ROMANCE LANGUAGES: SARDINIAN & EASTERN ROMANCE

[@aromanian-socialist]

as an aromanian thank you very much you are the only channel that gives spotlight to Aromanian !

[@poprobert5422]

Hey! Do you have discord or something? I'm a Romanian who is really interested in the Aromanian language and culture. I've never spolen to an Aromanian:)

[@saebica]

@@poprobert5422 We do have a Discord server

[@shootingeagle3554]

@@poprobert5422 I want to learn more about aromanians aswell

[@shootingeagle3554]

@@saebica what's your discord server, I want to see how much romanian you could understand

[@Cec1nator]

@@poprobert5422 vino in constanta si intalnesti destui:)))

[@DonTornado]

Istro-Romanian having Slavic numbers for nine and ten caught me by surprise. Lol

[@apyrrhus0]

I mean Romania is surrounded by Slavic speaking countries

[@wyqtor]

@@apyrrhus0 Ah, but Istro-Romanian is spoken in Croatia, not in Romania!

[@sjov9]

@@apyrrhus0 romanian has also slavic words i mean lets start with DA

[@mimisor66]

@@apyrrhus0 Istro -Romanian is spoken somewhere in Croatia

[@fireydoesstuff_real]

@@apyrrhus0 Hungary: 👀

[@robertofranciscomonsalvesp8080]

This is absolutely fascinating! Thank you, Andy.

[@viperking6573]

I literally love youuuuuu you included all varieties of sardiniaaaan 😍😍

[@ouoliao9561]

I'm learning Romanian💖

[@pow3redthebest]

Will you also make a video about italo-dalmatian languages? Neapolitan, Italian, sicilian etc

[@saebica]

Hi, Andi! I'm very glad Aromanian is here! I love seeing Aromanian promoted as we Aromanians do struggle with helping others get to know us. S'bâneadzã Armânanea di daima sh'di iutsido.

[@aromanian-socialist]

HELLO DUDE ITS ME from the server !

[@aiurea1]

I didn't understand the phrase

[@healththenopulence5106]

Daca ai stii… ca tu vorbesti limba daca

[@saebica]

@@healththenopulence5106 Cine vorbește limba dacă? :))) Te rog, nu veni cu istoria asta dacopată inventată de vreo 15 ani

[@saebica]

@@aromanian-socialist Helloooo

[@riccardosebis5333]

Tzincu... Saludos dae sa Sardigna,(sardigna no est Italia)

[@Sanzianabel]

sardinian and romanian both have “limba” instead of something like “lingua” like the other romance languages, same with the word for water

[@angelp.3924]

No sciu, da sa patti mea ( campidanu) acqua, si narada " agua o s'acqua ". In atrasa parti del sciu chi narant " Abba " I don't know, I know that in my part (Campidano) water is called "agua", in other parts (of Sardinia) it is called "Abba"

[@Sanzianabel]

@@angelp.3924 yes i was thinking about “abba” being more similar to “apa” in romanian

[@viperking6573]

@@Sanzianabel I know this doesn't make sense but my sardinian surname is the same as your youtube username xDDD

[@viperking6573]

@Timoc Timoc you say acva? Holy shit, so the word change from aqua to acva to apa, damm

[@viperking6573]

In logudorese and nuorese we say : Abba, apa, water Limba, limba, language Battor, patru, four There were others but I don't remember :T

[@Davlavi]

Informative as always.

[@gokith1119]

Another fascinating video, Andy. Thank you

[@danutbe6541]

Nice! I wish that there would be also the dialects from Romania, like from ; Banat, Ardeal...

[@saebica]

Those are accents

[@CrysolasChymera2117]

@@saebica Accents, and would be interesting to see the comparison in vocabulary and pronunciation isn't it?

[@angelp.3924]

I don't believe it! you really made a video about my second mother tongue, sardinian. 😀 in the Sardinian language there are many Spanish words, for example: Iglesias, ventana, carira, mesa... Or, In the city of Alghero, however, we also speak Catalan. 🙂

[@xtraviation]

Sardinia used to be controlled by aragon (aka big catalonia) so it makes sense that you speak catalan too.

