Kazakhstan: Russian colonialism

[@robwalsh9843]

I always found it laughable how the Soviet Union portrayed itself as an opponent of colonialism and imperialism while happily practicing those two things in Central Asia, North Caucasus and the Baltic States. I guess it goes with that old saying about paying attention to what someone does as opposed to what they say.

[@deadchannelxd0420]

then why do people from those regions have an overwelling postive view of the soviet union? and lets apply what ur saying to america :)

[@WladylawGomulka]

@@deadchannelxd0420 those people that you speak of are russians colonizers.

[@bobbydylsn2633]

@@deadchannelxd0420 So postive that they create own countries :P

[@robwalsh9843]

@@deadchannelxd0420 yes the Baltics just LOVE Russian nationalism and Soviet nostalgia, right? Chechens and Ingush just love fond memories of being carted off into death trains to Siberia, right? Georgians are just giddy over Ossetian separatism, right?

[@Manuka-px2pe]

And Urals and Siberia

[@Almaty_forever]

During the Soviet period Kazakhs were subjected to genocide, during collectivization half of population of Kazakhs died. Approximately 3 million Kazakhs died. There was also devastating famines in 20s, 30s and 40s. No holocaust can be compared to this atrocity of Soviet bastards. Why this expert never mentioned about that? The holodomor genocide of Ukrainians is recognized in the world but nobody want to acknowledge the same genocide in Kazakhstan which was even more deadly

[@devourthepower007]

this food shortage was also in Russia, not only in Kazakhstan

[@leksolee6135]

its politics. Whenever USA decides to drag Kazakhstan into NATO there will be tones of YT "historical" videos about famines in Kazakhstan and all Western countries will recognize it. Now its Ukraine's turn to be integrated into Western sphere. Thats why they talk only about Holodomor

[@greasher926]

@@devourthepower007rural population was impacted hardest by famine and collectivization at the expense of urban factory workers. Urban population was mainly Russian, so ethnic Russians were not as heavily impacted. Rural people were mostly ethnic minorities such as Kazakhs and Ukrainians, so they starved, as their food was forcibly taken away to feed the factory workers. If you look at the census data, you will see a big crash in minority populations in the 30s, while Russian populations grew. Not to say rural Russians didn’t experience hardships. For example in Russian RSFSR in 1926 there were 6,870,976 Ukrainians, but in 1939 only 3,205,061, a reduction of -53.3%. In the same time period Russian population went from 71,374,283 to 89,747,795, a growth of +25.7% In Ukrainian SSR in 1926 there was 23,218,860 Ukrainians and in 1939 there was 23,667,509 Ukrainians a growth of +1.9% in comparison Russian population in the same time period went from 2,677,166 to 4,175,299, a growth of +55.9%. In Kazakh SSR the Kazakh population went from 3,627,612 in 1926 to 2,327,625 in 1939 a decline of -35.83% in comparison same time period ethnic Russians grew from 1,275,055 to 2,458,687 a growth of +92.82%. Interestingly Ukrainian population also suffered in Kazakhstan. They declined from 860,201 to 658,319, a drop by -23.4%.

[@gigaxan]

3,968,289 in 1926 and 2,002,453 in 1937 for Kazakhs actually

[@devourthepower007]

@@greasher926 and now please do the same with ethnic Russians. Your sources sure say something about the Russians no? And your claim about Russians not being in rural areas is outrageous. Most of Russians lived in rural areas, check your history

[@p_sardar_b]

As a Kazakh thanks for making this🇰🇿🐴🐺🦅

[@FNFive-seveNN]

Türk kardeşim 🇹🇲🇰🇬🇲🇳🇺🇿🇦🇿🇰🇿🇹🇷

[@Meryem1618]

🇰🇿🇰🇿🇰🇿🇰🇿🇰🇿🇰🇿🦅🦅🦅🦅 🤝🏼🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🐺🐺🐺🐺 RAWRRR

[@nothingforyou-wb4jk]

Сен казаксынба?

[@Bstknk]

I’m studying Kazakh and I’d love to visit one day. Сәлеметсіз бе from the UK 🇬🇧🤝🇰🇿

[@erkinberdalin4381]

Finally truth about russian colonialism is spreading. Respect from KZ

[@user-jg4vl7xl2f]

Где это метрополии строят в колониях школы , больницы , промышленность , поднимают сельское хозяйство ? Расскажи бот как твои американские хозяева развили коренные народы северной Америки . Как индейцы получили свою письменность , промышленность , театры , балет , науку . Ну давай , не стесняйся .

[@neugeburt1952]

@@user-jg4vl7xl2f Строили для русских. Нам строить не надо было ничего, вас никто не просил. Захватили, геноцидили, еще спасибо просят за отсталую инфраструктуру.

[@ColoniaMurder20]

@@user-jg4vl7xl2f Spanish Empire also build same with schools, hospitals and industry.. but Spanish was called colonialism as well... Russia is same other empires who committed autocracy and their imperialism.

[@Идиот2.0-ъ9т]

Испанская империя массово загоняла в рабство и совершала геноцид местного населения в пользу метрополии​. Россия же этого не делала@@ColoniaMurder20

[@Mr.celery]

Proud of Kazakhstan from Iran

[@trueordrue]

Glad Iran escaped Russias colonialism bcz they had plenned it today but failed

[@Маскаленокпоросенок]

Иран нн помогайте русским против украины пожалуйста .Они русские враги иранцев тюрков и монгол ,враги ислама и других религий кроме провославия .

[@tonyattenborough3754]

Iran needs to stop supporting terrorism and arming Putin

[@nuperaa6617]

Stop with the drones! Why is Iran helping Russia?

[@Mr.celery]

@@nuperaa6617 because the government is bad, nobody in iran even likes them nor supports them

[@ttssa2030]

~600,000 Kazakhs lives in Russia as native population and it has zero Kazakh school! While there are thousands Russian schools in Kazakhstan. Modern Kremlin neo-colonism 😢

[@AhmedBabiker-sr8fl]

110M Russians live in Russia

[@Albion80s]

In Mongolia, the locals population use Russian language and can't read and write in their native language whereas in Inner Mongolia, China, their education system was entirely in Mongolian.

[@Anonim-tt6zo]

Кочевники в России пришлые ...

[@ttssa2030]

@@Anonim-tt6zo Это русские оккупанты пришлые. Земли от Саратова до Астрахани и до Тюмени это исконные земли кочевников (Улуса Джучи), а все тюркские народы их потомки!

[@Anonim-tt6zo]

@@ttssa2030 кочевники к городам не имеют отношение ..кочевники пасли скот где царь разрешил..и казахи не тюрки а тюркоговорящие

[@mazardam11]

Don't forget that there was also the first famine of 1919-1922 in Kazakhstan (-900,000 Kazakhs), the Kazakh uprising against the Russian Empire in 1916 (-450,000), and World War II (-500,000 Kazakhs). In total, the Kazakh ethnic group lost (together with Kazakhs who migrated abroad) about 4 or 4.5 million in just 25 years! Considering the crazy birth rate in Kazakh families in the second half of the 20th century, the population of Kazakhstan would most likely have grown to at least 45-50 million people.

[@ilbebackkk667]

im Kazakh, those numbers are bloated imo, but the population definitely declined

[@mazardam11]

@@ilbebackkk667 and where exactly is it exaggerated?

[@БекЬека]

@@mazardam11I think mobilized population for war from Kazakh USSR was evenly matched between Kazakhs and Russians.

[@Сергей-СаидРусскийТатарин]

Пиши уже миллиарды казахов. Что 4-5 миллионов. Для фантазии слабовато

[@Сергей-СаидРусскийТатарин]

​@@ilbebackkk667если читать перепись Российской империи и СССР, численность казахов наоборот увеличивалось.

[@TarlanT]

Russian heartland is west of Volga River. Everything east of it - colonized territories. Including Siberia. Where indigenous people were slaughtered in 18-19 centuries. Now they are tiny minorities there. Same with Central Asia.

[@Circassiangurl2002]

Russian Empire also targeted indigenous people from the Caucasus and caused a nasty genocide there as well. Empires bring death to everything they touch 💔

[@NoahGordon-x9x]

I was abt to say this video just said Central Asia I was like what abt Siberia and the caucus region hahaha😅

[@NoahGordon-x9x]

Apologies Caucasus* region

[@Juan-qu4oj]

They got a taste of their own medicine the Mongols and Turks oppressed Russia for many years.

[@TarlanT]

@@Juan-qu4oj Russia was never oppressed. They were lawful subjects. Tax rate was mere 10%. No religious bans, or exploitation.

[@jorgeluiscapiello414]

Declining Russia is a victim of its own ambitions.

[@tunuitahitianfire9875]

@@jorgeluiscapiello414 how is it in decline ? Have you seen what Russia looked like in the 90s ?

