In The Slums Of Jakarta

[@Kirmada385]

Indonesians tend to share selective, favorable images of Jakarta's modern buildings and infrastructure on social media, which can create the perception that the country is highly developed. However, the reality is more complex, as Indonesia still faces challenges with issues like poverty and cleanliness, just like any developing countries. It's important to avoid making broad generalizations and recognize that no country is perfect.

[@arjanasimov5933]

In 2012 I once lived in jakarta and witnessed for myself that jakarta is a metropolis that never sleeps for 24 hours, infrastructure and buildings are so magnificent and modern but on the other hand many villages or residential places are very shabby and it is adjacent to such a magnificent building what a very contrasting scene! There is such an unequal economic equality I think, I stayed there for 1 month..

[@momorudi]

I was born and still live here for more than 40 years. What you describe is correct.

[@arjanasimov5933]

@@momorudi So presumably I consider it appropriate for the capital of Indonesia to move as soon as possible to Kalimantan (according to the news I heard) Jakarta is already too heavy to be the capital of the country, a business city, a capital of the country, plus Jakarta is also prone to flooding

[@anandasyahendar7293]

2012 and 2022 very different, pal

[@bigdurianwalks5102]

Agreed. Extreme contrast here.

[@anandasyahendar7293]

@@bigdurianwalks5102 Contrast? You funny.. Every city in this world have that side, pal..

[@jaxs1121]

Indonesia and Philippines have the same problem very low government support for housing and sanitation 😢

[@raditmamen]

There was someone that have solution and he prove it's work but he got dethroned by his enemy for a simple mistake

[@paranoya733]

@@raditmamen not really, just accept the reality that nobody cares.. current governor is also the puppet of president, still he did nothing to this slum.. nobody try to fix

[@floffr]

​@@raditmamensiapa itu bang aku kuran tau

[@RIZKYNanda-eb3dx]

​@@floffrAhok di gulingkan dengan WAN ABUD politik identitas... dan warga jakarta semakin senang karena bertambah slum kumuh🤣🤣

[@JawaKawi]

@@RIZKYNanda-eb3dx tuh Singapore maling 5000 triliun rupiah tiap tahun sekitar 370 bilion USD, anda nyalakan pihak lain, luar biasa 👌

[@hindaviswarajya8853]

Slums in Tier-1 cities are a common phenomenon globally, and in my opinion the only way for the people living in those slums to come out of the misery is to start a life in a Tier-2 or Tier-3 city where cost of living is lower.

[@nardex_tv]

Very good video showing the real life of happy lower class people, thank you for sharing the video

[@gudangpsi2952]

Bro this channel deserves more attention.

[@suhotv6894]

If this is what slums in Indonesia look like, come to the Philippines it's worse. People literally built houses out of tents under the bridge.

[@abdulwahidmdtahir3660]

And in cemetery too.

[@paranoya733]

Both jakarta & manila are the same, bangkok's slum is better

[@thepurplepanda1194]

the service to the people is not perfect yet, but its getting better - comparing 15 0-20 years ago

[@edisianarki1939]

just learn from malaysia. especially KL area. during 70's 80's there a lots of slum area then slowly gov move (force to move) this people to the new flat housing area, if they not move, out of sudden the slum area facing a very big fire the next day, burn all the houses so the people doesn't have any choice but to move the new flat that gov already build. LOL

[@Ameng3471]

It works, atleast eridicate illegal immigrants and no lives is lost

[@rizkyadiyanto7922]

thats very inhumane way to force them. these days jakarta government tries to buy the land from the house owners, but some of them demands higher price than market price which make it difficult to make a deal.

[@raychabaharuddin3399]

@@rizkyadiyanto7922 Slums are populated by people living illegally on land, so nobody owns the land. So, there is no such thing as the government 'tries to buy land' from slum dwellers. What a bullshit artist you are!

[@junnaui5525]

​@@rizkyadiyanto7922your government is stupid

[@livliv2384]

Good, better to live in an affordable flat than living in the slum. Indonesia government failed their people. It's so sad.

[@mulyadiartclass]

There is minus and plus if we compare Indonesia and western area like America ..in Indonesia poor people still lucky becouse they still can rent the small room..but in America..some people who called homeless live in tent or care becouse the house rent so hight even some of them have a job..

[@timmartino7269]

True ....

[@diamdante]

Don't mention, if poor people can try to get a job, they can get a bit of money and try to improve their situation. In other nations, if you don't have a official home address, you can't even apply for a job, so you're stuck there forever

[@carabiner7999]

Great point! Brit in the US.

[@pietrojenkins6901]

@@carabiner7999 not true .

