Ice Cream Meltdown! Why Amber Heard’s Evidence BACKFIRED

At the Depp v. Heard trial, Amber Heard introduced a photograph of Johnny Depp asleep, with melted ice cream in his lap. But in the end, the evidence backfired and wound up helping Johnny. In Part 1 of a series, Harvard Lawyer Lee does a deep dive on the evidence presented at trial and how and why it helped or hurt the parties.
#johnnydepp #amberheard
Follow me on Twitter: LawyerLeeW

[@AnnieWarbux]

I hate that the "ice cream set up photo" is usually cropped. In this original full size photo, we can actually see her "bruise kit", sitting out in the open. I cannot BELIEVE this poor guy had to work 17 HOURS as Whitey Bulger and then go home to a Psychopath of a wife!! He is a Saint for Never Striking her!!

[@rlight7666]

Oh no! You can see her bruise kit @9:13😀

[@AnnieWarbux]

Tnx!

[@jctell1014]

The crazy thing is that they weren't even married yet at this point. So if he was doing all the things she claimed, why didn't she just walk away? She wanted and needed nothing from him, according to her.

[@rlight7666]

@@jctell1014 I didn't realize they weren't married at that point. Wow

[@blakekeane5507]

In hindsite these things are not easily learn't... the best course of action was for him to say "see ya later" and separate pre-2015 when his friends all completely hated her.

[@Kimi1968ful]

It's odd how she took these humiliating pics of him but didn't take any pictures of herself when he repeatedly punched her in the face with rings on every finger.

[@chrisw942]

Chef's kiss at that perfect answer!!😄--This is why comments are helpful to read!!

[@Kimi1968ful]

@@chrisw942 ❤

[@skyhime]

Its almost as if she was never beaten..

[@ShazGreenock]

@@skyhime 😂😂🐕🐝

[@stompthedragon4010]

But she did! Remember her ' bruise' kit🤣 Imagine if she' d claimed to have used a ' r..ape' kit, like they do in ' real' r...ape cases.

[@gleefulme9617]

Anybody who has put in a 17 hr day (which he had the day the photo was taken) will be tired. Amber is a jerk & proved it repeatedly through out the trial.

[@alicerose9140]

Especially once in yr 50's which she has no idea about, yet.

[@andreacarter8202]

She sure is a jerk.

[@gleefulme9617]

@@alicerose9140 She will. That is, if she lives that long.

[@fnyaung]

Also, the photo was taken at around 11 PM. That’s when people start to feel sleepy and considering he worked for 17 hrs he must have been exhausted

[@angieangie5461]

Yip the anxiety knowing to come to your home after a long days work 17 hours to a psycho who is going to taunt and mess with your mind. Looking for a fight over anything is unbearable and daunting destructive. I would also polish off a bottle or 2 of wine just to deal with a screetching demented schizo psycho. Poor Johnny putting up with her and her free loading low life friends. Its an ordeal beyond.

[@khristophertanase3324]

Generally speaking, when opiate addicts are heavily under the influence, they are extremely agreeable and nodding out. Something that they are not, is violent.

[@donnathomas6509]

But someone on provigil (AH) is aggressive and high strung, he just wanted to sleep , the only way he could block out her nastiness

[@stinehansen191]

Yeah i know

[@dalerimoller272]

As a recovering opiate addict, I agree with you.

[@jackwolf78]

Didn't she say the "opiate Johnny" wasn't abusive? I feel like I'm pretty sure she said that.

[@persus5727]

Believe me, I know. My husband was an opiate addict for 8 years. He was never violent.

[@wetwingnut]

Amber thinks : This picture shows how Johnny is an out of control addict. The rest of the world thinks : The fact that you took this picture shows how hard you were working to humiliate and degrade your partner. Amber still doesn't get the fact that the BEST witness for Johnny's case WAS HER!

[@MissaFits13]

TRUTH!

[@preciousjohnson1433]

Exactly

[@KingDWS]

Exactly. All she had to do was prove he hit her etc but all her so called evidence was either in question as to validity or went off topic like this. From watching trial (actually thinking he probably did at start...) I counted exactly TWO pieces of supporting evidence and both didn't seem right. ie the bruise seemed to move and changed shape even tho purportedly taken same incident. If you took them at face value then they had some relevance but to me they looked off like a makeup smudges or even or at best a bruise from a injection site... Molten ice cream on someone's lap doesn't go much towards proving abuse.

[@gailpeters4173]

Agree

[@Reesa601]

Very good comment! So true!

[@patnelms6378]

This video really illustrates why the jury didn’t believe Amber and ruled with Johnny. Amber seems so insincere.

[@harvardlawyerlee]

Thanks for the comment, Pat.

[@marieharris1230]

INSINCERE??? That,s putting it mildly. Disgusting POS!

[@rayc9899]

Why the hell would she take that picture of him, she want to destroy his image from the start, evil mind.

[@brendanboomhour7606]

According to the jury she came off as creepy, I don't blame them, I wouldn't want someone looking in my general direction while apparently talking to someone else either

[@roostersideburns3440]

but on one point what was the jury thinking awarding her 2 million for something his lawyer said.

[@kirsty.H34]

Its just dehumanising, disrespectful and degrading. I would never take pictures of my partner asleep like that. If he really was passed out then why? That's her husband, help him don't belittle him.

[@chrisw942]

Exactly! I would never do that to anyone I love. It really showed that JD was the vulnerable one. He didn't show photos of her high on coke, shrooms, prescription meds, and wine.

