Jars in DnD Horrify Me

[@nLinggod]

I used it for a bbeg in one game. Since the "jar" is actually a gemstone, he had it set in a crown. Using it he ruled a theocratic kingdom, "reincarnating" every generation into a new body. Whenever he 'died', any new children born in the next year were 'tested' by placing the crown on them and he chose one to inhabit. Yes he was absolutely an evil bastard.

[@wyattdavis7997]

That's wonderful and I'm stealing it

[@Kattlarv]

This leads to a rather peculiar situation tbh... Since babies aren't sentient until like... 1-2 years. That would lead to a baby that's actually sapient... and the swapped soul would probably stay a potato, since it never developed to be self aware.

[@ServantOfPuppets]

@@Kattlarv brb theorycrafting lore for my canonically most feral child

[@nLinggod]

@@Kattlarv yep. when confronted by the party, he brushed it off saying "those children never grew up and sinned, so they're guaranteed life in heaven. really I did them a favour.". yeah, he was evil with a capital E.

[@stephenwaldron2748]

I genuinely almost asked for the name of the show 😭😭

[@OccasionalGoof]

I guess, you could say, wizards are a lot like doors. When they're not themselves, they're ajar.

[@crazy4bricksthebrickbrothe722]

I climb in the jar

[@sweetbeetyourfriend1808]

this joke makes me violent. very funny!

[@Dyundu]

Heyo

[@dangalfthedruid]

This is a comment of profound evil. 10/10

[@warmachine5835]

It's you. You're the sicko this spell was made for.

[@capy-karma186]

I think the jar could work for a cult. I mean, imagine a jar cult that worships this ancient vessel and keeps giving it offerings in the form of bodies so their master can live on only for it to be some turbo old ass wizard using them as protection and a means of continuing their body snatching.

[@Volvith]

'The Cult of the Primordial Jar' is the most D&D thing i've heard in a while. _I'm absolutely using that._

[@Rippertear]

One of my PCs was essentially that concept- a high charisma wizard claiming to be a holy healer that tricked strong, unwise NPCs into getting possessed. (With the DM's approval ahead of time, of course)

[@Zakvadr1995]

So… the Warrior Jars from Elden Ring? I’m down!

[@Americanbadashh]

It could make for a good librarian scribe type. Books burn too easily, but the jar has survived.

[@nobody1755]

This is just the plot of The 100

[@yamato9753]

My DM had us fight a Villain once who used this spell. He was an archmage and "friend" to a warlord. One day the familiar of the Villain gave the Jar and a letter to that same Warlord, saying "it's a powerful artifact, use it wisely". Then it happened... and now the archmage is essentially also a 18th level fighter. That guy was terrifying as a Villain and horrificly strong to fight due to an improved spell list.

[@MalloonTarka]

RAW, that shouldn't have worked. "You retain the benefit of your own class features. If the target has any class levels, you can't use any of its class features." But the nice thing about being the DM is you can use spells like this as inspiration, rather than being shackled to their exact wording.

[@yamato9753]

@@MalloonTarka That's the thing, the Warlord has no class features. It's just his statblock that basically can do all things an 18th level fighter can. He has 3 attacks per action, he can reroll saves 3 times... But he doesn't explicitly have "indomitable" nor "extra attack".

[@michasokoowski6651]

Imagine... a villain who constantly returns with a new body because of this spell... and at the final encounter he offers a pact. He will stop trying whatever he was trying for 200 years and your party will stop hunting him because its starting to get annoying.

[@grimtygranule5125]

@@yamato9753 It's so funny to me that D&D has stat blocks for PEOPLE? "bandit" WHICH BANDIT? JOHN DOE??

[@prophetzarquon]

I like how inclusive the description of Commoner is; it includes merchants!

[@NertNeverlander]

So it's basically an extra deranged and super unhinged version of phylactery

[@warmachine5835]

It has some downsides. Proximity to the jar being one of them that phylacteries don't have, and you actually need another creature nearby to swap into AND that creature has to fail the will save. On the upside, no rotting corpse body.

[@samfish2550]

I see this as the enchanters eternal life route. You can charm and beguile a choice subject into taking the jar, and depending on how much they understand about what you're asking, maybe even into willingly failing their save. Enchanters can be more fucked up than necromancers and adding some necromancy and clever cruelty into the mix with this spell and some enhanced manipulation..... Chef's kiss. *Side note, imagine if you had a, likely less exaggerated example, of the volcano jump concept of the vidio, but you somehow survived the attempted betrayal. I kinda want to use this as a backstory for an oath of vengeance paladin.

[@ArkadiBolschek]

iirc, Magic Jar is one of the spells you need to create a phylactery.

[@charles3840]

The spell sounds like an early precursor to the lich ritual.

[@Oddmanoutre]

@@charles3840 This spell has been around since at least 2E, and according to the 2E Monster Manual entry for liches, is indeed part of the ritual (the jar becomes the phylactery).

[@TheLolbitGamer]

For ethical immortality, build a warforged body with the jar on the inside.

[@_zurr]

If the body swap requires a soul, this wouldn't be ethical, because you'd need a Warforged with a soul to swap with, thus dooming that (potentially newborn) soul to Mafuba Hell.

