Who can Draft a pitching staff with the lowest ERA? (NL Central Edition)

[@BananaSlicesForSure]

Can’t believe Dalton called that Chris Carpenter sequence lol

[@EthanC_09]

They should’ve let him have ‘09 just because they kind of talked him into ‘05 and he called it lol

[@BananaSlicesForSure]

@@EthanC_09 i agree lol. Too good to not let him have that

[@jdmorno]

The Lucas cam is the best addition to this series. He looks so happy during the "Is he there in 21 and is he good?" 😂

[@G8rSox95]

This was the funniest/best JM Baseball video in a minute! Between Dalton NAILING the Carpenter years and the "Coming 'round the Mountain" parody, comedy gold!

[@ByiLHS]

"I'm odd" "I'm even" "I'm Ryan" That made me crack up 😆

[@Saberlion]

Jolly you need to do a compilation video of the best reactions from these games. The Dalton one was peak comedy.

[@Vichewy]

LYRICS: is he there in '21 and is he good? is he there in '21 and is he good? is he there in '21? is he there in '21? is he there in '21 and is he good?

[@MatteR8]

I feel bad for everyone else bc Jolly never participated in the chant. He's a sore loser and should be hated by the community

[@RonyTambo4211]

Karaoke hit?

[@jotar4120]

I think Lucas gave Dalton Johnny Cueto's 2011 season, 2014 he had a 2.25 over 243.2 innings

[@davidbeenjammin]

Yeppppp......

[@dylancasalino637]

Yes he did.

[@DJforHeisman]

Yeah, he for sure did

[@Smallsey42]

They forgot about Roger Clemens in 2005. He had a 1.87 ERA in 211.1 innings in the NL Central.

[@frivolousbaseball]

I don't think they could technically use him, since they've been playing with a rule that they have to use one starter from every (current) team and there's only 5 starters. However, I think they could have justifiably used, say, Billy Wagner or Octavio Dotel.

[@wisyanksfangaming3434]

They have used the rule where they can use the Astros in place of another team

[@danielerickson7649]

@@frivolousbaseball They've done it in the past with other videos.

[@killacam2644]

Uhhhh Cueto had a 2.25 era in 243.2 ip Runner up to MVP Kershaw.

[@ScreamingRamen]

is he there and is he good was maybe in my top 5 favorite jomboy media moments. up there with dan rourke and jolly's walkoffs

[@jacobrichards3855]

I hope this got fixed later but 2014 Cueto was A LOT better than the 2011 year Dalton was given.

[@TheTEN24]

That dalton part was incredible man that’s something id do lmao

[@fredrichinkle8758]

You just can't miss 2005 Roger Clemens at 1.80 ERA for 221 innings and 2003 Billy Wagner at 1.78 for 86 innings. And they're both so safe because there's only two Clemens years and they're both amazing, and only like 4 Wagner seasons and they're also all amazing.

[@SuperCarFan-we2ug]

They also missed the best pitching season of all time, 68 bob gibson

[@BMAN0310]

these kids forget the astros were nl central

[@harrisonbaylor1432]

Brad Lidge 2004 was really good also. 1.90 era with 94.2 innings. Tom of innings for a relief pitcher.

[@GaryDodgerfan]

Gibson didn't pitch since 2000. As for Houston, they need to set rules about using them in these drafts and then remind each other. My suggestion for a draft like this would be that you are permitted to choose a Houston SP in place of another team, but then you must take a reliever from the missing team.

[@Mossman0302]

You guys should've just given Dalton the '09 Carpenter season after that, that was just incredible

[@themoeshow1343]

Dalton’s first pick was the most impressive thing I’ve ever seen 😂

[@brianmack2945]

New draft idea, longest home run. I feel like it's way more random but has room for a lot of fun guesses.

[@rustyalbrecht3034]

Dalton’s 50/50 / guessing skills are off the charts. 🤣

[@the51geese38]

I feel some kind of rivalry between Jolly and Shelf, especially after yesterday’s crazy game!

