How To Choose Between Maytag & Speed Queen: A Detailed Washing Machine Comparison

[@FredFlintstone21]

Awesome video! Wife and I bought the maytag commercial washer dryer pair, and the washer is MVWP585GW which has the added water level selector. Hopefully they will last for many years!

[@HarperandKnowles]

That is awesome! Thanks for watching!

[@bloqk16]

The aspect I love about top-loading washers is the ability to let the clothes/garments *_soak_* for a couple of hours in laundry detergent [using cold water], with the occasional running of the agitator for 30 seconds, then proceeding with letting it soak; then putting it through a short wash cycle. The result: Clean clothes without the use of bleach or other cleaning additives; with the exception of the washes for underwear/socks, then I sparingly use a powder additive. The short wash cycle [six minutes] also saves on electricity and the wear and tear of the washing machine.

[@HarperandKnowles]

Thanks for your incites and thanks for watching too!

[@stevegordon5243]

Thanks for the comparison! I've never used a TR series Speed Queen washer but it looks to me that the Maytag has superior wash action. I have a 2013 Speed Queen that is similar to the TC model and it has worked flawlessly for the last 10 years. It's just my wife and I now but the first 5 years of use there were 5 adults using it.........again, no issues whatsoever.

[@HarperandKnowles]

Thanks for the comment. Yeah, the TC5 model is comparable to the Maytag, but I really think it is built better. If you get 15 years out of the Maytag I'd be surprised! Thanks for watching!

[@stevegordon5243]

@@HarperandKnowles Totally agree!!

[@paulstanley3265]

Lol I would love to get 15 years . Do you think the tr washer will clean good I heard it both ways but I like that it is easier on clothes.

[@HarperandKnowles]

@@paulstanley3265 I have heard both good and bad reviews on the TR model. Most of the bad reviews are from those who are used to traditional washers' aggressive agitator action, and I doubt have given the alternative a chance to prove itself. I would think Speed Queen would have discontinued the production of it if it didn't do what it was designed for. Thanks for the comment!

[@jimbosc]

@@HarperandKnowles I have a TR7 - what I am finding is you might need to use the soak or pre-wash cycles more than you would have on a typical top loader for best results - we had a Crosley previously (which is just an off brand Whirlpool washer). Especially to get stains out. Honestly that is not even an option on Front loader HE machines so if you are coming from that to a TR - you might not even realize the purpose of those cycle options. Vast majority of what I wash is not heavily soiled (I have a desk job). I do yardwork and occasional car repairs but no washer has ever gotten those stains out reliably. The TR7 will get it's shot (we've only had it a few weeks so will need to get into the summer to test it out more).

[@davidbabcock7689]

LOVE YOUR VIDS! which machine is better? MVWP576KW1 vs MVWP585GW

[@HarperandKnowles]

Okay here is what my AI assistant came up with when I asked it to research these models. "The Maytag MVWP585GW, like the MVWP576KW, is a 3.5 cu.ft. top-load washer with a dual-action agitator, designed for robust cleaning and durability with commercial-grade parts. It offers multiple water level selections to suit various washing needs​​. Both models share similar features, including the commercial-grade construction, the dual-action agitator for effective cleaning, and a focus on durability with a 10-year limited parts warranty on the drive motor and stainless steel wash basket​​​​. Choosing between the MVWP576KW and MVWP585GW may come down to specific features like water level options in the MVWP585GW or other minor differences in design and functionality. Both machines are built to offer powerful, commercial-grade performance for residential use, ensuring long-term reliability and effectiveness in cleaning." I tend to pick models with less gadgets on them because if they are designed to clean your clothes that's all they need to do. All that extra stuff is just something else that can break. With that said, I think the MVWP576KW would be my choice. But my Missus may choose the other and she's the one I need to please! Thanks for watching!

[@jeremyd2003]

I wanted a speedqueen, but everywhere local wanted way over MSRP. The decent priced ones all wanted too much to ship or wouldnt deliver to my area. Ordered the maytag commercial with a first responder discount, delivered and installed for under 1000 totak. Hopefully, it does well.