[@rossiskaya]

🙄😂😂😂😂

[@bigmedge]

@@tunuitahitianfire9875it’s even worse now - at least back then they had high value-added industry , ailing as it was . Now, with the exception of some antiquated munitions plant & Renault-owned VAZ, Russia is purely a petrostate

[@tunuitahitianfire9875]

@@bigmedge not sure what you’re talking about unless you’re describing Russia in some alternative reality? In the 90s Russia became completely de-industrialized as a result of shock therapy economics and neoliberalism . These days Russia is more industrialized than it’s ever been since the end of the Cold War. Also Russia is outproducing the whole of NATO with its military industrial complex and this is according to American sources and American military analysts……

[@bigmedge]

@@tunuitahitianfire9875 “Russia is out producing all of NATO” 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 given how absurd & easily debunked your lies are , you might as well just admit that the Kremlin pays you Also, if you look at the list of the biggest bankrupted factories from the former USSR, you’ll see that they were ALL bankrupted well into the 2000s, b/c those bankruptcies were engineered by Putin & his cronies (since his real estate developer buddies would rather use that land to build malls)

[@PatriciaPalmer-o3e]

❗The Kazakh generations born after the USSR collapse are fierce in their belief in, and fealty to a free Kazakhstan sovereign nation, their culture and traditions. Siz beni jaqsi koremiz Kazakhstan !

[@abeke5523]

Biz seni*

[@PatriciaPalmer-o3e]

@@abeke5523 ❤️

[@sky-k1b5v]

🇰🇿🇷🇺💪 без России Мы не можем,

[@PatriciaPalmer-o3e]

@@sky-k1b5v ❤️ Sen sulwsin !

[@sonic3932]

@@sky-k1b5vСлава Украïне & Казахстану! 🫵🏻☝🏻💪🏻🇰🇿🇺🇦🇪🇺🕊️✊🏻😎

[@saulgoodmanKAZAKH]

The beginning is misleading. Much, much of Russia's vast land is also colonized, taken away from the native Turkic, Siberian, Mongolic, and other peoples. The beginning implied that the land shown as Russia was always Russian.

[@tunuitahitianfire9875]

@@saulgoodmanKAZAKH do you just dream of Balkanizing Russia ? How would you feel if I told you that many of those ethnic minority regions support Putin even more the Slavic core of Russia’s population ?

[@devourthepower007]

Russia industrialised Kazakhstan

[@yedigemagavin1694]

@@devourthepower007and? Is that an achievement? Are you wannabe colonizing sovereigns circlejerking themselves thanking each other for bringing light to “lesser people” or what? Such a colonizer mindset. We would have industrialized ourselves pretty fine, colonizer bastards. Your argument only works if you think yourselves to be better than others. When you are not.

[@Silver_Prussian]

Majority of the land russia has today was not previously inhabited by any people, so no very small parts of the land were inhabited by said peoples

[@moonman1612]

@@devourthepower007 more precisely, the USA industrialized the USSR

[@shyngystemir2924]

Smart guy. He showed a strongly understanding of what Qazaq people think and that some Russians consider local civilization as undeveloped.

[@orionnew-uu2eh]

не россияне а все

[@ОльгаВасенина-ц8д]

😂😂😂 че мы там думаем? Скока фантазеров в интернете, за нас придумывают что мы думаем. Пропагандистский ролик, один и тот же механизм воздействия на умы на всем постсоветском пространстве. Это каким же не думающим человеком надо быть чтоб на это покупаться(

[@shyngystemir2924]

@@ОльгаВасенина-ц8д do you consider yourself as a Qazaq people?

[@isarichfriday]

​@@ОльгаВасенина-ц8д Если вам что-то не нравится собирайте свои манатки и валите в свою родину. Она как раз в опасности, сына своего на сво не забудьте отправить.

[@opolchenec55]

Посмотрите на Афганистан так бы выглядела Средняя Азия без русских, но под британцами 😂

[@tonuykok577]

Much respect from Kazakhstan. Thank you for enlightenment ❤

[@ВалентинаЕрмольчева-д2о]

Просветили дурака😂

[@Northearthousewell]

As a Sakha (resident of Yakutia), I share the opinion that Russia is a colonial empire

[@mrobocop1666]

In colonial empire people of metropoly and colonies have different status and citizenship, they don't belong in the same country. In Russia and former USSR all peoples have/had the same citizenship and it was one contigious country, not metropoly and colonies. Colonies used only to extract resourses and money from them, while if you look at USSR budget, it's clear Russia, Belarus and Turkmenistan donated money to all the rest 12 republics of USSR, not received from them. Millions of Russian(I mean not ethnic, but all citizen - Russians, Tatars, Chuvash, etc.) specialists built entire cities and industries in Central Asia, which lived in Medieval level of development before USSR. So Russia definetely is a multiethnic empire, but not colonial in any definition, it's just Western propganda

[@adnyc82]

@@mrobocop1666What you say is only true on paper. In reality, non-Russians - especially if they’re visibly not white - are treated horribly in Russia and also were in the Soviet Union. Look at how indigenous peoples in Siberia were exploited for the fur trade to pay the “yasak” - it’s been compared to what King Leopold I did in the Congo. That’s why the relationship between the Russian metropole and the ethnic minority regions is so extractive, why Moscow and St. Petersburg look like modern, affluent European cities, while those in ethnic minority regions are all poor and run-down. It’s also why ethnic minorities from Dagestan, Buryatia, Kalmykia, etc. make up most of the cannon fodder being sent to Ukraine. Ask anyone who grew up under the Soviet Union as a person of color, especially from the Caucasus, Central Asia or the Far East, and they’ll tell you Russians are a deeply racist, chauvinistic people. So yeah, you’re a colonial empire. The Spaniards, British, French, Portuguese, Dutch etc. all acknowledge their colonial pasts. You Russians’ failure to even admit you’re a colonial empire, let alone atone for the awful things you’ve done for centuries, is a big reason why you’re such an amoral, psychopathic society today.

[@r0manov]

Нифига чё выдумал. У вас республика своя есть, какой ещё колониализм, чудик?)

[@Harrison-u7h]

​@@r0manovit's a disgruntled Jew.

[@Hanzada11]

Уруй Айхал💙

[@adamoliver4094]

I worked in Kazakhstan for a few years in my late 20s. I learned some Russian to be able to better communicate with my coworkers, but was only able to pick up a few phrases in Kazakh. Even in the early 2000's I had trouble finding books or other language resources to study Kazakh. Coworkers from Taraz and Shymkent were proud of their ability to speak Kazakh, but people from Semey, Aktau, or Kyzlorda frequently couldn't speak it. Working there are fond memories for me. My info is probably out of date, but I remember very tough people with a great sense of humor. If you show a little respect there, they will pay you back two-fold.

[@g4m3r222]

they somehow fixed themselves- they are now 60% but they were 30% in ussr

[@saulgoodmanKAZAKH]

Ethnic groups do not matter; you are accepted in Kazakhstan, no matter if you're Kazakh, Russian, German, Korean, or anyone else. As long as you are not brainwashed by the Russian TV, of course, which, unfortunately still operates in Kazakhstan.

[@ЕееНнн-п5с]

71% in 2024

[@Hygffhhuhhbc5]

A birth rate is one of the highest in the world there, even ethnic russians have significantly higher birth rates than the russians in russia proper

[@minniemoe4797]

Several generations of Kazakh women sacrificed themselves to raise big families and work hard in the countryside with minimum facilities.

[@Roky068]

They f with statistics😂😂😂.

[@KaissarTuganbay-g5c]

Finally some saying central Asia was a Russian former colony

[@paulurban2472]

The only difference is that they were not touched or enslaved by Russia if not have a better life afterwords

[@user-mh5xk6fl1x]

Колония, жители которой стали жить лучше, после того как их колонизировали.

[@andin3720]

@@paulurban2472You can say that Indians had a better life after they were conquered by the British. The British build infrastructure and development. That doesn’t make British good, same with Russians.

[@KaissarTuganbay-g5c]

Man I really want people now a days call central Asia that it used to be a Russian former colony because we are asians Not Europeans and Russians Europeans​@@andin3720

[@husanalikuvvatov3371]

@@paulurban2472 yeah, if if was not for their russian imperialism and annexation, these central asian countries would be way more developed by now!

[@bayas1302]

Kazakhs actually had a territory. They moved only when seasons changed, every 3-6 month. They always returned to their place. If another tribe would settle there, it was a crime. We needed big lands for animal farming, which was the main attribute of nomad life, for food, clothes, tools and transportation. So russians settled in that lands, so it was impossible to live in a small place when you have animals and family to care about.

[@askarsaiyn6295]

Сол туралы айтты ғой басында, жаңа поляк. Отырықшы секілді бір-екі жерді алмастырып пайдаланды деп

[@nomad7843]

As a Kazakh: Everything was true! Thanks for the video!

[@justjake5389]

Are you learning Chinese yet?

[@nomad7843]

@@justjake5389 I'm learning italian. I can speak German, Turkish, English and Kazakh of course. Chinese unfortunately not my favourite.