[@carabiner7999]

@@pietrojenkins6901 What's not true?! That I think MULYADI ART CLASS has a great point? *I DO* Or that I'm from the UK? *I AM* Or that I live in the USA? *I DO* Your opinion may differ, but I stand by what I wrote. Cheers.

[@pasonline7266]

Finally the government decided to moves the capital to East Kalimantan, well at least those policy will reduce the roles and burden of Jakarta, Jakarta are way too much roles as the central of government,.politics, economy, finance and technology

[@Operator214MerchantMarine]

honestly if these people are not just speaking a very different language ., i could have easily mistaken them and the place for philippines ., i mean they are so alike that its really hard to distiguish

[@hobby_garage1767]

Indonesia udah mendonia.. 😱😱🎉🎉🎉🇲🇨🇲🇨🇲🇨🇲🇨

[@SyifaNdut-hh2im]

Malingsial

[@nielk799]

BANGKOK and MANILA as well as the major cities of Vietnam has also extreme slums.

[@eyeswideopen7777]

and scabies

[@paranoya733]

Jakarta much worst than bangkok

[@CanIDrinkYourBlood]

​@@paranoya733bangkok much worst than jakarta

[@paranoya733]

@@CanIDrinkYourBlood According to BPS data, jakarta has 39% slum area.. almost 40% that's a lot, u better accept it

[@CanIDrinkYourBlood]

@@paranoya733 Now it's decreased to 19%

[@klewank2615]

Grateful are those who live in Malaysia

[@droidfanor4068]

You're not wrong

[@suhaimiabdan3403]

Slum areas in KL was normal scenario during the 1980’s. Nowadays there are no more slum areas found in KL.

[@thewaywardcyclist3992]

high speed trains are much more important than the living standards of citizens, it seems

[@agsrealistic8079]

They key word is ‘comfort’ repeated many times by the people living in the slum. If they are comfortable (being with their families, next to familiar surroundings etc) then they have no motivation to change the course of their lives

[@osisai4155]

So what is your solution? Take away their comfort as a way to motivate them to do better?

[@pietrojenkins6901]

@@osisai4155 what comfort ? Living in filthy areas?

[@pmboston]

The word comfort is confusing you. Liking what you are used to is a human trait, that’s what is meant by being comfortable. It just means there aren’t any surprises or new bad things happening. A comfortable chair or soft warm bed are physically comfortable but you see the difference? Also, you didn’t change the course of your life, your parents did. Their relations in the world did. It’s impossible to bootstrap your way out of slums when every waking moment is spent surviving day to day, hand to mouth. All you can accumulate is dirt. Slums need investment from those in better condition or they will always be with us.

[@bell-xk5dd]

If you understand their language, it literally means they are used to the environment and they are alright with it. Comfort is subjective, if they’re alright in that condition, they feel comfortable. Of course if they could get out of the slum, it would be better, but they’re poor and where could they go.

[@pmboston]

@@bell-xk5dd really. What is the word in their language? I think I would like to decide that for myself. ‘They’re poor and where would they go?’ Is an assumption of hopelessness and immutability. It’s up there with’ the poor will be with us always.’ One of the most nauseating of Christian principles to my mind.

[@Reypunk666]

Indonesian always said "We are rich" and always looking down to poor people from other countries, but what is this slums?? Lol stop hiding the truth indos, and be humble, PEACE ✌️

[@Kirmada385]

Indonesians tend to share selective, favorable images of Jakarta's modern buildings and infrastructure on social media, which can create the perception that the country is highly developed. However, the reality is more complex, as Indonesia still faces challenges with issues like poverty and cleanliness, just like any developing countries. It's important to avoid making broad generalizations and recognize that no country is perfect.

[@RPrasa233]

​@@Kirmada385 ya, sebenarnya itu bentuk pelarian sementara karena netizen indonesia takut kalau berhadapan sesuatu dengan kenyataan

[@gregzeng]

Very skilled production from "two medical students". In 1973, I worked in the School Of Physiology & Pharmacology, UNSW, Australia. Medical research. The solution is not medical, but "community medicine", which is a subset of national governance. Overpopulation is worldwide problem. Population governance is a well-understood science. Science has yet to become an applied technology. This slowness, to become an applied technology, is the problem. Better social engineering is the solution.

