Is Organ Donation Halal in Islam? | Ask Shaykh YQ #3

[@ahmednoor4451]

May Allah bless u N always guide u Ya Shaikh

[@21972012145525]

As Salam ale kum. I need your prayers...I am currently separated from my husband. The issues between us are big, but not bigger than allah swt. Please pray for me.

[@alishamorgan501]

Sorry for that. May Allah help you through. Pray to Allah a lot and be patient you are not alone. That is the shaytan driving you both to different directions like that. Shaytan is struggling to mislead as many. May Allah protect us from that devil.

[@ethioramble]

Www, how is it now? May Allah make it easy. We plan and Allah also plans, indeed Allah is the best of planners

[@denzelnolet]

Inshallah things have worked out for the best

[@21972012145525]

@@ethioramble we have not reconciled yet. Please pray for me. I’m suffering silently. I need your prayers and the help of Allah swt!

[@21972012145525]

@@denzelnolet we have not reconciled yet. Please pray for me. I’m suffering silently. I need your prayers and the help of Allah swt!

[@paramount842]

Thank you for the clarification. I am now on the organ donar register

[@21972012145525]

While the sheikh provided a lot of useful information, he failed to answer the basic question: should we check “yes” on our driver’s license to organ donation? I believe the answer is no, because the driver’s license does not go into all the details on when/which/how can the organs be donated. I hope the organ donor registrar does clarify these things before you’re able to donate

[@mak.ak.uk.]

@@21972012145525 It's strongly implied by the fact that he said its halal!

[@fagarfield9230]

Useful talk on organ donation. Love & blessings from UK. 😊🙋‍♀️🤚

[@pensivesoul_]

Jazaak Allah Khair Shaykh. May Allah(swt) guide you and reward you for your efforts, aameen. The Ummah needs knowledgeable and rational muslims like you. Alhamdulillah !!!

[@MeeshayT]

Jazak Allah

[@orwellianyoutube8978]

Sometimes they give up on patients who are declared brain dead, but technically they are not death. This can be tricky if you agree to be a donor. They should give the option to be only a donor if the heart stops beating and the longs stop breathing. That is the only time that you can be declared death in Islam.

[@ukhhalalchannel4165]

Assalamualaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh my brother teacher really good knowledge about donating organs may ALLAH SWT bless you and all the people around you and protect you guys and Ummah of Prophet MUHAMMAD peace be upon him IN SHAA ALLAH AMEEN AMEEN AMEEN🕊🕊🕊🕊🕊🕊🕊

[@abdullahlakay8448]

جزاك الله خيرا الشيخ ياسر

[@adibhamdani]

Summary: There are three categories: Clear Halal, Clear Haram and Grey Area. Clear Halal: Donating an organ to another needed for life and stability as long as not giving up life for that person e.g. Writing a will or donating an organ which we can live without. Clear Haram: 1) To sell an organ, including blood 2) To donate for ‘science’ after we die 3) To donate reproductive organ. Grey Area: 1) When there is no clear indication before death, then heirs have to agree. 2) When a person is on the line between life and death. P/S: Autopsy is not allowed except when very necessary

[@MuhammadKhan-kf6fb]

Assalamu alaikum sheikh, if donating bodies for science is not allowed, what about studies in medical schools using cadavers or peoples bodies that have been donated for the purpose of training doctors to understand the human body? Is this also not allowed?

[@purplespark8]

Did you get an answer? I wanted to ask the same thing

[@usufusuf6497]

Clearly explained. I undertsand now👍🏼

[@fathimashanaz4412]

Assalamu alaikkum Jazakallah khair Sheikh

[@tripleagg3072]

3:25 Asalamoalaykum! I'm not sure if this is the right place to ask, but does that mean dissecting animals is haram? Because I do that often in my high school classes. I don't necessarily do it intentionally, but since it's part of a high school requirement does that mean it's OK, if it is haram?

[@Akhan-di1gn]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rZunlnptlJd7hJY

[@jamanoorabuukhalid3311]

It's OK because animals don't have the same rights as humans

[@purplespark8]

Thanks for the clarification... I wanted to ask that if the body cannot be donated to science, how do we get cadavers for students to study?

[@ahussain8581]

Good summary by Sheikh Yasir. Organs removed from truly dead individuals are dead organs and NOT suitable for transplantation. Only living organs are suitable for transplantation and living organs can only be obtained from living people. If the Fiqh Council does not consider brain death to be Islamic death then essential organs cannot be donated becausetheir removal will be the cause of death and that is not permissible in Islam. If you do wish to donate organs do it while you are alive, donate a kidney or part of your liver, after seeking medical advice. If you want to donate when you are truly dead then you can donate your tissues only because your organs will also be dead when you are dead.