[@HarperandKnowles]

It should serve you well. Thanks for watching!

[@naranjojo]

Great breakdown. Would love to hear your take on the Speed Queen FF7 front-loader as well.

[@HarperandKnowles]

Perhaps I’ll review it in a future video. Thanks for watching!

[@C-eq1tj]

Yes. Speed Queen FF7 I’m considering- along with Amana (this brand of washer is still working 12 years later said a fellow customer in Lowe’s today as she pointed the washer out to me in store). I’m also considering Electrolux and Miele.

[@Nflguy4949]

We suffered with an LG Washer from 2013 to 2021. Tons of in warranty problems and several out of warranty issues. Even when it was working loads took FOREVER. Mainly because it would spend so much time weighing and balancing loads before it even started washing. It would also use as little water as possible and often didn’t use enough water to get even mildly dirty clothes clean. There was no option to have the tub fill all the way. Service tech came out and told me it needed over $400 in repairs. Reccomended we get a speed Queen. We got the TC5. It’s a little smaller than our LG was but works like a dream. Full loads wash in 35 minutes and you can set it to fill the tub.

[@HarperandKnowles]

Thanks for sharing your experience!

[@Johncourt409]

Build quality the speed queen wins hands down. Wash action the Maytag cleans better than any newer top loader I’ve seen.

[@HarperandKnowles]

Thanks for your insight! And, thanks for watching too!

[@rebecaesmeralda7399]

Thank you for your content. I’m exhausted doing research after the transmisión in my GE went out. My greatest need is towels and bedding. We have a kiddo with an autoimmune struggle that can cause multiple vomits a day for months when she has a flare up. She also is feeding tube dependent and the formula she needs is awful on clothing and bedding. We have literally often changed bedding 3-4 times a day. I was frustrated with my washer, but after all this research, I think she did the best she could under the circumstances. Besides doing smaller loads, which is my biggest concern with SQ because it’s capacity is pretty small…. With all that info, would your suggestion be any different? Or do you still think that’s gonna give us the best bang for our buck. Or wouod we better off going cheaper model and just accepting that we have to replace every 5 years. Appreciate any feedback. Thank you!

[@HarperandKnowles]

You might want to consider a Maytag Commercial washer. The tub isn’t that much bigger but it might be enough to get you another sheet or do in it. Choosing the Best Commercial Washer for Home Use: Maytag vs Speed Queen kzbin.info/www/bejne/qpTag5yFgtWJe7s Thanks for watching!

[@ignitedhouseofprayer2117]

I am having trouble locating a Maytag MVW574GW. The appliance store told me that it has been replaced with the MVW586GW model. Is it compatible? I am concerned since you mentioned to get the exact model number you mentioned. I had a Kenmore Series 70 for 30+ years but it now has a cracked and leaking plastic drum. Should I just get the drum replaced?

[@HarperandKnowles]

Here is the updated model number MVWP585GW and the link to the Maytag site where you can search for the nearest dealer. www.maytag.com/washers-and-dryers/washers/top-load-washers/p.commercial-grade-residential-agitator-washer-3.5-cu.-ft.mvwp585gw.html Thanks for watching!

[@Wigeon3211]

I would Replace the plastic drum if it were mine. Then it will go another 30yrs.

[@rodbutler4054]

Whirlpool heavy duty has served me well. Hint, leave the cover open when not in use to keep the inside dry.

[@HarperandKnowles]

Great tip! Thanks for watching!

[@DarrenHoffman-w6j]

How do they compare to the SQ TV2000?

[@HarperandKnowles]

The TV 2000 machines are basically the commercial model used in laundromats but without the coin boxes. Referred to as light commercial or a step above the one reviewed here.

[@spinnymathingy3149]

Can you successfully wash delicates, woollens in either machine ?

[@HarperandKnowles]

I'm pretty sure you can. Maytag has a delicate cycle and Speed Queen has hand wash cycle. Thanks for watching another one!