[@randomperson8375]

@@_zurr why should i care about that if I'm an old jar wizard with great mental stats and the ripped, un-aging body of a warforged Barbarian? ethics mean nothing to jar wizards

[@mjam_0673]

at that point it would probably just "end it all" after a while...

[@healdrop9313]

@@_zurrit does technically require a soul, but you can make a humanoid warforged, put a non-humanoid soul into it (idk, like, a mosquito, or something else you don’t mind killing), use magic jar, and then have them trapped in the jar. Next, you can have a cleric cast death ward on you, take the magic jar far away, and then break it. Dearth ward prevents you from dying, but not the mosquito, so it gets to go to… idk, bug heaven, you get a warforged body, and the weakness of having a magic jar that kills you if broken is nullified.

[@gabrielamaral978]

​@@healdrop9313 This doesn't work. Because you always come back to your original body when the spell ends. But when your body is dead or away, you also dies.

[@lionbryce10101]

Magic jar really is part of the lich ritual. That with a thing to automatically generate a body, and something to retrieve your soul on death.

[@samfish2550]

So magic jar plus clone.

[@ToonedMinecraft]

​@@samfish2550 and perhaps Soul Cage or Imprisonment?

[@samfish2550]

@@ToonedMinecraft now we are level 20 cooking

[@elitemook4234]

This is one of those spells that probobly was not created to be what it is, but instead was a very early attempt at creating a form of immortality.

[@loganb7059]

Yeah. Though I do think there’s some interesting utilities. Like imagine a wizard soul library. You need information from some wizard who lived 400 years ago, you go there, the librarian temporarily switches souls with the wizard, you get your info, and they switch back. As a DM you could tweak the spell to make it work for this (like there’s a time limit of an hour or they automatically go back in the jar if they try to leave the building) And conversely, consider soul jar jail. Some person is too valuable to let die due to information they have, or they’re immortal and too powerful to be contained under normal means. So you trap them in a jar, and if you need to pull them out you make sure you do so into some weak idiot who’s covered in wards and anti-magic mcguffins.

[@justinterry8894]

I think in the lore it's used in the ritual to become a Lich where instead of a jar you put your soul in the philactory you prepared.

[@krazyfan1489]

@@loganb7059 transformers did the latter one

[@lostbutfreesoul]

Consider Litchdom and how it relates. I concur, this was something created during experimentation into immortality.

[@spencermalgam7231]

​@loganb7059 This sounds like a fantasy version of the head museum from Futurama.

[@waterconsultant10]

I had a player nonchalantly pick up a jar in a market, then many sessions later, use Magic Jar to take control of a BBEG's high-level number 2 henchman and proceed to DESTROY the BBEG with round after round of Chain Lightning. This is why you need to pay attention to what spells get picked up as people level, lol.

[@MalloonTarka]

I don't thin that should have worked. "You retain the benefit of your own class features. If the target has any class levels, you can't use any of its class features."

[@ebertgameandstuff]

​@MalloonTarka true but RAW, if it's an ability from an npc stat block then they could by RAW do it. Not sure if it's RAI but I would treant monk video on it. I love magic jar

[@MalloonTarka]

@@ebertgameandstuff Hmmm, good point.

[@Zarlos01]

I have seen a way bizarre and ridiculous interesting way to use the Jar to become any creature permanently. Let pick a dragon for example; first be a mage and be able to cast the Jar, clone and true polymorph. Figth the dragon and spend all legendary resistances for security. Transform the dragon into the less charismatic humanoid, a kobold, and use the Jar to switch bodies. Now just make a clone of you as a dragon, we its ready Cntrl+Alt+Del in your life, and your soul goes to the your dragon clone. And different from true polymorph yourself into a dragon, you gain all the dragon Stat block and keep your abilities.

[@Rutgerman95]

You just had to bring up THAT jar at the last minute

[@mr.thurston7476]

"the smell" killed me. Dead.

[@lofi-kaveh]

what is it?

[@Rutgerman95]

@@lofi-kaveh An extremely gross story about a jar, a my little pony toy and certain bodily juices. Look up the details at your own peril

[@beng9790]

I believe there's also a combo where you can use this spell to possess way stronger stuff if you're high level. Basically, Magic Jar can only be used to possess humanoids, but what you can do is cast True Polymorph on a creature of your choice, such as a dragon or other powerful monster, and turn that creature into a humanoid. Then you use Magic Jar to swap bodies with the "humanoid", and dispel your True Polymorph. Thus, you now possess the body of whatever terrifying thing you had captured to begin with.

[@solsystem1342]

Wow😂 What a play 👏👏👏

[@WildBluntHickok]

Hopefully your DM doesn't rule that you're ejected from the body the moment it stops becoming a humanoid! Technically, possessing a character with wildshape would fall under the same problematic category.

[@scrubnub6203]

@@WildBluntHickok If that doesn't work you can use the spell "Nystul's Magic Aura" to make the dragon considered a humanoid for the purpose of spells. Then while in your dragon "humanoid" body cast clone on yourself. Now the next time you die, you'll reincarnate as a dragon with a bunch of wizard levels. Best choice for dragon possession is ancient gold dragon because they also shape change into powerful humanoids. You also probably be able to take the appearance of your original body.

[@Styxer1008]

Ever since I saw "1 Guy 1 Jar," I, too, and am afraid of jars.

