Lady in the Water - Movie Review

[@alexso7834]

We all have to atleast give credit to Shyamalan for making original movies and taking risks. Also The Happening is hilarious.

[@sociopathsurvivor7129]

Alex So You like hot dogs, right?

[@sameerhafeez7029]

I do

[@texasbeast239]

Homer Simpson: Mmm...hot dogs...

[@henryfanai7740]

@@texasbeast239 😂😂😂

[@frostb1041]

I do, i know some of his movies are cringe or downright hilariocity but i do have mad high praise for his ideas. It's pretty inspiring how he comes up with his movie ideas. Edit : except of course, The Last Airbender

[@Vercalos]

I'm weird. I actually liked this movie, overall.

[@AleadaA]

Me too -weird is good!

[@skylar4390]

I like it too!

[@rozwynn2349]

I love this movie I watch it annually.

[@ringsaphire]

Hahaha me also, I kinda liked this one! We are not alone ;)

[@zach6255]

saaammmeee

[@M.L.Shaw.]

Lady in the Water is one of my favorite movies of all time. I loved the absurdity of the mythology, it captured my imagination as a child more than any other film I've ever seen.

[@BigTonyRockets]

Objectively awful movie.

[@nhmisnomer]

I really got into the characters. I loved how distinct each apartment was and how matched to the tenant' s personality. I love the concept of a group of strangers cooperating toward a goal. None of the apt complexes I've lived in were like that in the slightest.

[@user-rp8dw9hg3j]

I loved the way this movie made me feel. I loved how I felt during and after the movie. In 2020, it took me away, just for a while. Let's not forget that this is the true magic of movies. No critic score can remove that.

[@timnyhouse8346]

Yes! Well said , I totally agree

[@lamelusina]

I loved the part when the little kid reads the cereal boxes tho, it's so pure ❤️

[@AlloY777]

I love how much time and dedication you put into your videos. You watched the movie for us (but duh cause that's what you need for the review), you read the book it was based off of TWICE, and then you watched it again. I have to say, good job mann, keep being awesometacular!

[@elijahblechman8633]

+The Octagon Master with Super Saiyan Vader Cruise i have seen you everywhere, or at lest your profile pic

[@Olsens13]

Chris is also a good time no alcohol required

[@uptoedownsasquatch4517]

Omg really nice attention to detail, I love how you spelled it "mann" instead of just "man" because his name is spelt "stuckMANN", I would buy you comment on blu-ray

[@AlloY777]

+UpToeDownSasquatch glad you noticed :D

[@elijahblechman8633]

The Octagon Master with Super Saiyan Vader Cruise that was really cool what you said

[@stacyxxy]

I felt everything in this movie. The msg behind it was also soooooo beautiful.

[@xisumavoid]

I think you got it spot on, its certainly a mix of good and bad. One thing that really bothered me with this movie is it all happened in one location. Maybe because it wasn't the most exciting movie i was hoping for a change of scenery but it always bothered me with this one.

[@vaughntaylor7687]

This is one of those movies where you have to listen to what they tell you and you have to abide by the rules the plot sets. If she has to be picked up from the same place she entered this world in why would she leave? Also in the beginning they explain once the humans moved away from the water they started going down hill I’m sure that’s also another factor that keeps her close to home. There would be no reason to venture outside of the set location outside of you just wanting to see that happen nor is there any room or reason to speed this movie up with action because the writers and directors want you to feel what the characters feel they want you to be just as clueless anxious and doubtful as the characters do. In 2020 compared to the story telling we have now I think this is a great movie

[@THX-bz8bi]

Yea i wanted to see the blue world.

[@wicked6186]

I actually like Shyamalan...honestly i feel most of his movies have been mis-categorized by Hollywood. Take The Village for example; that wasn't a true horror movie. It was sold as such, and the day i saw it, people were literally walking out of the theater. It's more of a modern-day fairytale. But even in that context it's hard to fully categorize it. Unbreakable is one of my favorite movies of all time, and I believe was copied in the tv show Heroes which was largely uninspired... but anyway, great work Chris! Love your reviews.

[@rubenespinoza1746]

Literaly watched people walk out the theater but unfortunately I stayed!!!

[@daniilashurov135]

Unbreakable deconstructed the superhero genre even before that genre really took of and years prior to Nolan's Dark Knight and Snyder's Watchmen.

[@amberunthank7209]

I completely agree. The Happening I didn't like it because of the acting of Mark Wahlberg and Zooey Deschanel.

[@aidanquinn62]

I've watched so many of his reviews that I can now predict what score he's gonna give

[@danaberry149]

Me too

[@Thurgor_Supreme]

Yup, same here. Its almost kinda freaky.

[@DarkTenka]

+Aidan Quinn I'm usually a plus or minus off .. I had him giving this one a C-.

[@Clownsatthecemetery]

+Aidan Quinn interesting,I have not stayed awake for a full review. Sum it up in 60, go see it or not. Cheap or no crap.

[@aParanormalEvent]

+Clownsatthecemetery If you want that kind of review, go read the amazon reviews. Such insights can be found inside them, like "WORST MOVIE EVER" and "I FELL ASLEEP CAUSE ITS SO BORING, WHERE ART THOU EXPLOSION?"

