J vs Ben: ULTIMATE Chamber of Secrets Harry Potter TRIVIA Quiz

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

But seriously.. What if the Basilisk was just like... totally misunderstood?

[@coolnerdlll6053]

Maybe the real Basilisk was the friends we made along the way.

[@LoonyTonks]

Maybe the baskilisk is still alive but just left a bead body there,cuz it’s smart

[@ianstratford1914]

It was there since before you were born

[@wonderingcrow1382]

He/she was a good boy/girl

[@mistyb1183]

The basilisk is misunderstood whoever controls the it is the one in power is if Harry controlled it would be nice.

[@sarahstef]

Who else would love to see a round of J v. Ben called "Magical or British?"

[@ShirleyLestrade]

Ohh yes!! Would be amazing

[@meganprasher6215]

Mee that would be so cool

[@MoonlightTiger]

Yessss

[@sq2678]

Hilarious 😂

[@prestonochsenhirt1246]

Yeah!

[@danlaarry2582]

‘Pudding just means dessert’ - J after writing something that most certainly is not a dessert

[@brice2597]

What would you call the American pudding because now I’m actually curious

[@danlaarry2582]

@@brice2597 as far as I know Brice we don’t really have the American pudding. We have like chocolate mousses and different types of yoghurt but I guess everything that falls in that bracket of being a sweet treat in a little plastic pot would just be a different type of yoghurt

[@Ranger1812]

@@danlaarry2582 Custard?

[@419malice]

@@danlaarry2582 We do have the american style pudding, funnily enough it's called dessert.

[@Cheddar-the-Chaos-Editor]

Yeah 😂

[@jakintalbot8298]

A Yorkshire pudding is basically a fluffy on the inside crisp on the outside pancake that goes with a roast dinner - As a brit I can confirm that they are absolutely delicious!

[@wulfie13snr]

From Yorkshire, can confirm the above, and also that cold, with a bit of jam, they work as a dessert (Think of it as a lighter version of the old suet puddings)

[@delikatessbruhe9843]

But seriously, what do you call pudding, as in the gooey kind, then to clarify what you're talking about?

[@wulfie13snr]

@@delikatessbruhe9843 Unless it's mousse (Which I highly doubt, given the description), no clue, never had it

[@jakintalbot8298]

@@delikatessbruhe9843 It depends on the flavour (in England pudding literally means desert) I guess our angel delight is the same as what Americans call pudding.

[@AuntyAwesome]

@@delikatessbruhe9843 in my country we have a mix of UK and American vocab and can use pudding or dessert interchangeably for the after dinner sweet food, depending on what the family prefers I guess, you can buy sachets of what looks like American pudding, and the packet says instant desserts. They don't really have a mainstream name - they aren't that common as far as I'm aware and pudding/dessert are too broad descriptions to be used for just those.

[@commandermercury6654]

“Kat, don’t be ridiculous. Gilderoy Lockhart’s not even a house-elf.” I laughed so much harder at that comment than I should have! 😂

[@NATER-TAINMENT]

😂

[@Joseph_Roffey]

I think part of the reason for your guys’ confusion around the Moaning Myrtle bathroom is that I’m fairly sure they go “up” to the first floor at various points, because in the UK 1st floor means US 2nd floor and in the UK what you call the 1st floor is usually referred to as the “Ground floor” (where the Great hall/Entrance hall are)

[@HoneyMike]

They did say third floor though so they still would've been wrong

[@Joseph_Roffey]

@@HoneyMike yeh, just some of their comments when they heard it was 1st floor sounded to me like they thought it was on the ground. 😅

[@arion1633]

@@HoneyMike And J did say he thought about between 2nd and 3rd floor. And I totally forgot that. I've read and heard about UK version of the floors, but I'm neither from UK nor from US and for me 1st floor gives at first the vibe that we're on ground floor.

[@ashleythompson8530]

Not exactly true. When Harry hears the Basilisk, they are in the entrance hall. Then it says they go to the first floor. Then it says they go "up" the next flight of stairs. Page 138 in the hardback copy of Chamber of Secrets.

