Lee Hsien Yang pays S$619,335 to Ministers Shanmugam and Balakrishnan in suit to protect family home

[@marklee-p1q]

Why is our gov becoming so petty. Whoever is the ruling party becoming more obnoxious than ever.

[@LonganLee]

@@marklee-p1q it surely is not out of self interest of rice bowl ? 🤭

[@gha9543]

Respect and honour the heroes and the fallen. Institutions are legacy of our great leaders.

[@pohmichael2978]

0:11 we have our utmost respect and admiration, your money will be for their FUNERALS !!

[@azhariann6843]

Dear sir your comments best of the best in sg 2024.👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👈

[@lucytheodas9808]

Many People have been asking and waiting for Shunmugan and Balakrishna to explain to The People why the two ministers use their Wife to sign SLA Tenancy Contract to rent SLA Black and White Bungalow??? Please enlighten Whether their wife meet the SLA tenancy Contract compliance. All SLA Tenants must show earning salary 3 times the bid rent. So the people are waiting for Shunmugan to show that his wife is earning pay cheque of $78,000 per month to meet SLA’s Tenancy Contract Compliance. Balakrishna’s wife should also show pay cheque of $60,000 per month to meet the compliance of SLA’s Tenancy Contract’s compliance. Since the two minister’s renting of black and White bungalow have attracted much interest Worldwide with Law Suite and World Media reporting. It is fair to ask, since both minister’s declare no wrong doing in them renting the two grand Black and White at below market rent.

[@user-ck2cp3lt3v]

If the Late Father still around..Who dare to ask for payment..

[@Hs5687]

In 2010 , LKY was caught Red Handed and Paraded like a Common Street Criminal at SG’s Sikh Police Temple… LKY Looked so Cute & Obedient after Caught 😂🎉❤

[@AlphaSorceror]

@@Hs5687what rubbish are you spouting?

[@firefly4326]

​@@Hs5687in 2010, your mother was caught Red handed and paraded like a Common street criminal. Looking so cute and obedient 😂😂😂

[@ongtayjoojames-ow1bs]

​@@Hs5687Wait a moment...!!!🤚 What r u talking abt...???!!!😬🤔

[@Hs5687]

If Father still ard, he’ll pbly be in Jail or in Exile for TREASON 😊… It’s must be Just a sheer Coincidence that Both he ( LKY ) & his Known blue Eyed Lap Dog, Goh Yong Hong ( SG’s Longest Serving & Ex Comm of Police ) Died within Weeks in 2015 AFTER Allegations Filed in SG High Court… RIP Buddy, KARMA Underway..❤

[@johnboon4731]

IN SINGAPORE THIS JUDGEMENT IS VALID BUT LOOK LIKE NO OTHER COUNTRIES IN THE WORLD AGREED TO THIS JUDGEMENT. 🙈🙈🙈

[@marktan8074]

Can anyone share more... what does the case of the black & white bungalows rental issue has to do with the Lee family saga? Isn't it 2 separate issues?

[@jackwong230]

not related at all but TOC doesn't care as long as it can make PAP look bad

[@dennistan4663]

Why not, it's 3 ply tissue. 😅😅😅

[@ChinnayyaPillaiThanasekaran]

Its always big news when indian ministers are concern.

[@0157matt]

Shouldn't pay .

[@AlphaSorceror]

He’s right to pay not for the defamation but for his sister’s sake.

[@sihanchen7552]

@@AlphaSorceror What happens if he doesn't pay? His sister will be chased out of the house meh?

[@AlphaSorceror]

@@sihanchen7552 Legally, it is possible. Do you have private housing? If you have then you would understand. If he doesn’t pay, the 2 ministers can apply to the court to legally seize his local assets which includes his inheritance for settlement.

[@AlphaSorceror]

@@sihanchen7552​​⁠ Let me clarify further. Suppose you and your spouse co-own a private estate, and I sue you for something you didn’t do. If you fail to show up in court to defend yourself, I win through default judgment. In my lawsuit, I would typically specify the amount I’m claiming. If you don’t defend yourself, you automatically lose. Even if you co-own the property with your spouse, I can legally force the sale of the estate to satisfy the claim. While your spouse would receive her share, I would be entitled to collect yours. Do you see now how, if you don’t pay me, the sale could force your spouse out of the property due to your loss? In essence, it’s the sale of your share of the property to recover my claim. If your spouse can afford to buy your share, that’s great. Otherwise, she risks being forced out. Similarly, the ministers can sell their claim against LHY to the state or any buyer willing to pay the amount by purchasing LHY’s share.

