I Turned The Smash Roster into ALL POKÉMON

today I answered a question nobody asked me too, but I enjoyed so, I hope you enjoy listening to me make up a roster as accurately as I can for a scenario that can never happen
follow my twitter :)
➤ / commadey
check out my other channel
➤‪@commaD‬

[@commaGarbage]

Welcome to the channel, I hope you like the video. Too weird? Just right? If you enjoy my stuff check out my other channel. www.youtube.com/@commaSecond So yeah I didn't just go a month without a video lol

[@WilliamiteWilliamiteStudiosWWS]

Can you turn the entire roster into Dutch angel dragons too?

[@Merc.FromSewer]

I loved the way you chose to put some less popular mons over going to the easy route of "top 72 pokemon"

[@commaGarbage]

Yeah tried to get some balance, prioritize Pokémon that would be unique. But still couldn’t disregard popularity.

[@bruhsonafes4844]

I can totally imagine Lugia being the Ridley stand-in for TimeSpace Emissary, where you'd fight regular Lugia first in a lab, then you'd fight Shadow Lugia as you're escaping Citadark as it's about to erupt or something.

[@commaGarbage]

Yooo that would be so sick

[@Merc.FromSewer]

Some fun facts that I thought would be interesting: -Puff in 64 is a "joke" that why its very similar to Kirby and really bad; -Meow was planned for 64, but couldn't appear to time development -There is a codename for Plus in Minus in Japanese code for brawl -Lucario in smash has "aura" that increase his power more he's hurt, (idk if that is in the movies?) Sakurai choose incernoar over decydue in ultimate because he preferes a wrestling style over a zoner archer

[@Merc.FromSewer]

Man it's hard write on phone

[@commaGarbage]

Yeah definitely kept some of that stuff in mind while making the video. Even got recommended a short about the plusle minun thing while making this video

[@elenagirip555]

​@@commaGarbageAdd one of Caterpie's evolutioms pls

[@Mike-di3mo]

​@@Merc.FromSewerpuff in 64 is mid tier 6/12

[@Mike-di3mo]

Explain to me why puff is really bad in 64

[@Dailvin]

I really enjoyed this video. You make PEAK content bro

[@commaGarbage]

Thanks dude, try my best

[@brandonwilliams6119]

This was a very fun watch and I love how you created these rosters based on what Pokémon games were out at the time of each Smash game being released. I even love the parallels you did too like Scyther and Scizor being the Marth and Roy, Plusle & Minun being the Ice Climbers, etc. I could definitely see Blaziken being the Captain Falcon. For third parties I was kinda expecting Digimon Augmon and maybe Dragon Quest Slime lol? But Darkrai and Deoxys aren’t terrible choices either for the Pokémon Brawl TimeSpace Emissary where all regions are merged love that plot idea too. I’d genuinely love a Pokémon Smash Bros!

[@commaGarbage]

Ooh time space emmissary is a cool name. Yeah I don’t think this video would have been nearly as fun for me if I wasn’t trying to correlate it with the real smash bros games. Also pokémon smash bros would be such a sick spin off.

[@cptnomar492]

Ditto could have represented the mii fighters

[@commaGarbage]

I could see it, honestly this made me think of smeargle, being a good pick due to sketch

[@vanessasandoval96]

Inkling girl and boy - Inkay and Clauncher Ridley - Aerodactyl Simon Chesnaught Richter - Heracross Dhelmise King K Rool Krookodile Isabelle Fennekin Piranha Plant - Carnivine and Mawile Joker - Roserade Luminary Flygon - Erdrick Dragonite - Solo Salamence - Eight and Munchie / Goodra and Dedenne Banjo Kazooie - Urasing Trumbeak Terry - Infernape Byleth Marowak Min Min - Hydriegon Steve Alex ice cube head penguin Sephiroth Yveltal and Cynthia Pyra- Mythra Tapu Koko Lele Kazuya Incineroar Mew Sora

[@jona_hehe3768]

He should be hired for pokken tournament

[@commaGarbage]

Me or Sakurai? I’m sure we’d do great jobs lol

[@vanessasandoval96]

Peach /Tsareena Daisy Flotetta Bowser Blastoise Ice Climbers / Plusle and Minum Zelda / Sheik- Meloetta Falco - Hawlucha Marth - Gallade Lucina - Virizon Young Link - Sirfetch’d Gannon- Emboar Roy - Keldeo Chrom Combulation Game and Watch - Octerilly

[@Jelly_shy_guy_man]

For the 3rd party’s you should have made them characters from other gamfreak games, maybe mega man is harmo knight.

