Joshua Graham and Geralt Debate God's Existence (AI)

[@TheCouriersGambit]

Thank you everyone for watching! I'll have some more videos with Geralt out over the next few days. If you're new here and want to see more Joshua Graham, here's a playlist: kzbin.info/aero/PLAjY2ERZ2Lo0n7hDyRhEsJXWVNN5AfIll&si=N23WdhT-m8eiz2zW As always, let me know what you would like to see in future videos :)

[@blablanobody5456]

No . Man thank you , This was nice 💜

[@daydreamdirty]

Personally I’d like to see a conversation between Joshua and Darth Vader or Malgus

[@Jillibanabean]

Id love to see john marston or arthur morgan talk with Joshua about redemption. itll be an interesting conversation piece

[@TheCouriersGambit]

Fantastic suggestion!

[@JoeMama-me2yj]

Honestly that is really intriguing...all very well written charecters

[@JustinCage56]

A RED video with those two could be DEAD in views. However, I'm sure having Joshua on it would bring it some REDEMPTION.

[@zm1786]

I'm sure you can straight up ask rob to talk about it lol, he loves talking to fans

[@zefft.f4010]

I find your use of "conversation piece" interesting, because it isn't really that (although I suppose it could be, if you show it to some friends and you proceed to have a conversation about it) but at the same time it is exactly that. A piece of content that is a conversation between two characters - a conversation piece. Language is funny sometimes.

[@jhosef0077]

Geralt: "One more thing before I go. Gwent, never heard of it?"

[@Firebird-he3sz]

Joshua: No, but we do have Caravan. Geralt: Caravan, what’s that? Joshua: A bad way to pass the time.

[@orangelinedevil2]

I really feel like my voice was heard. Thank you so much for reading my comment and making this.

[@checaaards]

keep the like count on this the same

[@markbenand]

I like these because it's nice to here an actual argument as per the traditional definition of the word argument. In a traditional argument, you present points based on sound reasoning and good presenters have no problem conceding valid points even if they reach different conclusions. Too much vitriol and shrieking when people disagree nowadays.

[@coreywong6229]

Sadly when two well written fictional characters using ai have more principles than any current real world person who is blinded by my emotions and opinion matter more on the premise of my way or the highway, but they are both flawed in a way and thats what makes them interesting characters.

[@nicholascauton9648]

Seeing these two interact would warm my heart. I love these two as if they were my own sons. (Note: I don’t actually have kids)

[@verified_JC_Denton]

Very well written. It was cool to see them interact.

[@divineburrito7894]

I never knew i needed those two to have a conversation until now

[@joelsamuel6457]

Please do Madara and Kratos 2 Ghosts discussing their lives, Peace, Revenge etc

[@CockroachStomper]

Pls make a video of Lambert and Master Chief talking about their origins and having a moral debate about what happened to them as children.

[@artemisarrow179]

LMAO I love how non chalantly Joshua Graham talked about different worlds. I now consider these interdimensional debates canon to Fallout

[@High-Pie_Chop]

3:05 My god, prey for Geralt that he doesn't go to cyberpunk that world is a fuck up. Also The Witcher and Cyberpunk 2077 is some how cannon.

[@TheCouriersGambit]

Haha, I’m actually thinking of making a video with him and Johnny!

[@ubermaster134]

When Ciri did her dimension hopping she did end up in Night City

[@identity7536]

@@TheCouriersGambitdo that please ! I think Johnny would have made Geralt 10 times more mad than V and atleast 3 times more than voldemir van everec managed

[@JustinCage56]

Video idea: Geralt and V talk about trauma

[@identity7536]

@@JustinCage56Hell YES. that would fit very well. most people don't get that Trauma is one of the biggest motives in CDPR RPGs

[@oskulate]

i love how you tied it into the witcher lore great job!

[@floatingcloud94]

Joshua Graham debating Father Alexander Anderson the Bayonet Priest would be a treat

[@christopherbravo1813]

which one?