[@a.p.selvampanneer8789]

After summon money 💰 goes to charity why not (lsy) pay to president star charity which is coming ahead, to directly inflate the ceiling donatable amount with direct transaction to charity instead of paying to (bk) n (s) n later back to charity.

[@mypetscatsandfishes4535]

If you can't even manage your family brothers and sisters in harmony, how to manage SG?!

[@Paul-H-Wolfram6608]

That was why he step down. 😁

[@Hs5687]

Ironically, LKY had the audacity to Play God with other Families… KARMA ❤😊

[@ongtayjoojames-ow1bs]

Precisely my thoughts too...!!!🙄😬🤨

[@ongtayjoojames-ow1bs]

​@@Paul-H-Wolfram6608Yuppp...!!!☝️🫵

[@elsieyong703]

See what happens to his children now?? LHY n family n his sister are suffering 3:31 suffering. suffering!..​@Hs5687

[@estherestherting987]

Pay out so much money. A hole in the pocket.

[@limtk55]

Let's see, if the black and white chalets costs 30k to rent, paying 600k will effectively give them 20 months of free rental. Astute.

[@raymondwan-k4w]

pap used the courts 2 silence critics....lhy has the right 2 free speech....

[@AlphaSorceror]

That right to “free speech” in Singapore must still follow Singapore laws. Those rights may be not be the same in UK compared to SGP.

[@edwinpoon]

No such thing as Free Speech la, say bird talker.

[@jennieloh6312]

Is easier to rule a country than own your siblings at home.

[@LonganLee]

@@jennieloh6312 union members call each other brothers and sisters. English is ambiguous , proven here again. It's not literally true brothers and sisters. It's a figure of speech, thus English is art is ambiguous

[@elsieyong703]

Received sinful money. God is watching..

[@Hs5687]

Hello TOC … Why remove my Comments?

[@Hs5687]

The Reason why We hardly hear of SG Scandals is bcz most are Covered- Up , Only Selected Ones are made Public thru their notoriously Controlled & Obedient Mainstream Media .Also SG is heavily invested in Cyber Surveillance .They Plant Honey Pots & lie in wait to Identify Threats or Pad Answers etc .sometimes if Lucky, They Can even Control Your Phone…Think You get the idea …😊

[@AlphaSorceror]

You don’t make sense. You spout bias.

[@ttkoh123]

Many People didn't know that their comments are being blocked from being "seen" by other readers. They can read their own comment BUT others cannot see it. Ask Why? Vote to Restore Free Expression. Vote for Change.

[@Hs5687]

Welcome to Digital Feudalism 😊

[@MichaelLim0907]

So TOC practice censorship just like everyoneelse. If they are presenting a bias view they deserve to be shut down

[@yumekogenshin1687]

I honestly do not believe Shanmugam and Vivian will seize 38 oxley road. It’s political suicide.

[@LonganLee]

Karma only can be effected by the voters. Likewise , democracy

[@temasek65]

OMG thats the life savings of a dozen common men! Hope the sum can be donated to the needy 😮.

[@RajooPalaniappan]

So black and white SHANMUGAM and balakrisnan can have proper meal wit LKY son money and can help goh Jin hian he looking for 196 million

[@AlphaSorceror]

GJH can just bankrupt himself to not pay then pay his Official Assignee to get out of bankruptcy. It isn’t that problematic if his assets are already held by his spouse or by a trust. It’s the cheapest way to get out of the 196m.

[@RajooPalaniappan]

@@AlphaSorceror but still must go to jail he was the mastermind in this scandle

[@AlphaSorceror]

@@RajooPalaniappan I believe they’ve already taken that into account. The person who pleaded guilty to market manipulation received only 12 weeks, while financial crimes like misappropriation usually result in 3 to 7 years. It seems they’ve set a ceiling for GJH’s sentence, likely using the earlier guilty plea as a benchmark-perhaps just 3 to 4 times longer. That’s probably the extent of it. It’s puzzling, though, that market manipulation on such a large scale would be punished less severely than misappropriation on a much smaller scale.

