It's 2024...Why Are We Still Believing These Skincare Myths?!

[@nathan1768]

Does anyone else see James as there comfort KZbinr. His voice, his editing and personality makes it feels like he’s talking directly to you.

[@Undefinedinc]

💯💯💯💯

[@shortyridesasporty]

i love his voice lol. love the energy and vibe

[@spiya6712]

Same with his brother, Robert. I love their videos

[@H.A.-zr2wc]

The twins are amazing 🖤💜

[@nathan1768]

@@spiya6712 Robert is so well educated in his field, as well as James

[@hodso1ra]

I'm so glad you mentioned that your brother still uses Garnier. I love my Garnier micellar water, but I can see some people having reactions to it.

[@JamesWelsh]

My brother literally has backups of the garnier! Some people HAAAATE bioderma! Just use whatever works for you 💜

[@phoebe543]

Been using garnier micellar water for years and never had a problem. It’s cheap and I have a chronic illness so if I had to go stand at a sink I just wouldn’t wash my face a lot of the time to be honest. Even small amounts of vitamin c in my skincare makes me go red but I’m not saying no one else should be using it.

[@HelloTruDee]

I had a bad reaction, but if it works for you, you don’t have to stop using it.

[@tilltab]

I have a number of allergies, and my skin is pretty reactive, but garnier micellar water works just fine on my skin, which is super, because a lot of low cost, widely available skin care products are terrible for me. There’s never going to be a product that is perfect for everyone - even tap water in certain parts of the country will irritate my skin!

[@dianaf6333]

Garnier is also cruelty free .... A huge plus in my book.

[@susan825]

I vaguely remember Drunk Elephant years ago saying something along the lines of: if you have a reaction to our products or if they dont work, its because you can't mix them with other brands. I'm not sure if that had anything to do with it

[@andresboehmwald9171]

They said that because a lot of people were having reactions to their products but they didn't want to take accountability, so they switch the blame to the costumers... FUCK DRUNK ELEPHANT

[@rhileynnna]

Yep. And they also said their products only work if you’re strictly using their products together! The founder is literally an idiot

[@sylmaerie]

^^ what they said. never used a single drunk elephant product again after i had a really odd reaction to their protini moisturizer and found out they were trying to blame consumers for having reactions….even a “no product is going to work for everyone” would’ve been a better response than that

[@reigenwb]

@@andresboehmwald9171 drunk elephant is just overpriced mediocrity, is people want actual good skincare that is worth its price, then they should look at japanese and korean skincare, they have the best spfs and serums

[@blinkingbat7447]

It might also have been influenced by the curly hair community. A few years ago there was a huge deva curl scandal, people who exclusively used their products eventually struggled with hair damage and even hair loss and scalp damage, I think there was even a lawsuit at some point.

[@artemiswiegand2090]

With the micellar water, it's also really useful for disabled people. Sometimes I can't stand up long enough to wash my face, and I need to save my energy, but I still deserve to feel clean/clean my face. Misellar water is great for that

[@amandaflippin5368]

That comedogenic scale is so absurd! I've struggled with cystic acne and missed out on so many amazing products that I have since found very helpful for reducing redness and inflammation due to the "comedogenic" label. While others claiming to be "non comedogenic" made me break out so much worse. Even professional derms would steer me in the wrong direction based on that scale.

[@samanthariley6822]

Saaaaaame. Especially since my acne is actually triggered by hyper-keratinized skin that isn't exfoliating properly because it's too dry and blocks the pore. I avoided rich moisturizers for years based on the "scale" and my dry cheek skin kept on forming comedones, which then became hormonal cysts once a month when my oil production ramped up. I slather my face twice a day in cetaphil moisturizing cream now (technically a body moisturizer!) and I'm acne free.

[@hillarybeautifile]

​@@samanthariley6822 I'm your skin twin!

[@daftoptimist]

Me too! I genuinely thought it was a real thing until this week, after 15 years of avoiding so many skincare formulas that could have worked for me.

[@liz3169]

@samanthariley6822 How did you find out what worked for you?! I am in that position and idk where to even begin with products. Everything suggested or prescribed by the derm really doesn’t do anything :(

[@amandaflippin5368]

@@liz3169 I started doing research and experimenting on my own. I started by finding a good cleanser, then slowly added in other steps. Being sure to take time after each addition to see how my skin reacted. Especially if I introduced an active of any kind. It's time consuming, and there will be times when breakouts happen, but if you're diligent the end result will be a routine that is custom made for you, by you.

[@callwyse]

James is a soothing teacher ...his voice is calming.