[@vandalieu5753]

​@@christopherbravo1813 most likely the Hellsing one

[@christopherbravo1813]

@@vandalieu5753 again, *which one?*

[@vandalieu5753]

@@christopherbravo1813 .....you serious, both ultimate and original Hellsing series has Alexander anderson

[@christopherbravo1813]

@@vandalieu5753 ...dude, I'm referring to the fact that there's an abridged series of Hellsing.

[@spaghettimonster2798]

Just came across this, super well done! Just now binging all your Joshua Graham videos, and if you’re taking requests, I’d love to see him have a sit down with (Norse) Kratos one or multiple times. Considering their previous misguided paths as blind weapons for cruel tyrants and the painful paths to redemption they’ve both had (ironically both being burnt men), I think they’d make for very interesting conversation. I like to believe Kratos would be confused at how someone as rational, strong, intelligent and pragmatic as Joshua Graham could have such an unwavering faith in his god, and would actually be curious to hear his thoughts as opposed to classing him as a blind, witless idiot. In any case, great job! Excited to see what more you have in store!

[@Nobody-kk3js]

My last 2 braincells when im trying to remember what i put in yogurt

[@HolyknightVader999]

Geralt has seen demons. He is the last person who should be denying the existence of God. If anything, he should be asking if God's protection will save him from the likes of Gaunter O'Dimm or the Wild Hunt.

[@roofied_galahad1675]

The existence of demons by no means indicates the existence of God

[@lukearmstrong1954]

Did you play the game? God did fuck all for him. He beat the odds himself. Never gave a thought to any god.

[@lukearmstrong1954]

Literally a main point of HoS in Witcher 3 and Blood and Wine. If there’s a god what’s the use of Geralt or witchers within that world?

[@lukearmstrong1954]

@@schrodinger2738 dude. Werewolves and vampires are real in this game. To extend your personal beliefs in God to this game in itself is idolatry. It’s unreal to me that anyone would believe that this video game designed by humans for humans with no relation to the Bible, would lead to people confirming or denying their beliefs in God. Pathetic.

[@HolyknightVader999]

@@roofied_galahad1675 Demons were fallen angels created by God. If anything, that should make Geralt open to believe in any supernatural power.

[@francescosaporiti1431]

Best game conversation ever!

[@h3lva642]

I think Master chief and geralt debate on what makes you human or something along those lines would awesome to see

[@lordsickomode]

1:27 I really dont think Geralt would paint it so black and white. Maybe a little cynical, but not outright lumping him in with the others without hearing him out more first. Wouldnt draw a conclusion that quickly.

[@razanon4373]

Nah, Geralt is real tired of the "it's the lesser evil" argument. He's seen so many try to justify their BS with that mindset. I could see him jumping on that immediately.

[@back5594]

Geralt draws conclusions and accusations like that pretty quickly in the books

[@ФирдавсИсмоилов-с6в]

Maybe add Optimus Prime in discussions? He preaches all the time

[@davidmingle5910]

Making Ciri part of the plot was genius. Makes it just that little bit more believable, and adds a whole lot.

[@Script-007]

I love the lore explanation for this video!

[@Marryjanesbud]

Nah this should be canon. I feel like both studios would be open to a shout out to eachother franchises as well.

[@edim108]

It's honestly sad that a KZbin video of two fictional characters talking with AI generated voices is one of the best debates I've seen in a while. Two intelligent men discussing a topic so profound and sparking such emotion with respect for eachother and being able to concide to a valid point made by the other even if their conclusions are radically different. Respect for the work. It isn't easy to write a debate like that. It wisdom to know the points that need to be made, intelligence to articulate them well and skill to put it all into an accessible format for other people to hear.

[@CandyChaos7]

I think Joshua Graham should have a "chat" with Johnny Silverhand (V) if you get my meaning... 😏

[@jb-wc1hx]

Hm, was the quote Gerald responded with “that’s a new one” a reference from Mormonism? 2:58

[@ThompsonExpress]

I wonder if Big Boss could have a conversation with one of them

[@maverickwolf4980]

can we get Joshua and Arthur Morgan one day?

[@charliebrenton4421]

These cids are my new obsession! I love these characters so much! Thought proviking!