[@fouraces1949]

It was her plan from the moment she met him

[@catrina24]

@@fouraces1949 I have said that from the beginning it’s his karma for leaving his kids mother

[@ArtBrain]

@@fouraces1949 It was. The fact that he fell for it is sad.

[@lickalotlickalot2210]

@@catrina24 Not Karma but the sexist law that would believe women based on their words alone! This could happen to any man good or bad! And you just blamed Johnny again you see what you did?

[@ThePhysicalReaction]

This doesn't look bad for depp. You follow someone around long enough in their home, and you'll be able to try and get a frame job on them. It looks terrible for her doing these things. She is a predatory, exploitative, arrogant, dishonest and deceptive. She tried to rip her insurance company off too by taking out a policy to try and cover her legal expenses should her defamation lawsuit scheme fail - which it did.

[@chrisw942]

Predatory is how I also view her. At the beginning of the trial, I had no opinion--but quickly understood she was a predator and liar!

[@Babidi111]

- heh, there are really insurance companies for losing defamation lawsuits? that seems so shady.

[@perryrhinitis]

@@Babidi111 I'm sort of following the insurance company lawsuit (they sued AH because of the DvH trial outcome) and she set up a "personal liability" insurance for $1M w/c would have been awarded to her if she had won the case.

[@LadyAstarionAncunin]

Good point. Some of the things I even just mutter to myself when irritated watching YT could make me look like a horrible person even though I'm not. You can form any narrative you want by taking things out of context.

[@MerelvandenHurk]

@@perryrhinitis Not just that, they would also cover her legal fees if I remember the policy correctly. Which means that it was a flat-out lie that she couldn't keep donating the divorce money "because" she was sued by Depp. She mentioned $6m before she was cut off but it's a bullshit argument, because her insurance was supposed to pay the legal fees. And that's on top of the fact that she had all the money 13 months before he sued her, which gives her no reason to stop her installments.

[@KG-cc6qx]

Poor Johnny! He was still such a sweet man throughout this trial! He had every right to stand up for himself!!

[@Grouchydragoon012]

The picture of him asleep with ice cream in between his legs makes sense in the fact she never cared for him as a husband or a person. She was in love with the fame that was attached to his name. If she was a caring wife she'd never have given him something like that and taken a picture of it like this. Instead she should've probably asked if he's struggling to keep awake maybe he should go to bed. The fact she never showed care for him in any of her pictures is the real evidence that is being shown.

[@notsofast60]

Constantly cheating on him shows everything about her character and how much she cared. This was all collected for nefarious reasons.

[@ae0ther]

A good person would take the ice cream before it melts on his lap at the very least

[@t.r.7958]

Mit einer Hand in der Hose isst man kein Eis, vielleicht hat sie gewartet bis er schläft und ihm dann das Eis auf den Schoß gestellt das dann erwartungsgemäß irgendwann mal umfällt und ausläuft .... erbärmlich diese Frau, denn er ist in dem Moment so hilflos .... armer Johnny, diese Frau war nicht gut genug für Dich. MEHR ANTWORTEN ANSEHEN

[@BreakofDawn]

Honestly the amount of staged photos she had and photos she had of him passed out and how long she had been doing it, made me believe that she drugged him with her sleeping pills to get those photos. It doesn’t make sense to me why anyone would take photos of someone like that instead of helping them

[@Matt-cr4vv]

You could MAYBE see photos like this from a different person. I.e. a person who’s been telling you about their concern for your substance abuse who takes a photo to show you what you as an addict aren’t seeing. She clearly wasn’t as you can see she was sending it to her friends etc which doesn’t demonstrate concern. Some people take photos or video of people who are intoxicated to show them when they’re sober so they can see what they’re really like when they’re in disbelief. That clearly wasn’t the case with her.

[@oscardesignma]

And yet, we're still waiting for Amber's photos of her "terrible" injuries, with her broken nose, blood everywhere, arms and feet cut and bleeding... What? No photos of that and no medical records? But sure, Amber has a looooot of photos of Johnny sleeping or passed out.

[@celticgold4028]

After she'd hurled a full Vodka bottle at him, severing the top of his finger and splintering the bone,... instead of rushing to help him, she just went upstairs, took a sleeping pill and went buh-byes. Not exactly the loving wife is she?

[@Songbirdstress]

@@Matt-cr4vv It seems she never even showed them to him. Or the doctors. Just her friends.

[@jborrego2406]

Me too

[@ceelow1073]

Staged…..what person eats ice cream with one hand jammed into their pocket? She is absolutely horrific

[@lisat776]

And his right hand was in his pocket.

[@benjie128]

I've honestly fallen asleep in the middle of eating, just because I was that tired.

[@BENI_MMNA]

But you were holding your spoon, no? Your hand was not in your pocket.

[@cynthiatucker2147]

Even Johnny said it too. His other hand was in his pocket. If he was eating ice cream where was the spoon? It was exactly as he said. AH had him hold the ice cream just to take the picture once he fell asleep. 🤦‍♀️ She never loved him. Never!

[@katanyajason3316]

And what person eats ice cream without a spoon?

[@hoptoit5910]

It just shows what a nasty person she is. To do something to another person when they’re not aware of what you’re doing. She’s so unbelievably cruel. Also the photo where he’s asleep where he has a ponytail right on the top of his head. You _know_ she deliberately did that to embarrass and belittle him. She then messaged that to others

[@jessicamarvel2309]

It wasn't JD's style to make a ponytail like that. It surely has to do with psychopath Amber making it as a ponytail while he was in deep sleep and laughing it off with her lesbian friends where her friends leave rent free and utility bill free in JD's house.

