Is China’s economic miracle unravelling?

[@ascoaptwwasmqx2840]

Actually this is the beginning of China reaping its technology and scientific investment. Due to west containment policy, China is stepping back to develop more fundamental technology currently. At the same time, explosive growth of its innovation is just starting.

[@0Zebadee0]

The downward spiral of China's economy and domestic technology, which is 20 years behind other countries, make that very unlikely. Eg., China's high-speed trains are already suffering from technical issues because they are not supplied with 70% of replacement components. And companies like Huawei are a good example of your description of “explosive innovation” because China's domestically produced microchips are 12 years out-of-date and result in performance issues. Without intellectual property and theft and stealing technology from foreign countries, China is no longer a global presence, especially with the global market preference for "zero-China."

[@ijatpingrhyb]

​@@0Zebadee0hahaha you are so far behind the eight ball it's hilarious . Go visit china and you'll realize that the west is twenty years behind China.

[@Enigma-t6n]

​@@0Zebadee0Now Basement new viewer, Maybe it's time for taking a step outside aka travel outside the bubble & Seriously when was the last time, u did that 😅 huh, my guess never. So take a break from armchair analysis from a broke bro stuck vibe. 😊

[@0Zebadee0]

@@Enigma-t6n I've been 'outside the bubble' for decades - a lot longer than you in my academic career in the politics, economics, and international relations of East Asia. Go back to school, get a Ph.D, then you'll be able to aim your pointless comments at people who know more than you with some relevance.

[@ysw8291]

@@0Zebadee0 Your icon reflects your mindset perfectly.

[@MichaelWan-s3c]

Its name says it all. News maker.

[@NeidlichesSchwert]

Semantics-based thinking is for morons.

[@petergreen5337]

❤Precisely well said and well OBSERVED.

[@kennethkong5484]

Again ! Every year for the last 30 years

[@theasianjaywalker4455]

No it isn't. Dont repeat that lie. Nobody has ever been hearing that for 30 years. 30 years ago everyone fully agreed that with the massive influx of US dolllars for manufacturing China was going to rise form the poverty-hole it was to become something like 100th out of 200 nations in 'per person wealth' and even surpass Japan for total GDP. For 30 years 'The Rise of China' has been THE biggest news story on earth. 30 years ago, some economists correctly predicted that China's 'boom time' rise would peak around 2015 and start it's inevitable decline around 2025. They were correct. but you and 27 upvoters don't get to 'rewrite history' and lie about this. You won't be allowed to 'make it become true' beause you lie about it enough.

[@roro-v3z]

@@GoldTau-s5j lets see China has solved problems and survived 3000 years, lets see this real estate crisis can take it down

[@kennethkong5484]

@@GoldTau-s5j Agree, but even with those problems, The World Bank predicts China’s growth at 5% is twice that of USA

[@kennethkong5484]

@@GoldTau-s5jAgree, but even with those problems, the World Bank predicts that China’s growth of 5% is twice that of the United States

[@jamessethi5792]

Came to china from london in 2015 and since then all i hear how china is going to fall… LMAO

[@theasianjaywalker4455]

Why the 'LMAO' though? I mean if you're going to how laughing in some twisted glee over the fall of the wealthy privileged Chinese I suppose that's one thing but you're 'LMAOing' at the worsening poverty of what are mostly relatively poorer people? That's sick

[@NeidlichesSchwert]

Address the issues brought up in the video. Anecdotes do nothing.

[@GoldTau-s5j]

I only remember recently seeing its real estate market actually crashing

[@Tungar111-mv2hw]

None of that is true.

[@Tungar111-mv2hw]

@@NeidlichesSchwert Wumaos are specifically told not to address points and only focus on anecdotes.

[@iechuanlee9326]

China's economic growth has slowed down, about 4.5% which is one of the highest compared to the rest of the G20 but not the gloom & doom as reported. This is on top of all the western sanctions, bans, tariff and propaganda echo channels from the west, they are not doing badly.

[@TacticalMayo]

You people really love vpns don't you?🤣

[@jglg7238]

jealousy, envy, hate, gets you nowhere.

[@theasianjaywalker4455]

It's driving Chinese mainlanders into a massive economic collapse. So yes, it does get your somewhere - down into a hole.

