Enrolling in Dutch's Charm School [Red Dead Redemption - Part 17]

[@idanordmark1786]

"We'll charm them," Dutch says, accompanied by the two least socially adept men on the planet.

[@MO-zk8qs]

1:37:32 Arthur’s “what is ittt 🙄” lol

[@uneasyspider]

John genuinely enjoying this game so much that he immerses in roleplay and story is what makes this an S-tier series to watch. I can’t get enough. I started RDR1 on pc, then started RDR2 and just caught up to this playthrough. John, i’m lovin’ it. Can’t wait to see the story unfold.

[@lollove7815]

I could literally watch a whole 3 hours episode of John just riding Tory through the whole map and just talking randomly 😂 RDR 2 podcast

[@gradeApuddin]

I appreciate John's dedication to the little cowboy hat bit.

[@PhlightYagami]

"This game really turns you into a psychopath, doesn't it?" John is learning the beauty of Rockstar Games.

[@cer0876]

Randomly checked youtube to see this posted seconds ago THANK YOUUUU. Watching you play got me to pick this game up again after years of not playing. + 🤠

[@cer0876]

(Also +1 on shaving the beard.... free arthur from that thing...)

[@Superfreaky2]

2:02:28 Micahs voice actor is damn brilliant. The way he speaks with the weird deep breaths in between words sometimes, really adds to his character.

[@samwisegamgee1243]

Agree, the actor did a great job selling him as a scummy douche.

[@cindydragons]

38:27 john quickscoping the guy on accident is so funny

[@Wasserliliensee]

I just started watching and of course Toris mood is calm, poor girl doesnt have the energy to be upset, malnourished as she is 😭

[@mattwoo556]

the amount of times youve gotten yourself in trouble due to the controller/button mapping is hilarious 🤣

[@djbeema]

Honestly can't blame him. Rockstar games are like in their own weird little universe for controller schemes

[@ntp4003]

John, Bald and Beautiful is the drag queen podcast with Trixie Mattel & Katya 😂

[@clayhair]

LMFAOO

[@meanboss14]

I think it's worth pointing out that you missed a couple of camp exchanges between Dutch and Molly that might have added a little more context to her behavior - nothing super expository, trouble in paradise and all that. It's impossible not to miss some things with this game. Loving the playthrough still!

[@amodelmannequin]

"This game really turns you into a psychopath, doesn't it?" - John "High Honor" Wolfe

[@NataliaDeCP]

41:15 When you pick up a new weapon, you'll still have your original one on your horse, even if you leave it on the ground.

[@PaopuDestiny]

"Shave? Y'all wish." lmao, it is so funny how male players tend to have their Arthur grow his beard out as far as it'll go, and then female usually players have their Arthur's clean or short-shaven. It's always so amusing to me, I love it. Thank you for your playthrough, John! I've been watching you for 15 (???) years and have always enjoyed everything you've uploaded. You've introduced me to a lot of games over the years, so it's great watching you play a game I've actually played a ton!

[@tiffinihansen6054]

@PaopuDestiny I literally just took Arthur to the barber 2hrs ago. Short side fade, #2guard for the goatee beard😂❤

[@lossite]

Typically, I like my Arthur with long hair and either a moustache or clean-shaven.

[@rainykanon]

I absolutely hate the long beard but John decides how to have his arthur 😅 also I always watch on my phone so I barely see anything anyways

[@RachelShorkey-rk6tb]

As someone who lives in Michigan fall is one of the best times to visit. Still fair weather, amazing fall leaf colors, cider mills, apple picking, haunted corn mazes, etc. If you go again in the summer Port Huron is a great place for the lake due to seeing all the barges on the water and being able to swim fairly close to them. You can also see the bridge to Canada and some of Canada in that area. Also the Sleeping Bear Dunes are top notch and you can’t miss taking the ferry to Mackinac Island. You can rent a bike to go around the island!(Cars aren’t allowed to avoid polluting the island).

[@jamespurple3637]

Thank god! I was starting to get withdrawals after a week of no rdr2 content 😂

[@MonaMello]

Don't worry about "dropping" guns. Always grab the new pistol cuz the old one will be stored on your horse! You don't actually drop them, but you can miss new ones if you don't pick them up!

[@empressgwenny2097]

couldn't help but hear dutch's book in the voice of a transcendentalist preacher. the last part about nature being a place where you can attune your soul or whatever, reminds me a lot of emerson and other essayists. but i can't really remember how influential transcendentalism was between 1850-1900 etc. just thought it was interesting re: historical vibes in this really fun game!

