Led Zeppelin "In My Time Of Dying" (REACTION) Subscriber Request: W. Geoffery Spaulding

Led Zeppelin "In My Time Of Dying" (REACTION) Subscriber Request: W. Geoffery Spaulding- Stairway To Heaven

[@davidzimmerli489]

Great reaction/review! Gumbo Supreme, Indeed I am convinced, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that no rock group will ever replace Led Zeppelin as the greatest Rock Band in the history of the genre. Most don't even come close. These 4 British musicians were, in their prime, ROCK GODS, and they deserve the respect and admiration of all serious listeners of music .... PERIOD .....

[@davescurry69]

I loved that look on Plant's face near the end, just after the band kicked in after the "Oh my Jesus" refrain. It was a look that simply said, "how fucking good are we". And they were.

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Yea RP was definitely FEELING HISSELF & the BAND!🤣

[@targetshootr]

We went to a lot of concerts back then and Zep was by far the loudest. The last time they came to town they played for 3 1/2 hours and my ears rang for a week. But we sat 20 feet away at eye level from the greatest band ever. It happened to be Bonzo's birthday so RP had 15k of us sing Happy Birthday.

[@teresaboone7298]

Yes!! Zeppelin are the GOAT!!

[@Bluewizard7131]

Check out the 28 minute version of Dazed and Confused. Greatest guitar solo ever recorded. They constantly improvise during live performances.

[@juliemanarin4127]

OMG yes! Unrivaled!!

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Ok, please send me a link when you get a chance. THANKS!

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Ok, please send me a link when you get a chance. THANKS!

[@Bluewizard7131]

@@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178 Here ya go! Mind blowing performance. kzbin.info/www/bejne/kILKiqFoaL2pmc0

[@eatthisvr6]

@@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178 the cello bow solo alone will leave you flat on your arse speechless!!

[@Codex7777]

JPJ is on bass. He was an accomplished multi instrumentalist. In Zeppelin he was the bassist AND keyboardist. Live, he'd often be playing 2 keyboards, whilst playing bass with his feet! He was also a noted mandolin player. :)

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

WOW....IDK you could even play Bass with your Feet! Thanks for the View & Comment and if any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@w.geoffreyspaulding6588]

@@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178 bass pedals on the organ…..

[@BBaldwin]

Jonesy is the silent assassin - a certified bad ass

[@BBaldwin]

They were, are and WILL ALWAYS BE the ultimate rock band…

[@36karpatoruski]

No autocorrect. No protools. No software mismanagement of any kind. Just 1 part acid blues, 1 part hard rock, a sprinkle of psychedelia, and raw talent times 4. There you go.

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

No Doubt! Thanks for the View & Comment! If any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@puromichoacan8339]

well hot darndit cletus whered chu learn so many darnget long words like that 🤣😅😂😆

[@27thangel23]

Zep took an old Blues tune, "Jesus Make Up My Dying Bed" by Blind Willie Johnson in 1927 and they decibelised it into Blues Rock perfection. They based many of their songs on great Black bluesmen- Muddy Waters, Willie Dixon, Robert Johnson- even Sam Cooke. And Blues Rock sprouted Progressive and Hard Rock. Maybe even Psychedelic Rock (see "Dazed and Confused" LIVE if poss.). But the undersung hero of "Dying" is Jonesy... he alone gives the propulsion necessary for the other three to add their filigrees of magic. Greetings from Canada, Rio- peace and be safe.

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

GREAT BREAKDOWN FAM! I literally had to look up a cpl of words you used "Filigrees & Decibelised" 🤣

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

When you get a chance let me know what "LIVE" performance of Dazed & Confused should I react to? ps- I grew up in Detroit and started going to Windsor at 19 because we could DRINK! And I've been to TO about 20 times. ✌🏾

[@27thangel23]

@@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178 Yeah, well I made up the decibelised- sorry about that... but it means increasing the decibels (the units of measure of loudness). i.e. they rockified the Blues. Good on you for looking them up- big fan of dictionaries here.

[@27thangel23]

@@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178 I was Canadian Army and could drink legally at 17... I know the impetus! The thing about D&C is that either Jimmy (usually) or Robert would change on each performance- each show is individual and wonderful. You'll get in the least trouble if you do the MSG, NYC, 1973 show in the movie The Song Remains the Same... it's about 28 minutes though. PS I'm Southern Ontario, Been to Flint, Michigan about 20 times... and I got love for Detroit: Was (not Was), Berry Gordy, Bob Seger, Mitch Ryder, Martha and the Vandellas...

[@nekaeljones3086]

You forgot about Howling Wolf "Killing Floor". They based 'The Lemon Song" off of it.

