His Daughter, Her Dispute

[@Solovelym3]

I’m glad he went back and listened. Because you could clearly hear she sounds the same in the video as she does in court. And she flat out said “You let your daughter put her hands on me”.

[@annea.4173]

They were all acting like fools in that video. And then the update at the end? LMAO.

[@Felipe-b5q2f]

How did he not hear her yelling in his video

[@payypayy20mali65]

I can Cleary hear her voice

[@TeamofMe]

Selective hearing is what old people call it.

[@chinnupllc709]

I believe he was referring to seeing her mace him because that's what he led with 🤷🏽‍♀️

[@4CQueen]

Because the plaintiff kept talking over the sound, I'm glad JM went back and listened to the video.

[@BuddaGheeski]

I'm glad he went back there & listened & examined that video. I think we all heard it the first time. Thought he was about to let that lady slide. That updare was crazy 😂

[@gardeningunderinfluence]

Same! I could hear it the first time!

[@tanishasummage3094]

I do not want any dealings with a man who can not control HIS KIDS!!! PERIOD!!!

[@tjneverdefeated4394]

I know that’s right.

[@Skigod_don]

No man can in 2024 tbh 😂 s/o to sexy red & drill music

[@timothyjacob6381]

Interesting how you automatically assume the kids are the issue and not this grown woman. Yup, living up to the tradition you were taught. Okie dokie. 🙄

[@kavonnewilliams279]

They are both a couple of clowns bringing kids into this nonsense

[@sheldoncole1151]

​@@timothyjacob6381 right exactly 🙄.

[@mysticalmuse333]

I feel like the woman is chaotic!! Some people are uncomfortable with peacefulness and humbleness… a life lesson well learned ❣️💋

[@iheartherbo]

the end cannot be true 😂

[@lendalouissaint114]

I juuuussssttt seeen it ommmgggg!!!!

[@lysantiapatrick3699]

😂😂

[@TheNyeles]

i'm dying i swear i lost hope lol

[@robert123461]

You can see he tried to stop his daughter when she first ran up and you can also hear it was the same voice in both videos

[@kashoutg2330]

She was on here before saying her brothers wife kidnapped her runaway daughter🤦🏽‍♂️

[@Crystal-Love]

🤔I think she looked familiar!

[@TopherGrant]

Sister-in-law

[@sheldoncole1151]

I remember

[@mercadeze]

Red flag she has issues with your child

[@infinitig37x84]

Correct

[@kingdjack6]

We always hear a man must accept my child but I read profiles of those exact same breath the man better not have kids of his whether he's a single father or not they'll up with when it's their child (they barely do that now) it's rare they put with it if they are not the bio mom.

[@infinitig37x84]

@@kingdjack6 what ever you wrote does make sense smh go back too school

[@brawnyjk]

​@infinitig37x84 Make sure you're in that same class. Lol

[@ColorMeeBlessed]

That’s right honey no person should ever choose a person that doesn’t treat their child as their own

[@Provostialish]

For the people asking how JM couldn’t hear her yelling in the tape, you have to remember that the audio is enhanced for (TV) viewers. What and how we hear the final production may not necessarily be what and how JM and everyone in the courtroom hears.

[@ggboot1]

Why in the world would they ever have gotten married. That's insane. I'm not going to be in the same room, let alone marry, someone who assaulted me.

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

💯💯

[@aptvdvd]

That's that crazy love some need it. lol.

[@julieannemichelle]

No son or daughter needs to see their parents behave like this.

[@sereneamani1713]

They are learning from it and no doubt will repeat what they learn.

[@heavyizthacrown-5842]

This fight at the school was the Plaintiff’s fault! A real one checks his woman and his daughter, and there won’t be a “next time”. My daughter and my woman ain’t gone be fighting and that’s the end of that.

[@sereneamani1713]

Always glad to see that there are still real men and women in this world.

[@___chief866]

Hahaha i did not see that ending coming at ALL judge Mathis is wild

[@kavonnewilliams279]

All that video showed is that they are both ignorant unfit parents smh

[@sereneamani1713]

That sums it up. They are on the same level as their children.

