Is Kat Von D Ripping Us Off? Let's DESTROY Tattoo Liners & Find Out! Scam or Not?

[@girlypanache7095]

"One of my kid's medicine cups... That will no longer be used." Poor Jen has to clarify EVERYTHING for the judgerydoos... 🙄

[@jenluv]

Gurl....you know I have to. Some Kelly is going to be like, “How can you call yourself a mother?? Are you trying to poison your kids?? Who puts ink in their kids’ medicine cups!! Unsubscribed!!” 😂

[@girlypanache7095]

@@jenluv 🤣😂 This is why we love you ❤️

[@donnadanielsen9411]

I actually like that she says all that. It sounds like people actually think before they talk. Rare in today’s world.

[@Helenahandbasket1971]

I thought the same thing. How sad is it that people who have no common sense, think that everyone is like them.

[@GaudyGotti]

right! i was thinking the same 🙄

[@0HxB0Y]

Your husband sounds so upset about the lack of liquid lol

[@tonyrosamusic]

Hahaha that's because he paid for those

[@sidehustlewithgloria]

😂😂😁

[@Kt-cn2rq]

😂

[@blupeppers6437]

Horrified

[@427skies]

He's thinking "What a waste of money".

[@mindy6293]

I don't think people realize just how a small amount .2ml of product is. I'm a nurse and I work work with these measurements all the time. Its a very small amount.

[@hanina12345]

That amount wouldn't even show up on a scale that starts at single grams either!

[@Alice-qe2kb]

me too i’m a vet nurse but they do advertise it to be that little amount so if people are silly enough to spend crazy money for that tiny amount then why wouldn’t they sell it 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@amkow89]

As a molecular biologist, I know how much 200uls should be and that sample size does not have that much. I guess like half of it must be lining the inside of the canister.

[@clarissejrsk7314]

Yeah but why only talking about the KVD ? It's nearly the same for a lot of liner

[@viktoriaschmied6627]

@@clarissejrsk7314 it's not only the KVD, this video just happened to be about it. All pen liners in general have so little product 😕

[@LJJabba]

Jeffrey Star is gonna love this lol

[@foxy10116]

Someone tagg him 😂😂

[@briebrie44313]

He doesn't fuck with Kat von d or her products

[@R3putaytion13]

He can’t relate to this though

[@ellasanti7132]

Yes he is lolol

[@joyceg1991]

Lisa Wrigley btw, you do know that she proven the rumor to be false. So yeah.

[@shonelllewis2019]

Moral of the story, just buy liquid eyeliner 😂😂 NYX Vinyl eyeliner is $7 and it works great 👍🏽

[@ShinJBean]

Shonell Lewis i buy liquid eyeliner from essence. Its around 3$ and works great! Its even waterproof. :)

[@abbyh102]

Shonell Lewis same

[@abbyh102]

Gyllen mine is mabaleene ny

[@sullysaints2337]

lol nyx vinyl eyeliner is my ride or die 😂

[@ShinJBean]

Awesome Abbie O okey you mean maybelline? 👍

[@CrazyNaz82]

Even though the full size had a lot more product, seeing that tiny amount that many of us pay $20+ for seems crazy. I don’t know why but this is really making me think about the high cost of makeup and what we’re actually getting. I’m Shook!

[@daniellec8171]

Yeah I kind of want to take 2 TB syringes from work to show people the actual amount that you're paying for. I mean it's not even ONE milliliter

[@PeanutButterZombie00]

Yeah, this is definitely making some drugstore brands look even more attractive to me.

[@NunyaNomi]

Danielle B Do it! I've been screaming at my screen that they need to use ink cartridge syringes with the very long blunt needle on every video 😂

[@LCx829]

So true. Im more worried about packaging so I would still buy the mini trooper liner. Also wondering about mascara ? Minis always work better for me.

[@gracesun9825]

This is strange to see because I feel like the small size I have lasts forever!

[@roxybroxy184]

So much plastic waste for so little product #thinkbeforeyoubuy

[@alejandritaag.8028]

Roxy Broxy I’m sure that was just a legit hater comment cause you probably just throw away plastic bags after going grocery shopping

[@Belial_Rat666]

But she's right. For the amount of product that's a lot of plastic.