[@eyeswideopen7777]

When their environment get toxic, they'll think twice about having more babies

[@yanu3778]

Science not go far from Technology

[@Lost24Smallville]

@@eyeswideopen7777 No need to think, when your religion does it for you

[@eyeswideopen7777]

@@Lost24Smallville god doesn't fix 🦥 lazy. Please

[@lennymomanyi7104]

I heard Indonesia was one of those nations given assignments by Selene, through Vladimir Putin. Indonesia is improving. Pulling each other or moving as a team. We are waiting for Selene's final verdict

[@UC5kym7PU5p4gqtCGShcXhFA]

jakarta sudah seperti kampung sebelah dua belas seperti kota kota di India Bangladesh dan sekitarnya ini kenapa alasan kenapa ibukota negara pindah

[@junnaui5525]

Jakarta should allocate funds and / or development costs to support the creation of housing for slums first, rather than Keretapi Cepat Indonesia China.

[@jojopratama285]

this is better than slum in america they sleep on the road. but why dont you report slum in america? it must be so interesting right?

[@carabiner7999]

Oh, I'm a Brit in the USA and there are tonnes of videos about unhoused people here! Usually, they'll be using words like "homeless" plus the city in the title, rather than "slums". The money making powers here would rather "protect people" by enforcing building codes (aka line their pockets) than allow "slums" (aka homeless encampment/tent cities).

[@bell-xk5dd]

Why compare Indonesia slums to American slums? Slums are the same everywhere, it’s unsightly and degrading

[@kingscorpion26m]

Indo slum is worst then America

[@timmartino7269]

Thank so much for your a video . In fack that is my city jakarta.. but the Goverment has helped lot for their people..,Bravo

[@watjejanssen7535]

i was born there 65 yrs ago

[@timmartino7269]

@@watjejanssen7535 wow... I love you 👍

[@willtjie3129]

You sure didn't know anything about Jakarta. The Government has do nothing shit for their people except extorting and wasting money.

[@cynthiadavid5282]

Intersting video thanku

[@yoshicooldj]

Such a educative and informative documentary, learned a lot! And the shots are great and the editing was on point

[@Chimpunk729]

Thats why we are moving our capital. Its the best solution. Make Jakarta as a bussiness city (not industrial, not manufacturing) and not government center anymore. Jakarta is also banned any new industrial facilities and start to push companies to move out their factory outside jakarta.

[@RickyzackYT]

This when some people think the jakarta is "city of dream", everyone come to this city with minimum skill & low educated.

[@D0C1234567]

the fact is that 40% (112 million) Indonesian are poor and midle income (world bank report 2017) the rest 60% (168 million) are high income and billionaire, look like its twice germany population (84 million on 2022). Its not poor Country at all, its in the right track to become wealthy country.

[@mohammadghufronalchotib4349]

Apaan, pendapatan gaji dibawah 6 juta sekitar 69% dari penduduk, apanya high income? Ngerti definisi high income gak?

[@beitruah]

No kampung is not a village. Kampung can be in a village or a city. It’s an alley with houses on one side or both sides.

[@WhyteHorse2023]

No that's called a gang.

[@beitruah]

@@WhyteHorse2023 yes it can also be called gang. I suppose kampung could be a bit bigger than gang or can consist of several gang but a lot smaller than a village.

[@AkaunGrabFoodAku]

You are wrong. Kampongs are well arranged well situated, beautiful no foul odore no illegal dumping of trash, while where else slums are not not ! So please do not call slums as kampongs.

[@AkaunGrabFoodAku]

You are wrong. Kampongs are well arranged well situated, beautiful no foul odore no illegal dumping of trash, while where else slums are not not ! So please do not call slums as kampongs.

[@AkaunGrabFoodAku]

You are wrong. Kampongs are well arranged well situated, beautiful no foul odore no illegal dumping of trash, while where else slums are not not ! So please do not call slums as kampongs.

[@marareyes1956]

Awesome to watch this channel

[@betawicanberra8823]

I am the original of Jakarta tribe called as Betawi. I lived in slums area in west Jakarta when I was a child. It wasn’t very nice environment for any human being to live. Then we move to Kampung southern district of the suburb of Jakarta it was better, cleaner not crowded but then over the years my kampung became crowded now hardly any gardens. Now I live in Canberra Australia I am so lucky.

[@yanu3778]

I'm happy 😁 to you too ☺️

[@panjis524]

Are u using whv to come to aussie? willing to work abroad as well😅

[@yanu3778]

@@panjis524 yes,is must be nice to some where else rather Stuck in Jakarta sir, have nice 😊 day

[@ahmadnasir9778]

Dan jangan balik lagi ke NKRI ye kalo Lo udah betah disono. !!

[@yanu3778]

@@ahmadnasir9778 Everyone have choice, any way whoever move to Overseas Didn't burden you Right?

[@holla105]

overproud dengan youtuber yang bawa keindahan indonesia, giliran yang kayak gini ilang wkwk

[@albertchiu655]

no birth controls ?

[@kyrgyzstanuzbekistan8065]

Stop FGM in Indonesia

[@albertchiu655]

over populated ? ?

