Jordan Rudess & Mike Portnoy - Dream Theater “The Spirit Carries On” - Cruise to the Edge 2024

Jordan Rudess & Mike Portnoy perform Dream Theater “The Spirit Carries On” with Charlie Griffiths (HAKEN) and That Joe Payne (vocals) on Cruise to the Edge 2024

[@TheDutchMusician]

can't wait to see Dream Theater with Portnoy again, please come to the Netherlands

[@MaxPower2719]

Yes, but take this singer please 🤭

[@pippo9830]

@@MaxPower2719 At this point anyone can sing better than Labrie, still I don't think this guy's voice could be ok with singing images and words anyway.

[@crsofteu1365]

@@MaxPower2719 or at least Lzzy hale for backup :D .

[@wurm90125]

Joe's voice works really well here. Didn't know he had the range.

[@yudhaadityasukmanto]

who:s joe?

[@safi493]

@@yudhaadityasukmanto joe father

[@would3984]

What a happy union! A nice singing with two living legendary players : Jordan and Mike.

[@terrariorecords]

clearly the drum kit does not really matters, either you have it or not. No need to add that Portnoy OWNS it

[@lopa-u9f]

so much feel

[@lincthomas7178]

oh yes it does, ya cant play decent music on shitty kits, trust me, TAMA is the way!!! lol

[@twocatsyelling723]

@@lopa-u9f MP has always blown me away with how organic and loose he plays, even when playing really technical stuff.

[@challengervideos8549]

It think what really proved it was when he played the hello kitty and Pokémon kits!

[@68Highlander3335]

The same with guitar and bass - it's all in the fingers!

[@reactions4u438]

wow that solo was played brilliantly!!

[@mkbou4299]

This guitar solo gave me chills every time .. took me to another part of world got me crying for no reason ….

[@Feltronc]

That last “I’ll be alright because I believe” with the falsetto broke me. What a beautiful, delicate vocal performance. I loved it so much.

[@brianhenn9872]

James is iconic but can we please replace him with this guy? 😂

[@arctic_2911]

When James sings, can't hear a single thing he's singing about.

[@brianhenn9872]

@@arctic_2911 yea, he's tired. He tries too hard. I'll still enjoy the shows but when Devin Townsend joined in last year, it was clear they could use someone fresher

[@savr1200gs]

Portnoy already trying to find a way to get this guy in as DT vocalist 😂

[@craigmoggy3461]

Go Charlie! Go! Just saw Haken Feb 25th in Toronto! Best show of my life!

[@iau]

Jesus that voice! Smooth as butter

[@Gorbyrev]

Wonderful, a taste of what's to come! And well done Charile and Joe.

[@halestormtv]

Wait... Charlie who?

[@Revenant4k]

@@halestormtv Charlie Griffiths from Haken

[@halestormtv]

@@Revenant4k I knew it! I saw him and thought he looks like Charlie from Haken, but wanted to be sure! How cool is that having he and Rudess play together. Never heard of Joe. Does he sing in another band?

[@mikedavis6884]

@@halestormtv Joe sang with the Enid, and has been solo now for quite a few years. I first saw him on the Dust tour, and his voice blew me away, as well as his stage presence. He's worked with Jordan Rudess recently which is how he got to CTTE.

[@mtfonte]

Great sound! This songs remember me a lot of good moments in my life. A love it All!!!

[@erikarvidsson-hv8df]

Great singer!

[@cathysherman5968]

Please keep sending videos😊. I wasn’t able to attend this year! Thanks for sharing.

[@danudamarjati5487]

The vocalist sounds like mix of Charlie Dominici and Maynard James Keenan

[@m0c0tub3]

OMG BEST COMMENT EVER

[@billbock6335]

This was beautiful thanks for uploading

[@gearofmetal23]

Props to the guitarist.

[@ProgInVain]

One of Haken's guitarists, I recommend checking them out if you like DT.

[@randyiswara]

Thanks for sharing this! Wow

[@boendahbandofficial8628]

Nostalgia

[@PabloSaavedra84]

Goosebumps on the last note with that cymbal roll 🥶

[@dionprayogo5758]

Drum soul is there 😊

[@dominic8129]

Powerful and lovely 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@remysyahdeini2469]

portnoy is da beast!

