Is The Thousand Year Door really THAT great?

[@NostalJackMusic]

I definitely agree with you that changing the series direction was a good idea at the time. I adore the first 2 games, but Super is actually my favorite in the series, Origami King is wonderful in my opinion and even Color Splash is... okay-ish. However, I do think that now, after more than 15 years, it would be really cool and special if they returned to this formula again with all the new ideas they’ve come up with since then. Kind of like how Mario Odyssey returned to the style of 64 and Sunshine. It would be a great moment for long time fans, and they certainly COULD improve at least slightly upon some of TTYD’s aspects. Great video man!! :)

[@danh9676]

Paper mario was an awesome game. The thousand year door is an incredible game.

[@hellomerio]

So weird you only have 6K subs, you make some of the best gaming content out there honestly. Keep it up!

[@EPICfranky]

I've been brought to your channel through the power of nostalgia. Those Chibi Robo review are A1. I wish your channel got more attention. Keep it up !!!!!

[@misterzygarde6431]

Considering the restrictions put on Intelligent Systems regarding Paper Mario nowadays. I think they should make use of obscure characters like the characters from the SNES version of Wario’s Woods, maybe even bring back Jewelry Land from Yoshi’s Safari. Also what would’ve happened if Paper Mario 64 had been called Mario Story across all regions?

[@السراقالمجهول]

then super will be called mario epic story or mario ultimate story

[@misterzygarde6431]

I do think Mario Story: Flipped could work better since it reflects the gameplay better. السراق المجهول

[@السراقالمجهول]

@@misterzygarde6431 oh yeah thats a good name hey imagine if super was an rpg because the game is dying to be one do you have any ideas for the title maybe paper mario the black void or dimension disaster because paper mario isnt a silly adventure like how intelligent systems think it is its actually an epic serious adventure to save the world from a real danger that have nothing to do with paper

[@misterzygarde6431]

I think the fact that it was titlted Super Paper Mario was probably deliberate as a way to disguise the fact that it was such a much more darker adventure than advertised.

[@السراقالمجهول]

@@misterzygarde6431 I though it was titled like that because the game is a platforming game like the old mario titles

[@NolanThunder]

Wonderful video! You've got a future ahead of you dude, keep up the great work!

[@johnnymind4151]

I've just watched the Paper Mario 64 video since I didn't watch it when it first came out, and now I'm here for this one, too! I'll say first of all that I really appreciate how you recognized all of these games' strengths and weak points, it makes for a really good critique of these amazing games and really interesting videos! I still hope that you'll revisit the other games in the future, too, because I'm curious to hear what you have to say about them, especially since you do have memories of playing them before. If there's one thing that I've always loved about the first two Paper Mario games, the fact that they aren't just RPGs, they are a completely distinct kind of RPG: simple, yet complex at the same time. Then we have all the elements that were for the most part all present in Super Paper Mario: epic overarching story, engaging chapter-by-chapter scenarios, partners/allies that assist you in battle, funny script, various interesting NPCs, distinct locations etc. Now, not everything is there in the more recent Paper Mario titles, but a lot of those elements are still there, while some aspects that were underdeveloped in the first three titles now are better, more engaging. All of that is to say that I really love this series overall, every game is worth playing... except for Sticker Stars, not because it's a "bad" game, just because that all the other titles in the series have done it better. I still had fun while playing Sticker Star when it released, but I think it doesn't compare to the others, it doesn't really stand out. I do still wish that they will revisit the original formula in the future, similar to what Bug Fables did (I have yet to play it myself, but I'm looking forward to trying it when I have the chance), because there's still a lot of potential in those core gameplay mechanics. Although, to be completely honest, I'd like a game that mixes all the good things from the previous Paper Mario titles, to try to reach even higher heights than any game before it.

[@hunterwynn3826]

Here's a problem, these games aren't year after year, they only come once per console. It's been 16 years since TTYD and there's still more stuff they can do with this battle system.

[@PsiMiami]

"Vivian is the best partner" Facts

[@richardgdungleman]

Ladies and gentlemen, he's back

[@السراقالمجهول]

7:10 your wish has been granted in the third game

[@oomelette]

hey youtube, i've got someone to recommend for your algorithm.