[@MohamedAli-rg4xp]

Perfectly Correct

[@yehthashamulhuq5251]

Assalamu alaikum wa rahmathullahi wa barakathahu. U cleared my doubts jazakallah. As a medical student I also had a question "Is it allowed for the family members to decide whether or not to remove the life support of a patient, who is brain dead"

[@venerasejdiu7356]

This is a really good question. Has he answered it? And if not, has any other reputable sheikh answered it?

[@allfusionx]

So it’s ok for us (Muslims) to benefit from research that happens as a result of others (non Muslims) making donations for scientific research but we won’t participate in the deed to benefit others. I think the fiqh council needs to revisit this point.

[@lonnekhalid2395]

He said it pretty clear. If you are dead, you can donate after your death but u should not donate your organs for the sake of money but if someone’s life is in danger and they need an organ you can donate it. For kidney not heart. U don’t kill ur selves to save someone else.

[@terintiaflavius3349]

Ok here is my thoughts: Non Muslims are individuals who do not believe for whatever reason they have. That does not mean that Allah did not create these people, Allah still has love for all people. This is why he accepts them back after for whatever reason they return to belief. So if he also created them then he gave them life and knowledge.

[@crestfire8008]

@@terintiaflavius3349 you just vomited word salad. Nothing you said has any relevance to the main comment

[@4k3el]

If bodies can not be examined for autopsy or for scientific research, how then do doctors understand how the body functions and also if we didnt know how bodies function then transplants won't be possible therefore transplant should be forbidden since you have cut up a dead body anyway. I understand why bodies are not allowed to be mutilated because it is done to disrespect the deceased.

[@naif8731]

Question: If donating the body for medical research isn’t permitted, how would science evolve? Also, muslims and others too enjoy the benefits of medical treatment which perhaps have been developed through research on cadaver.

[@refayatul]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rZOohZaJlshsrMk

[@crestfire8008]

Muslims only like to enjoy the benefits of other's sacrifices. They make no contribution of their own

[@talhaiqbal6798]

Also, what about autopsies when it's required for a criminal investigation? It might not be forced by a government but to solve a crime it may be needed.

[@MyName123.]

isn't it mentioned "breaking the bone of person who died is like breaking it when he's alive"

[@alkauzar6467]

Alhamdulillah

[@nt3825]

ASA is it permissable to do cadeveric dissections for studying? Is it sinnful if we do it for the scope of educating?

[@bigbentraveller]

Glad to see scholars like you... but people like zakir naik are creating Naissance in the name of Islam.

[@fouziashabieh4295]

Alhamdulillah...

[@uploadvoice]

Slm please fix the echo noise !!! For long videos it is really irritative

[@comb528491]

We're working on it

[@comb528491]

The whole masjid system is gonna be updated

[@uploadvoice]

@@comb528491 barrakallahoufikom, you are giving high quality materials, it is so sad to have poor audio quality ... Hoping it will get updated soon.

[@user-sz1kg3eu8e]

What about body donation for medical college for the sake of education purposes for the upcoming young doctors..am I medical doctor...we learnt human anatomy on donated dead bodies..

[@jamanoorabuukhalid3311]

Haram.... This is under the mutilation that the sh. Mentioned Only donate to save a sick patient

[@tamilhitmovies2299]

Use English Caption Please!

[@jashimw04]

I researched it because i wanted to donate my eyes..after death

[@balafied]

Jazak Allah Khairan for the informative video...I want to know the reason for ulama disallowing organ donation based on the argument that our body doesn't belong to us. Can you shed some light on this?

[@Kamadev888]

probably coz they overthink things. you should know that in the 18th-19th centuries there were almost no printing presses in the muslim world coz the 'ulama' considered it forbidden. 'Ulama' are in a good position to make the whole muslim world backwards.

[@balafied]

@@Kamadev888 thanks but this question was not for you but for the noble sheikh...I need an academic reply and not a 'probably' based answer.

[@sash8099]

A dead person feels pain just like a living person.

[@mohammadimran5235]

Assalamu alaykum. Can anyone please inform us of the Qur'an recitor in the intro of this video? Many thanks

[@iftikar3953]

Mohammed mourad

[@iftikar3953]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/q2fJdYmMiph8jK8

[@voiceofreason314]

What about the hadeeth about using warm water to wash the dead because the body feels it?

[@safiyap4085]

Donating sperms must clearly a haram right? Jazakallah Khairan. This was a valid information.

[@21972012145525]

Safiya P dyes, he said reproductive organs

[@paramount842]

Sperm is not a reproductive organ

[@21972012145525]

David Nash yes, sperm is not an organ but donating sperm is probably for many reasons. I’m not an alim or sheikh, which is why I’m saying probably, but it is kind of common sense why it would be....

[@zeeshanmansoor5298]

Dear Imam, A O A, Alhamdulillah we have been taught more of afterlife than all other religions combined. please can you suggest authentic book or research papers regarding afterlife with references to hadees (ie book, number, Hasan,saheeh or dhaeef etc). We pray that Allah guides us all here and in hereafter through our journey. Jazak Allah Khair katheer

[@bodymind195]

What about medical ie health insurance

[@21972012145525]

While the sheikh provided a lot of useful information, he failed to answer the basic question: should we check “yes” on our driver’s license to organ donation? I believe the answer is no, because the driver’s license does not go into all the details on when/which/how can the organs be donated.

