Intel Analyst on the Wars in Ukraine and Gaza | feat. Ryan McBeth

[@ckpoon5871]

I would rather watch Ryan smoke and spit truth than listen to other people blow smoke and put out misinformation. It's not good for Ryan's health but he enjoys it and my mental health is deeply grateful.

[@Zyzyx442]

You don't inhale cigar smoke like a cigarette.

[@AirForceJuan747]

He’s like Bender in human form

[@CountryAndProud]

​@@AirForceJuan747😂😂😂that's golden

[@chickenfishhybrid44]

@@ckpoon5871 "spit truth", so cringe

[@solaireastora5394]

​@@chickenfishhybrid44so is calling something cringe

[@JamesGrim08]

It was nice seeing Ryan dispute the silly stuff Bryan has picked up. It great seeing Ryan's presence grow and grow.

[@richardarriaga6271]

Ryan can't cover up the war crimes of the IDF. The young can see people warcrimed by colonial oppressors from Rafah to Bucha.

[@chickenfishhybrid44]

Ryan also has his line to tow.

[@NeygarzruinedAmerica]

​@JR-gp2zkIt's a conspiracy until it's true huh? Where are those WMDs that were supposedly in Iraq?

[@Mrsumone12]

All Ryan is doing is parroting the state department talking points. If you're seriously believing that what the state department is releasing to the American people is the truth and not just how they want us to see it, you're a fool

[@quattordicimontenapoleone3113]

I thought you were kidding but shit Bryan seems to have some pretty stupid ideas.

[@dabrack9350]

Ryan is a new member of my hero class - I too think that refusing to go to the gym is a form of resistance training.

[@DudemeisterNL]

Lmao nice

[@g-dawg79]

🤣

[@shueyk2320]

He's a zogbot

[@davidradtke160]

He does triathlons despite how he looks.

[@texasforever7887]

Lol he also runs marathons

[@BladeFitAcademy]

That's some serious military humor from Ryan. " Eh, drop a bomb on it. What are they going to do, hate us more?" 😂 I don't know why that's so funny but it's dark as hell.

[@RustyShackleford76]

I don’t think it’s that bad, but then again I’m pretty fucked up 😂

[@axl-j9o]

Tbh I have a strong feeling it's the exact opposite for Israel. There is only one success metric in that war, it's obvious it's been the main pursuit of Hamas since they started it - erosion of patience for Israel hitting civilians, locally and globally. I imagine eh could be their most natural baseline, but I imagine in this one Israel will know to be quite careful with PR management.

[@MelGibsonMovie]

Ryan McBeth is really awesome. I was born in Moldova and he knows what he's talking about and does it so in a very casual way. Great informative video!

[@arturallay8116]

This guys a joke, got the Ukraine war all wrong, you think he’s gonna be right about Israel ? 😂

[@mikejess04]

Lol

[@emi_goes]

What's he been wrong on ?

[@arturallay8116]

@@emi_goes like the whole Ukraine war? Or are you one of those that still thinks they’re winning?? 😂😂

[@arturallay8116]

He’s great for cope maybe

[@jonathanbeck8233]

I love Ryan's take on things no spin right wing or left wing rhetoric. Just facts with a little bit of humor. More people need to follow

[@jonathanbeck8233]

@rlgh2867 what facts were cherry picked?

[@Markuden]

He sometimes go political and he leans left. He has an army background and under trump there were no new wars and under biden we are on the brink of ww3. So i can see why he often is pro biden.

[@jakeroper1096]

@@rlgh2867how do you know you don’t cherry pick?

[@jocksharerock7318]

@@rlgh2867the idea that his account is a year old is more telling.

[@jocksharerock7318]

@@rlgh2867 get three more years to your name and I’ll tell you🤔

[@dylanjones4267]

1:03 "You've also got a large humidifier..." outstanding

[@brocephus1107]

It's from Ryan's bio on his website

[@Yourmom48602]

Lol

[@BenjaminGatti]

I think it's called a humidor.

[@thatindiandude4602]

I see the Ivans are out in full force today.

[@gorkyd7912]

At least that's what the ideologues call anyone who disagrees about any aspect of a complex foreign policy topic.

[@WarPigstheHun]

​@@gorkyd7912then let me explain via common sense and common knowledge why arming Ukraine is in EVERYONE'S best interest: France, Poland, and Estonia are threatening to ESCALATE the war by sending BOOTS ON THE GROUND, but ONLY if Ukraine is LOSING. When multiple nuclear capable European nations are at war with each other, EVERYONE suffers. In contrast, sending arms to Ukraine and giving them the upper advantage CONTAINS the war to just Ukraine and small attacks in Russia. Do you understand?