[@JamesWelsh]

💜💜💜

[@baileydubs]

I’m glad I’m not on tik tok. From “debunking” videos I see, I am saving myself from exasperation 😂

[@jessicafern8112]

My last social media platform was Instagram 😂. I’ve aged out of Snapchat and TikTok 🤷🏻‍♀️😂

[@dimplesd8931]

Shout out to Lab Muffin. I love her channel. I wash off my micellar water but I thought I was supposed to. 🤦🏾‍♀️ As for the “studies” unless the trials are on 100’s-1000’s of humans, aged 18-70, male and female in multiple countries, you can’t really say what will happen to you when you use a product. What if that cosmetic “study” was in 10 American men, ages 18-27? Or 60 women in Japan ages 40-70? On your face or body…..🤷🏾‍♀️

[@colinf2316]

The comedogenic thing. Wait till they find out I slug with CeraVe Healing Ointment every, single, day. Not a pimple in sight. The amount of misinformation on TikTok (And other social media, but it's worst on TikTok) is truly concerning.

[@fattiesunite2288]

Thats because the healing ointment and other ointments like vaseline petroleum jelly are non comedogenic. Applying it is like applying a whole walled layer that doesn’t absorb in the skin.

[@_linlin_]

@@fattiesunite2288 Exactly. Your skin won't take more than it needs or can. That's why collagen patches are pure bs.

[@itsabbiebear]

The cerave healing ointment is non-comedogenic I believe :) glad it works for you

[@fattiesunite2288]

@wyltedleaves ive been using vaseline on my whole face and neck for years esp a few times a months since starting tretnoin and it really helped. I even have it on right now and it really sky rocketed my skin to another level. I have never had any problems of clogged pores by petroleum jelly at all. There must be another product that you apply that does that because vaseline is non comedogenicz

[@aliciawilson2217]

I also love how the TicTok slugging trend started off with them telling you to do it everyday/ every other day. Not to mention I've also met women all my life who only use Vaseline or Beef Tallow, with perfect and beautiful skin... wild!

[@denaemichele]

Seems like TikTok is always a couple years behind KZbin with information. Maybe it's partially due to the average age of viewers and creators on the platforms (i.e. people on KZbin being older and have already figured out the things younger people on TikTok are now learning)? 🤷‍♀️

[@SirThinks2Much]

I think also because TikTok has a lower barrier to entry re: content creation - it's right there on their phone, everyone's got one, and generally used on the fly. Whereas KZbin videos generally tends toward being more produced, having a decent camera/room/etc.

[@heathershangovercure]

​@@SirThinks2MuchYeah, that could be a factor

[@woboznz]

Yes!!! I agree... these gen z tiktokers who think they invented everything from dnb to 90s fashion to makeup trends. Uhm no kids. It's all derivative. Please try to invent at least one new thing, every generation before you has.

[@oracle1351]

The information you’re saying is absolutely not redundant- even mainly consuming content on yt, I actually didn’t know a lot of things you brought up. The distinction of comedogenic vs non comedogenic and what micellar water’s key benefit are all new to me! Please keep doing stuff like this you’re amazinggg

[@leslieraab1820]

I absolutely love falling asleep listening to him! Best asmr voice ever. Then I go back and watch the video again during the day to make sure I hear whatever I missed the first time and note down the new products I want to try 😊😋

[@mscj7348]

Same 😂😂😂

[@Jaylynnjuarez45]

I just started watching him and I also fell asleep and woke up and his brother’s video was on and I was very confused 😂

[@lunakat7020]

​@@Jaylynnjuarez45Really?.. They do look different especially with Roberts hair style.

[@Jaylynnjuarez45]

@@lunakat7020 at the time I didn’t know he had a brother

[@lunakat7020]

@@Jaylynnjuarez45 You were probably wondering..Why does his hair look different? 😊

[@caoimhenimhuireadhaigh1303]

I have *very* oily sensitive skin, and the only moisturiser that doesn't break me out is the CeraVe Moisturising Lotion "For dry and very dry skin". Unfortunately, it truly is a case of trial and error to figure out what your skin specifically does and doesn't like.

[@Kdannyst]

I started using bioderma micellar water based on recommendation here, and I LOVE it. I don't think I could remove it from my lineup of products.

[@geekspertise]

0:37 I think the first time I heard this first from a hairdresser, because there was no line that had everything I needed to care for and style my (natural textured) hair. I think it traveled from haircare.

[@rebeccadanger9214]

Omg thank you for specifically mentioning mineral oil. I totally still thought it was bad for your skin and have been stunned by how many products use it as one of the main ingredients. It has definitely stopped me from buying a lot of products but now I'm definitely going to have to experiment more!