[@vanessasandoval96]

Meta Knight - Fortress Pit - Dartrix Dark Pit /Honchkrow Zero Suit Lopunny Wario Mimikyu Snake - Seviper Ike Tekron Diddy Kong - Chimchar Lucas Female Meowstic Sonic - Alolan Sandslash Dedede Empoleon Olimar - Dewpider Toon Link Celabi Wolf Lycanroc midnight dusk midday

[@Deltidion]

I would play this.

[@commaGarbage]

but who would you main?

[@Deltidion]

@commaGarbage probroably eevee, my faviroute Pokémon. Especially if one of its smash moves let's it turn into a jolteon, flareon or vaporeon. That would be sick.

[@ViorbyX]

Guys, hear me out. Mario replaced with Brionnne

[@vanessasandoval96]

Villager - elemental monkeys Mega Man- Golem Wii Fit -Medicham Rosalina Luma Gardivoir Minor Little Mac Hitmoncham Mii as Ditto Mega Gardivoir Palutena PAC MAN - ghastly Robin -Zeraura Shulk -Absol Sivallia Bowser Jr Larry Roy Wendy Iggy Morton Lemmy Ludwig / Squirtle Vaporeon Espeon Sylveon Leafeon Umbreon Jolteon Glaceon Duck Hunt - Smergle Herdier and Ducklett Ryu Lucario Ken Blaziken Cloud Samorutt Corrin Kingdra Bayonetta- Pheromosa

[@liamfitzgerald1400]

Yeah, I'd play it!!

[@commaGarbage]

It be nice to get some more Pokémon spin offs in general

[@2tontyler]

As someone who has Gourgeist as a close, and I mean VERY close second favorite Pokémon (Pikachu being my number one), I’m disappointed that Gourgeist didn’t make the cut for any of the later two games, but I can understand why.

[@vanessasandoval96]

Mario/Pikachu DK Rillaboom Slaking Link Decidueye Samus Deoxys Dark Samus Genesect Yoshi Bagon Kirby Jigglypuff Fox Braixen Luigi Eevee Ness Male Meowstic Captain Falcon Talonflame

[@commaGarbage]

I didn’t take this approach but this is a pretty cool way to do it

[@joopvanhedel1372]

Jigglypuff is popular in the anime

[@commaGarbage]

True it showed up relatively often during the original series

[@TheReZisTLust]

Yup, back in the day the Jigglypuff Sings episode became iconic due to sass.

[@StarWalker-si4nm]

I haven’t watched the video yet, in the future after I finish my career in programming I will make a game like this. It’s not going to be easy but I already got the pokemon for the first characters that will be playable on first build assuming I’m able to start the project. I know pikachu is the mascot but that’s a little lame for my taste so I’d have to go with a starting roster of 6. Blastoise, Charizard, Hypno, Dodrio, Marowak and Machamp. I feel like with this I can establish a few different play styles and different styles of characters. Later on Nidoking and Gengar would definitely need to be added in a long side a few others but these six are definitely good to start with IMO. Edit: Thinking it through, instead of adding Gengar I’m going to go for Haunter because I genuinely like Haunter better it could lead to more creativity. Venusaur needs to be included since the other two starters are in. Alakazam could use some weird kinesis techniques which seems cool to me. Give me ideas I’ll write them down for the future.

[@commaGarbage]

That is sooo cool, I would love to play it one day. For some extra ideas I think Scyther or Kabutops would add a "sword/slashing" character. Also Ditto would be funny, I imagine all it could do is move around slowly, with it's only move being transform, changing it into one of the pokemon on the field or a random one from the roster. Though you could also turn it into a really cool fighter by having it transform into different pokemon for it's different attacks say it's up B makes it a pidgeot flying up.