[@gorkyd7912]

@@WarPigstheHun Your appeal to common sense is noted but what we're doing is weak; we're letting Ukraine get massacred and we're offering just enough resistance to make it costly to Russia without being too costly that they stop the aggression. So Ukraine is getting decimated, all their men are sacrificed. Russia forges new alliances with enemies of the West as it grows increasingly desperate, China is getting emboldened by our weakness, Iran is emboldened, new fronts of the war are opening everywhere and soon you should expect a global war of survival which probably will escalate into nuclear confrontation. They look at the US and the EU and see countries that are deeply in debt, can barely afford interest payments plus obligation. The see unrest and upheaval everywhere, division over basic crap like gender let alone race and religion. Meanwhile Russia, China, Iran, the "global south" are all highly motivated, indoctrinated, deeply patriotic populations with an axe to grind against the west. YOU think we're grinding down Russia in Ukraine. THEY know that we can barely afford our own governments yet alone another 20-year quagmire. THEY know we can't recruit anyone to the military because our populations are demoralized and with rampant immigration from around the world soon we'll have more enemies within than soldiers. So the absolute worst idea is to drag on this conflict instead of dealing decisive blows WITH an easy-out for Russia that doesn't leave egg on their face.

[@michaelwolfe1853]

@@WarPigstheHun careful alot of these Ivans cant read that much, just put USA GOOD, POOTIN BAD

[@buktomsin]

🤣🤣🤣

[@Rookie11]

Ryan McBeth is great!

[@minecraftboy4208]

@@rlgh2867okay vatnik

[@bthemedia]

Yet another war monger

[@richardarriaga6271]

Genocide apologist. If the ICJ wasn't afraid of the US, he would be treated the same way as the Russians.

[@russelltindale9428]

@@rlgh2867 No i think you are a bot. 2 year old channel that i have seen in many comment threads on this video.

[@yurgey777]

@@russelltindale9428the kremlin has lots of capabilities

[@molfar9049]

Ryan is the uncle i always wanted:)

[@Jcruises_]

One of the best shows

[@hagestad]

Somewhat informative but pretty delusional @ the same time : 12:50 take Poland - you really think that is the plan? And what biggest NATO Ramstein Air Base will just be sitting there looking pretty rather than wrecking Russians @ the polish border? This is delusional talk. Let me remind you that nuclear bombers from Ramstein and from as far as UK are flying over Poland for over a year officially at least.

[@michaelinsc9724]

Ryan is absolutely fantastic! He does such a great job sifting thru all the noise and getting to the facts.

[@Smurph789]

Ryan is great.

[@baxter6574]

Thank you for a great discussion. Appreciation for both of you!

[@AXISMEDIATV]

Dam brian getting great guests

[@0bservationis1]

I've been a McBeth fan for a year now. Now I have only seen one episode, but I am a fan of your page now.

[@AntonAdelson]

Israeli here. It seems to me that a lot of military analysts are missing out on Israeli domestic politics when discussing IDF's goals and reasons. Yes, military considerations are VERY important and MOST people, who don't understand military at all, miss out on military considerations. Which is exactly why we NEED people like Ryan explaining to everyone. But it's also a mistake to do the opposite, to completely ignore the political reasons. To miss what kind of person Benjamin Netaniyahu is. How his family behaves. Who are the other ministers on his government. What were their biggest struggles BEFORE the war. And what their POLITICAL goals in the near future. Do you know what I mean? Because ultimately, the job of the military is to just blindly follow the goals the "commander in chief" had set them. Is it not?

[@danielheckel2755]

What do y ou think of analysts such as Shaiel Ben Ephraim?

[@conman413]

Ideally the military is supposed to deny illegal orders but that's a problem pointing to Israel's laws and its militaries laws and the training of its troops. Conscripts are poorly trained soldiers at best. They can be relied upon to make mistakes in the absence of a training and leadership.

[@liammarra4003]

Illegal according whom?

[@pepparmostheelder]

That's a very good point. As a naive europeen what is sort of the "abridged version" of who Benjamin Netaniyahu is? Now obviously there is plenty of information on the net and I am working on learning more but it always interresting to hear perspectives from Israel as in media its very much Palestine dominated.

