Fixing YOUR art!

[@mooonblooom]

I 100% get where those who dislike this series are coming from, because it's true that most of the "fixing your art" videos aren't done very well. However, these actually give good critique and talks about how to work certain elements in a stylized way. Because yes, stylization is GOOD, but studying anatomy, colors, etc. are all aspects that are vital to learn as an aspiring artist. Lots of art criticism videos are flat-out bullying and turning stylized art into realism, which is pretty shitty. These give good CONSTRUCTIVE critiques to artists who ASK for them! People just need to realize that not all critique is bad. **Constructive** critique is GOOD and is something you will HAVE to get used to if you ever want to pursue an art career.

[@poumybeloved]

Because she is actually professional and knows her job pretty well. Most people who makes videos like these are self-taught (there isnt anything wrong with it, although if we generalize it, its like that.) and still learning things. I agree with you.

[@IzzieCuevas]

Bullying is a bit dramatic and I think kinda rude. She is a pretty soft kind critic considering others

[@faithminic5570]

she's pretty soft with it all, especially compared to some other 'fixing your art/roasting your art' series i've seen. Plus, she keeps the pieces in the same style, while still 'fixing' it.

[@pemanilnoob]

@@IzzieCuevasthey weren’t talking about the person in the video, OBVIOUSLY

[@queenofpents3442]

I agree. Huge difference btw constructive criticism and roasting or bullying just for the views.

[@lindsaybee93]

i would love to see more critiques from that character design perspective you did for austin! the posing especially was really helpful and inspired me a lot!

[@kfish6347]

I agree!

[@lauren7998]

ID LOVE THIS SO MUCH PLEASE DO!!

[@labaker4285]

I like the tip about the fingers, I enjoy seeing 3 in simple cartoons like the Simpsons but couldn't figure out why it felt weird seeing it in more elaborate art online

[@corruptedchannelx745]

I know! Originally people used 3 fingers so it was easier to animate, but I don’t get why people do that when their art is more detailed and they don’t need to simplify it

[@AltKaxREAL]

I myself have 2 characters that have 2 fingers and 1 thumb in each hand (kinda the like the Ninja Turtles), I always had a bit of trouble figuring out "how do I make this look normal?" and then I just figured by making their hands be shaped normally, just making it seem that they have no fingers in between their pointers and pinkies, the hands looked a little monstrous and very sharp which i didn't really like, it looks much more natural now

[@BBrostik]

@@corruptedchannelx745 Cos most of the time its solely a preference and they wanna stylise their characters like that. I vastly prefer drawing 4 fingers for most of my characters cos I love the 4 finger trope and how cartoony it looks. Nothin wrong with that

[@tuvalu636]

@@BBrostikit’s just that it doesn’t really work for a more detailed style, unless you have a very cartoony style…

[@slashbat2375]

She's not a human character so I can see why they made a three finger choice. If you watch the dragon Prince all the elves have three fingers+thumb, but humans have 4 fingers+thumb. I think it's an interesting world building difference

[@ChantelleArts]

you critique so politely, I don't get how people could be annoyed 🥺

[@spacegoldenretriever8678]

I love how you fix drawings without changing the style, and give valid criticism without bringing people down

[@LIttle_paper_h3artzz]

Without changing the style? Yeah.... Totally..

[@kiirakunn]

people crying about stylization need to understand 1. you need to know the rules, to break the rules 2. these artists SUBMITTED these drawings for a voluntary critique aye

[@SmbodyIused2know]

TRUEEE. Like stylisation is one thing but that doesn’t stop a drawing from looking anatomically/visually offset

[@AlphyAdventures]

the way you critique this is way more helpful than most "fixing art pieces" I've seen. This is actually really great!

[@VVesteria]

I’d say the most helpful person I know in this genre is naoki saito. He never changes the original vision of the art but always improves the technical aspects of it.

[@haytendo]

thanks for the critique Jackie! I agree with what you said and I will definitely start drawing 5 fingers haha

[@dragonmoonwave]

Don’t change for her, 3 fingers looks nice.

[@frankieloinandgroin]

⁠​⁠@@dragonmoonwave I can’t believe you’re so butthurt over her content that even when the person being consensually critiqued LIKES the changes she made, you try to convince them that their own choice isn’t actually their choice. Change and grow as person.