[@kleddiecute]

These legs haunt me to this day

[@skeletonbuyingpealts7134]

My little pony

[@VolkAus]

This could also be used in a different way. Neutral wizards/others storing their souls in a library or academy. Having a willing host that can take up time in a jar so the stored soul can bring forth knowledge and expertise from the past. Soul Jar library.

[@samfish2550]

Ooh I love that. I'm stealing this.

[@middox239]

thats literaly a subplot of the Skullduggery Pleasant books

[@samfish2550]

@@middox239 hmph. Still neat.

[@middox239]

@@samfish2550 they are good books, all 15 of them

[@connordarvall8482]

Who said the wizards had to be neutral? Maybe enchantment magic is necessary to interrogate the wizard and to get them to swap back afterwards. If the wizard succeeds his saves, you then have a resurrected wizard. Hope you didn't leave any spellbooks on the body.

[@jaceg810]

I would like to make one addendum: The spell can be used, not only on mundane jars of mayonnaise (actually, only if you have mayonnaise worth over 500 gold), however also on any sufficiently valuable gemstone or reliquary. It does not specify this gemstone needs to be nonmagical, so one could, say, make their magic jar the "indestructible crystal staff of awesomeness", and, if you put a magic aura on it masking that it is being affected by a spell, you not only got your budget lichdom with a mostly shatterproof container. But also have a guarantee that at some point someone important will probably hear of this great relic of old, go find it, only for this person to be body snatched.

[@dawildbear]

Ye ye ye, so how much mayonnaise is 500g? What if the jar is worth 500g then any amount of mayonnaise will do? What if the mayonnaise is on the outside of the jar so I can lure in victims with the sweet, delicious taste?

[@gege0298]

@@dawildbear Could set up a honeypot operation. Except, you know. With mayonnaise.

[@ToonedMinecraft]

I'd pick some kind of necklace, as that seems a lot harder to lose than a staff. I'd prefer an adamantine necklace but if you can find something truly indestructible, that might be better. Are there artifact gemstones/necklaces? Orb of Dragonkind seems to be the only one :P.

[@dawildbear]

Ok so I googled it and apparently "1gp = $536.37" and I'm not gonna question that. So 500gp would only be $268k of mayonnaise so assuming an exchange of $5/l, we only need to acquire 53.6l of sweet sweet mayo. 2 gallons is approximately 9l if we're talking imperial gallons (otherwise 7.6l), so it'd only take 6 days (or 8) for an alchemist jug to dispense the required mayonnaise.

[@GR20000]

@@dawildbear $268k of mayo would be 268185 L of mayo

[@TheDeadmandoo]

In a previous campaign one of my players was turned into a jar of Vegemite, she still could fight as a Warrior Jar (think Elden Ring), but was weak to bludgeoning damage. Took her nearly 4 months to undo that. Was possibly the most Australian D&D experience I have ever had.

[@orlandoriviere2]

My dm once gave us a great encounter in an insane asylum with a guy who thought he was a lich trapped in his own phylactery but had actually just been jarred

[@loganb7059]

An alternative, not evil use of this could be as a sort of wizard conscious data library. Like you need information from some Wiznar the magnificent who lived a full, happy life and decided to “donate his soul” so to speak. You contact the librarian, they find the correct jar, and temporarily switch souls with the wizard. You get your info, the wizard goes back in the jar, and you go on your way. Maybe they’ve tweaked the spell a bit for safety, like if the host tries to leave the building they go back automatically or there’s a time limit.

[@feralgoblin92]

In one of my campaigns, the BBEG is a necromancer in the process of trying to become a Lich and she used Magic Jar as a key part of her plans. Since she knew she would need multiple lifetimes to accomplish the transformation to lichdom, she made multiple clones that she could jump to whenever she unalived. But, assuming that she would gain some powerful enemies in the process, she used Magic Jar to possess about a dozen people over a few years, each time making a Clone using that person's body before swapping back to the jar and unaliving the "donor". So now whenever she dies, she jumps to a Clone of a different body, so no one knows who she will be when she comes back.

[@t2i3m4]

Pair it with simulacrum, party kills a wizard, he poofs into some magical bullshit and they loot a potion off his body. In another encounter they go to drink it and bam, evil wizards back. I wouldnt do a health potion, as theyd already be injured but maybe a charm or strength one, as theyre rarely used when hp is low.

[@NetherStray]

"He's poisoned and low on health! He reaches in his pocket, but as he pulls out a healing potion, the poison does its work and kills him. The potion rolls away from his lifeless hand as he hits the ground." _Five sessions later_ "Our barbarian keeps acting strangely and is making a lot of these int checks... What's going on with that?"

[@bskec2177]

For safety, you could keep a couple of them in a bank. You know, the Jar-Jar Banks.

[@seanfulldark]

But that's how jar jar binks became Darth jar! The true mastermind sith Lord that caused the downfall of the Republic

[@Einola_0.0]

how rude

[@warmachine5835]

This is getting out of hand. Now there are two [jar based puns]

[@ketsuekikumori9145]

"Your players don't deserve this." Debatable.

[@korbinkepner7264]

This reminds me of that creepy post after Mario odyssey was revealed, where old man on his death bed gave his son his hat, and then possessed him saying “there are no more game overs”

[@asgrahim9164]

He turned himself into a jar. Funniest shit I've ever seen.

