Jonathan Schanzer: The War in Israel - Danger Close with Jack Carr

[@marcgebeloff2036]

Thank you for being such a tremendous friend of sanity and democracy. Your fairness and resistance to the sudden infatuation of the media today to support terrorists is noted and appreciated. You clearly respect the responsibility your platform requires, if others with your reach showed a fraction of your discipline we wouldn't have the crisis of truth we find ourselves in today. You have earned a loyal fan and I let no opportunity to spread the word about what a gem your channel is pass me by!!!!

[@TylerAutryUSA]

Happy Veterans Day Jack, and thank you for another great podcast. You’re one of the reliable sources we have for information regarding “why”, not just what’s happening.

[@bsmithhammer]

That was great and very informative. Thanks for having Mr. Schanzer on the show to provide a lot more historical background/context.

[@thebrucebruce2935]

😊😊

[@deborahforbes52]

Oh my goodness jack! Thank you and johnathan! The most thorough explanation of the situation. Sharing this with everyone!

[@jonnyref3475]

Thank you Jack for hosting this series. You are (sadly) one of the few factual news sources to rely on in regard to this issue given the failures in Western media.

[@andrewvare3173]

One big problem is that Israel is pretty warm towards Russia. Yeah, those guys.

[@Joejoe-vd2do]

@@andrewvare3173 Not really, Russia is very cozy with Iran. Israel knows this. Though there are a lot of Russian jews in Israel.

[@oklikeuknow4827]

BS. Russia came out in support of Hamas. If they are close it’s for tactical reasons.

[@haveaniceday2753]

Russia supported the Syrians when they attacked Israel in 1967 Six day war. Only when Israel defeated Egypt, Jordan and destroyed Syria's allies in Lebanon did the Russians back down. Cold war era but there's @@oklikeuknow4827 political ,diplomatic relationships maintained across the world. Doesn't make them friends.

[@chief_9938]

no wonder why redneck information is so messed up after watching this interview

[@debra9866]

The adults don’t know history at all. Great discuss and so much truth. Thank you for this!

[@gmfischerster]

This was an exceptionally good one. As an Israeli who served 20 years ago, and often talks with my army buddies about how little the west can follow the whole story with it's multiple actors, this episode I would highly recommend. I do have two points I'd think would be important to point out: 1) The PA-PLO-Fatah being called pragmatic might be misunderstood as them having their goals set on coexisting with Israel. They were pragmatic in the means they would like to use to gain land and other objectives Arafat had a way of reassuring his people by giving them the message that they did not give up on the intifada, they just used the negotiating table and Israel's addiction to peace. Many in Israel's "hopeful" camp, would assume that he said this to his people to keep them under control but I am of the opinion that he was duping Israel and the west and the 93 Oslo accords were a trojan horse.. Most here should already know the fact the PA give stipends to families of dead terrorists. Encouraging terrorist activity amongst the poor. 2) the meta objective in Israel's currant war in Gaza is to regain a real deterrence in the whole region. One can't have a peaceful state in this area without convincing your neighbors that provoking us is survivable. Our "containment" doctrine we practiced over the years inspired our enemies to think one could: attack Israel, suffer some losses rebuild, and continue. We can't allow another 10/7.. Some of us in Israel think we should have retaliated with this level of force for lesser attacks that we suffered in the last 30 years to avoid 10/7.

[@jackharle1251]

How about Israel getting off of America's teet?

[@zd1322]

@@jackharle1251Found the idiot. Take a hike.

[@Grammichal]

@@jackharle1251 Hmmm…. How about you appreciate our alliance with the only true democracy in the Middle East? How about you appreciate the thriving nation of Israel? Israelis have brought so many technological and medical breakthroughs to the rest of the world….

[@gmfischerster]

@@jackharle1251 all for it! I prefer trading If one would calculate the dollar value of what Israel provided the US over years in tech, Intel, and more we would be making more money... The aid is in US interest.. AT THE SAME TIME I'm proud of Israel's generosity to the US..