[@ChloeFromUtah]

I completed 600 hours of esthetics school and this video answered questions I didn't know I I had! Thank you so much!

[@understitchYT]

What you're saying at 9:36 about the test giving unreliable results I really relate to, I have unfortunately very sensitive skin and so I can't use most products, (I mostly go to Sephora to look at packaging, marketing and merchandising tbh) but it's devalued a lot of creators (or even industry people) I once looked up to because, for me, very thick moisturiser has been a real godsend while the thinner ones just absorb too fast and it just doesn't work well for my skin and yet nearly everyone recommends thinner moisturiser, or even for hands scented moisturisers, which is a hard no-go for me. So really, now anyone saying skincare (or make up really too) is one size fits all *cough Drunk Elephant* maybe isn't realising that thats not a wholistic view and in the long run may cause them to be devalued when they, idk, maybe have some kind of negative effect on customers, who then, idk, complain, and then, idk, maybe -drunk- -elephant- -will- the brand will fight against the customer, and then give themselves a bad reputation, but idk tho, idk

[@NineTailedOtaku]

I was so confused like I'm pretty sure I subcribed to this KZbinr yesterday but something is different? Turns out it was his twin 🙈 **subbed here too now**

[@debbyd5729]

They have a channel where they do fun/entertaining videos together and their tagline is “this is your reminder that we’re not the same person” 😆

[@Boooo_39]

I swear it happens to most of us here at some point 😂

[@monicapatton1405]

And then there is Marcus.

[@purplepeoplreater1]

I'm so glad you did this. I've been thinking about these myths a lot lately. I always wash off micellar water, because I use it as a first cleanse to break down sunscreen and makeup. Even if I go in and use it until everything is off really well, I break out if I don't rinse off. I use Bioderma. So that's a perfect example of not one size fits all that you were talking about.

[@JustAFace_InTheCrowd]

What would our skin without you, James? Thank you for telling us about the comedogenic bullspit. I’m now learning a lot of things people told me would be bad for me my whole life were actually things I desperately needed…… like moisturizer lmaooooo. Everyone in the 2000’s told me moisturizing my acne would make it worse…. 😭💀

[@JamesWelsh]

Omg we are the same 😭 I grew up thinking I had to dry my skin out

[@Naroru]

Same!!! Like im from Spain and here we were told the same lmao my poor skin hadn't seen a single drop of any kind of cream until I was like 26😂

[@iamjackspyramidshapedhelmet]

NOT moisturizing makes it worse! We all learned that the hard way 😩

[@RacerX_1111]

Same here… never used a moisturizer cause I thought I would break out more.

[@RNthe21st]

Honestly vexed right now and James posting a new video is calming me down and saving a family relationship. Thank you.

[@JamesWelsh]

😂💜💜

[@Cypresssina]

You should also get bonus points for using "vexed," it's a fabulous word. It should definitely be used more frequently.

[@hecatedionysus7562]

I’m so glad you mentioned the comedogenic scale bc I get obsessed over checking for pore clogging ingredients and have thrown away so much skincare bc of it

[@jamie1602]

We live in fear so long and turns out it's an ingredient or two that we're actually sensitive to. And sometimes if it's listed low enough we won't respond to it. It's so screwed up and we live like this for so long... And then turns out all that science is total crap and we could be living it up. But hey, you're free now. Sort of. The best way to keep track is keep a list of ingredients you notice in certain products that you have a reaction to. That's how I figured out my problems. And... here's the actual bad part? Every few years you have to go over it because your body will change and your reaction will get stronger or weaker. GO FORTH AND LIVE YOUR BEAUTY DREAMS, GORGEOUS.

[@spadefantasy]

James, you’ve gotten me back into skincare. You’re the reason I decided to finally update my routine and figure out what’s better for my skin, absolutely adore your videos so much!

[@tiffanychill8219]

Yes I'm acne prone and sensitive and combo skin and my all time holy Grail is CeraVe moisturizer cream!!!! It's thick and I'm in love !!!! Ole Hendrickson peptide strength trainer is a great one too . I've tried about 50-60 and not 1 has beat the CeraVe ever !!! Everyone says I'm crazy for using CeraVe and but the only time I've been breaking out is when I try DIFFERENT BRANDS AND INGREDIENTS AND I'VE USED CERAVE 2 TIMES A DAY FOR Years AND IM NOT BROKEN OUT DAILY SO I KNOW ITS NOT FROM THAT .