[@thecaptainsushi0991]

Only 5 minutes in and already John gets himself in trouble lol! Love this playthrough

[@p0t4t3r8]

For the cigarette cards, you'll need a full set before you can sell them. Then when you have a set, I believe you send them in via post like the dino bones. Still loving this playthrough, so happy you're enjoying it too!

[@olmyjulia]

To add to this, you can sell duplicate cards at a fence!

[@AbbaJoe26]

" "Bears, Beets, Battlestar Galactica." " :) Nicely snuck in the quick The Office line, John. Perhaps the best of all bits from that series. Love it. :)

[@nopeoftheworld1271]

the way John just kept speaking over the Thunder and Dutch was the funniest part of this series omg

[@LadyMisalein]

He got no chance against the loudest thing in the rdr universe tho.. : Dutchs Grammophone

[@WolfEX126]

Just want to say I've been a fan for a very long time; your videos are truly a respite for me, and especially so during a difficult time in my life as of late. So happy to see more Red Dead - thank you John ❤️

[@AlexDraut]

Like others have said, The Grand Canyon is worth a trip. But If you're going to AZ, please spend a day in Sedona and Jerome!

[@scarymarilynn]

Jerome was so cool when I visited! The arrangement of the town on the hill, the history, the folk arts!

[@velashimada255]

John, I wanted you to know that you were my #1 most watched on my KZbin gaming rewind. 😊

[@zubrjanusz1153]

another horse tip: while galloping, if you press the calm button every 25-30 seconds (i don't remember exactly, i just spam the button lol) it will replenish quite a bit of Tori's stamina since you're at max level bonding with her. thanks to this, you can run at full speed more or less indefinitely if you time it right. it's a useful thing for the timed challenges and races :)

[@emilyweaver]

John has Arthur looking very much like a member of ZZ Top with the beard and outfit

[@Yvesenjoyer666]

Arthur accidentally rolling against the shooting mini game npc and aggro him took me OUT 😂 another banger ep plus cowboy! micah just ranting his edgelord thinkpieces and none of the characters reacting to it was hilarious, no one gaf micah

[@Emily-xk2du]

Arthur: (forced by the game to be nice to Herr Strauss) John: nooOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!

[@charlfoo]

I love the Mr. Black & Mr. White storyline :)

[@Seihaname]

Anyone else wanna see John use the raiders as victims for the challenge lol

[@BuffyWinch2]

I’ve enjoyed watching this play through! I also just want to say, as a native Memphian, thank you for saying something kind and positive about our city. It’s got its issues of course, every place does, but it’s so refreshing that that’s not all everyone sees. Love Huey’s too!

[@ssss-rt5qu]

The lady Arthur encounters at the foggy cemetery as soon as he steps in is a ghost. It's well known in the RDR2 community

[@coldfooted]

happy thanksgiving, wolfe family! i am so very thankful for this playthrough dropping today ❤️ can't wait to dig in.

[@cemeteryclown8760]

I've been to Estes Park, CO about 4-5 times and I didn't know there was a name for this path, but I knew EXACTLY what treacherous road you're talking about. I still have nightmares about it and Ive only been through it once during a huge snow storm that blocked the main way up. Colorado is my favorite state to visit, though. It's beautiful in every way, even the flora and fauna are amazing. I usually go in the fall but the whole state feels like Christmas morning. You might like Wyoming, but it's like if Colorado was barren, dry, with seemingly no one around and lots of ghost towns. I've lived in Kansas my whole life, and you have no reason to visit if you haven't already been. There's basically no redeeming qualities. Plus we have about 5 months of 100+f heat and 5 months of -0f, the other 2 months are slightly cold but mostly raining. And doesn't matter what season, it's tornadoes alllll year round and severe weather (Flooding, hail, tornado watches) every other week. The heat is probably the most unbearable part for me. On another note, these are the perfect calm videos for me to watch while decompressing. I wasn't super into the game when I played it, but watching you play makes me want to give it another try. (: Hope you had a good thanksgiving John!

[@kat.w.RBF444]

Now I want to visit Colorado. It sounds beautiful. Not that anyone cares, but listening to John made me realize even more that I need to see more of this country and the world. But air travel is very often painful (and expensive) and driving from the East Coast to the middle of the country or further is a bit daunting. Might get an RV and do it in style one day though. I love hearing about people’s impressions of different places in the U.S. and beyond. I’d really like to see Ireland one day, where my ancestors lived and left in search of a better life. This world has so much to see and experience, but you need time and money to see even a quarter of it. I hope I live that long and can save up enough to do even half of what I’d like. If anyone reading this has traveled a lot, you’re lucky and I hope you got lots of photos.