[@austinsalinasart]

Thank you Jackie, I absolutely loved the advice that you gave me on my character, I have never really looked at a character of mine like that. The way you were able to bring it to life, I feel like my art has always struggled in that sense. But the advice you gave me is something I’m now looking at through all of my characters, thank you again!!!

[@giftofthewild6665]

Cool, which one of these was yours?

[@amme.m]

If anyone is wondering about the pink fairy character she is the mc from “ Mia and me” hope this helps

[@Estella_alsoknownasgabi123]

I remember watching it as a kid! But couldn't remember the name! Is it still on Netflix because I want to rewatch it and see how it is! I don't have much memory of it, only the character

[@faeryeclair]

@@Estella_alsoknownasgabi123 yeah its still on netflix! only the 2nd and 3rd season im pretty sure

[@NoEyes]

This unlocked so many memories for me

[@EvieWren]

@faeryeclair Unfortunate they took off the first... I really liked that season, and never did finish it.

[@BrokenPencilArts]

Oh my God I was addicted to that show as a kid... I genuinely forgot it existed 💀💀

[@Silly_Goober.net21]

I LOVE this its not just turning them into asian anime girls in your style to the point your recreating it like sam does thank you so much for keeping the artstyle :)

[@kfish6347]

My favourite thing about these videos is how I start thinking ‘wow that’s great.. how is she gonna improve this?’ And then this shifts to ‘well duhhhh!!! How didn’t I see that!’ 😂❤

[@desperating]

Literally!

[@strawberriean]

You don't change the design and you actually help people be a better artist and that is what I am so happy to see!

[@dragonmoonwave]

Except for changing stylistic choices and redrawing an entire character

[@tr4sh.doll_]

@@dragonmoonwave the characters still look like themselves, they keep their personality and their style she mainly brings technical improvements, I don't have materials for digital art so for now I only draw on paper but if I submitted my art to someone to improve it I would totally want to submit it to her because her critiques are objective and useful while keeping it polite

[@AdrinaDutta-x7r]

@@dragonmoonwave everything is a stylistic choice now, is it?

[@mustanggox]

i love this series!! The people who are upset about it are coming from a place of ignorance about how it works.

[@teamili7957]

And isn't it her patreon supporters submitted their drawings to be critiqued? People always assume that artists do this to random people without knowing stuff lol

[@wondaraptor]

@@teamili7957 for real, not like its kooleen who is rude and just redrawing pictures in her art style, there's actual art tips that help

[@lovebirdwillingten]

oh no, that's not my mindset. I think she's a wonderful artist and is AMAZING. I'm not even upset, I'm just... a tiny bit bothered that she "fixes" stylistic choices. But I get it!! and that's okie, I just want to say that the people who are 'upset' aren't coming from ignorance. Have a nice day!

[@mustanggox]

@@lovebirdwillingten That's fine, I understand the concerns. To be fair she does acknowledge that it's all subjective, and that the changes are a matter of opinion. What I mean when I say it comes from ignorance is that many people don't know that it's even requested by the person getting critiqued. Thanks for the response, it helped hearing another view on this! :)

[@lovebirdwillingten]

@@mustanggox aww, I get it. Yeah, your welcome for the new perspective! I like seeing how different people think and your point is really good. Bye! ☺️

[@Frenchaboo]

I'm not a beginner artist, but I tend to get hyper focused on one part of the drawing and get completely blinded to the design being wrong or anatomy errors. Yours and Naoki Saito's videos have been extremely useful in thinking "wider" about my art and identifying why it looks "off" by the end.

[@ParacelsusCaspari]

those notes were things i wouldn't even have thought of but they enhanced it so much! thanks a lot

[@BackYardRejects]

i love how you dont just "fix art" by drawing it in your artstyle! you actually give good tips and critiques thank fuck omg

[@themoonwarrior]

What I personally love is she actually helps and doesn’t redraw it to her own style, I’ve noticed some artists doing it so this video is really helpful for me ^^

[@Lyn_.00]

this is so far the best "fixing your art" video bc she doesnt totally change the characters features instead just adjusts the propotions correctly and fixes the poses i enjoyed the video alot too its not too boring and also she doesnt critizise the artists instead advices them on the mistakes they are making and also learned alot during the video😊

[@joshuasmith7089]

I love how you don't remove certains charather's features, like how you kept the first art strong chin 😊

[@labaker4285]

"people are calling me mean 😾" why was that cute? 😆

[@JackieDroujko]

Because I’m cute

[@Preppyyesss]

@@JackieDroujkoreal

[@UvaVerde12]

​@@JackieDroujkothis was truly honest and true

[@seasideoranges]

out of all art critique videos I’ve seen, yours have got to me my favorite. i always learn something from your videos, your very respectful and kind, and you always make sure to not change the style of the art you critique drastically. i really appreciate that!