[@fayegrant5738]

She is one monster that needs to be exposed! The woman is so demented! Once it was out that she had a baby, all I could think of it that poor child! What she did to JD, is beyond apprehensible! She is one sick cookie!

[@deboracopeland4795]

She filmed him the day his mother died, how cruel.

[@javanjunkindahouse6625]

@@deboracopeland4795 omg nooo, did she really?? Jeezus she has zero compassion.

[@beest_]

Still some meat on this AHGD trial to make💵. Nice breakdown on the topic.

[@hdnft4633]

A narcissist will make you feel small, humiliate you at every turn, and beat you into submission just to feel superior. Her jealousy is so tragic. She set him up to frame him.

[@loritalbot3063]

She said she wanted him to get off the the boos but when he asked to help him and stop drinking herself she said " I don't have a problem " That doesn't sound like someone supporting her spouse!

[@Ultamami]

*booze

[@Dollgrl1]

Amber Heard is a bigger drunk & druggie than JD could ever be , she was also drugging him .

[@YayaBolender]

What a shame to do something like that and chiefly to show the photos to other people. There was a photo, I’m not sure if it is this one, where AH forgot to remove her bruise kit from the floor, and we can clearly see the bruise kit. They didn’t talk about it during the trial, but it only proves that the jurors’ decision was the right one. AH is really not a nice person. And she is not as smart as she thinks. Camille Vasquez is much much smarter.

[@MyChilepepper]

@ 6:21 shows the bruise kit picture

[@brendanboomhour7606]

Pretty sure it's the uncropped version of the ice cream one, the bruise kit's right at the bottom

[@YayaBolender]

@@brendanboomhour7606 I thought so, that it was on this photo

[@agotapongor2069]

This picture shows the bruise kit. I have to correct you! Camilla is smart here, no Camille is brilliant, adorable and in comparison: Amber is the opposite!

[@emom358]

From the start she spent too much time trying to embarrass him, and not enough time on him allegedly being physically abusive.

[@amberturdcoloringbook1733]

She was supposed to be helping him get better and not embarrass him. Not love she had for him. She just wanted fame and money.

[@sleeplesshead602]

@@amberturdcoloringbook1733 your username got me 🤣🤣

[@kellidinit3725]

Well, it didn’t do her any good when the TMZ guy said she called them to tip them off she was filing abuse charges against him with that bruise after not being near him for over two weeks.

[@dawnhowells2591]

Because she wasn't abused...

[@amberturdcoloringbook1733]

@@sleeplesshead602 My user name is taken from a real book. 🤭

[@falseking989]

Camile: If JD was such a monster didn’t it scare you to send an embarrassing photo of him to a friend knowing he would get upset? Amber: Why would it? This was a huge smoking gun. Amber claimed outrageous life changing levels of abuse. But she couldn’t understand the issue of making fun of him to her friend???

[@chrisw942]

AH using photos or footage of JD to exploit him, to gain approval--how could he have trusted her during their marriage? She sold footage to TMZ--So self serving, and calculating! Thank you for this breakdown, Harvard Lawyer Lee!

[@harvardlawyerlee]

You’re welcome, Chris W.

[@donnakawana]

That's the work of a narcissist with Histrionic mental issues... This is how this woman is per Dr. Curry...

[@gailruffu6073]

Astonished that There is a photo of Johnny on a boat/vacation (with his hand still bandaged) with Amber AFTER Amber amputated his finger. Also a recording of Johnny alone in a hotel room AFTER she got the TRO and TMZ PHOTO of a faked bruise on her face. Mind boggling! Why did he continue to hang out with her, alone no less, following these events? Me thinks He may still be in danger of being lured back into her web. Perish the tought!

[@mazzid9973]

@@gailruffu6073 He put up with her as long as he could, after that incident it started to wake him up, he realised she was like his mother, that was the wake up call, he knew he couldn't go through that trauma again. 🙄 😵‍💫😳🐨🙃🦘

[@jackwolf78]

The pictures were only meant for Depp, not meant to be made public. And selling to TMZ? I see why people would think that, but all it is HARD speculation.

[@kariberg9494]

It looks like Johnny Depp's ice cream cup was spilled and then placed back on his lap. it's sitting straight up isn't it?

[@kariberg9494]

The cup is sitting straight up

[@lauraelliott6909]

Good point! If this had been properly staged, she would have left it tipped over.

[@mamiestacy1704]

I believe if she truly loved and wanted to help him, she wouldn't want take a photo that was clearly embarrassing to both of them. That is a strange way to show your concern. Johnny married someone that didn't love him and was not ever in his corner. She lacks compassion.

[@deliamartinex2710]

All of them..that Rocky woman..her sister..her parents..all of them parasites..living for free in JD's building..taking advantage of him..making fun of him ...being witnesses if you can call it that ..for that evil woman!!! They are all discusting!!!

[@loriloucks-loricanhelp2771]

What an excellent and educational way to compare and contrast. Would love to see you dig into more examples.

[@harvardlawyerlee]

Glad you liked it!

[@LeynaViera]

I know right! This is saving me hours of streams, love this place 💜

[@rayc9899]

Nothing better than ice cream or chocolate when you are stone....lol with Disney carton.