[@theresapangkc3190]

🙏🙏 for LKY family Pity 🙏🙏 LWL in her illnesses Met her yesterday RIP….

[@EyumaLin]

can kinda see why lky wanted that building demolished

[@davidhkchng]

Good brother

[@Whatisnottaken]

Why should two ministers pursue the defamation case in the U.K? Instead of defending himself right here in Singapore, he fled because couldn’t back up his allegations. Why if moves to the U.S tomorrow? Is he going to challenge the ministers to sue him there?

[@LonganLee]

LHY should ensure this is well spent

[@douglasang3527]

VTO PAP , THE BEST OPTION in GE2025 ! Only CHANGE in Government , Singapore Citizens will know the whole truths ! 😅

[@ongtayjoojames-ow1bs]

Agreed...!!!

[@bertchooky]

Opportunist...

[@steventan2550]

Vote for CHANGE and see the difference. Malaysia, the UK, ..........

[@nomanisanisland2109]

@@bertchookyAre you not one yourself???

[@ExitTwo888]

After 100 years , who is he and you and me ?

[@franciscody9622]

Another good reason to vote Opposition.

[@lamsunyong343]

for us, another good reason not to vote for the incompetent oppos

[@Hs5687]

No Different really… All Diff Cheeks of same PAP A&$e 😊

[@meganfoxbf]

​@Hs5687 - nobody forced you to vote

[@ongtayjoojames-ow1bs]

Agreed...!!!

[@LonganLee]

Put it this way, what is a system if full of or all comprising only like-minded people? What is typical behavior of a group of like-minded people to those who offer Alternative thinking , ideas or opinions? I am not alluding to bigotry but something else which I shall keep you in suspense thanks to the ambiguity in English allowing for oral masturbation

[@stevenheng3336]

So by paying, what he posted is incorrect?

[@AlphaSorceror]

Do you own any private asset in your name? If you do, it’s easier to understand why he paid.

[@ACTio-i4m]

He should come back, appear in court, and prove he's right, y pay??? he got no family home in Singapore already, if he's worried abt his sister, what does she hv to do with his case???

[@Buttercookies0]

You are asking him to enter the lion's den. Are you sure you will come back if you are him???

[@ACTio-i4m]

I will if I have the proofs

[@Buttercookies0]

@@ACTio-i4m You are naive or pro-pap?

[@Hs5687]

LKY had Bad Habit of Land Grab , Looting & Plundering Ptys … it’s Funny Now LKY’s Own home might be Grabbed by State …KARMA 😂❤

[@ACTio-i4m]

@@Buttercookies0 u are pro-wp, bro? me 2

[@SpinalAVMSG]

Red Dot can’t escape the Vanguard good Brudder to take care of Wei Ling!

[@peterchew4018]

Brother & Sister no worries. Heaven is watching 365❤

[@kwokleongawyong1064]

With Dr Lee's death, this is beyond outrageous, all moral high ground had been forfeited. The timing is uncanny

[@franciscody9622]

His son did the same thing. He should have played hard ball with the two ministers.

[@ongtayjoojames-ow1bs]

Agreed...!!!

[@jimbaranresidence8]

Believe in karma, the cycle wil cast misfortune @those whose harm their luv1s....

[@Hs5687]

The Cycle has to start ard the time LKY Grabbed Power by throwing The Oppo in Jail & Won the Elections … Similar to Alimah’s Scandalous Uncontested PE17 … U see a Pattern? 😂😂😂 ..

[@Hs5687]

Believe Cycle Started in Lim Yew Hock’s time rdy … lucky our Government thot us Contact-Tracing rdy 😊

[@noelkwek]

Please do not demolish this monumental residential private property. It must be left for future generations of interested Singaporeans to enter as registered visitors through the National Heritage Board (NHB) / Singapore Tourism Board (STB) to discover artifacts of historical political value linking the founding leader and father, the former first PM of Singapore, the late Mr. Lee Kuan Yew who left behind his legacy of forming the ruling government, the People's Action Party (PAP).

