted this report and concluded that the U.S. government or military enacted a foreign policy to overthrow the Hawaiian Monarchy. ✔ All of the allies and treaty holders of the Hawaiian Kingdom provided de facto, formal and written recognition of the Provisional Government, Republic of Hawaii and Annexation. The international community legitimized every phase of the Kingdom's transition from country to territory to state. ✔ The U.S. has used acts and joint resolutions in lieu of treaties many times (such as the annexation of Texas and Hawai'i, ending of World War I, etc). Please refer to *"Acts and Joint Resolutions of Congress as Substitutes for Treaties"* (James W. Garner) www.jstor.org/stable/2190424?seq=1 ✔✔✔

[@OperationHawaiiana]

very informative. mana no ka lahui!!!!

[@based_kumanovar4799]

Missionaries before arriving to Hawaii: Ok now I’m going to these islands to spread the Word of Jesus Missionaries after arriving to Hawaii: Wait there is sugar here....uhm.... well, Jesus would love Sugar

[@-Mitra-]

Actually it is missionaries who brought sugar cane there, to raise it on rich Hawaiian lands.

[@joshoduwole]

He’s back with these awesome vids, keep it up man. Your editing skills are elite!

[@oscarp2972]

When u like surfing so much u steal a whole country

[@dreadpiraterobertsii4420]

Pineapples*

[@sirij8784]

the first americans actually hated surfing. they said God didn't approve and banned it

[@shutupandeaturgrass8872]

Siri J god don’t approve Christianity

[@robanson32]

Yeah but Charlie don't surf son

[@paliaha706]

I'm born & raised Pake/Buddha Head. I've always said I'm from Hawaii; never America. As I drive thru the Navajo & Hopi nations as a tourist I realize that all of this land, all of America is stolen.

[@BrooklynBeTheBoro]

So essentially an invasive species arrived on ships in small numbers, began to multiply, and eventually infested every inch of the islands.

[@HiperKich]

RATS! oh srry you are talking about Americans?

[@BrooklynBeTheBoro]

Al94 OV BINGO!!!

[@whiteeagle6370]

LOL, good way to put it.

[@komisar3937]

Interesting, that's how the "Hawaiians" got there as well.

[@justinloup]

@@komisar3937 so you'll be ok with the reconquista of the American Southwest?

[@taylorlishka]

nothing but respect for hawai’i. i hope everyone know what happened, because this beautiful place deserves respect

[@seanleaf3165]

That can be said for the WHOLE earth.

[@Robert-dx7rj]

tell that to joe biden. Democrat leadership allowed all the homelessness

[@laquintanhouston2663]

This applies to Africa, the Americas, Ireland, Australia, Brazil, Caribbeans, Canada amongst many other countries

[@GabrielMislaNieves]

As a Puerto Rican seeing this happening to Puerto Rico as well, I feel for the indigenous people of Hawaii. My love to you and I wish for your independence from the empire.

[@MsMimo07]

Yet the majority of Boricuas don't want independence (for economic reasons I guess)

[@ogutumbeke6041]

@@MsMimo07 I mean it is understandable the island is already fairly poor becoming independent would only make it worse

[@joshrobertson8189]

To the victor belong the spoils

[@sujeewaslbux7525]

90 % residents of Hawaii don't like to become independent nation from US.

[@jalicea1650]

@@MsMimo07 Have you seen what Americans have done to people who do not bend the knee? Ask the Cubans, the Dominicans, Hondurans and any nation in the Americas who doesn't bend the knee. America would utterly destroy us even worse as a people.... Just what the empire does... We Puerto Ricans recognize this and don't want independence out of fear of what they would do to us.

[@MartinIvette]

I'm from Puerto Rico, one of the oldest colonies still in USA claws. Inspite all, Boricuas have resisted to be assimilated, but the struggle continues and now a days our natural resources and land are under serious attack. It's unbelievable that the story keeps going on through ages.

[@YupMel]

Are you an actual Native or a descendent of Spain

[@MartinIvette]

@@YupMel I'm descendent mostly of spaniards and africans, but natives tainos still lives in every Boricuas..that's something that we feel spiritually.

[@andrewmclaughlin2701]

A Spanish colony turned American. Puerto Ricans have had a net benefit being American yet America has had a net negative having Puerto Rico. Liberate Puerto Rico now.

[@josephinetracy1485]

@@andrewmclaughlin2701 They're always too GD bashful to mention the Spanish Empire.... or the Portuguese Empire.

[@rosemadder5547]

What a beautiful culture. I homeschool my son, and I use these videos all the time. Imagine if our schools taught from these types of points of view, and real history. What a difference.

[@gaiusjuliuscaesar4256]

"These points of view" are extremely biased, and if you cannot see that then that is quite unfortunate. If I may make a recommendation; stop using these videos. Find a non-American non partisan person to give you the history, without its presentation being viewed through a lens of bias.