[@whatthe9078]

Speed queen tr series is definitely gentler

[@dtom1145]

The Maytag access for service looks great! Just a couple screws to access the controls or top cover. Finally!

[@HarperandKnowles]

LOL, well said Service Tech! Thanks for watching!

[@Pooroljc]

I'm looking at the Speed Queen TC 5 model, it's more simpler for me. I don't believe it will spin as fast as my Fisher/Paykel. Thanks for your video..

[@HarperandKnowles]

Thanks for watching!

[@suselew]

I would love to get your opinion on the SQueen TR7.

[@HarperandKnowles]

My sister has one and she's well pleased with it. If you commonly have real dirty clothes the TC5 is probably a better choice. Thanks for watching!

[@jimbosc]

@@HarperandKnowles I have a TR7 - love it. But agree if you need max cleaning ability opt for the TC5.

[@thewest5329]

Is the MVWP586GW just a new version or should I stay away from that? It says it had a full 5 year parts and labor warranty.

[@HarperandKnowles]

It looks like a newer model, it should be okay if you decide to get one. Thanks for watching!

[@thewest5329]

@@HarperandKnowles Thank You!

[@common_c3nts]

The only problem I have with Speed Queen is going to a local, no-name place that can go out of business at any time. You will have zero chance for refund or help if there are problems. I think I will just go with the maytag as I can get that at home depot.

[@HarperandKnowles]

That’s a good choice too but I think the Speed Queen has them beat. Thanks for watching!

[@maryfrank5180]

Speed queen has great customer service. So if by chance the small business you purchased it from goes out of business, it would be WAY easier to get ahold of speed queen customer service then it would be to ever contact home depot. They just tell you to call the manufacturer. Which is a joke. Typically, speed queen is only sold at self service dealers which is another great benefit over box stores.

[@doublea6835]

What about the GE Commercial model?

[@HarperandKnowles]

I haven't seen enough of those machines to be able to recommend them. They might be perfectly okay. Thanks for watching!

[@liz6cats280]

You stated that the Speed Queen model allowed a human to choose the water level. According to a person at a store that sells them, whom I talked to yesterday on the phone, govt mandated sensors choose your water level.

[@HarperandKnowles]

Thank you for your comment. I understand that some washing machines have government-mandated sensors for water efficiency. However, in my experience with the Speed Queen model I reviewed, users can adjust the water level using the load size and soil level selections. It's possible that the model combines both manual settings and automatic sensors for flexibility and efficiency. I'd recommend checking the user manual or the official Speed Queen website for more specific details on the model you are considering. Thanks for watching!

[@maxsaviation9512]

Stupid government mandates

[@jennifertiffany363]

I've heard of so many people having issues with the SQ dryer. That's holding me back from jumping into it.

[@HarperandKnowles]

Most of the problems I’ve heard about were from folk’s that have longer than average exhaust vents. These get build ups of lint inside the pipe and the flow of air slows to the point of causing the thermal protection devises to blow as they are designed to do. They seem to be pretty much trouble free if the exhaust ports aren’t restricted. Thanks for watching!

[@douglashaner6802]

​@HarperandKnowles what is the average length? Mine is close to 20 feet.

[@rickwoodruff8211]

Bought a Speed Queen TR5000WN about six years ago. It's making an awful belt noise and leaking as I right this. Look at SQ reviews and you'll see a LOT of unhappy customers. One of the selling points by the dealer I bought it from was it last more than seven years. This one didn't!

[@HarperandKnowles]

You seem to be one of the few people that have negative experiences with the brand. Thanks for watching!

[@pridi28d]

How many towels can the speed queen wash per cycle?

[@HarperandKnowles]

I have no idea. Thanks for watching!