[@richardarriaga6271]

​@@conman413When they started quoting Scripture about genociding people, there's more than lack of training. Lack of training explains it getting to Tik Tok, not the evil behind the chant. Look up the clip presented in the South African case with the ICJ.

[@JRay2113]

Ryan and Peter Zeihan are the GenX pragmatists we’ve been needing in our discourse.

[@NeygarzruinedAmerica]

Both Kamala supporters I'm sure. That's a traitor in my book

[@Alex.Kalashnik]

@@NeygarzruinedAmericaWhere did you get that from? Lol

[@aeseki]

Peter zeihan is a debunked joke that panders to the intelligence community. His whole geography is the basis of work politics and such is old as the 1800s and is just as flawed/doesn't work. His predictions don't hold water. China is still producing iPhones there's been no mass fertilizer shortage famines the United States is still acting as the world police (literal boats right next to Israel) hell one of his books names is the absent super powers the US has been anything but absent since ha started spouting none sense.

[@Mrsumone12]

Lmao Ryan is not a pragmatist. He's a cope dealer

[@aeseki]

Nice glad to see my comment was deleted just because I pointed out zeihan is a source of misinformation good deal.

[@Steve2016100]

"Moms for Action, so of course i had to check it out".. I love you Ryan

[@Excalibur_86]

Anti gun or for sensible gun laws?

[@abysswalks]

Thank both you gentlemen for having this conversation. We need more convos like this.

[@BeGunNer]

Oh man I love this. ❤ Finally someone spitting facts

[@AlfonseGambino]

I could listen to Mcbeth all day long.

[@Nylonscheme]

Lots of Russian IT professionals in this thread; that are trying to make Ryan, a 20yr 🇺🇸 veteran turned senior cyber/warfare analyst with two tours to Europe …look like a telegram influencer. Ryan has experience so he can rock the cigar

[@geneeverett33]

Anyone who points out truth is a Russian bot? Come on man

[@Skabanis]

Putting a mic I front of someone doesn’t make them anything they could be propaganda or truth…Raytheon recorded operating profit of $996 million, up 74 percent versus the prior year. The increase in operating profit was driven primarily by higher volume and improved net productivity, partially offset by unfavorable mix.Apr 23, 2024

[@mcs131313]

@@Skabanis that might mean a lot in your country. And - not trying to be insulting here, in the US, that’s tiny. We spend roughly $20bn a year on farmer subsidies. We pay billions in EV tax credits to the auto industry. If you want to find influence - gvt sponsored healthcare costs $1.5T a year. So while the defense industry will fight for influence just like anyone else - they do not hold the particularly strong influence that people assert. They’d love to - but simple math would tell you they’re not rich or important enough to be dictating policy.

[@mcs131313]

@@Skabanis and to parrot your logic of “just because you put a mic”… Just because an industries making money doesn’t mean it’s why it’s happening. This war is certainly an enormous windfall for anyone involved in Russian military production - public or private. But I don’t think “military industrial complex influence” is the reason Putin chose to start it.

[@marcpedneault3362]

Ryan is a paid salesman for the military. You are just gullible like the rest.

[@BirdDogey1]

I'm old. Got trained back when the Army had M60A3s.

[@SaltyMeatHook]

The Sgt. York worked. But it had two problems. It was placed on the old tank chasis and was slower than the Abrams. Then, the USSR came out with a longer range missile for their attack helicopters that rendered the York obsolete before it hit the field. When Geraldo did his expose on it, he failed to report the truth. The misses where programmed into the fire control to save money on drones and other targets. The tracking radar had enough resolution to tell the system how far it missed it's target, thus being a hit if missed by programmed parameters. Geraldo did America no favors that day, shameful. I have first hand knowledge about the system.

[@ruger6049]

Geraldo reported "live, from the front in Iraq..." and was quickly called out on it. He was nowhere near Iraq and the scene was done in an American desert. Zero credibiltiy.

[@df8340]

“Worked” it also emptied its ammo in just a few seconds. The treads on the m48 chaises were too thin and the engine underpowered.

[@SaltyMeatHook]

@@df8340 It didn't use ammo up like a CWIS. Two shots for most kills.

[@df8340]

@@SaltyMeatHook Lol it sure did, hell I have family that worked on the project as a pm. The gun could fire for a few seconds before it would empty itself, it would fire in bursts. Could only carry about 500ish rounds and it just ate them up

[@SaltyMeatHook]

@@df8340 I was also there in White Sands. The York was never designed to lay down the whole 9 yards though. It could, but it didn't need too. The York led to a lot of software fire control development too. A step in the past that led us to our tech superiority today.