[@Sainoupenia]

should've added cleffa over igglybuff imo, clefairy was originally going to be the mascot b4 getting determined to be "to girly"

[@Clodsireenjoyer-bc9cd]

I love Zacian but that thing terrorized competitive pokemon and competitive pokemon unite

[@commaGarbage]

interested to see how it does now after the ability nerf

[@Clodsireenjoyer-bc9cd]

@@commaGarbage not just ability, 20 less attack. Due to being from the same generation, Zamasenta got both defenses lowered by 10. Also, Zacian is still doing good because it's typing is excellent and still has high stats. As for pokemon unite, it was the best release in the entire history of the game, some could argue it could be lower though. It even is getting nerfed in unite soon. Sorry for the rambling

[@commaGarbage]

@@Clodsireenjoyer-bc9cd I’ve never really played vgc or unite so it’s cool to hear about it

[@axemredalawadhi8482]

No Grovyle from PMD? Bruh

[@commaGarbage]

yeah that would been a cool choice honestly

[@stevesamuals2651]

Should have included smeargle as a fighter imo.

[@WilliamiteWilliamiteStudiosWWS]

Can you turn the. Into Dutch angel dragons too?

[@james8183]

you couldve had fineon be the pirahna plant of this game smh

[@Tylerr_Creative]

You could do Pokémon Battle for the name ngl Pokemon Rumble would’ve been perfect name

[@commaGarbage]

yeah both of those work better than pokémon smash

[@weirdguy1495]

Pokemon Rumble already exists unfortunately.

[@Rexred09]

Hey I have an Idea. Maybe you could bring custom moves into Ultimate but treat them like TMs in a sence where if you reach some sort of achievement, you unlock a TM disc and teach it to your pokemon. Just select the pokemon and then if they can, they learn the move. This can either slightly change the pokemons moveset or change it entirely.

[@commaGarbage]

oh yeah i can see something like that it reminds me of the custom moves in smash 4, but with a pokémon twist.

[@Rexred09]

There are also some pokemon that Personally I would have put instead Heracross Bisharp Kleavor The Hitmons Abomasnow Marshadow Nidoking. I also feel like you couldve put in a gen 9 rep to draw up hype for gen 9. Maybe Tinkaton.

[@commaGarbage]

Yeah definitely some good picks, as for a Gen 9 rep, I don’t think Gen 9 was even announced by the time sora came out, plus BDSP Legends Arceus were the next unreleased games so adding one of the Hisiuan Pokemon would be pretty cool

[@Rexred09]

@@commaGarbageBy that logic, I would pick Kleavor. Unique type combo, completes the Scyther line, can do alot with the massize axes etc

[@GreenHousehold]

Dude, Sudowoodo is one of my top 7 favorite pokemon.

[@commaGarbage]

he’s a pretty neat guy

[@Linkling21]

i would have gone with bulbasaur because hes the most iconic and is pokedex no 1

[@commaGarbage]

Yeah I would add bulbasaur too

[@TheRealTeddyGaming]

Poké-Brawl

[@Sam-nh1ye]

So Sigma video

[@DiamondsGaming32]

Next time you need ludicolo

[@KirbyZilla]

SmashMon

[@TheReZisTLust]

Super Pokemon Scratch Pals

[@skypiea115]

Is this SynthCool?

[@commaGarbage]

no, but if i was would i tell the truth

[@enternamehere9223]

Yo i'd be a Serperior main is all i'm saying lol.

[@commaGarbage]

I’d be playing Raikou, big quadripedal smash character just seems cool

[@enternamehere9223]

@@commaGarbage Ooh also seems cool, DOPE! All your choices were peak.

[@thefatass500]

I think Munchlax and Bonsly would have been must-haves in Pokémon Brawl. They were added in late gen 3 media to promote (the upcoming at the time) gen 4 (i.e.: XD Gale of Darkness, Destiny Deoxys), so it'd be a crime to not add them both in Brawl.

[@commaGarbage]

I could definitely see that, I’m not sure how important those 2 were by 2008 though since gen 4 had long been out by then.

[@_Gemkas_]

These ideas could use some work IMO

[@commaGarbage]

yeah definitely coulda fully formed these some more

[@_Gemkas_]

@commaGarbage some ideas were very great, however I didn't like the whole "1 to 1" pitches ~ it feels too rudimentary with the restrictions in that the creative liberty of choice is almost gone. For example, "we need an ice climbers character" ~ "we need a zelda/shiek character" ~ "we need a Dr.Mario character" \ all that to me made me slightly rather unimpressed with the pitch. Though aside from that there was a lot of good here so great job, regardless of such the video was very impressive!

[@huhfeesh]

NSFW version of this Video. I smashed all Pokemon.

[@Meeetyfeet]

Bro just recoloured the tf2 logo

[@commaGarbage]

noooo I recoloured it, and put a circle in the middle, completely copyright free