[@jakobtg8452]

These are filmed like months in advance I’m pretty sure

[@suckafatty7790]

Why are we talking about shelf when he aint even in the video lmfao

[@MatteR8]

​@jakobtg8452 usually these vids are recorded 1 month in advance. That being said, I still think jolly should be fired from JM.

[@EthanC_09]

@@MatteR8why, what happened?

[@jakobtg8452]

@@MatteR8 why I really like jolly

[@severfieldtv1224]

GIVE DALTON THE '09 CARPENTER YEAR SINCE HE CALLED IT SO CLEANLY

[@severfieldtv1224]

never mind, 50 extra innings makes me rescind my statement

[@IamtheSifu]

The Chris Carpenter pull was INSANE LOL

[@samuelpickle4135]

Banger Video, Cant wait to see Ryan dominate the All Time Draft next week

[@ironn0c]

kevin siegrist was a victim of the Matheny era where he shoved the same pitcher out non stop until theyre arms fell off lmao...i was hoping someone pulled Stone Buddha aka Seungwhan Oh in 2016 1.92 Era with 79 innings

[@dingo535]

Couldn’t but chuckle at Jolly’s “I actually feel bad…”.

[@DanielHensley-1996]

Dalton should have gotten Chis Carpenter’s 05 innings and 09 ERA since he nailed it

[@thestonedog69]

I love the attempt at Kevin Siegrist jolly really surprised me that he’s even heard of my guy Kev

[@dgood1062]

50/50 Dalton is undefeated

[@craign8464]

CC Sabathia fir the Brewed in 2008 was dominant after being traded for and still had a respectable 130 innings.

[@JakeWellsRacing]

That was insane by Dalton!

[@dshiesty1871]

I put the video on 2x speed right at 10:50 on accident and it was the greatest thing 🤣🤣

[@TonyGarciaxProdigy1994]

Dalton at 2:39 was wild LOL

[@andrewfarelli9241]

I'm surprised no one said 2004 Oliver Perez, 2004 Ben Sheets those guys were nasty that year

[@j66gv]

Dalton said Hendricks has been bad ever since 2016? No man. He was very good up until 2021. He was even solid in 2023.

[@KHGorman]

DALTON FEELY MASTERCLASS PICK OF CARP OMGGGGG

[@RockyMtnRebecca]

Oh Jolly - OUCH @ 16:39!

[@lilsleepy3332]

best draft video yet. so many classic moments 😂

[@MatteR8]

It would be better without hearing jollys voice

[@Cardsfan5]

2018 Miles Mikolas, 2016 Carlos Martinez, Kyle Lohse 2012, lance lynn 2014, John Lackey 2015

[@hiyapyth]

2019 Giovanny Gallegos, 2015 Trevor Rosenthal, 2016 Seunghwan Oh, 2014 Pat Neshek, and 2011 Fernando Salas are all great reliever picks too

[@CristopherSmith-zr7uh]

Bob Gibson '85 1.12 ERA

[@bencramer2869]

@@CristopherSmith-zr7uh ‘68* lol

[@CristopherSmith-zr7uh]

​@@bencramer2869lol im not sure why i put 85, but at least ya knew what i meant haha

[@kristopherwilson506]

@@CristopherSmith-zr7uhit’s since 2000

[@spencermuffler]

As a Brewers fan it is funny to see these guys struggle a bit in the NL Central drafts haha

[@mernest6835]

sd loves ryan

[@logani54]

Here's where no one takes 04 Sheets and we all get mad

[@kevinlane7923]

The best series!!!

[@kevinhinkle7632]

The Roger Clemens 05 omission was criminal

[@Elunder105]

Yall should do this live and set a moneyline for the participants and us the viewers be able to bet on who’s gonna win 🥇 😂

[@itsBrunk]

Another NL Central video where I’m yelling Carlos Marmol at the top of my lungs

[@ryoryo9936]

I don’t know if it’s been suggested before, but I think a salary draft would be fun. Whoever picks a lineup with the biggest salary wins.