[@Lowkey-NoPressure]

This movie is about the power of art (literature, movies, *stories*) to help us find out who we are, and to help us find our purpose. In the intro fairy tale thing, we are told that humans have been ignoring the water women muses sent to inspire them to greatness. We have become disillusioned with stories. We only really experience them in the form of hollywood films, and our interpretations of them are filtered through the eyes of critics, who are especially jaded. For example even if a filmmaker tried to use rain as a metaphor for purification, a critic would see it is as just a cliche. So we have a situation where people don't know how to analyze movies anymore to really connect with them. They make superficial connections, like Paul Giamatti does at first when he assumes that he is the protector, that the guild are the men, that the healer is the old lady, and that the interpreter is the crossword guy. On the surface, these all seem to fit. We find out later that he is completely wrong on all counts. He was overlooking the true way he fit into the story because he was trying to force a more conventional interpretation. Meanwhile, Story herself was unable to tell him he was wrong, because she is here as the representation of a work of art or a story--she can't tell us how to interpret her, she can only give us clues to nudge us towards inspiration. So the film is reminding us to view art/stories/movies with the eyes of a child, to drink in their wonder again in hopes that we might be inspired. (the old asian lady wouldn't tell Paul Giamatti the story unless she viewed him as harmless, like a child--the one dude said he wanted to believe in the story like a kid again). It reminds us that our destinies may be something that we did not anticipate.

[@TheKeyser94]

+bw13187 This movie is more about the power of the ego, how the ego of the side of a mountain and total narcissism.

[@monkeyassasins]

Perfectly summed up! Finally watched this film and enjoyed its message

[@elegantoddity8609]

As ironic as this statement is he could have brought that across in a less egotistical manner like making the critic so obviously a prat and not making everyone behave in a ridiculous manner(to a point). Also not making himself seem like Jesus would help. He doesn't have to put a neon sign up either explaining it but getting a message across kind've requires the audience to have a touch point and it's hard to not get bogged down with all the random crazy addition and poor acting.

[@acspicer]

Counterpoint: It's dumber than a sack of hammers.

[@Red-ej6he]

Bravo! Someone really, really gets this movie! I got this movie. But all art is open for interpretation. So nobody is wrong or right in their interpretation.

[@basedjebkush2760]

They should sell the lady in the water back to marvel.

[@basedjebkush2760]

+Chandler Bing SpongeBob is DC idiot. You don't know shit about comics or anime.

[@dericjames2018]

nope i want them to sell it to Sony Pictures Home Entertainment ;)

[@tatehildyard5332]

I can tell this joke will spread over the web like an STD which we all get bothered by but fuck it, it's funny now.

[@infomaniac2407]

I'm going to sell the rights to me back to marvel. Hopefully they can do something better.

[@basedjebkush2760]

+Chandler Bing is rich from reviewtechusa your new sponsor?

[@1987MartinT]

In my opinion, Lady In The Water is a beautifully filmed, wonderfully atmospheric, convoluted mess. You can get stuff out of it, if you are able to follow it.

[@tyrantgregcagkaiju71]

Oddly, I feel the same way.

[@LAkadian]

Bryce Dallas Howard emerging from the pool = Iconically sexy as hell.

[@RamiFive4Five]

Lady in the Water reminds me to some of the most beautiful dreams I ever had. I'm so happy to be one of those who understand the real message and to be inspired by it.

[@maxdondada]

Me too

[@exoxophanie4363]

Glad someone understands

[@zedell1233]

same here!

[@zedell1233]

***** i like your profile pic J. dreamy

[@EthanJohn1986]

you're just saying that AFTER you saw this review...say it on your own terms

[@JoeQuake]

Please review the sequel: "The Dude in the Dirt".

[@B1G_WENGH]

I'm still waiting for your annual blu-ray collection video.

[@VMG3001]

^^^^^^^

[@danaberry149]

This is correct man speaking people^

[@hassaanmirza4628]

It's gonna be awesome.

[@dineshrashid2766]

He just released photos on his Twitter page, but yes, I hope he does one soon as well

[@cjlynn3411]

I want to see his anime collection... Hopefully soon

[@mrmonar5]

I remember watching this film when I was younger, I was intrigued, and then afterwards I went to any swimming pool I could find with great expectations. Great film. There was another aspect of the mythology that I loved, the fact that there were false duplicates, it created a lot of tension, because finding the right combo of people before time runs out, it scared the shit out of me, once again, I was a child. Watching things from this perspective makes films beautiful, and that's how I've left it, I've never seen the film again, and it is still hauntingly beautiful because I left it there, I left it in the limbo of a vague memory and almost a dream sequence.

[@forceaidan8]

So in the same way I defend the Star Wars prequels, you defend the M. Night films that most people hate.

[@robcain8865]

The Star Wars prequels aren't absolutely awful films with no redeeming qualities, but they were definitely jarring for those who watched the originals. It seems the fans anger has turned into an effort to wash away the bad taste of the prequels. Even the new Star Wars Battlefront ignores the Clone Wars despite it having potential for some awesome multiplayer battles. As for M Night, he comes off as a bit arrogant based on how I've seen him act. First casting himself in Lady in the Water and then calling The Last Airbender "the most culturally diverse movie ever made" in an interview with TIME. That's really asking for a backlash which only got worse when the film came out in 2010.

[@AxioProductions]

The prequels had good ideas on paper and potential, but it suffered from bad directions and script. The clone wars saga was cool, seeing Yoda in action, and Darth Plaguis novel explained from how midichlorian work to Palpatine's rise to power and how everything lead up to the prequels perfectly.

[@Clownsatthecemetery]

+Rob Cain yes the 3 pre are pure crap. Real star wars fans do not acknowledge their existence. I do not

[@AxioProductions]

Clownsatthecemetery What about Maul, having a black Jedi, Yoda and Lee? If you dislike, your right to your fan believe as mine

[@JefeTheSituation]

+Rob Cain Attack of the Clones has almost no redeeming qualities.

[@CONCISEtheGHOST]

I, personally, love this movie.

[@JakeJarvi]

Yeah. I'm one of those assholes who really likes Lady in the Water. The framing is exceptional and I was into the trappings of a really crazy fable story trapped in a modern apartment complex.