[@charliegoo1314]

You must be talking about ccp

[@GoldTau-s5j]

Neither does real estate crash

[@LaPlaya-rw1cp]

It's perplexing how China has managed to control so many people in other countries​@@charliegoo1314

[@gzchenjz]

@@charliegoo1314 ccp doesn't mind what you said, because you r nothing to it

[@mamacryright5740]

Actually, it's the beginning of China's 4th Industrial revolution, to be exact , more to come in 2025

[@0Zebadee0]

Good luck with the next Great Leap Forward. How did that work out last time?

[@ysw8291]

@@0Zebadee0 It ended with everyone in the west having at least one T-shirt made in China.

[@tupolevi]

@@0Zebadee0 This time, they already send the most special gifts for your X-mas celebration i.e. 2 variants of 6th gen aircrafts, 1 no. of improvised early warning aircraft & a new amphibious assault ship with electronic catapult system. These are the state of art weapons that are existed only in western movies and drawing boards. Didn't you know that?

[@0Zebadee0]

@@ysw8291 I was referring to the pre-t-shirt boom, when 89 million Chinese people died because of failed CCP policies.

[@0Zebadee0]

@@tupolevi Incorrect. They were invented foreign countries and copied through intellectual property theft. I don't think the Xinjiang people (in the "west") featured these in their movies.

[@mrjaratpon]

I would like to tell everone that there is no such thing as over production. It’s simply a western term which means “you are making so much, it’s pushing price down so much that we cannot compete.”.

[@TacticalMayo]

We're Americans. Why are you telling us?

[@armchairwarrior963]

China is fine, us snd eu not so fine.

[@RiteMoEquations]

Use economic indicators to support that. The US economy has been stable and predictable for over a century. China is the nation showing signs of slowing down.

[@Djursnerable]

Whatever you say, Winnie the Pooh.

[@MichiganTroopers123]

@@RiteMoEquationshow has the us economy been predictable and stable lol

[@NeidlichesSchwert]

All assertion, no argument.

[@Ned-zl1qt]

@@RiteMoEquations Haven't watched video have you? US GPD 22% from the FIRE sectors, 17% from Healthcare despite having the worst possible healthcare system in the developed world. Indicators are to make their GPD look bigger than it actually is.

[@pacificeye456]

The guests have very well balanced opinions. China has transformed into high tech, high quality industrial output economy in last 5 years. It will continually grow, despite many westerners’ pessimistic views.

[@theasianjaywalker4455]

Nope, it hasn't done any of those things in the past 5 years. one day, maybe you can visit China and see for yourself but there's just 5 years of stagnation, more closed businesses than ever before, economic collapses in real estate and more things simply breaking down and getting old.

[@ipinsos2000]

@@theasianjaywalker4455 Congrats 👏👏👏your IQ76 is awesome 🐄🐮😜😛😁

[@WingkKong]

​@@theasianjaywalker4455China is the number one trading partner of 130 country

[@theasianjaywalker4455]

@@WingkKong Chinese are easily mind-tricked by things like "number one" as if that in itself is a gaokao score then they must be wealthy and successful! but still being the number one trading partner is the 'number one curse' when more of that trade is selling at a loss to Chinese. when more of that has to be kept that way with massive subsidizing, when more of those 130 are putting tariffs on more and more things. Using the same measures, I suppose China, under the Qing Dynasty collapse may have been the number one trading partner of 100 countries while its government was collapsing, while nations moved to take ports, while terrible social uprisings were decimating China. While Japanese were annexing parts of China and taking islands. at that time, an impoversihed Chinese in great distress, seeing it all fall apart could also say: "ya but China is the number one trading partner of the most countries!" you see?

[@theasianjaywalker4455]

@@ipinsos2000 hello teenager, my iQ could be 76 and yet anyone with an IQ of 76 would be able to walk around and realize China has stagnated and only bcome poorer since 2019. They could even see 5G towers rusting, unfinished conrete buildings where they stood 5 years ago, and more closed shops than ever before. A 76 IQ can figure that out. Why can't you?

[@ze9947]

Currently, mainland China is competing with the West in the fields of science and technology, sports and military. Now it is actually a comparison between China and the entire Western world.