[@wwlee5]

Great show, Jack. Thank you and Dr. Schanzer.

[@ArtHistorianVictoria]

Sadly this conversation demonstrates that not the brightest and smartest are in D.C. We can do better America. Thank you Veterans for your service.

[@GeorgeBurlakos]

ANOTHER GREAT INTERVIEW THANXS JACK FOR KNOWLEDGE

[@ThxHeavyShorts]

Providing the facts is appreciated 👊🏼

[@kandywestmoreland5164]

Jack, your interviews are the best. The guests are so educational and help us to understand what the history in this region is all about. I applaud you.

[@jilllathers9215]

This is amazing!! I’m going after it again because there’s so much. Thank you!!! We all need to understand this history. 🙏🏻♥️🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸

[@Zensci18]

Fantastic and informative interview! Jonathan Schanzer is the “Dr. Drew” of Middle East Foreign Policy!

[@Banana04218]

Another excellent conversation

[@tricyclejesus4572]

Thanks man. I love these. Great guests, great discussions.

[@dmyerstc55]

Awesome show Jack! I love the channel and absolutely love your books.

[@Fishtory]

Wonderful episode! Thank you.

[@ilana]

A very direct, clear and easy to follow no walkabouts voice. This is a very good interview. Thanq

[@alanledzep1967]

Just discovered your site Jack. Subbed and thank you from Canada.

[@BonnieB-i1k]

Great content. Any chance you could get Dr Schanzer to come back on with you now that’s it’s past two months of this war going on? I’d like to hear what he might have to say now, where things go now etc. Thank you for your service. Bonnie SoCal.

[@craiggoodman7]

This is the most comprehensive and the most accurate assessment of the war today in Israel in response to Hamas as well as yesteryear in direct terms to documented history! If you have the time, intelligence and patience to really understand what is going on in Israel, this will consolidate and sum-up the truth about Israel!

[@craiggoodman7]

In 2008 when I served in Operation Cast Lead (with no Iron Dome - was not yet deployed), and I have been serving for 23 years in the IDF (Israel Defense Forces). I have been deployed in this war as well in the medical front-line combat unit that I continue to serve. We all have families and children! Where is the world's moral compass?

[@Firehorse39]

The relentless horror of the reality of the hostages is unbearable agony for we strangers. Unimaginably horrific for parents families friends neighbors .

[@bearowen5480]

He's right that the American and European mainstream media news outlets are not only blatantly biased, they are also woefully uninformed and shallow in their reporting. It's their own fault of course, but part of the blame also has to be lain upon their consumers who have short attention spans and a dismal lack of curiosity about the facts that are necessarily complex and challenging to understand. It would seem that those of us who are willing or able to read books and spend time listening to detailed podcasts like this one are an insignificant minority of the audience. It's frustrating and debilitating, but increasingly that seems to be the case.

[@ginabinawina]

You should listen to Israeli Historians like ilan pappe. Written multiple books Noam chomsky also

[@zd1322]

@@ginabinawinaLMAO, just looked at Pappe’s Wikipedia. He is, in effect, a genocide advocate, but in reverse. He wants to sacrifice Israel to the psychos.

[@ginabinawina]

@zd1322 oh, so you're accusing him of being a self hating jew? How about a panel of Holocaust experts who are stating the same thing? Israel propaganda has rewritten history to look like victims while being perpetrators behind the scenes. Constant deliberate sabotage of peace while pretending they want peace. They worked with and funded Hamas to create division and it worked. They were their own golem in Jewish history come to life.

[@ginabinawina]

@@zd1322 kzbin.infoKZ3-k2l6JIA?si=2-qJghuCSvza2U_W

[@ginabinawina]

@@zd1322 do you also know how poorly Holocaust survivors are treated in Israel? They live in extremely poor conditions while Israel took reparations on their behalf from Germany.