[@cemeteryclown8760]

@@kat.w.RBF444 I hope you get to visit Colorado, it's really worth it. If you do visit, head up to Estes Park. They have great cabins to stay in, with wonderful views. And it's right by the Rocky Mountain National Park. I've never taken a plane, I've only driven up there but fortunately for me, its not too far from Kansas, maybe a 10hr drive or so. The price of gas and hotels/cabins can be quite expensive though. I think I spent around 2-3k last time to stay for just a week. It's been a plan of mine to get an RV and travel around the US for a long time now but recently, I decided I'd rather head up to Europe. There's a lot I'd like to see here in the US first, but Germany is my ultimate final destination. Expenses are my biggest setback as well. I'm on disability and foodstamps so I don't make much money at all. Luckily I have family members who have the same traveling goals, and we're helping each other to reach that. I hope you get to reach those goals, sincerely. I'd recommend looking at places you want to visit through google street view, I fell in love with Berlin just looking around the whole city in google street view. I might have to take a plane to get to that one though 😂

[@tylerwells72]

Just had a good Thanksgiving and came home to see this! Hell yeah! ❤

[@MonaMello]

TIP for QUESTS! Tap left on the D pad to see all active quests! Don't hold it cuz that brings up satchel, just tap!

[@djbeema]

Hope you had a good thanksgiving John. So glad to have this back. This LP has become like a cozy place to go hang out lately 😊 31:00 Wolves on this game ade absurdly aggressive. Theyll come after you feom a mile away and chase you to the end of the earth 43:00 I believe you can randomly get cigarette cards feom picking of packa of premium cigarettes

[@mikenzieogburn8813]

Grand Canyon is an absolute must see! And Utah, it’s an all around beautiful state, but Zion national park is absolutely breathtaking! Montana/Wyoming are gorgeous, specially the BigHorn Mountains in Wyoming. Yeah, Gary is bad.. but there’s really nothing in Indiana (from Middletown/Anderson IN)

[@anacsadder]

I've only ever driven through Utah, but I do like the deserts there. Great rock formations.

[@82566]

I recently went to Moab in utah to Dead Horse Point & Archs. This game reminds me of those places 😊

[@mikenzieogburn8813]

@ i bet that was gorgeous!!

[@mikenzieogburn8813]

@@anacsadder yes, it is gorgeous! I loved the drive from Las Vegas to St George Utah, it was gorgeous! We used to go there just to get Texas Roadhouse 😂

[@fabiog9447]

Alternate title: American states and their cities, deep beginner guide

[@outrojulia]

i absolutely love this gameplay of yours, it’s amazing 🙌🏻

[@narkedandafraid]

We happen to be playing through this game at the same time, and I cannot tell you how delightful an experience that is.

[@devi_lish1]

To be honest, trying to be not chaotic in a rockstar game is tough. Playing any of the GTA games all you wanna do is just go ballistic 😂 having the military and helicopters after you is so much fun

[@bugdomrulez]

as someone who lives in la, yup it fits your description of dallas. hot, excellent food, everything spread apart. altho california has some very nice mountains, big bear is great!

[@dudeseriously79]

I did enjoy your little travel talk. I'm from Michigan and growing up on Lake Huron was the best. I'd take it over the ocean any day although commercial fishing in Massachusetts was good eating.

[@origamipapercut4682]

John, wasting the “shoot the bottles guy” is the end game 😂

[@clayhair]

Happy Thanksgiving, John! Thank you for the upload, this was such a treat! Also there’s a lot of dialogue you missed during Jack’s coming-home party that clarifies certain characters’ mindsets, Molly’s in particular. It’s all kind of easy to miss, but at around 2:03:51, Molly & Dutch get into a pretty heated argument. She yells at him for “ruining” her life & Dutch just brushes her off and ignores her, you can see parts of it in the subtitles on screen. Pretty interesting stories that go on in the background that I only really noticed on my second playthrough lol.

[@samwisegamgee1243]

I’m glad you clarified that about the dialogue, I was so confused trying to read the song subtitles when that dialogue popped up! 😂 I was like, “Are they really singing all that??”

[@JncGwen]

That's it, thanksgiving is canceled. I have plans. 🤠 👢

[@robowaffler6674]

Thanks for not judging all of Indiana on Gary. Can’t say the rest of it is more interesting, but at least it’s safer. 😂

[@ntp4003]

I love the Mary quests in St Denis! Hope you get to them soon

[@emilyweaver]

i needed this so bad today it makes me look stupid

[@Jamie-o6v]

Love it John, and yeah you get a cigarette card from picking up a pack of premium cigs. You have to complete all sets of the cigarette cards to be able to post them for the reward.