[@amylewis4100]

Agreed

[@paulinamorales8854]

@Alex Nagy Just because YOU do it doesn't mean everyone else does it ;)

[@kendalmariehudson3106]

Paulina Morales that’s the point, they should do it. Plastic is ruining our earth. I personally think this comment was more directed at The beauty product and maker more so than the youtuber. If all of these makeup brands just took a handful of steps and apply it to their business we would be saving so much waste! :)

[@hannahstahl1857]

Don’t be like Kat Von D and please #VaccinateYourChildren

[@michaeljaysonbanua4870]

I'm rolling right now... 😆🤣😂

[@jayal5771]

Just vaccinate your favourite ones.

[@redrum4139]

Oh god can you not..

[@SweetPeaAly]

@@sourgrapes354 ONLY complete idiots who live under a boulder they can't escape don't know what vaccines are. I knew what they were the moment I could pronounce "booster shot." don't be a dumbass and come up with better remarks

[@GeekmomD]

I had a good laugh when I found out her cats are vaccinated, but not her kid.

[@anamariazambrano2404]

I’m looking through the comments and realizing that half of the people that wrote them did not watch the video at all. At all.

[@Damaged69Youth]

people are really dumb and hateful

[@AlohaPanda]

I don’t think these people watched through the whole video lol...she isn’t ripping us off, the full size has more liquid in it.

[@MaryFaulds]

I think what actually entails a ripoff is subjective 😂😂😂

[@kaeluciano5698]

3.5 ml wet n wild waterproof liquid eyeliner is like $4 at the drugstore. It doesn't smudge or flake. Kat con D's is .55 ml? Wtf? And its what $20-$50? RIP OFF. Especially when the drugstore product is better quality AND more product. Idk. If the product was actually more quality than a drugstore brand I could accept people paying more just for a name. But obvious ripoff is obvious.

[@nelliee6736]

@@kaeluciano5698 and ? You can get 10€ drugstore make up palettes and people will still buy Anastasia or Jeffrey palettes for 46€. Its about Support and preferences...

[@rjm5080]

​@@kaeluciano5698 I mean yes, but drugstore brands have a history of using cheap unethically sourced ingredients. KVD is a vegan, cruelty-free, clean beauty brand, and people are willing to pay more for these tags. Wet n Wild could be using pigments, mica, etc in their products that are from animal sources meaning animals are murdered to source these ingredients or they are mined through human slavery and child labour. Children and adults are made to work 16+ hrs in a day in the most dangerous conditions while being paid less than $2/day. So many of these workers die on the job. Some of the ingredients in cheaper products can also be toxic or harmful for you. So many companies are being sued for using carcinogenic ingredients in their products.

[@MasterofScrutiny]

So Kat Von D was being honest. They both weighed the same and that's because they used plastic in the sample to take up the volume of the ink in the regular size.

[@kikiTHEalien]

I just got recommended this video. I hope it makes a mini- comeback and finally gets a million views

[@SussexSandra]

This was so cool to watch. But damn, we really are paying for packaging and not product aren't we? SMH!

[@prettyinpink9893]

The product includes the packaging. Or do you just want some ink in a bag?

[@lar8200]

Also i dont think people realize what a unit of measurement actually is. A mL is a very small amount

[@birdview9085]

@@prettyinpink9893 there's no reason for the snark. She was just saying since there is so little product it seems like we're paying for packaging.

[@birdview9085]

For roughly the same price eyeko has . 07oz vs KVD . 018oz and Stila . 016oz

[@sonyahdepasse9424]

Or one from a dollar store.l promise you that if you try one from every $1 source including online you WILL find one to suit you.l kid you not.99% of makeup is made in China anyway & repackaged.We just like paying lots of money for shiny designer *everything*.Not everyone wants the same shinies but everyone has some shinies that they cannot resist,me included.l just know that I'm being massively ripped off for packaging. I still want moschino and kenzo and expensive makeup tho,but only certain products..

[@EmpressKadesh]

Now let's judge the entire beauty industry for all that plastic for such a tiny amount of product!!

[@redtankgirl5]

Agreed, the entire industry uses far too much packaging not only to house the products but the packaging you will throw away upon purchase. There is a constant flow to the land fills from the beauty industry but we all want some of that beauty.

[@arleenlopez3022]

I actually stopped using it because I got tired of constantly having to pick up a new liner ALL the time. I caught on after the second time and switched back to Stila

[@dancinkitty77]

LOVE Stila. ❤️

[@lisajswan]

You should have returned it if you bought it at Sephora. They take back everything.