[@AuthenticJoShow]

I'm glad JM went back and listened to his video. This is a toxic relationship... can't even believe the update!!!!

[@cleftheart1969]

Toxic is norm these days 😮‍💨

[@sheldoncole1151]

What a toxic relationship the two of them have together

[@chancest.thomas5160]

Smh @ "Put a Tracker on His Phone"

[@sheldoncole1151]

Y'all saying his daughter is out of control and disrespectful but she came on the show again regarding her own daughter apparently not obeying her mother and ran away from home or something like that. The other lady allegedly kidnapped her daughter and the defendant in this case won the case and she was the plaintiff in that case.

[@sheldoncole1151]

The way the defendant had her arms crossed during the plaintiff video towards the end of the video 😂

[@AnthonyIngram-h5c]

Lol judge said this case is over 😂😂

[@Indema117]

Why would they think it’s wise to get married after this incident?! Marriage doesn’t solve problems, wisdom and maturity does.

[@KayB-l5h]

Them two fools right there 🤦‍♀️

[@sheldoncole1151]

Y'all saying his daughter is out of control and disrespectful but she came on the show again regarding her own daughter apparently not obeying her mother and ran away from home or something like that.

[@sereneamani1713]

All involved are out-of-control. IMO.

[@luffygamerrr1]

Plaintiff stutters too much 😂

[@Malaan7]

I'm not arguing with a child! She should've left that whole situation. Not a single person showed an ounce of maturity that day. All of that loud talking was unnecessary. Ladies, you do not always have to have the last word. Walk away! Silence is sometimes solace. It doesn't mean you're weak.

[@sereneamani1713]

No one showed an ounce of maturity, because NO ONE is mature.

[@_MoneyMike_]

JM is wrong. The police don’t follow thru when a woman assaults a man.

[@sereneamani1713]

I've seen evidence to the contrary in more than one city and state. What is your observation based on?

[@michaelallen4766]

The heavy set lady in the back has lost so much weight compared to the recent Mathis cases So good for her😁

[@margiework11]

And the saga continues…..smh

[@RLMassey16]

Her almost lost while they playin 😂😂

[@mywifiiscoolerthanyours]

just watched another episode and JM ripped into a young man for saying “Listen” to a judge.. here he let it slide smh😭

[@___chief866]

Hahaha I followed here from the same video and said the exact same thing 😂

[@misterbee66]

I am surprised. I remember that episode. It is dependent upon his mood.

[@BigBoss-zi5ss]

This is ridiculous .. these woman gotta put navigation on a man and she already has five kids...get your priorities straight...obviously she puts men over everything

[@1GHOSTWRITER]

If the producers hadn’t stopped him & had him actually watch & listen to this guys video he’d ruled for this lying bag smh 🤦🏾‍♀️ he talked the whole time trying to make jokes never even tried to hear the evidence!

[@sereneamani1713]

Many people don't actually grow up and mature as adults. Time passes, they stay alive, and get older in age. That's it, that's all! Today, people talk a lot about mandatory DNA. It would be good to have mandatory education staring with critical thinking skills in every grade and semester. Mandatory parenting classes for every pregnant woman and every sexually active human being. Wishful thinking. It would never happen. This system is beyond repair.

[@NJoiMe1]

She sounds ridiculous. There are too many women acting this childish.

[@PCross38115]

She had the nerve to marry him after all that 😂😂😂

[@sereneamani1713]

They had the nerve to marry each other. That's actually immaturity and insanity.

[@sheldoncole1151]

I want to see that 2002 episode. I was a toddler back then.

[@diamondk6369]

Wat his daughter got to do with her father cheating that weird and a red flag

[@MariwittheI]

Hello Judge Mathis. This case looks interesting let's see😊 This is so cra cra my child is a child not yours at all. She the defendant is messy for this baby mama baby daddy drama and his teenage daughter. 😢case grow up lady! This is so so 😢.

[@tikatikatikatika3066]

I wish he would of slowed down talking , he should of never stayed with that lady , his daughter been not liking her listen to your kids

[@sereneamani1713]

He's as toxic and immature as she is.