[@princephantom1294]

Alternatively, charm your target to accept a nystuls magic aura and change any creature’s creature type into humanoid. Now, you can swap bodies with literally anything!

[@grayrook8637]

And insult to injury it was the jar that guy kept his farts in.

[@Alistair5861]

Oh man it was fart in a jar Martins jar that makes it 10 times worse

[@accursedblackmage]

It's like my mother always used to say: You can keep all your farts in a bag, but you'll never truly appreciate the first time you let it rip.

[@nathangamble125]

@@Alistair5861 At least he only farted in a jar 1 time in 4th grade. Imagine if it was some disgusting person who farted in a jar multiple times, or even worse, queefed in a can!

[@Fallenmonkd20]

I'm real sorry guys

[@TheBigFormerlyPurpleT]

What sorcery is this?

[@Jamison-kh5wu]

How were you here a day ago wyf

[@Fallenmonkd20]

@@Jamison-kh5wu feywild time stuff

[@changingpeopleslivesmoon2993]

Good

[@Jamison-kh5wu]

@@Fallenmonkd20 makes sense

[@ThrallJo]

I always thought of this spell as a way to do some cool infiltration. Your group kidnaps a member of some organization you're against and gets the wizard to possess them, and now they're an inside man and can't be caught with stuff like detect magic and the like. Very evil, very good potential.

[@Trivial_Whim]

It's sort of like they failed at becoming a lich. Instead of the mind staying in the body and the soul moving, they accidentally moved the everything.

[@derpherp1810]

"Yeah, I hate it when people say I am "not a real lich" like do they even know how hard that shit is? Yeah call me lazy, I got a jar of dirt with my soul in it and you don't and you will never find it." "Meanwhile all my friends are liches or archmages or whatever and I am just a soul in a jar. Man it sucks to just be "that guy who's soul is in a jar", its so reductive and dehumanizing" "Yeah I can make you immortal, you got a jar and fiftybucks?"

[@Neutral_Tired]

Fun idea: Cast Clone on the barbarian, cast Clone on yourself, cast Magic Jar on yourself, inhabit the Barbarian clone. Carry the jar with you, if you die you return to the jar, if the jar breaks you die and inhabit the clone of yourself, if the barbarian dies you can share custody of the barbarian clone until you can reach your own body and inhabit that instead, then repeat the process

[@AmaraTheBarbarian]

The best part of this is it doesn't have to be a jar and probably couldn't be since it specifies it has to be an ornamental container worth at least 500gp. You could have your container made of some very nice and durable materials so you don't generally fear destruction of the vessel. The idea that I thought of is, imagine your campaigns BBEG or at least some kind of BEG, is humanoid. You can jar yourself before the fight and have your party throw you at them or have a sneaky character place you somewhere they would go. You are now a soul trap hand grenade/land mine.

[@mehonizer]

I feel like this can be used as a fun way to give away your character in higher level campaigns. Like "I don't want to play this character anymore" and someone else goes "Ooh but I do". Highly unlikely, but y'know, fun.

[@anthonysliger5563]

There are 3 uses i think can of. 1. Allow you to play as a humanoid monster. Example a goblin. 2. character in a jar. Have your backup character come from the jar. 3. Fake death. There is a spell that can cast another spell when trigger conditions are matched and have it thrown your soul in the jar before you die.

[@FirstLast-cg2nk]

Of all the forms of undeath, this one is the one you'd pick if you don't want to give up on the pleasures of life. A lich is powerful, but cannot taste or feel. The jar allows you to go on living while at the same time escaping death, and escaping death is ultimately what it has always been about.

[@kylepessell1350]

Note that your soul's aging only stops when you are in jar form which means after a couple lifetimes the Marut are going to take notice and come for you.

[@josephwilliams5292]

“A Lich is powerful but cannot taste or feel” headcanon

[@angelic8632002]

So you put a bunch of bad people to sleep indefinitely. Stash them with the jar in a bunker like building deep underground and reach practical immortality. Just snag another body if the one you are using expires. Or if you just want to play as many different assumed identities like a spymaster or something.

[@gege0298]

My favourite TTRPG, Nephilim, has you play as this pretty much! You're a spirit that's existed for most of eternity, but around the middle, humanity rose up and forced you into a jar. You have to steal someone's body whenever you're not in the jar, and when they die you have to switch body, get back in the jar or dissipate. The game takes place in Real World Earth But Fucked Up à la WoD, and you can pull from historical periods your character was incarnated in for skills rather than having full stat sheets (e.g. "I pull from my XVIIth Century Charlatan incarnation to convince this guy that those pearls are Totally Real")

[@naturegirl1999]

This sounds fun

[@schachmaster]

My brother once used it in a Pathfinder 1e game to trap the soul of a solar angel so he could then possess its body as his own. This was also mid-flight, so he left the jar to fall to the ground thousands of feet below.

[@sharksam8583]

Funniest method to achieve immortality in all of fiction.

[@EGOHVCbcn]

I feel like this spell (with some homebrew finaggling from the DM to make it work) would be really cool for a backstory as someone who got their soul sucked out of their body and then left in the jar for a while before some other people found it by accident, somehow swapped with that person, and then are trying to find the evil wizard running around the world in your body while also protecting a jar with the poor dude who you accidentally body swapped with so you can both have your bodies back

[@JAY-gl5xd]

Who does this? A wizard who is trying to delay damnation. Great uncle Gannondolf made a devil's deal, but doesn't want to pay up now that his time has come. So he stashed his soul into an urn that gets handed down through generations to the least liked nephew.