[@queenofpents3442]

Love how you're not making the characters YOUR style but just addressing the changes and fixes in a practical way. A lot of artist on YT tend to "modify" not fix the art so much it just looks like their own character and not the senders. Great job and I learned a lot from this :)

[@ogkpopper]

You're so great at making a point without changing the style of the artist, I love it! 💕

[@rafa3l_22]

I love this series, you politely give criticism. I’m often scared to show my art to others for tips because I’m bad at taking things lightly but watching this and seeing how polite you are it makes me want to show my art more and get criticism

[@elizacarrie7433]

Hi! I love your KZbin shorts and I followed for these exact videos! Your eye for composition and anatomy have really helped me correct my own drawings without rage quitting. I’m a coder by day and an artist by night, but used to have so much trouble with drawings just not looking right, which always makes me feel discouraged. Your critiques have really really been encouraging😊

[@NARUHOTEL]

You are so charming. I've really stepped up my art over the last few months. I've been drawing my entire life but really have leaned into it as an escape lately and it's been good for me. I'll share what I've got and maybe I'll get to hear your thoughts. 😊

[@blue_berry18]

17:29 that Mia and Me drawing brings back MEMORIES

[@evodolka]

Really nice work, i like how this is more art advice rather than the usual forms of "fixing" art online

[@faithminic5570]

oh man I think this is my favorite 'fixing your art' series, because you are not only telling us what is wrong, but also demonstrating it in a way that makes it apparent that you can apply this anywhere! Can't wait to bingewatch the rest of the series, thanks so much.

[@zoemoore4485]

I don't know why or how this appeared on my homepage - I'm not an artist, and have never watched art critique videos before. But I've already subscribed. Your content is awesome - really positive and constructive and very enjoyable to watch!

[@Shadow_Skullz]

Even i have troubles with anatomy and action poses but this has some good pointers un like the "other type of art fixers" Im glad there are people who fix the art to be more helpful with these types of situations.

[@LOLZYY.]

I just realized that the last drawing she critiqued was fanart of mia from mia and me. That show was my whole entire childhood

[@LOLZYY.]

@amariajade255 im 11, also chill. It's not like I'm watching an 18 video. How did you know how old I was? Did you also watch the show? That implies you were way out of the age range or that you are also ten. And the other option, which is if you googled it, which is weird to do just to reply to a comment. Jesus

[@MidnightCapricorn2696]

@@LOLZYY. if you're 13 you shouldn't be on youtube, let alone announcing it- youtube (among other social media)'s minimum age requirement is 13. Although I don't think youtube deletes accounts things like discord will

[@zukina5323]

​​@@MidnightCapricorn2696bro it is 2023 wake up💀💀let the damn kid live

[@raincoattt.]

@@LOLZYY.hey not telling u to get off of social media but please never announce your age on public platforms, it’s dangerous. this is coming from someone who was targeted at that age and is now an adult, stay safe.

[@jolinski]

⁠@@amariajade255 I don’t really know why you sound so hostile but like… I‘m 20 and I recognised the character and watched the show when I was in elementary school lmao.

[@Lucifer_Abysseum]

i love this serie it gives so much advices and inspiration, and i just love seeing how the tweeks just suddenly make a peace have more sense

[@Ryuatewater]

They are so much nicer than my art teachers (i go to fine arts ) our teachers dont tell us what weve done wrong and just say "this isnt good" and draw on a big X (over our art) but this girl is so much nicer and fixing the art is so cool idk how to express it

[@FazartOrganization]

This was one of your best so far. I love how you take already good drawings to the next level.

[@elimoon378]

Well the last character is Mia from Mia and me so a fanartist would just redraw her og outfit 😅 corset sounds fun for her though

[@missjoannaofyeetyoink]

Yesss I was looking for this comment

[@humansizedKitkat]

I was looking for this comment I loved Mia and me as a kid

[@faithtangen1227]

please do more of these they’re your most helpful videos when it comes to proportions

[@ShortSkullDog]

I really like how while you fixed the art. You still hept it withon what could feasibly be the creator's style.