[@justjake5389]

@@nomad7843 dann warte mal ab. Früher oder später werden sich die Chinesen ihr Land wieder zurückholen ☝️ diesmal werden es keine Russen verhindern.

[@Korea-d8o]

​@@justjake5389Russians will learn Chinese, in Siberia and the Urals the Chinese are already building farms

[@justjake5389]

@@Korea-d8o So what? And we in the West own all of Kazakhstan's raw materials. All the companies that mine the raw materials belong to the West. What is the problem now that the Chinese are doing business with Russia in Siberia?

[@4xhoser]

The free people are with you, don’t let colonizers win! 🇨🇦🇺🇦🇰🇿

[@wingedvictory8694]

Slava Ukraini!

[@tunuitahitianfire9875]

@@4xhoser how free are the First Nations of Canada from their western colonizers ?

[@tunuitahitianfire9875]

@@4xhoser how free are the First Nations people of Canada from their western colonizers ?

[@gramograzYT]

​@tunuitahitianfire9875 very free, canadians are literally just english and french people so there's nothing much for them to be free from

[@tunuitahitianfire9875]

@@gramograzYT if you’re going to talk this way about freedom from colonizers then at the very least you should leave Canada so that the indigenous First Nations people can be free of your colonialism

[@dubsar]

How many more Kazakhstans are held hostage by Moscow?

[@wingedvictory8694]

Yakutia, Tatarstan, Buryatia, Bashkortostan, Dagestan, Chechnya And this is in the very least…

[@dubsar]

@@wingedvictory8694 Tannu Tuva

[@tunuitahitianfire9875]

@@wingedvictory8694 have you ever travelled to any of these ethnic minority regions of Russia ? Putin enjoys even stronger support in these areas compared to the Slavic core west of the Volga…. It seems the desire to Balkanize Russia is more of a globalist western desire rather than a grassroots desire of these ethnic minorities…..

[@Squee.1366]

There are 22 "national" republics and many more "autonomous" "national regions" in the russian "federation"

[@NotUselessProductions]

@@wingedvictory8694yes

[@draconian8994]

In Africa Russia had been portrayed as anti colonialism, and Africans believe it. But Russia's Colonial enterprise had been against its neighbours and in Asia where it had exploited their resources to its advantage and spread his people and language to the detriment of local languages. A factor that is still causing problems in virtually all the former Soviet countries till today. If today its neighbours see it as a threat and distance themselves from it, it is simply logical. Only leaders with dictatorial ambitions among them like in Belarus warm up to Putin, to silence critics and obtain his protection. Such leaders in Georgia are daily at variance with the public opinion. How can someone rejected by his neighbours be seen a friend in Africa?

[@saulgoodmanKAZAKH]

Unfortunately part of this "find new big brother" mentality is also a thing for Kazakhs. Leaving Russian influence, some Kazakh search for some other infleunce and not complete independence. Some face the US, some Turkey, some the Arab states.

[@paulurban2472]

The difference between western colonists and Russia is that Russia did not enslave them or kill them. If anything their life became much better. And for Russias neighbors, many people in the former Soviet republics have a good view on the ussr and Russia even Ukraine. It’s just their corrupt governments always choose the anti Russia can distaste and their elections decide nothing. Even Russia had that problem when Yeltsin was in power, for his second term practically everyone was voting for the communist party but he still somehow magically won the second term

[@justjake5389]

@@saulgoodmanKAZAKH the usa is responsible for 80 million dead native americans. great partners.

[@justjake5389]

you are spreading foolish western propaganda here, the russians behaved like everyone else at the time. the turks or the english also conquered territories and expanded their influence.

[@SAYLAW88]

​@@justjake5389No one can compare with Russia in colonization. Godless Russia destroyed half of the Kazakh people, but Türkiye and England did not do this, look at India how it rose today because England was there and not Russia. If Russia were there, it would be very worse.

[@FNFive-seveNN]

Thank you for bringing attention to this. Kazakh people lost their language because of the Russians. 🇰🇿🇺🇿🇦🇿🇹🇲🇰🇬🇲🇳🇹🇷

[@justjake5389]

And why are the Kurds forbidden to speak Kurdish in Turkey?

[@dantok2626]

​@@justjake5389 because turkey doesn't want them to speak it?

[@opolchenec55]

​@@justjake5389это другое 😂

[@FNFive-seveNN]

@@justjake5389 They‘re not. They‘re not allowed to use it in the government because the official language is Turkish. They live in Türkiye, so they need to learn turkish. It‘s pretty simple

[@jekiaka3411]

When I was child, I was asked my self why thare are no people from Kazakhstan on TV. All Russians and all praises to russians. My parents shush me do not talk out loud about that

[@эддимерфи-е3ю]

не ври

[@justjake5389]

Were all white people in the Soviet Union automatically Russians?

[@АндрейП-у1ю]

This is still the case in modern Russia as well. You almost never see any asian looking people on Russian TV.

[@justjake5389]

@@АндрейП-у1ю maybe because at least 85% of Russia’s population are white?!

[@cohonasking24]

​@@АндрейП-у1ю бред. Сразу Азамат в голову пришëл. И куча других людей.

[@St0nehead999]

Kazakhstan is eager to align itself with the civilized world, moving away from its historical ties with Russia. Throughout history, Russia has inflicted immense suffering on the Kazakh people, from the mass starvation and genocidal policies of the 1920s and 1930s to the brutal slaughter of civilians by ataman Boris Annenkov. These atrocities are part of a long-standing pattern of oppression, including the decades-long genocide and ethnocide under Soviet rule, the devastation caused by the Semipalatinsk nuclear testing site, and the exploitation of Baikonur. In recent years, Russian politicians have consistently issued threats against Kazakhstan, including calls to invade and annex our northern territories. Kazakhstan refuses to accept this hostility and seeks partnership with nations that respect sovereignty and human rights.

[@St0nehead999]

Unfortunately, the civilized world has repeatedly turned its back on us. In January 2022, with the silent consent of these nations, we were gunned down in the streets, and no one stood up for us. On January 7, 2022, when communication was finally restored in my city, I called the UN mission in Kazakhstan and asked why the world wasn’t seeing the killing of ordinary citizens here. Their response was blunt: "The UN does not deal with such matters." This indifference is a painful reminder that in moments of crisis, we cannot always rely on international support.

[@FNFive-seveNN]

We still love you brother There’s no friend for a Türk other than other türks 🇰🇿🇹🇲🇦🇿🇺🇿🇰🇬🇲🇳🇹🇷

[@mrobocop1666]

​@@St0nehead999 considering Kazakhstan is housing a lot of Western influence and Western organisations, and Russia, China, Iran don't need West getting foundation in their backyard, Russia's next target after Ukraine will be Kazakhstan, but unlike Ukraine, NATO wouldn't help it with ammo, weapons and money so it will be much quicker than Ukraine. China would silently support Russia, Chinese foreign ministry recently even officially condemned KZ for housing US military biolabs (that was one of reasons of war in Ukraine). Muslim world today as well supports Russia as leading figher against Western hegemony. Russia would leave alone only Southern Kazakhstan with religious militant population and weak economy. The rest of kazakhstan with europeanised population will again become a Russian asset and part of the federation, like Kazakhstan was autonomous republic of RSFSR prior to 1936.

[@St0nehead999]

@@mrobocop1666 sad, but true…😢

[@Дан-п3т]

20 и 30 е годы голод устроили коммунисты а не Россия

[@ufcfan2018]

Рақмет сіздерге шындық және қолдау үшін!

[@Dark-Mustang]

"Does Russia still pose a threat to Kazakhstan?" After watching what they've done to Chechnya, Georgia, and Ukraine - the answer is obvious.

[@stadtbekanntertunichtgut]

I only found this channel by chance on the KZbin homepage, but I see it as a happy coincidence. You're doing a great job! Keep it up.

[@bizzarostormy]

Very interesting, This has me interested in learning more about this area and its history, and that is a feat.

[@ka3axka370]

The Capitol of Gengiz Khan Empire was Karakorum which is in Kazakhstan

[@steiner7045]

жили в степях кочевники . пришли русские и дали им заводы. технологии . культуру .современное образование . построили города .предприятия . имели Казахстан право выхода из СССР как и остальные. была дружба народов и африканцы и азиаты все в ссср не подвергались дискриминации и шли вместе к общему счастливому будущему . ссср изничтожили изнутри . казахстан купили сша и брюсель и 74.5% всех ресурсов Казахстан принадлежит западным компаниям .бансковская сфера тоже . и план настроить всех против россии и даже учебники англосаксы пишут о жизни в ссср заменив Казахстан Африкой , а СШа Россией . и видим это видео. найди на ютубе Nord Kazah там этнический казах правду говорит и по фактам доказывает .а вот это видео пропаганда для идиотов

[@ShynarEsmagambetova]

​@@steiner7045 началось...про стоя ссать научили забыл сказать....про за юрту срать ходили .....вши падали в тарелку.