[@Emily-xk2du]

Not me wanting a tierlist on the states (now that I know my state wouldn't be on the bottom). I'm with John on views in this game: the snowy mountaintops, Saint Denis at night (as always!), and the storm at the base camp. Fave moment was probably John trying to read Dutch's book over the VERY LOUD thunder without acknowledging it at first lmao

[@Count_Gustav]

Just bought RDR2 while on discount in Steam thx to your playthrough.

[@Cheddarhead7]

Very interesting hearing some of your thoughts on Dutch at the end!

[@DarkAttackYT]

Angelo Bronte is played by the same actor who played Kraven in Spider-Man 2 game.

[@Junnibee]

I like Arthur's little Igor run he does when he's bending over to sneak around

[@samwisegamgee1243]

I feel bad that people in Arthur’s life suck so much. I’m pretty sure Dutch is on his way to getting the gang kicked out of Saint Denis. He made them outlaws, tried to rub elbows with the sheriff, and is now hanging around the mafia. For a father figure, he’s such a mess. And Mary seems manipulative too in the way she somewhat puts down Arthur but also brings up their past relationship whenever she needs help. I get it that she doesn’t like him being an outlaw, but it kinda feels like she’s stringing him along now that her husband is dead. I hope she redeems herself sometime, but for now it feels like about half of Arthur’s support circle sucks. Tilly, Mary-Beth, Lenny, and Charles seem ok so far, and I don’t really mind Kieran either.

[@liio415]

Happy Thanksgiving, fellow shareholders! Couldn’t be more grateful to be a part of this company, and to be led by a man with such high honor. Let’s close out Q4 with a bang!

[@devi_lish1]

Duluth, Minnesota is beautiful to see. You can ride up the North Shore of lakes superior along the coastline of cliffs, and I also highly recommend driving through the badlands of South Dakota. So incredible to see

[@vascocacolac]

wow surprise afternoon John Twolfe rdr2 video??? count me in bruther

[@mrmandodude7591]

Thank you so much for the red dead upload brother

[@mandyholt1795]

If you haven’t been to Chattanooga, TN or Asheville, NC you would probably really enjoy visiting. I live in Chattanooga and moved to a couple other cities but had to come back. I love it. Surrounded by mountains and rivers but pretty easy drive to ATL and Nashville. And for a great chill beach scene you should try Hilton Head. Your family would love it!

[@mika7072]

Another RDR2 upload?? Thank you for this birthday gift

[@normahidup]

Ah, finally, we're back to John's fascination with the X button on controller, "is this for jumping or reloading?"

[@carleebraddick1995]

As someone from Indiana, Gary is definitely one of the worst places to visit

[@anacsadder]

(EDIT: Las Vegas has some neat shows and rides if you don't want to drink or gamble, but everything is way too expensive.) 31:19 I like the echo effect on the gunshot sounds in the mountains. It's a nice attention to detail. I don't remember if I already commented this or not (because it's this game that made me think of it), but the other day I was telling my partner that fighting wolf enemies in games makes me uncomfortable. I know that for realism sake, they have to yelp like that when they're injured, but the hurt dog yelp immediately makes me feel bad every time. It's like an instinctual thing.

[@g_lovestv]

That storm at the end, dutch's speech out there, the whole night after getting Jack back is sooooooooo goooooood. It's not necessary to hear everything but if you are there there's so much to learn and see.

[@therealspacecoyote]

I will say this about California. I’ve gone to a screenwriting retreat twice about three hours east of LA in the mountains. A town called Idyllwild. It is BEAUTIFUL out there. A must if you want a nature experience.

[@commanderkorra3316]

Beard won't grow unless you go and buy the hair tonics at the general store, and fast traveling can help it grow. Took a while for me, felt like an accomplishment though lol.

[@emilyweaver]

Southern Colorado is so beautiful. I love it there

[@theartofseven]

the Seinfeld references are killer!

[@BoneStack117]

I like first person for interior segments or searching for junk

[@reaperman111]

ohhhh cielito lindo...i wasn't expecting that, hearing them sing it was very nice also pretty interesting to read the book, i wonder what his opinion of it is (though since he quoted it i suppose he must like it but like you said, it is also kinda about him too)

[@trevicarus172]

Ah I've been looking so forward to this.

[@azurtempest4443]

That’s definitely Gary lol I live like 20 minutes from there

[@overthetopdevito7503]

Best Horse stats wise is Albino one found to the west of the lake by Colter

[@trystanstewart1120]

Lake Isabella

[@AngeliqueStP]

Well now... this shareholder likes the beard. But then again I've always liked bears. 🐻

[@themerovingian7154]

24:34 This one was a female moose. Bull moose is the rarest

[@scarymarilynn]

I was born and spent the first 14 years of my life in DFW, then moved to CO to live with my dad. I've been here for 20 years now, and I'm still in awe every day with the beauty of Pikes Peak, Garden of the Gods, the Rockies, the dunes, and the valleys... It's just so gosh darn pretty.