[@gizabitadat1499]

great insight into the overall view from good intel thank you for this interview clear and truthful

What an excellent interview! I know a lot about the history of this region, but I learned even more by watching this video. One important thing to note - When the anti-Israel/pro-Palestinian activists (and their supporters) are talking about "the occupation", they are NOT just talking about the West Bank and Gaza. They're talking about ALL of the land that compromises the modern state of Israel. It is critically important to be very clear about the ramifications of this ideological stance, since it means there is no compromise possible with anyone holding that viewpoint. They are not seeking some mutually acceptable formula for peaceful co-existence. They seek annihilation. I'm almost certain the Jonathan would agree with me on this point and I imagine he would have brought it up himself if the the interview had been longer. Once again, thank you for the thoughtful and insightful discussion of a very complex issue!

[@snake_doc1788]

Would be interesting to have someone with a Palestinian view on the show as Jack does a great job of asking questions and listening

[@sherylkruger3344]

An excellent account of the truth. Thank you

[@iara_pimenta]

Very, very good explanation! Thank you! 🇮🇱

[@jonnysterling6917]

Your discussion of how complex this is, and then about how people don't/won't take the time to understand is spot on. And thanks for doing this for those of us who really want to understand and will take the time. Unfortunately, we are the critical thinkers of society, and there aren't very many of us. So, great, here we are over in the corner understanding while the rest of the room lobs bombs at each other in their uneducated hysteria...

[@theunboundDragon]

Hope is not a course of action, exactly! Thank you for a very interesting and informative interview

[@FreeAmericanUSA]

Outstanding conversation. 📚

[@DanTierney1]

Fascinating, informative and educational interview! Well done on both of your parts and I learned about 2 new authors to read up on regarding your books. I Subscribed to and Liked your video.

[@Discernment-ev5dz]

This is brilliant! Thanks so much.

[@danapeck5382]

Thanks, nice to hear the Muslim Brotherhood mentioned. Any chance for a whole show on them? All the best

[@damnhappytobehere]

Excellent. Thank you!

[@PeaceChildGuy]

AMAZING INTERVIEW. MANY THX. 😎🌵

[@Kvell55]

Excellent episode. Thank you.

[@Crowderchowder689]

Excellent thank you

[@MikeJones888x]

Great interview!!

[@zarathustra007]

This was a great QA and episode! Very nuanced.

[@GaryKatz]

Thank you, Jack and Dr. Schanzer. All elements of your discussion Should be common knowledge. It's not.

[@kathrynludrick4821]

Thank you

[@terrenceb.9860]

Excellent information.

[@patrickshanley4466]

Awesome discussion 👍

[@fishthe2066]

This content is awesome, Jack. Totally one of the best attempts I’ve seen at explaining the conflict and context and informing the American public on this complicated issue that so many of us are feeling obligated to understand.

[@GaryKatz]

The 'mastermind' of Hamas death squads, alZahar, proclaimed in 2009, that Hamas and Arafat were in close contact with each other during CampDavid. Zahar said he was just waiting for Arafat to give the green light to Hamas to begin the 2nd Intifada's suicide bombing reign of terror /horror I was in Israel 🇮🇱 at the time ;it was a mocking, sickening public admission and boasting of the horrific post-Camp David genocide implementation. I'm very familiar with this horror, as I was almost killed in the Hamas/Muzbrohoodlum mass atrocities on June 1st of 2000. 21 kids blown to pieces, and I was nearly #22. That led to PTSD and a commitment to research on the sadistic reality of the Muslim Brotherhood. October 7th showed the depraved genocidal intent of the terrorist Palestinians and Iran /proxies. 49:24

[@jaredrichards7094]

Every time I hear your intro strings it gives me chills. Its almost eery but its almost savage too.

[@christiereynolds1335]

Well presented and very informative

[@nikolasbbq]

WTF - commercial every 5 mins! FANTASTIC guest - saw him earlier on Israeli TV.