[@friars8854]

Wow Brian. You Got McBeth. Outstanding. He is a solid guy.

[@HRM.H]

Ryan is a certified legend

[@marcpedneault3362]

He sells war. Thats his job.

[@tarstarkusz]

No, he's a dummy spouting the narrative (TM). Russia has no interest in the Balkans or in Poland. The Balkans are already in the North treaty alliance.

[@marcpedneault3362]

@@tarstarkusz hes a paid prooagandist.

[@Alex.Kalashnik]

@@tarstarkuszwell, russians openly say they are interested in the entire world and that their borders don’t end anywhere. So, they will only stop where they are stopped.

[@jakeroper1096]

@@tarstarkuszis that what you were instructed to call everything you don’t like? “Narrative (TM)” cute

[@jeffreymennenga6647]

Thank you for your service. Plus your continued service to our country. Plus the freedom to the world.

[@llttrr]

Please add chapters, I wanna get to the juicy bits FAST.

[@youtubecontent6394]

Thank god Bryan has his own podcast. Everyone around him brought him down.

[@PastorTerranceRhodes]

Ryan Macbeth fan checking this out. Great collaboration

[@brek5]

I don't agree that the phones aren't listening. I've had this happen a few times: I have been hanging out, and then a few French speakers show up, and we hang out and spek French for a few hours, have some beers. I don't use the phone or type anything, and even if I were to google something, I google stuff in English, not in my third language, haha, so there is no input on my part in French except the phone is on and sitting on the table. Later that night or the next day, I start getting ads in French on the phone/computer. No one has access to my accounts, and the wife and kids don't speak French anyway. So, with the only French input being my friends and I talking, how else would the powers that be decide to start serving me ads in French?

[@TomG-f4r]

Sue them , fraud theft invasion of privacy. , don't accept ' shoddy'

[@mailmeabhilash]

Yes the phones are listening.

[@macpalin4099]

You were in the same place as people speaking french. It showed you were in the same location as them. They might have googled something or google just assumed that because you were in the same place that you might enjoy similar things. Its really that easy.

[@ChucksSEADnDEAD]

​@@macpalin4099 So google ain't worth a shid because other people can influence your PERSONAL account? Advertising really getting scammed buying contaminated data.

[@danielheckel2755]

French using phones were in your location, maybe used your wifi, and shared messages with you to arrange the meeting. Plus, maybe not in French but you Google stuff that are in the sphere of influence of French speakers. Think Googling bidet more often than Mcdonald's.

[@inzhener2007]

The No Fly zone should be done not at the start of the invasion, but prior to it. That would be enough to prevent the invasion.

[@MS-wz9jm]

It wouldnt have prevented anything. Just like Soviet nukes in Cuba was critical for the US, NATO in Ukraine is critical for Russia.

[@Vlad.Impaleur]

To establish a no fly zone you first have to establish a fly zone for yourself. Wich you can’t

[@richardarriaga6271]

​@@MS-wz9jmNo it isn't. NATO expanded a short drive from St. Petersberg, but Russia didn't invade. Being part of NATO is the only guarantee Russia won't seize your territory. Just look at Transnistria. NATO expanded not an inch after the USSR collapsed, but Russia took land from Moldova.

[@SPENCEx1x3]

Potentially, but that would also mean that enforcement of it has NATO personnel killing Russians, which is a line that no one wanted to cross at the time.

[@dallysinghson5569]

Hardly. Russia wants Ukraine, not need, wants. More precisely it wants what Ukraine has...

[@jordanwhite8567]

No one on KZbin better represents my feelings on Ukraine/Israel than Ryan. I’m so glad I found him. I wish more people knew about him he’s so good at articulating and breaking down the things I feel so strongly about with regard to these conflicts

[@Mrsumone12]

Crazy how yall have no problem coming out and saying you support the people of 4 different countries being killed on an industrial scale

[@SK_2521]

Regarding traffic cams - in some places like Germany pictures taken always have passenger seat blacked out - in order to prevent disclosing people doing affairs. So that the pictures are to the point - speed tickets

[@poppyrider5541]

This is the first I ever hard of this. Here in the UK they are taken from behind so this wasn't a problem I suppose. I found this well funny.