[@sheldoncole1151]

This episode was a mess 😂😂😂😂

[@calleciaelam3076]

they both like chaos

[@HolyKupcakeSweets]

I am completely flabbergasted by the update 😅

[@sheldoncole1151]

They must be running out of episodes

[@sheldoncole1151]

I wanted to see all of her videos 😂😂😂😂

[@nettricegaskins1871]

He won the case but lost in life because he married someone who clearly should have moved on from there.

[@arethaanderson]

Can someone say TOXICITY and even gotten married whew child I got exhausted just listening to this for almost 20mins 😩

[@julieannemichelle]

If you feel that you need to gps your man, walk away because it’s not worth it. Never get into personal relationship issues with that other person’s child. This is really sad and very ridiculous of this woman.

[@fundifferent1]

LOL So we're "throwing back" all the way to 2021 with the covid cases

[@sheldoncole1151]

Judge Mathis at the end "you finally won one today" 😂😂😂😂

[@darrenbennett9132]

And you can also tell in voice he was madd !!! Because after the staff introduced the video he was dam how can I switch up now on him 😮🤬😭

[@sheldoncole1151]

​@@darrenbennett9132 hell yeah 😂😂😂😂

[@LIFEOFAPRINCESS21]

Yes good decision judge cause she something else!

[@sheilataylor7497]

Are you serious??? 😂🤣

[@sheldoncole1151]

The defendant came back to the show and won her case against another lady who "kidnapped" her daughter

[@bryanjohnson8982]

They ended up getting married lol. Wow

[@sheldoncole1151]

I wonder what's the update on her other case 🤔

[@feliparivera7896]

Definition of a toxic relationship

[@mdanielsrr]

This is the ghetto-est mess I have ever heard come to a court of law. They should have been too embarrassed to even come to court.

[@GloryStephane]

They got married after?! 😢😮

[@sereneamani1713]

Another example of how unbalanced this world is..

[@kingdjack6]

Considering she got her claim dismiss for perjury I don't anything said about them getting married she's trying to make herself look good.

[@robbingivens841]

I think he sat her up and he was dead wrong for letting that girl disrespect that grown woman like that 😢

[@TopherGrant]

How did he *set her up? He didn't start or finish the fight. He isn't his daughter

[@nicolerobinson835]

the child is disrespectful

[@sheldoncole1151]

They got married after the case 😂😂😂🤣

[@juskimmie]

The defendant is a Liar from start to finish.

[@tracym4175]

I wish JM would just ask how old the daughter is instead of the constant sarcasm/the plaintiff would catch the damn hints 🙄

[@marylenehall405]

This whole thing is one hell of a mess but from I can’t get along with your child or you can’t get along with my child it’s a no.

[@chrisedickerson2526]

My opinion if you in a relationship and your mate and child doesn't get along most likely that relationship not go last it'll always be issues. PERIOD!!

[@brandone869]

This man either lying or shoulda went to speech therapy classes

[@joegrizz2011]

They got married 😄😄😄😄

[@Culvers_simp]

13:20 I hate how judge commends what the defendant said. The woman admitted to having beef, with her ex's DAUGHTER, a, as she put it... CHILD, due to her GROWN MAN'S infidelity. Yet when the child fights back, clearly being put under a lot of stress, she needs to stay in a "child's place" Hypocrisy at its finest, "you're a child, stay in a child's place... Unless I want information about what your father has been doing" That woman ain't even her momma. What a shame.

[@ninobayyb]

Yall keep failing to realize the reason the daughter disrespected this woman is because this woman was trying to beef with a child about what the child’s father and mother had going on behind the girlfriend’s back . The girlfriend wife or whatever she is is the one in the wrong. Period point blank. Adults have to understand you can’t constantly disrespect children or disrespect children’s parents in their presence, that will also resonate with them , just bc the daddy forgave the girlfriend don’t mean the daughter did or EVER WILL. That’s just my personal opinion.this whole case was dumb and a waste of judge Mathis time

[@RacieRain]

He sees a place to live in you.

[@apb38]

Him= 2 kids, her= 4kids. Bottom line is unless you plan on getting married there is no need to be introducing your kids to the person you are "messing" around with. And if you see your kids are acting violent then they are not ready for it. Jeez this dude is dumb.