[@stephenjay1186]

lol….which western world 😂 aside America is Europe innovative

[@NoFrillz-G]

They just can’t get anywhere with soccer. Serious too.

[@TacticalMayo]

Currently there's 50 cent bots that can't handle the truth so they're trying to flood this thinking they'll change the narrative. Sorry it's over 🤣

[@SonuDR007]

Lol the crappy Chinese military equipment. Ask the poor Africans, Bangladeshi, Maymar and Pakistani on the crappy quality of Chinese weapons. Tank barrels blowing up when a shell is fired. Chinese aircraft fuselage falling apart due to flutter causing Maymar to ground the aircraft.

[@benet-vt6vv]

i am just curious about China, 1.4B population, 10 year free education system, over 10M undergraduates every year, no beggar on the street, millions and millions of all kinds of businesses. furthermore, the govenment controls most of its weath, and ccp controls their army. they work much harder than all countries in the world. how do you think such a giant country is going to collopse? this thougt is really amazing.

[@peterlongland6862]

Ccp micro manages every part of Chinese life. As for their population myth, china has never had a population of 1.4 billion. 40 years of a one child policy makes it purely impossible!! Right now china is making stuff for markets that don't want what china has made. Worse still the ccp will not create a consumer economy simply because in a consumer market, it the consumer that has the power. It's for this reason the ccp has deliberately curtailed companies such as ANT Group, Tenscent and others simply because no organisation can be as big and as powerful as the ccp. The ccp is a lot like Sauron from Lord of the Rings in that they don't share power. The big issue that none of tge panel addresses is the undisclosed promise of tge ccp after the Tiananmen square massacre which was, you the people can go make money as long as you don't look at how we the ccp runs control of society. What happens when no one makes money or worse, loses money?? Which is what's hapright now. Ps, I've been to china 3 times and there are heaps of beggars everywhere!!

[@WingkKong]

Because the west is collapsing

[@NeidlichesSchwert]

High school isn't even free here in China! Beggars are arrested here in Beijing, but I see trash-diggers outside my building every morning. Go visit Beijings 6th Ring Road; you'll find entire homeless communities living in make-shift tarps and scrap metal. It's robotic nationalists like you that prevent these Chinese people from getting attention and help. Shame on you.

[@dattape2828]

50 cent for you comrade

[@Tungar111-mv2hw]

Ahhhh I see that you are curious about China and asking leading questions that imply how perfect it is (even though you're just asking questions), and I know your are a westerner because you have the eiffel tower in your profile picture. Very convincing.

[@PMZInternational-le6rk]

Europeans whose economies are collapsing since the Ukraine war, say China has an ailing economy. China is booming and is the largest exporter of cars worldwide. Things are going very well in China. It is europe that is closing its industries and facing a jobs bloodbath.

[@2mek99]

China's debt is exploding. The property bubble, the overinvestment in high-speed trains. Debt as % of GDP in China is equal to the US while China is still a poor country.

[@PMZInternational-le6rk]

@2mek99 , I thought you would back up your argument with stats. Well, let me get you stats: China debt to GDp at 77% is about 17 trillion RNB. That is about 2.5 trillion in US dollars. That is 77% of their GDp. The US debt to Gdp is at 122%. Last I checked, the US debts was over 30 trillion dollars. Now, using logic and your best understanding of mathematics, do you think the debt of China is blowing up? 🤔

[@2mek99]

@@PMZInternational-le6rk You do not have knowledge of this topic. You compare central government debt. In the case of China, you need to add local government debt. And this debt is at the level of 60% of GDP (20% is official and 40% is hidden related to the property bubble). So overall it is higher then in the US. Additionally, corporate and household debts are much higher in China.

[@RiteMoEquations]

​@@PMZInternational-le6rkWhat rate of growth is the Chinese economy growing? You can complain about high levels of debt in the US, but you can't use any economic indicators or financial markets to identify signs of an eminent economic recession.

[@congruent-thoughts8781]

@@2mek99 ok you believe the propaganda. US is using 1,8 billion $ for Anti American propaganda.

[@ysw8291]

Not sure why westerners can't let go of China's past while China has long moved on.