[@MybeautifulandamazingPrincess]

pineappleboyfilms How can you be an a-hole for liking something, a-holes are people who hate on it for no reason

[@nhmisnomer]

me too! I loved how each apartment was decorated unique to that tenant and I loved the tenants, especially the guy who only worked out half his body as a way of comparing how far he'd progressed. And I love the idea that apartment dwellers -- who never seem interesting at all in your own apartment complex -- might actually be unique and special.

[@georginatoland]

This movie still has a place in my heart. ❤️

[@TheMaskedChef7]

pineappleboyfilms It's my num1 Favorite movie and I don't care what any Muggle sais ;)

[@wpegram9868]

It blew my mind to realize the movie only had one person in it.

[@leonelcastanarez3407]

man i don't know why people say M. Night Shaymalan it's consitered a bad director... i mean he made godly awful movies like After Earth and The Last Airbender but... he made Unbreakable, The Sixth Sense and Signs!!

[@Kaefer1973]

+Leonel Castañarez Yeah I'm among the many of us who never got what anyone could possibly see in "Signs", but I'll agree he made some good movies, and since almost every director had made some shit as well, the hate really does seem misplaced. He was just seriously over hyped and than suffered a just as seriously overgrown backlash, when it became clear that he's not the next Kubrick after all.

[@StewartFletcher]

Leonel Castañarez "One good act does not wash out the bad; nor the bad, the good." -- Stannis Baratheon

[@Jordan-hs5kf]

No, but another good Shyamalan movie might help people further forgive the rough patch of bad movies he had. Not undo them, but put him back in peoples' good graces.

[@chuckmovies7535]

And now he's done SPLIT. Shyamalan is awesome again!!

[@realstubaby]

Chuck Movies I know right?!

[@TearYouApart360]

I really hope The Visit is good. I'm rooting for M. Night because I really enjoyed most of his earlier movies.

[@lln7065]

What was that spirit movie called?

[@TearYouApart360]

The Sixth Sense? 

[@haunttheeditor]

+Joshua Night's King The Visit is fucking AWESOME

[@DeleteButtonForEvil]

+Chandler Bing haha that's funny

[@aryehlevine8677]

+Chandler Bing lol

[@wpahp]

I'm only one minute into the video and had to stop to purchase that book. Lady In The Water is the most underrated movie of all time, and I can't believe there's a book about this. It's going to take decades for most people to understand the brilliance of that movie. Thanks already!

[@Vahisofficial]

Me tio, i started looking but didnt found it anywhere.

[@lifereviewed]

This and Speed Racer are the most underrated. Though it appears Speed Racer is finally getting some credit.

[@koustave]

Thanks for putting it so meticulously. I've always loved Lady in the Water for its unconventional nature. Its a fairy tale and if you see it from a kid's perspective its actually quite memorable. I think this would probably grow into a classic as time passes and will be remembered as one of Shyamalan's greatest works.

[@daydreamer50000]

I for one can totally agree with you here. I just finished watching it again and it just amazes me how awesome this movie really is.

[@maxdondada]

I loved Lady in the Water.

[@icywinterof88]

someone else finally agrees with me lol

[@idkkimberlyanne]

noel acevedo it's a beautiful story, I love this movie.

[@Trainwheel_Time]

Me too. Loved it.

[@Brastius]

I can't say I loved it, but I did like it.

[@davidmckesey7119]

I love lady in the water. Story of hope 💪

[@alzar11]

This is the movie that killed Shyamalan for me. I don't 'mind' the village, but this movie I really struggled to finish.

[@dericjames2018]

agreed first M. Night movie i started to hate badly and started to make shit movies.

[@BIGTENFanatic]

Same here mate. I hate this movie with a burning passion. Seriously one of the worst movies I've ever seen.

[@Seomus]

+GibJen McHorse I was in denial after seeing this film. I kept believing, but then I bought it on DVD and I realized it was bad.

[@EliDEVITTSpeaks]

For me i gave on Shyamalan after THE VILLAGE.

[@violettaeve]

+GibJen McHorse me too! Lady in the water was like a story your drunk uncle tells you at thanksgiving, that's like 9 stories in one also its half fiction and he lets slip out his sexual fantasies in there. at the end your horrified confused and speechless and just want to leave.

[@Orion_TheyThem]

The thing about this movie is that it's a bedtime story he told his kids. That's why there's opening narration and why it's so mystical and fantastic. He literally made this movie for his children. I actually loved this movie. And his part. The moral is finding your true purpose and knowing that you can be something great, even if you come from nothing.

[@led_tower]

Chris, where is the Star Wars Episode IV Review?

[@Jonnnyy1]

Link!

[@led_tower]

Jonathan Alvarez Jonathan!

[@simian4752]

+Red Key Hello, alternate timeline Link!

[@superjakedrake]

+Jonathan Alvarez I thought his name was Zelda?

[@unlessitsmarco]

+Super Nakul Boss!!! *facepalm*

[@daydreamer50000]

What I personally loved about this movie was the fact that you didn't know a whole lot about the blue world. It was supposed to be based off of Legends and stories passed down from generation to generation. It even said in the beginning of the movie Men had forgotten and could no longer listen. I found it pretty cool that you really wouldn't know how the blue world really was so you could leave it up to interpretation in your own mind. I watched this movie is a teenager when it first came out and thought it was absolutely amazing. To this day I still watch it and still cry when I watch the movie, because seeing these characters come together to see there is something more to our world than the mundane is just simply amazing. The cinematic score is superb, and even the quirky acting of some of these characters is on point. I feel like in order to enjoy this movie you have to really open your mind, if you're not willing to do that you're not going to enjoy it.

[@ador7572]

Please review "The Last Samurai"

[@jtrex9531]

Yes please

[@ador7572]

please up vote my comment so Chris can see it

[@impohnny88]

+ador757 Agreed, also I believe Chris has said that "The Last Samurai" is one of his favorite samurai films.

[@thegroove14]

+ador757 It's Dances with Wolves but in Japan.