[@cedarwho7]

I have had the same covergirl eyeliner for a year and it still work amazing.. lol

[@Kozickih]

Welp. This reinforces my choice not to repurchase fancy eyeliner. Im not paying 20+$ for less than 1mL of product.

[@trina0109]

Kozickih wet n wild eyeliner will always be my favorite

[@xo7499]

you don't actually pay for size but quality ( or brandor celebrity name trend ). I am not saying that every expensive brand it of quality, but that's why people buy these

[@relaxregan]

The product quality is very important to me, as well as the ingredients and chemicals in them. A lot of cheaper ones have not as great recipes. I can tell the quality, because I will get severe allergic reactions to the harsh chemicals in cheap eye liners. Just because they’re cheap, does not mean that they’re infinitely “better”

[@darkstraylily1477]

Just because theyre expensive and marketed as "make up by celebs" dont mean theyre better either.... Its all chemicals. Ever read the label of any of those? Yeah. Some freaky shit right there. Regardless of brand and pricetag.

[@ladymaiden2308]

I found some really great eyeshadow that I used as eyeliner instead, it stays put and it's fantastic! I wouldn't call it waterproof but it works for the times that I don't plan on swimming. Name brand is Root. I really recommend their eyeshadows for use as eyeshadow and eyeliner, plus I have a brow powder that does a really amazing job of staying put! Cruelty free and vegan as well.

[@LiiteskiinDeliite]

The husband was so disappointed 🗣”there’s no liquid” 🤣🤣

[@MakeupMolly]

Your husband is such a pal for helping

[@anthonylawson518]

$50 for eyeliner...I would say you wasted your money alright!

[@Mangzorz]

Lol yeah! I pay $8-10 and I think that's pricey. Lol Maybe in just broke. It's fine.

[@anthonylawson518]

@@Mangzorz im just cheap....plus with it being Kat Von D ..you are paying for a name ...but aren't there better names to pay for...like any...lol

[@dutchik5107]

@@Mangzorz i pay like 3 euros. Offbrand. Same for concealer. Only that's of essense. Works pretty well and spreads easily (yeah with ma finger. I don't do a lot of make up.

[@alliegator716]

I think that was her total! The full size is 20$ + tax so the 50$ should be that and the cost of the sample duo :)

[@Corgis34700]

Anthony Lawson I mean either way cheap or expensive, makeup has nasty stuff in it. Cheap makeup for foundation, they use like chicken carcass cause that slimy stuff on the chicken makes your face soft. And I haven’t looked into the expensive makeup but it’s nasty. Why I don’t wear makeup and just learn to accept my crusty face days 😂

[@AndreaMatillano]

This was such an interesting video! It’s kind of crazy when you see how much liquid is actually in the liner. Thanks for sharing Jen!

[@jenluv]

So glad you liked it, Andrea! Thanks for watching!

[@drawitout]

You mean how little. I would love to do a mass makeup boycott just to pull prices down.

[@namikonoda]

So basically she’s selling you guys $3 wet and wild eyeliner? 🙄

[@ElaineS0t0]

kimáni kat’s eyeliner last all day and doesn’t come off or melt 🖤 so even tho she’s reaping us off, it’s worth it . My opinion lol

[@namikonoda]

Killerqueen97 wet and wild eyeliner doesn’t either! IMO best drug store liner!

[@Anairamrp1]

I bought a brand new one and it started so smear really early. RIP KVD

[@shawn170204]

Killerqueen97 lol that’s crazy it’s all in your head. Eyeliner is not worth $50 lol

[@vilegore7622]

girl, wet and wild is the best drugstore brand. their eyeliner is amazing as well,

[@jayleevt]

On the Sephora website it clearly says that this eyeliner holds 0.55 mL, which is about what you found when you opened it. People in the comments are like "OMG IT'S ONLY .55 ML???" .... Yes. Yes it is, lol. I think we read that but can't visualize how much that actually is. We see how big the tube is and assume we're getting that much.

[@gabye.]

It is a problem when people in America can't visualize metric system. I come from a country where is the only measurement you use, so I know exactly what I am getting when I buy something, if you weren't't taught within this system, you are getting mostly surprises when it comes to volume and sizes of products

[@jayleevt]

@@gabye. I mean, Google does really easy conversion calculation

[@gabye.]