[@gulfELAl9155]

Counseling: the provision of assistance and guidance in resolving personal, social, or psychological problems and difficulties, especially by a professional.

[@beexiong9047]

lol no surprise here at the end. They stuck together and will continue to fight.

[@Belle2oo8]

The update 😩 whyyyyy

[@K_Cole0128]

They got back together and got married?? SMH!!

[@kashoutg2330]

You can hear that lady clearly in his video same voice ect

[@deejai1173]

What’s “ect”?

[@TopherGrant]

It didn't sound like her to me. Couldn't see anything anyway. Useless video

[@sheldoncole1151]

​@@TopherGrantit sounded exactly like her💯.

[@sheldoncole1151]

I know right

[@TopherGrant]

@sheldoncole1151 well, if that's what you heard. Cool. But me and Judge couldn't make that distinction enough to say conclusively.

[@ariyoung6725]

Judge Mathis how you don’t hear that raspy voice yelling

[@kingoffarts8352]

I understand that the defendant lied and she should of lost no doubt,but he could of walked away during both videos. When you have a kid you are supposed to set a example for them,not engage in violence or foolish drama. I didn't believe the defendant form the start but to me this was mutual combat so both should of lost.

[@taiodus3401]

She stabbed the tries and maces him she has a distinct voice.

[@brendawright5353]

I like the defended blouses

[@infinitig37x84]

I know some kids teenagers can be a mess but u have to be the bigger person unless hands are put on you that’s when u have to defend yourself

[@squalle83]

I vividly remember this two on judge Marthis show.

[@Waz683]

Lmaooo they toxic af

[@sheldoncole1151]

This was uploaded before

[@Fleefromsin]

2024 we're NOT making excuses we're telling 🗣️ people about the LOVE of Jesus Our Savior 🙌🏽

[@paulgeary6511]

HES REALLY TRYING SOOOOOO HARD TO WIN/ THINK OF THE RIGHT WORDS TO SAY*! BETWEEN ALLLLLLL THE "UHHHHHHHHH...* & THE STUTTERING*! LISTEN TO HOW MANY TIMES HES "UHHH'ING & STUTTERING" 🤨🤨🤨🤔🤔🤔💭😮‍💨😮‍💨😮‍💨🙄🙄🙄😒😒😒🧐🧐🧐

[@ebeleifedigbo506]

😂😂😂 boy was nervous AF lol

[@TopherGrant]

That's almost as weird as you using all caps and too many emojis. Are you an 11 year old girl? You type like one.

[@lia8006]

He needs to correct his daughter… yeah she shouldn’t have engaged with the little girl but disrespect is disrespect and it can’t be ignored! You see what happens when adults let that disrespect slide smh.

[@Coco-ef9ps]

Toxic!!!

[@sheldoncole1151]

How many children does he have and how many children does she have?

[@sheldoncole1151]

I see she has 4 daughters and a son.

[@sheldoncole1151]

He seems to have just a son and a daughter but probably more than that.

[@ramsesstafford4640]

I don't feel sorry for no man with huge blisters on his hands who loves playing with fire. If that really is true that he married her anyway you you get what you ask for.🤷🏽‍♂️

[@OhHappyDayz]

She’s a little child… lady needs to take a seat!! She’s a walking red flag….

[@sheldoncole1151]

So the father, son, and daughter jumped her🤔?

[@locafly]

Toxic ppl

[@AnthonyIngram-h5c]

GD EVENING 🌄

[@jerrypearce5920]

Damit !😂

[@sheldoncole1151]

He look like Will Smith a little bit

[@dawnettereed843]

Toxicity

[@timothyjacob6381]

Men, never ever put a bitter toxic female ahead of your child. Furthermore, this is why I suggest more men remain single, acquire your own homes and enjoy your peace/tranquility instead of putting up with foolishness. You will feel much better in the long run. 🙄

[@sereneamani1713]

For someone who had such a loving mother (as you've mentioned on other videos), how did you develop such a disdain for women. It would seem that you had all the preparation you would have needed to pick a perfect wife and live happily ever after. While you're suggesting that more men remain single, are you also suggesting that they remain celibate in their singleness? Something is not adding up.