[@robm6645]

+ador757 Please review "Seven Samurai"

[@exoxophanie4363]

This film is meant to be a fairytale hence the beginning with the animated story... This is an understated film which is magical and beautiful and Paul giamatti is amazing. The hate for shyamalan is bollocks, the happening is the only truly bad film he's made and I personally didn't like after Earth. Stop being sheep and hating him just because everyone else finds it fun to mock him

[@Rainbowhawk1993]

I fell in love with the film because of that and it just breaks my heart that people hate this movie just because it's fun to ride the hate wagon for M. Night. I just hope that this premise can be brought back and done better. Saw a comment on Nostalgia Critic's video that this concept, when adjusted, would be perfect for an Anime. Kind of like an Ah! My Goddess story but with Water Nymphs and Monsters instead of Goddesses and Devils.

[@Aeberon]

Don't generalize my dislike for Shyamalan. A lot of people agreeing that he's a bad director doesn't mean that everyone who thinks that way is on the bandwagon. Most stereotypes have roots in truth. The guy just isn't good, and neither is this movie. In my opinion.

[@bigbruno2232]

This movie is like a lucid dream to me. Very beautiful looking and an interesting story. I don't hate Shyamalan he just needs to focus more on the acting and writing.

[@Kaefer1973]

+stephanie wasling A lot of people hate him for The Last Airbender, and while I don't think anyone could have made a truly great single movie from a whole season of a series, at least not a movie as good as said whole season of the source material (just too much going on), he certainly could have done a better job. People aren't forgiving when it comes to things they love, they might be a little to harsh in such a case, but it doesn't mean they are sheepish. Anyway I never loved a single one of his movies even though I thought the Sixth Sense was okay. I don't hate him but he doesn't really produce for my taste.

[@JoshThewhiteDad]

stephanie wasling the last Airbender

[@benwasserman8223]

Personally, THIS is where Shyamalan's career began to go down both the drain and the rabbit hole

[@benwasserman8223]

+Hank Hill Signs and The Village were ok films. Not good but not absolutely horrible. This was the first actual WTF movie he made

[@cb1671]

+Ben Wasserman Agreed. Signs and The Village were not as good as his previous films, but he at least made decent films. After that, his work went straight down the shitter. P.S: Nice profile pics, to the both of you.

[@benwasserman8223]

+Chris Barbati Thanks

[@PassTheMarmalade1957]

Honestly, coupled with M. Night casting himself as a writer destined to change the world and become a martyr, it's hard to see the miserable film critic character as a good-humoured joke.

[@Corn_Pone_Flicks]

Truly...this film is an object lesson in how not to respond to criticism. Had he simply cast someone else in that role, he'd have not been seen as such a self-important jerk. It's amazing he couldn't predict how that would play out with the public.

[@JasonBlackYT1]

It's scary how much Shyamalan looks like a young Michael Jackson from the Thriller era. And by that I mean facially, not because he's black

[@stacyxxy]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 thriller!!!!!!

[@deka0014]

+Evan Waffle indians are black brown white and oriental. In india shyam would be considered black

[@metronum]

+Jason Black the eyes init

[@yudhveer99]

so glad im kinda white...even though im indian...but then im a big racist so...

[@metronum]

Yuvi Singh Dont be harsh on yourself, you are a big bones racist.

[@martinijean4099]

I love Lady In The Water (and love M. Night), and thank you for being different and actually having a well-rounded review. As soon as you held up "The Man Who Heard Voices" (which I also read), I knew you would give a fair and just take on the movie. You're awesome. Subscribed.

[@basedjebkush2760]

Still waiting on the next Star Wars review.........

[@TheSMLIFfilms]

I bet you're a red letter media fan

[@sennajordan7968]

+TheSMLIFfilms jeb Bush

[@ethanguizzo6879]

Ikr

[@pennywisetheclown773]

+TheSMLIFfilms "It's gonna be great."

[@glenis83]

I've seen this movie numerous times and for me it has really taken on a character of its own. I enjoy the offbeat tone and the sort of freestyle "as if telling the story off the top of your head" flow that it has. And of course the music is just phenomenal. Paul Giamatti gives an incredibly earnest performance. The entire cast seems to just be letting loose and enjoying themselves and the movie itself is just nuts but I think that's what makes it fun. It's also incredibly heartfelt and sincere, and has one of the most beautiful final shots I've ever seen in a movie. Chris Martin of Coldplay said that the song "Yellow" doesn't really provide any deep meaning... but what it does do is evoke a feeling. Whether its intentional or not, some things just make you feel warm to your core and Lady in the Water is one of the few movies of which I can say that is absolutely the case, at least for me.

[@TheCpobarnet]

I loved this movie. And often rewatch it from time to time. This movie gives hope in times when hope seems forgotten. I think the movie can be easily appreciated by people who are empathetic, who is cynical by nature, but wants to believe their is still good in this world. I am happy to be amongst a few people who appreciate the movie for what it was. And not focusing on the fact that the director played a pivotal role.

[@abercrombiedrive]

I really enjoy how earnest and enthusiastic you are in your reviews. And your willingness to delve deep in the search of endearing qualities despite any "shallow apprehensions" you may have about the film. Keep up the good work, you earned yourself a subscriber!

[@Okulele-d4t]

anyway glad to find someone who appreciate this movie. It is emotionally strong, the tone and visuals are stunning, and the score is beautiful. I dont care if it has sooo many dumb scenes. it gets my heart.

[@Steve_SCirca30]

Thanks for doing this. I haven’t seen the film in years, but I really enjoyed it. Thank you for taking the time to read the book and break everything down. I hope this will allow others to appreciate this film for what it is and not tear it apart for what it’s not. I think it deserves more credit then it gets. As always thanks for doing what you do.