[@mctaguer]

I want to reinforce what Ryan said about "reading everything." The more you learn--from factual sources--about a broad array of things, the better of a sense you get for "does this make sense?" Because what you're reading/seeing might have plausible details militarily or politically... but not quite add up socially, or in some other basic aspect. So, it's important to learn about things outside your lane.

[@axl-j9o]

Yup. But things like Israel-Gaza will have too many rigorous seeming sources that are actually way too skewed. Going through archives yourself is infeasible. So you sort of have to at least burn through the 2 skewed high-detail sources and ideally find a minimally biased, detailed perspective from there.

[@KuroNekoExMachina]

Boosted because Bryan is awesomen and Ryan is amazing :D

[@capnstewy55]

I'm here for Ryan, but I remember liking Bryan's stand-up.

[@jopo7996]

What I love most about Bryan is his consistent upload schedule.

[@MichaelHatfield-j2z]

BRYAN CALLEN i have missed you so much thank god i found your podcast ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@andreasl3821]

Bryan, you bring the best content on youtube! keep it up. Excellent interviewer

[@jmpetersrn]

He's a great guest. Well worth the time to watch.

[@pete7110]

Ryan is a legend, really top analyst. Happy you had him on board

[@averagemcgee8604]

The guy is advocating killing foreigners at around 1 hour in for "spreading misinformation", and than thinks we need a no fly zone over Ukraine, putting US forces in direct conflict with Russia (something American politicians have specifically NOT done during the entire cold war), he's a fucking nut job! I knew dudes like this when I was doing my degree in IT. They're good with tech, but are morons when it comes to anything else, and this guy shows it.

[@rikjorna5470]

Bryan is back❤ God bless you brian ❤

[@LukeHuchMusic]

Let’s go! Great Pod!

[@jasonlivingston8827]

Ryan is a blessing..

[@_Ferrigno]

Uncle Callen and Uncle McBeth in one show :D

[@arturallay8116]

Dumb and dumber

[@BeerBarbecueDad]

Was not expecting this! I hope you can do more podcasts with Intel Analysts :))

[@larsr.hansen6589]

Great interview.

[@GarrettBoling-o3j]

We the people appreciate you Bryan for using your platform to make us laugh and to keep us informed ❤

[@BruceRowling]

Love your show , you are thinning out on top your head , I think you make a perfect Mr Potato Head

[@zulubeatz1]

Great to hear intelligent people talking sense.

[@michaeltichonuk2176]

Ryan is definitely an mind opener...outstanding podcast!

[@david01879]

I worked in the defence industry for 25 years and I never met anyone that was happy when a war broke out. I'm sure they existed, but even the CEO of Lockheed is a human being who would not rejoice at the death of other humans no matter the profit.

[@mitchellbailey7030]

GREAT EPISODE 👍🏻🇺🇸

[@benwarnock]

Came to KZbin to watch the same Bryan Callen Chris Delia videos I’ve seen multiple times, ended up learning some shit

[@keithcoombs2185]

“Bidens two state solution is Michigan and Minnesota” -Douglas Murray

[@KY-te4mn]

Indeed. The next “God Promise Land” yaaaaay 😁😁😆.A Land with out white people for all the people with out land from all African and Latin America👍👍👍🤟. Michigan and Minneapolis need brown people colonialists to settle and take this new land 🎆🎇🎆🎇

[@skeewiffenator]

I actually liked that one.

[@fedorbutochnikow5312]

This is a fascinating discussion, I want to watch more of his talking, he's very intelligent.

[@averagemcgee8604]

The dudes advocating at around 1 hour in killing foreigners that "spread misinformation" this guy is a nut job!

[@paperandmedals8316]

100% our phones are listening to us. My wife and I were talking about mortgage refinancing and within 10 minutes a KZbin ad popped up in TV with mortgage refinancing and we’ve never seen that add again

[@oviss5946]

This guy is completely 100% ignorant and that’s why he has 3 jobs….he didn’t see is wrong? Com on , they brainwashed him good.

[@TomG-f4r]

Invasion of privacy..get mad ,stay mad , sue them into the stone age...don't accept ' shoddy'

[@synewparadigm]

Yes, Ryan is wrong with that.

[@paperandmedals8316]

@@TomG-f4r you don’t realize you are giving permission for these companies to listen to your speech and read your text. Very few people read through an app’s agreement. Some app heard me and sold that data to google who ran a mortgage refinancing ad and billed the mortgage company. That’s the social media business model.