[@eldoradoboy]

@@HarperandKnowles I have a TR7 and regularly wash 10-12 bath towels in it... i use auto water level for most loads unless i want to soak something or for bedding and it does a good job.. the wash action in my TR7 will be indentical to thye TR5 he reviewed.. with 10-12 towels in the machine it doesnt seem to phase it.. still easily gets up to the full high speed spin 800 RPM I think? doesnt shake the house at all.. ive had the machine 4 and a half years and zero service calls.. friend of mine has the maytag 575 and has equally good results.. he has had his for a few years and no issues.. while my TR7 does get my coveralls pretty clean after working on my vintage diesel busses , I do think for really dirty items the maytag or any machine with traditional agitator action works better.. but for 99% of the time the speed queen TR does a fantastic job.. the matching dryer works good too.. only thing I dont like about the dryer is the lint filter isnt removeable so have to finger out the lint

[@hippo-potamus]

What are you talking about mate? The water level option is NOT present on either models. I just looked at the TC5 and there is no way to select water level size. The only option you can press is "deep fill" button.

[@HarperandKnowles]

Deep fill IS a water level option.

[@elevatorproductionsbymaxpassa]

I would prefer Speed Queen.

[@HarperandKnowles]

I agree. There are a lot of places that Speed Queen dealers are very scarce so a commercial Maytag could be the answer for those folks. Thanks for watching!

[@suefortin9625]

Just purchased the MVWP586 Model (Sept 2023) Deep wash does not fill tub to the top (barely half way up! Unlike my previous 30 yr old Maytag, you cannot choose the temperature of the rince cycle. If you live in a Northern Climate where the cold water from the tap is barely above freezing for 5 months out of the year, this is a huge disappointment! Maytag could have added the extra option (had it on the old machine) Still better than all the new electronic models, but not much! This is what happens when the government gets involved in controlling our every day lives! First the light bulb, then the gas stoves, wood burning fireplaces, ceiling fans and cars!! Thank god I’m old!

[@HarperandKnowles]

Don’t forget those water saving toilets that you have to flush 3 times! Water saver….. yeah right! Thanks for watching!

[@LReno-di9cm]

I miss the Mautag man. Loneliest man in town.

[@HarperandKnowles]

He hasn’t been seen since Whirlpool bought them out. Thanks for watching!

[@bobjohnson2172]

Thank you.

[@HarperandKnowles]

You are welcome! Thanks for watching!

[@tempusfugit6820]

I have owned the Maytag for 6 months. I DO NOT RECOMMEND IT. 1- The water level can only be set for 2 of the cycles. 2- The washer will sometimes shut off inexplicably when you turn it on. 3- It sometimes complete a wash cycle but the cycle lights don't change. 4- The adjustable water levels are on the low side leaving "Deep water" and "High" as the only useful levels. The main electronic board was changed on it and the issues remained. Worst purchase I have made in a long time. More edits: the control board was changed 3X so far. The lid switch was changed and eventually they changed the motor. And I STILL HAVE ISSUES. Now, it refuses to spin. That washer is dead weight!! Stay away!!

[@HarperandKnowles]

Thanks for your input. Thanks for watching too!

[@judithjensen2601]

This machine has been extremely frustrating. Just completely shuts off after I turn it on and then the soak light flashes. If you don’t cancel the cycle, it will ignore whatever setting you have on it and fill with just 2 inches of water. It also randomly turns off when I open the lid to throw in a sock I may have dropped. I’ve had the control panel changed twice and the lid switch replaced. Nothing has solved the problem so they are replacing the machine. Reading your post, I don’t have high hopes.

[@tempusfugit6820]

@@judithjensen2601 mine does the same and more. It is a piece of crap and an expensive one at that. The service guy has been to my place 7 times so far.

[@judithjensen2601]

@tempusfugit6820 Maytag replaced my machine after 5 service calls. The service company I was using told me there was nothing more they could do and gave me a reference number to call Maytag with directly. I did that, they escalated it to a special department, someone called me from that department and asked what was going on, I told them in detail (and have videos) and they ended up replacing my machine. So far, 2 weeks using it, I’ve had no problems. My other machine I had problems from day 1.

[@HarperandKnowles]

Some lemons make it by Quality Control. It can't be helped. Thanks for watching!

