Jack's REAL Father? Red Dead Redemption Cast React to Fan Theories 10 Years On | MCM Presents

[@Literallyryangosling777]

Dutch isn't jack father because jack wasn't planned and dutch always has a plan

[@eliseo5416]

Lol this was good.

[@Murdokk00]

Checkmate, flatearthers

[@MAKG-kd3sn]

The thing is his plans don't work out

[@anthonybatuello6153]

Guess not a plan b...

[@ultrafire5330]

Abigail, I got a plan

[@alperenerol1852]

Fans: We insist on a dlc. R*: they InSiSt...

[@oflippert]

It's almost like they don't want to make a DLC just out of spite. They know that the fans want one SO badly. It just doesn't make any sense why they wouldn't, especially since RDO is a fantastic failure.

[@krunkler1185]

oflippert For real! It’s honestly sad because even as much of a colossal failure that RDO is, people still spend a lot of money on it.

[@donwright6056]

@@oflippert they won't make a story DLC because the old rockstar is dead hopefully we'll still get a story campaign for GTA 6.

[@HansBjorgman]

Yeah, even the actors in RDR/RDR2 want a DLC! Rockstar is disappointing sometimes...

[@robz3017]

8 years of development and y’all want more lol I want some too but damn they gave us a lot of content

[@oronk60]

Damn, John Marston really is just Rob. That's so cool how he doesn't change his voice at all. He just is him. Dude's a living legend.

[@curiousmind_]

I have heard this a million times

[@whodatninja439]

plus he's a family man and works in farming, sorta

[@arandompasserby7940]

I love Roger Clark as Arthur Morgan, and in many ways, I think he's a far more fleshed out protagonist - but there's something about Rob's humble, down-to-earth personality and his natural accent that will make me always have a special place in my heart for his character, and I particularly enjoyed that they brought him back (along with Ben and the others) for RDR2

[@whodatninja439]

@@arandompasserby7940 if John got a new voice actor, there wouldve been riots in the streets lol

[@Ben59910]

@Exotic Films not so much with Arthur

[@keirand4606]

Jack's real father was gavin that's why he ran away

[@austinsherrer]

GAAAVVVIIIIIIIINNNN!?!?!?

[@Cam_23554]

lUmBaGo

[@somedudefromapharmacy]

WhErE’S mY MonEH BoAh

[@AKAGubin]

he's not my son

[@majima8173]

How are you here I thought I killed you

[@Growmetheus]

“Hey pa wanna play swords?” “What did you call me? Later: “Hey son wanna go hunt?” “No, sir.”

[@OneandonlyKiwi]

that disappointed me

[@peakyswan7719]

Just realized that Dutch is sitting with AirPods in his ears. The man had money all along

[@saadkhalid7734]

His mango business is making him gold.

[@Eazy-V]

I'm dying hahaha

[@a-cxnt]

airpods costs around $150, more or less, in today's money. $150 in 1899 would be around $4,634. in conclusion, dutch do be kinda rich doe

[@jadeschmidt2891]

He had money but not a plan? Hmmm 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔

[@treenalll]

MUNEH

[@stars111535]

Arthur's voice actor is the only one that doesn't sound like him normally lol

[@Luca_Talis]

@A.A.Ron Davis Arthur has British/Welsh ancestory which is interesting

[@jambamram8441]

Landon Ricketts you learn something new everyday

[@Luca_Talis]

@@jambamram8441 I loved his character even more after I learned that

[@xvxvcaspervxvx]

You mean his mo-cap actor or just simply; his actor! Roger didn't just stand in a sound booth and read from a script.

[@carteljameson8395]

Voice acting isn't necessarily about having different accents. That can be a creative choice but it's not the end all be all to voice acting. It's about emoting and line readings.

[@AES9519]

The fact that Dutch’s voice actor is such a big fan of the game makes me so happy

[@Crusade11722]

100% the game and everything lol, I thought they were all just entertaining it like they play it. Dutch definitely does

[@buckeyezak89]

That's what happens when you follow the goddamn plan!

[@bobbyk8690]

Rockstar might have paid them to say these things idk, I find it hard to believe these old men have enough time to play the game fully in depth

[@cienega7139]

@@bobbyk8690 I think they get payed to play the game tho. They for sure have to know the lore

[@anantmohan1769]

@@bobbyk8690 i know but i guess they all are passionate about it. I mean given the fact that they devoted atleast 5 years of their lives for this project. It seems to me that after all that they are really passionate about the game and enjoy it as well

[@luizmarinho6138]

I find it really cool that Rob didn't want to be an actor anymore, but he still came back just for John.

[@finncoppack]

Loki: I have an army Tony: We have hulk Dutch: I have a plan

[@josueayala1707]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/moLaZapvjMyLmbM

[@SkyBlu554]

@@josueayala1707 I have memorized the link, you can’t fool me

[@davidsibley2025]

Lol

[@faizaan_787]

@@SkyBlu554 Is it a rick roll?