[@anitapaulus937]

That’s JPJ on the fretless bass playing right along with Jimmy.

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Ok, I've never heard of a "Fretless" bass. Thanks for the View & Comment! If any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@anitapaulus937]

@@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178 Frets allow you to hit the pitch of every note perfectly without worrying about going sharp or flat. They’re like markers to help determine notes. Jimmy was using a slide on his guitar and JPJ was essentially sliding on his bass as well.

[@derekjackson1039]

We need an isolated bass track on this one

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

@@anitapaulus937 Got It! Thanks for the 💎

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

@@derekjackson1039 👌🏿

[@teresaboone7298]

They are gonna play this song and a few others at my funeral. Listen to every word!!

[@carlhughes6459]

Got hold of the blues in 69 repackaged it and sent it back to the states, heavy rock was born and never bettered, listen to the first two albums there ain’t a bad track and even to this day no one has played as heavy and as good

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Thanks for the View & Comment! If any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@carlhughes6459]

@@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178 now looking 👍

[@vahanvrijian4114]

Love zepplin great reaction. Another great geoff castellucci cover of 16 tons is awesome.

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

👌🏿

[@tomleslie6668]

I think you said it well when you called John Paul Jones the swiss-army knife. By now, of course, people have told you that he's also the source of all Zep's rock-steady base. Nice reaction. Good to see people reacting to the old stuff. It's kind of like hearing it again for the first time.

[@shaunchittick3503]

"Swiss Army Knife of the group". I love it!

[@tektoniks_architects]

JPJ does it all. 4 master musicians, improvising nightly, going wherever they want, anyplace, anytime.

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

That's DOPE! Thanks for the View & Comment and if any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@marymargaretmoore9034]

Better musicians is my answer. Yep, that's JPJ on bass (he also plays keyboards and bass pedals simultaneously).

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Thanks for the View & Comment! If any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@joescott8877]

I Love how you went back and listened to the intro THREE times, lol! I was there with you every one, even though I've heard it three hundred at least, lol! Love your enthusiasm and humor and intelligence in your reactions. ZEPPELIN!! Random suggestion: "In the Light" from the same album this song's on, is incredible and usually gets amazed reactions!

[@BenDover-tb8cr]

That’s Bonzo’s right foot moving so fast.

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

CRAZY FAST! I hear Bill Burr talking about trying to get his paddle foot as fast as Bonheims 🤣

[@sicotshit7068]

I’ve watched your reactions each several times, yes they really are that great, & the best equipment too. Bonham would adjust his drums to get the exact sound he wanted, he also used just his wrists more then his whole arms. His son said his dad held the sticks down further, which maybe gave him better control, & that deeper beat. I’ve loved them for about 50 years, I love all you newer young people, finding & loving them too.

[@henriettaskolnick4445]

John Paul Jones is playing bass on this, there's no organ on this song so he's not playing the keys. However, if you want a monster jam with JPJ playing keys, react to Trampled Under Foot from this same concert (Earls Court) kzbin.info/www/bejne/fnipeoeiatJ5rNU

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Ok, I will add this to the Request List! Thanks for the View & Comment and If any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@ballsyrocker]

He is playing a Danelectro guitar with what they call "lipstick pickups". We had one from the '90s with 3 pickups. Great tone and resonance for slide guitar. Peace.

[@christophermorris7616]

Love the fact that you stop 🛑 and go back to examine and clarify 🍃 did I just hear and see that correctly😳 that yes the utter brilliance of an in synch group of musical magicians 🍃

[@sherryneal6575]

More Led Zeppelin please

[@juliemanarin4127]

Aren't they the BEST?!! Please do The Song Remains The Same/The Rain Song!! Just the best musicians! JPJ plays bass and keyboards and mandolin...no keys in this one. That is JPJ on bass...only 4 in this group!

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Got'cha! When you have a chance can you send me a link for a LIVE version of The Song Remains The Same/The Rain Song that I can react to. Thanks!

[@bonzossticks9405]

Really enjoyed your insight and reaction. Cheers!

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Thanks for the View & Comment and if any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@cherryvalley5000]

Led Zeppelin..... 4 geniuses that together created a 5th being; something more that music, something magical!!!!!

[@lowlypeasant]

Best reaction ever lol.

[@DGW374]

A classic example of what I tell my kids: if you love what you do and are good at it you never work a day in your life. These guys were insane, but joyously so.

[@swann331]

“JPJ is like the Swiss Army knife of the group” hahahaha the best description of Jonesy I’ve ever heard!!!

