Canada di current condition nal jo halaat students de ne te jo onna de parents nal vaprda hai , usdi Real Picture tusi apne program ch discuss kiti hai , eh video dekh k Punjab ton aoun valian nu lesson laina chahida hai , specially Non PR students de parents nu , Eh Discussion bahut vdhia mudde te kiti , well done
@dipendersingh35349 ай бұрын
Very good explanation... This is the ground reality of our community.
@RajbirSingh-sy7sv9 ай бұрын
pls bring this person again. He seems very knowledgeable and intellectual
@rajkahlon82549 ай бұрын
I agree with you sir. Very good topic
@SimarDeep-ye6yt9 ай бұрын
ਹੈਲਪ ਮੀ
@gmeetg1239 ай бұрын
Really Great Conversation.. One of the best of all I have seen on RedFM. Shameel Ji tuhade Guest nu mere wallo lakh lakh thanks. Enna Badhia analysis. I shared it to all my friends and relatives in India.. Great..
@NewYork0110J9 ай бұрын
People must respect other human beings whether students or their family members they are potential citizens of Canada and fellow countrymen from India
@harmailsingh13089 ай бұрын
ਬਾਈ ਜੀ ਰਹਿਣ ਵਾਸਤੇ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਨਾਲੋਂ ਵਧੀਆ ਕੋਈ ਥਾਂ ਨਹੀਂ।
@vikksingh9109 ай бұрын
👍👍👍👍
@manoharlal66688 ай бұрын
Bhed chal hai ji
@ramankang81057 ай бұрын
Haji,tarbooj te hor fal sbjia nu teeke,dudh ch chemical,peen wale paani ch chemical,sadhe hoe tobhe,beimaan sarkaaran,berujgaari,naukri ch reservation,corrupt officer,sach hi punjab ta swarg hi aa
@dyumansharma84836 ай бұрын
Amazing conversation. Please bring more people like him who can share more stories of parents life in Canada. Thanks
In most of cases it happens what Dr Sahib has described however there might be some exception too.
@gursharandhillon29319 ай бұрын
Very good discussion. I met some known who went to Canada last week to see his student children. His was so dissatisfied that he called his daughter back to India who had completed her study. His son will complete the study next year and he will also come back next year and join his father's business in India which is going well.
@lakhvirsinghgrewal77778 ай бұрын
Very informative and useful discussion. This professor is very intelligent. Please make one or two episodes on this burning topic.
Right, par Bhai Sahib 80% parents di soch work krn di a, students hi nai bal ki PR de parents v e soche a, Haan kam sab nu nai milda, tnx
@Universe3709 ай бұрын
Bai thodi mata da apni mitti naal moh Ghat hona. Nahi ta Punjab vrgi rees ki ha
@luckysidhu19529 ай бұрын
TERE WARGA KOE 100WICHO 2/YA4 HON GE KAKA JITHE.MAA BAP KHUSH NE LOKA DE BOHAT. HE WORST NE HALAT
@dhanwantmoga9 ай бұрын
Sadi Mata ne tan 5 month kadne aokhe ho gaye ce
@ManjitSingh-ce5sq9 ай бұрын
Tell me about majority
@jaipalsinghsohi68119 ай бұрын
oh jaa!!! We keep our parents on the top of our hearts, I live with my mother in her home in Canada. We Sikh students are very close to our parents and respect/love them. Stop stereotyping students.
@Jfs114209 ай бұрын
Yes bro . Ehde putt ne bhaande manjwaaye hone sale de ne , Taaahi baitha bakwas kar rea
@jaipalsinghsohi68119 ай бұрын
@@Jfs11420 hatt da o ni har roz iko gal, ehnu kaho jo kudia vakha k gaddia vechan lagge hoye ne ohde baare v kade bol. But NO.
@harpreetdhaliwal60729 ай бұрын
This man shameel doesn’t know anything
@anilsharma20459 ай бұрын
This is not fit for all
@jaipalsinghsohi68119 ай бұрын
@@meenusingh7064 in your dreams
@canadiancanadian76209 ай бұрын
Great exchange of realty situation. Sadly people in Punjab don’t know this. New comers don’t tell their friends and relatives the truth about their lives here.
@Worldwidevirk9 ай бұрын
Do worry billy coming out of jhola these days
@sanjeevrai55639 ай бұрын
The reality is told
@harkanwaluppal71219 ай бұрын
Reality hurts to most of people.He is right great discussion.