[@alvinbjerke6080]

Lol xd lol

[@dra6ke]

Imagine being in a restaurant and hearing John Marston's voice actor ordering a burger. *new bucket list item*

[@jakholl]

"can I get a mcdouble and a large fry? No water please."

[@KingTay-xg4mi]

The cashier all like can we speed this up

[@mase5995]

How about hearing Dutch’s voice actor ordering?

[@TheSpiderTre]

**walks into restaurant** "HEY MISTER"

[@oleanderkazzy_]

"Can I get some food?" Or "Let me try the Big Mac"

[@sirstashalot7441]

Robs hat is a perfect mixture of John's and Arthur's

[@rusteddenial453]

he has such a crazy voice they all do tbh

[@MausOfTheHouse]

I prefer john's. The brim was too tall for me on arhtur's hat. John's hat is classic.

[@davidaltass1740]

THE MUSTACHE ON YOUR PROFILE PIC

[@gabrielt.c]

Your mustache is amazing!

[@theoutsiderjess1869]

@@MausOfTheHouse I prefer wearing Arthur's hat on John

[@bluemarais2897]

Seeing Rob have a mental breakdown about Jack is amazing

[@BanishedSilentShadow3318]

Its like he's thinking "idk who came up with such idea but I'm gonna find this person, laso them up and take them to the train tracks"

[@ToDamnRight]

Roger just running wild with it

[@prolongedfart]

dude went through all the stages of grief in seconds

[@lukewc533]

Jack’s resemblance to John in the epilogue of RDR1 is almost identical. He is definitely John’s son

[@nicholasroberts7891]

I think he looks like Dutch. The eye shape is identical, the nose as well. He also has a passion for books, well there's only one other Character in red dead that shares his same passion. Arthur states in rdr2 that Jack doesn't look like John. The only part that resembles John is the hairstyle.

[@nicholasroberts7891]

@Keknov Arthur actually does not and has a random convo with John in chapter 2 telling John that Jack doesnt look anything like him

[@MerelvandenHurk]

I agree. I get why people see the resemblance to Javier though, but it's just the facial hair. I get it because facial hair is such a prominent feature on one's face, but it's also highly variable and dependent on how you grow it or shave it. I prefer to look at features that cannot be altered in that way, like the shape and position of the eyebrows and the eyes etc. Javier has kind of small, deep-set eyes with "lazy" eyelids in a sense, while Jack shares John's low-set brow that looks like it's just set to angry by default.

[@popupheadlights]

​@MerelvandenHurk they indeed do have very similar browlines as well as a similar shaped nose, jack resembles john more then anyone in camp at least

[@gentlemanpleasant7335]

They all sound a little sad when they talk about undead nightmare not happening it makes my heart break a little

[@drumbeard]

They would really love to do it but Take Two and Rockstar pulled the plug on single player expansions (There were meant to be such for GTA V until they noticed how much money GTAO is making)

[@avahumphries4571]

Ikr? All the actors have said that they would happily come back and make a dlc. Rockstar just wants the money :(

[@scarecrowjones1]

i thought they sounded hopeful-ish

[@vhscopyofseinfeld]

@@drumbeard the fucking online gaming sucks too. There’s no depth to RDRO or GTAO

[@drumbeard]

@@vhscopyofseinfeld I wholeheartedly agree

[@carbruck7395]

Roger and ben: “jack isnt johns son” Rob: “😐”

[@ISCA510]

😐

[@jonah.serrato]

😐

[@nbgyguy]

😐

[@theultimatehorselover1954]

Man, his reaction is *Priceless* XD

[@MysteriousGambler2007]

😐

[@OguzGaming]

I love how RDR 2 is almost 2 years old but the Cast is still sooooo active 😍🔥

[@Erakelus]

So if somebody was born 2 years ago means that he isn't active?

[@OguzGaming]

@@Erakelus you didnt get the point 😂

[@Erakelus]

@@OguzGaming i didn't.

[@gibraltar2843]

Fialovej Biftek I think what he’s trying to say is that most people just stop interacting with fans and stuff for the most part after the game has been out for this long. I mean, most of the actors in games like COD or something don’t even do stuff like this. So it’s kinda cool that they take time out of their day to interact with fans and discuss fan theories even though they get nothing out of it.

[@hpkurdo9144]

Maybe they are working on undead nightmare 2🤔

[@Zeroshiki]

Whether biological or not, John was Jack's father.

[@Eazy-V]

true ;)

[@ItalianoAMG]

Ayyyy a wholesome comment ❤️

[@Idk-mp6fn]

Hold on " was " . I only played rdr2 but i don't like where this is going

[@Eazy-V]

@@Idk-mp6fn lol

[@Idk-mp6fn]

@@Eazy-V i'm missing a few pieces but i also don't wanna search it up since it may spoil rdr1 for me. Like idk if was a nice peacefull death or one like Spoiler for rdr2 Or one like arthurs. Sick and weak.