@@jayleevt I know but some people won't even bother to do so

[@UNEARTHED36]

I work in a lab which makes the visualisation way easier Haha. Ever since I learned those volumes it opened my eyes, for sure!

[@chawndel8279]

Same thing happened ELF's primer. People were claiming rip off because the packaging has wasted space, but they print right on the container the exact amount you're buying. People just can't visualize the amount, especially in comparison to the size of the packaging.

[@kimforeman5409]

Science experiments require repetition to validate results - your running the experiment to validate the experiments of the other KZbinrs is sound science!

[@sagi1142]

☺ You're cool!

[@enyo0047]

But why spend 20+ dollars on a eyeliner that only has .55ml.

[@littlereddress82]

I love urban decay 24 7 eyeliners. Now l oreal and mayballine has come out with similar ones. I will only be buying the urban decay ones i use that loreal and mayballine dont make the color of

[@cupcakexlindsay]

Cuz it’s the only liner that doesn’t run on my watery eyes (not kat von d but stila) I’ve tried every single drugstore one and they all bleed and run on my watery inner corners.

[@cannibalisticrequiem]

Because you're mostly paying for the name of the brand, whether you admit it or not. 🤷‍♀️

[@janelle009]

Jes Lightning EXACTLY!! I will admit that some items are actually better but for the most part you’re paying for the name.

[@littlereddress82]

@@cannibalisticrequiem except when you want a cobalt blue eyeliner and urban decay is the only company that makes one then you are stuck.

[@deedeeOWL]

The ink-liner-pen was original a Japanese beauty technology (an idea derived from ink-brush-pen made for students in the Eastern Asia region who use them for Chinese/Kanji practice) , some of these ink-liner-brush-pen are sold for as low as $13-$15 in Japanese stores. Same quality

[@redrum4139]

Then shipping Will be another $5-$7.. Rather buy the kat one here in the US.

[@rainbowdashsailormoon6005]

@@redrum4139 I get my eyeliner from etude house which is a Korean brand. I get it on Amazon with free shipping, and I don't think it's even $10. Highly recommend it

[@deedeeOWL]

Red Rum I should have specified, if you live in CA, there are plenty of Asian supermarkets that sell the ink-brush-liner without shipping cost 😉

[@liv97497]

I really enjoyed this video! But I have to say, this is why Americans should learn the metric system😅 0.2 mL (the sample size) is a tiny little amount. For comparison, your little cup's first measure is 2.5 mL (I think that's what I saw?), which is a little more than ten times what's in the package. Another way to compare: 0.2 mL is roughly *one thousandth* of a cup, or 1/25th, four percent, of a teaspoon. It looks like very little on the cup, especially because of the size of the container - you would only be able to somewhat measure it in a very tiny syringe.

[@ashleymartinez9635]

Smarty pants. 😂

[@amylouwho8991]

Now we know why the mini dries out so fast.

[@LCx829]

My mini lasts a long time. Im still using 1 from 4 months ago.

[@raev87]

At the risk of sounding haughty, I hadn’t heard about this controversy but when Jen showed the clip of the cartridges being the same size, my first thought was “yeah they probably put less actual product into the trial size cartridge.” Other people have said what I think, that people always need something to bitch about, and it’s not that I don’t believe a company would try to rip you off, but people need to actually find this crap out before starting unfounded rumors. This reminds me of the ELF primer or whatever that was, where people didn’t understand how an airless pump works and then flipped it over, took out the inner container, and saw the excess space and thought “they aren’t putting anything in here!” And I think Jen addressed that controversy in a similar manner, too. So thank you Jen, for actually doing the stuff that sensationalists don’t bother to do. That’s why we love you 💗

[@EgoBrain1]

Exactly

[@freebird1599]

Rachel V I totally agree! I can’t stand that people put rumors out in the universe...because true or not people tend to believe them!

[@alyssabrown-carleton6173]

And especially being from an already controversial brand, it was easy to just demonize her

[@hitzchicky]

I thought the same. I saw the two and was like, oh, that's pretty normal in manufacturing. Why create two sizes of something when you can just use one?

[@leighsutherland6222]

It is common knowledge. That so many of the buyers of this brand are clueess says a lot about them.

[@dottyroads46]

I think people need to be more mindful of their own consumerism. Instead of screaming everything is a scandal because they didn't bother reading the label before they bought something.