@hardeepcheema6919 ай бұрын
Very true social reality discussion.
@kaurraman82519 ай бұрын
Veer ji bhut vadia gallha.ne ..ssa ji
@ManjitSingh-ce5sq9 ай бұрын
Waheguru da shukar ae je othay gurdawara sahi na hunday tan adhe ton wadh bukhay marday Dhan babay nanak da langar Jo harek lyi khula hai chahay jis v qoum da hovay
@22.00 Beg, borrow or steal...in our veins... reality
@harjitgill81659 ай бұрын
shameel ji, tuhade program da visha v vadhia hunda te tuhade guest v but tusi galbaat nu vichale kat dende ho te next swaal shuru kar dende ho jo ke changa nahi lagda kise di gal nu viche hi kat dena. Vese program vadhia hunda hai. Thanks 🙏
@psmangat8 ай бұрын
same, main vi note kita
@jugrajssarao9 ай бұрын
ਬਹੁਤ ਹੀ ਸਿੱਖਿਆਦਾਇਕ ਗੱਲਬਾਤ
@manashsingh65509 ай бұрын
Sir ji middle class de karan hi Canada, Australia di value hain otherwise othe janda kaun, Dr saab Mumbai, Banglore, Ahmedabad city ch gaye nahin lagde, buildings sab India ch b hain. Dr Saab ne bhi kafi kuchh sehya lagda hain.
@jogabining47599 ай бұрын
Very true Bhaji
@Worldwidevirk9 ай бұрын
15:18 true
@Gillmjot9 ай бұрын
Bahut vdia discussion sir ji
@gurvindersaund74669 ай бұрын
Good discussion and msg
@manmeetsingh95919 ай бұрын
Canada is a land of opportunity and everyone need chance to change its life so not everyone did any 420 to came here. So respect everyone keep your views and hate within yourself and if you are not helping others dont blame anyone because life is all about survival.
@Simranjeet_Singh18049 ай бұрын
Bro India is a land of opportunities. We have 142 crore of consumer base. Even CANADIAN COMPANIES are investing in INDIA by disinvestment in CANADA. Last year total disinvestment and bankruptcy in CANADA $66 billion.
@RandhawaPB469 ай бұрын
@@Simranjeet_Singh1804canada nalo Jadia opportunity ne Indian ch... Canada ch jina crime drug kite jada jinia Cara Indian ch pure saal ch chori hundia onia canada ch 1 month ch ho jandia oh vi bas ina di 1 2 state vich... eh hlaat ne canada de police kehdi je chor chori krn awe te apni gaddi di chabbi apni door kol rakho ta ki oh chabi Lake jaan wala bane na kise nu nuksaan kare car chori krke turda bane😅😂
@RandhawaPB469 ай бұрын
rehn de oye jina canada canad lye va onna hun ina palle haga ni kujj 600 Cara ina di iko state ch chori hoyea jehri Faria tak ni gyea ina kolo ithe govt school cha jake dasdo drug kida leni tusi je gay lesbian ban na oh tuhada gander change karoon lye paise dinde tuhadi family is vich kush ni kr skdi... 😅 ithe kine farzi university colg chalde student nu looten lye... punjabi sabto fukre bas mustang leni bhave dyari krda howe bass ch loan diya kista ni ditya Jandia ina kolo😅... bara kuj va gal lambi ho jani hun canada ne bah pye 12 karke aun wale hun punjab ch e reela banon ge... baki south wale India to citizen ship lake aunde sidhi punjabia wangu wrong way nal fake paper lake ni visa ni lende... 😅
@rohitjamwal61579 ай бұрын
Canada sarkar ne bharat che pension schemes che apne share kharide ne.
@parminderkaur-dv6df9 ай бұрын
I agree with sir and plz plz give some water so that sir ji feel comfortable
@Worldwidevirk9 ай бұрын
19:00 rhatka real canadian systen da, jhtka exploitation da
J ithe kise kol kise nl gl krn da time nhi ae ta tuhadi 36 minutes di video dekhan a time heiga?
@Rajahunk13139 ай бұрын
Uncle good🎉
@GurpreetSinghBhullar-t9x9 ай бұрын
Mere bete nu three year hoge bhramtion mein per asi vistor visa nahi liy
@Worldwidevirk9 ай бұрын
12:12 true
@Worldwidevirk9 ай бұрын
32:31 so true, all nang khach beniyat are here in canada now
@prabhjeetsinghmonga31965 ай бұрын
You should come out of Brampton, and meet the students outside GTA. Punjabi ch Tarjma kar deva?