[@GenXBitch]

Without getting too personal myself, I know exactly what he means when he says he took opiates to feel normal. That’s what it becomes. You take them to avoid withdrawal and so you can function. For those who don’t know, opiate Withdrawal is indescribable and horrific. When she went to the island with him when he went to kick the pills it was pure torture for him I can assure you. Just listening to someone talk is painful. She’s an evil twisted person.

[@ugaugauga488]

Lots of people vilify addicts of these opiates not realizing that they're going through hell and are struggling to get back to normal. There's much inhumanity in many people who just judge and then go to church hoping to go to some kind of heaven.

[@Solitude11-11]

@@ugaugauga488 Especially as in most cases they were prescribed the medication by their doctor for pain, with no idea they would be come an addict. You don’t realise until you try to stop. Not something you do for fun.

[@ugaugauga488]

@@Solitude11-11 yes

[@stevenmorrison2953]

She refused to give him his actual medication when he was trying to get off the stuff . She withheld it from him ! Pure evil

[@agotapongor2069]

Even surgeons in Australia removed Amber from Johnny!

[@MrUppertorso]

“Weren’t you scared that your abusive husband was going to find out you were sending embarrassing photos of him to your friends?” “Why would I be?” Amber’s PTSD in a nutshell

[@alwayslernin4400]

100%!

[@avg5658]

🙄PTSD???? 🤔Idts.....Feeling superior, lacking empathy, exploiting others, sensitive to rejection ... All are hallmarks of Narcissistic Personality Disorder, not PTSD.

[@verenamenzel8958]

leaking fotos or videos of johnny without his permission is that not called abuse too????

[@edie1011]

Wondering why the owner of that driver’s license apparently used to cut cocaine on the table was never addressed. Did the drivers license belong to Amber or to Johnny.

[@mazzid9973]

@@edie1011 I believe someone said it was Amber's licence. 😵‍💫😳🙄🐨🙃🦘

[@caroledwards3289]

She constantly turned her head away from people asking questions to look at the jury. Like any answer she gave was just some answer to give to the jury. As if she was ignoring the person asking the questions. That is what trials are about. Questions to determine the truth.

[@arbiter1]

Yea some jurors have spoke up keeping themselves unnamed for now that they said it was creepy she was doing that and didn't help when she would be crying no tears then stone cold faced 2sec later.

[@danielwagman9794]

Yes...and it's interesting to contrast her turning toward the jury with Johnny Depp's camly and thoughtfully responding directly to the attorney asking him questions. In doing so, I think Johnny appeared much more honest, reasonable, and relatable.

[@juliad.6372]

Ha.,ha..ha..Yet it backfired right ? Great...

[@Wanda-lm5fq]

When I saw the "melted ice cream" picture, my first thought was -- "Why would Amber think this made her story more believable? WHY did she think it cast her in a good light and made Johnny look bad?" It looked like he was so tired and/or exhausted that he couldn't stay awake. He has a job that requires really long days and very vigorous physical activity. Why WOULDN'T he be so tired that he fell asleep while he was having ice cream? BUT --- on the other hand, how likely is it that she STAGED it? She saw he was exhausted and gonna pass out, so she waited for him to be sleeping and then maybe SHE PUT THE MELTED ICE CREAM IN HIS HAND/LAP for her 'photo op'. To me, it seems totally in character for her to do something like that

[@jessicamarvel2309]

JD is a right handed and it is unlikely of him to hold ice cream on his left hand.

[@bevnicholson9916]

She is not normal and she has no idea how normal people think.

[@cathylindeboom4494]

Me too. I also think that Johnny was by far the bigger person for not similarly exploiting HER. She drinks, or drank, two bottles of wine a night? She sounded drunk/high on MANY of those audio interactions. You can't tell me she didn't have similar moments which he could've used to try to embarrass her, but he didn't. Whereas she seemed to look for those opportunities with Johnny.

[@ameliab7245]

Johnny wasn't having ice cream. That was Amber's ice cream and she put it in his lap. A loving responsible wife for one thing would not do that. For another thing, if Johnny was eating ice cream and fell asleep a loving responsible wife would take it out of his hand and clean up the mess. But we know Johnny's right hand was in his pocket. I'm surprised the dogs weren't up there licking up the ice cream. Where were the dogs when all this was going on? Most dogs would love to have a feast of spilled melted ice cream. I don't even think this possibility was brought up during the trial. I'm also wondering who cleaned up the mess after Johnny woke up.? I have the feeling Amber left him covered in ice cream all night long while he slept after working a long 17 hour day. she obviously had no respect for her husband and didn't appreciate all the work he did and didn't appreciate her living there for free along with her free loading friends. and she wasn't paying for those $500 bottles of wine she and her friends were drinking it was Johnny's money that she was spending very wastfully I might add.

[@julieo4580]

I know it’s sorta crazy sounding but I absolutely believe she was planning on an overdose or something like that and that’s why she had so many pictures like that. She’s on audio telling him here take a Xanax, you need it. She withheld treatment from him on the island. That’s not what anyone who cares about another would do. And the picture of the Coke on the table with the text “yay for mornings” - yay is slang for Coke.

[@juliad.6372]

Intentions were premeditated for sure...It was our God who intervened here..her I niquities reached the heavens..the lowest of the lowest..

[@sarahspencer1010]

I bet you're right about the overdose.

[@notagain2856]

Amber demanded Johnny to put her in his will since start of their marriage. She started showing her true colors when it dawned on her Johnny never going to put her in his will.