[@BIGSchuZ]

Wow you really said exactly how i feel about this movie. Its so dumb at parts but I actually cried at one point because James Newton Howard's score was so breathtaking and emotional.

[@Okulele-d4t]

Bryce Dallas Howrds performance was, I think she was wonderful. she did her best within small area provided by the script. for most of the movie, Shes a faity tale character. and she just needed to look like one. and she NAILS IT. and later when we get to know her better, the scene where she confesses her fear and gets comforted. when she becomes humane. she was, dare I say, FANTASTIC.

[@themuchdingdong]

Bryce Dallas Howard looks like Dave Mustaine

[@SiLvErWaRe000]

Dude, I really love the honesty in your reviews. I love this movie, this is one of my watch over and over movies. It's mostly because I can typically guess what's gonna happen in movies and as I was guessing with my first watch everything was wrong. At that point I had to shut my brain off and just enjoy the movie. I do agree with what you said about not feeling like the blue world was something that was real. I could never put my finger on what it was whenever I watch it, just felt like something was missing.

[@immunityzeroIZ]

I love this film because of the originality. It always reminds me of the love and hate that role-playing games get. Keep up the great work.

[@tabby25hope]

I saw this movie just once as a kid and got stuck in my head for years. I still have scenes that I remember with great detail. For me, all the weird things from it just made it much more interesting, it's very original and mysterious, I didn't mind the cryptic aspect of it. I really liked it.

[@LaMaestra2102]

I thought this was a movie that should have never been made. It was wholly convoluted. I actually felt like Shyamalan just threw it together as if you're supposed to do a few bad films once in a while - so long as you keep working. Thank you as always, Chris!

[@SayHelloHelli]

I loved lady in the water as a kid and today I still love it. the mix of different people at the apartment complex is just great.

[@JoaqMan]

Review The Last Airbender, Chris.

[@danaberry149]

He already did

[@JoaqMan]

Over There Not the same way as the other movies.

[@danaberry149]

True, but there is really nothing new he could say. Everything that could possible be said about that abomination has been said a million times already.

[@96TeenSpirit]

+J Wizard Phoenix he has in the past. Thats why hes not doing it again

[@miguelrealp]

+J Wizard Phoenix B+

[@michaeltaube7554]

I've watched this at least 40 times. It's a guilty pleasure. Paul Giamatti is excellent.

[@Gouthamedara]

I only saw this yesterday and I loved it!! It totally went over peoples heads

[@idkkimberlyanne]

goutham edara as most of his films do. It's a beautiful movie.

[@Corn_Pone_Flicks]

I don't think this went over anyone's head. It's obvious what the film is saying: critics don't know anything, Shyamalan's a genius, and children are pure and innocent and we should be more like them, the problem being that only one of those thing is even sometimes true. For a film about storytelling, it doesn't know how to tell one. It writes itself into corners and then Paul Giamatti asks the Asian mother and daughter to explain the magical exception to the rule that will let things move forward again. It's like writing a Superman story where Superman is tied up in Kryptonite chains while Lex Luthor is about to destroy Metropolis, only to suddenly have the voice of Jor El come in and say, "actually, if an eclipse happens on my son's birthday, kryptonite will become a life-giving power source...have I not mentioned this before?" and suddenly it's all hunky-dory.

[@Gouthamedara]

@@Corn_Pone_Flicks I would say critics and children are on the mark. As for Shyamalan, I dont think he tried to say he is a genius lol. His acting seemed totally fine to me. If we watch it with open mind its not bad at all. At least not all the flak he gets

[@DimmyCracksDemons]

Once again, excellent review. This review (and many like it) is the reason you are my favorite reviewer. Thanks.

[@swdshfsh]

I watched this movie when i was like 10-12 and it made me scared of grass at night lool

[@katieinthe80s57]

Miechiu 😂

[@zach6255]

same. I hated sprinklers toooo

[@harambeftw8363]

Same

[@DrPreston2]

I'm not amazed this movie didn't destroy Shamalan's career. I'm amazed that The Happening, Last Airbender, and After Earth somehow didn't destroy his career.

[@NewoandMe]

Before Christopher Nolans next movie (not counting his short documentary) you should do a series on his older films. These are: Following, Memento, Insomnia and The Prestige.

[@NewoandMe]

I would also enjoy a more in-depth review of Inception since your one from 2010 is really dated and, sorry but, not to good.

[@DavisWOW]

+NewoandMe Reviewing Nolan's work is completly unnecessary. You can just sum them up in a few words: Very good movies.

[@jamesflanagan7693]

From the very first viewing in the theater I thought this movie was absolutely AMAZING! I wept! As a long time M Night fan I personally consider this his masterpiece! Absolute perfection in my opinion! The most tight film of his. This is THE most misunderstood and underrated movie of all-time! The themes of finding one's place in the world, of the wickedness of mankind as a whole, and also the beauty of mankind I found deeply touching. The scene after the party where the plan has fallen apart and they can't understand why everything is going so wrong is the key scene! And directly brings to mind the Biblical verse about not leaning on your own understanding but trusting the Lord and giving him the control and just having faith. Faith is a recurring theme in his films and one of the main reasons I enjoy them. Some time before seeing this film my pastor had done a very beautiful sermon on spiritual gifts and how we should let the Lord reveal our spiritual gifts to us in his own time rather than trying to figure out what gift he has given us. He related stories about knowing pastors who had been preaching for decades and then coming to the conclusion later in life that teaching the word was not their spiritual gift after all. This goes back to not leaning on our own understanding. It is only when they stop trying to control the situation themselves in the film that they understand who the true interpreter, and healer and so forth are. And like many Biblical characters Cleveland is reluctant to accept the role God has given to him. This movie is SO beautiful, SO moving, and SO inspiring to me! I cannot state enough how near and dear to my heart this film is! They mismarketed this one from the very start because all studios care about is the bottom line so they marketed it as another M Night thriller/suspense flick to try and draw in the audience. This film has more of a kinship to Chronicles Of Narnia than it does Signs or The Sixth Sense. And the backlash from disappointed fans over The Village was another reason this film isn't held in higher regard. Had this followed Signs instead of The Village I have no doubt it would have performed very well financially!