[@mmendes239]

You're absolutely right!

[@keshk4056]

Thank you Jen for always doing honest impartial video's & in depth research. Most beauty blogger's won't put this much effort. You deserve way more subscribers.

[@Monica-le9oi]

Suddenly I need this circular tool you’re using to clip the liquid tube. 🙈

[@Saiege]

I believe they are wire cutters

[@DarlinDesigns]

They are lock, chain or cable cutters

[@clareburrow5616]

You wouldn’t want that tool to get into the hands of your enemy - you wouldn’t be able to play “This Little Piggy” ever again.... MWHA HA HA HA"...!

[@KatieMarie]

This was SO entertaining to watch - thanks for the experiment! And I don’t follow either of those other channels who did it, so I’m very glad you did it as well!

[@SandyDiVa]

Well then, you SHOULD really sub to BEAUTY NEWS if only for their makeup breakup series! It's just like this but every product you can imagine 😉

[@becky1854]

If people didn't make a video just because someone else did, we'd only hear one voice and that leads down a dangerous rabbit hole. Great video and glad you had fun making it!

[@JennRobHall]

QueenAuna 💯

[@erikkasepiphany85]

This is exactly why these dry out so fast because you barely get any ink!!!!🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄#feelingannoyed

[@Selene32986]

Erikka's Epiphany yeah! It’s crazy how fast you run out of ink with this liner... I really like it but have always hated it runs out so quickly.

[@sahirarodriguez9782]

Omg yessssssss!!! 😒😒

[@Vandalynn]

I've never had a problem with this eyeliner drying out fast. They last months of daily use.

[@candacelacy1564]

Mine barely worked when I first opened it!! I have switched to Quickliner, the one with the stamp on one end, it’s AMAZING!! Waterproof, sweat proof, huge contents and You get 2 pens per box.

[@marilamar821]

The lesson: always go for the full size product cause minis are meant to lure you into buying the full size, just another conspiracy of mine

[@peachxtaehyung]

Here to help you get to a million! Ive been a sub of yours since this and the loccitane video

[@erinptrsn]

This scandal didn't even bother me, but you're the ONLY video I've seen that actually determined there was a smaller tube in there that proves there's less eyeliner in there and that she's not lying. I'm impressed! Great detective work! (Still never buying her eyeliner! )

[@Puglover130]

Erin Petersen beauty news determined it as well (and sooner)

[@anitadidion5048]

🖒

[@whyaddnamehere]

I love that you and Beauty News did this. The more people who tries this out the better! We are all makeup lovers here.

[@karenm9305]

I agree with your husband... "who does this" LOL. In all seriousness I never questioned this particular issue because, really a) we would have heard about that type of thing much sooner from a leak from a disgruntled employee were it true and b) while I may question KVD's life choices, I really doubt in this information age neither she nor the brand parent company would have risked that level of dishonesty. Thank you for investing your dollars for science :D

[@bryssanevarez4853]

And this is why I just buy $3 eyeliner Bc it all works the same

[@lannaramirez174]

Right!!!

[@briannapatterson8158]

I just use the wet n wild eyeliner that’s like 1.50 🤷‍♀️

[@punkrockmetalqueen92]

Disagree tarte sex kitten and tarte maneater eyeliner is life-changing to the eyeliner game

[@poisonxivy420]

@weirdocentral Totally agree!! I was lucky enough to get a sample of the sex kitten liner when I bought my makeup, and I fell in love! Best eyeliner I've ever tried😍 went back and bought the full size when my sample ran out 👍

[@alissam4296]

I really enjoy your channel because aside from your good looks and makeup skills, you’ve got your intelligence & awesome personality to offer! I find you far more interesting to watch than influencers that apply lipstick and then pout & wink at the camera. 😹 (and I mean no disrespect to those types of channels by saying this. To each his own, of course! ❤️🤷🏻‍♀️☺️)

[@therandomrissa]

Can we pause to appreciate your eye look today?? Yasssss!!

[@mememe217]

Riggghhhhhttt!!!! That's all i was focused on you look breath taking jen!

[@melb4116]

I have turned to Nyx liquid liner pretty damn good and half the price

[@Labbfreak]

Love that you spoke about reproducibility in experiments 🙌 🧪

[@cassandraculley5659]

I LOVE that you included the snip of you mentioning the other youtubers who put they’re time into making their own video. Support and love is what we need!