[@1.4billion65]

Why Chinese don't know the difference between Turkey and West?

[@zenithsomining820]

​@@1.4billion65 turkey is west to china

[@williamgoquay5475]

​@@1.4billion65 Go ahead and tell us what's the difference between Turkiye and the west.

[@1.4billion65]

@@williamgoquay5475 if the Chinese can't see the difference between Turkey and the west, don't cry when you face racist in the West!

[@亦如飞鸟]

狗中哈士奇，国中土耳其。​@@1.4billion65

[@conchitamacario2599]

US black propaganda

[@calicoesblue4703]

You mean US white Propaganda 🤷

[@NeidlichesSchwert]

Same ol' predictable wumao comment. POST SOMETHING ORIGINAL!

[@conchitamacario2599]

@@NeidlichesSchwert US is always engaging in black propaganda to countries that are considered a threat thus the same comment. Maybe I should add something to that, US black propaganda a prelude to regime change.

[@conchitamacario2599]

@@NeidlichesSchwert I can’t change for what it really is. If you already know it’s black propaganda then it’s for people who don’t know.

[@conchitamacario2599]

@@NeidlichesSchwert Black propaganda a prelude to regime change. How about that?

[@henryng9406]

USA has a black heart.

[@NeidlichesSchwert]

This channel isn't American.

[@TacticalMayo]

God bless, the United States of America 🇺🇸

[@nkvk2810]

China's fading dream? What a useless question to begin with. Chine is already living in the future. See their technological development. Those who think China is declining have been drinking the wrong beer😂😂😂

[@eliso5973]

We should talk about US and its allies declining, not China.

[@TonyVCetinski]

Overcapacity. Economic collapsing. Which is which

[@KonglengLee-t6l]

While US kept dreaming

[@TacticalMayo]

And this guy from China coping 🤣

[@Im-mono]

Western news report regarding China is like "Make a wish" all the time... And they get frustrated all the time and continue making wishes...

[@TacticalMayo]

Oh my God, this one over here about from China thinking he's convincing anyone of anything 🤣

[@yqzhang9192]

西方的"中國崩潰論"已經說了三十多年了。。。什麼時候崩潰？

[@ijatpingrhyb]

Be quiet the west don't like the truth 😂😂

[@1.4billion65]

They are Turkey, not the West!

[@yqzhang9192]

@@1.4billion65 對中國來說北約國家都是西方

[@defintity_9951]

@@yqzhang9192 Where did it say China will collapse? China's growth has went from 14% in 2008, to 8% in 2017, to less than 5% in 2024, with the IMF expecting it to be 3% by 2028. This means that at least reative to the US, China's GDP per capita will stagnate at ~15% of the US number nominally, and ~25-30% on a PPP basis. Already, China's consumption and retail growth is slower than in the US, in which China used to be 2x to 3x faster as late as 2015. South Korea for example kept their growth rate of 10% and above for more than double the amount that China did, from the 1960s to 1990s, and kept high growth (7-8%) for another 20 years after that.

[@defintity_9951]

@@yqzhang9192 And the existing slowdown hasn't even been caused by the looming demographic issues, in which threatens to slow growth further, especially when China's urbanization rate stagnates as estimated by the late 2020s-early 2030s. No major country with a declining working-age population managed GDP growth above 2% over its following 2 decades, with most averaging 1% (Japan, Italy).

[@lsvaralokasf8249]

Bad mouthing China is an outdated concept nowadays, apparently even the gullible would not believe this kind of cheap analysis anymore. You need to compete with China then the world will respect you, spreading lies will get you spiraling down the drain.

[@petergreen5337]

❤Precisely

[@lalatubby4836]

yeah but...the 1.6BILLION USD anti China fund come in handy tho

[@TacticalMayo]

God bless America 🇺🇸

[@TacticalMayo]

No we will not do any of that. We will stay number one, that's it.

[@jintaowang9897]

China's GDP per capita is $12,969 in 2024, pretty sure they are not satisfied with that. Economic growth will continue.

[@thomasrogers9146]

JUST LOOKING AT CHINESE TECHNOLOGICAL BREAK THROUGH REALESED IS MIND BOGGLING.. LEAVE THESE PEOPLE ALONE.