[@TheMaleRei]

Joshua says the thing. REJOICE!

[@anthonywayne1928]

And with THAT, I hit the subscribe button.

[@blackhole7668]

Who asked?

[@anthonywayne1928]

​@@blackhole7668Why you wanna know?

[@e.j5813]

You did

[@e.j5813]

You did

[@theeternal2734]

I Know He Doesn't Have A Voice But I'd Want To Know What An Interaction Between Joshua Graham And John From Faith Would Be Like

[@pauldemon1624]

Noice!

[@TKNoire]

Joshua Graham and Dracula (Castlevania Netflix) talking about god would also be interesting

[@gamercow4297]

Yes

[@gaz4553]

Yeah well geralt got beat up by his girls ex so badly he had visions of his mommy. lol

[@evanmorris6507]

Why do I think of dark elves

[@bobidybilly]

Geralt and old snake next please 🙏

[@joshpelillo957]

I would love to have Joshua debate faith or prayer to someone form the 40k universe.

[@arrowtooth]

Sadly it probably would just end in “HERESY!*bolter fire*” unless it’s with the emperor or his sons.

[@TheMaleRei]

@@arrowtooth I think a Salamanders Chaplain could be amenable... But yes, it would be entertaining to hear Joshua speak to the Emperor - especially if one could manage it from TTS... Or even Lorgar, talking about the four Chaos Gods and Joshua saying - "Your universe sucks."

[@MrParanoidUnge]

Sarevok vs Jon Irenicus next plz

[@billyjarvis5341]

Joshua Graham and mad max from the game

[@niklyke2319]

What about Kreia and optimus prime?

[@Angelharts5ds]

5 stars Moment here

[@bald_egg_5944]

I womder what program is used to make this

[@Gothicgirlscout]

eh... I feel like some of this doesnt make sense. geralt doesnt have really a conception of a christian god just the gods of his world and he has seen literal magic before his eyes. joshua has faith in a god but has never seen geralt's world and does not have the conception on how magic would effect his. similar with kreia and the force when she and joshua had the same debate. the force changes everything in that context because unlike the duality of god and satan the force is both light and dark. some people have the idea that the dark side is people's corruption of the force but that's not really possible because the force dictates those people's feelings and actions. the dark side is also not exclusively evil, it can be for good. just as the light can be misused for evil there is just an inclination of alignment. the important thing though is neither character should be able to perceive eachother's perspectives to that degree and so quickly

[@teyanuputorti7927]

They both have equal points

[@Cyberskullxx]

Beautiful that's all i can say.

[@thecommenter9678]

The true faithful do not believe their actions are driven by, or sanctioned by god. They believe their actions are their own, informed only by their ability to choose the right path based on their best understanding of what their god would least object to. To that i believe god wishes us to live, not to simply lay down and die or be slave to another. To live our lives doing as least damage to others as is permitted by our circumstance. To be charitable when blessed with abundance, and to be understanding of those who cannot give as much as we might like or need. Geralts argument is far more based on the idea that one should not seek to make changes in things, that by trying to we only make things worse, but that is colored by his life of being swept up in things so large and important that no matter the choice, there are grave and usually unpleasant consequences. But most situations normal people are thrust into will not be of such scale, and even if they were, inaction is a choice with consequences as well.

[@synthedits]

jesus

[@Kriegsman14]

The only problem I have with this is that Joshua is not Christian, He's a Mormon. Other than that its great.

[@shayanali8771]

Mormons aren't christians? Mormons would say likewise that you guys are not real christians

[@charlottewalnut3118]

Gerald you met the devil

[@gamemasterultima]

Joshua position is absolute insanity to believe you can do the same violence as others but canseperate yours from theirs through your faith is ridiculous there’s no difference at all

[@You_already_know937]

Joshua Graham isn’t Christian, he’s Mormon. In the game Joshua Graham refers to his Colt 1911 pistol as being made by a member of his tribe more than 400 years ago. The creator of the Colt 1911 semi automatic .45 caliber pistol was John Moses Browning, a known prolific Mormon.

[@The.marauders]

Bro he is Christian