@hirdaybhinder89679 ай бұрын
Punjabi main Bhave app kaaha main vi punjabi aa. Sade pind ik pr Hoya pind sari raat atishbazi kiti. Ki Karo ge Adha pind depression ch chala gaya. Main ik doctor aa India ch boht vadia set aa par kise ne role model nahi kia role model kon aa jera Bahar jaa ke labour Kar riha
@navdeepkang51629 ай бұрын
There should be one program on How Canadian Born Grand kids treat their Parents and Grandparents. Then , you will understand How well students parents are getting treated....Every parent is same and all should get respect they deserve...It is high time that we should stop making the categories.
@Worldwidevirk9 ай бұрын
31:13 sanaj nhi tantar " system" raje da tantar
@sukhwindersinghmultani91239 ай бұрын
Such veer ji 🙏🏿
@priyabadyal-y2e9 ай бұрын
Pra koi solution v das daily batha jande criticise karn
@amarbajwa65349 ай бұрын
How many novels about Canada did you read before coming here, sir? Giving uninvited and free advice is very easy and very self-satisfying.
@AmandeepSingh-qd9gm9 ай бұрын
❤
@JaswinderBrar-cx9rp8 ай бұрын
Challaaa..heaho kartoosh
@hirdaybhinder89679 ай бұрын
Problem ih aa parents ajey vi ih hi sochde ne nri uh hi ne jere Una ne 20saal pahila dekhe uh sochde ne asi te sade bache vi uhi nri ban Gaye Jo Hai nahi
@Worldwidevirk9 ай бұрын
7:00 Gehne gharn wala ta vadiya kmaa hi skda 8:30 dnt judge book by its cover
@GurpreetSinghBhullar-t9x9 ай бұрын
Corporate de nazer Punjab de land per hai kyon ki food process all world demand
@amandeep-fd6oo5 ай бұрын
Every one have different scenarios.... My mother in law enjoyed to be here.. . never want to go back... But my mother have a big house and land is there... She don't want to be here... 2 years since she have approved visa.. not visit a single time😅
@Worldwidevirk9 ай бұрын
19:41 paise realtors khaa ge😢
@daveohri88489 ай бұрын
Please make title in English.
@bhupinderkalra51889 ай бұрын
Negativity should not be spreaded , almost all immigrants are going to settled only timing is matter.
@grewal22023 ай бұрын
Ambition da matlab hunda Canada jaake dehadi launi? Punjabi ambitious nhi bhole hunde aa. Sara kuj bech battke othe dehadian launa te hand to mouth rehna kitho di syanap hogi?
Bai ji jehra kehanda punjab safe send him ferozepur result in less then 2Hrs
@Worldwidevirk9 ай бұрын
30:48 jhooth bole tusi khach bhori, sabb milta hai yahaan "royal paan" to tube wala jarda, cool lip, kamini uplabd hai, dode-bhukki feem groceriee store dinde han, etho de born kai bache deliver krde han, chita v rajj k milda hai
@chaina3579 ай бұрын
Students de parent ne Canada ja ke Kerna ki hai
@mandeepbrar19799 ай бұрын
bhejan layee jo paise lagge si uh recover kiwein hone aa? Pindan vale tan jameen vech ke jayee jande aa..
@Worldwidevirk9 ай бұрын
Shareek ni fukkne?
@sapnasharma17433 ай бұрын
kiu jana chai da ji ja ke dekho ta sahi ki bachy Rehh de kidda ne othy mai v ayi hoyi aa apne bacheya kol Canada
@jaspreetdhaliwal1475Ай бұрын
True sab gallbaat
@traversingh19 ай бұрын
Majority of these are Jatt community problems, and not Punjabi community problems. All the examples quoted in the discussions are from villages, farming. Shameel ji please get people from other sikh communites esp urban Punjabis. They have completely different stories..
@akashdeep1369 ай бұрын
Half knowledge is very dangerous. Go ahead and first educate yourself. Saare apne Parents nu bout vdia rakh rhe eitthe.
@mandeepbrar19799 ай бұрын
Dont generalize. Half knowledge might be on your side. Different classes have different problems. He is talking about lower middle class immigration as well.