[@DKingFisher]

How can we write will about something that DOES NOT BELONG to us? You said it belongs to Allah. I do not get it. I am sorry for disagreeing about the "WILL" part

[@shahanas9732]

Can muslim use donor egg for IVF treatment?

[@SROUMALD]

I want to ask the Sheik a question , how do you become a Dr ? Saleem

[@iali3589]

Good question brother

[@SROUMALD]

@@iali3589 Same to you blind follower

[@iali3589]

Ok mate.

[@iali3589]

your father is blind as he married your mother Edit; MuslimAlways has educated me and i am very sorry my brother.

[@labib8aug]

He got PhD from Yale University brother

[@shanusmuzu5686]

Can animal organ can be accepted ??

[@bawarali6123]

What about mutilation of animals? "For science sake"

[@Akhan-di1gn]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rZunlnptlJd7hJY

[@bodymind195]

Assalam...m a doctor..as far as i know...when an eeg ie electroencephalogram..is unrecordable the person is brain dead and as such there is no grey area in this regard

[@21972012145525]

In my mind, The question is heart failure, brain dead, and lack of consciousness the same or different? I think the answer to that would help develop an appropriate fatwa.

[@bodymind195]

@@21972012145525 insha'Allah will answer. Please give some time

[@OsaidSasi]

So is it haram to donate plasma?

[@hso3insl]

No it isn't.

[@OsaidSasi]

Kadreya Muthana even if I’m getting money for the donation?

[@21972012145525]

Yes. If you are getting$

[@talhaiqbal6798]

I don't understand the logic of you cannot sell your blood because you don't own it. I don't own anything including my iPhone or material posessions so why are those allowed? It is inconsistent.

[@azamsiddiqui7437]

You bought a IPhone you own itm You did not buy blood.

[@aminasmith9341]

So donating your plasma for money is haram?

[@shawol-lwannable6059]

Yes

[@atharsuhail7438]

Only braveli mullahs are against organ donation.

[@abdisamad6762]

They be patient or inpatient it will be same for them brother yasir you do not have to answer this question it's not from hearts of true believers be careful Of people who ask such questions

[@purplestripes4076]

Can't donate to science? So you reap the benefits of medical science and knowledge on the basis of nonmuslims donating to medical students for study. Sounds very selfish.

[@Quaidian]

He did not mention any relevent hadith or reference of Prophet Muhammad S.A.W or a sahabi R.A. Secondly, organ donation and cutting etc in or after a war are two very different topics and cannot be correlateable like he did. Finally, everything he said was based on their own understanding, apprantly as mentionend earlier that there is no solid evidence of donating an organ to a person (muslim/non-muslim). However, on the other hand clearly Prophet Muhammad S.A.W opposes the idea of donating organs to ANYONE and anyone means father, mother, sister, brother, ANYONE...so kindly add some authentic references or remove this video as this may lead someone to imperfect actions w.r.t Islam.

[@taseenmannan1202]

Aslaam Sheikh may I know your name so I can watch your talks? I'm very eager to learn which university did you graduate from

[@symbiotezilla12345]

Taseen Mannan Sh qadhi graduated with an ijaazah in hadeeth from university of madinah. And got his Ph.D from Yale university in Islamic theology

[@atharsuhail7438]

Umer Abdur Rehman Mohammed was not a doctor and at that time there was no science of organ donation.

[@Quaidian]

@@atharsuhail7438 Prophet Muhammad S.A.W was not a doctor and a scientist that is why today science is endorsing many of His (S.A.W) so called philosophies. You should understand this. He was not literate and that is why the world wonders how an illeterate person brings such a big change on the face of the world. It is not the matter of doctor, philosopher, scientist etc etc. It is the matter of faith!

[@taseenmannan1202]

@@Quaidian You said to remove this video. I am asking a basic question, he graduated with ijaazah in hadith from university of madina, also having his PhD from Yale about Islamic theology. May I be so kind to ask what you have? Other than watching these types of videos on Google? The reason why, it's because not everything is explaining by looking at the Qur'an so you have to "interpret" which involves using the Qur'an and hadith both together. For example how is smoking haram? The Qur'an doesn't say smoking is haram nor the hadith? But we know Muhammad saw said all intoxicants are haram especially that harms your body with this substance. He's explaining that inside family members as long as you don't die in the process such as 1 kidney, you're allowed. Or giving blood but you cannot ask for any money since the body parts are not yours. There will never be any direct hadith or Qur'an for specific scientific scenarios such as. "Are we allowed to go into space"? Can you give me an answer to that using just the Qur'an or hadith. Just quote me the hadith. Don't explain it or interpret it now this Sheikh did