[@ramuneanwen1041]

Ugh this series is so good! I love how you don’t change their art style and give awesome critique! Keep it up😊

[@v0id_is_inactiv3]

i love how respectfully and actually helpfully jackie does this

[@damienglynn]

I feel like I learn more about art from these critique videos than any standard art tutorial. Great job. :)

[@julsstay74]

I wanna highlight how your sponsor bit was the best I've seen in a loooong time. I usually either play that part faster to get through it quickly, but I sat through yours fully and I'm actually interested in getting it! Tysm, I hope it helps me!

[@Haizou]

for the fairy one,I think they were trying to go for like a circular flow which is why the hands and legs were so curved so I think would’ve been cool if u leaned on that while still make it proportional like channel your inner loisb😆 but the correction was still very informative and I liked how it came to be so good job:DDD

[@figaroismycat]

Yes, the hand needed to move up, but the legs were almost fine how they started. The ones after were way too thin barely bones.

[@amarantalagana1490]

@@figaroismycatthe legs before did not look fine at all. they were so unnaturally curved and bones only are straight lol. also, the thinness of the legs is normal

[@figaroismycat]

@@amarantalagana1490 perhaps, but the difference make it seem worse than it needed to be. Too big of a contrast imo. Also both thin and rounder legs are valid. Maybe if the tips had a reference to show what examples they use would make it easier to understand. I know not everyone can include them in the videos, however when accuracy is the key over inspiration then we like to see it. Thanks for the feedback.

[@fuzzydragons]

Always handy and a learning video when artwork is critiqued and redlined (with permission of course!). Helps you see mess ups in your own work 😊

[@elalaela2694]

Oh the Mia and me fanart took me by suprise so much, what a throwback

[@allergies9099]

frrrr

[@elalaela2694]

@@allergies9099 can we talk about your profile picture 😭

[@winston.iscool]

love the little detail of hobie holding the mic so much

[@SmileyzArtz]

These videos are like free art lessons for me and i am HERE FOR IT, THANK YOU

[@MikomiKawaii]

I love how you improve their art while still keeping their style and quirks

[@noshima88]

This video helped me a lot!! I really like your opinions on the drawings 🧡

[@BubbleDragon8]

I love watching the tiktoks of you helping improve art! What a treat to have an extended format!

[@Irisandstuff]

I love just seeing how you mind works. You point out and do little fixes that i feel like no one would even think about and they always make a great difference!

[@Austin.Kilgore]

Omg lol ever since you said this 2:26 I can’t unsee it! I only noticed it once you pointed it out but now that’s all I’m able to see it as… just a giant hand. Lol

[@Mimi-Aury]

Hobie is holding ur microphone! I love that

[@why_is_life]

Why do you give better advice than my art teacher? Ive learned more from you than my art teacher, your also nicer in your (helpful) criticism

[@ilomilo-mk4xn]

the last character is actually a fan art from the kids show mia and me!! I really like the way you do the critique though!

[@r4mdisk]

I would love to see more of these from a character design perspective (and not just bc thats all I submit to the server lolol) This one was definitely my favourite so far!

[@speakwithanimals]

wow jackie it's sooooo mean of you to provide useful, insightful criticism for the community

[@imnotlelo]

Your videos are always sm fun to watch

[@PlantFood_]

OMG MIA AND ME!! I forgot the name of that story and I was looking for it for so long!

[@kendrixxxoliviaaa2100]

I love this! The constructive community and art summits ❤ making me a long time subscriber 🥰 makes me want to summit my work too

[@kisvigado9799]

The last character is Mia.It’s a series called Mia and I if I remember right.I watched it often when I was in kindergarten.(sorry for the bad english).

[@brandycole387]

Awesome job! I honestly learn so much just from watching your videos, and you are honestly so calm and polite!

[@terrych6175]

I saw the first piece in a short and decided to check your channel. I love it and I subscribed❤

[@susanagutierrez9341]

18:33 literally my childhood

[@Kybalion963]

As an artist, an Aquarius and a human I'd like to express how absolutely gorgeous you and I love your art as well!!! Happy 2024!!!