[@BirdSaver]

I thought it just happened to me. Never seen so many ads every 3 minutes and two at a time. Awful, made it hard to follow talk.

[@JoanoftheArk300]

“The people of Gaza” invaded the area to LOOT after ham aSS tore down the fence

[@moshebron2105]

His books aren't available on Audible.

[@bearowen5480]

In your rightful criticism of American foreign policy in the region while advocating a "back to the basics" approach, i think you should have given some credit to Trump's promising policy of negotiating the Abraham Accords, and to Netanyahu's concomitant cooperation in working toward a peaceful relationship with Saudi Arabia. Fear of that vector threatening to make Hamas irrelevant, seems to have been a motivating factor in the timing of the October 7th massacres. So far, somewhat surprisingly, the Saudis appear to be restrained in their response to Israel's current war against Hamas and Hezbollah. For purely selfish political reasons, Biden and Blinken continie to downplay the success of the Accords, because they clearly don't want to give any credit to Gerald Kushner and Trump for any foreign policy successes going into the 2024 elections.

Excellent points!

[@slamm1t]

Mr. Carr, I wanted to tell you about a book I'm currently reading titled "Spy Handler: Memoirs of a KGB Officer". The auther Victor Cherkashin was stationed in Lebanon during the late 1960's. He has some great stories to tell about the Middle East.

[@QuickRthanU]

Love watching your videos. Can you invest in some better microphones? sound quality is sometimes lacking.

[@therealdavidboyd]

Excellent analysis

[@rafaelertel23]

Jonathan Schanzer makes too much sense. :)

[@Firehorse39]

One of the few authentic brief summaries of this history. additionally Israel was forced to code every new build and most existing to include “safe rooms” in response to unabated attacks, rockets fire balloons bombs et al.

[@melaniegrant3934]

Thank you very interesting, happy veterans day

[@unclejj13er75]

10/7 is a new threshold that may very well lead to something worse if there is complacency or appeasement. Iran and nukes is the elephant I see getting ignored which has the ability to turn this world absolutely upside down.

[@bearowen5480]

Despite the evidence of Israel's complacency which made the country vulnerable to the 10/7 attacks, I remain fairly confident that the Israelis are realistically vigilant and anxious about Iran's nuclear weapons program and the truly existential threat it represents. The actual carnage that a Hiroshima-sized warhead over downtown Tel Aviv would create makes the 10/7 attacks tiny by comparison, a pinprick vs a beheading. I would be shocked to think that Israel doesn't have a minutely detailed plan and the aircraft and munitions all ready to launch on a moment's notice for utterly destroying Iran's nuclear weapons production facilities. They of course would like us to do it for them, but failing that, they'll willingly face the approbation of the world and do the job for themselves. The people who experienced the Holocaust will not sit idly by and allow Tehran to point a nuclear weapon at their heads and not react preemptively and decisively. Also, they will not allow themselves to be dragged into a nuclear suicide pact like the one that the US and the Soviets engaged in for nearly 65 years. That Mutually Assured Destruction policy worked because the Americans and the Soviets were both led by rational actors. But, the Iranians have proven that they are irrational when it comes to the death of Israel and the United States. No rational leader should ever be confident that the Jihadists currently in control of Iran wouldn't push the big red button against Tel Aviv, even if it meant their own certain thermonuclear annihilation. Israel will preemptively act when it knows that Iran has achieved a deliverable nuke. End of story.

[@djeasy9978]

Jack you do a great job

[@josephrudys2615]

Hi Jack, Can you interview Dr. Walid Phares ?