[@SDCarlin]

Houston Astros were in the NL Central until 2012, and Brad Lidge had some crazy years.

[@TimothyTylerThomason]

where the astros? 2004 Brad Lidge, 2005 Roy Oswalt, 2005 Roger Clemens, 2003 Billy Wagner, 2005 Andy Pettite

[@Bladedamus]

They didn’t get their usual reminder from Lucas so they probably forgot lol.

[@TheLastPrime38]

I forgot lol so they probably did also.

[@PHXNKVHXLIC]

Just waiting on the batting average versus splitters between 80-82 mph draft NL East Version

[@zachmiller1175]

No Jason Isringhuasen is crazy lol

[@daltonroberts6700]

For the next pitching draft you guys should do wins for the starters plus saves for the relievers

[@Blakelyboy21392]

Billy Hamilton, Roy Oswalt, Wandy Rodriguez, Roger Clemons, Andy Petitte I’m surprised no loopholes were picked.

[@sixfourrecords]

The 2005 Derrick Turnbow and 2004 Ben Sheets erasure makes me sad.

[@andydavidson6673]

IS HE THERE IN '21 AND IS HE GOOD

[@jasonb809]

10:47 banger

[@KrennyLavitzz]

Hahaha Dalton. Wild bruh

[@bergentrueckung_2557]

Hector Rondon had a sneaky good season for the Cubs in 2015👀

[@mfdixon1985]

Kerry Wood's 20 K game was 1998

[@bensweetra4871]

HOWWW DALTONNNNN?

[@croke835]

You guys should do a 2024 theme after you do the schedule you have planned, you can do all of the draft themes you already did, but expand the pitchers to 6 so one from each division

[@prestonjones20013]

The lack of NL Central knowledge here is insane😂 2017 Wade Davis, 2016 Jon Lester, 2015 AJ Burnett, 2008 Ryan Dempster, 2010 Jaime García, 2015 John Lackey, 2014 Lance Lynn, 2015 Trevor Rosenthal, 2004 Ben Sheets, 2011 Jeff Samardzija, 2015 Hector Rondon (he was insane), 2014 Pedro Strop, 2018 Jeremy Jeffress (he was even more insane). All of these really good seasons went unmentioned, much less unpicked

[@StatMatt]

Forgetting that the Astros were available cost them some very good seasons from Oswald, Clemens, Wagner, and Lidge.

[@jonathanterrell4506]

Joe Kelly was a starter and a reliever in 2013. 2.69 over 124 IP. Would have been interesting to see how that would have been handled. Also, 2004 Ben Sheets.

[@6Snaus]

I was waiting for someone to say Sheets. He was dominant, best 12-6 curve I've ever seen.

[@jonathanterrell4506]

⁠@@6Snaus Only reason I remembered that year for Sheets was because he had 18 strikeouts in a game against the Braves

[@DumpsterM0nkey6]

Can't believe Jolly didn't go with former Met Jason Ishringhausen

[@AllanBProductions]

Finally done with the confusing ERA draft.

[@jockgreens9452]

Jolly stop reminding the brewers lost in 21. Im not even over this year yet. We are them most cursed playoff team in baseball rn and its not even close

[@paulabbottii6937]

If Walter Johnson isn’t chosen first overall that man does not know ball.

[@henrik_klubert300]

can’t believe cc sabathia went in drafted

[@MrBroomStick02]

2018 Jeremy Jeffress

[@MrBroomStick02]

1.29 in 76.2 innings

[@justjoking7756]

I’m late on this. Just thought of a scoring system. Total outs recorded divided by total earned runs given up. Person with highest number wins.

[@josenogames]

Oh man, they forgot '00-'12 Astros. Roger Clemens and Roy Oswalt goes untaken.