[@IzzieCuevas]

I didn’t know that you were human

[@eviewalters9245]

The fairy one is a character from a show I used to watch with my little sister. Some of the design choices were intentional, so the ponytail and that bracelet

[@scoobylinny]

I love seeing these! But a very personal thing from me, is that I feel like the hand pose in the last one actually works better with her character? (She's from an animated tv show) although I do think it makes more sense in the drawing how you did it, it gives me more like 'I'm pretty' vibes which the character itself doesn't give? Like she wouldn't care about any of that at all. Just my thoughts while watching that :)

[@roderichedelstein5762]

Wow, such a glow up on all of them :D Can I suggest you zoom in the recording of your Photoshop window more in post so it's a bit easier to see on a small screen? Thanks :)

[@twizzlindoodz]

Absolutely love this series! Its always so helpful, and I learn so much from each drawing you critique!!

[@isotro]

Hello Jackie, I just stumbled upon your channel, I recently started drawing and I am loving your content! I love the constructive criticism and although the "roasting" is done on specific drawings we can all get some tips for our own art. Amazing talent and character!! Also beautiful really cool drawings from everyone!

[@yeyezen]

the first pose was a really hard one to draw in the first place omg

[@Snek-Jay-Jay]

This actually really helped me with my art!

[@heartstringsduets]

I really think these videos are so helpful because it helps me see my art with more critical eyes

[@anisa2273]

damn every fix really makes the drawing pop, I really hope I get as good at drawing as you

[@adria345]

Your critiques are always super helpful, I love watching your videos!

[@desperating]

19:20, SHE'S FROM THAT TV SHOW, THAT'S SO COOL MY CHILDHOOD.

[@gambara3298]

I love your wall.

[@Clémente_DearWorths]

Love the spiderpunk holding her microphone

[@heybella2867]

These videos are so insightful!!! Also off topic but I love your nose shape, you’re very pretty!

[@Lloydetc]

I’m glad to have found your channel! You are fantastic! I really enjoy these videos very educational too

[@EmreAymelek]

It is very informative. I am so glad my short scroll led me find this account! 🙌

[@ur._fnsm]

I love your videos Jackie!!

[@lisdmon6538]

love your channel! your criticism is so insightful and informative, really great stuff!! ❤

[@giftofthewild6665]

The wings coming out high is correct. They attach to the top of the shoulders like arms do (just below the arms would). Wings never come out of the middle of the back on ANY vertebrate animal, that would make no sense. I liked the thin wings, they reminded me of dragonfly wings.

[@Kwkwk-qu2hb]

While drawing 2 hours in, I look at my drawing and I'm like that's what's its missing! I forgot the arms..

[@Preppyyesss]

haha!

[@e67538]

lol how’d you miss that!? 😂

[@nataliefluckiger6568]

Great video and fantastic advice for those pieces! I love watching your critiquing videos

[@milenia.3870]

Thanks for inspiring me Jackie

[@Ur-Fancy-Butler]

The last critique she dose of the fairy if I’m not mistaken if from a show called”Mia and Me” so it’s fun to see her crit a character design from a legitimate show:D(no hate)I think the corset would add a lot

[@rednitch]

it actually helped me know where to directly place the mouth

[@dianamendez9914]

I love watching your critiques

[@isorangewow]

haha talking abt the outfit, shes actually a real character from a tv show. i use to LOVE it as a kid. her names Mia I think? 19:04

[@uwahayo]

the mia and me fanart ??!?! woahh

[@pemyep800]

It's so amazing to see the progress. I believe that you're helping these artists improve in the best ways possible. Like letting them know where to focus next. I've given up on art lessons a long time ago so simple videos like this really help and just what we need (⁠ ⁠◜⁠‿⁠◝⁠ ⁠)

[@Aizen11507]

I’m a new viewer, and, uh, 0:00 THE SPIDERPUNK MIC HOLDERRR❤❤❤❤ I LOVE SPIDERPUNKKK

[@ayelad3096]

WOAAHHHHHH, this helps so much omg

[@miredo9743]

19:00 it's Mia, isn't it? My childhood... Such nostalgia 😭😭😭

[@neil88879]

Okay guys chill out, she gave credits.

[@Random-pu7he]

I love that her shirt matches the background😂

[@therianjungle-gy8vk]

19:25 MIA AND ME! I LOVED THAT SHOW AND STILL DO!!!