[@sophroniel]

Thank u for acknowledging that "repeated" videos on this kind of thing is good!

[@windycitygal_diana]

Haha! I love the editing! I did see Beauty News do this as well! Great detective skills on your part.... all for science of course.

[@jessfrezz4764]

It’s Jen’s version of MythBusters! Love it! 😄

[@Ashley_Marie23]

Jess Frezz omg what a cool series for her!!!😃👍🏻

[@kaivickers166]

“Failure is always an option.”

[@cases_with_kat]

The one thing this scandal showed is how little is in the KvD liner. Benefit and Tarte both have liners in the same price range with 1 ml of product, but the packaging size is the same. The mini benefit roller lash liner has the same amount of product as the full size KvD.

[@karly8257]

I bought the sample and love the formula however after using it everyday it ran dry after 15 uses.

[@karengius8064]

Thus, why it is labeled as sample. I wish they made samples of all of that stuff, it's quite expensive and it would be nice to try out eye shadows, foundations, and others before buying the full size.

[@vabeachfreak]

Mine didn’t even work!😢

[@sxfm1585]

The cartridge contains cotton which soaks up the liquid so as to mediate product delivery to the tip...that is why it appears empty

[@irisk934]

Glad to hear she was being honest. Thanks for this review Jen

[@ashleyb7139]

"Who the hell does this....Who thought to do this?!?!" 😂 That was my thought, but I'm kind of glad someone did lol

[@kathleengoriup4988]

I ALWAYS CHECK THE PRICES OF BOTH SAMPLE/TRAVEL SIZE VS. FULL SIZE. YOU WOULDN'T BELIEVE THAT IT'S SOMETIMES CHEAPER TO BUY A COUPLe OF TRAVEL SIZES. I FIND THIS IN SKINCARE AS WELL.

[@1234chicken567grease]

Kathleen Goriup great tip 💛

[@EmGrace4012]

I’ve recently found your channel so I’m binging all of your videos and I don’t know what it is about your voice and the way you speak but omg.. I could literally listen to you talk ALL DAY LONG. A new subscriber ❤

[@annaward4004]

I love that your hubby supports your interests and helps you! Y’all are awesome!

[@mishmash3968]

You’re husband has the same reaction I do, who the hell does this?😂 There is liquid. It is IN the cartridge, like a marker. 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@89tothbianka]

Your*

[@kwristal00]

People are soo quick to jump on the "CANCELED" train and don't care where they are going or who is driving it! I am soo tired of people looking for something to rage about. Great video Jen! 👌🏼

[@EgoBrain1]

Same

[@kaivickers166]

I accept people’s anger without problem. What I have trouble with is when a person or company tries to fix it and they’re still pissed. Like Tarte’s newest foundation launch. Why should anyone try to be better if they’ll never be forgiven anyway?

[@tamarasweidan4041]

Kai Vickers well said 100%

[@bunhime9903]

Kat Von D has others reasons she deserves to be cancelled lmao

[@yoursocialmoth]

Well, Kat dates/marries neo Nazis and doesn't believe in vaccinations. Seems like pretty good reasons to cancel her ass to me

[@j355nic0l3]

I love you & your husband working togther. It just brings out a different side of you. I'm enjoying it. 💖

[@BindleBelle]

Coming from todays chat// I hope you reach 1 M ❤❤❤❤

[@victoriahilton62]

People,just buy the L'Oréal eyeliner!Over the years I tried so many high end liquid liner and I always go back to L'Oréal.Its half the price of all the other ones and does an amazing job!

[@neonsvampen1]

That one is shit. The waterproof one is not waterproof. U can just wet your finger and its gone

[@kensiem8252]

but l’oréal is an awful company. They are known for harshly testing on helpless animals. I would not support them.

[@Chrise501]

Wouldn’t KVD cosmetics be required by law to have exact product weight listed on the package?

[@jenluv]

Absolutely.

[@Chrise501]

Jen Luvs Reviews Yes, I had to Google that. Lol, inquiring minds. It looks like there are three federal laws for product labeling. Depending on if it’s a first offense or intended misrep, it could be either a misdemeanor or felony with jail time. Plus civil suits with fines up to ten million. Something like that could also cost her whatever goodwill she has left.

[@shannonsaenz8028]

In the beauty news that she mentioned they said it can’t be less than 10% of what’s on the package so unfortunately it can be slightly less than advertised.