[@renisetiawati831]

Yes

[@johnruvolis874]

They get free health care but they want to get paid for lost work time? This is a harsh uncertain world, each of us has to take responsibility to make our individual life better. No government is going to walk you by the hand from the cradle to the grave.

[@triratnawati6490]

The 'rich' provincial government of Jakarta should provide comfortable 'communal' apartments to all of the residents of the slum areas (free of charge for renting, electricity&clean water)....The Jakarta provincial government also should give a kind of "endorsements", such as : stipends & job opportunities.. Usually those "poor" people are reluctant to move to another place due to " family reasons", job reasons, money shortages, no government assistance & no better alternatives ...Sorry this is only an opinion of a commoner. Thanks.

[@hijadanggara]

Yang tinggal di pemukiman kumuh itu lebih 50% bukan orang asli Jakarta bu.. saya orang Cianjur Jawa barat punya pengalaman lebih 6 tahun hilir mudik ke Jakarta bekerja di pembangunan proyek di Jakarta, hampir saya pernah tinggal di seluruh area di jakarta.. yang saya tau penghuni pemukiman itu rata-rata pekerja perantau yg datang dari daerah rata² orang Jawa yang ngontrak di Jakarta..

[@jomish8719]

TELL THEM.ALSO TO STOP MAKING MORE BABIES !!

[@SecretOnly-e1j]

@@jomish8719 Ouchhh that is true! Despite of the fact that they build the house ion government land, slums habitant were offered to be relocated yet they didn't take the offer, living in slum is super cheap and near the center of Jakarta where they make money by selling food or work in construction or work in office building. True also that majority of those who live in slums are not Jakarta people but people came from onother cities and become burden to Jakarta budget. Government has been so generous to support them with free health insurance and free education up to high school level and many also enjoy education allowance through Smart Jakarta Card (Kartu Jakarta Pintar) and some enjoy scholarship allowance up to university.

[@KhairulAnwar-mp8lo]

Thanks for the short documentary. Great content.

[@chafidrhomadon735]

Wow Free Healthcare

[@yanu3778]

Poverty ,slum every country have facing all so Whoever can Strive their own for sure, have found better life.... Good luck everyone...

[@fighter8784.]

related to health care ,i think go to work and paid and go back home with some money to fulfill the needed of their family more important rather then go to Puskesmas latter their won't be pay because of absent .

[@pablosilva6988]

The solution to the problema is very simple, if you are below a certain economic standard do not procreate. Cover it up PLEASE. I'm poor and i wont bring a life into being, only to endure the pain and struggle of living. As i have been forced to endure by my mother and father. THINk about it PLEASE

[@Princess-Lavender]

Often people can not afford birth control

[@pablosilva6988]

@@Princess-Lavender a clear sign You shouldn't do the deed. If you can't afford a pack of condoms, how on earth can You provide for a child?

[@pablosilva6988]

@@Princess-Lavender agreed but don't subject a child to a life of torment. PLEASE

[@nodymus6519]

@@Princess-Lavender if these people can buy cigarettes the same prices as condom then the problem is them procreating without thinking the consequences

[@mysterioanonymous3206]

Haha, poor people have the most kids. The higher the income the fewer kids people have. The single highest correlation with birth rates is womens educational attainment. So the single most effective measure is to educate girls, relentlessly, all the way into and through university to higher degrees. And then you're like us, the west, where birth rates are below replacement. So pick your poison.

[@doll3842]

So inspiring and heartwarming 😱😱😱👀❤️🔥

[@Alwi-v8z]

Pasti kau malaysoa😂🇲🇾🤪

[@jhare18]

It’s not just in Jakarta that this is apparent. It’s all over Asia or Asian countries except Asian countries that restrict the truth (mostly communist country) and want to portray that they don’t have any problem.

[@abdulwahidmdtahir3660]

You meant "North Korea"?

[@michealrai6082]

@@abdulwahidmdtahir3660 he means china

[@aimyon1996]

Ini dekat jepang

[@sophyroeun46]

The could probably can learn how to grow garden and sale vegetables for some money to support life . Vegetables can be grown in the house all they need is big pottery with soil seeds and water and some sun.

[@syariphidayatullah9313]

In Kuala Lumpur Malaysia there are also many street beggars they are all just overproud on KZbin 😊😊

[@sxckuchris]

Beggar from Indon

[@adijanuardea1582]

@@sxckuchris Its Malon homeless 😀

[@sxckuchris]

@@adijanuardea1582 dhakarta jawa sdm rendah wkwkwkwkw,dasar suku c4bul kumuh

[@darthazua]

Most of them imports from Myanmar (Rohingya), Cambodia, Indonesia, Philippines (southern), Some of them act like a local. All lady usually wears shawl or hijjab even they are not muslim. Many of them come in under United Nation refugee, some illegal. Locals under rule, they can't simply beggar people's money, they must have something to sell minimum tissue paper. Most who doing this are disable people because hey can't do works like normal people. They also under protected and get paid by zakat center & social welfare department.