[@politereminder6284]

Considering she cut off his finger over a prenup while complaining that she wasn't in his will ...👀

[@myvids718]

Totally agree! She intended to drive him to od so she could claim all his things. She probably doesn’t even think it’s wrong smfh

[@Almondeyezzz84]

His humor is who he is. Why would that change once he's on the stand. He's genuine and not trying to hide his true character like amber so depritley tried to do while she was on the stand.

[@sarahlang2119]

So true

[@Bess9779]

I wondered while watching the trial how 'out of their mind' someone could be and STILL put extensive hours per day into filming a very physically demanding movie. Thanks for the video!!

[@kaljlowe]

I agree that it seems insincere to say she feared him yet took ALL these embarrassing pictures.

[@louiseplatiel5431]

An excellent breakdown of what really ruined AH's case: her testimony.

[@ungenx]

She did not have a case.

[@memnocktdevil]

You know what it was? She rarely just answered a question. She seemed to always re-frame every question. Doing that made it seem like she thought she was better than Camille. You just knew from her answers that she thought "alright little girl I'll show you whose in charge here." Then she'd look at the jury like we all know whose right here. It was just creepy.

[@keturahspencer]

If you zoom out that picture, there's a bruise kit on the coffee table. By bruise kit I mean a theater makeup kit for making bruises.

[@ingiford175]

Came here to say that. And the color pallet of that kit is a bruise creation kit that is used in theater, not one to conceal bruises.

[@Vixen781]

AH isn't smart enough to be clever, she left a lot of breadcrumbs behind her.

[@arielmcgillacuddy6640]

Or a kit for covering bruised up.

[@keturahspencer]

@@arielmcgillacuddy6640 that's not what was on the table.

[@arielmcgillacuddy6640]

So she openly kept a “bruise kit” as you call it? And he knew all about her making bruises on herself and he never mentioned it? Never said why are you making bruises on yourself? Hmmm I am not sure what it is. Make up maybe. Very well could have been his. Don’t you find it odd that in all those recordings where they discussed their physical fights he never once proclaims “I have never laid a hand on you Amber.” Not once. Oh never mind you know he hit her you just don’t like her so you think she deserved it!

[@vampkilmer]

"Why would I be?" It's amazing because this was a rare moment in the trial she was being 100% honest. Its also a perfect example of her narcissism; she can only mirror/mimic normal emotions to a point. She was not genuinely afraid of him, and her inability to feel neurological emotions prevented her from understanding why most everyone watching *would* have been afraid of being caught by an abusive spouse.

[@jordanmorris5194]

It’s kind of impressive how many times Amber walked into the “Do you recall “…”?” “No.” “Let me refresh your recollection….”

[@theredrover3217]

That first one was deadly❗ Best part was Camille's delivery, just shy of glee. 😜

[@aClownBaby-]

@@katecrab9340 Also so so combative even with “you decided to confront Mr Depp, right?” - “I didn’t decided to, I *wanted to* “ 💀

[@mzznewyork5406]

and I love every bit of "let me refresh" WOW ! Camille was awesome and amazing

[@dianaroach3093]

I loved that part of the trial. Let's refresh your recollection....priceless

[@XeroJin84]

As someone who grew up in an abusive household, what Amber said makes no sense. Amber Turd doesn’t know what it feels like at all.

[@gjstone368]

She just admitted she put lit cigarettes out on him when he was passed out… wtf?!

[@aliaf22]

Yes I just clocked that! Oh so she was just checking how passed out he was. She is even more of a sicko than I thought. And admits it!

[@nic8834]

That's sadistic. What timestamp?

[@JayMaverick]

"Wasn't participating in the festival of ice cream." That's brilliant.

[@wittnessbe_judged8723]

I was just talking with my son last night about this exact image and I noted to him that Johnny Depp's hand was in his pocket. There is no spoon, so there's no way that he knew he was going to eat ice cream. I bet my Son a 100 bucks that Amber, put that ice cream in his lap, then took that image, and sat on it. If it were my husband or the man of my dreams, I certainly would not have taken an image of my love in that condition. I would have been successful in waking him up, asking him if he was OK then, I would've cleaned the ice cream off changed the clothes of my husband, put him into his PJs kissed him, and told him, I love you. I will see you in the morning, good night. The one person you are to trust is the one you live with that the one that you say I love you to every morning and every night you don't take the most ugliest images of him to embarrass him and to be bold in enough to take it and share it with others a wife is supposed to love and honor her husband Amber everyone should be aware of the who that you are

[@t.r.7958]

Mit einer Hand in der Hose isst man kein Eis, vielleicht hat sie gewartet bis er schläft und ihm dann das Eis auf den Schoß gestellt das dann erwartungsgemäß irgendwann mal umfällt und ausläuft .... erbärmlich diese Frau, denn er ist in dem Moment so hilflos .... armer Johnny, diese Frau war nicht gut genug für Dich. MEHR ANTWORTEN ANSEHEN

[@t.r.7958]

Du hast so recht, wenn man jemand liebt dann nutzt man solche Momente nicht aus um ihn bloß zu stellen, sondern hilft ihm das alles gut wird, ich glaube das sie das mit dem Eis selber arrangiert hat um ihn in ein schlechtes Licht zu stellen.