[@Joseph_Roffey]

@@ashleythompson8530 I mean that’s some dedication 😅 Thank you for re-reading a book just for me 👉🥹👈

[@Triple_Y_turn]

I just love the "pretty obvious" running gag. I catch myself saying it in my everyday life sometimes

[@maia.papaya]

I wonder how their version of “if Harry was in gryffindor” would be if Harry was actually in slytherin

[@chrisrogers1898]

Mind bending comment

[@ShirleyLestrade]

🤯

[@meganprasher6215]

I never thought abused that🤯

[@MasterCrander]

_If Harry Potter was in Slytherin What If Harry was in Gryffindor Harry Potter Theory vs Ben_ (Part 2)

[@JuanMataCFC]

" ... but that, is another story!"

[@jamespottersgf]

I like to think that when they say "Hey Brother! " together they are talking to Tyler!

[@GubbiGap]

We need a custom quiz made to ask questions about the "If Harry Potter was in Slytherin" series xD

[@annaking6877]

Question three was so painfully hilarious as British person. The second J put down “Yorkshire pudding” on the note pad I was like “awe bless you sweetie. You have no idea 😂

[@brice2597]

What would you call the American pudding because now I’m actually curious

[@annaking6877]

It’s moose babe 😂 basically like yogurt but thicker. It’s nasty 😂

[@thirdcoastfirebird]

Welcome to being a fanfiction writer gentlemen. That is our day to day. Juggling actual canon with our own. And why I reread HP.... dang it.

[@Mooinator3000]

As a brit, seeing J put Yorkshire Pudding as a pudding.. it hurt.. it really hurt

[@Ruddigore]

Yep, thank goodness he is unaware of steak and kidney pudding.

[@AllTheArtsy]

yeah it was painful lol

[@MattModify]

i was shouting at the screen " but its not even a pudding" hahaa

[@sierrabokoskie8374]

I'm not a Brit but I watch a lot of cooking things and I definitely chuckled as he simultaneously wrote Yorkshire pudding and described a British pudding as being a generic word for dessert. 😂

[@slingshotwaffles]

I’m sorry for your loss

[@EmilyCheetham]

Yorkshire pudding is most definitely savoury. It’s usually served with roast meat or sausage. There is a sausage & Yorkshire pudding dish called toad in the hole as the sausages are served inside the Yorkshire pudding. But Christmas pudding is definitely a sweet item. It’s a fruit cake that is cooked in a pressure cooker and often soaked in brandy or certain other spirits.

[@brice2597]

What would you call the American pudding because now I’m actually curious

[@EmilyCheetham]

@@brice2597 in uk what Americans call pudding we call Angel delight. Or that’s the main brand here in uk. I used to like the chocolate and sometimes the strawberry flavour when I was a kid. We have to make ours up at home you can’t really find it pre-made here in uk.

[@lewis1423]

i love the idea that nearly headless nick was subject to a witch trial beheading at hogwarts because he was so bad at dentistry

[@riluna3695]

Little known fact: Inigo Montoya enjoyed his dinners far more than his desserts. "Don't bother me with Trifles. There will be _Blood Sausages_ tonight!"

[@DavidRay_40]

Without the sausage part.

[@thechampion2430]

Love your vs. videos! Literally everytime I need to renew my Harry Potter knowledge, I just binge watch these.

[@andrewbuik1915]

I appreciate the thanks guys. Hopefully next time I can give questions both of you can’t answer 😊

[@stuffingtonjfluffypantsiii]

Something tells me if Hermione grew up in wizarding world prior to getting into Hogwarts she'd hero worship Dumbledore

[@Narmatonia]

My idea is that the 'Mad Muggle' keeps witnessing witches and wizards do magic, but he's the only one, and none of the other muggles believe him when he tries to tell them. Each issue ends with his fellow muggles saying "You're mad, Martin Miggs", while wizards laugh and cavort in the background.

[@balbert24]

Just got out of brain surgery and this is so so awesome to come out of and watch as one of my first videos on KZbin to be able to watch since the surgery. You guys really rock and the best part is I just finished chamber of secrets while recovering. This is awesome guys

[@derpyderp8559]

I loved the Harry Potter in Slytherin series lol and I love hearing these two geeks going at it together 🤣🤣

[@meganprasher6215]

Mee too❤

[@AuthorZaraHoffman]

J normally knows the "fresh pickled toad" and Ben is normally the one who just says "toad"! OMG

[@markbrown2640]

You guys could do a "Breakfast with Banshees" special with Kendall and Alvin from the Babbish Culinary Universe.