[@dantesalazar7805]

If you compare slums in philippines and indonesia,philippine slums is more terrible,indonesian slums a little bit decent

[@jomish8719]

Coming from a FILIPINO??? have you done anything to help or just yapping nonsense??

[@pietrojenkins6901]

These are ghettos ,the ones in the Philippines are slums.

[@lordfrieza458]

A slum is a slum.Anyone who lives there are poor and need help.There's no such thing such as a "better" slum.

[@reydeanlasru5917]

Haha slums in manila has wifi aircon refrigerators and their 🏠 has 2nd floor and they own motorcycles

[@dantesalazar7805]

@@reydeanlasru5917 and videoke

[@willtjie3129]

I have been live in Jakarta for 3 decades, I lived in Tokyo, and Hongkong too. I noticed that Jakarta problems is the weak goverment and people's mindset to go to big city and do nothing. Homeless, slums definitely getting worse there, and those people are screaming for money from government. And of course, the crooked government sold their lands to those people or mafia. What a shame, the government don't have such a control over their people. It is easier to nuke them for sure, otherwise they will rampage and go to the presidential palace for anarchy demonstration.

[@tubester4567]

You want to nuke them? Thats harsh, they are just poor people. Maybe the government should build some low cost housing or apartments.

[@willtjie3129]

@@tubester4567 It is more complex than you think, the criminals coming from those slums. And the Facts is those poor people don't want to relocate to low-cost housing. The more fun facts all of them not local Jakartans. They are coming from rural areas without any job or skills and having a dream to get easy life in Jakarta. Unfortunately, it is not happening. What they do just occupied any empty lands for 1 generation and asking for compensation after relocate. Use your logic because THEY ARE POOR doesn't mean they are not wrong !

[@danisetiawan2676]

agreed 😂😅

[@altezzaandre9651]

Fun fact: most of those living in slum houses are immigrants from outside Jakarta 😌

[@hafizrahim1197]

I don't think so

[@paranoya733]

Fun fact jakarta are worst than bangkok

[@hanrianangga2608]

"Fun fact"

[@MeganLubna]

they have a big house in their place

[@lolanya00]

Calling them "immigrant" when they're literally Indonesian as well...

[@stephenyu6890]

Same in Philippines

[@radityarasqa4547]

Just wonder are they have a healthy card for free for those lived in slum area

[@JackSparrow47038]

😂😂😂ewwww

[@thaimayoree1494]

Thailand is beautiful

[@abdulwahidmdtahir3660]

Yes, beautiful Bangkok. kzbin.info/www/bejne/qXa1hqaVecuYrrs

[@Sumatra2878]

Philippines is god tier beautiful 😎😎😎😎😎😎

[@thaimayoree1494]

@@Sumatra2878 am not from PH.

[@averagesingaporean3]

​@@Sumatra2878manila,bad transport,heavy traffic jams say no

[@rarindraprakarsa4376]

Things that never be shown by ex governor. Instead showing golden triangle all the time. lol

[@arashi441xyz]

Those are slums? Oh God I feel really bad for my country now.

[@ronnieboucherthecrystalcraftsm]

family`s are having too many children and the men are lazy - i was there in 1979 - 80 and it is still the same = it is what they believe in !

[@xeedsenterprise505]

Paskesmas?

[@Alwi-v8z]

আমার মতে ইন্দোনেশিয়া আমার দেশ বাংলাদেশের চেয়ে অনেক বেশি উন্নত 😢

[@SeetheworldwithImran]

Proud to be a Bangladeshi 😂😂😂

[@AkaunGrabFoodAku]

You are wrong. Kampongs are well arranged well situated, beautiful no foul odore no illegal dumping of trash, while where else slums are not not ! So please do not call slums as kampongs.

[@jasperangel]

Fan here in the Philippines 🌴

[@Ogugua-k1w]

lol

[@BlackMasterones]

Why this content is different than other on yours vids mannn? 😂😂

[@sarayen5099]

BPJS doctors also not that good, but probably still better than other doctors outside BPJS that materialistic/money only. St Carolus hospital example, doctors there not knowledge money only.