[@bigbobabc123]

i agree. everyone has had experiences like this. just impossible it's not listening.

[@joex120]

I feel Bryan's exhaustion at trying to discern truth in the current media landscape. I so desperately want to find smart people to listen to without feeling like I am (or they are) being taken for a ride. Ryan seems like a good person to listen to.

[@RealismAndHonor]

Great pod fellas

[@The88Cheat]

This was and an amazing video. Ryan McBeth is one of my favorite KZbinrs.

[@ziggyc3004]

Ry! Ry! He's our guy!

[@TheDreadPirateRoberts-jr2fk]

Lol so gey

[@Teney1994]

"y" is a "u" in Cyrillic, means you just wrote the acronym for Russia. :)

[@courtneyricks500]

Great podcast. Very much appreciated.

[@charles_cody]

Love Ryan's point about MIC & the biggest defense contractor's (LM) profit being orders of magnitude below modern technology companies.

[@luminyam6145]

I do love Ryan McBeth, an amazing man.

[@9879SigmundS]

The massive bureaucracy is easily navigable by the huge defense contractors. In fact, the love it because it creates a barrier to entry.

[@seanmcgrath5686]

I think having the necessary infrastructure, skilled labor force and access to capital are the barriers to entry in trying to be the next defense contractor.

[@9879SigmundS]

@@seanmcgrath5686 you've never had to advise clients with regard to the CFRs.

[@finnancahill2644]

What are you basing these claims on?

[@9879SigmundS]

@@finnancahill2644 Regulatory burdens fall disproportionately on smaller contractors. For instance, if a contractor must hire a law firm to help comply with a regulation the cost is essentially the same whether the contractor is big or small. (In the real world, the large contractor has an internal legal department, so the cost is arguably zero, but lets assume they both retained an outside firm.) Thus, the cost necessarily burdens the smaller firm more as a percentage of their sales. The very large contractors want smaller firms to have larger relative costs as this creates barriers to entry.

[@mcs131313]

I don’t see why people think they have so much influence. They’re large - but they’re tiny compared to healthcare spending, agriculture and related subsidies, any number of special interests. Also yes - it’s an industry with large concentrated players by nature (is are healthcare, utilities - most industries with some combo of high capex and high regulation / consistency requirements. ) There is also an ecosystem of startups and smaller players - they just wind up being subcontractors or being purchased by the internal VC arms of the big guys (so small guys are still competing and making some money).

[@alternavent]

1:16:50 I like what Bryan is saying here about why he appreciates how McBeth communicates his information.

[@pravdasircone1691]

Awesome podcast! Next We need ryan on joe rogan!

[@NeapolitanApe]

Joe Rogan only has clowns on nowadays.

[@terjeoseberg990]

@@NeapolitanApe, Unfortunately.

[@NeapolitanApe]

@@terjeoseberg990 he can have Ryan and his former CIA friend on at the same time maybe

[@thecoin5394]

​@@NeapolitanApeyou and Ryan are clowns

[@NeapolitanApe]

@@thecoin5394 Why

[@Tsudkyk]

Ryan needs to make a return soon, I really enjoyed this conversation

[@stephenreich4102]

Thanks, Bryan, great interview!

[@jato62]

Bryan thanks for having Ryan on. Please consider Gen. Ben Hodges or Gen Philip Breedlove to talk about Ukraine.

[@CurlyHeadedFark]

This is a weird mixing of worlds I’m into

[@MrSirlulzalot]

Truth ❤

[@Chevy64w]

It’s crazy to see Callen talking to Macbeth what a crossover

[@HershalG]

Ryan, your comparison of Israeli and US NCD policy is off. The US has not fought any of its recent wars with a neghibour on its border and US cities were not threatened by thousands of rockets.

[@ravenmusic6392]

But it isn't a "neighbour" in the sense that its a hostile state, it's an occupied (and yes, even before the 7th the UNSC ratified Gaza as occupied due to Israeli water and airspace control) territory which is subject to regular military operations by a larger power who does it with impunity.

[@shovelhead2155]

USA NCO's are not a monolith. Many have come here from war torn area's around the world.

[@RANDO4743]

​@ravenmusic6392 "occupied" as if jews are not native to the land? Jews which git their name from Judea,or was judah a kingdom in Europe?

[@ravenmusic6392]

@@RANDO4743 so what lmao. Nobody outside of a small group of religious fundamentalists seriously believes that an ethnic groups has dibs on land because they were there 1000 years ago. Occupation is occupation. When IDF troops go to the west bank they are literally put on "occupation duty" lol

[@Cock_Diesel]

@@ravenmusic6392 water control???????? where is gaza going to get water from???????????