[@nomanisanisland2109]

For what???

[@DavidLow-s7p]

U did good ,

[@LonganLee]

I hope to see LHY fund the Democracy movement by the same amount

[@Hs5687]

Lee Family Political Dynasty Over lah … There’s No Comback … SG rdy seen how Lee Siblings Recklessly tarnished LKY’s Legacy…Which nut case You know will put Own Personal Family Problems publicly in Parliament , But Our Genius 2 Rtd BG Siblings did it ? 😂🎉❤ …

[@JacksonWong-pw4zq]

Snakemugum $88 million property plus other assets would be ???

[@ongchinlam4631]

Let me say. Singapore is heading for big trouble. Okay

[@bertchooky]

Then it's time for you to consider migrating..

[@nomanisanisland2109]

@@bertchookyWhy! Cannot give feedback meh???

[@RajooPalaniappan]

All 38 oxley road and 2 black and white banglow were debate in parliament without lee hsien yang own self argue own self own decisions good system

[@Hs5687]

Same System Not Only also Redefined Race but also Changed DNA of Living Adult Indian to Malay … to Suit Outcome of Scandalous Uncontested 2017 Presidential Elections 😂🎉❤

[@NoName-qh8rv]

I don't trust both lees and their party. Pui....!

[@Hs5687]

Not even 1 LKY Trusted General even Bothered to Intervene to Rescue LKY’s Reckless Kids in Lee Family Circus & again When Sitting PM has to helplessly watch Subordinates Sue Sibling … Believe Writing rdy on Wall … End of Lee Family Political Dynasty… 😊

[@benbow7998]

The ligitants must remember blood is thicker than comradeship,

[@factaky]

You must remember a thick wad of money is thicker than blood.

[@marcuschonglanceanderson2390]

@@factaky Truth.

[@elsieyong703]

Some people n blood related people can have the nerve to watch LHY being destroyed by those opponents....That hundreds of thousands of dollars 💸 shouldn't be spent... sinful money....obtained forcefully.

[@ericsim5791]

No

[@marinekong235]

sup sup soi lah - the price of a cheap Maserati

[@anghockseng5686]

Retire

[@nomanisanisland2109]

For what? Brain still working right?

[@dennylindianyan8123]

Huh? How is a defamation suit linked to protecting family home? Something wrong with this title.

[@meganfoxbf]

why LHY cannot get a better lawyer in the world.

[@AlphaSorceror]

@@dennylindianyan8123 It is linked. If he does not pay up to the default judgment, his assets in Singapore can be seized for settlements. If he owns public housing, this cannot be done but if he owns private housing, the 2 ministers can apply via the courts to freeze his assets in Singapore for sale.

[@AlphaSorceror]

@@meganfoxbf it was already default judgement that he lost in Singapore because he didn’t hire any lawyer to help him defend the case in Singapore.

[@meganfoxbf]

@AlphaSorceror - he did not get a lawyer to fight for him now he blame others for his own fault ? smart son of LKY. without world class lawyer how do you know is default judgement ? no need proof and no need to be responsible of what you say ( freedom of speech)

[@AlphaSorceror]

@@meganfoxbf Have you ever sue another person or been sued before? I guess you haven’t because of what you wrote. It’s true that it requires proof. However, if you don’t turn up in court to defend yourself then proof is not needed. The person suing you automatically wins which is what happened to LHY. He lost by default. No proof required because none is needed if he doesn’t even bother to defend himself.

[@BelachanFluffy]

I dont think he is wise in his words In e end who wins ?when r these clowns n e likes of him gonna learn

[@mjoswong1947]

Pay for ur mistake dun add the question how we are not interested . It is not as though u have only that house to sell . So dun make story

[@louischen2109]

Another internal dispute resolved. Great. Please stay peaceful after this. We have other more important issues to focus and handle, which is more beneficial to the public. Please gentlemen restraint yourself in these kind of fictions. We are tired on such matters more on personal matters, when many national issues, which require the national resources to be confined to a better causes.

[@HG-kn3hb]

Don't have to pay as long as one keep the mouth shut. What a waste of money.