[@juhasg5690]

Jakarta rasa India🤣🤣🤣

[@mohdbadrulhisyambadrulhisy353]

hahahaha🤣🤣😂 new delhi versi jakarta g20 yg dikatakan terkaya dunia

[@reallive8525]

mailing sial diam

[@juhasg5690]

@@mohdbadrulhisyambadrulhisy353 g20 untuk negara miskin bro

[@sharxM16]

serumpun😂

[@Amoghavarsha.]

Dirty Indonesia 🤮

[@sutediheriyonoBaladMaUng]

Slump because they don't have access to clean water and thras management. Ppl throw every thrash into the irrigation chanel (old days irigation for agriculture).

[@droneviewssrilanka4409]

❤❤❤

[@ashokathegreat4534]

And these people make fun of India. Maybe we need to rule them again for hundreds of years like we did 1500 years ago when South Indians ruled the entire Malay region.

[@Axyl-bx7vo]

not only india/indo are racist in other neigbor

[@averagesingaporean3]

India is much more compact tho,and it's not like you prideful indians also try to cover up

[@ashokathegreat4534]

@@Axyl-bx7vo Indonesians should be the last people to make fun of others. They literally have been ruled their entire history by others. Never had their own civilization or ancient emperors. Now they pretend to be hijab arabs and western christians.

[@SeetheworldwithImran]

Proud to be a Bangladeshi 🇧🇩

[@marygracetapang4975]

Indonesian said Philippines very country😂but the Philippines and indonesia very satiation😂😂😂😂😅😅

[@Risingworldd]

Oho they also have slums then why Mumbai slums is so famous ??? Even it generates 1 billion dollars every year !! And contribute a huge role in Mumbai economy

[@baladewajakarta4401]

Jakarta slum is so much better because they have free healtcare and free education. The only problem is that they dont want to be relocated. So the govt kedp clasify them as "poor" and they will get lot of benefit. Indeed, not all, but most of them are parasite.

[@sanjoe7265]

Indonesian slums are much cleaner than mumbai slums!! Heard adani is planning to redevelopment dharavi slum..hope it will get any progress..

[@Amoghavarsha.]

​@@sanjoe7265we can see how clean it is 🤮 it looks like Lagos Nigeria 😂

[@darthazua]

Jakartan are so unfortunate because the government not pro-people. No proper public housing mean, no clean water supply, electricity, sewage also waste management. The government keep allocate the budget to less priority or unnecessary project than straight to the people. It's not about cash money but a better life even it just a low cost apartment.

[@แก้วตา-ผ6ฬ]

อยากให้คนอินโดนีเซียมาดูสภาพประเทศตัวเอง ก่อนจะไปทับถมประเทศอื่น😂

[@ohmycontent6012]

😂

[@χσχσ-ν3χ]

😂😂😂

[@tunsri9257]

Agree

[@tunsri9257]

😂😂

[@Amoghavarsha.]

Hahha dirty Indonesia.😹

[@laxmiravula]

Dirty Indonesia...😮

[@Axyl-bx7vo]

yeah

[@markinnes4264]

Robot voice?

[@FransToyShop]

Correct

[@alvianeleven11]

Just let jakarta sink slowly , who's care ?!

[@hazmanriess8949]

There are Slum living every where in indonesian. Not just Jakarta. But we can see in Bandung, Medan and even in Bali. Jawa inhabited by 150 million people. Even more than population of Russia just 144 million with 19 million sq km. Apa jua indonesia rasa bangga masuki klub G20.

[@dhiananovitasari8652]

Adakah video ini menyinggung anda? Saat butuh kekuatan memperkokoh guna menandingi dominasi kaum china Tamil, mengatasnamakn bangsa Melayu semua suku2 di Indonesia kalian anggap melayu, budaya dikatakan serumpun,, agama , bahasa serumpun antara Indonesia Malaysia, tp giliran kalian per kapita lbh tinggi n merasa paling kaya sungguh sombong merendahkan kami. Yg kaya di negaramu.n Singapore itu kebanyakan orang China, smntara orang tempatan tersingkir di kampung2 dan pinggiran. ayo aq ajak Kau lihat suasana kampung2 di Indonesia gk jauh beda dg kampung2 di negaramu. Jgn terlalu sombong China dahulu sebelum tahun 2000 adalah negara termiskin per kapita dibawah Indonesia skrg bisa meningkat, Korsel 1970an jg negara miskin. Roda kehidupan berputar bro, Singapore yg dulu dikick out Malaysia krn dianggap tdk menguntungkan skrg lihat jauuuuh meninggalkan Malaysia karena dominasi n kecerdasan orang2 China di Singapore

[@EJAXD6954]

2045 gw harap indonesia dan jakarta akan jadi negara dan kota maju sekarang perkembangan negara kita lagi naik pesat terima kasih atas mengkritiknya mogahan pemerintah indonesia akan lebih baik lagi

[@growthmindset-kd3tg]

@@dhiananovitasari8652 sudah abaikan aja org macam begitu. kita jg sudah tau klo org2 melayu dibanding ras china dan india memiliki pendapatan terendah. mending kita belajar dari bangsa china yg mostly sukses dimanapun berada.