[@geog26]

bro the crossovers on YT get better and better ^^

[@haraldisdead]

"NATO could take out the entire Russian army in a long weekend." The greatest cause of every war has to be the "home by Christmas" myth.

[@richardarriaga6271]

Iraq's airforce disappeared in weeks when its plane count rivaled great powers, but occupation took years til the Iran influenced legislature told them no immunity for war crimes.

[@janholub1559]

Like Kiev in 3 days?

[@tomnps1671]

The Sound of Music and Lt. Gen. Puller. Quite a library.

[@bradmcmahon]

whiskey drinking is a pre-req for infosec staff above junior staff

[@chiguireespacialespecial]

some make water

[@TomG-f4r]

Nah the real ...now the gig tis mda injected into the aquious humor's

[@910rado]

Big fan of this podcast. Major respect to Bryan for being such a great interviewer and for giving a platform to qualified analysts. Put in a word to Joe and maybe we'll get Ryan on to combat the Russian disinformation that's RAMPANT with some of his previous guests!

[@edl653]

Ryan is great and that is partly because he works hard and is smart. He is not ignorant of the danger of cigars and eating bread but makes knowledgeable choices out of understanding and not denial or ignorance.

[@chiguireespacialespecial]

say as we preach not as we do,

[@alsosprachzarathustra5505]

The dangers of eating bread😂

[@Raphael11001]

@@alsosprachzarathustra5505 Constipation

[@andrewedris2800]

Excellent nuanced discussion. Great content. Thanks gents.

[@tarstarkusz]

16:00 So the US imposes a no fly zone. What happens when US planes start falling out of the sky? The US cannot and should not try to impose a no fly zone anywhere the Russian air force is active.

[@jakeroper1096]

Why would US planes fall out of the sky? Did it get sanctioned by the US?

[@tarstarkusz]

@@jakeroper1096 When they meet Russian resistance.

[@jakeroper1096]

@@tarstarkusz Russia has to prove they can shoot down f15 before you can claim to shoot down a f35 😂

[@tarstarkusz]

@@jakeroper1096 What makes you think they cannot?

[@MrSolLeks]

They shot down a u2, while their tech is meh, we enevidably would have some losses.

[@therivalyn195]

Thank you so much for this. Subscribed!

[@h2didenkov]

Is it OK for Cuba, as an independent country, to host Russian or Chinese rockets?

[@domt7925]

You beat me to it. Literally his first point is easily disproven. We don't tolerate build ups on our border, but Russia has to allow it. The hilarious hypocrisy

[@geneeverett33]

Of course not. But but NATO putting them in Ukraine is different man 🤪🤪🤪🤪 It’s amazing the level of hypocrisy here

[@Raphael11001]

@@geneeverett33 Placing US nukes in Ukraine has never been under consideration. Ironically, Ukraine had the 3rd largest nuclear arsenal at the fall of the Soviet Union. They agreed to disarm them (gave to Russia), and I will quote this, _in exchange for assurances from Russia, the United States and United Kingdom to respect the Ukrainian independence and sovereignty in the existing borders._ About having nukes in Cuba. Russia already has nuclear weapons stationed in Kaliningrad, Murmansk and Belarus. Those border NATO countries without nuclear weapons and who currently do not have foreign nukes in their territory. Poland, Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia, Finland and Norway. Lastly, the US and other Western nuclear powers, haven't been threatening to nuke Russia. Russia is the only country threatening to use nukes against the West.

[@JohnPartyka]

@@Raphael11001 Sure, we Canadians are in NATO and don't have nukes. Wtf do you think would happen if 'harmless' Canada joined a military alliance with Russia? Or China? (You can't really be THAT naïve mate.)

[@Raphael11001]

@@JohnPartyka I think I understand the point you're trying to make, but your hypothetical example makes no sense. It's like saying "what do you think would happen if North Korea and Iran joined NATO"? Is the US threatening to invade Canada? Because that is what Russia is doing to its neighbors. They invaded and took a chunk of Georgia in 2008. Invaded and took Crimea from Ukraine in 2014. They invaded Ukraine again in 2022 and are occupying the East and South of the country. How would you feel if the US invaded and annexed Toronto? Would you be ok with it if the US said it was for safety reasons? It sits at striking range of NYC and DC. Also let's not forget that Russia's territory is 85% the size of the US and Canada combined. And some Russians like the idea of "taking back Аляска (Alaska)".