[@yep8109]

Someone make a petition for a single player DLC rn

[@freddirak3033]

Sounds like a plan Dutch.

[@logans2976]

Okay Dutch

[@keknov5555]

Please. I think the actors would love to do a dlc especially considering how much they loved the game

[@kingragnarlothbrok275]

Thats your plan dutch?

[@chief5604]

Nope even if a quitillion people signed in we all know rockstarwill still dont care and not listen

[@racingfuel28]

Fans: “When do we get more DLC?” Rockstar: “I hAvE a pLAn!?!?”

[@burnthetrolls5971]

Yeh that plan is called Milking GTA V until the end of time

[@Veijo33]

@@burnthetrolls5971 Have some goddamn FAITH

[@blacksoul8054]

All we need is the last big score and get the hell out of here

[@OCanalDeVideoGames]

@@blacksoul8054 and be loyal to rockstar club

[@thegreenwizard688]

A tahiti dlc

[@lexgaming3550]

TFW even the actors want singleplayer DLC but Rockstar STILL won't give it to us...

[@zacheryhallett8302]

@Lec Gaminy honestly tho like the actors have said they would all come back happily if they were working on a new dlc everyone wants it from the fans to the actors I feel rockstar isnt respecting there fan base in that matter but is it me or at 6:28 was Roger Clark facial kinda hinting at something when undead nightmare was brought up he seemed to be making a facial expression to hint possibly cause as he said even if they were he cant tell anyone I mean I could be wrong but I just hope either once next gene comes out they do something fans really want

[@come4tmebro]

@@zacheryhallett8302 I got the same feeling from that. Playing hours of LA Noire made me feel like that Roger is hinting towards something

[@MrFusion]

@@zacheryhallett8302 Y'know, considering the fact that there hasn't been any major RDRO updates in nearly 7 months, I wouldn't be surprised if they started working on a story DLC. I also heard rumors they're remaking RDR1 and that it's in late production, but that's just rumors.

[@zacheryhallett8302]

@@MrFusion yea I heard the same I think the black lash from gta 5 re release will change there route and I hope rdr 1 is being remaked

[@轟焦凍-g9p]

Don’t worry, they were hard at work with a beans discount for rdo

[@Swells-lv3uz]

Dutch is so proud he got the “ornamental dagger” 😂

[@maddixoliver333]

You don’t even have to get 100% to get it just kill the vampire

[@rab_22..w]

YVNGTRAPPER 317 I think he was referring to the fact that you had to kill the vampire to get the dagger which is needed for 100% completion

[@universal_wisdom3416]

just so we all know, **ornate** dagger

[@nutsackreviews]

@@rab_22..w not necessarily. you dont need every weapon in the game, just a certain amount so you can skip the ornate dagger

[@gangsterskull3357]

@@maddixoliver333 it can be in story or in epilogue

[@dennishuang7764]

I'll just say that Jack is the entire Van Der Linde gang's son

[@odin8578]

then he would have Lumbago from uncles genes

[@erenkrn16]

Odin haha

[@Erakelus]

Well, community might disagree with you, Jack had a moustache se he is probably son of Dutch, Javier, Pearson, Trelawny, Swanson and Micah.

[@jpm2x]

@@Erakelus Micah wasn't in the gang when Abigail was getting piped down

[@traegoins6903]

@@odin8578 i actually learned from my grandma today that lumbago was an old school term for arthuritis.

[@AVerdadeEstaLaForaMapping]

5:34 no, don't scare me mister Morgan.

[@yourexistencehasexpired9545]

What?

[@AVerdadeEstaLaForaMapping]

@@yourexistencehasexpired9545 "It is quite a cough"

[@vikutaa]

Oh no!

[@comradebear2095]

Everyone : Jack could be Dutch's or Javier's baby Me : It's Pearson

[@hudsonlong8351]

Pearson is a player

[@samjackson9560]

Uncle

[@HokoriJS]

Morgan

[@chelseaf.3352]

It's obviously Lenny

[@cassiedevereaux-smith3890]

@Maximiliano Almiron Has to be to fight off all those vicious sardines. With his mouth, I'm assuming. Dude's well fed.

[@xhappymochix6029]

These questions were great, but what about the REAL question... Where is Gavin?

[@caylunholt2378]

gavin?

[@caylunholt2378]

oh im so worried....

[@caylunholt2378]

@BRYTON COLE GAVIN????

[@bussy7264]

The guy looking for Gavin is gavin

[@caitlinclarence2617]

Loot him. His name is Nigel

[@prosimian]

If Jack's real dad was indeed Javier...that would mean his adoptive dad killed his real dad....darcc

[@juanjoseaguilar3668]

If you kill him

[@jambamram8441]

juan jose aguilar24 either way javier dies, either John kills him or Javier gets hung

[@felipegomez4769]

Arthur is jacks dad

[@Cryahaat]

@@felipegomez4769 no.