[@helloworld-ti5zs]

​@@steiner7045Совершенно верно. Totally agree. I am Kazakh and lived in USSR.

[@j045ua]

I love the videos about kazakhstan great job! I would love to see more maps throughout your videos! thank you😊

[@Hyperion1040]

Russia is the last colonial state that still holds many nations inside 😢

[@mattllaves]

Nope, we have all the nations in the Americas, China, Israel, Turkey, Iran, Indian and a bunch more

[@Hyperion1040]

@@mattllaves China is new colonial power with Tibet, Singciang and others.

[@Silver_Prussian]

Not colonial at all

[@Karibija]

That's not colonialism, that's human rights. Colonialism is when you don't let them have all this, or when you try to expell or exterminate them. After all, Kazakhstan is packed with many ethnic minorities without having any of these rights.

[@greasher926]

@@mattllavesyes, at least in Russia some of the native minorities have their own autonomous republics and have large populations and thriving languages. You can’t really say the same thing about the Natives in the US or Canada.

[@medaslk]

we were honestly raised in illusion of soviet equality and brotherhood .

[@asd99579]

unlike american natives :D. Let muricu nts give you a lesson of friendship

[@panslavism01]

​@@asd99579😂😂😂

[@aurelius5961]

Liberate Kazakhstan

[@Finally23]

The fun fact: Russia has been our colony for 300 years.During Golden Horde times.Toktamys burnt Miscow when they did not pay taxes .

[@mrobocop1666]

Golden Horde wasn't state Kazakhs, but all Kypchaks. Kazakhs never lived in cities like Saray, Astrakhan, Tomsk, they were built by Tatars, who weren't nomads, but lived in cities and village, and today Tatars are Russian citizens

[@frs_printing_press]

@@mrobocop1666 татары разве не рабы? это ж те же русские, только принявшие религию и язык господ. все кыпчаки и монголы были азиатами.

[@quirky-smooths]

I grew up in Kazakhstan and I'm not Russian. Although some statements in this video are clearly true, I can say that the point of view of the person being interviewed is quite biased and far from being balanced. Specifically, the story about the driver that gave the best spot to a "Russian" is complete nonsense. This may only happen if the passenger would have been a minor or a relative of the driver, so he asked him to give the spot to an elder passenger out of respect. Otherwise, this is _impossible_ to imagine in any other set up. The explanation that this was an example of a "colonial" mindset is simply ridiculous and even offensive.

[@letsplaywithmegacyborg3098]

ok but the rest?

[@QnA22]

It may not have happened to you, but to me it did. You could argue about the interpretation of it. Colonial or hospitality? Or maybe the mix of the two. I would do the same though. If someone gets in and speaks English, I will try to accommodate them.

[@Limemill]

I’m Russian and used to live close to the Kazakhstan border. There’s 100% a colonial mindset still present, but it’s getting better and quite fast due to the rebounding of local culture and language. Suffice it to check out some videos from Kazakhstan, like I recently saw one with some impressive athlete captured “something-something-amazing-Kazakh” and half the comments were in Russian (by probably older generation Kazakhs) pleading “Why would you mention his ethnicity”, “Doesn’t matter what ethnicity he is, the important thing is that he is such a great athlete” and dozens of similar posts. This is the proverbial mix of internalized fear of one’s national identity and Stockholm syndrome so typical of formerly (or presently) colonized nations. And decolonization always passes through language and culture. As soon as the Kazakh language will reach the point where it will be subconsciously treated as the language of prestige, no one will have that mentality (and I think, judging by the younger generations, the local music and video scene, Kazakhstan is on the right track)

[@nuclon]

@@Limemill 👏👏👍

[@CenturionKZ]

​@@QnA22English is a recognized by the whole world as international language, Russian is invader's language, it's totally normal that Kazakhs can refuse to speak it, and it doesn't matter if they might speak it better than some Russians

[@flyingfox707b]

You cannot mentioning russian colonization and omit SIBERIA, MANCHURIA, MONGOLIA in the Far East, Northern Europe, Baltic States and Eastern Europe? Other than the glaring omissions in the intro, I find it a really good documentary!

[@justjake5389]

so then the usa can give alaska back to the indigenous natives, right?!

[@tearet741]

​@@justjake5389But how , if they are minority there

[@kllermen5554]

Russians please not cry

[@kllermen5554]

Всегда плачете

[@aromozu1689]

​@kllermen5554 интернет герои, но против путина нихуя сделать не могут

[@Nsr666]

Don't cry my baby ❤

[@kllermen5554]

@@Nsr666 10 летний щегол иди играй игры

[@varvarith3090]

I agree. When westerners are challenged about their conquests they usualy say they are the owners of civilisation and globalism and that's how it should be. We should stop crying, stop make excuses and start making promises.

[@ruslanzhabashkanov7179]

Great video! I hope more topics on colonialism in Central Asia will be discussed

[@helloworld-ti5zs]

Руслан , но это не мешает вам пользоваться советской инфраструктурой. Вы греетесь зимой советскими ТЭЦ, вы едите хлеб из элеватора колониального СССР. Я казашка и я жила в СССР, а вы нет. Не вам рассуждать о прошлом , которое вы и не видали. Да вы даже покрасить не сможете всё то , что построили коммунисты в то время!!!!

[@ruslanzhabashkanov7179]

@@helloworld-ti5zs Hi! Thanks for your reply! Sorry if you feel this way, but I meant the impact of the Russian Empire on Central Asian countries, I think this topic is not well-researched, and I appreciate the Centre for Eastern Studies (OSW) for conducting this research and making it available to the global public.

[@Маскаленокпоросенок]

Голод погибло 2 млн за все время и уехало 2 млн в соседние страны казахов ,Ядерные испытание ,казахов в казахстане было меньше чем русских .Они отобрали наши северо западные степи построив там крепости ныне русскиеи города ,они для войн мобилизировали насиление погибали на чужих землях ,этого мы никогда не прости русским москве и их имперским странам как бы они не назывались .

[@Anonim-tt6zo]

Сказочник не было такой численности у кочевников...кз появился только в ссср

[@madinaumamira652]

As kazakh thanks for this movie Alga Kazakhstan 🇰🇿 Glory Ukraine 🇺🇦

[@АртурФилиппов-ы9ц]

Насколько же отвратительно когда твою страну сравнивают с Европейскими странами. Российский колониализм был очень сильно разным в разных местах, в одних местах это была самооборона. Представь тебе из границы постоянно совершают налëты, всë разграбляют и уходят обратно, что можно сделать в таком случае? Только одно, взять регион из которого совершаются налëты под свой контроль. Больше никак ты это не сделаешь. А, например, в таких регионах как современная Грузия, они сами просили о коллониализме России, так как они постоянно подвергались набегами с Юга и буквально молили Екатерину, чтобы она взяла их под свой контроль и навела порядок. Всë было очень по разному. Бывало и плохое отрицать не буду. Вот только это едва ли сравниться с тем что творила Европа. Которые некоторые народы почти под ноль истребили. А другие превращали в своих рабов которые до сих пор из за этого комплексуют и называют Н-ворд. И же сли бы Россия хотя бы наполовину вела бы себя как Британия Казахского народа, да и многих других было бы в десятки раз меньше их бы ни на какую современную государственность не хватило. Так же замечу (хоть я и не сторонник внушения религии и вообще атеист), но в некоторых регионах внедрение православия было абсолютно верным решением, потому что некоторые (не буду говорить кто, чтоб никого не обидеть) не брезговали такими вещами как рабство и канибализм. И замена их культуры на что то более прогрессивное для того времени было правильным решением. А теперь мои маленькие любители американской пропаганды задам вам вопрос. А почему в ваших стереотипах страна которая порабощала, проводила геноцид народов, единственная в мире применявшая ядерное оружие против мирного населения, каждая современная война которая впоследствии оказывалась ложью (например оружие в Иране). У вас ассоциируется с добром? А например Россия, Беларусь и Китай (Китай и Беларусь вообще ни на кого не нападали) со злом, хотя эти страны как раз таки этим не занимались? А я вам отвечу, вы стали жертвами американской пропоганды. А Запад умеет обманыаать, например индейцам они дарили бусы и одеяла с оспой (под видом добродетели). Жителей Африки они ловили не сами, они обманом заставляли местных ловить своих собратьев для себя. Про современные войны типо Ирака и его оружие я уже писал. Про то что Ядерное оружие было для оканчания войны это тоже ложь. Подписать капитуляцию их вынудили необходимость воевать на новых фронтах с СССР, где Китай и СССР уже разгромили всю сухопутную армию, а про ядерный взрыв узнали после капитуляции, на момент войны это казалось обычной потерей связи. И ещë вопросик. А знаете почему США прекратили использовать ядерное оружие после Японии? - "Они после этого стали добрыми и решили что ядерное оружие это плохо". Неправильный ответ. Они перестали его использовать потому что СССР создал своë ядерое оружие и лишила США возможности безнаказанно его использовать. И сейчас США для своей гегемонии вынуждина тратить деньги на базы НАТО. Вместо того что бы карать всех несогласных ядерным оружием. И то что из большинства из вас не сделали рабами США или ядерной пылью вы должны благодорить СССР и Россию. Что я слышу вместо этого. "Пропоганда США рассказала мне сказку в которой мне надо ненавидеть всех, кто не нравится руководству США. Они переписали мне историю где вместо того что бы написать как мы воевали плечëм к плечу против европейских и японских нацистов, написали как меня якобы притисняли русские и китайцы. По этому я буду их ненавидеть и писать чушь в интернете. Уэээээээ". Здорово, молодцы. Вот только если падëт Россия, и Китай не перехватит ядерную триаду. Судьба большинства из вас будет не очень хорошей. Никто из тех кто верил сладкой лжи США и Европы не кончил хорошо. Вас ждëт либо безмолвное подчинение, либо ядерная бомбардировка США за отказ подчиняться.