[@bethnicholson1788]

Only if they try a Yorkshire pudding 🤣

[@stephaniebarney]

Oooo

[@mjpete27]

Hullo Brothers, I am quite a new subscriber and I am truly glad that you are continuing to share Harry Potter quizzes! I have been enjoying the backlog of videos and just wanted to say BRAVO! Well done. Thank you. I am looking forward to discovering more of the content on your channel.

[@inawoodenhouse]

Just wanted to point out that Rachel is the one who made the trifle, Joey is the only one who liked it 🤣

[@pizzadohpaz]

Yes, clearly we need a Friend's trivia video...😂

[@guywood4955]

I came here to say this, thank you! Triffle with beef! xD

[@JE_Johnsn]

Thank you so much

[@MikeDCWeld]

What wasn't to like? Custard? ... good. Jam? ... good. Meat? ... GOOOOD!

[@annaoffive]

Rachel: I wasn’t suppose to put meat in the trifle!

[@prastarkeepers]

12:34 I would honestly be more inclined to think it’s the axe the Bloody Baron used to kill Helena, and it was hid in there by him out of shame or by Rowena out of remorse.

[@MordechaiHershoffyoutube]

He used a knife

[@corgimom5626]

When I was a child I was always convinced my socks were on the wrong feet 😂😂😂

[@pinicius]

Was there ever an "all quizmaster questions" JvB, no specific theme? I feel it would be the ultimate JvB ever.

[@Triple_Y_turn]

There actually was one like two years ago. I think it's called something like 'hardest trivia quiz - quizmaster edition'.

[@JustTommyBoy]

I love how every quiz goes: Question 1: give me any answer that has anything to do with Harry Potter. Question 2: give me the same answer you put for Question 1. And now for the first Patreon QuizMaster question of the game! Question: On page 74 of Chamber of Secrets, the 17th word is "he". Describe Harry's GPS coordinates in longitude and latitude exactly 9 pages after the word "he"

[@zachrichins2313]

I mever laughed so hard when Ben said the article about intelligence and then have gilderoy say who am I after was the best 😂😂😂

[@TheRibottoStudios]

That series was really good, but I do wish you had put a bit more emphasis on what Harry's relationship with Snape would've been like. After all, true he doesn't have MUCH of a relationship with Minerva, but it's clear she does care about the boy. "Potter....it's good to see you." is more than enough proof of that. With moments of Harry needing someone to confide in during the whole Chamber of Secrets fiasco, I think Snape would've been a rather nice and interesting choice. I think the reason why Severitus and *Harry in Slytherin!* fics are so popular is there is that HUGE curiosity of "what if these two god dang idiots could just see past their prejudice of each other?" Would've been very interesting indeed. I would love to see y'all do more AU stories though, like maybe dive into Star Wars again like you did back in the day and have a whole "what if Anakin won against Obi-Wan?" or "What if Ahsoka didn't leave?" that would be interesting too.

[@ErikBjornSmith]

The Yorkshire Pudding bit made me chuckle. Its not a desert, but is a pastry item made with flour, egg and milk that we cook in the oven and have with meals like roast chicken.

[@marthashepley]

Here’s your friendly brit to explain the complicated use of the word pudding in Britain: You’re right, it is used for any dessert, so you might say “what’s for pudding?” after a meal, however if someone were to describe something as “a pudding” it would typically mean something closer to the American meaning, rather than just anything sweet. Yorkshire pudding: a savoury doughy thing that you would typically have with a Sunday roast (i.e. roast chicken, roast potatoes, gravy etc.) absolutely delicious. Black pudding: this is the “blood sausage” you were talking about. This is had with a full English breakfast (hash browns, BEANS, sausages, bacon, whatever really), made of blood, kind of disgusting if you think about it but actually tastes pretty good! Christmas pudding: sweet but not goopy, it’s got like dried fruit in it and there’s a weird tradition of putting a coin in it and covering it in brandy and then setting fire to it before serving it, bit strange and not a huge amount of people actually like the taste of it, but the coin fire thing is fun for Christmas Day

[@oliviamccormick3586]

I love how you guys are doing tests on each book. I’m here for it

[@Astralkidd0]

after school i really needed this !