[@charlieharrington9555]

felipe gomez Dumbest comment yet

[@francescodiilio7755]

The Strange Man = The Devil Blind Old Man = God

[@MrZsasz25]

Well the blind man is clearly modeled after the blind seer Theiresias from Greek mythology (he stumbled over the goddess Artemis taking a bath in the woods and in a fit of anger she struck him with blindness - but since she was sorry for her overreaction the gave him the gift of being able to see the future). Come to think of it there a quite a few characters that may men analogues for characters from Greek mythology: Arthur (Achilles), Micah (Thersistes), Dutch (Odysseus), Hoseah (Nestor),...

[@jorgeloredo100]

Strange man is death tough

[@flimsypopcorn638]

Everytime I see him I don't have enough Money

[@omokok1877]

why did you choose the blind old man as god

[@12227UserName]

Personally I think the blind man is simply a stereotypical hermit and prophet. I don't think he's suppose to be God by any means. And if I had to guess, the Strange Man is mostly likely the devil, a demon or death. In his cabin in RDR2 he's clearly written to be some sort of force beyond our comprehension, being known for causing the plauge in Armadilo. The way it's written, it would appear he's a version of death. However, what's odd is that the cabin is listed as "Serial Killer's Cabin," so who knows. I think the cabin name may have just been a place holder name while the game was in development and R* simply forgot to rename it to something more fitting. But again, who knows for sure.

[@josuearriaza3952]

I think John is the dad but the fact that everyone tells him he might not be... is testing him if he would still be a father regardless to the women he loved. Nice touch that older Jack wears similar clothes to Aurther.

[@bobi7800]

If they do a rdr1 remaster i want jack jacket to have the texture that arthur's jacket did

[@Tostito422]

Jack wears Arthur’s jacket. Or he was originally gonna. Arthur’s beta outfit looks like jacks jacket so I think they were gonna make it the same

[@logans2976]

When John Marston hears someone say that Jack isn't his son (activates dead eye and make you drop dead)

[@cinnabonfire5374]

The 2 dislikes are from Colm O’ Driscoll and Leviticus Cornwall.

[@lilsquige9452]

Well it’s now 15, so we can add Micah to that list too

[@ianoconnell8678]

And Angelo Bronte and Bratihwaites and Grays

[@duhastbitch]

Jim Milton, too

[@ciemny9410]

Mr.Dickens too

[@diegonin5181]

Edgar Ross? De Santa? Allende? Dutch? Javier? Bill?

[@c0ntra605]

I would give 5 years of my life to have a voice like Marston.

[@emtee7138]

What about Arthur

[@c0ntra605]

EMTEE undoubtedly

[@snakeenjoyingacanofbeans5219]

And a whole lot of Premium Cigarettes

[@biggiecheese726]

If you smoke enough to sound like him you’ll probably lose those 5 years anyways

[@jamesagwe2981]

@@snakeenjoyingacanofbeans5219 don't forget your cocaine gum

[@fluffybluefastboi103]

John’s VA is literally John Marston irl, he acts and of course sounds just like him

[@brt1strrbb110]

And lives on a farm

[@kriscorner9390]

@@brt1strrbb110 does he actually?! That would be awesome.

[@landondover]

You should watch the KZbin video of him after RDR1, it almost symbolizes his role in the game, he left the Hollywood life to just live a normal life on a ranch with his family

[@suribuxton9079]

He should just change his name to Rob Marston at this point

[@chavalugo9855]

They're not just VA they did most of the game in Motion Capture, so it's normal he would have some mannerism ressembling John

[@JayEmsey35]

It's so strange to hear John Marston's voice come from not John Marston

[@gabrielarkangelo]

Even John Marston himself wants a single player dlc ! We should sign petitions..

[@chief5604]

Rockstar don't care even if a quitillion people singed in

[@angrycinnamontoast794]

@@chief5604 what about 2 quintillion

[@chief5604]

@@angrycinnamontoast794 rockstar still won't listen

[@angrycinnamontoast794]

@@chief5604 what about 3 quintillion

[@chief5604]

@@angrycinnamontoast794 same thing

[@RainbowBubbleSparkle]

cashier: “that’ll be $20 sir” Rob: “here you go” cashier: •_• “john?”

[@theaquaticadventurer5602]

*Smiles* Want an autograph, son?

[@satan6412]

I had this exact same thought while watching this. Id recognize that voice in a heartbeat. Haha. Id want his autograph to say John Marston 😂

[@hzjake]

Rob : No , I'm Jim Milton

[@samuelbennett7681]

😂😂😂

[@musicbot1630]

*happy Pearson noises*

[@chair7261]

When John said *”S N I F F”* I felt that...