[@henrewest588]

still waitin for a new hope...

[@ryanproctor4476]

I'm pretty sure he's already filmed it.

[@pedro_a_martins]

+HenRe West You mean the film or are you actually hopeless?

[@adamschneider4143]

M. Night Shyamalan is a very good director who isnt afraid to take a huge risk. Lady in The water was actually a really good modern take on a Action Fantasy movie.

[@OMGYasuke]

M. Night Shyamalan is a Legend

[@godymcgork481]

+Reverse SteveJobs Punished Shyamalan "A fallen Legend"

[@dericjames2018]

Once this film came out his films started to suck badly.

[@AxioProductions]

Was a legend

[@redluca56]

A legend as in people tell stories about when he used to be good

[@redpotatoes1515]

That's Adam Johnston's line

[@AStarr-bj3cq]

One of your fans, +Night Mind dropped your name. As a fan of his, I can see where the influences come from! Excellent review and analysis, Chris! I look forward to checking out your stuff! Don't worry though, I won't dig too deep. This review has definitely made me want to watch Lady in the Water from a totally different perspective. I was surprised when you didn't touch on the most memorable part of the movie (for me), which was Freddy Rodriguez's character who only works out the one arm, then the amazingly cheeky shot of him in the rain. Truly the ultimate characterization of the duality of Man. ;-)

[@KanishQQuotes]

The problem is that pretentiousness is often taken as "too deep to understand"

[@GossipGyal1]

Exactly

[@luiginastro8831]

@penguin this movie is trash

[@MoviesWithDallin]

This is always my answer for "what movie do you think is underrated?" My favourite part of this movie is the very last scene. Earlier in the movie when the critic talks about "why do people stand around and talk in the rain" Paul Giamatti's response is "Purification, starting anew." Cut to the very last scene of the movie, Paul Giamatti and Story are standing in the rain, and he says, "Thank you for saving my life." His life is now starting anew. I think it's beautiful poetry.

[@helekin2000]

a. Imo the craziness of this story is what made it unique. I watched this film after the other Siamalan films that came before it. And the fact that they all had a revelation at the end, made me think that this time again, the story teller is effing with as throughout the whole time watching this. I expected to see a twist in the end telling us that all this was a joke or made up (like in The Village) and another part of me (the inner kid's part) begged for all this to be true and come ton an epic closure. Not revealing this fairy 'world/universe' at all, actually worked for me. Cause I did not know what to believe or how to view this film till the end. b. The fact that 'Story' was an other worldly creature, a fairy of some sorts made the actress' performance even better in my eyes. Because it kept intriguing me. I could not connect with her while I wanted it so much! I felt like the main character of this film, who was willing to give everything to help her, without even knowing her.

[@loolovesyou]

I always liked this movie. Loved it when I was younger. I can definitely see the flaws but I really loved the apartment setting/dynamics and the characters finding themselves in the story. Plus Paul Giamatti of course.

[@isaacgroves]

Chris would you truly be this forgiving of this film if you didn't have such a nostalgic connection to the director? Honest question.

[@abyp1883]

Great point. Ouch, that was a bullet!

[@JGarMedia]

Hello Stuckmann. I'm the one who helped you get a ticket to M. Night Shyamalan's panel at Comic Con back in July. I spoke to him as you did. I think The Village is his best movie, and someone else said the same at the panel. As for Lady In The Water, I love the mix of humor and fantasy in it, and talked about it in my own video about M. Night's movies. The critic clearly represents the many viewers who don't believe that anyone can be original or creative anymore, and this movie is exactly that, as you said. I also really liked Bryce Dallas Howard in both films, and I told her that when I met her two years ago. I'm looking forward to The Visit, and your thoughts on it when you share.

[@AiggEbe]

A NEW HOPE CHRIS!!!!

[@PhoenixRiseinFlame]

I have to respect Shamaylan for attempting to create original movies. Some of his movies are really bad but at least he’s taking risks. Most of the American film industry is so risk averse these days.

[@MattRyanBurrows]

"Nymphs called Narfs" lollololollololololol

[@MattRyanBurrows]

"Narfs" is the most uncreative name I've ever heard

[@Saoirse_don_Phalaistín]

Ursahhh

[@nikkis.2066]

+Matt B Drawings I immediately think of Thundercats and Snarf & Snarfer going "Snarf snarf!" xD

[@tyrantgregcagkaiju71]

You'd almost expect a "Narf" to be some kind of gnome or elf.

[@MybeautifulandamazingPrincess]

Narf is a deity of Nordic cosmology. Pathetic how a-holes like you try to find a way to insult others at any cost. Trying to ruin other people’s enjoyment 😣

[@roetheboat1]

The largest issue that I had with this movie is the fact that Shyamalan put himself in the role of the person whose work will change the world for the better because it is great. Also, people won't understand his work at first because it's SO great. It seems like a huge ego trip on his part. I do actually agree somewhat with your point on the film critic. It is definitely does seem like some lighthearted jabbing, but I also have some difficulty in believing that because of how it seems like Shyamalan is using this movie as a way to talk about how great he is.

[@kingoceanblu4445]

I'm sorry Chris, but u are an absolute M. Night Fan!!!!! it really shows here.... Just because Night knows it's an absolute mess.... Doesn't mean it makes it better

[@dr.manhattan7283]

Or maybe his films are flawless masterpieces!!!!!!!!