[@wittnessbe_judged8723]

@@t.r.7958 Diese Frau ist der wenig schmeichelhafteste Mensch, den ich je gesehen habe, ein Licht über dem anderen, sie kann sich nicht einmal an ihre Lügen erinnern, sie ist so betrunken, dass sie die betrunkene Nummer wählt und sich nicht daran erinnert, was sie sagt, wenn Sie das britische Gericht sehen wo es nichts mit Amber an sich zu tun hat, aber Amber ist dort zur Unterstützung der Sonnenzeitung. Ich glaube, Elaine Amber hat gehört, dass die Anwaltschaft entzogen werden sollte. Es gibt so viele Dinge über diese Frau, die ich Ihnen sagen könnte, aber es macht wirklich keinen aus Unterschied für dein Auge, nicht wahr? Ich lebe mein Leben nicht so. Ich liebe meinen Mann. Ich respektiere meinen Mann. Ich würde meinem Mann niemals erlauben, mich zu hassen, noch würde ich meinen Mann schlagen ein Bild von ihm in diesem Zustand, und Sie haben Recht, Johnny Depp hat auf keinen Fall Eis gegessen, er ist mit den Händen in der Tasche eingeschlafen, während seine eine Hand in seiner Tasche und die andere auf der Couch lag, auf die sie das Schmelzen gelegt hat Eis in seinem Schoß, aber schau, was sonst noch im Ph ist otograph da ist ein blaues kit drin das einzige was diese frau wollte war jack deps ruhm und geld und all seine monetären dinge sie mag frauen sie mag leute erpressen alles für einen buck ich bezweifle sogar dass sie ein baby hat ich sehe es nicht Elon Musk kämpft um das Sorgerecht, also glaube ich nicht, dass sie ein Baby hat, und was Sara angeht, ist der einzige Grund, warum diese Frau kein Baby austragen konnte, weil sie drogenabhängig und alkoholkrank ist, es würde ihr irreparablen Schaden zufügen Kind, sie ist ein Sludmuffin

[@k.c.5426]

This picture makes me so sad. It shows how Monster Turd took advantage of Johnny in his most vulnerable moments. 💔

[@pln3153]

Same here. My heart breaks for Johnny 💔. She is so vile and disgusting.

[@t.r.7958]

Mit einer Hand in der Hose isst man kein Eis, vielleicht hat sie gewartet bis er schläft und ihm dann das Eis auf den Schoß gestellt das dann erwartungsgemäß irgendwann mal umfällt und ausläuft .... erbärmlich diese Frau, denn er ist in dem Moment so hilflos .... armer Johnny, diese Frau war nicht gut genug für Dich. MEHR ANTWORTEN ANSEHEN

[@trippaloz3037]

all she has is photos of him on the nod dunno how he can be violent when all she has legit photos of is him sleeping it just makes me laugh how wrong amber is

[@zedmelor8842]

Yeah, where is the photo of 'monster' Johnny as she claimed? Not one.

[@jessicamarvel2309]

So true, no photo of JD abusing Amber. Only a video of him assaulting the kitchen cabinets. There was this one audio where Amber Turd said "Stop pushing me, Stop pushing me, Stop pushing me". And JD went blur out and said "I'm not pushing you". Amber Turd tried to frame JD of assault when actually she was assaulting JD multiple of times. She is one crazy lunatic unappreciative wannabe actress

[@observationsfromthefringe9048]

If you look at the non-croped version of the Ice cream photograph, at the bottom left there is a literal "bruise" make-up kit opened for all to see. That's where her bruises came from. She slipped up and mentioned it at one point during the trial, then quickly corrected herself. I can't wait until she shuts up and disappears into obscurity.

[@karensteck3800]

how did i miss festival of ice cream before? that was priceless!

[@made-line7627]

Sounds like the best day ever 🍦

[@sandraknight4751]

With a mega pint!

[@johnwiles4391]

I didn't watch all of the trial but I did listen to the audio that was in evidence. You are so correct to emphasize how Ms. Vasquez revealed the lie that AH was afraid of JD. The audio (to an unbiased listener) makes it absolutely clear that AH had no fear of JD whatsoever.

[@usainengland]

?? What do you think about the critique of this trial, that it was a popularity contest? I found photo evidence to be shocking. I wouldn’t take photos of my worst enemy passed out. Too cruel.

[@a.m.5541]

people who think it was a popularity contest did not watch the trial because if someone watched it and thats their take its laughable

[@seratonin7004]

It's always a pleasure to receive a notification that you have a new video up, and to hear your lovely voice!

[@harvardlawyerlee]

What a nice comment! Thanks!

[@ShockwaveDawn]

This was probably the point where I lost the last grain of any belief I might have had and Amber's case - when she brought in 3 photos of Johnny sleeping. Her claims were about how he was physically abusive towards her, and all she has to show for it is how he falls asleep in various places... what a monster he is!

[@adriannemalden8668]

Im thinking she was tellibg him he was a monster and did these horrific things when he would nod off and of course he didn't remember. I say because it never happened.

[@SpookyRooster135]

This is the ultimate betrayal of trust. Someone taking photos of you, at your most vulnerable and sharing them, without permission. It's disgusting.

[@innocentnemesis3519]

When she said ‘why would it?’ THAT was the point of no return in this trial. Compulsively lie all you want, Amber - but her self-absorption tells on her in that statement. When you’re trying to paint yourself as the victim, be sure you’re actually empathetic enough to understand when a true victim would be scared of incurring abuse.

[@katanyajason3316]

I'm surprised that nobody addressed the question: "Where's the spoon??"

[@elaineparisi8626]

JD was open about the pictures and everything else when she said the monster she was referring to herself, she is out of her mind I'm so glad that JD got away from her she is a piece of bologna. Thank you.