[@Hanzada11]

Вам надо почитать историю Казахстана 10-го класса. Чем Рашка отличается от той же Британии с ее Ирландской колонией? Не оправдывайте себя

[@АртурФилиппов-ы9ц]

@@Hanzada11 Мне оправдания не нужны. Я легко воспринимаю плохое, но при условии, что это правда. Я историю воспринимаю как историю, а не попытку оправдать комплекс национальной неполноценности. По поводу Казахстанских учебников. Мне хватило офигенного совета того "как меня обманывают, почитай Украинский учебник, там правда". Я психику чуть не потерял во время чтения. Оказывается, что все доблестные украинцы воевали против СССР и Рейха, под руководством великого патриота Бандеры. А потом оказывается что под руководством СССР доблестные Украинцы в одну харю разбили Рейх, пока жалкие Русские плакались за печкой. Верните мне потраченные время и психику. И Рим оказывается тоже хохлы победили. В общем сова перемоги совершала такие rule 34 с глобусом Украины, что диву даëшься. Так же хочу напомнить. Что Казахстанские предприятия на 80% принадлежат Западным корпорациям и имеют влияние на политику в Казахстане, а так же на издаваемые учебники. Так что вполне могут написать неправду или полуправду. Или ты думаешь, что они благородные рыцари и не будут переписывать историю в угоду себе, для того что бы перенести гнев беднеющего Казахстанского народа с себя на Русских, что бы вы не мешали вас грабить? Наивно. И тратить своë время, на прочтение возможной белеберды я больше не буду. Если хочешь, можешь как я описать что и как происходило. Хотя бы своими словами.

[@Идиот2.0-ъ9т]

​@@Hanzada11тем, что не истребляла коренные народы

[@incumbentvinyl9291]

The Dutch should have been mentioned, they still have a ton of land from colonial times and were present on four continents.

[@city-dweller]

I'm surprised why speaker didn't mention this, but in Kazakhstan there are two official languages: Kazakh and Russian. All the state laws are published on 2 languages. Legal proceedings can be ongoing on Kazakh or Russian as well. So I'm not surprised that guide switched to the Russian. Everybody seems to know it. Russian is very common. Even young people use it as their main language.

[@elya31630]

Russians go home

[@aianchik2873]

русский язык не имеет ниакого статуса в Казахстане вероятное вы имели ввиду Кыргызстан

[@CenturionKZ]

According to the Constitution of Kazakhstan Russian is NOT an official language in the country.

[@dantok2626]

​@@aianchik2873 русский имеет официальный статус тогда как казахский - государственный. Это было ещё утверждено в 1990 году, даже до распада СССР.

[@aianchik2873]

@@dantok2626 эмм нет не имеет русский язык просто наравне с Казахским в гос учреждених и все в остальном нету не имеет никакого статуса

[@Chesterr379]

There is reason why international law does not consider ussr as a colony and especially colony of Russia, but propaganda doesn’t care much. Firstly, Soviet Union (not Russia), was structured as a federal state, meaning it had constitution, that you haven’t even opened (I bet you never even had a look at your own countries constitution, you probably just know it exists). Second the whole idea of communism was built around CLASS STRUGLE AND CLASS WARS, rather than ethnic, religious or cultural wars which is exactly opposite of what colonisers do (colonisers normally shake when they hear class wars, including west). USSR had Supreme Soviet (we call it parliament usually), where all member states had seats and were taking part in future and shape of USSR. For example Ukrainians had 500 seats out of 1500 in supreme soviet, that is 1/3, but you choose to blame just Russia? USSR was recognised by all international institutions, including UN. I could go on, but purpose of video is clearly to spread propaganda and certain way of thinking. Alternatively, we must come to conclusion that admitting USSR to United Nations was collective approval of the whole world of colonisation?

[@ShynarEsmagambetova]

В Конституции СССР ,есть пункт...каждая Республика имеет право выхода....

[@Идиот2.0-ъ9т]

​@@ShynarEsmagambetovaи он был исполнен, все вышли, кроме Казахстана

[@JaiD0427]

Russian Empire was a colonizing power. Soviet Union was a Brutal but industrialising dictatorship! Today if you don’t see the 5 Stans become like Afghanistan & Azerbaijan become like Iran - thank the Soviets! Industrialisation (even the low quality Commie one) is a mind altering process - making people urban, educated, women-emancipated, law abiding etc! Look at the condition of Turkmens, Tajiks & Uzbeks in Afghanistan & then see how they live in these 5 stans!

[@tearet741]

And look also at the condition of North and South korea , and Karelia and Finland , and baltic states and former communist countries they are all become backward and poor in front of their non-occupient neighbour

[@paungabriel9360]

I have a friend that worked in the UK a lot of years and even got to catch the British accent quite well(we are Romanian, just for context). Then he was on vacation in the EU and got to do a payment at a store where an Indian was working. When the Indian saw some British pounds in the wallet he immediately started addressing him as "Sir" and got to be over respectfull. Now this is the effect colonialism has on the colonized. And keep in mind that UK has a way smaller population compared to the indian subcontinemt and could never have fully integrated it. Compare this to Russia where there always was a lot more eastern slavs(I am staying eastern slavs because the Russian empire also used a lot of Ukrainians and Belarusians to colonize asia) compared to kazakhs and in time if it not got independent they would have been fully absorbed into Russia propper.

[@kazagulu]

😢 Егер тәуелсіздік алмасақ қазіргі сібір сияқты толықтай Ресейдің бөлшегі болар едік. Жағдайды Британиямен салыстыра отырып дәл жеткіздіңіз👏🏻 Тағы қосатыным бар, Индия мен Британия жер шарының екі тарабында, ал ресей мен Қазақстан көрші мемлекеттер, арамызды теңіз, мұхит немесе таулар бөліп тұрған жоқ

[@paungabriel9360]

@@kazagulu Try writing in English if you expect a response

[@АндрейП-у1ю]

@@paungabriel9360 there's a translation option available if you hadn't noticed.

[@akertaylor9913]

War in Ukraine did speed up decolonization and desovetization but examples in this video are mostly exaggerated based on personal experience and thoughts rather than facts.

[@anthonymanderson7671]

The russian bots are crying about this.

[@KeithMelville]

I once owned an accommodation business in New Zealand. One of my guests was German not from Germany but from Kazakhstan where he was born. He said he thought has grandparents were from the Volga in Russia but were expelled to Kazachstan during the war years. He was not sure about the cicumstances but added he had also lived in Germany during part of his younger life when the German Government offered people like himself the opportunity to live in Germany.

[@justjake5389]

They were deported to Kazakhstan because they were Na*i collaborators during the Second World War. My grandmother once told me that when the Wehrmacht came, the people in the village welcomed them with flowers and food. This is something that many Russian-Germans don't want to talk about. It wasn't everyone, but in the end everyone was punished.

[@qazaqledi9872]

в КЗ была и к сожалению до сей поры есть руская оккупация (((😢

[@kutuzovmikhailillarionovic2120]

Вот если бы вы всё еще жили в юртах и не умели писать вот тогда была бы оккупация настоящая а сейчас вы пользуетесь благами которые получили при ссср и еще и жертву из себя строите

[@opolchenec55]

​@@kutuzovmikhailillarionovic2120они даже не в состоянии были починить ТЭЦ в том году, просили Россию им помочь, они не понимают, что были бы вторым Афганистаном...

[@Gchco]

Kazakhstan should be independent

[@fish5671]

Kazakhstan is rightfully mongolian...

[@wingedvictory8694]

@@fish5671 the most petarded take

[@AndresLeon-hz5qe]

Kazakstan is independent you fool.

[@saulgoodmanKAZAKH]

​@@fish5671 let's not do this Russian-like bullсгар. If we all started searching for our "old lands" in the 21st century, the world would be a mess. We, Kazakh, could also go for Orenburg, Omsk and etc but we do not do that.