[@williamcabell142]

That’s what you call dropin the beat...for real! 😎👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@teresaboone7298]

I told family that I would haunt them if they didn't play All of this AND ALL of Stairway To Heaven at my funeral! Lol...

[@franticproductions]

Got me with the 'The Hat'… The home of rock and roll!!! Good reaction, “I'll be back”. PS I live in Detroit Metro.

[@teresaboone7298]

Looooove Jimmy!!!🎸🎙🎶

[@nathans3241]

Jimmy Page once said that when you listen to Led Zeppelin you clearly hear each band member performing.

[@inJesusname1992]

Great reaction bro

[@VlxWIZzZARDxlV]

Both. They had amazing mics and sound quality back in the 1970s. And they're the all star team of rock and roll

[@jamestickle3070]

Compared to other bands of this era, these guys were much higher trained musicians. Jimmy had a lot of background as a producer and technical expert on mixing and getting the right sound. No doubt it’s how they got the blend to sound so perfect live. He had a GREAT ear.

[@bobbyn.9773]

John Paul Jones is on bass

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

👌🏾

[@guitarttimman]

It's cool that you like these classics.

[@ORIGINALDaveB]

Good job brother! Greatest Rock Band of all time! Thats JPJ on Bass in case no one mentioned it.

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

JPJ did it ALL! Thanks for the View & Comment and if any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@robertakline9785]

Just found this channel and am totally diggin you dude! I'm into all the re-dos you want.

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Thanks for the View & Comment and if any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@jamestickle3070]

Damn they kick ass.

[@user-gk1nt6sm2z]

Nice reaction

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Thanks for the View & Comment and if any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@mervinward256]

you are about to go in to the relm of real music. and this band was greatest of them all

[@TRUMP-2024-STF]

Great version..!!

[@bobbyn.9773]

nice reaction....just subscribed! If you can ..do the Song Remains the Same/Rain Song from the 1973 MSG live concert...thank you bro

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Ok, I’ll add to the Request List. Thanks for the View & Comment! If any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@bobbyn.9773]

@@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178 here is the link for The Song Remains the Same/ Rain Song brother kzbin.info/www/bejne/oqvJgZuHZaiIbtE

[@TheSledge77]

John Paul Jones on base. As you said, he is the swiss arm knife of the band

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

No Doubt....Thanks for the View & Comment and if any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@heliotropezzz333]

*bass

[@TheSledge77]

@@heliotropezzz333 It was a simple spelling mistake, it happens to all of us

[@heliotropezzz333]

@@TheSledge77 O.K. A lot of people confuse those two words though.

[@julienmarquet8612]

John paul jones is playing the bass, keys, mandolin, guitar, it's a genius, made a lot of arregements of Led Zep, he was so quiet, in the shadow, but he was the glue, of LED ZEP! The 3 others were so huge monsters, improvising all the time, without him, it won't have worked! As other guys said, you should watch the Madison Square Garden concert in 1973,the movie called THE SONG REMAINS THE SAME! All the songs are crazy masterpieces! The sound production is perfect, the versions are perfect, and you can feel the telepathic link between them, always improvising to make the songs evolve every noghts, it's madness! WATCH DAZED AND CONFUSED! THEY'RE POSSESSED! PAGE IS THE DEVIL HIMSELF! IT'S COMING FROM ANOTHER WORLD, DIMENSION, GALAXY! Peace from France bro 😂👍✌️🎸🇫🇷

[@mikecalderon5251]

You forgot that this was "In My Time of Dying"? Welcome to the 70's... 🤪

[@volbeatrules6528]

Great ! Now I want some gumbo!

[@eatthisvr6]

SWAG!!!!

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Fa'Sho! Thanks for the View & Comment and if any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@eatthisvr6]

@@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178 got any more zep? theyre the best band ever imo

[@emersongoss16]

You get the Zep effect. You got Zepped!!! :)

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

I actually got Zepped when I met white people for the fist time in 1988🤷🏿‍♂️🤣. Thanks for the View & Comment and if any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@tonylosternau8110]

lol...this is the greatest band ever and that is a fact bro

[@TheGreatsagegoku]

JPJ is on the bass, AND the keys, synth,, melotrron, whatever it may be.

[@Newfie-zc7ug]

BETTER than everyone ,to be honest. Hearing all the instruments and Plant on each and every song, slow and fast or hard. It's what seperated them from all other bands. Oh and of course there's Bonzo .

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Agreed! Thanks for the View & Comment and if any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@mmurphy53]

John Paul Jones plays keys AND bass, sometimes both at the same time (with his feet when he is on the Hammond B3) HIGHLY underrated........He and John Bonham hold the fort down for Jimmy to play over and really star themselves

[@williamcabell142]

John Paul Jones on bass!