[@AlphaSorceror]

He’s correct. If he doesn’t pay, they can seize his local asset which includes his inheritance. -- Let me clarify further. Suppose you and your spouse co-own a private estate, and I sue you for something you didn’t do. If you fail to show up in court to defend yourself, I win through default judgment. In my lawsuit, I would typically specify the amount I’m claiming. If you don’t defend yourself, you automatically lose. Even if you co-own the property with your spouse, I can legally force the sale of the estate to satisfy the claim. While your spouse would receive her share, I would be entitled to collect yours. Do you see now how, if you don’t pay me, the sale could force your spouse out of the property due to your loss? In essence, it’s the sale of your share of the property to recover my claim. If your spouse can afford to buy your share, that’s great. Otherwise, she risks being forced out. Similarly, the ministers can sell their claim against LHY to the state or any buyer willing to pay the amount by purchasing LHY’s share.

[@sihanchen7552]

Seize ler then what? Its not like they will do anything to the house will they?

[@AlphaSorceror]

@@sihanchen7552 Yes, they can. Have you sued anyone before? I have. When LHY didn’t contest the charges brought by the two ministers, he lost the defamation case through what is known as a default judgment, as he chose not to mount a defense. Following that loss, the defendant becomes subject to a financial claim. The plaintiff, or the person suing, has the legal right to apply to the courts to seize the defendant’s assets to satisfy the claim. This right is afforded to plaintiffs by law, allowing them to seize and dispose of the assets, regardless of the defendant’s status. It’s a fundamental right creditors have.

[@sihanchen7552]

@@AlphaSorceror Wow, thanks for the blatantly apparent & conspicuous explanation, Captain Obvious ~~~ What I mean is, the ministers wun dare to do any physical changes to the house, would they?

[@AlphaSorceror]

@@sihanchen7552 Let me clarify further. Suppose you and your spouse co-own a private estate, and I sue you for something you didn’t do. If you fail to show up in court to defend yourself, I win through default judgment. In my lawsuit, I would typically specify the amount I’m claiming. If you don’t defend yourself, you automatically lose. Even if you co-own the property with your spouse, I can legally force the sale of the estate to satisfy the claim. While your spouse would receive her share, I would be entitled to collect yours. Do you see now how, if you don’t pay me, the sale could force your spouse out of the property due to your loss?

[@AlphaSorceror]

@@sihanchen7552 In essence, it’s the sale of your share of the property to recover my claim. If your spouse can afford to buy your share, that’s great. Otherwise, she risks being forced out. Similarly, the ministers can sell their claim against LHY to the state or any buyer willing to pay the amount by purchasing LHY’s share.

[@meganfoxbf]

why LHY cannot get a better lawyer ?

[@Hs5687]

Bcz he’s very“Bright” to hv chosen to Destroy Own Parents Legacy Publicly… SG Not Dumb or Naive … They’ve seen True Colours of the Lee Siblings 😊

[@wks2291]

there are some cases in Singapore no lawyer, not even god can win one

[@baoling2936]

李光耀的屋子自从他死到现在请问政府多少年了怎么一直在讲一直在讲😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅你讲一年两年我们还可以说十年都要来了一直讲一直讲一直讲😅😅

[@cecacecaratssteal1395]

May calamity strike this country of betrayal

[@nomanisanisland2109]

So evil. Pray it doesn’t bounce back to you. What betrayal? Please elaborate.

[@skylinengng9140]

Fake news 😅😅😅😅

[@jollyjolly5633]

If its not in local new😂😅 it's fake news.

[@Hs5687]

Honey Pot .. 😊

[@patricks2022]

It's not fake news, you are ignorant!

[@nomanisanisland2109]

Yeah. As fake as you!

[@davidng8143]

What is there to protect . A coward just making noises for a charade .

[@yamanhnguyet9382]

$600k is peanuts to him. All of the Lees are super duper rich. Just a tiny drop into the ocean.

[@muralikrishnan4104]

Say wrong pay more.

[@lamsunyong343]

so he acknowledge that he had defame the two ministers, a disgrace to the nation

[@elsieyong703]

He shouldn't have paid😢😢😢 them..

[@HUAHUA1]

@@elsieyong703 talk easy... sure there is a reason behind...