[@izzyv830]

I feel like this could work I lot like how you described rogue intilect devoured, just hopping from body to body stealing all the knowledge of all of them.

[@samfish2550]

I feel like somehow surviving the attepted kill/reswap could be a fun oragin story for a oath of vengeance paladin who has it out for all practitioners of the arcane arts and preserved goods alike.

[@EvelynNdenial]

0:01 the night after eating fantasy taco bell

[@WoobooRidesAgain]

A benevolent twist for the magic jar idea would be one I'd shamelessly rip off from the Star Wars B'omar Monks: A religious order of monks whose oldest and most venerated members are eventually soul jar'd of their own volition so they can exist in a bodyless state when they are at the end of their lives, cutting them off from the temptation of the flesh in order to contemplate the higher mysteries of the universe or their faith to better attain enlightenment without distraction while still being around to offer their wisdom if they so choose. They possess mid-rank monks who willingly offer their bodies to the spirits of the venerated elder monks when they need to speak directly to their fellow monks for a while, but are otherwise left in sanctified peace in a shrine within the monastery, perhaps placed near their mummified bodies preserved in meditative poses (or even IN their bodies, in hollows cut into their chests perhaps).

[@fmor2779]

As if the risk of an oil lamp or a mirror isn't enough, we have to be suspicious of the peanut butter jars XD

[@tricktrade6767]

How about a dungeon where there is no traps, well there are but they're inactive...at the end is a ton of gold... and a jar of seemingly magical ooze... the person who picks it up immediately loses due to wizard bull, and now they are possessed and they secretly have to activate all the traps and get out

[@timebrain3188]

Its for those who wish for immortality but can’t afford to become a lich. Or, alternatively, an evil wizard curses a hero/adventurer to be stuck as a jar, a fate made worse knowing that in order to do anything they have to swap places with some unknowing fool.

[@zacharygurney3402]

Theres one more terifying thing you havent realized with Magic Jar. Gold dragons. Gold dragons can shapeshift into a humanoid, and when they do their have that creatures stat block (other than a few things like mental stats) INCLUDING their creature type. But the best part? They retain their shapechange ability. Which means you can possess the body of an ancient gold dragon in their humanoid form, then shapeshift into the gold dragon with at least 11 wizard levels.

[@jkillyleagh953]

Our game had an interesting use for magic jar, one of our players was playing someone actively dying of old age, so he cast magic jar and stuffed his soul into a warforged's body. Suddenly he was immortal. Or at least immune to aging. He didn't quite get he wasn't indestructible until a few sessions in (our other wizard said "yeah you can still die")

[@MagicScientist]

There are several spells in the player's handbook that are really more there for the DM to use as a plot device, not for the players. Magic Jar is one of them.

[@0hate9]

I'm like 90% sure I remember there being a racial feat set in pathfinder *specifically* based around this spell. EDIT: ok I just checked and I remembered right. it's "demonic possession" and later "improved possession". the first requires you to be a demon with 21 cha and 17 wis, and gives you magic jar as a spell-like-ability once per day, and the second requires the first and 25 charisma, and improves the ability. if you're a venerable (really really old) human and ideally-allocate your skill points, you can have 23 cha and 17 wis at level 1 (and 10 int, 5 str, and 6 dex and con, but we don't need those so much). at level 1 we can take racial heritage: babau to make us a demon, and demonic possession. then at level 8 (well, 9, since you don't get a feat at 8) (or after otherwise obtaining 2 more points of cha), we can take improved possession. oh, and those skill points I mentioned are only if you're using 25 skill points. many games go higher (and a few go lower - you *can* do this with 20 skill points, but you'll have *even lower* physical scores).

[@curtisthornsberry4236]

Used this spell when my wizard got infected with an illithid tadpole back in 3.5. Little bastard activated my trap card.

[@jacobtamisari8570]

i actually did this to my party. the wizard just used it to body swap a bunch to escape being killed by the party, then when he was clear, he stashed the jar in a pocket dimension so it was safe. he was plotting his return when we ended the campaign. good spell, really fun.

[@merovetouchstone]

I dunno about later editions but initially, that spell is just a part of the process. To become a lich, you mummify your corpse then animate it, then possess it back. You can also use planar binding to bargain for better bodies, or possess certain constructs.

[@justadude450]

Play as the Jar. Whenever your character dies, have your party take it to the next victim and possess the new character without having to make new lore.

[@coryscout1]

I've always wanted to make a character like this, it'd make for a very interesting play style. Playing as a character that's functionally immortal, but would definitely be considered and evil, body snatching necromancer that's to be hunted down and slain by an order of paladins. So the goal would be to remain inconspicuous and hide your jar using abjuration spells like nystuls magic aura and nondetection. It just wouldn't mesh with a party very well as you can't keep this secret from them for long and if any of them are good they just wouldn't like you or want you around.

[@kjj26k]

I doubt it would gel with even an evil group, as they would be at least jealous of your longevity.

[@gromph4]

Do you think souls in jars have the consistency of runny honey or set honey.