[@jimmyconway3814]

good stuff jack. i read his book hamas vs fatah which id recommend. also if you can control the number/frequency of ads on your channel you might want to tone it down. everyone expects a few ads, no problem. however im 30 mins in with maybe 8-9 ads so far which really detracts from a great chat. maybe its just me, maybe you cant control the frequency or maybe you dont really care which id also understand. just fyi since its otherwise a solid product

[@angelatakano6072]

Not only in Israel , because there were dual Israeli citizens of different countries, so it was felt by many many people, it was heartbreaking to see that amount of suffering, that continues until now with the losses and hostages taken . What is incredibly heartbreaking is to see people supporting Hamas, UN saying the attack did not occur “in a vaccum” ( what does she mean? Does she mean it’s Israel’s fault? ) and the amount of antisemitism after the Israeli people have suffered so much…. It makes me lose faith in humanity and the future

[@seanmcfadden6576]

Jews have suffered so much in history across the world. Ppl of Israel have suffered much less than the ppl of Palestine. There are Israeli ppl protesting the war. Ppl are not supporting Hamas, ppl are supporting Palestine and its ppl. Oct 7 was not created in vacuum because there has been decades of war that has never ended. How many innocent Palestinians have to be killed or displaced before it makes up for Oct 7? There seems to be no end in sight. It is a war that Israel has been winning since the 1940s. The so called terror attacks are acts of war trying to fight back for all that has been done.

[@H.Hardrada]

I agree. I used to be a more liberal guy, but I came to recognize an undercurrent of leftwing ideas that I think are profoundly wrong. Those same ideas have captured many liberal nations and led them into bad thinking patterns. You see these patterns playing out when Western countries show preference for terrorists and other malevolent anti-Western actors.

[@stendari07]

Turn More volume

[@jaxcrax9644]

Every statement has some truth in it.

[@cesarmeza5331]

Almost sounds like maybe we should stay out if it...

[@JoanoftheArk300]

Pure Democracy is MOB rule and that’s exactly what we have Worldwide 🎉 #Extremism groSS 🤮

[@colemeeker908]

We will get a sensible foreign policy when democrats and republicans stop arguing about which bathroom to use.

[@skcrw252]

Abas description sounded like Biden

[@alexchertin3]

I think the role of the media and ultra left wasnt taken in the account in the historic review and the desicions that was made.

[@jackharle1251]

Dr Schwanzel

[@govindagovindaji4662]

58:18 I love the question: "what about this 'occupation' narrative we keep hearing about? (If Israel did indeed leave Gaza in 2006); I am looking forward to his answer. However, based on other studies [equally good ones] it is not exactly true that Gaza and the West Bank were not 'occupied'. (It might come down to the definition of the word). The biggest thing I learned recently is that the people living in Gaza (other than those w work/medical visas to Israel; Egypt) are NOT allowed to leave Gaza, period. They cannot get a passport to travel say to the US or Europe, etc. to visit relatives. Or leastwise, it is extremely, extremely difficult. And this often includes family members who travel INTO Gaza. So relatives are reluctant to visit. A really sad story here on You Tube, is beyond comprehension (and well documented). He has 9 siblings & parents most all whom are college educated living in Gaza, and none of whom have work. He has a cafe in Germany which he considers his "2nd home" (he is happy there) for some 20 years now, and a prosthetic leg - he's about 43. He has no criminal record in either region. He went ALL the way to the Jordanian border on a passport but was not allowed in. After weeks and a lot of finagling with the embassies [Jordan, Israel, Gaza], he was told he'd be allowed into Gaza but with no guarantee of being allowed back out. [Sad, sad story - the effect this had on his family]. Somehow, it was both the Gazan and the Israeli countries that were preventing him this free travel. I mean, neither country would even take the time out to really learn about him and them and make an exception here. It is one of the saddest stories I've seen recently. And this was a year or two BEFORE October 7th, 2023. OTHER, West Bank residents are not allowed to travel say to Jerusalem where the mosque and big shopping is or anywhere outside the West Bank without a lot of hullabaloo at crossings and often complete denial depending on the mood of armed guards. Its absurd. And of course, Netanyahu's govt keeps encroaching with new settlements into the West Bank even against many Israeli's (& Trump's & Biden's) people's will these last few years. I MEAN if you are not allowed to get passports and travel outside a 25 mile radius like in the Gaza, that IS being occupied in one sense of the word, or at least controlled 24/7, 365 days a year, every year. Sorry for the long post. Now for his answer.