[@theasianjaywalker4455]

Name one of these TECHNOLOGICAL BREAK THROUGHS?

[@charliegoo1314]

Why Chinese can not leave Taiwan alone. They are much more peaceful and much helpful to the outside world. Why can't Chinese just leave them alone?

[@Zlaland]

​@@charliegoo1314 not even US Recognised Taiwan as a country

[@Joraceso]

Most of China's technology was pirated from the US

[@TacticalMayo]

Listen to the guy whose name is now Thomas Rogers Mr. Wang. 🤣

[@amin8202]

Let's accept it. Chinese are hard working and peaceful

[@Cha-jq2po]

Peaceful in what sense? You ever take a look at what Chinese propaganda looks like?

[@rastoferi6012]

​@Cha-jq2poyes, there's not a single regime change message in sight

[@Cha-jq2po]

@@rastoferi6012 nope, only constant missile threats, support for dictators and a disdain of any US ally, with China denying them their right to choose a policy.

[@Cha-jq2po]

@@rastoferi6012 there’s no peace in Chinese propaganda

[@rastoferi6012]

@Cha-jq2po it literally said by peaceful means. Poor illiterate bot

[@darvidkoh2707]

What utter crap. The bozos here will be seen to be making fools of themselves in the months and years ahead.

[@albback8176]

Hardly. Their online content is quite intelligent.

[@TacticalMayo]

Mr. Wing Chun would you care for some hot chili oil to garnish your cope?🤣

[@darvidkoh2707]

@@TacticalMayo Dunno what you are talking about. You intelligence is as limited as your literacy.

[@bleedingmay]

the host is coping so hard

[@siphoramashiya531]

She really wished she didn't invite Ben

[@soonpohtay4794]

Another grant application to the NED

[@TacticalMayo]

And another cheenk using a VPN to access a social media platform they're not supposed to be on.

[@paulmatters2641]

@@TacticalMayo The quality of NED trolling is pathetic champ. You get paid for this? Really

[@skyhighnightlight]

Chinese cars are Great! Thank You People of China!!!

[@TacticalMayo]

God bless the United States of America and this person is from China. We know better.

[@johannsteinberg6218]

What about the US? Will it decline after a big rise over the last 90 years? It is a question to ask in order to improve.

[@horridohobbies]

Japan's economy eventually recovered??? Are we looking at the same country? Japan's economy is in major crisis.

[@dynasty781]

2024 China gdp 5% what is this lady talking about??😂😂

[@TacticalMayo]

Lol. Look at the cope. They're literally going out their way to buy a VPN as fast as they can. Thinking if they say something it will change anything LOL 🤣

[@franciskenyi3139]

What's the Chinese growth , and that of the U S A, and Europe

[@Black_Sun_Dark_Star]

Does the West really have time to worry about the Chinese economy?

[@brianlowe3529]

American. Dream is over also

[@TacticalMayo]

Trust me, it will either be an American dream or a nuclear nightmare.

[@martinchristianaguilar5135]

Sinophobe Propaganda

[@NeidlichesSchwert]

Empty assertion. No receipts.

[@pardeeptandon]

Japan was a kid compared to China.

[@theasianjaywalker4455]

China is only 75 years old. Its only had a modern economy for around 30 years.

[@GoldTau-s5j]

Both have demographic problems

[@ghvjhcgyg]

@@theasianjaywalker4455 that's PRC, not China

[@soonmeteh4150]

@@ghvjhcgyg you got mental problem.

[@huangzb8060]

The host should invite Gordon Chang on board to speak what she and most westerners wanted to hear.

[@theasianjaywalker4455]

Westerners aren't just Chinese people with different faces. They don't have a 'Shame Culture' so they don't get off on the idea of China being poorer than them and sneeeer and jack off over how someone is poorer than them. But yes, Gordon Chang is far more realistic than this panel of creeps.

[@stvdmc2011]

He is already booked on the more main stream media like Fox, CNN, ABC....

[@petergreen5337]

❤exactly

[@TacticalMayo]

Has everyone noticed all the 50 cent bots popping up cuz the cope is too hard?🤣

[@David-mv6si]

@@TacticalMayo you are a CIA bot.