[@MichaelPalpatine]

Idk but, "Runny Honey" is a pretty good band name!

[@novaiscool1]

I see this as a spell a wizard keeps in their back pocket for an emergency. Say magical protections youve cast on your fortress have failed, and you know you cant defeat the people coming to destroy you. So you cast this spell on a jar hidden away in the walls of your fortress and later on take over the body of someone that finds it

[@avakio19]

Lorewise, I am under the impression that the spell is a necessity for making a Phylactery, as the Phylactery functions in a similar manner but at much better range and much greater range of success. There was a whole process in older editions, but obviously they haven't released any details on how to become a lich for 5e canon yet, so don't know if that's still up to date. I once used Magic Jar for taking over a barbarian's body from a player who was about to leave the campaign. Let me tell you, its nice having that d12 hit points. As a gnome wizard, the Charisma save was still reasonably easy to make when it did come up. The only thing that sucked was needing a separate clone jar for the host body and my wizard. Also Flesh to Stone is certainly not in an instant, it takes its sweet time to happen at best. Never seen anyone use it against anything that wasn't like a commoner or something that would easily fail the back to back saves. It is decidedly less useful than Magic Jar.

[@JJM-jh9oh]

One lich, two jars.

[@megablazeiken8977]

There is actually a canon Forgotten Realms villain who is a Magic Jar user. I think the spell worked a little different in older editions because her lore/flavor text doesn't exactly match the 5e spell. Her name is Aumathra, and her shtick is that she is revered by a clan of orcs who every 100 years or so capture a young woman who looks like how Aumathra did when she was alive and bring her to the 'jar' (which is actually Aumathra's sarcophagus with Magic Jar cast on it) and the young woman is possessed. Aumathra then leads the orcs to battle, raiding the surrounding countryside until she is eventually 'slain', at which point she returns to the jar/sarcophagus.

[@Daktangle]

It's Pound Shop Lichdom.

[@dantefrance-stradiota1360]

I can see this spell not being used for villainous ends, but more self sacrificial. I am picturing a prosperous village that has been around for centuries, and the villagers grant this prosperity to a wise a benevolent spirit who aid them, the catch being it must inhabit another to communicate and help, many volunteer for this at the local shrine. In reality the spirit is a ancient wizard born in the town who's legend is lost to time, and after a tragedy, made his jar and hid it in the shrine. A way to loop a campaign into it is the wizard is tho only being old enough to remember a crucial fact on defending against a equally ancient threat, however, in the years of being many people and a jar, their sense of time is warped, and can't tell if something happens last week or 500 years ago nor with whom, leading the party on a hunt for items and stories of the wizards first life to jog their memories

[@ObeyBunny]

So, I've known about this spell in a vague, half remembered way from another channel's D&D deep dive. I always assumed it was the earlier form of the Lych spell, complete with a phylactery and a need to "consume" other living people.

[@Groovebot3k]

Okay but imagine a curse that did sort of the opposite: You pass by a jar or something and instantly everything goes dark, and when you regain consciousness everything you see is from the perspective of some wizard who has turned himself into a walking vessel that traps souls in his own body... you have no influence on the wizard whatsoever and no voice to cry out in resistance, only unblinking eyes to watch whatever depravity (or insipidity) the wizard gets up to for an amount of time before being shunted back to your body, possibly even drained and exhausted from the endeavor. As a spell itself, say that as the wizard who casts the spell, you gain the prepared magics (spell slots, magical abilities, enchantments, etc) of the soul you trap in your body for a time, and are unaffected by going without rest except to refresh spell slots (which are theoretically covered by trapping the soul)... when they're released, they suffer the exhaustion you would have instead.

[@Oree_Nabisko]

I always assumed this spell was a failed attempt at becoming a necromancer.

[@IAmOnFyre]

failed attempt? You have to be a pretty powerful necromancer to cast it, and then youget another lifetime to get even better at necromancy before swapping again!

[@Oree_Nabisko]

@@IAmOnFyre Yeah, but I thought that the creation of the spell in the first place was the failed attempt. That a wizard on his journey to becoming a necromancer had developed this spell along the way. And that’s why this spell is in the school of necromancy.

[@johandori7795]

@@Oree_Nabisko Necromancer is "person who uses magic relating to death", I think you're probably thinking of "Lich", which is "necromancer who used magic to rip out their own soul and trap it in a powerful magical object that can regenerate their now undead body if it is destroyed" This magical object is a "phylactery", and apparently according to 2E, it uses Magic Jar as one of the elements to make it.

[@Oree_Nabisko]

@@johandori7795 Yeah. I should have said lich. I

[@pyromaniac000000]

Realize this would be FAR scarier if it werent limited to dnd, because there is literally no where else that has “saving throws” in real life or literally any other fictional world, it just happens and theres nothing you can do about it!! The wider implications of such an item are TERRIFYING!

[@gambitsheild9814]

Alright, so considering how intense the process is to become a lich, I could see an evil necromancer undertaking to use this spell because its easier than lichdom and they don't have the abilities to complete all the preparations that they would want to in time. Then they would elect to using the host's body to progress up to and including completing the ritual if they could. Also if they are doing the ritual on their own body, but using someone else's, they might get a measure of security in case the ritual goes wrong. That way they aren't turned into a demi lich or something worse.