[@gianna4954]

That one guy kinda sounds like me...

[@johnmarston222]

Y'know, I was thinkin the exact same thing..

[@rondodacorsa720]

I was also thinking that

[@prowthegamer]

Lmao

[@danish1650]

Dang you all dont know who is he he is your voice actor

[@kierangreenfield2815]

@@danish1650 it's a joke relax

[@menoknow1972]

Rob seems like the most happiest and purest person ever, I bet he's a joy to be around just seems so happy and nice all the time. How does he turn into this badass outlaw? And one of video games' greatest characters.

[@CastTerror5]

I wanna see John Marston's voice actor in Walking Dead

[@lifeasiknowit5688]

He would be a great character!!

[@louiswebtser]

And Micah!

[@seanwarner9893]

I love that the voice actors are actually invested in the game! This wasn't just a job for them.

[@col.nugget1524]

Exactly! It is so cool and heartwarming to see they know it so well, and love talking about it. Its like Arthur John and Dutch on a Zoom call!

[@Kanal7Indonesia]

Bruh RDR is love RDR is life

[@maxwelldavies7118]

Yeah definetely. I love that the guy who played John is so creeped out by the strange man

[@blownbraens4688]

Maxwell Davies 🤣

[@aidanrogers4438]

I think they purposely designed adult Jack Marston to resemble multiple members of the gang to leave his father ambiguous for the players. I personally think John is Jack’s dad, since it adds a deeper meaning to their relationship. John left the gang for a time, abandoning his role as father, then as the game progresses he gradually learns to accept his role as Jack’s father and genuinely wants to grow closer to him.

[@sonoftheking1977]

I like to believe he is but absolutely no doubt he resembles Javier a lot. He resembles both of them bu javi more I think

[@MPal24]

@@sonoftheking1977 But as Roger says, he does have elements of Dutch. And in-game, Arthur states to Jack whilst antagonising him that Bill could be his father. Did Arthur ever sleep with Abigail? It's all done to be deliberately ambiguous.

[@thurman5342]

@Keknov i mean if you read aurthors journal it states that abigale got in the gang because she was a prositute (along with miss grimshaw) and that aurthor wanted to mary her as well. i dont see any of aurthor in jack but i do see javiar but the thing is jack is not completed like javier and yes even if he is mixed with a white person he would still be a little dark but i also see dutch in him as well as a bit of bill. maybe bill rejected jack as his kid and thats why she hates him

[@myskirionprime992]

I get the feeling of a live audience tv show wanting to know WHO IS THE FATHER here lol

[@mcmcomiccon]

wow spoilers but we really missed a trick not doing a whole DNA test segment..

[@myskirionprime992]

@@mcmcomiccon that is a very good PLAN a dna test for to see who is THE FATHER of jack really is

[@zajkoo]

It doesn't matter who the father is, because we know who's his daddy.

[@myskirionprime992]

@@zajkoo do we tho really ?

[@swaggerfm9838]

Dutch. Look at Jack's nose and Dutch's. He's definitely his.

[@arando1410]

I believe the robot is Jack's father

[@thatsnodildo1974]

Johns voice actor laughing about the dlc makes me cry knowing the dlc aint coming

[@OutsiderHALL]

I love how the actors themselves know the details and mechanics of the games so well. Maybe not Rob because he isn't a gamer like he mentioned before. But damn both Roger and Ben definitely know the games very well.

[@thatoneshortboi]

The fact that Ben openly said he 100 percented the game is just wow to me - that's dedication of a person who helped make and enjoy their own masterpiece.

[@gerardgarcia4005]

It’s honestly really like the coolest thing ever and I imagine Rob knows his way around the game a little bit.

[@MrFusion]

@@thatoneshortboi Damn, he hundoed the game? Fuck me, I'm still at 95%. Those gambler challenges are a bitch.

[@reececowell6642]

@@MrFusion and Ben's mother played it too

[@MrFusion]

@@reececowell6642 Didn't he upload some essay she wrote on Reddit? I think I read it a few months back.

[@kahlbutomacfarland]

“He May have been your father boy, but he wasn’t your daddy.” Doesn’t matter who was Jack’s seed donator. And that’s what makes John’s arc that much more admirable.

[@eezdung]

Who said that again?

[@rinzler8272]

No shit lol, I mean I'm adopted myself. It's still fun to speculate though and it adds more layers to the Gang

[@gerardgarcia4005]

Rinzler X maybe dutch or John is your father.

[@lane250lk]

“Rockstar is focusing on Red Dead Online.” Ha, yeah ummm no.

[@Ghosty-eb9hg]

I'm not so sure dude. They're probably gonna put a lot of content in after next gen starts

[@rileymccreanor6492]

@悪Aiiko ...How? Moonshiners was the best update so far.