[@atyanthdutt6632]

@@gaiusjuliuscaesar4256 nah America has a dark past from butchering natives to toppling democratic governments to funding terrorists to war crimes like biscari and my lai massacre. Americans are just the sons/daughters of the British and they have proved that

[@gaiusjuliuscaesar4256]

@@atyanthdutt6632 This is literally any nation out there. France, Germany, Russia, Spain, Portugal, UK, Italy, Belgium, Turkey and even Canada all have butchered natives. They toppled democratic regimes because they were communist and gave the Soviets an edge in the Cold War. As for funding terrorists, they did, however it was before they came out as being terrorists, back when they still seemed to be democratic regimes.

[@atyanthdutt6632]

@@gaiusjuliuscaesar4256 That, by no means can justify the war crimes committed by the US. Those countries should answer for their brutality and Germany has done so in the past, continues to do so in the present unlike the US. It's quite foolish and absurd on your behalf to justify American war crimes by weighing them against the crimes committed by other powers. Lest we forget, NATO was under the leadership and strong influence of the US and toppling of democratically elected socialist governments were perpetrated with prior knowledge of the US.

[@DanielPeaster]

There are several good books on the history of Hawai'i written by Hawaiians would lived through it that tell a much different, more nuanced story. Sadly the only accepted point of view to look at History through these days has become "white man bad, native people good" this is just obviously over simplified and wrong. It's sad because it misses to opportunity to use history as a tool to examine ourselves and see what happens when good intentions pave the way to hell.

[@OnwardAndAwkward]

As someone born and raised in Hawai'i this meant a lot to me.

[@BiggieBalls808]

Same

[@bherber]

@Chris Buell - I'm sure that you do enjoy protection from the U.S. though and knowing that if anyone tried to invade you, you'd have the protection of the U.S. military. Unless you want to be on your own?

[@gstater4life]

Bryan Herber you sound like mafia, extort the resource for protection? It would be better for the US to protect the Hawaiian islands even if the Islands went back to Hawaii regardless, no?

[@bherber]

@@gstater4life - Jacob who would you have rather taken over Hawaii back then? Japan & the Axis? Somebody would have taken it over if not the U.S. Just not sure who you'd rather that be.

[@gstater4life]

Bryan Herber it’s still talking out of the both sides of your cheek, aren’t we supposed to be different as a nation? Freedom for some strong arm for the rest?

[@Tizzo1982]

Thank you so much for this. Our history isn't known to most. My Great Great Grandmother was arrested and spent time in jail because she only knew The Hawaiian Language, and was teaching Hula. Both illegal at the time. When people visit, and the welcome isn't very warm, they ask "wHeRe'S tHe AlOhA sPiRiT?" Well, it's there, but it's dying. We, as a culture, are getting fed up and angry. This past year, tourism was at an all time high, and for an island, that's not a good thing. I, myself has had to move away from my home twice because I was on the verge of homelessness. But i come back everytime because I want to fight to live where I love and was born and raised.

[@sunnysied713]

In 1830, Queen Ka’ahumanu banned hula in public places, but it was lightly enforced. Hula wasn't criminalized and punished on a large scale. Some people, such as Christians, didn't like how the hula was practiced while _naked._ Simple problem, simple solution. The dancers put on clothes.

[@Revealthereal_]

Black people can relate. I feel my identity is so lost I can only cling to a color. I hate cruel colonialism and white washing! It’s okay to be proud of your skin! Whether in Mexico they speak Spanish from their oppressors in Spain. Brazilians speak Portuguese from their oppressors in Portugal. The Haitians speak French! The Fujians, New Zealanders, Australians etc etc!!!! Across cultures darker people suffer most, why! Because they don’t want you to realize your strength is like a wild horse. Don’t let them keep your spirit caged like a tamed horse! “Injustice anywhere is injustice everywhere!” - MLK Jr. We need to fight back against the brainwashing /white washing media that teaches us to hate our skin!

[@armandosierra7417]

Thank God, King Kalakaua (The Merrie Monarch), brought the hula back to our people. When kanaka maoli end up "houseless" and living on the beach, should we be happy about that? Mega wealthy people, like Mark Zuckerberg and Oprah WInfrey are buying up prime land in Hawaii, while our people are being pushed onto the beaches. If you are Hawaiian or part Hawaiian and own a home, don't sell your home but keep it in the family. Don't give up the fight. An American Indian saying goes like this, "We are on this Earth for a short time, but the rocks live forever" Well, I feel that our culture will also live forever.

[@thomassanio8745]

Rise up and take it back👍

[@huiqinjinxi4514]

This makes me so angry. Who on earth gave the westerners right to do the unspeakable things to other people?!