[@ntp4003]

Just when I was getting some up cowboy withdrawals!

[@xvromo1362]

38:27 the quick scope was crazy

[@mikiwink]

So glad to not only see an unexpected episode today but also that you're finally giving Victoria more of the good stuff! For the saddles, you won't find the good ones at the stables. You need to go to the trapper for the good stat saddles (ngl, they're kinda ugly though 😅). Depending on the saddle, they usually require a legendary pelt and/or perfect skins. Thankfully, the game will always give you enough of the legendary pelts needed to purchase all items that require them if you want to do so. I usually get any and all small pelts that fit on my horse during my travels, sell less than perfect ones to regular shops that take them and save perfects for Pearson if camp needs them or the trapper since he keeps a running total for purchases. Makes it not feel so chore-like. The other legendary items you get from the animals (hearts, claws, etc.), sell to a fence. Happy Thanksgiving!

[@sikksotoo]

Northern Arizona is nice. The Grand Canyon, Flagstaff, Sedona, etc. Utah is beautiful, too.

[@JBarG22]

I live in the state of Santa Catarina in Brazil. The region I live is simply the best one out of the entire country for someone to live, we can even drink tap water here, because it is the cleanest of the whole South, and criminality rates are the lowest around (not in all cities, capitals are still dangerous). When it comes to tourism, we have many beaches, mountains and even snow here! There's also some towns that have a majority German-speaking population (That's crazy to think about). So I'm proud of my state and I'm proud of the Southern region.

[@jasonwrestlingfan1626]

Missed you here the last few days! Welcome back. Hopefully you got around to fears to fathom episode 5, and anything you had planned this month. Can’t wait for tomorrow’s video regardless!

[@InsomniaYoutube-wz1ju]

Now this is something to be thankful for!!! Thanks for looking out for the people who need to just get through the holidays 🎉

[@maskedmisfit364]

Fastest click in the west!

[@frannyxfury42069]

I was so excited to customize tori and then he didn't even look at the appearance options 😭

[@JohnTwolfe]

yeah because I already customized the appearance to my liking in like, episode 2

[@frannyxfury42069]

​@@JohnTwolfe you absolutely did my apologies lmao

[@PeepoNasty]

Horsemaxxing 🐎 ➕

[@uwotmate69]

Appreciate the ups for Michigan in the state ranking flow of consciousness. Just curious if you want to share what brought you to the Grand Rapids area of Michigan? We definitely have some cool local events like ArtPrize and Comic Con. Hope you got to try some coney style hot dogs. Also, I hear wet burritos are a Midwest or Michigan thing....my brother grew up in Michigan and moved to Texas and cannot find wet burritos there. Basically, a burrito covered with sauce, cheese, and toppings.

[@samwisegamgee1243]

Hmm burritos covered in cheese and sauce sounds like some of the Tex-Mex dishes in Texas. Idk about “toppings” though. Unless you mean like jalapeños or cilantro, that’s pretty common on some dishes.

[@donna3290]

🦃 + 🤠. Yes... By the way, you can make your beard even longer by using hair tonic.

[@SNP80]

I’m pretty sure Mark Johnson is supposed to parallel John Marston’s story.

[@SNP80]

Forgot to add that you’re definitely on to something about Dutch and how he perceives his favorite author (Evelyn Miller’s) musings. He definitely interprets things in ways that don’t seem to align with the books as time goes on. It’s interesting seeing his character almost derail which you’ve commented on. Not giving big spoilers but you may want to give Arthur a bath and get him looking nice before continuing the Mary mission. Not that it’s necessary but I recall her mentioning Arthur’s appearance and that’s a pretty fun mission in general with her that I think you’d enjoy if you decide to do it.

[@82566]

Binge watching & catching up from episode 13 , its a great day 🎉😊

[@ImageryDoesFit]

Connecticut is pretty middle of the road, C maybe low B depending on tastes

[@DaronGl]

Dang i wasn't expecting a flashbang on the beginning of the video.

[@BTSB7221]

I NEED John to continue the serial killer side quest

[@DummyPages]

As someone who was born and raised about an hour outside of Seattle… we really don’t like it that much. It’s a much bigger hit with out of towners and just something we endure on special occasions.

[@coffeecat600]

Yes, I remember that sneeze! 😂