[@Dezznut09]

​@@growthmindset-kd3tglah ,yang komen juga orang elu . Sekurangnya bumiputera Malaysia mempunyai syarikat GLC besar dan semuanya melayu bukan cina pemiliknya 🤣 .Apa khabar isu rempang ya

[@jojobuenaflor3568]

The slums in the Philippines look much worse than this but comes election time people still vote for politicians who keep them poor

[@kingscorpion26m]

Both looks worst

[@vangodwinmyyoutubealias7592]

People living in slum communities must be offered free birth control as they may Not be able to afford it on their own or they may NOT be aware or adequately educated to see that it is the solution to gradually ( humanely ) phasing slum life out of a normal thriving, economically viable community. To also invest in their education and their transition into professional life that will allow them to transition out of the slum community gradually and humanely. This solution is worth the investment by the corporate rich.

[@Br4m76]

At least we are far more better than those in small African countries where the poverties are second to none . We also better than the India people.

[@adijanuardea1582]

200 slum areas in Jakarta We call it kampung atau RW kumuh. @ 5000 peoples in 20,000 square metres. Total 1M peoples in 200 kampungs. In 4 Millions square metres. 700k people are from outside of jakarta. They have big house in their hometown. They rent house or built illegal house in Jakarta. 300k peoples are jakartans since 1950 or before, so they have land certified. Government of Jakarta already build more than 100 flat or semi apartment building since 2014 - 2023 or more than 30k new house or equal for 120k peoples. They build it in government land. But Its not enough So, government must buy land. The price of slum land is 10 millions rupiah / square metres. It cost 4 Millions square metres * 10 millions rupiah = 40 Trilyun rupiah Or 2 billions $. Its small cost. Cause jakarta have cash money 80 Trilyun rupiah /year. We can do this for next 10 years If we want to. But former gubernur 2017 - 2022 doesn't want that consept. Maybe our next gubernur 👍

[@RitaFlannery-nl6cv]

They could clear the litter themselves

[@jonwick7635]

they dont wanna move anyway, expect violence first

[@seminky5341]

The great nation of Asia....

[@pmboston]

It’s a continent.

[@agent4you2]

i guess every place has its poverty- even USA.

[@bell-xk5dd]

But there are a few countries that manage to eradicate extreme poverty and homelessness. Took China some 30 years to lift more than 800 millions people out of poverty. If there’s a will, there’s a way, and the Chinese government was determined to eradicate poverty and they succeeded. Now 80% of the Chinese live a middle class lifestyle with very high standards of living. 80% middle class is an ideal percentage for all countries. China has 1.4 billion people, that’s huge. If China can do it, so can Indonesia. It takes a dedicated and determined government to do it. China still has rooms for improvement and they are thriving to clean up the rural areas. Though there are still many old houses in rural areas in China but they are not slums, many old houses are uninhabited and abandoned. What Indonesia needs is a good, strong government, free from corruption and greed.

[@uh-huh-uh2074]

​@@bell-xk5ddwell its easier to do in communist countries, they dont agree with the government, oh boy you will never know if you live or not tomorrow, communist countries is easier to govern their people cause they always use "shorcuts", and government doesnt even care if its morally good or not to use that kind of "shortcuts"

[@zuraidaaeschbacher4136]

PLEASE TELL THE TRUTH TO THE WORLD THE POOR DO NOT GET FREE MEDICAL. CARE FROM THE. GOVERNMENT

[@radityarasqa4547]

Kaka saya pakai KIS untuk operasi kistanya yg sudah seberat 7 kilo dan itu gratis Alhamdulillah sekarang sudah sehat,,saya tinggal si Kab Bekasi, cara berobat gratis ya ke puskesmas dulu setelah di rujuk baru ke rumah sakit kelas C ga ribet,,

[@sophyroeun46]

I hope someone go to help donate some vegetables seeds and help educate them so that they may help themselves. 😊

[@thewaywardcyclist3992]

hopefully it's just vegetable seeds...

[@gianttigerthots]

soooooooooo have the adults realized that many kids is a bad thing atm? have they reduced having kids to maybe 1/household? as a responsible adult would?

[@carabiner7999]

Don't be such a git. Poor people are not irresponsible children, FFS. There are many reasons why they may have large families and your being a snide arse makes me wonder what sort of parents *you* have. Oh, China tried that one child thing. Turns out that it's not a great solution to poverty, lack of education/opportunities, poor infrastructure, socio-cultural issues and a host of other issues at play here.