[@NostalJackMusic]

Yo Vivian is cool and all, but shoutouts to Bobbery and Bobby, bob-ombs just bring it with the emotional moments in this series!

[@madgadgetss]

can't believe you crunched mario D: that was a sweet video!!!

[@professionalspecialist5780]

Bug Fables alone proves there's more to be done with the formula, so I hard disagree that it was smart to abandon this rpg style

[@Mqstodon]

It really doesn't, it's just paper mario but with morr characters and the psrty mechanic is completely different

[@SuperSiege]

@@Mqstodon To be honest, the differences Bug Fables made to the Paper Mario and Mario and Luigi formulas made it almost indistinguishable from those games. The creators really made a unique game, which is why I cringe whenever someone brings it up as a Paper Mario clone, since it is soooooooo much more than that.

[@Danominator]

That calendar joke was great my dude

[@GreatGonzalez]

0:47 guess what happened now

[@anomoly40]

This is an extremely well made video.

[@السراقالمجهول]

6:16 hey this is super intro

[@7sonicmario]

The backtracking wasnt so bad. It had a lot of interesting sidequests. Its about the journey, not the destination.

[@supersonicbro]

Huh, that Mario and Luigi series comparison was a really good point. Maybe this was for the better!

[@السراقالمجهول]

I have a perfect strategy to beat every single boss just charge 4 or 5 times and then use the power bounce and congratulations you have beaten the boss

[@XellosNi]

Randos: We should commend the latest Paper Mario games for trying something different. Jakstalgia: PM: TTYD went for something REALLY different. Me: Oh, nice to hear. But really, it's all the faults you brought up is why I believe they could further polish it up even further in a return to this formula. Jakstalgia: TTYD is practically the highest point this formula could go. Perhaps it was for the best. Me: **in saitama meme tone** okay

[@pippo17173]

Still enjoyable to this very day.

[@darkdoctor1915]

I have that game, I beat it, and Loved it

[@goobersen443]

17:41 yo what a cool name. totally not biased

[@FatalityPWN]

Eyy new vid

[@camilleisabel]

Bug Fables

[@السراقالمجهول]

no alphadream went bankrupt because 1-paper jam was a disappointment and it wasnt the cross over every one expected so it selled badly 2-the last 2 remakes were on a dead console so they selled very badly so if they maked a new game for the switch it will became the highest selling mario rpg yet and also ttyd style can easily be improved bug fables is the best example of that and also its been a very long time since the last game with ttyd style so now its a perfect time to do another game with that style or artless a remake of the first game or a remaster of the second or heck even a trilogy

[@BomberDuck]

Cough.

[@السراقالمجهول]

do you still think that super is a bad one because its NOT

[@supersaloomy]

Color splash> super> origami> 64> ttyd> sticker star

[@prismason]

for me it’s 64 > cs >>> tok > ttyd = ss >>>>>>>>>> spm

[@ForrestFox626]

Someone doesn't like RPGs

[@السراقالمجهول]

@@prismason wow you really think that sticker star widely considered a cursed game is better than super

[@chippotato5647]

Why is Color Splash your favorite, out of the series?

[@supersaloomy]

@@chippotato5647 dang been a while since ive made the comment. 1- it has the best and funniest writing in the entire series. The game doesnt take itself too seriously making the dialogue a constant joy to read. 2-The music is incredibly beautiful, and some of the best in the franchise. 3-great graphics. 4- the map system is fantastic in that it keeps the feeling of progression through worlds by color coding the map, but the way you constantly jump between different terrains keeps the levels feeling fresh, as opposed to say 64, which just shoves all the grass, then all the desert etc. 5-the painting mechanic in the overworld is incredibly satisfying, trying to reach 100% paint in each and every level is something that imo no other pm game has topped. 6-I never found the turn based battle system here bad like many others did. Is it too many taps to do one attack? Maybe. But if i was concerned with stuff like that id be playing a platformer over an rpg! These are just some of the reasons that pop up on my mind after all these years. Im incredibly excited to play through the ttyd and mario rpg remakes! Thank you for your reply!

[@InsigK]

1st