[@antonioiz]

Так он независим

[@travellerstoryteller]

All the east of Asia is part of colonialism policy of Russia, Vladivostok is still a colony of Russia, like Siberia and all the territories east of Urals!! Another example of colonialism is the occupation of the city of Kazan, Tatarstan should be independent

[@mattllaves]

We should liberate the Americas, Australia and new Zealand from the colonisers too

[@AlexPortela-ch2lm]

Then America is a colony? It used to be all native. Separatism is illegal in the US. These are modern borders

[@Дан-п3т]

Что по поводу Шотландии?

[@AlexB-vt5xe]

This was a very interesting video. thank you for uploading it

[@ermuhambetcalmenov8104]

Kazakhstan tek qana ALGA!

[@iberiano-ls2rv]

Wojciech Górecki, it is a privilege listening to you . Thank you.

[@mrkiplingreallywasanexceed8311]

Britain could learn something about this and be a little more proud of its heritage - and let those who want to take offense, be offended......

[@Идиот2.0-ъ9т]

Согласен, продали неграм и арабам свою историю. Обидно за некогда великую империю

[@davidmorris8319]

Most of the asian parts of Russia are basically colonies that have been incorporated into the main country in a similar fashion to what France did with Algeria once. Algeria simply manager to regain its independence. It's unlikely that Siberia will ever break away from Russia after centuries of russification though.

[@reload7522]

Do you now, who mostly live in Siberia now? Let me answer - it's Russians. So, I lived there, my family (all of them are Russians) live there. About 90% of population in my home region are Russians. So, why we need to break away? Of yes - Algeria. Region with non-french population, which independence was supported by USSR. Nice example. Another example of how wars for independence are impossible without active support from abroad.

[@prernagupta46]

Western propoganda always win .

[@Northearthousewell]

KZbin is a Western video hosting service. If you don't like the West, stop watching KZbin. And give up other Western technologies.

[@ThePizzaGoblin]

You live in Kazakhstan, speak Kazakh. Not a difficult concept. If you love russia so much, go live in russia. You live in ukraine, speak ukrainian. If you love russia so much, go live in russia.

[@saulgoodmanKAZAKH]

"Khazak" if you're not Kazakh, I do not think that you should meddle, though I do agree. Kazakh should be made the mandatory language.

[@ThePizzaGoblin]

@@saulgoodmanKAZAKH sorry for the misspelling. I just don't get people who live in a country and refuse to understand the local culture.

[@ivancertic5197]

@@ThePizzaGoblin Were they ever asked whether they want to live in that country and in that way, and what other options are presented to them in order to live as they want, without having to be expelled?

[@ThePizzaGoblin]

@@ivancertic5197 you live in Kazakhstan, you should speak Kazakh. Just like if you live in the US or the UK, you should speak English.

[@ivancertic5197]

@@ThePizzaGoblin Ok. So if Russia get to possess whole of Ukraine, then Ukrainians should speak Russian?

[@Brooklyn_9_9_]

Thank you from Kazakhstan. Finally about that to started speaking 🇰🇿🙏

[@Ilohimushka]

Да некоторые талпичи не понимают, как продразверстка и коллективизация ударила по степи

[@hybridarmyoffreeworld]

Our national MARTYR Kastuś Kalinoŭski SAID : «…Браты мае, мужыкі родныя. З-пад шыбеніцы маскоўскай прыходзіць мне да вас пісаці, і, можа, раз астатні. Горка пакінуць зямельку родную і цябе, дарагі мой народзе. Грудзі застогнуць, забаліць сэрца, - но не жаль згінуць за тваю праўду… Няма ш, браткі, большага шчасця на гэтым свеце, як калі чалавек у галаве мае розум і науку… Но як дзень з ноччу не ходзіць разам, так не ідзе разам наука праўдзіва з няволяй маскоўскай. Дапокуль яна ў нас будзе, у нас нічога не будзе, не будзе праўды, багацтва і ніякай наукі, - адно намі, як скацінай, варочаць будуць не для дабра, но на пагібель нашу… Бо я табе з-пад шыбеніцы кажу, Народзе, што тагды толькі зажывеш шчасліва, калі над табою Маскаля ўжэ не будзе. Твой слуга Яська-гаспадар з-пад Вільні»

[@saulgoodmanKAZAKH]

It would be great if you provided a translation, of course..

[@asdrubalanibal6853]

Mexico: US colonialism “The USA. We don’t often think of it as a colonial power…”

[@iliaalekov2949]

great video!

[@gintasvilkelis2544]

Russian Fedaration itself is a huge colony, ruling over nearly 200 oppressed nationalities.

[@justjake5389]

The Russians don't have to apologize to any do*s. Who occupy America, Australia and New Zealand. 😂

[@Дан-п3т]

And USA too

[@justjake5389]

@@gintasvilkelis2544 Germanic territories once had over 350 independent sovereign states with their own language and culture! Until almost everthing was conquered by Prussia! Is Germany now a huge colony ruled by Berlin?

[@gintasvilkelis2544]

​@@justjake5389 Out of those 350 (tiny) independent "states", the vast majority were ethnically Germanic principalities, so this was a unification / consolidation (similar things happened with Spain, Italy and France). In case of all embodiments of the Russian Empire (incl. the modern Russian Federation), the vast majority of ethnicities are non-Slavic (Tatars, Chechens, Buryats, etc. etc. etc. - the nearly 200 of them).

[@gintasvilkelis2544]

@@Дан-п3т Which nationalities is the US oppressing?

[@oxvendivil442]

As a Chinese Filipino, as a Han Chinese blooded person, I still hope that China can take back the lands the Russians took in the form of the Russian Far-east/Outer Manchuria region and unite with Mongolia/Outer Mongolia that the Russians turned into vassals and separated from China, China used to be the protector/overlord of Siberia, China allowed them to manage their affairs as they saw fit but at China's time of weakness, the Russians took that land from Chinese protection; maybe it would be China that would be able to protect Central Asia from Russian influence and Neo-colonialism and give the region a more equitable relationship with the Chinese.

[@chuluunsugarragchaa6659]

@Oxvendivil442 Get lost.

[@justjake5389]

If you were Chinese, you wouldn't write such nonsense! China can start with its Kazakh brothers.

[@Hanzada11]

That’s not how it should work. Idc about Manchuria(because manchus are different from other indigenous people in China) but what China is doing to Mongolians and Uyghurs, Kazakhs is also a form of colonialism, and it should stop

[@JohnDoe-qz3qi]

🇰🇿 Land of Borat 🇰🇿 Wawaweewaa!! 👍👍

[@teamjager-97]

Swearing and mocking others is a Russian🇷🇺 tradition 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🇷🇺

[@begite_ya_konchennyi]

көтіңді қыс

[@trashdub9687]

Ну да, лучше ведь в юртах жить или под британской короной мои бы предки работали как африканцы без человеческих прав. Всё это видео натягивание совы на глобус

[@benlamprecht6414]

Thanks for a fascinating video!

[@helloworld-ti5zs]

Brainwashed propaganda. Many Kazakhs miss USSR. My dad got a flat for free. My parents had an education for free. And it was excellent education. We lived happily. History of any country had bad and sad pages. Stalin's period was horrible and after his death it came to an end . Prisoners were set free , Gulags were destroyed in 1956. Stalin was declared as a state criminal in USSR. At present terrible corruption is Kazakhstan. The country is dying. (((

[@freeman4899]

Canada and Europe are also colonies of USA.

[@AnalniyBandit]

Мдааа, поляки прям объективны про нашу историю, если вы это верите то окей ваш выбор, не не навязывайте его дркгим под соусым правды

[@olhjlhjchjl]

Намного более объективние руских лол

[@EdgyNumber1]

*This is a very good, informative channel.* *I have SUBSCRIBED* 🔔

[@deadchannelxd0420]

ur stupid lol

[@tomoyosakagami9874]

Cool country, never been there but wanna Go there someday 🇩🇪🤝🇰🇿

[@user-mh5xk6fl1x]

Цель лидеров западных стран и мировой закулисы - разрушить многонациональное государство Россию, как до этого они разрушили СССР, а затем, поставить под свой контроль ее ослабленные осколки - автономные республики и безраздельно и без опаски пользоваться их природными и человеческими ресурсами. По мнению этих, якобы, борцов с российскими колонизаторами, лучше они будут боссами в этой истории, а не русские. Одним словом - лицемеры.

[@juanquintana6070]

I think you are far away from the truth. The difference in this story is that Russia, as empire likes to keep all the ex soviet states in control and with no freedom to decide or chose whatever they want. That is the feeling, Russia is too big, and difficult to rule with so many ethnics. US or Europe are to these people and example of independence and democracy.

[@user-mh5xk6fl1x]

@@juanquintana6070 По вашей логике - США это суперимперия, которая предпочитает держать под своим контролем все страны мира ;) Для реализации этой задачи США имеет самый большой оборонный бюджет, содержит мощнейший в мире военно-морской флот с авианосцами и десантными кораблями и корпусом морской пехоты. Кроме этого, для оперативного реагирования и вмешательство в мировые процессы, оказания давления на народы и правительства различных стран мира, у США по всей планете расположено около 900 военных баз. Смешно слушать о демократии и независимости в контексте мирового гегемона и жандарма США.