[@jvcaleta]

Ha Ha Ha Ha, Ha ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha, Newsmakers is a funniest News, It make laugh a lot !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. Ha Ha Ha.........

[@flickbaitvrc173]

stop being a black

[@RubyJustin-c3m]

Nonsense

[@larryCatford]

western mainstream - ' the Chinese People are suffering without food and electricity ! ' | Chongqing China's Future City | 75th Anniversary of the P.R.C | | Beijing China Walking Tour | Modern Shopping Mall & Bustling Nightlife | 4K UHD | | Walking Tour of Shenzhen's Most Jaw-Dropping Architecture | China Travel | - youtube

[@TacticalMayo]

Lol listen to this one knowing he's from China calling himself Larry. Come on man. You ain't fooling no one

[@mathiasalexander7795]

Western "experts" predicting China's "collapse" all the while their own countries going down the toilet :D

[@TacticalMayo]

What country you live in? Never mind I already know 🤣

[@gogorunalways]

China,China,China....let China alone and do u own work more

[@TacticalMayo]

Why don't you stay behind your firewall?

[@tupolevi]

British Chancellor invites China to invest in UK electric vehicle and renewable energy industries - 25 dec 2024

[@nick-l4o2z]

india is the biggest investor in uk

[@marcdefang5487]

You guys are looking at Chinas problem at Western point of view. The real problem isn’t the economy but what caused. Which is the policies which is the CCP. You can’t judge China using western textbooks

[@bobbyschannel349]

when I see all these videos talking about how bad China economy is getting....... I'm like yo. Everybody economy is messed up all around the world.

[@chopinmack5418]

Globalization is slowing down in the G7 countries, whereas increasing rapidly between the Global South countries ( w/ 85% of World population ) w/ the help of China. This will improve the living standard of people in these areas.

[@TacticalMayo]

And we have another person from China trying to come in with to earn their $0.50. thinking what they're saying will change anything. It will not

[@mikeg02]

China own manufacturing innovation and commodities supply chains from Africa to Asia which they secured by providing major infrastructure projects that transformed those countries. While America and Europe think China will fall due to selling fewer temu, shein and tech products to their citizens, china is building billion dollar ports, railways, dams and securing raw material supply chains all over the world while creating billions of customers for their products in Asia, Africa and South America.

[@John-s8n4e]

Chinese govt and people working together very hard working. Democracy nation they didn’t..

[@OctavioLopezMaldonado]

You people keep saying this since 2008! You´re funny people! LOL!

[@TonyVCetinski]

I thought. Economy collapse. China over collapsing 😂

[@muradfarooqui1741]

Fantastic analysis. For the first time in my life, I think China is the beacon of hope for the planet, especially with it's massive input to produce green energy.

[@eugeniovazquez1483]

That is what western media wishes

[@KingKong-lb3vh]

[@JonTan-z3e]

china gdp is now 20 trillion, obviously it cant grow at the same rate when it was 2 or 3 trillion.

[@nick-l4o2z]

20 trillion and yet millions r entering usa illegaly particularly through Mexican boarder?

[@TacticalMayo]

China's GDP is at 18 trillion. The United States GDP is at 28.6 trillion 🤣

[@nick-l4o2z]

@TacticalMayo chinas perhaps income 11000 and America's 90000

[@JonTan-z3e]

@@nick-l4o2z anyone believe americas gdp per cap is nearly 90,000 that 340 million people is making nearly 90,000 usd per cap in economic output? a small country with a small population thats filthy rich and extremely high income thats still believable.....say australia with 60,000 gdp per cap.mind u 60,000 is already considered insanely high..... most first world countries in the world stalls around 40 to 50,000 maybe 60,000. there are some which are much higher like luxembourg or singapore or ireland but they dont really count because their populations are very small which skews the results higher. but USA a country of population of 330 million has 80,000 gdp per cap which is mind boggling? i call there is something seriously wrong here considering her economy has been atrocious the past several years.

[@soonmeteh4150]

@@TacticalMayo US GDP is fake one, in 2019,China GDP is 18.7 trillion, US 22 Trillion, the US print 4 Trillion more USD every year since to boost their fake GDP by give money to their citizens and wall street to boom their stocks, then count it as GDP, they produce nothing but only consuming without pay the world. it won't last long. American life are all rely on the privilege of printing money but will eventually come to an end.