[@ronniel879]

Led Zeppelin still taken them all to church !!! Lol

[@Minceontoast2]

Even though Robert plant was having some vocal issues he sure still did great

[@bishlap]

true, some songs better than others, but, consider all the touring and 3 HOUR shows, what/who's voice could hold up?

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

REQUEST: Henrietta Skolnick (In My Time Of Dying) kzbin.info/www/bejne/i37TnoybjMhgi6M

[@zosometalgod]

That's John Paul Jones on the bass there is no keyboards on this song!

[@markacuna2828]

Bass John Paul Jones n keyboards n mandolin n 3 neck acoustic guitar

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

JPJ did it ALL! Thanks for the View & Comment and if any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@franticproductions]

Like you said John Paul Jones 'Swiss-army-knife' is on bass. (no organ this time).

[@arthurdrake6083]

🔥👍❤️❤️❤️🕊️😁👈

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Thanks for the View & Comment! If any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@arthurdrake6083]

@@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178 👍 Ozark mountain daredevils

[@williamcabell142]

Bass/keys John Paul Jones.

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Thanks for the View & Comment and if any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@williamcabell142]

John Paul Jones....is on bass. There are only four of them!

[@zimjun7]

Mortimer and Randolph Duke.

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

"A karate man bleeds on the inside, but you wouldn't know that because yous a big Barry White lookin nigga" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@leemcintyre9490]

John Paul Jones plays the Bass. Or Base guitar!

[@heliotropezzz333]

*bass, pronounced base

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

JPJ did it ALL! Thanks for the View & Comment and if any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

JPJ did it ALL! Thanks for the View & Comment and if any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@peggybrown9694]

Jones was and still is an unbelievable musical talent. He's a better bassist than Jimmy is a guitarist.

[@smartjunayd]

PLEASE REACT TO J.I.D - FUNK FLEX FREESTYLE RICO!!!

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Aight bet, I will add it to the Request List.

[@smartjunayd]

@@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178 you're gonna love it, and I meant Rio lol 😅

[@theStacyJames]

Better musicians

[@tanyatrejo6627]

There is something weird with this vocal analysis for this song. And this is not the only analysis doing it. I don't know how or why but they are skipping a very climatic part for this song, that actually ends with a You Shook me riff and verse. Can someone tell me what's going on? its confusing me a little 😂

[@roseannecohen]

You may be thinking of another live version of this song. There is another one at Earls Court where the "You Shook Me" part is included.

[@teresaboone7298]

WHO THE CRAP ARE THE 3 "IDIOTS" WHO PUT THUMBS DOWN?!!!!Smfh

[@richardmanitowoc52]

John Paul Jones

[@markusvounas9998]

What's up man love your reactions! I have a song that should be a MUST "YBN Cordae- Old Niggas" Young rapper responding to Old heads on why they do what they do and HOW they are now in they are in the same position y'all were once in when HipHop was new!

[@smartjunayd]

Cordae - Parables much better lyrically while the one you're suggesting is more about subject matter but still fire

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Ok, I’ll add to the Request List. Thanks for the View & Comment! If any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

@@smartjunayd 👌🏾

[@johndillon1299]

🤣

[@paul1x1]

No keys in this song anything you hear that isn't guitar or drums ls John Paul Jones

[@Trucker231610]

if your sound didn't suck I wouldn't mind starting over 3 times. I had enough thanks.

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Thanks for the Comment (it actually helps the channel) and if any of my other Reactions look interesting to you, do me a favor and check it out and let me know what you think.

[@Trucker231610]

@@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178 Instead of being a smart ass why don't you fix your sound!

[@eatthisvr6]

this is tame by bonhams standards lol

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Damn🤦🏿‍♂️🤣

[@eatthisvr6]

@@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178 if you want to hear Bonham REALLY obliterating everybody then check out a gig called listen to this Eddie. Even from the 1st rack he simply wasn't human that night. I'm not kidding he was unbelievable!!!

[@eatthisvr6]

@@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178 kzbin.info/www/bejne/onixnZ2ffJV-rcU

[@tannonwraith4692]

There is ONLY Robert Plant Jimmie Page John Paul Jones John Bonham

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

Got'cha........but it sounds like there's 7 instruments playing at the same damn time! 🤷🏾‍♂️🤣

[@ruddyy123]

Do some more Eminem reactions please.

[@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178]

EVERY 10th Reaction will be Marshall.

[@ruddyy123]

@@oldschoolhip-hopheadriorea9178 looking forward to it mate. Loving the reactions and things you pick up on