[@govindagovindaji4662]

1:07:46 omg. this poor guy. You can see Jonathan's realizing every last question is just another 2nd to last question and decides to text someone saying...."no way I'm gonna make it on time."

[@judahlyons1284]

Is he Woody Allen's son?

[@BirdSaver]

Good catch, I was thinking he reminded me of someone.

[@JoanoftheArk300]

From the river to the sea 🌊 means a world without opposition to an pedo idol

[@andrewshagoury2288]

Intersting

[@kathrynludrick4821]

Chuck Holton describes the reality of the West Bank, ie that it's divided into 3 zones (A, B, C) per Oslo Accords. Zone A only Palestinians allowed, Zone B is supposedly a safe transit zone. Zone C for Israelis, although there are Palestinians who live there. You should interview Holton.

[@direwolf6234]

there's one basic question .. do the jewish people have a right to their own country on some portion of their ancestral homeland .. yes or no ?? if yes then fine let them be .. if no is there a non-violent solution suggested by any arab nation ?? and how will they control the jihadists...??

[@kevinoconnell9056]

He works for the FDD. Whats that group do in DC?

[@govindagovindaji4662]

40:31 Correction: threaten our 'enemies' [why ppl don't correct in real time is always a mystery to me ~ how'd that go over Jack's head~?]

[@mr.kilanski4254]

watching this a 100 days into the war , doesnt seem like hamas is going anywhere 😢!

[@heyhayhay247]

I'd like to see an Israel that includes the West Bank, Gaza Strip, and the Golan Heights with Jerusalem as their capitol. The Palestinians can ally with Israel and leave.

[@grannygear1001]

As good as this discussion is I am out early getting so many ad$ ad$ ad$ ad$ ad$ ad$ ad$ ad$ ad$ every 4-5 minutes. Please have mercy on us poor subscribers! I have bought your amazing books and congratulate you. One thing Israel has forgotten, their God, Jehovah. When they followed Him, (not their traditions that were added to their scriptures) when this country followed their Scriptures, they were blessed. Someday after the Christian church age ends, their Redeemer will come back, win a war (Armageddon) and set up the millennial Kingdom. WoW.

[@Wawi633]

#JordanisPalestine Be creative!

[@stendari07]

Micks are low.

[@Valmorphanator]

Why should we care about this part of the world?

[@mjswoosh]

Love the channel & wide breadth of opinions & information you provide on the channel, Jack. Having said that, while I am always open to those differing viewpoints for I firmly believe one of the best ways we learn & grow is to challenge ourselves & question everything, I must say that this particular guest is at best a propagandist & at worst an outright liar. Mr. Schanzer spun & omitted so many salient facts in this interview that I don’t see how anyone could take him seriously. For example, one major lie by omission was that in his description of the history of the relationship between Israel & Palestinians & the growth of Hamas he failed to mention the fact that Israel - at Bibi’s direction - funded & grew Hamas into the military & political force that we see today. The rationale for this was to oppose the PLO in order to create “permanent division” within the Palestinian people. Israel saw the PLO as the greater political threat & felt they needed to be counter balanced by an “extremist group” to continue this schism in perpetuity & to prevent the Palestinians from coalescing around one leadership & thereby prevent any real threat of regaining lost territories. Unfortunately, it didn’t work out as planned with Hamas “winning” this standoff with the PLO & gaining greater not lesser favor with the Palestinian people bc they saw them as actually able to accomplish goals whether thru peaceful or violent means. In short, Israel essentially created its own “Frankenstein’s Monster” & are reaping what Bibi sowed as we speak. EDIT: As Mr. Schanzer well knows, all of the terrorist attacks which occurred during this formative period especially happened within Israel leadership’s purview, & that includes US think tanks & bureaucrats. This is, by the way the same idiotic & disastrous philosophy which led the US down the fateful path of funding Saddam Hussein to oppose Iran & funding Al Quaeda to oppose the Russians before that. We can see the fingerprints of people like Mr. Schanzer all over Bibi’s “brilliant” plan to fund & grow Hamas. Mind boggling. There are of course countless spun facts & lies contained within the rest of Mr. Schanzer’s long winded delivery, but this is perhaps the most important one of the first 15 or so minutes of this discussion for what should be obvious reasons. Countless lives have been lost in all of these aforementioned theaters at least in part bc people like Mr. Schanzer are in positions of influence & their ideas become policy which then repeatedly blow up in everyone’s faces. And then people like Mr. Schanzer do the rounds to cover up those mistakes by spinning how all of these conflicts started &/or escalated in the first place: because people like Mr. Schanzer are pencil pushing morons who don’t know WTF they are doing.