[@michaelmaki6857]

Narratively I tend to imagine that royal crowns and regalia get this treatment you basically get to be king forever as long as no one manages to kill you in your sleep

[@CaptainZlex]

New character idea: A person from ancient times who spent so long in a Magic Jar that they forgot who they were and only got out by happenstance.

[@peterniles8984]

The thing is, the jar doesn't need to be a jar. It needs to be an "ornamental container worth at least 500gp", so you can make a super expensive mythril ring with a tiny little box on it, and make that your jar. You're likely an evil wizard if you're chill with immortality through possession, so grab a "volunteer" as your first new body and cast the spell. Wear the ring around, anyone wanting to kill you will likely just take the ring after you "die" (jump into the ring when you're near death), and you can jump to them at your leisure. It's risky, but easier immortality than becoming a litch

[@JazzJackrabbit]

Magic Jar is an awesome GM spell

[@TheAngmarbucket]

It seems like a useful spell for an antagonist who has nothing left to lose. A PC, not so much.

[@TheXell]

Feels kinda like practice for aspiring liches.

[@bray2964]

One mage. One jar.

[@HeadZonkTV]

This reminds me of H.P. Lovectaft's "the Terrible Old Man. The titular old man had bottles in his house with labels like "Jack, Scar-Face, Long Tom, Spanish Joe, Peters, and Mate Ellis" and when he'd talk to the bottles, the little lead weight inside would vibrate in response.

[@mustange69]

What can be defined as a jar and can you possess monsters like mind flayers, Strahd, dragons and liches? What happens if you're an evil jar, possess someone and then get possessed by a different evil jar. Does knowing the spell grant you any benefit/resistance to possession?

[@AztecCroc]

Humanoids only, so Strahd and some liches yes, dragons and mind flayers no.

[@mustange69]

@@AztecCroc what if the dragon was in human form?

[@kjj26k]

​@@mustange69 I would think that counts. And if it was you who made them that way...

[@MeatyCandy]

Congrats! You are now a discount lich!

[@chocokittybo]

Now I want to create a vigilante character in Pathfinder that's basically just a fighter and a wizard jar acting as a system together. Like they're both on board with the arrangement

[@ContagiousRepublic]

This is where having a true friend helps find your jar a nice body, LOL I smell an evil party theme here...

[@etherraichu]

I like powerful spells that just do one really specific thing. They're always the most fun. my favorite is Ship of Fools. It makes everyone on a boat temporarily forget how to operate a boat. Its such a simple idea, but it can cause a ridiculous amount of chaos. Much like Magic Jar.

[@cammo353]

Now I'm just imagining a scenario where you introduce PC that's a wizard stuck in jar form and through shenanigans, you have 2 players using the jar to share a body to achieve a common goal (maybe for 2 players that have conflicting schedules?)

[@exzyyd392]

Gain someone's trust Offer them a gift Place the jar in their hand Cast Magic Jar Immediately swap to their body Send the jar to another plane Repeat when necessary

[@Kingkent1207]

I think this spell would be a really cool if unpredictable way of breaking into a secure place like a well guarded castle, especially if you are paired with a druid character who can turn into a small animal. Have the druid as a small animal carry the jar into the castle and then switch bodies with a guard and put the jar and small animal into your pocket. Every time you reach a security check point you can't get through or pass someone of higher rank switch bodies with the person above you. You would need to "take care of" the guy whose body you have left behind, but given that you are now of higher rank you can accuse him of being a traitor or something and have his jar and animal "confiscated". If it doesn't go your way have the druid grab the jar and run; you'll both be small enough to hide somewhere out of sight pretty easily. This would admittedly require a lot of luck, but is successful could get you to the right hand of king with the perfect disguise.

[@chaos4654]

The funniest/saddest plot you can have with a Soul In a Jar is the Wizard forgetting who they were and has to piece together their old life while on their new adventure. I say it can be funny, because I'm sure theres a lot of punchlines you can make before, during, and after they become a Soul in a Jar.

[@FanOfMostEverything]

I was neither mentally nor emotionally prepared for a Dash jar reference in a Runesmith video. Good God, man.

[@Birdsflight44]

Imagine this getting flipped into the most wholesome, middle school chapter book altogether- a jar of Smuckers that gets passed around, and helps kids with their homework, ace their piano recital, and helps the kid in the hospital passively come along in Jar form to the school camping trip.

[@godzilla80192]

Someone could just magically clone themselves and use the jar to inhabit the same body everytime

[@jasonbarry3301]

The kind of person who turns themselves in to a jar is every person who plays a casters but needs divine spell casting explained to them

[@winter945]

8 was waiting for the jar joke but I didn't expect it to be the entier mlp jar there

[@jonskowitz]

And as of now the BBEG of my next campaign will be the dark wizard, Grap D'Jelli.

[@MemphiStig]

Being a wizard, you could try to divine when your current body is going to die and just swap out before then, like your volcano scenario, only you can get out any time before the end. Also divine someone to jump into that isn't going to die for a long time. Repeat forever. Or until the murderhobos catch up with you. They're probably the only thing that can kill you at that point.

[@mecha-sheep7674]

Any dispel magic may insta-kill you.

[@Connorses]

I imagine there's like a cult who worships the immortal jar wizard and they keep it safe and whenever the leader needs a new body for any reason, a cultist willingly fails their charisma saving throw to let the jar wizard possess them that's how your villain guarantees he won't like, fail to possess someone and get his jar destroyed or dispelled.