[@johnp.smithasimpleman7281]

悪Aiiko Man I completely agree, specially on the pvp part. Everyone is SUCH a tryhard now, and I say this as a really good player rank 265. Every high player is just using tonics every 30 seconds. I normally don’t like taking tonics, I only use dead eye 50% of the time, I always use regular ammo, I use just 1 revolver and no Mauser pistols. Some of my friends think they’re better than me, because they’re going full tryhard on people. Also the gameplay was much better in the beta, everything is so fast and stupid now. I miss the old movement

[@michaelrodriguez3327]

Yes.... we haven’t got anything for story mode in a year and they are milking online. Y’all fools if you can’t see it

[@JTmaxx]

Why would you even want anything for red dead online? It barely feels like an Online game, and it'll just ruin any chance of a SP DLC Just like GTA Online. I quit playing MONTHS ago.

[@Sniper33779]

I love how they all feel so connected to their characters, like Rob getting offended at the thought of Jack not being his son

[@Unclep318]

I really love that we finally got Rob to confirm the strange man is indeed strange

[@twoodluger4350]

Roger: they're probably working more on Red Dead Online Me: Nope.

[@Puck_Ringz]

I called bullshit so loud😂

[@itsjustdubz]

Did you notice how he looked to the side when he said that? I'm calling it now, they will add the blackwater massacre to rdo and he's recording lines. It would be a genius move to bring all the players back

[@continuousrage4974]

Well he did kinda hint towards Arthur featuring in RDO, which would probably make since considering that Blackwater is currently in chaos now since Amos Lancing was killed who was on comparison with Angelo Bronte in terms of power and control. Since he's out of the loop thanks to Jessica LeClerk, it leaves Blackwater wide open for a potential robbery and the appearance of a particular Legendary Gunslinger 😉 Patience is a virtue.

[@itsjustdubz]

@@continuousrage4974 if they bring Arthur and Landon to rdo i will literally cry tears of joy

[@Erakelus]

@@itsjustdubz that would be bullshit

[@27eabell]

Im closing my eyes watching this just so I can picture Arthur, Dutch and John have a convo about Jack possibly being John’s son😂🤣😂

[@RobertC6661]

The crying made me laugh lol

[@whodatninja439]

Rob is like "who came up with this theory, i just wanna talk 😠" 😂

[@gerardgarcia4005]

It’s just at the part of the standoff near the end of the game their just all talking to each other and Micah is just there standing in the background wondering what the fuck is going on right now even the Pinkertons are watching this all go down lol!!!

[@monsieurjacob1033]

Hi other Ethan

[@pischpilot]

We need something like that with Charles, Hosea, Sadie, Micah's actors

[@thecourier2016]

Ik this is creepy but sadie topless

[@isabellasutcliffe4409]

The Courier go onto rdr2.private.affairs on ig

[@_DMNO_]

@@thecourier2016 well at least you have the confidence to say it

[@gaga7247]

Why micha?

[@NameHere2243]

zombie micah, we can beat him forever

[@mrhouse8936]

“I’m not a gamer” Rob wiethoff

[@BKnight_]

These 3 seem so genuinely down-to-Earth and kind. I imagine they're an absolute blast to have a drink with.

[@bluemarais2897]

I like the platform where they read off the questions as opposed to some sweaty dude who interrupts too much at some convention questioning them. This allows for genuine reactions

[@gabriel_alemdoaquario]

So freaking cool to know that Benjamin not only played but got 100% completion on the game.

[@matiaslipovec]

A true fan

[@Jorja_47]

i’m stuck on gambler 8 😂😅

[@ahmadbani1452]

​@Jorja_47 the very worse challenge

[@Trymie98]

I love them all but man, Rob is something else! He’s just always so happy and smiling and you get a little bit happier just by watching him. He radiates joy in a way I wish I knew how to!

[@garychaidez]

Even Micah was a good guy

[@theothercrypt]

I love that you can tell the whole cast has their regular voice and their acting voice. Like you can recognize what character they play, but they don’t sound quite the same as when they’re actually IN character. But then there’s Rob, and there is no differentiation whatsoever between his voice and Johns voice. He just sounds like John all the time. Made no attempt to sound different for the games cuz his voice was so perfect for it in the first place lol

[@karito_karma]

I love how all the characters look pretty much exact to the actors, it's beautiful-

[@bluerobot8543]

Rockstar really nailed it with that haha

[@loadingpage8625]

Yeah it’s like the younger version of them all!!

[@tatertot7719]

dutch.

[@ToniKroos5]

arthur.

[@mencobasukses97]

it's the obese version of them except rob

[@bigness8006]

john marston's voice actor: i don't know *with a small smile* me: he knows

[@legendgamer676]

There’s something quite poetic about the idea of Jack being Dutch or maybe even Arthur’s son. I like that theory. The idea that Arthur sacrificed himself for the gang and saved John, and so unbeknownst to him John could raise his son and take care of him is interesting

[@alijahtheguy]

@akari. schnapp Ikr it's weird!