[@liranhassin4141]

Oversimplification much? You said a whole bunch of nothing and the one statement you made was horseshit. Israel didn’t fund or grow Hamas as a counterbalance to fatah. In the beginning of Hamas under sheikh Ahmad Yasin they were a non violent grass roots movement concentrated on social services and a religious alternative to the morbidly corrupt and inept government of Arafat. Israel didn’t get in their way because they weren’t a threat. You’re either forgetting or blatantly omitting in your little diatribe that in 1986 Arafat was an arch terrorist with blood on his hands and his organization was until that point Israel’s biggest non state enemy. Additionally, Bibi was no where near his first term as PM in the late 80s when Hamas was forming. Once Hamas sent their first human bomb into Israel’s population centers Hamas was enemy no 2 and Israel placed all available resources to thwart it. This whole Israel and Bibi created Hamas is utter crap. Your agenda to blame Israel is telling.

My friend, you should carefully wipe the spittle off your keyboard, go outside, take a series of deep breaths and rethink how you ended up in such a difficult place. Pretty much everything you wrote in your diatribe is a lie, a mischaracterization, or just hateful and ignorant. I’m not sure how you got so mixed up, but hopefully at some point you’ll grow out of it and become a mature, functioning adult.

[@JrJVintage1956]

Thank God Orange Man was removed from the White House and the world was allowed to return to peace , love and prosperity!

[@mkaberli]

Sarcasm is underrated as a form of humor.

[@integralmark]

A leader to a long term solution will have to find a way to corral the media environment of the moment, that is, the food fights and stupidity being replicated endlessly

[@integralmark]

I watched this twice... while I am of the opinion that some sort of 2 nation solution is the only long term solution, I do now appreciate more the Israeli fear that any time and space given the Palestinians would allow remnants of Hamas or its similarly fanatical successors to develop new tactics, rearm and go at Israel again. And also the pessimism that any Palestinian leadership that forgoes violence against Israel would not be respected by the Palestinian population, or that no other leadership even has a chance due to civil war violence. Any ultimate 2 tribe solution (I'm just playing with synonyms to keep it fresh) should allow for regional policing and should model global excellence in policing while catching potential culture forest fires of jihadism early. And there simply have to be leaders that emerge that can meet the moment.

[@positivelypositive1324]

What is with this insane obsession with people, media, etc., with Israel and Palestinians. It's as if there is no other conflict, peoples, or countries in the world.

[@jonathanpersson1205]

I dont understand the relationship between Iran and Hamas. Iran is shiite and hates Sunni's whereas Hamas is Sunni. How does that work?

The enemy of my enemy...

[@sigmarecon]

You should have Norman Finkelstein on your podcast brother

[@ginabinawina]

Netinyahu fed hamas support and funds to exactly create a divide between palestinian factions.

[@gtamir613]

Are you listening Barack-Biden Administration?

[@kickinsnarehat]

The sooner you stop listening to this episode the better. You’ll have to unlearn it to understand this conflict.