[@flokimuyukijones670]

Please, that's a great insult to bolognas lol. Just compare her to a turd, thank you haha

[@juliad.6372]

Yes indeed..myself felt soo outraged while watching the trial..the things wanting to say we're bad..because of sheer low immoral Lifestyle ..adding all..just have no words..

[@veronicasandoval5767]

Please dont insult bolgogne in such a manner

[@Ckawauchi35]

Johnny is actually a saint for never laying a finger on AH throughout all those abuse and provocation by her. In the beginning, I have heard some KZbinrs say that they were both at fault but it is now obvious that Johnny has only been tolerant, kind, and even a passive victim.

[@patriciawilliamson686]

This is something a narcissist will do to "show" that the problem isn't her but is her partner. Talk to her friends about how bad her partner is, so they will think what she says is true.

[@sharonjuniorchess]

I bet Amber used to play as a kid setting her dolls up to play out her little stories. Pity it didn't work on grown up jury members.

[@BreakofDawn]

I imagine her more to be the type who rips off the heads of her dolls and then mutilates their bodies. Just seems like something she’d do

[@sharronjones1017]

Actually she used her sister & pets.

[@janai5074]

The photo of Ben Affleck passed out on the deck of a boat yesterday...."I had so much hope for this couple, but I had no idea Jen was a victim of DV or IVP." The lack of foresight in Amber using these pictures as an exhibit, it continually exposes her lack of humanity.

[@raivilafreedom8208]

If he was my husband and he fell asleep like that after a day of work, I’d make sure he was comfortable to get a good sleep.

[@gs-xx8uv]

I would never take a photo of my spouse like that! If our relationship had deteriorated to that point, I would have left long ago.

[@sisterssquad909]

And it was before their marriage....

[@idykay2935]

This is such a good video. helps me understand how the evidence worked against her.

[@carolenglish8805]

8

[@jocelyntraywick5945]

What great evidence would AH have had? None of her evidence showed he abused her or anything. All it showed was he's a man that likes to drink and passes out. Or worked a 17 hr day and was too tired to stay up. Or was upset cause his mom died. Never a video of him putting his hands on her. Never a real photo or medical records of all the horrible things he did to her. May I add a lot she's said she should have been in the hospital. She is a piece of work. She makes me so angry.

[@lottieerdfalvi1030]

As a narcissist abuse survivor I truly believe that this monster Turd had an even more evil agenda for all those years....she wanted to do away with Johnny building the way to a fatal overdose witch she could have perfectly backed up with her "evidences" ... she's a psychopath....

[@jocelyntraywick5945]

@@lottieerdfalvi1030 oh yea it definitely was planned

[@Korcasandromedaa]

The main story of the ice cream he worked 17 hrs filming. She's evil everything she did was with a purpose.

[@politereminder6284]

He also took opiates and predictably dropped off from them

[@mewho6199]

I just realized that Heard mentions a lit cigarette in her response about the ice cream photo. There is no reason to do that at that moment unless she is trying to subtly remind her victim about how she put out a lit cigarette on his face after she cut his finger with the bottle. The more you listen to this person, the more she reveals about how sadistic she is.

[@eirintowne]

I wish everyone in the HeardHerd could be made to sit through this 5 or 6 times, until they could manage to understand the tiniest smidgeon of why everybody else in the world sees something they don't see!

[@richaddulieu1967]

There's 2 versions of this picture and you can see the coffee table with a bruise kit in view for making bruises

[@lisat776]

I saw that. It is literally called a “bruise and abrasion” kit. It is used to MAKE bruises; not hide them.

[@Almondeyezzz84]

The hand in the pocket is what did it for me. Lmao

[@RoseSharon7777]

Notice the bruise kit on the coffe table in the ice cream photo. It appears.

[@culby276]

Oh man! Thank you for pointing that out. I never realized

[@SheXyShellyMarie]

That’s what it looks like. She’s not the brightest cat ever.

[@anontwofourfive]

What I don't understand is why would she have her bruise kit out for him to see? Was it a passive way of showing Johnny what she could do if things don't go her way?

[@anacleta424]

She should be ashamed of herself Taking pictures of him like that She’s a monster she’s evil woman

[@katewest130]

Your BEST video on the Heard-Depp case by far. Insider information that only an attorney could provide.

[@Jkjoannaki]

"Yes miss heard showed it to me kindly the day after she took it" I don't know whether to laugh or cry wtf

[@WhiteRabbitAnne]

Great analysis much more in depth than many of the other "let me explain court to you" crew. KZbin is always about finding your perfect niche and giving audiences something they can't find elsewhere.

[@hoptoit5910]

She should have been grateful to have such a kind and loving man as a husband that would do anything for her. That wasn’t enough. She wanted _everything_ of his and wanted to destroy him and his career. Yet she claimed to ‘love’ him 😖

[@jonfreeman9682]

Oh she had it good and was at the top of the world. Then blew it all up.

[@BenginamanTheBawws]

the ice cream photo that AH's team submitted has the bruise kit cropped out and the one that JD's team has not been cropped and Camille asked AH "and you took this photo too, didn't you?" making sure the the bruise kit was visible and open and potentially being used at that point in time when he clearly couldn't have struck her because he was unconscious

[@ellietobe]

There could have been an entirely different type of trial if it was held in California. They got a judge that went by the book in Virginia. A prejudice judge in these things can make or break a case. In this case the judge just left justice run it’s course.

[@silverdar]

you can clearly see the bruise kit at the bottom of the photograph.