[@Sam-cv6un]

can't wait for the new album

[@liramicky]

great guitarist...!! amazing voice too...

[@rossanna.g]

No estoy llorando 😢

[@josemercadofotografo]

Wow Wow Wow ❤❤❤❤

[@timiskra4355]

That was fun! Thanks for sharing. ☮🤘

[@dapksp25]

Appreciate James LaBrie….. he takes so much crap… but he is the voice of Dream Theater

[@mr.sidecomments9278]

yeah I appreciate what James LaBrie did in this video!! 😉He should keep doing what he does here🤣

[@heavymetal9749]

Probably the first time MP's ever played this in years

[@yangerozk4184]

Can't replace James at no cost judgment as a music student

[@u.v.s.5583]

But you do know that spinach tastes better if you replace with a good beef steak, don't you?

[@yangerozk4184]

@@u.v.s.5583 and a beef steak tastes better with a heavy meal does it... Let's embrace him at this stage... It all depends on how we perceive it, and for me his chorus are not a match to any metal singers out there, that I hope you can agree on? 😃😃

[@yangerozk4184]

Listened again after I replied.😊.. That chorus is straight fire btw😂 I might wanted to change my mind about my defence but I really like James since his voice is also unique in his own way

[@jeffc651]

Nicely done all the way around!

This is AWESOME!

[@danieljakubovic]

What a beautiful voice

[@yunusd8167]

How nice to see Jordan Rudess and Portnoy together. But cant see the bass player :)

[@danielgomes3004]

Jordan played on keys(left hand)

[@kohirhasbulloh8019]

I like this song ❤❤❤❤

[@SilvyRevallina]

Menggokil❤

[@1976oswald]

Awesome !!!

[@NoelAmores-ux2ye]

Can't wait to see MP play MM era songs....

[@ijasariperkasa1599]

Where the sound bass? The sound bass from keyboard or player?

[@RemarkablePerson]

The bass was from the portnoy's mouth

[@dcairol]

WOW

[@AnnWahlquist]

❤❤

[@sorgrinder]

Great performance!

[@PepewConsoleBox]

at last the soul of drum MP is back after drum of robotic MM

[@shawnbates5106]

Looking forward to the new Dream Theater album!👍❤️

[@ribosmanYT]

Memang beda kalau drummer asli yang mainkan lagu ini...karna beliau yang menciptakan ketukan drum di lagu ini ...

[@wildandrumchannel3063]

iyaya..walau pun ga persis sama d rekaman.. tapi perasaannya ttep dapet

[@drummeryn]

포트노이 형 빨리 한국에 와줘요~!

[@polymathg]

Is this the first live performance between Rudess and Portnoy since 2010?

[@progreport]

No, they played together on the cruise before a few years ago.

[@flashanddancedj]

To me this is the core of dream theater….

[@boendahbandofficial8628]

Emang sentuhan portnoy tidak tergantikan😢

[@dwispo9857]

lebih mantap dan power full

[@barhell666]

Aura nya beda kalo MP yang bawain lagu ini emang.

[@FakhriNovriandy]

iyaa bg,kayak udah melekat kali klo portnoy yg main groove nya

[@situationing]

🤙🏾

[@BlissStreamID]

warm up!!!

[@rizkyarafa]

What the event name? Then where?

[@andrewlongshaw2128]

Best performance so far.

[@cmmm2258]

Mike portnoy😊😊😊

[@corbinmccasland7869]

Is Jordan playing bass? I hear it but don't see it.

[@winterboss6204]

Keyboarding xd

[@tieukhavu8832]

I think he was splitting the keyboard sounds, so he is playing the bass on the left hand and all the other sounds in the right hand. Don’t forget his foot switch pedal kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHrCeWRsr659nKssi=0H5MQW00s1-sEtBy

[@fungear9613]

Eat curry without salt dude

[@cesarfranku]

does joe has a band?

[@benjamindixon4825]

I dont do cruises or whatever this is but might to sit that close to MP

[@musisiberas]

pas ketika aku muter lagu ini❤

[@SystematiCChaoSDT1]

....james is james!!!!!!!!