[@trangluu8754]

I know theres no such thing as perfection but bloody hell... your skin is looking perfect! Im currently experiencing alot of reddness in my skin and praying for tbe day it goes away

[@WinterGirl1969]

James is my comfort zone when I need to forget the world and concentrate on myself...he is knowledgeable and just soothing to listen to. ❤

[@JamesWelsh]

🥹💜💜💜

[@polinatalmeltzer450]

This is so interesting, I’m 2000-2010 we were told by brands that we SHOULD stick to one and only brand 😂 Which is also not necessary, as we know))

[@BlackRainbow84]

I use a garnier salicylic acid with eucalyptus cleanser, the ordinary glycolic acid toner, the ordinary salicylic acid serum, some by mi retinol eye cream or the ordinary 2% retinoid emulsion with the ordinary moisturiser. Sometimes argireline or matrixyl serum during the day. My skin is great, you don't need to use very expensive products or change things constantly. Also vaseline works great for dryness i love it around the eye area.

[@LazyAmericanWoman]

i used that micellar water once and threw it away. my skin and eyes were super irritated. but i see some of my fav youtubers use it and love it 😩

[@nervousbreakdown711]

I use it because it’s cheaper than cleansing balm. I’ve been having a fine time

[@CeruleanStar]

I have very sensitive skin, but it works fine for me. Given, I've always washed it off. With my skin type, I never trusted the "you can leave it on" thing. I really only use it to cut through waterproof makeup, which it does well enough. Then I rinse it off and use my actual cleanser. Doing this works very well for my skin, but everyone is different. Everyone is sensitive to different things.

[@SamRabbitx]

Different skin, Different needs

[@faithphoenix3999]

Same, and it doesn't work for my waterproof mascara, regardless of the brand of mascara or micellar. Oil cleansing works better for me all round

[@TeacupTSauceror]

so weird that you and your brother have the same genes but different reactions to products! goes to show how individual these things can be

[@JamesWelsh]

I’ve never thought of that before! We have completely different ‘skin types’ too

[@michellemckenna2233]

OMG! LOVE THS!! This is the most informative skin care I have ever seen!! I am a 49-year-old woman and I remember when things started being labeled comedogenic, etc. I appreciate and love all your videos James, keep up the good work!!💚💚💚

[@Hippo-finds]

I’ve been using dandruf shampoo on my face and a Vaseline moisturizer and my face has been clearer than ever. It’s kinda not typical but I saw one girl on YT reals recommend it and I already had the products and so I thought why not. I haven’t had any major breakouts since. It’s been a few months. My skin isn’t perfect but it’s like night and day

[@dinasilva9263]

My skin doesn't like Garnier but loves Nivea😅 I absolutely love James voice. I wish his voice was a skincare😂❤

[@kristinalutz6770]

I used to believe that my cleanser was just for removing that excess oil/dirt after my first cleanse. Since changing to a cream cleanser with actives and extracts and it’s really changed my skin

[@lindaoostmeyer4637]

Thank you James for busting those myths! 💜

[@simplybri3608]

I didn’t like the dermatica products they pilled so bad but do like the simplicity. Skin care has become so complicated. I no longer use a hydrating serum my moisturizer has the same humectants as the serums.

[@GeneCapri]

Would really like to see an updated facial hair care video (plus best sunscreens for the beard area and tips for people trying to grow a beard)! I know that most of your viewers probably don't have beards but it would be great for those of us who do and educational for those who don’t but might know someone who does 🌻

[@jodiekelly1355]

Garner Micellar water I'd the only one I've ever tried where I've WANTED to wash it off. Not only that, it's terrible at removing my makeup. Sainsbury's have an own brand micellar water that's like 2.50 for a big bottle and it works so much better! I usually wash mine off though, just because I use it as a first step in removing makeup

[@pattycarljackson]

Using micellar water and leaving it on the skin isn’t horrible like you said but it also isn’t cleaning the skin as using a regular cleanser either like a lot of people think it does, it is going to leave dirt or makeup behind and sunscreen.

[@saya-mi]

I use micellar water in the morning because my atopic skin doesn't like pure water - water makes my skin dry and flaky and it doesn't rally matter where I am, if the water is too hard or not. And I use Avene Cleanance Hydra cleanser in the evening - it's the only cleanser till now, after that I don't have to put on moisturizer immediately, like I can finally wait for 5 minutes, I don't have to rush (again, no drying out, no flaking).

[@GenXfrom75]

I’m not brand loyal. I do skin care on a budget. However, Curology and The Ordinary Argireline and their multi peptide eye serum will never be traded out. ❤❤

[@iamjackspyramidshapedhelmet]

Ooh does that help with dark circles?

[@GenXfrom75]

@@iamjackspyramidshapedhelmet the Ordinary Multipeptide eye serum does!