[@husler1999]

I bought the tv 2000 speed queen

[@HarperandKnowles]

Thanks for sharing. Let us know what you think about it!

[@zepplin839]

I guess I royally messed up getting the TR5 over the TC5

[@HarperandKnowles]

They are both great machines, and the TR5 is much quieter too. Thanks for watching!

[@eldoradoboy]

with a TR, learn to use it.. always use the heavy duty cycle.. never the normal eco.. use the auto water level.. the washer knows best.. only time you use large is for bedding.. when I used to just run full tub in my TR it didnt move the clothes at all.. using auto water level my clothes get clean even though they dont have traditional "massive turnover"....

[@wharrison7131]

Had a Maytag. Two months after the warranty expired, it needed a repair which would cost $350. Never buy another Maytag product again.

[@HarperandKnowles]

Maytag went bankrupt in 2005 and Whirlpool acquired them later the same year. The quality of the product has never been the same. Maytags in the store have exactly the same parts in them as a Whirlpool but Whirlpool sells the Maytag brand at a premium. Thanks for watching!

[@poolahpot]

🤗🤗 best to put "TR series" in the video title otherwise people who might not watch all of your video will assume "all speed queens are the same" just a thought I would only get a TR series if i only had delicates to wash 😏

[@HarperandKnowles]

I’ll keep it in mind. Thanks for watching!

[@231mac]

I have the TR5 and it's been absolutely great. It gets out stains with ease while not ripping up/wearing my clothes. It's a lot better than you've been told.

[@jd2799]

Ok these are totally different washers…. The TR Series is Speed Queens first attempt at a high efficiency washer. The Maytag MGW575 is not high efficiency. The Speed Queen TR has a fake agitator that’s bolted to the tub thus it doesn’t move. The tub moves and doesn’t clean anything. It just swooshes the clothes around. The Maytag 575GW has a dual action agitator that is not bolted to the tub. The tub and agitator move meaning your clothes are being washed and agitated. The Speed Queen TC models are closer comparisons to the Maytag Commercial Washer not to be confused by the terrible Maytag Commercial Technology Washers.

[@HarperandKnowles]

It's clear from your comment that you might not have had the chance to watch the entire video. I actually covered the differences you mentioned between the TR series and the Maytag MGW575 in the review. I went into detail about the agitator design and how it impacts the washing process in both machines. Additionally, I discussed the TC models as well. It's always a good idea to watch the full video before commenting to ensure that all aspects are covered. Thanks for your interest!

[@poolahpot]

best to put "TR series" in the video title otherwise people who might not watch all of your video will assume "all speed queens are the same" just a thought I would only get a TR series if i only had delicates to wash 😏

[@michaelh7877]

Does the Maytag still use a plastic drive hub kit? I have owned it for a year and I will be installing my second drive hub this weekend. Which washer is better for a household of seven people

[@HarperandKnowles]

The Speed Queen would be my choice.

[@intelin123]

Wheres your video

[@DorendaHead]

We bought a Maytag 14 months ago. The motor went out. Maytag covered the motor, but the labor and extra parts that had to be bought. Fixed for about $400. Two months later, (16 month old washer) the whole board goes out. The Maytag is TRASH!!! Never will we purchase anything that make!!!!

[@HarperandKnowles]

It sounds like they over charged you. I don’t know what sort of extra parts they needed to change a motor, and their labor cost sounds exorbitant too. Thanks for watching!

[@parrisestatessouthernhomec3246]

My granny’s 1986 Maytag is a great machine

[@marychambley3601]

I hear Whirlpool bought Kenmore AND Maytag around 2006??

[@HarperandKnowles]

Whirlpool acquired Maytag in April of 2006. Kenmore is a Sears brand and their appliances were outsourced to several different manufacturers. You can tell who built your Kenmore machine by the model number. Whirlpool used the 110.xxxxx format. As of 2017, Kenmore products are produced by manufacturers including Whirlpool, Samsung, LG, Electrolux, Panasonic, Cleva North America, and Winia Electronics. Today, the brand's portfolio is sold across Amazon, Lowe's, The Home Depot, Target, and many other online retailers. According to Wikipedia. Thanks for watching.