[@kingoceanblu4445]

+Alex Styles I'm sure in some people's minds

[@Joshiepoo2525]

Great video, Chris. Nice to have people kinda defending this one, but I do disagree one one thing. Just because the "rest of the world" will see a movie (or work of art, or music, or anything) does not mean it shouldn't be made. It may be personal but there are people who love this movie (myself included). Not appealing to a mass audience, in my opinion, is not and should not be a requirement for a filmmaker. There're definitely things to consider from a production and financial standpoint, but if someone is willing to get behind the artist and let him make his small-audience-minded art, I say more power to him. There may only be a small audience that can appreciate what Shyamalan tried to do with this movie (as he was very aware of and parodied in the screenplay), but I do not think it is unfortunate that the rest of the world had to endure it. Although I suppose you could chalk that up to bad marketing, since a lot more people probably saw this movie than would enjoy it on a conceptual level.

[@ashesmandalay1762]

The reason why I hated the stupid critic death thing in Lady in the Water wasn't because I can't take a joke, but because the joke was a) really stupid and hack - as you said yourself it's been done over and over forever b) incredibly self serving and, alongside casting himself as the hero, makes him look like an egomaniac c) it wasn't compelling in the slightest to me, I did not care about that character and his death meant nothing to the story.

[@wpp7562]

I'm a filmmaker (a writer/producer in LA) and I have been a sub of yours for many years and a big fan of what you do. Very excited for SHELBY OAKS btw. And I don't think I have ever disagreed with you on any of your reviews, past (like this one) and present. That said, for some reason this and your review of THE VILLAGE popped up in my feeds today. And I have to disagree with you about some of your takes on both M. Night past films (not all your takes in this video and in The Village review), but some. For me, The Village was terrific and Lady in the Water was magical to me. Absurd, but who cares if it captures the imagination and gave us an original story. I also am partial to this film as I went to see this the night before production started on my first movie back in 2006, so I was just so excited the following morning and this film made me feel like the world was special. All that said, I do agree with some of your points in this video and The Village - like in your review of The Village, you made an excellent point that Ivy should have battled it out with the creature BEFOFE we got the William Hurt flashback tell her (and us) that the creatures weren't real. And then it could have shown the face of Adrian Brody in the hole he fell into. Excellent point. Anyway, I just wanted to add my two cents. Again, love what you do and always watch your videos. Be well!

[@Sean-eq9ig]

Are you going to review Season 1 of Wayward Pines? M Night was the executive producer and it's very good, If I had to describe it, it's kind of like The Village, but MUCH BETTER. I would highly recommend it, thanks!

[@KlingonCaptain]

+MrSean I especially liked all of the references to the British, science fiction TV show "The Prisoner" from 1967.

[@tatehildyard5332]

I might watch it if I get time. How similar is it to Twin Peaks because the commercials put that vibe out.

[@cb1671]

+Tate Hildyard They definitely seem to be going for the same feeling, but I've never seen Wayward Pines. If it's half as good as Twin Peaks, I'll give it a watch.

[@tatehildyard5332]

Excited for season 3 on showtime in 2017?

[@cb1671]

Tate Hildyard Absolutely.

[@LeaPrufrock]

Very fair as ever, Chris. I really love how in your reviews you can talk about movies people love to mock and pull apart (see:signs) and unflinchingly show their good sides. it's very persuasive :)

[@unpleasedwitch2235]

Oh, this movie! I actually remembered loving this movie. It was weird, but I loved it

[@muticere]

That feel about right. I enjoyed some parts but for me a lot of the bad outweighed the good. My issue with the critic character is that Yes, I can tell he was meant to be a joke character and his whole presence in the film was meant to be a joke about criticism. However I don't think it was a joke told very well. I actually liked the critic, I thought he was funny. I would probably enjoy reading his reviews to see how over the top negative he'd get about movies. And I also much preferred his interpretation of the events of the story and what character would play which role. But whatever. It's a mess of a film, but it's still enjoyable to watch.

[@MarKRMartell]

+Chris Stuckmann, you forgot his movie "Devil." Please do a review.

[@VTPPGLVR]

My dad watched this movie at home a few years back, and the kid reading the cereal boxes was the first thing I ever saw of this movie. My dad started laughing because of all the parts for me to walk in on, THAT was my first encounter. I stared at him and asked if that scene would make sense if I watched the movie. He shook his head and said "Not really."

[@cushiro]

new hope where is it

[@TheGreatMerman]

A very good and thorough review. I might give this movie a shot just to see some of the better points. Speaking of your statement about reviewing older films - have you thought about picking a director and doing a series of reviews of their films? My first thought is Andrew Nicol (Gattaca, Lord of War, The Truman Show) and Kevin Reynolds (Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves, Count of Monte Cristo, and Tristan and Isolde). Would give you a nice variety and a chance to play on the nostalgia a bit.

[@kimrangel7581]

Chris can you review Donnie Darko?

[@philthemovieguy81]

I feel like what most people miss is the messages of the film. It's presented in a fairytale/storybook kind of way. I am always a deep thinker so that is what I hone in on in stories and film. I love the fairytale aspect of it, it felt like I was a kid again. I felt the story of the movie was about this character named Story who comes into the life of a man with a tragic past. Fear is presented in several ways and fear plays a role for several reasons. Fear of not knowing your place or role in the world, fear of knowing what you're suppose to do but don't think you'll be good at it, fear of dealing with the past, fear of moving forward; and ultimately, overcoming those fears through use of the gifts you have and maybe knew you had or gifts you didn't know you had. Very deep topics discussed through a child-like fairytale.

[@Kaefer1973]

I like fairytales, it's the reason I still like a new hope best of all Star Wars movies. But this one just isn't the type of fairietale I love. People can not like something you like for more reasons than "not understanding it", there just are different tastes out there.