[@LAMBYWORKS]

Great video lady, still won't support her, but you were awesome to spend money on science, thanks girl!!

[@fueledbycupcakes]

Same. Never trusted her anyway.

[@ribbonsuffocation]

Same! I can't stomach her at all.

[@hannahstahl1857]

Same because she doesn’t vaccinate her children

[@loki-fy9gl]

Hannah Stahl watch her latest video

[@LivinOnTheEdge1001]

Hey Jen this was such a great video. Honestly it’s so unfortunate that people would think Kat Von D would try to scam people like that. First off it’s illegal to falsely advertise a product. Now I know many people don’t like Kat but she’s a businesswoman and shes definitely not dumb enough to try to scam people buy falsely advertising the volumes of the mini and regular size liner. It would cost her way too much money. Secondly it’s sad that people think that the cartridge would be different just because the mini is a mini and the regular is a regular. Again this is a BUSINESS it would cost way too much money to make two different cartridge so it makes sense that they would add that extra piece of plastic to the mini to take up the extra volume in the cartridge. Like why would they manufacture two separate cartridge it would be such as waste of money. It is so pathetic that people don’t understand these things. What a sad sad world. Anyways great video as always Jen (and husband). Keep up the great work!

[@EgoBrain1]

People love to start controversy these days.

[@makingupaminute600]

Also so classy that you added those other channels that had already posted. I don't subscribe to either of those so would never have seen this without you! Great work and way to stay true.

[@yasssgawwwd5643]

It absorbs the saturated cotton insert via the long insertion piece you initially took out. So you just add more or less liquid to the inside to absorb. 1 ml is 20 drop approximately thus .2 is 4 drops sample and 10-11 drops .55 :) I’m a chemist so I know my liquid and solid measurements:) but I’m sure it can be looked up too:)

[@karimac3251]

Lol that was cute to hear you and your husbands interaction.

[@sweet_ume3902]

IMO this is not a scam.. it's marketing. The amount of product is clearly labeled on the package. We just need better consumerism. Not with just make-up, but also with food. Read your labels people.

[@EgoBrain1]

Yes! Exactly! It's not a scam when the customer is given the information.

[@AlbinoAxolotl]

Absolutely! It's so irritating that people are so shocked to find out information that they've clearly had access to the entire time and then go on outraged rants on the internet. Just because it's the first time someone is seeing how little they're actually getting in a product like this doesn't mean that all of the sudden they're being ripped off. It's sad to see just how effective flashy packaging is at fooling people into thinking they're getting 'better" or "more" and peoples' lack of consumer awareness is degrading the power of our money. It takes literally seconds to see how much of a product you're getting and to calculate a price per unit/volume but instead people are being swayed through a combination of laziness, lack of education, and fancy packaging and marketing.

[@Vandalynn]

I'm convinced half of the commenters didn't even watch the video. They somehow only managed to read the packaging lol

[@nopeninja8883]

Glad you did it also. Just to see how you all do things differently and show the same results:)

[@renzy5270]

$50 for 2mls of liquid. You know what they say about a fool and their money

[@minoena]

The liner is $20 tho

[@qoq5417]

More than $50

[@karengius8064]

She bought the full size and the sample size, together totaling $50.

[@clarissejrsk7314]

@@karengius8064 impossible. Full size = 20$

[@CovertCrow]

.2 ml

[@BlacqRomantic]

Revlon’s liquid liner has always been my go-to and it’s less than $15

[@sarahbragg2322]

Bill Nye photo bomb is everything!!

[@jenluv]

Haha! Love me some Bill!

[@Shannon_Vlogs]

Yesssssss 🙌

[@cassiebrannick6420]

I'm so excited for you to do this :) you're the best Jen

[@amandas3511]

I don't even buy KVD but this was so fascinating and entertaining to watch.

[@drjones6567]

I never wear this but this was super entertaining. I do completely "clean" makeup by Savvy minerals. Which does take a small amount of trial and error to work since it's completely different - no fillers at all. But out of all the makeup I've used over the years, this is hands down the best. No skin or eye irritation and no breakout. Totally amazing. I get complements all the time! Plus you actually see how much product your getting... lol.

[@tamaramorton8812]

Wow. That's that! Claps hands together sideways.👍🏼 Thanks for being so thorough.