[@Shaninski23]

Once Arrieta and Hendricks were gone, I was saying 03 Mark Prior over and over

[@pudge5614]

I think they forgot the cheat code of the Astros, clemens had 1 great year there and Brad Lidge had 1 really good year

[@seryph13]

Jolly, you should require 1 player from each division and no more that 2 from the same division for all time drafts.

[@gibbywierenga7703]

Oh hey Dalt shaved

[@garrettcatalana94]

Were the Astros not eligible for this? 05 Clemens, some really good Oswalt seasons, even Brandon Backe, plus Billy Wagner!

[@garrettkroells8292]

Playoff Home run per player per division next please.

[@JippyDove]

Next do strikeouts by batter or pitcher walks

[@jonietrombonie]

Put myself in Dalton's shoes (3rd pick OVR, can't take anyone already drafted by the time his picks come up including his own selections) and I came up with this: Pick 3: Hendricks ’16 (2.13, 190 IP) Pick 4: Wainwright ’14 (2.38, 227 IP) Pick 9: Cole ’15 (2.60, 208 IP) Pick 10 to make it spicy: Kimbrel ’21 (0.49, only 36 IP w/Cubs) Pick 15: Gray ’19 (2.87, 175 IP) Pick 16: Woodruff ’21 (2.56, 179 IP) Pick 21: Rosenthal ’15 (2.10, 68 IP) Pick 22: Iglesias ’19 (4.16, 67 IP, yikes) Screwed the pooch on the last one but maybe this’d be enough to win??

[@SuperCarFan-we2ug]

68 BOB GIBSON?????? Best pitching season of all time man

[@chowder-]

this is since 2000

[@SuperCarFan-we2ug]

@@chowder- oh

[@jolamayne]

I was really hoping someone would’ve said 2018 Jeremy Jeffress with the Brewers. I think he beats Melancon for the 2nd RP spot. I bought his jersey that year and then he fumbled the bag for us in the playoffs.

[@johnzengerle7576]

When they do the all time list, how many will be 1969?

[@bencramer2869]

Not sure if the ERA drafts are since 2000, but you gotta at least mention Bob Gibson’s 1.12 in 1968

[@aaronpreuss4261]

I would have loved to see aa Bronson Arroyo shout, same with Jason Isringhousen.

[@lukecurtis537]

is he there in 21 and is he good might go triple platinum

[@yankee2858]

People forget Hader wasn’t the closer in 2018

[@isaiahhainline3840]

Roy Oswalt 2005 was a huge miss they forgot about Astros being NL central

[@LjQuinn-rp2wb]

Surprised no one took skenes this year for the pirates 155innings with a 1.96 era

[@WisconsinSPORTS24626]

How can you all forget about the Houston Astros? Clemens and Oswalt

[@WilliamSt.Clair1399]

22:21 sorry to take the drama away; but I think the era would be 2.78 for Ryan. Even with the Cueto year wrong Dalt had a 2.73.

[@WilliamSt.Clair1399]

It is a little funny that they’ve slandered Cueto saying that’s his 2014, had to have just marked it wrong because they did it at the end too

[@Redsox4444443]

I was screaming 2003 Mark Prior at Ryan….Sadage.

[@grime-ndofficial9894]

Jon Lester 2016. 2.44 over 202. Not going is crazy

[@danielbuck3082]

I write in capitals… like a dad!

[@Chris-jr9eh]

Rodger Clemens 2005 18:18 and Brad lidge 2004

[@hanj31]

no andy petit or roger clemens? they were on the Astros in the NL Central

[@kylelarsen9908]

Havent watched, really hoping someone gets Hector Rondon 2015

[@GaryDodgerfan]

Why does everybody always overlook the fact the Astros are part of this division for half these years?

[@Stoops05]

What next? Win? Double?

[@kristennoll4475]

is he there in 21 and is he good?

[@ybassiouny2005]

need another scattergories

[@coryschulenberg4330]

2014 Tony Watson would have been a good Pirate reliever, 1.63 over 77.1

[@TobySoprano300]

Bob Gibson in the year of the pitcher 1968.