[@ShiftySetax]

Bruh, the end of the video was UNCALLED FOR. I HAD TO LOOK THAT UP LOGAN!

[@M.Datura]

It is a terrifying spell, that's for sure, but anything with great potential often is. There are scenarios where this can be really, really good to use, especially with some leeway, which DnD has so much of. It does hard vibe as a lich spell from first impression though.

[@Zakvadr1995]

Actually, this is an interesting Chaotic character idea KENNY FROM SOUTH PARK! They show up as a normal party level character, with half the hit points and never raise them. When they fail the Death Saving throw, they just change to the Jar and let their old body perish while taking a new one that the party is fighting. Leaving a total WTF from the party and being able to play as regular new characters!

[@TheKamenZero]

You say not to use this spell as a DM, but I thought of a possible scenario that *could* be fun. Hear me out. Deep in some runious dungeon, a party encounters a room with six ornate jars on a pedistal in the middle of the room, one of which is our funny Magic Wizard Jar. We'll get to the other five in a moment. Uppon approaching the pedistal, the magic jar will attempt to posses the party one by one until it succeeds in snatching a body. Now this particular Wizard's Soul has been down here in this deep and dark dungeon for a very long time. Long enough that any sense of reason has left them causing them to be utterly insane and attack the rest of the party should they sucssed in getting a body. If they don't, then this encounter changes dynamics a bit. More on that later. Now this is an assumption based upon my players and how I know they operate/think, so milage may vary. But once an ally starts attacking them for no reason after the DM asks for a Charisma Save, they're gonna know something's up, and they'll likely suspect the random jars that are on display. And with a party member attacking them, they might think to smash the jars. Smashing (or just opening) the Wizard's jar results in the spell ending and the effected party member getting their body back. Easy peasy, encounter over. Well what about the other five jars? Well, originally my plan was for them to just be decoys, empty jars with nothing special about them. But then I thought "What if these jars also had souls in them?" So if any of the other jars are broken/open, a Ghost comes out of it. Just the standard C4 Ghost from the Monster Manual, or some other kind of spirit/elemental enemy that could reasonably be stored in a magic jar, that part is up to you. Maybe something weaker or stronger depending on how difficult you want this encounter to be. Or maybe one of the ghosts is friendly and will help the party out, just to lower the difficulty a bit if you think this encounter is to mean. And putting ghosts/some other enemy in the other jars provides a possible encounter if the Wizard fails to posses every member of the party. "You don't just put six jars on a pedistal for no good reason," the party will think, and they'll investigate on their own. Which will lead to some version encounter one way or another. Is this a well designed encounter? I have no idea. I'm still a fairly new and inexperienced DM, so this encounter could be utter garbage or it could be genius. I honestly have no idea. But after listening to this video and hearing what was up with this nonsense spell, I couldn't help but think up a "fair" way to throw it at my players. I do plan on throwing this at my players at some point, especially considering they have a high charisma bard who *should* be able to sucssed the Charisma Save if nothing else, but I have no idea how it will go. Feel free to use/modify this idea in your own games if you end up liking it, or you can reply to this comment and tell me how much of a stinky doodoo brain I am for designing this trash encounter.

[@christianbradley6960]

I made a character that eventually became based around this spell, he lost his original body and just kept hopping between new ones when convenient, he got so good at it he was able to modify the spell allowing him to possess a dragon in the end, truly every kobolds dream.

[@br0wneyedsusan]

We were playing the first edition bloodstone series and we were right at the part where you had to use the battle system to do this huge two army fight and we took a break. My DM was really looking forward to running the war and I looked through the spells available to my very powerful wizard. Set up contingency to teleport my body should it ever lay on the floor for longer than a second back to my lair. I put vocalize on, so I didn’t have to speak out loud I put greater invisibility on, silence, and then I teleported without error to the enemy kingdoms capital right beside their ruler. Cast time stop at which point I cast feeble mind upon him and then put the jar on the guy’s lap and cast magic jar. When time starts, my body fell on the floor, invisible and teleported home while I hopped into the the feebleminded evil king. Called my generals together to organize a meeting to discuss peace and war averted

[@JoelReid]

A DM can use this on a player who is gettign bored with their class. basically you have them find the jar, then pass them a note to explain what has occurred... and emphasize they have to keep it secret (unless they think the party will go along with the fact the player is now a different person and has squashed the personality of their character). Even more fun would be watching the rest of the party begin to question why the player seems so attached to a jar...

[@Jakewake52]

As a player the two main uses I can think of for this are stealth break-ins or infeltrstion of enemy bases or the much funnier, get the strongest most unbreakable jar possible and have a teammate throw your soul onto groups of enemies or the main target so youre functionally teleporting and possessing them, or youre trying to possess everyone on the way over if theyre close enough- make the wizard a good actor and they can do the alax mercer in Prototype accusation where you call out one of the randomers or the boss as having been possessed in hopes everyone else joins in attacking them

[@umbra4540]

i had the idea for a civilization that used to store their elders in magic jars to preserve their knowledge. of course the civilization collapses, and almost all the jars break, but at least one survives to get found by an archeologist who's studying ancient necromancy, and they agree to some mutually beneficial bodysharing