“It is usually futile to try to talk facts and analysis to people who are enjoying a sense of moral superiority in their ignorance.” - (Thomas Sowell) I'm pretty sure Mr. Sowell was talking about you.

[@seanmcfadden6576]

Its hard to succinctly put out the entire history, i get it. But this is challenging to listen to through the beginning. I might continue and see where things go. But this has been a heavily ...one sided view of history so far. I dont need someone talking about how Oct 7 was a massacre because of how many ppl were brutally murdered, and how some hostages were taken, when the other side has done the same for decades and in response to Oct 7, at a MUCH larger scale, and its just self defense or acts of war. Acts of war are acts of terrorism. The current Israeli government strategy is ruthless...and a much different strategy compared with how the US government has tried to execute it's "war on terror." Frankly, it seems more and more like the US government wants the Israeli government to do what it never would: decimate the region, push the so called terrorists across an imaginary border, and hope they never return. But it only fuels the next bunch. If Oct 7 is viewed as a "terrorist attack" its solely because no one acknowledges Hamas, despite Israel, and the US contributing to its formation. They view themselves as the only answer in a never ending war, that really was started because some western power decided to take their land and give it to someone else. Countless attacks have been performed by either side. It is a war. A war that Israel is winning, but frankly despite Israel being an "enemy of our enemy" with the frabric of America being made up of so many different ppl, ppl of different cultures and religions (very different from what Israel wants) things can and will get very dicey moving forward in terms of safety on our soil. To me, this conflict needs to be something that the government of the US would be better off distancing itself from. Far too many ppl, countries, governements are starting to get angry.

[@andy47456]

@Jack Carr LOVE your channel but PLEASE have a Palestinian guest for objectivity.

[@lightworker4512]

Watch son of Hamas founder

[@MK-br3gl]

No

[@andy47456]

@lightworker4512 He's FAR outside mainstream Palestinian thought. You righties want to listen to something interesting. Try Jordan Peterson's daughter and Norman Finkelstein. Might change your lives!

[@Specter044]

⁠@@andy47456You’re right. Mainstream Palestinian thought demands the destruction of Israel and the Jewish people, evident by polling and the election of Hamas as the governing authority of Gaza.

[@mushogi]

Quite a pro Israel podcast, I was looking for something a bit more nuanced and factual. To put the blame on Palestine for a refusal of a two state solution is to ignore that Israel has always been working for a greater Israel which encompasses the biblical land. If Israel had been willing for a Palestinian state then they wouldn't have built a single settlement in the occupied West Bank.

[@H.Hardrada]

As it should be. As Americans and Westerners, why on earth would we show favor towards the other nations in the Middle East, who have always been adversarial towards us, over a Western democratic ally in the region?

[@Kman666]

Hence why he is asking for a nuanced and factual podcast rather than pro-Israel one.@@H.Hardrada

[@H.Hardrada]

@@Kman666 The problem is that IT IS a factual and nuanced podcast. If the facts don't go your way, maybe start reassessing your position. I'm also pointing out that it's ridiculous to call for more and more nuance. If you're nuancing this thing to death, with the hope of receiving a different set of facts, then it's also probably time to reassess yourself. Were we bending over backward, making sure we interviewed every member of AL Qaeda after 9/11 to make sure we got all the nuance? Wtf is your guys' deal? What are you grasping at so desperately?

[@matthewsmith472]

If that's what Israel wanted they wouldn't have traded that land for peace repeatedly. Keep your antisemetic tropes to yourself.

[@mushogi]

@@matthewsmith472 calling someone antisemitic is the refuge of someone loosing the argument. Even by the skewed official definition, critism of Israel is not antisemitism. Which land and when were Israel willing to trade for peace. Even after the Oslo accords when the Palestinians gave up a lot for peace, Israel carried on building on the West Bank.

[@mazzari725]

Your so called historian twist facts, maybe you can invite Max Blumenthal, to give you better history lessons vs. this expert