[@MuzikFreak161]

You’re the reason I stopped using the Garnier micellar water and switched to Bioderma to remove my makeup and it was the best thing I’ve done in a long time 😩

[@JamesWelsh]

Omg love that 🥹🥹

[@olive944]

I feel like a chemist or something whenever i buy the bioderma micellar water, i love the packaging

[@mari-bella]

James your skin looks sooo healthy and you're so glowy! 🥰 I'm gonna need a 'current skincare' video please~

[@ashleepurefancy]

thank you so much for this. i always try to read the ingredients on things i use but more often than not, i have no idea what im looking for and my only compass is mainstream media and old wives tales. you clearly know what you’re talking about and its honestly so comforting and reassuring to hear the truth from a thoroughly educated person who isn’t just trying to sell me something. your skin is stunning btw (obviously). much love ✌️

[@sarahcarroll8206]

I love Bioderma for mornings, and I do rinse it off. Application and rinsing saves me at least 30 seconds vs a traditional cleanse, AND I don't have to secure my enormous hair (saving another 30 seconds). Maybe I'm just lazy, but totally worth it IMO.

[@noora7773]

I've used micellar water to clean my ears PM when I've used sunscreen. It's really annoying to use double cleansing on ears and get your hair wet while doing so...Otherwise I have used micellar water only if there's a break in the availability of running water...I don't feel like it really washes the dirt away well enough, so that's why I prefer double cleansing.

[@heatherduke7703]

11:30 Since everyone was recommending bioderma micellar water, I started using it, even though I was leery of the fact that it contains salicylates. I bought two of the little bottles and finally upgraded to a medium size bottle when I started reacting with constant eye irritation, inflammation, and swelling 😢 I still have over half the (expensive) bottle left.

[@crying2emoji5]

I’ve been following you for years and your advice as well as the advice from some of the dermatologists’ channels you source your info from and referenced has really transformed my skincare routine. The other day my boss asked me if I get Botox… like she doesn’t know I don’t get paid enough to afford Botox 😂

[@hellsbells8689]

James can you nip round my house and put some moisturiser on my face. I have just used a cleansing balm and went straight into painting my nails. My face feels a little tight. Help! STAND DOWN! I found a re-hydrating spray toner. 💜🖤💋

[@JamesWelsh]

😂😂😂

[@SoHighFr]

What are you wearing on your lips? The minimal tint looks great ❤

[@Paula_SG]

My face doesn't like any micellar water. Been using Banila Balm and love it

[@thefluffyaj4119]

im pretty low energy but i live in a state wgere its very very hot and i get very sweaty. i dont always have the energy to wash my face and apply my acne medication, so micellar water has become great for me for just whiping away that surface level of grime. im aware its not a replacement for washing, its just something i use just to try to clean up since i work out in 100 degree weather i actuslly only discovered it recently, i used to only use it as a makeup remover for years, but then i read closer and realised it said it could remove everyday grime. and i tried it on my bare skin after work and by cotton pad was fully brown haha! on the lighter side, but still, i was NOT expecting that amount of dirt to cone off on me, i didnt know thst that amoynt of grime was on my face every day! i suspect its mostly just natural oils, but still, it feels good to just whipe down my face and look at the dirty pad and know that thats off my face now

[@Noggo]

The problem I have with using the same brands products is that I might LOVE their cleanser, but the rest of the products I'm indifferent about. Now in my case I've been doing skincare for 10 years and have had time to find products that I love and swear by, but everything comes down to cost and formula. Round lab have the best cleanser and toner in my opinion, but their moisturisers are too expensive and their oil cleanser I've never bothered with, skin1004 have the best sunscreen and serum, purito have the best moisturiser and cos de baha have my favourite retinol and azelaic acid products. If you are a beginner or confused about ingredient lists I agree to stick to one brand with high reputation within the right budget, but if you invest a lot of time and research on skincare and learning ingredients, I personally think its better to not use the same brands skincare, both for cost and effectivity

[@jazwhoaskedforthis]

Active cleansers are great for beginners and young folk, actually. You get a more gentle introduction to active ingredients, and you can leave it on your face for a few minutes while you brush your teeth if you want more time. I introduced my skin to tret by putting a small amount on and then washing it off like a mask, very careful of my eyes. I have a SA cleanser and a serum, and I still notice a difference if I let my cleanser sit. It's doing a job and I can wash it off and the serum can still do it's thing but it's gonna be on longer. The combo hasn't been too much for my skin either. My oil cleaner breaks down spf and makeup, but my other cleanser might as well do a Lil something. Also, bioderma micellar water hits different than those Garnier ones. I use it in the mornings when I'm rushing and it's a nice alternative to a plain water rinse especially if I had some heavier stuff on my face the night before.