[@chrisandmegsmom]

If you think about how much 2 milliliters is, which is the same as 2 ccs in medicine, it's not a lot. Also think about how much of that you'd actually put on your eyes at a time and it would be immeasurable. I think this is just a fact of life for all of us makeup lovers. Any high end eye liners are going to be the same way.

[@glitterchick91]

It's actually 0.2ml in the travel size one and 0.5ml in the full size. So even smaller amounts again!

[@tailorandmakeup2212]

Love that you both (hubby and yourself) have fun together doing these videos. #relationshipgoals

[@marleydeva]

Also here to help send this over a million 🤩

[@sharonpowell2798]

What a great helper seems very supportive and happy to help you.

[@SabbiMG]

Watching this a second time to try and get Jen to one million views ❤

[@RavenSiren]

Not surprised by the results. As much as I dislike Kat Von D and think she is utter trash, I didn't think she was trying to scam customers like that.

[@SamanthaMarchxo]

not sure how I completely missed this but whoa!

[@heidinichole4680]

Some people just want to complain and start drama no matter what! Great video !

[@zmelkian]

That was awesome to see. No wonder sample size doesn't last as long as the full size. It was a great method of finding out what's inside the pencil. Glad to know we are not lied too by KVD.

[@chawndel8279]

Thank you for posting, I don't follow the other two KZbinrs. Plus, I love that you took an actual scientific approach rather than just looking at the cartridges and making an assumption. It's ELF primer all over again. Sigh.. But, it's good to know the truth.

[@CountCrackulaMyWay]

Here to get this to a million views

[@leapinglizardz]

I appreciate the upload!! You just saved me from buying that for the first time. Lol 💕

[@Gremlinbemlim]

Omg. I was literally complaining about this eyeliner a few weeks ago. That I've had much better $10 drugstore liners.

[@samanthashine4506]

Once upon a time I was addicted to buying high-end department store makeup brands: Lancôme, Ultima II, Borghese....then I learned that all of these have drugstore formulas and many of them are as good, maybe better. And generally speaking, I am fairly happy with L'oreal and Revlon and Maybelline shadows and liners. Occasionally I spring for MAC because they always have something fun.

[@Izzy61906]

LMAO exactly...Same!! 👌👌👌👌👌👌

[@myxkm]

Some dupes I found to be nice to try for some people. Kat’s eyeliner is made from Korea, so I tried all these out! *can buy all from ebay* -the yeon -1day tattoo real lasting eyeliner 24H WP -drawing show brush liner from etude house -missha pen liner (have matt effect and bold)

[@romeoa.6634]

Milly Moon Clio kill? eyeliner is noice too

[@RomanicHopeless]

All of a sudden everyone is quality control 😆 oh lord

[@paulabroussard1824]

Why are people so suspicious? Don't they realize there are legal tests to meet for packaging labels?

[@hannahsurbaugh9180]

Paula Broussard the Internet, especially social media, is just come for you madness. Herd mentality it seems.

[@novahanson8020]

Yeah it doesn’t make any sense what a stupid rumour

[@chandlersmith769]

But it’s true. Her products are very mis leading

[@paulabroussard1824]

chandler smith how are they misleading?

[@makeupmomma5503]

🙈🙈🙈I love these kinds of videos but sorta cringe when makeup is destroyed lol

[@samanthanebe9230]

So if you ever pulled apart a maker the ink is in a cotton/sponge like tube with a whole straight in the middle and with a waxy plastic wrapping the tube. It looks like this is constructed very much the same way. So it was VERY helpful that you cracked it open to see how much was actually soaked up in it! Loved the video! Glad to see I'm really getting my money's worth! Thank you!

[@littlereddstar5264]

Jen is like the friend who breaks things down for you so you make informed decisions. I’m going to stick to my Physicians Formula Eye Booster 2-in-1 eyeliner.

[@zaddkiel4458]

People scream scandal without even think about it...

[@veronicaguidos9460]

Reminds me of the Salem witch trials... smh

[@EgoBrain1]

@@veronicaguidos9460 ikr 😄

[@prettyinpink9893]

Lmbo your husbands sentiment “who the hell does this” are my exact thoughts lolol

[@Fixxashley]

When I first bought it, it didn't even least a month

[@courtneywatson255]

Glad to know we’re not being scammed! Thanks for testing!

[@whitneyhatton3736]

Thanks for taking the time to not just look at the canisters but actually the inner liquid.