[@SkyTouch08]

Appreciate the unbiased truth brother. Enjoy the content! Very informative

[@johnversosas8298]

Please do about atrocities committed by US in the Philippines.

[@kallenmurphy]

Philippines are a good ally of the US?

[@dreadpiraterobertsii4420]

the Spanish or Japanese not more brutal?

[@carlo6870]

@@dreadpiraterobertsii4420 Just as bad.

[@shrek7957]

Johnny Angel Their were atrocities, but not on the scale of the Japanese. On the war part only 20,000 Philippinos died of actual combat, but 500,000 died from disease. But personally I feel that the rape and execution of millions is worse than accidental disease outbreaks.

[@iwantcoconutv2877]

I will give you a summary of how usa treated our ancestors. Our first president had a contract with USA to keep allying with them to liberate ourselves from Spain just like Cuba (1898) why our ancestors do that why they trust them if you ask? It's Simple they think they understand their situation because they are once a colony of European too.

[@IdealMotivation]

"The only conquests that are permanent and leave no regrets are our conquests over ourselves." - Napoleon Bonaparte

[@Not_Your_Usual_Username]

“With bigger guns, and an insatiable desire for control” describes the US to a T

[@sunnysied713]

The U.S. didn't fight any wars or battles with the Hawaiian Kingdom. Queen Lili'uokalani, the royalists, rebels and American soldiers all testified that U.S. soldiers played no active role in the Revolution of 1893. Queen Lili'uokalani had attempted an illegal and unconstitutional power grab, which instigated her overthrow. The Committee of Safety and Honolulu Rifles (1,100 - 1,600 local militiamen) forced her to abdicate the throne in a bloodless coup. The U.S. didn't 'steal' Hawai'i. In 1898, the Republic of Hawaii requested annexation and the U.S. granted it.

[@atyanthdutt6632]

@@sunnysied713 sureeee threatening a sovereign power by sending a gun boat is like supporting a coup. You're logic is quite absurd

[@sunnysied713]

@@atyanthdutt6632 There's no historical account that the U.S.S. Boston ever aimed its guns in a threatening way towards the Hawaiian Kingdom. Do you even know Hawaiian history?

[@atyanthdutt6632]

@@sunnysied713 sure man, whatever makes you happy. I've been to Hawaii and can say the natives despise Americans and ig I know more Hawaiian history than you cos you just spreading propaganda

[@sunnysied713]

@@atyanthdutt6632 Brah, I live in Hawai'i. There's no historical record that the U.S.S. Boston ever aimed or fired its guns at the Hawaiian Kingdom. Never happened. Just because you read a tourist pamphlet, that doesn't mean you know mo'olelo hawai'i. Hawai'i is part of the United States. Most kanaka love being part of the U.S. Only a small minority 'hate America'.

[@judithforgony5276]

Thank you for sharing our history

[@alexzea9091]

Latin America being the US’ backyard for its whole existence: we feel you Hawaii

[@theviniso]

Yeah, I'd be happier if they left us alone.

[@dustindiaz9493]

Operacion condor is still remember

[@corey2232]

Uh huh... Because Latin America is the way it is because of Spanish being so nice right? They didn't wipe out entire civilizations & cultures right? Sorry the Brits prevailed in empire building over the Spanish?

[@corey2232]

@@theviniso Mexico's history is rife with wonderful Spanish stories. Such great peoples that took advantage of the locals & committed mass genocide across Central & South America. But let's pretend the US is the only country with a shitty past.

[@theviniso]

@@corey2232 The US has a shitty present, my dude. They and Russia are no different, just imperialistic assholes bullying weaker countries, the US is just a little subtler and has a better PR team.

[@battlestrategistxsupreme3966]

Britain was like " that's my boy".

[@vicparmisano9282]

when US & NATO esp. UK forces were defeated by the taliban all they can sau is 'oh bloody shit'

[@idefyreality2.074]

@@vicparmisano9282 what does that have to do with anything you clown?

[@not_noah69]

@@vicparmisano9282 cope

[@raiderraza6945]

This makes me feel really sad for the people of hawaii and their ancestors.

[@sunnysied713]

This video is full of many historical inaccuracies, half-truths and propaganda. Always perform your own independent research to confirm what you read, see and hear.

[@omikredarhcs8221]

I don't feel sad for them. They had a golden opportunity to take control of 95% of all jobs in Hawaii. But like the Indians in the states , they did nothing. People have been taking from the weak for eons.

[@corbinglenn2567]

@@omikredarhcs8221 dude they were a tiny island taken by a superpower

[@omikredarhcs8221]

@@corbinglenn2567 hmmmm, a tiny island, which island?

[@corbinglenn2567]

@@omikredarhcs8221 sorry a couple of islands controlled by the natives central government with their own leader

[@xochitl7489]

Great program