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

enjoy!

[@sirboats6620]

just a quick note on how we count floors in the UK, we count the Ground floor as 0 not 1st so if you are trying to find a floor in a building in the UK you would count Ground ,1st, 2nd, 3rd etc

[@SgtSupaman]

So the 3rd floor corridor was actually on the 4th floor then? That really was a long way for them to fall...

[@Egg_Sandwich1]

Ben repeating lines during the honey ad read was one of the funniest things I’ve seen

[@bunnywifalaptop3684]

Chamber of Secrets is probably my favorite, but it's mainly the basilisk, it totally carried

[@johnyshadow]

I had it tied as the worst book (with Order) when I was younger, for that reason. Basilisk. (And it didn´t help that the translated name was much creepier.) Mild case of snake-phobia (and spiders), or I was just too young for all the creepy stuff. (Which is weird to say about a children's book, lol.) I did grow to appreciate it a bit more, though I still speed through the *whisper* parts.

[@bunnywifalaptop3684]

@@johnyshadow That's understandable, especially with the phobia. Everyone has different tastes and i can respect that, which is your favorite rn?

[@johnyshadow]

@@bunnywifalaptop3684 I think Azkaban is pretty solid up there, helped a lot by the movie. But I like beginnings (and nostalgia), so I more often return to just quickly read through Philosopher´s Stone. (Side note, I actually really enjoyed Order as a movie, but the book, especially the start/trial dragged on for too long for me.) Edit: Funny thing I should mention concerning snakes. Pottermore insists on me being Slytherin. XD

[@bunnywifalaptop3684]

@@johnyshadow Ooh, good choice, Azkaban is really fun and a good introduction to the more cruel parts of the wizarding world

[@hagarr8404]

The trifle that RACHEL makes in friends

[@victoriatowell2979]

Me an English person dying at the Yorkshire pudding answer (that goes on a roast). You mean black pudding (that goes on a fry up/breakfast) and what you call pudding I guess we call chocolate mousse but it’s not common here! Happy to help with any culinary questions! From the real Towell section ❤

[@IslandpferdeHaukagil]

No chocolate mousse is even different, made with whipped eggs and whipped cream. The pudding they refer to is milk and chocolate heated up with starch to make it a creamy paste, but eaten after it cooled down.

[@victoriatowell2979]

@@IslandpferdeHaukagil oh right, I didn’t know what it was made of just looked at the picture. Is it more like custard then would you say?

[@IslandpferdeHaukagil]

@@victoriatowell2979 yes, I think it's called custard.

[@thephonegamespecialist6883]

11:11 The British eat Yorkshire pudding with roast dinner.

[@rhodryaddis9477]

Does anyone else absolutely love the scenic route? Like, I know they're ads for things I already use, but I love the bit

[@jordywalnut1336]

Saying pudding means dessert then writing Yorkshire pudding almost killed me😂

[@brice2597]

What would you call the American pudding because now I’m actually curious

[@alexroberts771]

Yorkshire pudding has the same recipe as pancake mix, but rather than cooking in a frying pan, it is cooked in hot oil in an oven so that they rise and are fluffy. They can be enjoyed as part of a sweet or savoury dish but are mostly enjoyed as part of a roast meal, traditionally beef

[@ugly-duckling123]

23:48 In Britain (and possibly the rest of Europe) what we call the First Floor is your (American's) Second Floor E A Ground Floor First Floor First Floor Second Floor Second Floor Third Floor etc...

[@imsonotsophisticated]

We call blood sausage 'Black pudding' 😆 and yeh Yorkshire puddings are a staple of a British roast dinner, like a savoury pancake batter but it rises to make little (or sometimes not so little!) pastry bowls.

[@rhodryaddis9477]

Loved the "who's line is it anyway" reference at 24:17

[@randomperson2777]

Every time I watch one of these, I can’t help but wonder… do the people who make these quizzes watch their videos? Because I’m sure those at Pottermore have at least *heard* of them at this point, but I’d like to believe that they watch these once they’re done making the quizzes or something lol, even if it’s just wishful thinking.