[@maxhoughtonmusic]

@akari. schnapp I thought it was Reyes when I first played the original game lol

[@captainbeastwinger4940]

@akari. schnapp in rdr 2 Young Jack looks white and has Brown hair in rdr 1 he looks Mexican or native american i wonder if they did that on purpose

[@Janzq13]

@@captainbeastwinger4940 I don't think he looks Mexican or Native American. Abigail and John both have very dark hair and so does Jack as an adult. Jack's skin tone is light too.

[@sadieadler3065]

I like to think it’s Javier because he’s my favourite character. He didn’t mean to do the wrong thing he was just loyal to the man who saved his life, an it’s nice to think even a small part of that intense and beautiful personality and character lives on in Jack.

[@F3nax]

Red Dead Redemption 2 Staring ⭐️ John Marston as John Marston

[@maxhoughtonmusic]

Staring at who?

[@hereliesnaif]

Max Houghton at john Marston

[@Ellemen_LMN]

Gothboi ...as John Marston

[@hulkbelowall3162]

Rob's face during the Jack's father question is pricelesss!!!!!!

[@FrankHorigan]

0:06 johns just like what are you talking about

[@terminaator0073]

Didn’t even know Dutch was wearing AirPods till he turned at 4:59 😂

[@azaz2552]

God damn man idk why but every time Rob smiles and laugh it cheers me up so much 😂😂😂

[@cmcproductions26]

For me, I can tell that he's just loving, living life. He laughs, and smiles so much, because he just loves life. And it definitely shows.

[@Kanal7Indonesia]

John in the game : •_• John irl : XD

[@boltuz]

This content is pure gold, the expressions/reactions they make while answering the theories is outstanding

[@jennajewel5148]

I turned away from the screen to get ice as Rob was talking and the face of John instantly popped into my head 😂

[@MrWorldWide305-1]

Young Jack can look like anyone’s kid, but my first thought was 100% Escuella when he grew up

[@SweetAeromotion]

Exactly

[@denlillavatten.67yearsago82]

No he’s John marston son rockstar has confirmed

[@cloud2676]

If I can ask God for one thing? I would ask him to give me Rob’s voice.

[@col.nugget1524]

It’s like a river of precious jewels and gems going through a garbage disposal. It sounds so heavenly yet so manly at the same time.

[@TBT707]

@@col.nugget1524 so damn detailed lmao

[@ABlueElitefromHaloCE]

He has such a gruff, manly voice but maybe because I’m just picturing John Marston every time. I want Benjamin’s voice just so I can yell Dutch lines.

[@BiohazardReject]

Those guys are so genuine and pure

[@azaz2552]

6:34 I think Rob’s expression and slight smile is telling us something 🤔

[@oflippert]

Both he and Roger smirked and laughed. Rob seemed to lose it a bit. I'm sure it's just wishful thinking on our part, but man I would be THRILLED with a single-player DLC.

[@maryroseswan4323]

@Viper Hareous ye but imagine how long it would take to make up a story

[@allyshaddad3123]

@Viper Hareous they were busy on porting it to pc

[@imjustheresoiwontgetfined3890]

If it does happen I hope it's a free update

[@pizzaissogoodright5076]

4 years later:

[@cwxgames468]

"He may have been your father, but I'm your daddy boy." ... or what ever the line from guardians of galaxy 2 was

[@Garobie]

Its truly beautiful when the voice actors of characters are this passionate about their work and as into it as their fans are! Id love to meet these guys!

[@igorsimcik6478]

thank you guys for hosting these absolute gods among men

[@Jamesamong007]

Maury Povich : "John Marston....You are NOT the father!"

[@despacitodaniel801]

*dead eyes everyone in the room*

[@gerardgarcia4005]

I know that look from anywhere everyone get on the fucking ground i’m not getting shot today!!!

[@anakinsimpwalker4526]

Abigail: 🏃🏻‍♀️

[@galilalexandro4793]

I think rob did a perfect job for red dead redemption

[@gerardgarcia4005]

Honestly they’re all amazing.

[@yjm.6-w7c]

0:51 i think this guy has a plan

[@chrisidoo]

I'm so glad how Rob has changed from the first Red Dead Redemption, to Red Dead Redemption 2. After the first RDR, I believe he went back to his life the way it was before, but in this video, he seems very happy to work more on the game. Judging from 6:06.

[@dominicbaldie9558]

I freaking love that Clint Eastwood music when we see Rob mad about John not being the Jack's father.