[@guts6560]

Fantastic episode

[@Jpd77171]

Remember when we had a full airbase of supplies, ground vehicles, advanced aircraft and we just left it to the taliban wasted 20 years and the lives of thousands of Americans to give it all up

[@Paul-wm6cq]

We got our eye 👁 on you 🦅

[@jonathanventura2257]

If Bryan thinks we should “defend” corrupt Ukraine. Then you go to the front lines and see how you do against Russia.

[@jdmo741]

You don’t understand the subject you are commenting on.

[@quattordicimontenapoleone3113]

When you ask good open questions, don't close them but turning them into some list of options. But good interview overall I have to say. Nice job!

[@breckenridgelong7692]

Trying to predict the future by claiming Russia will invade Poland is either propaganda or ridiculous hubris.

[@Alex.Kalashnik]

They have done so multiple times and openly say they want to do it again.

[@Dru517]

@@Alex.KalashnikPoland has an incredible army now. They’ve never been this strong. As well as Estonia Latvia Lithuania Finland. All these states now have the same technology and weaponry as Russia does. That’s never been the case before. Russia has manpower and Nuclear weapons. Thats the only advantage. Russia knows now everyone is on equal footing for the most part and these states will band together and fight. This isn’t the Middle Ages anymore you can’t just conquer lands like you used too.

[@mobygodfrey4936]

As shown in Ukraine Russia doesn't care about superior weapons or how much they lose they will throw meat at the problem until they have none left they've done it many times before and are doing it now

[@Rotwold]

@@Alex.Kalashnikand what nation have invaded Russia in the 1900's Germany: 3 USA: 1 UK: 1 Seems like your logic confirms that Germany will invade. Oh and Germany invaded Poland two times as well. So that's on the menu as well.

[@herrjose]

two awesome people talking

[@ilikeshroomgals]

Those Gazans are not going to forget.

[@modify.d7160]

Neither are the Isrealis

[@lukecaldwell7721]

Supposing there's going to be any left.

[@garethmorgan3665]

​@lukecaldwell7721 They'll be there. It's insane how durable humans are let alone ideas.

[@paddington1670]

good, never forget voting for Hamas in 2006. losers

[@zeroch1ll911]

The internet is a mirror of human society.

[@garethmorgan3665]

Not exactly . I would say it's more like a Hall of mirrors that reflects society but in a very extreme and distorted way. Many of the views expressed and ideas discussed as urgent matters of contemporary life online are barely thought about by your avenge joe on the street. People online hype shit up for clicks. If you look at most podcasts it's a carrousel of the same peolple.

[@haraldisdead]

'NATO should have put up a "no-fly zone."' This man is a lunatic.

[@jddyea5527]

I agree. NATO is going to shoot down Russian planes in a non NATO nation? This idiot wants ww3

[@NickSnarchy]

A great person to interview!

[@wildermarzo9611]

How is Ryan an intelligence expert coming from a grunt/mechanized platoon??? Don't get it? Perspective on line unit (squad to batallion) operations, very much so. But beyond that.....

[@holdfast-tf3gw]

He's a brain

[@patrickshanley4466]

Awesome discussion guys!!!

[@ObieOnce]

"The military indistrial complex is fake". His proof? Apple makes more money. Insane

[@robtorres5518]

Relative to what it was during the cold war. He doesn't state those caveats but perhaps he should.

[@ObieOnce]

@@robtorres5518 if it was a caveated statement, I definitely missed that context. This whole interview felt like, if I'm being charitable, he was trying to be impressive and over the top to wow Callen. I generally like McBeths analysis but to me he came across like a blowhard pushing as agenda here.

[@robtorres5518]

Just regarding the Apple comment, the military complex was once a 10 trillion dollar machine.

[@ObieOnce]

@@robtorres5518 sure but you now have various industries that have functionally broken out of the MIC or been created using technology developed as a result of MIC funding/spending/research. Functionally the whole space flight industry, many (most?) of the computer tech fields including much of the massive video game industry, modern telecom/cell phone infrastructure, the Internet (kinda), many more. On a real level you can trace some very significant amount of Apple's success to MIC efforts.

[@arturallay8116]

He convinces the feeble minded with nonsensical simple logic and they all get exited

[@TheQutapi]

59:59 haha! I love this description of the history of warfare 😂