[@HoneyMike]

Really interesting thing about the 11th question, the haunted bathroom is on the first floor but it's not the ground floor. In the US the first floor and the ground floor are the same but in the UK the first floor is the one above the ground floor. So i was thinking it was on the second floor because i knew it was on the floor above the Entrance Hall. I knew which floor it was on but i got it wrong because we call that the second floor in America.

[@andrewpickett722]

My names Andrew! Thanks for the shout out during the first quiz master question 🤣🤣 was that a mistake that was dubbed over for Samuel and Dola? Lol

[@doctorwhat21]

Thats what I thought and also it is my Dads Name

[@lindleahuttar3763]

I was so happy to see J write down 1942 at first before he realized that he flipped the 4 and the 9! I do the same thing all the time🤣

[@lanrehaliax2942]

I’m fairly sure Myrtle’s bathroom was on the second floor. The first floor’s one was where Hermione was attacked by the troll in TPS

[@bradi.fayth.nails1]

I was looking for this comment

[@kazoohero93]

Ironically, the blood sausage in an English breakfast is called “black pudding”

[@thephonegamespecialist6883]

09:46 We call it chocolate mousse 😊

[@HeyLookWatchMe]

Love the whose line reference. “The stairs are made up and the classes don’t matter; That’s right, the classes are like Voldemorts party planning skills.”

[@benwillis5840]

Yorkshire puddings are traditionally served with roast beef and gravy (UK gravy is different from American gravy). Toad in the hole is a dish which is basically sausages in Yorkshire pudding and is one of my favourite comfort foods.

[@dustintirey6122]

You guys timed the iPad turn on question 4 perfectly. Good ol' Salazar!

[@kayleighkimberley7783]

i think the closest thing we have in the UK to "pudding" is angel delight/ custard. (Seriously Butterscotch and chocolate angel delight mixed is yum) as for Yorkshire puds. they were originally served as a starter/ first course to "fill you up" although i have heard of people eating them with Jam or putting stewed fruit in as a desert

[@mettedevos2743]

I really love your video's can you make another what if series

[@morrigankasa570]

I want them to do a full series of "What if Dudley was a Wizard".

[@mettedevos2743]

@@morrigankasa570 good one

[@AdrianChazz]

Fun fact: the title has been translated for spanish speaking audiences both as _“HP and the Chamber of Secrets” (HP y la Cámara de los Secretos)_ and _“HP and the Secret Chamber” (HP y la Cámara Secreta)_ So common that at this point both sound good to me (in spanish, of course… In English there’s only one correct answer) Saludos desde México, hermanos! 🇲🇽

[@shades9723]

The carlin brothers need to do play throughs in the new Harry Potter game!! 🔥

[@fan_girl_2103]

Rachel makes the trifle in Friends. Joey thinks it’s delicious and Ross says “It taste like feet” 11:11

[@vallentinac9513]

I was looking for this comment.

[@JordanLove593]

The Banshee Lockhart book is called Break with a Banshee

[@izzysmith105]

J writing Yorkshire Pudding for an actual pudding: Brits: 🤣🤣🤣 At least I was

[@wolfiezzgaming7045]

Oooh I love the "Whose line is it anyway" reference 😂😂😂

[@AlixSam97]

I'm British so watching J write yorkshire pudding as a dessert was low-key hilarious. 😂😂

[@brice2597]

What would you call the American pudding because now I’m actually curious

[@ThePrincessSabrina]

What cookbook would Seamus Finnagon never order? Breakfast with a Banchee.

[@mellow3995]

I might be wrong but I'm pretty sure the closest thing to American pudding we have here in the UK is Angel Delight. Also Yorkshire puddings are amazing and a total must for any Sunday dinner.

[@RyanHaney55]

It's called custard in England, like Doctor Who had fish fingers and custard, but it looked exactly like fish sticks and vanilla pudding.

[@mellow3995]

@@RyanHaney55 Oh that's embarrassing, I'm literally from England and I completely forgot custard was a thing. I'm kinda shocked that's what pudding is (in America) cause custard is really gross by itself. Normally you eat custard with other desserts like apple crumble, fig rolls and fish fingers of course.