[@yudhaadityasukmanto]

look at these crowds

[@PerceptionsofFate]

what do you want them to do, dance? lmao it's prog, let them chill and experience the talent lmao

[@SimonFerocius]

His voice is so evangelic....

[@RadarThirtyOne]

Beautiful.

[@FirstLast-cd6vv]

That audience should have been packed.

[@joeyb.8613]

Mike "EFFIN" Portnoy!!

[@JohnDunstonDrums]

Joe sounds amazing.

[@jmvm31]

Better than Labrie

[@RemarkablePerson]

​@@jmvm31every singer has the time themselves

[@aloissidler6980]

Ich mag den Sänger - wäre eine sehr gute Alternative.

[@justforpang]

no bass?

[@TheRealBlueSwan]

Who is playing bass? I don't see anybody with a bass? This doesn't seem to be the kind of setting where you'd use a backing tape for anything?

[@danielgomes3004]

Jordan probably played the basses with his left hand

[@danielgomes3004]

No, Jordan played the basses (left hand)

[@Aegylon85]

Love the guy, but there's just ONE Petrucci

[@skrete]

i dont understand a comment like this here. this is clearly a one off thing, probably even unrehearsed. petrucci wrote the thing. of course the writer/composer will play it better with his own mark/stamp. charlie is a monster player as haken is a monster band. i dont think petrucci could play some of charlies riffs

[@eqprog]

All these musicians on the boat and they couldn’t find a bass player?!

[@Vortex-gz8se]

Bass players aren’t important anyway

[@richardkupper]

Hqhahah😂​@@Vortex-gz8se

[@bakerfrank98531]

​@@Vortex-gz8se No we're not 😂

[@troyanotz]

Who's singing?

[@progreport]

That Joe Payne

[@DainGeek]

Is the first time that i prefer james labrie

[@edmiddlebrooks1696]

Nice voice on the singer but he keeps trying to screw up the timing, at least at the begining. Just sing it straight, it works better.. Gave me chills though.

[@fredericosilva4336]

Prove that you don't need tons of toms and cymbals to sound great!

[@SuperKakaras]

Pink Theater🤭

[@jheovanderfelix1600]

CANTA NO TEMPO CERTO CARALHO

[@Archangel_Reez]

Where's Myung?🙄

[@progreport]

Missed the boat

[@kevinpowers9024]

Snoozefest. Really hope they don't play this on the tour. Same for PMU and Metropolis. Will be a good bathroom break song if they do play it.

[@AndyPritikin]

Is that more solo notes for Charlie than his entire Haken career?? 😂

[@papaigun]

Singing plainly can make a song worse, too much improvisation can worsen it.

[@marcotoscano4692]

The proof that Myung is totally unnecessary 😆😆😆

[@alexmarguti6865]

On this song maybe yes 😅

[@FallingPT2003]

Nice voice but cant reach the power

[@gehausecabinet5073]

dont ever let this guy sing any DT song again...ever. doesnt suit his voice. sounds poor to me

[@progreport]

NEVER AGAIN!! 😆

[@Toddheenan802]

The singer is paynefully out of place here

[@shaunsteele6926]

sounds better than James LaBrie lol

[@Killerklownsfromouterspace]

@@shaunsteele6926So does Vince Neil.😂

[@andysalter7192]

I think he is awesome! Sounds better then James ...

[@cunjoz]

@@shaunsteele6926 yes, his voice is more pleasant than James' voice nowadays, but his execution doesn't fit the song. he can't stop syncopating and adding blues licks and trillers to his lines. yeah the style of the song is sort of gospel-ish, but the lead vocal line isn't like that.

[@progreport]

@@cunjoz he's not replacing anyone, he was just singing a song for a cool moment. it's ok to enjoy it. :)

[@martinator7]

Mike portnoy plays like amateur in hear 😂😂😂😂. Maybe because he's not playing spirit cariies on for a long time 😂😂😂😂

[@drummerdan95]

Get 😂 new 😂😂 ears 😂😂😂

[@martinator7]

@@drummerdan95 you dont understand music i think 🤣🤣🤣

[@theScarletSprig]

Did kinda have casual warm-up vibes

[@guimaribas]

Portnoy is very bad, the band's sound loses 60% of its musicality

[@progreport]

You’ve got to be kidding 😂