[@stephaniecuzner8147]

As someone who has such sensitive skin, it's easier to list the active ingredients I'm not allergic to, using a single brand is way easier. I've found if one product from a brand works, most of the rest of their products will at least not give me a bad reaction

[@jelatinosa]

I know a cleanser does matter because there's this one cleanser with glycolic acid that is the only thing that helped me with my hormonal breakouts. As soon as I stopped using it I started getting breakouts again. Used it again, no breakouts. Ran out and started using one with salicylic acid and I'm getting hormonal breakouts again. When my cleanser runs out, I'm getting the glycolic one again if I can find it for sure.

[@auroras_hairpins]

Best background so far 🫶 always good to come here for Jamisis videos 💜💜💜

[@SerenaFaith2024]

Thank you so much for the info and your expertise on comedogenic products!! I never knew that because i myself have avoided alcohols due to drying issues. But also know that the products are listed by most to least on the label.

[@kaybee9645]

There's too much going on with skincare, I can't deal with it. I think I look about the same regardless, and way too much pressure is being put on everybody to just buy a bunch of products in hopes of suddenly being perfect and beautiful. Thanks for your content 👍

[@MeechPeach26]

I didn't start using micellar water so that I didn't have to rinse it off. I started using it because it's easier and less messy to clean my face that way. It's way easier to rinse off than a regular cleanser too. I almost always risne it off, very rarely I will leave it on. Some are very sticky feeling too which I hate. I like to use ones that have ingredients that are more in line with a toner anyway so no suds in them which usually makes them not be sticky.

[@k-isfor-kristina]

I don't like leaving micellar water on my face because I feel like it doesn't take dirt/sweat/sunscreen off - it removes some but I still feel "dirty". I use it as a first step when I near make up to remove the bulk of it (and it's great on eye make up) and then I wash my face

[@LouleyK]

Cleansing is, everything for me - without Liz Earle Cleanse & Polish my extreme combination skin returns, oil slick down the middle/desert round the edges. No matter what I've tried from other brands, I'm middle aged and used it for 20+ years and nothing else balances and softens my remarkably unwrinkly skin!! Might not work for you but gotta be worth a try!

[@chrystalmanning439]

You make me day so bright. ❤

[@danilyons2367]

I don’t like actives in my cleanser because I have sensitive skin and I find I’m more likely to react to an active in the cleansing stage, which makes me think that they very likely do have some benefit even if it’s only on your face for a bit

[@JamesWelsh]

Ohhh that’s so interesting! Derms usually recommend those types of cleansers for people with sensitive skin! Goes to show you how different everyone’s skin is!

[@danilyons2367]

@@JamesWelsh tbf, I think for me it’s that my skin is really dry, easily stripped and so is kinda sensitive to cleansing in general, so adding anything extra can be really irritating. Might not apply to many other people haha

[@tearfulxsoul]

I had not heard of anyone having a horrible reaction to the garnier micellar water except my sister and I. We were thinking we were just cursed with horrible skin (we weren’t blessed with great skin though). She works as a graphic designer in marketing for beauty/skincare/pharmacy and had access to discounted skincare & samples, she found the the bioderma micellar water a few years ago and we were like “wow.. this is what micellar water is supposed to be like” and it’s the only one we can use. But I know countless people that swear by garnier and don’t break out in a rash. Can’t relate but it’s refreshing knowing we aren’t the only ones. The La Roche Posay B5+ Baume was also lifechanging for us (and our mum) because we get bad eczema and it is super soothing.

[@SeeMeRolling]

the garnier micellar water i use it to wipe off my nivea milky cleanser sometimes especially if I'm wearing makeup then rinse with water most times i just rinse the milky cleanser with water I have another micellar water that's smaller and more portable, and it's cheap off brand and it's got my countrys "astma allergy" approval on it, and this one works great for removing makeup on the go (or other reasons) with a cheap moisturizer afterwards

[@docp4449]

You are the sassy Bob Ross of skincare and I love it so much. Not sure if that made sense to anyone except me but it’s meant as a compliment 🤣💕

[@monique90me]

I Could Not Focus On The Vídeo w/ The Two Reflected Light On Your Nose. 😂 I’ll Try Again Later.

[@andrelini]

yeah i had to learn it the hard way that while something is labelled non comedogenic it doesn't mean it won't break me out. i went from having perfectly fine skin to having some terrible cysts while using some setting spray that thankfully went away after i stopped using it

[@lja530]

I actually think cleansers with actives only make sense if you're willing to leave them on for a bit and then they do something, in my experience. But then you would really be using them as kind of a mask. I also don't think the shampoo comparison quite works - the actives in the shampoo are cleansing agents and they work in short time just like cleansing agents in cleansers. I don't think that shampoos have any conditioning value or can repair hair either. I agree with all your other points though.