[@RyanHaney55]

@@mellow3995 I wouldn't have known about the custard thing if it wasn't for the 11th Doctor, but I knew better than J that it wasn't Yorkshire pudding. Hahaha😄

[@JennyThePlatypus]

Isn’t the book technically called “Harry Potter and The Chamber Of Secrets”

[@Doomzdeh]

The one reason why I don’t believe that Nearly Headless Nick was beheaded at the castle is that I doubt he would’ve stuck around the school hanging around with his murderers. But idk. I guess Moaning Myrtle did the same thing in hindsight. Also, wouldn’t Nick have been a grownup when he was beheaded? And a man with the title of Sir? Maybe he was a professor who was killed by his students? And maybe he made up the Sir title just to be petty.

[@mingusclark400]

Yorkshire Pudding is not a desert, it is a side usually served with Roast Beef. They are kind of like large Batter Dumplings, which are savoury

[@VenomCobrah]

28:10 that gave me "In first place Slytherin house" "Gryffindor wins the house cup" vibes

[@cassecorrea]

I can’t wait to join Drawtober though! Perfect as an artist and SCB fan !!

[@zakhm05]

You should make it a staple of these trivia. Try to guess answers before it comes up. Brownie points awarded

[@stephenlloyd4670]

Hey Brother!!!!

[@mod1954]

Hey brother

[@viniciuspego94]

Great Job J! 🥳 Stay Strong Ben, we're with you!

[@Angryoyster]

My hand writing is so bad that one time I had someone ask me if I was “writing in short hand”. I was very much not writing in short hand, I was also trying my very best to print neatly.

[@JMHoyle]

Hey Brother! You guys talked about having a Founders series in the future and while I’m not a professional writer currently, I’m actually earning my degree in TV production and a goal of mine is to make a Founders series. Who knows maybe it’ll happen and you guys could cameo😉. I love you guys so much and you’ve gotten me through rough times, so keep on keeping on.

[@stephaniebachman397]

My cats name is literally "Dobbert" as the formal version (head cannon) of Dobby. 😆 🤣 🤣

[@LifeInspection448]

The Mad Muggle comic probably mirrors Kowalski's adventures with Newt.

[@zimonzieclown1633]

28:49 Someone actually recreated that scene in Lego; that's awesome!

[@Orvos-]

Do a “what if Neville Longbottom was the chosen one” or what if Voldemort thought Neville was.

[@judydalton3812]

thank you again! thesequizzes make my day every time!!!

[@Jan_Koopman]

About the Basilisk, you know what they say: A pet is only as good/bad as its owner.

[@FulcanMal]

Morag is the planet where Peter Quill gets the Power Stone in Guardians of the Galaxy.

[@traylorc.3653]

Nobody: Ben's handwriting: Solc7cr Slytherin

[@weshouldgooutmore1684]

a Yorkshire pudding is very a savoury thing and is very unusual to have it for dessert.

[@alicialimon9103]

I have to wash the dishes and was like ughhh but this is gonna make it so much easier lol

[@tomhubbard8510]

24:14. Wrong. It is not the 1st floor... it is the ground floor!!! FOR WE ARE IN BRITAIN, YOU NAVE!!

[@charmedforlife165]

Yorkshire pudding is usually a part of roast dinners like the ones we have on Christmas day and most Sundays that spring,autumn, and winter.

[@DavidRay_40]

14:48 - that image would be impossible irl, since the sun has to be behind you in order for rainbows to be seen.

[@LoonyTonks]

YASS one with my favorite book

[@avoidmyrage2596]

Binging the quizzes and bam, 17 minutes ago a new one!

[@davidstears7037]

Yorkshire pudding is typically savoury. Most common used standalone with a roast dinner on sunday, or the main ingredient and giant version used in Toad in the Hole. It's a very popular item in the UK.

[@stecky87]

I started laughing when J put down yorkshire pudding is usually savory, not sweet

[@Los_BreadstickMartian]

Yorkshire pudding is DELCIOUS, but you are right it is much more savory. Generally you'd have like gravy to put in the center of it.

[@fatthorstumtum6593]

08:20 that would be a great next video series!

[@Esterferreiradecastro]

You guys should definitely be more active on this “making a marauders series”, like send your resumes to warner, build a proposal of what the show would be etc Cause i trust you guys would make something awesome

[@BelbyB]

Yorkshire Pudding- "You Can Taste The Yorkshire!"