[@angelp.3924]

@@xtraviation Um, no, unfortunately I don't speak Catalan because I live in the southern part of Sardinia. therefore I speak Campidanese Sardinian and I have difficulty understanding who speaks Nuorese Sardinian. 🙂 That's right, Sardinia has also undergone Spanish domination for centuries, this explains why the language is also close to Spanish. For example, I don't have an Italian surname, but I have a spanish surname 🙂 So I believe my ancestor was Spanish.

[@diegone080]

@@angelp.3924 no one in sardinia have an italian surname, maybe only people in the highest north because they are basically corsicans

[@riccardosebis5333]

@@angelp.3924 De aundi ses?

[@riccardosebis5333]

@@diegone080 esatto, quelli italiani hanno origine corsa o siciliana e del resto d'Italia

[@raihanfarrelofficial]

Request: Spanish & Portuguese Dialects

[@goodstuff8156]

There should be one video with all of the languages and every dialect. Or even just all of the European dialects.

[@Exodus-16]

I've never seen a flag of Croatia with a style of Romania. I've been in Istria 3 times and never heard about Istro-Romanian. 🤔

[@antonioconstantinmusic]

Because the istro-romanian unfortunately is on the verge to go extinct

[@francek3892]

Well am from Croatia and how Dalmatian language died in the 19st so are the languages in Istria dying Like in Istria you have: Italian, Istriotski and Istro-Romanian Istriotski and Istro-Romanian are dying except Italian

[@diegone080]

@@francek3892 i hope italian will stay forever in istria

[@francek3892]

@@diegone080 it probabbly will be alive bcs there are more people who speak Italian than Istriot and Istro-Romanian. But also Italians still want Istria and Dalmatia in their hands and they are anoying just bcs Romance languages were spoken in those regions

[@turnermarius4471]

Romanian language is one of the few that writing and speaking sound the same, what i mean is not like German, where what you write and what you speak is the same. Plus is the closed to Latin, next to Italy. Plus yes Romania has roots, in Slavic, Germanic, and even some Arabic, but mostly Latin.

[@massimolisoni4990]

Italians say the same about their language, but it's not 100% true as some groups of letters like ch, sc, gl are pronounced differently in different languages. Anyway Romanian, Italian, Spanish, Catalan, Japanese are the closest in pronuciation and writing 👍 English is just the hell 😄👎

[@diegone080]

Sardinian is actually the closest to latin

[@comraderomania7988]

ARABIC? turkish loanwords not arab

[@healththenopulence5106]

Romanian is not slavic, turkic or other nonsense.. romanian actually has deep dacian roots but at the time of the nation building of Romania in 1848… the indo-europenistic language studies disnt exist so they couldnt study romanias substrate. They went with an imposture variant of history claiming we are romans.. which is nonsense, we are the dacians.. proven by linguists in new york To hide the dacian roots of our language, the fathers of this artificial history looked in the dictionaries of our surrounding languages and attributed their origin there just if the words looked similar.. For example of this grave mistake… you my friend think Romanian has slavic in it… well, as a romanian which also studied russian i can tell you i didnt know 1 russian word… Its because the word “razboi” they atributed to slavic because they wanted to get rid of the dacian origin… so they found something similar to “razboi” in russian which actually means “theft”… see the mistake? For turkish “loan words” its even more funny… they wanted to get rid of the dacian word “bursuc” so they found in the turkish dictionary “borsuk” which is a tree species… Everything that didnt look latin was considered a loan word from other languages… to get rid of the dacian element Our history the way its written is a farse, we are here for more than 3000-7000 years (hungarian chronicles also say it… our enemies) Its very stupid how Academia Romana ignores this.. because look at bulgarians or hungarians… every nation looks for even a coin or bone on their land, to prove their historical right… and us romanians give our dacian words to others…….

[@healththenopulence5106]

For more info look on YT: Mihai Vinereanu, Daniel Roxin, Carme Huertas, etc

[@dragskcinnay3184]

I mean... the point with vulgar Latin is that it was dialectal in nature, right ? There was no "standard vulgar Latin", because the whole point is that it's "vulgar", it's the Latin that's spoken by the people, as opposed to the litterary, written standard. So I feel like including a "vulgar Latin" row doesn't really make much sense, since we don't know the time or place. And I'm also fairly confident, though I don't really know the details so it's possible I'm partly wrong, that "vulgar" and "classical" Latin were never both spoken at the same time and place ; "vulgar" Latin emerged when people started pronouncing Latin differently from the pronunciation of the Classical period, while still retaining the exact same writing. So for example, there isn't a word in "vulgar Latin" to say three, it's just that different people from different times and places pronounce the Latin word for three each in their own way.