[@ChrystalVanDusseldorp]

Thank you for another great informative video! 💜🖤💜🖤

[@msabbyk1]

I literally adore you and really trust your opinions on skin care. I have learned almost everything I know from you and truly appreciate your honesty. Thank you for continuing these highly informative and comforting videos❤

[@user-xm1od9nb1m]

I feel like Garnier micellar water dries out my skin if I use it consistently like every day, but I have a little bottle to fix eyeshadow or eyeliner from time to time. Or if I have worn a loot of makeup and just want to wipe off the first layer before washing. I personally dont see the point in using micellar water every day when I wash my face anyway bc I feel like micellar water dont take off makeup fully 🤷‍♀️

[@user-xm1od9nb1m]

@Jack-px8lf I dont use oil cleanser bc Im too lazy hehe if my makeup is very stubborn I just go twice with a gel cleanser

[@crazy_cat_Lady88]

I use the Garnier rosewater micellar water. I can leave it on with no issues. However the strange thing is that I can only use the rosewater one and not any of the other Garnier micellar water or any of their other products. I've never tried Bioderma. I feel I should give it a go. ❤

[@smileygirl1742]

Tested on animals.

[@chikybelle]

When i hv difficult sleeping.. i play james's video.. 1 video is enough for me to fall asleep😂 thats how soothing james's voice ❤

[@monicapatton1405]

I use a bit of Garnier Micellar on a pointed qtip to clean up and shape my winged liner-never even considered washing it off-never had an issue.

[@mckennayoung2710]

I ended up deleting tiktok because of the sheer amount of misinformation going around on there. It's crazy

[@lar-in-a-crisis]

I remember hearing the "switch up brands" myth quite a lot. The reasoning presented to me was that the products are designed to help in the short term but then stop working after a while so that you have to keep buying more products. Wild.

[@JelenaP991]

I'm annoyed because some people still believe that drinking water or specific tea will clear your acne 🙄

[@JustAFace_InTheCrowd]

Same. It does HELP- but no, it doesn’t clear it. My personal frustration is that people think some people have acne cause they don’t/can’t shower twice a day like they do…. Like people don’t have skin conditions that make them need to space their showers out so they don’t turn into a giant flaky human-cracker. Dryness can also cause acne, so the logic they have is flawed.

[@amy1160]

Ik like the whole chlorophyll/green drops they love to promote

[@dimplesd8931]

@@JustAFace_InTheCrowd Yep sometimes changing from sugary drinks to water helps because you’re reducing inflammation in the body and the bacteria that feed off sugars secreted via the skin don’t have as much to eat and your skin calms down. A lot of fighting acne is reducing or stopping the skin infection first. Sometimes diet can help with that, but not as much as a doctor/dermatologist and good meds.

[@makinka0cp]

Well, yes, but I'm not annoyed with the people. Cause they can get really desperate. My ex wouldn't even take off his tshirt in front of me, cause he had bad back acne and was terribly ashamed. Once I found out, I made him see a derm and tend to him. It got a lot better. But many people don't have access to treatment. So I'm mainly upset with companies selling snake oil.

[@UndertheNeedle282]

​@@JustAFace_InTheCrowdPeople are showering twice a day? Why? My skin would be so ashy 😂

[@RosePhantoma]

10:18 micellar waters. garnier's has ALWAYS lowkey left my skin feeling burny/hot/tingly in a BAD way. store brand micellar water? never did that.

[@kaikristinemac]

I have rosacea and very reactive skin, but I love my Garnier micellar water which I have been using for yearsss. Mind you, it has to be the right one with the light pink transparent cap! All the other versions are irritating for me.

[@doreenrussell2978]

James, I appreciate your very balanced reviews of, and opinions on, skin care products.

[@Emmiiillyyy]

James could really do skincare in an asmr tone of voice and I'd still watch

[@gkeller1031]

I occasionally use the garnier micellar water on lazy nights when I just can't make myself do a full double cleanse, and while I don't rinse it off, I usually take a damp cotton pad or tissue and just swipe over my face after it because I find that it leaves me feeling like I have an oily residue all over my face. I haven't tried any other micellar waters because I don't use them that often in general, but maybe a different one would leave me with a less oily feeling.

[@BexREB]

I always assumed people meant dont just buy every single stage from the same brand and that just because one product of theirs works for you doesnt mean all of their products are the best options for you But no idea if ive just fully misunderstood that

[@Draggonny]

I just assumed it meant that a brand that is the best for cleansers isn't necessarily going to be the best for moisturisers, toners, serums etc. Pick and choose the best products for you across different brands. Although it does make sense that brands would formulate their products to work well together, even if there isn't a one-size-fits-all range of products.