[@AlexPortela-ch2lm]

@@juanquintana6070the US decimated all the native population and then millions of immigrants came, that’s not at example that is hypocrisy. Russia is a multinational country like Spain or any other with its own minorities. Then countries like France still had a neo-colonial empire in Africa to this day

[@GrooveStreet4Life310]

У орка заполыхало😂😂😂

[@ShynarEsmagambetova]

Это можно было сделать ,при развале союза. Не пишите бред. Тогда Россия была ослаблена.

[@christophercrowley9873]

That opening sentence went straight over the 20th century

[@cg986]

Amazing

[@durelmissamou9410]

Most the countries around the world have seen their territories growing up that way. By saying that it is colonisation you mean the US and almost all big countries around the world are colonizers.

[@justjake5389]

In this case, it was actually Russia that defeated the Golden Horde that had besieged Russia for 250 years. The Russians defeated the Central Asians and conquered part of their land in the process. The Kazakhs are simply bad losers and hide the truth.

[@Hanzada11]

Literally everyone around the world knows that US and other huge countries are colonizers…useless whataboutism argument won’t do it

[@Indigenous_Rambo]

Hi am im a native american. Can you do a video on Western European colonialization of North America, or do you only do videos slandering Russia? Thanks.

[@moonman1612]

Where did you see slander?

[@Tilda1180]

This is the truth, not slander

[@paulurban2472]

@@Tilda1180he never mentioned how Russias “colonies” where not enslaved or best to death. If anything their quality of life enhanced. And some of Russias previous “colonies” where not colonies at all. Georgia was a gift to Russia so the ottomans did not annex it for example.

[@user-mh5xk6fl1x]

Они не сделают видео подобного формата о западноевропейской колонизации Северной Америки. Они тенденциозны и их цель - очернение России и разжигание межнациональных отношений с жителями бывших союзных республик СССР и наций внутри современной России.

[@moonman1612]

@@user-mh5xk6fl1x лол, вся история России руки во крови

[@lukak6372]

Kazakhstan as a country excites because of Russia. Before the soviet union they had no statehood

[@Elena-bz6gk]

Ага, хорош колонизм- построили города, заводы, фабрики, дороги, дали образование населению, распахали целину, все, чем пользуется сейчас Казахстан, построено при СССР, убери советское наследие и будет голая степь!!!!

[@frs_printing_press]

убери западное европейское наследие и будут просто болота с избушками и землянками!

[@teamjager-97]

🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🤮🤮🤮🤮Disgusting Russia, stay away from us

[@Hanzada11]

🤣🤣🤣типичный аргумент рашистки. Может ты еще и Орду хочет вернуть на Россию? Мы же вам построили города с многочисленными рынками, храмами, гостиницами и банями. Без Орды только лапти и ваши мини-домики деревянные были бы

[@JJONNYREPP]

Kazakhstan: Russian colonialism 1031am 3.10.24 soviet colonialism. yeah, we comprehended that. do you want your country brought kicking and screaming into the technologically advanced world...? ok.... mute pause.... these nations seemed happy to benefit from the off shoots of industrialisation irrespective of what we think about industrialization. which might now be seen as a perverted period in global history... you want the era of soviet influence erased from your national history? ok.. then i suppose you will not mind them removing all the investment and the perks of that era.... the UK for, all the alleged horrors of the raj era, should have done likewise and removed everything relating to it's own tawdry influence. discuss......

[@EURASIAPLUS]

Just as English is a design language, so the ethnonym Russian is designed. many small peoples on the Eurasian territory have lost their culture, their identity under the deliberate influence of the empire, which needs new territories and new Russians, because many Russians are former Tatars, Erzya, Moksha, Ukrainians, Vepsians, Finno-Ugrians, etc. a Russian today is a supporter of the empire, with a firm conviction that the whole world is envious and hostile and only Russians are great with the largest territory and nuclear weapons. the evil empire, the prison of nations must disintegrate.

[@bienewolf6917]

good comment

[@max_skim-pontoon-cough]

@@bienewolf6917it’s delusional

[@Scion-cy6wj]

what in the world is a "design language"? no such term in linguistics

[@Scion-cy6wj]

@@bienewolf6917 no, it was not a good comment

[@AlexPortela-ch2lm]

America exterminated their natives so they don’t have to give them back any territory 😂

[@shermoore1693]

In Vladivostok, (a port on the Sea of Japan) the population is 93% Russian people, 4.5% people from former soviet countries (Romania, Bulgaria) and only 2.5% Asian, mostly Koreans who fled the war in the 1950s.

[@artyyyomka]

Собрались, значит, в комментариях ущемленные. Какой же совок плохой, Россия - фу, и прочее. Что вы там пишите про голодомор? Вы его застали? Ваши предки его застали? Нет. Вы же сейчас существуете как-то. Не нужно писать о том, чего не было. Намеренного голодомора не было, был просто ГОЛОД.

[@artyyyomka]

Гугл-англичане в комментариях, вы стали какими-то соевыми, как Навальнята в России - одно отвращение от вас. Живите здесь и сейчас, думайте о сегодняшнем дне с оптимизмом.

[@panslavism01]

Пусть лучше бы они познали колониальную политику Запада или Китая, раз они так плохо отзываются о русских 😊 А то много понтов колется о том что у них не было крепостного права 😅

[@elpaso5298]

🇰🇿🤝🇺🇦🇪🇺🇺🇲♥️🙌🙌🙌

[@justjake5389]

The West is on the verge of collapse 😂

[@unknownmf2599]

Turkiye, Azerbaijan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan: Hey russia

[@pedrocavalcante5822]

Do most Kazakhs speak Russian or their own language?

[@jajajejehjune4301]

they speak Kazach

[@oscarm5368]

Since independence, most Kazakhs speak Kazakh. But most still know how to speak Russian especially since there’s a large Russian minority in Kazakhstan and from Soviet rule.

[@MrCalls1]

Most Kazakhs under the age of 30 speak Kazakh as their primary language. Those over the age of 30 were born before independence. If you are over the age of 50, and you live in the North your primary language will be Russian about 66% ofthe time, but if you are over the age of 50 and live in the south your primary language will be Kazakh for 66% of people. Nowadays basically everyone in Kazakhstan understands Kazakh and most people will begin conversation with an unknown person in Kazakh, unless they are old and look ethnicly Russian. That's my understanding at least

[@saulgoodmanKAZAKH]

Some Kazakhs from the major cities of Astana and Almaty may speak only Russian. Mostly rich, russified kids unfortunately.

[@moonman1612]

Both

[@mereketore4105]

Дұрыс айтады. Бұрында қазақтардың ойына кіріп шықпас еді екінші сорт екенін. Енді оянып, өзін кім екенін танып ап, жердің егесі екенін біліп жатыр. Білімді болайық - мықты болайық!

[@фийкё]

Россия колонизировала Казахстан, вела себя просто ужасно, убивала всех и превращала страну в пустыню, но с каждым годом в стране становилось только больше казахов, уровень жизни и образования казахов с каждым годом только рос, а из кочевников много казахов стали учеными, работали в космической программе, с каждым годом в Казахстане становилось больше городов, степь превращалась в пашню с лесополосами, только больше заводов, только больше школ и парков. Россия вложила столько денег в Казахстан, но что Россия получила? Видео на ютубе длиной аж 20 минут. Спасибо. Радует, что хотя бы казахи достаточно умные, чтобы иметь другое мнение. Спасибо за видео.

[@shk439]

В Брежневское время казахское население действительно росло и развивалось, но при Сталине был самый настоящий геноцид. А развивали Казахстан, потому что доля казахов была низкой и не представляла угрозу. По сути Сталин сделал Казахстан русским. Но как только хватка ослабла, казахи начали расти

[@фийкё]

@@shk439 так Сталин даже не был русским... Он блин грузин... Вы слышали его акцент? Он на русском языке с трудом говорил. Извините, но разве это по логике не грузинская колонизация? Когда он голодомор устроил (вы видимо об этом) в поволжье от половины до 80% вообще всего население умерло, а это немного (в несколько раз больше вообще) чем умерло в Казахстане. Странно, что никто не говорит об этом, для меня это самый настоящий геноцид, моя семья (ну предки) поэтому оттуда и уехали однажды

[@bogdanpoklad6600]

@@фийкё Так Сталин видел себя сверхнациональным человеком, не грузином и не русским. Он имперец, но в советском, а не русском варианте. Комуняки считали нации пережитком. Это во время 2МВ он начал педалировать русскую тему, т.к. увидел, что это работает для пропаганды

[@ХадижатИбрагимова-е8ь]

Сам Сталин ответил на ваш вопрос..однажды какой-то советский генерал сказал: "среди вас грузин есть анекдот.."-на что Сталин тут же его перебил: " я НЕ грузин..я-русский грузинского происхождения.."-те генетически он был кавказец..но ощущал и считал себя русским имперцем..поэтому довольно паскудно выглядят те русские которые пытаются приписать все достижения тов Сталина-себе..РУССКОМУ народу втч победу в ВОВ..а когда говорят о преступлениях Сталина-то тогда это уже не "великий русский лидер.."-а "какой-то грузин.."😂😂😂😂..это потому что русские народ Иуд..а еще в Библии сказано: "..не успеет петух пропеть..до рассвета..ты трижды отречешься от меня.."-русские такие лицемеры и ничтожества..когда все хорошо-они с тобой..когда плохо-они тут же предадут тебя..мы кавказцы не отказываемся от Сталина..хотя он и сам отказался​ от нас..@@фийкё

[@quick-tech-tricks]

Конечно, "матюшка россиюшка" дала все своим обворованым, колониях, а теперь они наговаривают. Какий плохие. Хорошо что росиюшка то великая, путин папа молодец! Убьём соседей, земли, ресурсы украдём и все буде как раньше. Слава великой рассиюшке!