[@Gooduser-Jevin-h4k]

Romance languages (Sardinian and Eastern Romance and Search language) Vulgar Latin Sardinian (Logudorese) Sardinian (Nuorese) Sardinian (Campidanese) Romanian Istro-Romanian Aromanian Megleno-Romanian

[@Tubulce]

@Timoc Timoc Moldavian is not a language.

[@riccardosebis5333]

Logudoresu(nugoresu), campidanesu

[@Celik_2012-g3t]

Bună ziua Andy eu sunt Krissy cum voi puteţ draduseti aşa de greli limibi eu nu ştiu

[@turnermarius4471]

Ar trebui sa știi romanii nu au dificultate cu limbile străine . Plus dacă studiezi numai limbi străine can hobby, totul are sens.

[@antonioconstantinmusic]

@@turnermarius4471 Românii invata limbi straine foarte usor deoarece o avem in genetica noastra proto-europeana si limba noastra Româna se trage defapt din cele mai vechi radacini proto-europene, indo-europene insa istoria este manipulata si plina de minciuni!

[@sjov9]

As slav istro romanian shocked me :)))

[@saebica]

HEHHE

[@AceAmericiumWind]

thanksssss

[@ThePanEthiopian]

The croatian romanian flag is cool

[@Chriss-yp9sb]

Amazing video ! I am from Romania and I can say that we , Romanian and Istro-Romanian have a significant slavic influence while Aromanian and Megleno have a Greek influence. Our standard Romanian language is based on the Daco-Romanian dialect (as the Romans interracted with the Dacians) but nowadays the Dacian words in our language are very few, and there is not much evidence of thraco-dacian language group.

[@jer8036]

@@antonioconstantinmusic latin and dacian are both indo european and the proto languages of the branches were similar so what is the proof

[@manygor2687]

@@antonioconstantinmusic Romania was settled by Slavs during slavic immigration like the rest of northern balkans!

[@healththenopulence5106]

We dont have slavic influence. We latinized some slavs and they kept words close to them. But we romanians have our latin words. Thats why we got duplicates in our language

[@deacudaniel1635]

As a Romanian, I can confirm your Romanian pronunciation in this video is pretty good.I can still hear a foreign accent but not that strong.I don't know what is Andy's native language.I'm curious.

[@massimolisoni4990]

Filipino I guess

[@cjanoel]

Filipino

[@ouoliao9561]

Formosan languages,please💖💖💖

[@dean.haraldkolompar7624]

1:55

[@MazdakLindsey]

Hello!!!!!

[@SauTunSud2025]

Never heard of balcanic Latin Proto Romanian came from , balcanic Latin '?? It's a made up story to lie that some Latin words in south Danube countries are not from Romanian, but from Latin as well. Like Slavic ,dosto'( enough) is not from Romanian,destul'( enough).. There's another related word Satul( tired of) from Latin , Satulius ' In the balcans there was Greek, Proto Romanian and all other related languages and of course Dalmatian which was the link between Daco Romanian and Italic languages notably, Venetian.

[@Sanzianabel]

Romanian is from the balkan branch of the romance family

[@jacksonamaral329]

interesting. the brazilian portuguese is come from this family.

[@ninds437]

Português Brasileiro é Ibero-Românico, uma língua românica ocidental

[@paolorossi9180]

@@ninds437 Just portuguese

[@michaelfernando5672]

No. It's part of Ibero-Romance family.

[@OkThisllbeMyName]

unu xd

[@maplesyrup5244]

first

[@narudoshow7123]

Where is moldavian language ?

[@cosmina.m.7570]

That doesn't exist! It's plain romanian. The only difference in spoken language is the accent. And also some random russian words.

[@DeliaRoman-vy2ki]

Istro-Romanian having Slavic numbers for nine and ten caught me by surprise. Lol