[@jeremyd2003]

This one or another model?

[@emarr3720]

What’s the though process here? I would expect the comparison to the Maytag to be the TC5 since they both feature a independent moving agitator & have transmissions. I’ve decided I don’t want to buy crap anymore & I’m willing to spend the extra money. I’m tired of the fantasies that purport to be more efficient & use less water & energy when there’s no difference when you do the math. Sure, they use less water & power but they makeup for it by having these ridiculous long cycles. Same fantasy with high efficiency toilets that have been foisted on us without having the option. Sure, they use use water per flush but you gave flush more than once so where’s the savings & the saving of the planet? I buy replacement toilets in Mexico to get around the water restrictions & I’m not bothered in the lease about the 5-7 gallons per flush bc in the end it’s all the same. I value your knowledge & experience & want to buy the best option. I’m leaning towards the Speed Queen bc I’m not restricted by the water police.

[@HarperandKnowles]

My choice is the TC5 too, but the video is about the two most popular commercial machines on the market. It seems more people are buying the TR7 over the TC5. I’m in total agreement about the toilets too. I think that mandate needs to be walked back. Thanks for watching!

[@Antiorganizer]

Wouldn't the TC5 have made a better comparison? I see you talk about it later in the video. The TC5 seems to have a much stronger washing action. Imagine throwing in a full load of jeans. You want pure hardcore washing with a bit of oomph, and not the back and forth caressing that the TRs seems to do. TC5 seems loud though, but ok if you have a laundry room that you can close. One thing is clear. If you want good quality, build and durability wise, you need to spend double that of a budget machine. One huge downside if everyone started to buy Speed Queens though.... you'd be out of business except your youtube channel (just kidding).

[@HarperandKnowles]

If you look at the data most consumers pick the TR7 over the TC5 because of the added features. That made it the leader ahead of the TC5. I wanted to reach the consumer that had probably considered the TR7 as their first choice and also show them why they shouldn’t discount the TC5. My thinking was that if they had already picked the TR7 as the one to compare to the Maytag then they would have passed on the video.

[@WhittyPics]

Not your mother's Maytag. Today they are Whirlpool

[@HarperandKnowles]

Exactly! Thanks for watching!

[@chompnormski]

I will never buy another Maytag anything ever again!!!!!

[@HarperandKnowles]

Looks like you may be a Speed Queen fan then? Thanks for watching!

[@iLoveBoysandBerries]

Samsung makes the best washer hands down

[@HarperandKnowles]

Lol, there are many technicians out there that will strongly disagree with you. I’m one of them!

[@dannylee1987]

​@@HarperandKnowles Samsung makes great tablets and TVs , but junk washers and refrigerators ...

[@HarperandKnowles]

Thanks for the comment!

[@jeffreyjourdonais298]

The Maytag will not last 25 years imho.

[@HarperandKnowles]

I think you are right. Thanks for watching!

[@margaretnorvell9555]

Be careful on what models you buy in both brands. I think both of them have models made in Mexico. Black and Decker used to be a good brand for small appliances until they offshored to Mexico. Now they are junk. Whirlpool makes a habit of hiring Mexican nationals in their US factories. How do i know? Bc when Whirlpool had a temporary layoff in our city, the unemployment office was deluged with claimants who spoke Spanish, no English. And after being stationed at Ft Huachua Az and watching Army men take their cars for repair or body work to Nogales Mexico, thinking they were getting a good deal and seeing the end result, I will buy any product from any part of the world rather than Mexico or south of the US border.

[@HarperandKnowles]

I’m pretty certain that Speed Queens sold in America are made in America, in Ripon Wisconsin. Unfortunately some of the electronics are from Mexico with Asian components on them, but that is because there aren’t any electronics manufacturers left in the USA. Thanks for watching!