[@Renee_egan]

What resources would you recommend for realistic, non- fearmongering representations of ” noncomedogenic” ingredients? Is there any place I can go to for a quick look at an objective, non biased comparison of actives? I believe for myself the trigger for breakouts is usually a certain product as a whole - I doubt I'm more sensitive to a single ingredient than the certain product. Whether it's that products formulation (or what it is idk) but I think for me its a product usually; but I believe a list of ingredients will be less skewed than one of products- how do we know a certain brand isnt the behind the scenes sponsor of a "black list" of acne/sensitizing un-safe products with the goal of portraying competition as a bad choice and themselves as "universally safe". It goes beyond that but in a bit shell... Now of course certain ingredients do go onto an instant no-go list for me but thats because of how Ive reacted to it in the past, not because of some arbitrary list. My goal is to try to get an idea of what might be better actives for myself and discover products I might have not otherwise tried. Or if that made no sense (currently sick af and little looped from cough syrup lol) what resources do you recommend would be worth looking at for our own education? I always want to be better informed and ultimately make informed decisions and smart purchases, not be victim to impulse buys based on hype or how much a company will spend on pr and they have a good public image because they give out a ton of free pr and thats the reason for the hype as opposed to their efficacy. Love your videos, informative and hilarious!

[@Uruveilhobbit]

Oooo that Garnier miceller stings my face and eyes so bad, it smells like dirt to me too for some reason! I usually wash off makeup with one of those fluffy cloths and Cerave’s foaming cleanser now … which is more effort but doesn’t hurt to use 😅

[@nadineo1983]

You had me sold on that prequel cleanser and it's heavenly. I also love their barrier cream. It's so good

[@CaityRaindrop]

My cleanser's are really cheap but I notice a different in how my skin feels after, it's gentle, non stripping. Its creighton's h2o wash and is like £2.50.

[@CaityRaindrop]

I also wash Micellar water off, can't afford the derma but I always saw it as a make up remover since I was a teen and not a "cleanser". To me you always washed after removing make up for that extra precaution you missed anything (guess I was double cleansing before I knew it was a thing). I'm trying out some balms/oils for make up removal instead but I ai t been wearing it a lot

[@tonyaweaver483]

Your such a great influencer & you seem to really care about your followers & understand what they want and need, I really appreciate that I just unsubscribe rot a girl that tried to say she was a influencer & cared about people & she completely changed & thought she was so pretty it ruined her whole attitude & career

[@ElWCont]

Dermatica is great. I helped my mom set up her reoccurring tret prescription and she loves it

[@JamesWelsh]

I put off their subscription service for so long because I just wasn’t bothered I guess?! But tried it and loved it.

[@doedarling1215]

I use derma e brand. But i do use cetaphil spf/body lotion and la roche posey foaming wash. But i keep it all simple, and only add heavier creams and serums for winter. During summer im a sweaty girl and pull back on heavy cream products. Even my mother didnt understand me washing my face: spf, makeup, and just the day need to come off. She never had acne and doesnt wear makeup, so she just doesnt get it. Shes in her 60s and looks 40s and she just uses baby lotion!

[@NaomiR51]

Woww just shows how different skins are garnier micellar water is my favorite. It did never anything bad for me, I love it

[@EchoAshbell]

My skincare routine is mostly one brand. It's all about what helps my severely dry skin

[@Narangarath]

Same here. The fact I also can't do most fragrances on my face (triggers migraines) tends to leave a rare few brands I can use on my face.

[@lamissu133]

For washing the face luke warm water glicerin soap rince with cold water and then a really good moisturizer 💜

[@amazingpanda4404]

Like shampoos. for years i used sulphate/silicone free and my hair hated it. I used those because i was told those things are bad blah blah Now ive switched back and my hair is THRIVING. Nearly down to my tail bone 🥰

[@schneeroseful]

You should not have silicone in your shampoo, at least not ones that are not water solluible. But you can have them in your conditioner, leave in and else however you want. Most brands do that

[@ElwingLuna]

Late to the party here, but as someone with chronic illnesses and dynamic disabilities I just wanted to drop a note to say that it meant a lot that you mentioned micellar waters might be used by people who can't always get to sink. Thank you

[@SamRabbitx]

Micellar water has lowkey changed my skin for the better. I use the Garnier too lol. I love it. Different skin, different needs.

[@shawnahhobbs911]

I would absolutely love to hang out with James. Like, have tea and talk about skincare and just be besties ❤