[@whitemoon5752]

So a growth rate of 5% GDP on a $18.5T is bad 😂 hmmm

[@cspdx11]

Lol. Wishful thinking from the West

[@TheDavidlloydjones]

No, China is not unravelling. China is making an important transition. China has just reached -- or returned to what it had 200 years ago -- its position on the world's average of wealth per capita. This means it is making the transition from being a net net importer to being a net net exporter of cheap jobs -- and hence of edging slowly into becoming an advanced economy overall, not just at the commanding heights.

[@joey3291]

Thumbs up for Ben!

[@OctavioLopezMaldonado]

And is still growing much more than US and EU! LOL!

[@TacticalMayo]

Cope harder🤣

[@who-dn5cl]

The West should buy a cheap air ticket, back pack for 1 month, then experience the actual happiness and economy in Chiina. I was there in 2024 for 3 weeks and using the local public transport . There is so much food and every day bustling business in every day life. Did not see food banks, homelessness graffitti, crime.. Felt very secure and safe at 11pm in city - so busy and vibrant. Research into the web on China's internal infrastructure projects tells me of a long term growth projection. China over 10 years have been building , concreting on average 700km rural roads in provinces and villages. Over 10 mega dam s generating electricty along Yangtze alone. Diversion of water from South West to North East. Solar, Wind, massive energy storage etc... Expanding industries .. Rapid policy changes to counter unsuitable , less than successful events happening.. Sand storm, not enough land to grow - policy to claim back desert the size of Wales every year. Introduce Solar Panels, animals to graze reclaimed desert. Vertical farming.... Then the expansion of Belt and Road with ports and railway infrastures to create domestic economies of 3rd world. Unemployment, real estate issues.. Read up the resolution policies yourself . Building of Thorium reactors (dozens of them).. Reducing oil, gas imports... Expansion of BRICS.. Call it Economy unravelling?

[@亦如飞鸟]

恭喜欧洲回到农业时代！

[@CHRIS_CHANNEL_CN]

Hardly to think that the Global South including all Latin America, Africa & even to include South East Asia markets in full Capacity today would be able to replace the enormous Size, & Value of US alone, not even close, even more with the majority of the West, in absorbing the Products from Mainland. At least, not fast enough to grow to equivalent the Size & Value of the US Market, to be able to Sustain the Mainland Economic Growth. They should build Domestic Market very large enough & very fast enough to absorb their Industrial Output, plus over Production, as mentioned sometime ago alike Dual Cycle Economy, to include Domestic Economy, but the fact is the Domestic People would love more to Save their Money first (that's why their household Saving rate among Highest in the World) rather than Purchase their own Industrial Output, or at least Buying a lot Properties first (which go downward in Value now) before spending & absorbing Industrial over Production. +++

[@JS-jh4cy]

Funded by turkey... surprisingly good propaganda

[@dunkinpossum]

What a tease! It wouldve been wonderful to hear more from Warrick and Ben.

[@Arugula100]

Is this a propaganda channel? I thought that i heard the same news with a British accent earlier. Now I hear it in a different accent.

[@JoelMatas-oc4bl]

Your always portraying that China's economy is collapsing, You don't considering that the U.S.A.,is much more on gloomy days, an empire collapsing more than the other countries, like China. Even if China's economy is slowing down, because real estate not so good, but it will not equate to an entire country to collapsed, because China now is focusing not only on real estate but also on the following: Research and development Infrastructure Green technology EV's like BYD leading the world BRI New Development Bank BRICS And others....

[@obinnaezealah2465]

We've been hearing this same song for 30 years. Do something else.

[@1Query1]

"Is China’s economic miracle unravelling?" How braindead must one be to think that way?

[@TacticalMayo]

This is coming from a person acting like they're not from China using a VPN. I mean are you serious?🤣

[@shadowlessbeam8124]

Spend so much time talk trashes about China , it you would spened the same amount of anergy , looking after your peoples lives for prosperity and be more cooperative , make it your priority new resolutions .