[@pitterjord28]

That is a village not city🤦🏻‍♂️. INDONESIAN city is modern and clean

[@bell-xk5dd]

What’s the use one city is clean while the whole of Indonesia is one big slum?

[@zionarivelon]

Excuse me but I live in village. Its cleaner, less polution, less people too -not crowded like these Kampung on jakarta. Most people here are farmers, some of them keep some animals like chicken, sheep and cows. My house is a mid size in Village, but I have banana, mango trees and flowers+plants in my backyard.

[@Adrianirsyad1]

Ahahaahhah sejak kapan bodoh

[@yabaniadama]

Otw pindah negara 😎🔥

[@LisaLisa-mo2tg]

How about poor country malaysia..

[@sharxM16]

Di malaysia tiada kayak begini cok😂

[@zaxisontherun]

Laugh at this user

[@sxckuchris]

When peenoise n hindunesial stupid

[@ardentblue7493]

if you cannot accept the harsh reality of your own country, your country will be in this bad situation forever...

[@thewaywardcyclist3992]

what a miracle many migrants want to come to poor country malaysia, what is the attraction

[@emeraldkimble7602]

The poor area oof Manila Philippine s is called tondo

[@marijolivitzky4336]

Excuse me, this video is only about the slums in Indonesia nothing to do with the Philippines. OK?

[@silent389]

😆😆😆you did not accept the fact that you have slum too🤣🤣everywhere has slum dont be shy on it

[@cookiemurph8532]

Your wrong, Tondo is the chairman of Manila.

[@reydeanlasru5917]

Eepal nanman mga noypi kahit di tungkol sa kanila🤣

[@sherrijennings9309]

OMG the pronunciation of the narrator is hurting my ears!!!!!

[@sharxM16]

Wkwkwkwkwk indon sungai jakarta nya jernih bangat😂

[@dbsk06]

Hey at least Indonesians even in these slums have universal healthcare unlike the US 😊

[@radityarasqa4547]

​@lionelbmessibut its true dude

[@kyrgyzstanuzbekistan8065]

FGM should be banned in Indonesia

[@user-np3cp2cb7u]

but no one does FGM in Indonesia.

[@zekeriyamustafa9952]

@@user-np3cp2cb7u I'm sorry but there is scientific data that FGM still happens in indonesia..

[@JeremiahHexx]

Would have been so much better if you didn't use that AI voice, and you recorded the narration yourself. Those fake, compuTer AI voices are horrible. But otherwise enjoyed it.

[@Jonathan-wygygb]

India and indonesia almost look- alike

[@maryellenblount6376]

A story of the haves and the have nots. Seriously messed up.

[@LizaGalvez-rx4to]

Those motorcycles are nuisance

[@soupbums]

Garbage pollution I thought this was India oops 😂

[@coratheexplorer1824]

In short no work no pay or they live subsistence living cut it short

[@cartoons981]

that non breathing health professional with mask on won't be healthy without breathing for long

[@carabiner7999]

You are aware that people in healthcare and beyond have been breathing through face masks for generations, right?

[@cartoons981]

@@carabiner7999 you must also be aware why dead body's face is covered after it stops breathing ?

[@carabiner7999]

@@cartoons981 Well, depending on the culture, there are various reasons. Also, FYI, a body that has stopped breathing *is* dead, usually. The gentleman in the video is alive. Some cover faces of the dead out of respect, others to stop the soul from escaping, faces are covered immediately to stop flies from laying eggs or carrion birds and snakes from sneaking a meal, often murderers will cover the face of a victim they know, others to establish a relationship between the covering/mask with the spirit world, also it can protect the face from a coffin lid.... I'd go on, but I am sure I have misunderstood your point from the beginning; Mea Culpa! Please enlighten me. Namaste.

[@cartoons981]

@@carabiner7999 why do you wear mask ?

[@carabiner7999]

@@cartoons981 Well, during the height of the Pandemic, it was the law where I live. The stats showed that wearing one could help stop the spread of COVID by as much as 25%. People who didn't have the vaccines/had underlying health issues were/are likely to die if they catch it. As I don't want that for anyone, I wore/wear the mask if I can stop from passing on something I may not know I have. When I work with particulates I wear one, because I don't want to inhale them, just as I wear a respirator when I work with toxins. I also wear a safety belt when driving, and don't drink and drive. Sometimes I wear masks as a disguise/costume, but not medical ones. Or maybe, I wear them because I'm dead and contacting you from behind the veil? The line is so fine between living and dead, that may be it. And your point, please?