[@ellensmellen11]

I think it not only highlights how argumentative and unbelievable she was but also her lawyers were both pretty inept as far as objections and the remount of times I watched them ask the same question over and over after johnny already answered made me cinge

[@annawallace9276]

Great video! I always love your perspectives!!

[@susanwelch9087]

I love listening to your breakdown of things. Thank you. I think JD just telling the simple truth is what turned Scamber's own evidence against her and showed how cruel and cunning and devious she really is. Him just being himself too. The PI that Scamber hired to dig up dirt on him (who she fired) went back decades to try to find stuff and all he got was how well loved and respected JD is.

[@PureSparkles22]

If she hated taking photos of him sleeping.... then why do it?

[@aluxcia7885]

Everything you've pointed out is so true and in contrast it looks so bad how Amber denied any faults whatsoever and it was a situation where she's saying she's an angel and we all know no human is an angel but she really tried to portray that character on top of denying how vicious she was in those tapes and I can only imagine how she was when she wasn't recorded

[@crimsonshadow1649]

When AH asked "Why would it?" my jaw dropped at how stupid and nonsensical that answer was. If I were on the jury, that would have been the moment for me that she lost her case.

[@sarahlang2119]

I totally thought that too. Remember her evidence re giving him the knife? "I didn't think he'd stab me with it"

[@after-arts4708]

I agree. She contradicted-and negated- her entire argument.

[@winstongordon9694]

@after-arts4708 She an idiot lol 😆 😂

[@barbaragraf5639]

Watching your videos with joy and I love that you are so neutral in this case, just explaining and not blaiming. Thanks a lot and kind regards from Germany 😍

[@remohor]

Excellent analysis. Now, I want to be a law student at Harvard!

[@KG-cc6qx]

How would he change the narrative WITHOUT being a little argumentative??? And he’s a LITTLE argumentative NOT constant like Amber Turd!!!

[@AScribblingTurtle]

I love this kind of Deep-dive analysis. It shows, that lawyers have way more to do than just ask questions and show evidence. They have to keep track of the narrative, what the Jury may think, and most importantly how they ask questions. Can't wait to see more of this. Subscribed. 🔔

[@Westwindymoto]

I don't get why Amber didn't Help Johnny in that moment. I woulda cleaned up my passed out friend best I could, pillow for his head & maybe a light blanket. Gollllllllllly. She Never loved Johnny.

[@SledDog5678]

Incapable of loving someone.

[@罗晶耀]

It appears to me that she somehow admitted to have asked Johnny to hold the ice-cream, knowing what would gonna happen as he has said. Her goal was to " let him realize how his addiction can be an embarrassment and seek for help"....

[@bojohanconstantlyconfused1386]

Great video of the breakdown of trial lawyers and the preparation needed. I would have liked to see Dr. Smeagle telling the court he was told it was vomit...whole other deviousness.

[@tracik1277]

And he said it was ‘vomitus’ who says that ever?

[@vexedvixen]

@@tracik1277 ah, I know right, but it IS such a fun word to say!😆

[@tracik1277]

@@vexedvixen Yeah man, it’s sick!

[@KG-cc6qx]

You make some valid points but I don’t even see what alleged evidence Amber had and I m not a lawyer or forensic specialist!

[@BreakofDawn]

Right! The only evidence I see is someone heartless decided to take an embarrassing photo of their loved one to publicly shame them, instead of helping them like they should have

[@banditkitty2743]

Per Dr. Spiegel (Smeagle/Gollum) Amber Heard's team told him it was vomitus

[@tomasfuchsbauer1536]

Spiegel .. Mirror in German .. mirror mirror on the wall who's the doc brown on the wall ?

[@bmyra]

Excellent analysis and explanation. Thank you.

[@harvardlawyerlee]

Glad you liked it, bmyra.

[@joseh3564]

Her lawyers were terrible because they should have anticipated this.

[@leescience]

One of the things that came out was that on the coffee table in the foreground has a theatrical bruise makeup kit

[@sedalionthunder6295]

I loved Camille’s questions, kept the jury and Amber focused on quick and short answers and drawing on the evidence and witnesses around Amber to destroy the original narrative.

[@barbaraceleste9486]

Before you start: what kind of IQ dose it take to put a melting Ice Cream in the lap of “THE SEXIEST MAN OF THE YEAR” twice.😂😜😊 I am only human 😜

[@hannahalice1000]

The more I hear about the trial the more i realize how superior JD lawyers were. Not just in the overall strategy but in the preparation they must have given to JD to agree to, and even more importantly, follow that strategy.

[@Melissa-zg3ih]

She had plans to destroy him before they were married. She had a three year plan. There's a recording of it.

[@caseytenney2150]

I absolutely LOVE your explanation of things!

[@missmays4933]

I’m sure throughout the day everyone has at least one gringy moment like ice cream melting on our laps. She lost because her evidence was bs! Instead of painting JD as belligerent and outta of control, AH made him more relatable to the average Joe.

[@swally4704]

Yes

[@ReaL0RazZ]

When I was suffering from addiction no where did anyone take embarrassing pictures of me in order for me to get help. Even in the rehab none of the councilors mentioned anything about embarrassing pictures being needed in order for someone to get help. Amber thinks everyone in the Jury is stupid.

[@Boo-jy5ju]

Johnny worked 18 hrs!! He was exhausted. She set that photo up. Disgusting! Shows how low she stoops!!🤬

[@Inflatableorc]

14:40 Something about the way she says 'why would it' , and the context, sounds like every evil psychopath woman I've ever met rolled into one.