[@WingkKong]

Because they understand they cannot do it

[@sportszone9159]

You guys telling this Hawks since 1990 😂😂😂😂

[@distantraveller9876]

I've been hearing this for decades...lol

[@TacticalMayo]

You're laughing but if they surpass the United States it's over for humanity.

[@SpSingh-jv3ne]

Let's " celebrate" the failing of China's economy. Are you makers of News OR news constructors !

[@rastoferi6012]

I am so glad reading the comments section a lot of people are skeptical of this video as it runs counter to economic data

[@ThisHell_ThisParadise_IsOurs]

In the West, media outlets conduct casting selections when recruiting personnel.😅

[@anonymousanonymous1997]

This host & show are mainstream media hackery 🤦🏽‍♂️🤷🏾‍♂️

[@alexroc172]

This was a fascinating conversation. Particularly interesting was the statement about China's domestic consumption of EVs at around 90% of those produced, which makes exporting less fundamental to their success. Their massive state investment in green tech. solar panels and batteries are crucial for the fight against pollution and global warming, and of course the price reductions in Kilowatt -hours now make Solar very attractive indeed. The point that China wants to be part of a multi-polar new order i.e. BRICS, is clearly a direct challenge to Western hegemony. We live in interesting times.

[@geraldkohar]

The news maker is making a report on the western economic condition

[@Steve-pq7cb]

Such a provocative title can only be conceived as ill-wishing propaganda.

[@Abdul-t6i3y]

China is failing coz of usa can't accept defeat peacefully...😅

[@yijiun7553]

Market cap. BYD: $100 billion, Tesla: $1000 billion This is a snapshot of unjustifiable imbalances that can trigger crises. 🤫

[@aioi8492]

Talk is cheap. Time will tell the truth.

[@TacticalMayo]

Well you actually have two choices in this world. Pray to God the USA is number one because that second choice guarantees nothing will be number one.

[@daanishpadha5261]

Hows this a discussion. All 3 speakers have the same stance.

[@cocococo-jn5vy]

You are making up stories about China . Now I understand why you are called the newsmaker instead of reporting the news.

[@K1pp3rs]

Newsmaker: so basically blatantly stating that they make crap up for clicks in the name alone.

[@wallacekatini3424]

Propaganda machine spewing total bs and nonsense 😂😂

[@NorCalMoDo]

想想，主持人也挺可怜的。下了节目跟老板汇报“我努力了”。美国国会的抗中宣传经费也不是那么容易拿啊！

[@Teppei888-w2l]

I say it will China 🇨🇳 economy will blossom 🌸 … a millennial year old civilization. Wishing luck from the Philippines 🇵🇭

[@seanle8778]

Thanks for sharing your video

[@tromboneJTS]

Very enlightening interviews with positive perspectives on China's future...

[@cenkufukyildiran3844]

Really good discussion!

[@Waverlyduli]

We're being swamped with groundless pro-Pooh economy talking points and nonsense on PoohTube.

[@haihangrangneume5118]

All the best Mr. REPORTER... BEST OF LUCK... HOPE YOU GET ENUFF VIEWERS

[@sufenzhang6526]

年年唱衰，年年增长，几十年了，你们累吗😂有点时间，做好自己的事儿不好吗😢

[@lijackson-x6r]

The prosperity of human society is related to the six industrial revolutions. The reason of population aging is a minor reason. Japan's economy stagnated because it missed the industrial revolution of "information technology and the Internet". At the same time, it also missed the technological revolution of "new energy vehicles" (it clicked the wrong technology tree, and Japan developed hydrogen energy at a slow pace). China and the United States are currently on the track of the industrial revolution of "artificial intelligence and robotics industry", and China is more likely to continue to lead, so it will continue to prosper. 1. Steam engine and industrial mechanization; 2. Electricity and electrification; 3. Internal combustion engine and transportation revolution 4. Information technology and the Internet 5. Biotechnology and genetic engineering 6. Artificial intelligence and machine learning

[@Lost_Johnny]

The question is can Turkey solve its own massive economic problems? Maybe it should stop its investment in terrorist groups and concentrate on the economy instead?

[@dwaynejones1555]

What happens to the Social Security safety net for the last workers at the bottom of the Ponzi Pyramid?

[@wayne1264]

Outstanding x

[@terrymcmaster2787]

No