[@emanuelleonardo6613]

“He may have been your father, boy, but he wasn’t your daddy.” - a brave space pirate

[@gordo9165]

A brave space pirate didn’t say that you idiot it was Said by Mary Poppins

[@coreysweet8990]

When Jack was young, I always though he looked more like Arthur, simply cus if his hair color. Then when Jack grew up, his hair got darker, and no doubt he looked mostly like Javier. But I still see young John in there too. Facial hair rarely indicates bloodline. And John had somewhat of an olive complexion, like Jack does. I guess the father is whoever we decide it is, cus it’s a video game lol.

[@Tornadic]

I always thought John and Jack were pretty similar looking. They both have the same features, such as their cheeks. I remember when RDR1 came out some people called Jack a John clone without scars lol

[@aronbabb115]

OMG I love John’s voice actor.

[@choklatecheeseburger]

It's amazing that Roger and Rob have to kind of change their voice and accent a little for their characters, but Benjamin Byron Davis is literally just Dutch when he speaks.

[@Gigi-fv9ky]

This was lots of fun. Oh, and I loved the fact that the "real" Arthur watches some of the same RDR2 videos I do as I remember the one where, i think it wasTag, carries the vampire on his horse waiting for sunrise.

[@husseinali354]

Do you want to know who Jack's real father is? Dutch:we all had her

[@laserdiscisawesome1263]

I feel like it’s Javier. He has the same facial structure and when Jack is older, he kinda has the same facial hair as Javier and looks like him

[@sunnex474]

Javier joined when Abigail was pregnant so I think it’s either John, Dutch, or Arthur

[@NCCalvin9]

@@sunnex474 it’s not Aurthor he was just a made up character for rdr 2 without rdr 2 he wouldn’t exist

[@Ali-jb9jq]

@@NCCalvin9 they could retroactively change his dad

[@NCCalvin9]

@@Ali-jb9jq no they can’t

[@SlyLilFoxo]

I feel Javier would've known if it was him and use it to spite John at some point. Especially in RDR 1.

[@casadilla111]

The irony of Arthur saying the Strange Man has a “tying someone to a train track” mustache when I have personally witnessed Arthur himself doing the exact same thing…

[@Harrebs]

yeah lol

[@GameRoll]

Honestly I think that’s why jack calls him ‘sir’. Maybe between 1899 and 1907 Abigail told jack that John wasn’t his father. Ik it was polite back then but still

[@flamingmonkey7712]

I think Western or Southern Americans do call their fathers "sir" when they're young which is considered as a sign of respect.

[@stankyratman5685]

@@flamingmonkey7712 I’ve always said “yes ma’am” and “yes sir” to my parents. But Jack is a little formal about it. It’s probably because he’s nervous around him and feels disconnected from him more than anything, though.

[@vhscopyofseinfeld]

@@stankyratman5685 or it’s just how the VA delivered his lines

[@bamesman2091]

Can we get a “Kek or cringe” rendition with the main cast during these trying times?

[@tylerszoke349]

“Alright Dutch, let me see what I can pull out.”

[@Br0nzeDuke]

"Dutch, Dutch I've got a meeme for you"

[@bosskbennjpw]

No no Dutch don’t these memes are cringe I’ll show you a real meme something black lung and Johnny boy could never come up with

[@Br0nzeDuke]

" that's kek right Dutch"

[@bosskbennjpw]

It’s making me cringe Dutch uhh ahhh hooo😵

[@dreadfullyd1701]

I would like to thank you for listening the community and remove the song that was on previous videos! The interviews are amazing! Thanks for your work and, again, to listening to us!

[@GamerTech_YTB]

5:59 I did it

[@WhiteNm]

Легенда.

[@soimn6321]

Instead of being an ass about it and self promoting yourself, say something like you were happy and appreciated him watching your video

[@YGK-]

@@soimn6321 bruh he just said I did it it's not a big deal

[@yeetboidalydaly8555]

s o i m n chill

[@stex6315]

@@soimn6321 bro what's with the anger

[@N_wah_King]

Dutch and johns voice actors sound exactly like the characters

[@burtmacklin1939]

The fact that Roger freakin’ Clark watches Embear makes me so happy 😂

[@col.nugget1524]

I love how much these guys genuinely know and love these games. Of course they’d have to know it, given the amount they worked on it, but it is awesome to see they are all so passionate about it and are still buddies. Fuck it is like having Arthur John and Dutch on a Zoom call. If only we could get Hosea, then we’d have the whole family.

[@captcardinal7082]

Honestly the fact that Jack looks so much like John at the end of RDR1 is confirmation that he is indeed John Marston’s son

[@sabbagels]

4:43 - I think "The Moon will shine on in the darkness" isn't really reaching if you account for the fact that not only does Herbert Moon have the Strange Man picture, but in the epilogue of RDRII he is the *only* person in town not sick with cholera. He definitely sold his soul for protection or something.

[@mikopolaruso1525]

7:38 - 7:51 i'm guessing abigail had an active social life.

[@Meefer-fn6fs]

Rob looks like that old meme about that guy talking about hot food