[@kelvindoang1228]

People in left forgot that USSR is communist 😂 their supposed to be utophia

[@ОльгаВасенина-ц8д]

Россия самая справедливая и прекрасная страна❤ Будущее за странами БРИКС❤ Долой англосаксонских хозяев мира, колонизаторов и поработителей! Да здравствует многополярное мировое сообщество! Казахи, будьте бдительны! Не станьте рабами англосаксов!

[@olhjlhjchjl]

Не смотри телевизор лол

[@ЕленаХрящёва]

Ну да, Украину разфигачили, на очереди Казахстан, льют в уши дерьмо, а они рады. Мы 30 лет живем отдельно, вопрос казахам, ваша жизнь стала в разы лучше, чьи корпорации качают вашу нефть, газ, ископаемые получая львиную долю дохода, Казахстану оставляя крохи, кто владеет вашими рессурсами? Кто сформировал Казахстан как государство, дал, образование, медицину, построил фабрики и заводы при СССР вы были дотационной республикой потребляли больше чем производили и кто кого кормил тогда, ответте. А по поводу голодухи, голодали не только Украина и Казахстан, голодала вся Россия, сто творилось в селах, это не описать. Вопрос почему, кто то задавал? Неурожай тогда случился по всему миру практически за редким исключением, и Запад ничего не придумал лучше, чем торговать с коммунистами за зерно. А нам нужны были станки, паравозы, сталь, и очень много всего, страна становилась из сельскохозяйственной ,промышленной. Сталин знал, что война рано или поздно начнется, и спешил построить заводы, если бы не эта индустриализация, за которую мы заплатили , высокую цену, смертью от голода, тогда ещё не известно, чем бы закончилась ВОВ. Я могу понять, украинцев и вас казахи, одним всё равно кто у них будет хозяином , они нормально жить не могут, если у них пана нет, того кто буде ими управлять. А вот вы казахи, думаете, что у вас было бы отдельное государство и вы жили бы в нем сыто и богато, у вас сейчас коррупция , ваши богатеи те же баи, что были до прихода русских, так почему же вы думаете, что простой народ жил бы лучше без русских. Так это я не говорю о внешней угрозе захвата, рядом Китай или Эрдоган бредит тюркскими халифатом. Думайте, казахи, думайте , что лучше жить в мире с соседями или как Украина петь под чужую дудку США уничтожая себя.

[@Maria-vm6wy]

Что объяснять отсталым, они живут в своем мирке, так и должно остаться, когда-нибудь они сами себя сожрут. При условии, что США требовали оплату зерном за свою помощь во Второй мировой, при этом у них его было навалом и они его выбрасывали... этим всё сказано.

[@Maria-vm6wy]

Что объяснять отсталым, они живут в своем мирке, так и должно остаться, когда-нибудь они сами себя сожрут. При условии, что США требовали оплату зерном за свою помощь во Второй мировой, при этом у них его было навалом и они его выбрасывали... этим всё сказано.

[@olhjlhjchjl]

1: казахам все дели бы казахи если бы не савок 2: у вас мяса на казахов не хватит, вы уже проспали почти пол миллиона руских поросят на "СВО" тут ещё и Казахстан что в разы больше по насленению и тереторриях

[@ЕленаХрящёва]

@@olhjlhjchjl О, казахский фюрер пасть разявил, иди учись юрту ставить это твое будущее и твоих внуков.

[@tunuitahitianfire9875]

How many western NGO’s are on the ground in Kazakhstan to help flare up tensions and divisions between Russia and Kazakhstan ? If not for Russia do these Kazakhs think that aligning with the declining collective west is a smart move ?

[@Scion-cy6wj]

You are a bit of a delusional git, aren't ya?

[@saulgoodmanKAZAKH]

Kremlin bot🤡

[@tunuitahitianfire9875]

@@saulgoodmanKAZAKH it’s a serious question . Do you think KZ would be better off burning bridges with Russia and aligning with the West ?

[@praetoriancorps]

If they're aligning with the west its probably with the Turks right? Since both are ethnically Turkic. China and Kazakhstan also massively improved relations with China having become their top trading partner. If NGO's are involved in stoking tensions it looks like all they do is poor gasoline on the fire. But then I'm wondering which NGO's are they? These are things every country does usually trough social media.

[@trueordrue]

​@@tunuitahitianfire9875yes i am kazakh. Russia is dragging us behind. We dont want them

[@ALEakaKorwin]

Fix subtitles please.

[@peterjaniceforan3080]

🇰🇿🫡 🇷🇺👎🏼

[@opolchenec55]

🤣🫵 🤡

[@johnnylarue9722]

Yeah, but Russia has "family values " 😅😅😅

[@paulzx2000]

You cant put "Russia" and "Colonialism" in one sentence. In India only Brits were allowed to visit hospitals. Russians built hospitals for Kazakhs. Feel the difference, man. Russia conquered, subjugated, swallowed... whatever.. not "colonized".

[@greasher926]

Colonialism comes in different forms depending on who is practicing it and in what time period. Furthermore there is a difference between Imperial Russian and Soviet “colonialism”. At its most basic form, colonialism is when someone conquers a foreign land and settles it at the expense of the natives, either by expelling/extermination or assimilation.

[@paulzx2000]

@@greasher926Why you constantly try to explain other civilizations in the terms suitable for the Western civilization? The only Russian colony is Siberia - the exact copy of Australia, resource chest, force-settled by prisoners. And even there, it was a temporary measure. Every citizen of the Empire has the same rights and opportunities, access to the shared resource pool etc. And the Western colonialism is defined by the clear division line between a metropoly and colonized lands - you can't find this in Russia. So you pick the definitions that suites your narrative and forget everything else. Not good.

[@greasher926]

@@paulzx2000 not sure what you exactly mean by “a division line between a metropoly and colonized lands” but yes Russians did this, Russians would conquer a land, establish cities and settle them with ethnic Russians, and the countryside would be mostly natives. For example in 1926 in Uzbekistan the Urban population of Russians was 208,678 vs 609,059 Uzbeks. In comparison the rural population there was only 37,843 Russians vs 2,866,281 Uzbeks. The Urban to Rural ratios of each ethnic group in Uzbekistan in 1926 is as follows. Russian: 84.6% Uzbeks: 17.5% Tajik: 15.3% Kazakh: 2.5%

[@paulzx2000]

@@greasher926 Yes. And how it can be different? Khazahs are nomadic people. 13 out of 15 biggest cities in Kazakhstan were founded by Russians. Same with Ukraine. 26 out of 30 biggest Ukrainian cities were founded by Russians after we reconquered these lands from Turks and Tatars. Generally its a bad idea to have cities if the nomads are present around, because cities become an attractive targets for raids and plunder. So you need to pacify nomadic tribes, in some way, before citybuilding. The only urban or settled people in the Central Asia are Uzbeks. All others are nomads. Many of them even did not have an alphabet. Russians create an alphabet for them. And you talk cities 😁

[@greasher926]

@@paulzx2000 I’m not sure if you are tone deaf or I just don’t know which side of the argument you stand on. But what you just described sounds like colonialism, not much different to what Europeans did in the Americas.

[@TurtleChad1]

CIA video

[@siyacer]

you are an embarrassment

[@justjake5389]

@@siyacer Why? When will there be a video about America, Australia and New Zealand? Do you actually know what happened to the indigenous people?

[@siyacer]

@@justjake5389 classic whataboutism

[@justjake5389]

@@siyacer The victims of Western colonialism still live in reservations today. If Russia had acted in the same way, Kazakhstan would no longer exist!

[@siyacer]

@@justjake5389 and what does this have to do with kazakstans situation?

[@Lashyn_kus]

I am kazakh, Nazarbaev, Tokaev dictator's. Gud politics Muhtar Ablyiazov, Seryikzhan Blyiash

[@panslavism01]

😂😂😂

[@eltonbritt1502]

Your map of Russia is outdated 😆