@bsingh48819 ай бұрын
Very different opinions Of all Canadian indians. Very much is commented wrong.
There are very complications in family life husband and wife both had to work the payment goes to joint bank account where Indian husband rerely wants that his wife use credit or atm card the daughters thus lead a slavery and disappointed life.
@sahijaulakh45209 ай бұрын
💯
@NikS4049 ай бұрын
uncle fukri maar gya, j tu 2004 ch 24 lakh show kita c te apne munde lai hi kita c kise lai thodi. Naale je enna paise othe c te ethe munda amb lain aaya. Jide kol pushtaini paisa hove na oh aini aakad nai maarde, nava nava paisa aaya lagda aise peedi ch.
@SunnyR-yi9te4 ай бұрын
JUSTIN T. & JAGMEET need to resign Home Crisis , Inflation , Two bedroom puppy colleges , High Rent , crime and POOR Medical service . Canada need only 200k students but in flow is 1 million Justin T need to give answer
@sohandhillon9 ай бұрын
Parents are very intelligent and literate....and Dr is talking about only illiterate population of punjab. Students now a days are taking technology courses instead of the management.
Manu eh lagda punjabia de bhar jaan nal punjabiyat kite na kite khtre ch pa gyi c.. te jo society da Mada haal aun wale 10-20 Sal ch huna Jina de Maa baap ithe te dhee putt Canada... ajj beshak oh parents khus par Kal nu una hi rona paina... ma apeel karda sab nu foreign na jao punjab bachao punjabiyat bachao... ithe hi economy de geda deo.... skillful bano.. business karo.. ethe hi raho ... en khushal punjab.. hasda wasda punjab... eh jo Anni doud lagyi h eh da ant vi Anna h..
@MrKumar-f6r5 ай бұрын
Views are personal.. discussion is open but no argument..
Jo ethe purane jina de bache v ethe de born ohna di zindgi jada mari , because ohna de bache ta ohna nu puchde ni alne ee maa pyo toh kharcha mangde , but apne bache jo punjab toh aaye ne oh bhut krde ne apne parents di. So jehdi pension di gal krde o , pta mainu kina ku standard ehna da month de middle ch ohna kol kuch palle ni rehnda. So topic rakhde o discussion li soch smj k rkhya kro , eve na apniyan veliyan mari jaya kro .
@Universe3709 ай бұрын
Jablia mari janda. Jihnu parmatma ne do paise zada ditte a oh zada bakwaas krda😅
@jeetsingh-nv8vy9 ай бұрын
A app ve jado aea huna ae Kuz karda hou aj galla marda😂
@Universe3709 ай бұрын
Sahi keha purane set hoya nu zada glla aundia ne. Gyan den lgga hoya😂
@Worldwidevirk9 ай бұрын
31:37 haaan chakarviyuh, mkaaar jaal, metrix , shameel v aapna haircut aap es metrix to tang aa k hi aap krda
28:48 ye kya keh diya sirdar ji, yahaan sab gulam ne, uk aale raje de gulam
@AvtarSingh-zu5rd7 ай бұрын
Parents are not safe and respectful in these developed countries sometimes they feel disregarded and even misbehaved by grand children as they have forgotten their culture.
@subhashchandar35489 ай бұрын
I went to Canada on pr base I feel I wasted my time money and energy
@GurmitBSingh9 ай бұрын
Ssaji ROOT CAUSE. IS THE LEADERSHIP OF SUBCONTINENT ; HEERAMANDI LAHORE WARGEY DALAL CULT PUJARI KANJAR PIMPS HANJI SUSPECTED? AANPARDTA BY THEM ; VISIONLESS JI?
@pkdhillon22398 ай бұрын
Kidde oukhe ho rye a
@MrKala29 ай бұрын
Koi v vadwaan aunda ohnu eh pucho v tu kive aiya .
@balbirgrewal88525 ай бұрын
Why do they come. They bloody cant afford the fees than why do they come here. Govt should stop their visas. All work on cash than condemn Cabada.
@hirdaybhinder89679 ай бұрын
Sabh to vadh moorkh te nasujwan log ne parents . Ih uh ne Jina ne India ch bachia De jaan khadi hundi Bahar jao falne da vi chala gaya flane da vi. India ch hi log ne Jina Karke aj bache kise vi mulkh ch dhake khaan Lai tyar ho gae.