[@ksrugis]

I think the exposition scenes were some of the most hilarious and well done scenes in the movie. He really turned a negative into a positive in this movie imo. Also, it is a fairy tale for children being told to adults, so throughout the movie characters, like the viewers, need to suspend their disbelief and just take what they see and hear for fact without too much questioning the logic or science of it. I think the movie is a solid B+

[@kinvoya]

I've only watched about four of your reviews so far but I am so pleased and excited about how even-handed you are with a movie like this. I wanted this movie to be amazing so much and, of course, I was disappointed. Still, I enjoyed aspects of it and I appreciated Shyamalan's efforts. Thank you for being so thoughtful and for not taking a good/bad approach to the films you review.

[@HYLOBRO]

A FUCKING C+ ?!?!? I always support you Chris. Always. You continue to inspire me and have given me hope that I will someday do what you do, and more. But I think you are way too forgiving with M. Night. This movie in no way deserves even a passing grade, so to speak. At best, this movie is a D film. Please try not to be so wrapped up in the production, and what he went through making this. Judge it by the film itself, without the nostalgia and biases that make you such a huge fan of his. Just my two cents. Continue being awesome, I always appreciate the effort you put into reviews.

[@minuterice19540]

+Dillon Jenings Yeah, a C+ is a bit much, but that's how fanboys work. I should know, I'm a Godzilla fanboy and thought that the movie last year was God's gift to the world. I had to watch it five or six times before I started noticing the problems. So I get where he's coming from.

[@unlessitsmarco]

its his opinion idiot

[@AlkoWasAlreadyTaken]

Oh fuck off, it's his opinion.

[@thomasgriffiths6758]

When your mother read you Nursery Rhymes as a kid did you break them down and analyze them like you do this??

[@calsnow6807]

you didn't say anything about the guy with one huge arm and leg...he was like quagmires character from family guy after he discovered porn

[@texasbeast239]

I think he was a symbolic representation of people who overuse certain strengths to the point of imbalance against many other important traits and abilities needed in life.

[@Rickloven]

The way you describe the film in the first 2 minutes was hilarious. Sounds like a film you're pitching to your friends after smoking a bunch. Lol

[@chrisokeeffe3895]

do a top 10 most overrated movies ever

[@Nanu67-e9j]

He loves all movies that are highly rated

[@NeoConnor1]

Art is subjective.

[@mena94x3]

I really appreciate how you try to give an honest review, after having seen it several times with an open mind and open heart, not just jumping on the haters bandwagon for the sake of it. I admittedly have a “bad habit” of walking into each movie with no preconceived expectations. I think too many moviegoers go to a movie with their minds made up about how it should be and are inevitably disappointed when it doesn’t fulfill their their preconceived expectations. I say this is a “bad habit” because it results in me generally liking every movie I see for what it is. There are obviously some movies that absolutely stunning, and others that underwhelm me, but I don’t ever feel the need to bash them.

[@BobinKafa]

The only thing that would save a ridiculous story like this one would be pure originality, which was never the strongsuit of Shyamalan. I can ignore the fact that he uses the building which has people from all colors and nationalities as metaphore of America just like " Million Dollar Hotel" but if your main character is saved by "Gwaihir" from "Lord of the Rings" while being chased by "G'mork" from "Neverending Story", I wouldn't call that story original. Also, if he has a problem with movie critics he should arrange boxing matches like Uwe Boll and duke it out like a man, not let them getting eaten by wolves in a movie where he plays a prophet.

[@madcap3450]

It shouldn't have been an urban fantasy. Urban fantasy is so fuckin stupid just let your fantasy take place in a fantasy world

[@rebecalescano8209]

Maybe I am too simple minded? Or maybe I don't look at movies the same way, but I LOVE THIS MOVIE. To me the whole Narf story was great, and how he was told about it was even greater. Mind you the best part of my childhood was lying in bed listening to my father telling stories, and I grew up with a huge love for fantasy and mythology. So I do not consider it "dumb"... I was kindda hurt by you saying so... but I do understand why you would say that. Yeah... a good deal of this movie is cheesy but I thought it clever. I completely loved the twist with the tenants cause I was disappointed they thought the adult was the reader of messages when to me it was obvious it was the kid, cause he saw more than what other people could in everyday life. I also liked the critic and his death... not that I don't like critics or criticism. It's more like I saw him as a clear representation of those bitter people who don't see the magic in life... And... I really liked Brice... Bryce? Uhm... Dang it... I really suck at names. Story, I think I understood her, how she wasn't supposed to tell others about her background, her world, how she was scared and unsure of herself, I really liked how fragile and dainty she looked and acted, yeah, sure, she was a damsel in distress and not a rough and tough woman, but I liked her that way in the story cause her weakness made others braver, stronger and that was great... Anyway... this video is sooo old I really doubt you'll ever read this comment, I guess I just wanted to say something since this time I disagree in a lot of things you said and I usually agree with you like 100% so... anyway... thanks for the video :) and Im totally a fan of yours.

[@aaronsynra6867]

I recently posted a remark about this review in the hopes that Chris would just happen to read it... someday. Perhaps he will. Anyway, you are not alone in your love for this film. It's been one of favorites since its release. I saw it in the theater and was hooked as soon as the music that covers the introduction started.

[@lewismoore3047]

NEW HOPE PLEASE STUCKMANN!

[@kodyeldridge5847]

I will happily die defending the "lady in the water" hill, Paul Giamatti, Jeffrey Wright and Bryce Dallas Howard are all absolutely brilliant in this movie.

[@elderofzion]

if i was you stuckmann, i'd watch out for that grass-wolf

[@ZatannaFan94]

Scrunt

[@belennathalieferreira6899]

I think Lady in the water is a movie for a specific public. I watched this movie when i was 12 and i loved it. That's why he wanted Disney to be involved in the movie, it's supposed to be like a tale. He was making this for children and older people who like magical stories. I think the movie has a great story and cool characters.