Lily Potter's SECRET Letter to Sirius Black - Harry Potter Explained

Hey everyone,
Welcome to another installment of Harry Potter Theory. In today’s video, we’re going to be discussing Harry Potter’s mother, Lily, and Harry’s godfather, Sirius Black. More specifically, we’re going to be taking a look at a secret letter that Lily wrote to Sirius in the year 1981- shortly after Harry Potter was born.
Harry Potter was of course born to parents James Potter and Lily Evans. The story of their love was an interesting one, as when they first met Lily wasn’t too impressed by James. Lily had grown up in the town of Cokeworth, and spent much of her youth with her childhood companion Severus Snape, who grew up in nearby Spinner’s End. When Lily and Snape began attending Hogwarts, James Potter was horrible to Snape- which negatively skewed Lily’s perception of James. However, when Snape eventually began to go down a very dark and troubled path- a path involving dark magic and terrible people, things changed. One day, while Snape was being bullied by James, Lily intervened. The embarrassed Snape then lashed out at Lily- calling her a ‘filthy mudblood’- this effectively ended their relationship.
While James was at school he was a part of a quartet of boys that called themselves The Marauders. The boys began their studies in 1971, the same year as Severus Snape, and they all had one thing in common - they were all Gryffindors. Before the sorting ceremony even happened the boys hit it off, and when they were eventually sorted in to the same house, they knew that they were destined to be friends. Though the boys got on with many of their other classmates, this particular group of 4 boys had a truly special bond. This group was comprised of James Potter, Remus Lupin, Peter Pettigrew, and the subject of this video: Sirius Black.
Sirius was a great friend to the Potters- so much so that he was chosen to be the godfather of Harry Potter. Sirius hailed from the powerful wizarding family, The Blacks- and while many of his family members placed an unreasonable amount of value on blood purity, Sirius did not share this same belief. Many of the members of the black family went down a very dark path- but Sirius was able to choose his own path. After graduating, Sirius, along with the other Marauders, went on to join the Order of the Phoenix. The purpose of the order was to oppose Voldemort and the Death Eaters. However, it turned out that not all members of the Order were good-as Sirius’ old friend, Peter Pettigrew, would go on to frame Sirius for a heinous crime.
In 1981, just 1 day after the Potters were murdered- Peter Pettigrew murdered 12 muggles using a dark and powerful blasting curse. Someway, somehow, Sirius Black was blamed, and was promptly sent to Azkaban. After being banished to Azkaban, seemingly the whole world turned on Sirius, and he was left there to rot for an astonishing 12 years. That was the 1st of November 1981.
However, just a few months before everything exploded, Sirius Black received a letter from none other than Lily Potter. This is what that letter said....
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @harrypottertheory
Please LIKE / SUBSCRIBE / SHARE to support the channel
Leave your video ideas down below!
Thanks!
Instagram - / hptheory
Star Wars Channel - / starwarstheory
Music by:
Juan Naranjo
Jacob A. Cadmus
Samuel Kim
All content falls under fair use: any copying of copyrighted material done for a limited and “transformative” purpose, such as to comment upon, criticize, or parody a copyrighted work. Such uses can be done without permission from the copyright owner.

[@HarryPotterTheory]

Thanks for watching guys! If you enjoy the content, please consider liking/subscribing to support the channel

[@elysiajoseph7807]

Peter Pettigrew was such a weak traitor it's hard to believe he is the strongest since he could kill so many muggles at one shot

[@pratt_and_whitney_f119]

Harry Potter theory when will you make the video on the most intelligent harry potter characters please reply I am asking for 3 videos 😭

[@pratt_and_whitney_f119]

Please reply harry potter theory please 😭

[@POTTERS_HOME]

Video idea:- what would happen if harry managed to kill Peter petigrew (wormtail) in prisoner of azkaban. Video idea:- what if Harry wasn't a horcrux

[@POTTERS_HOME]

@@torny841 I dunno

[@williamreed7267]

I appreciate the examination of this letter. It's heartbreaking to realize Lilly, James, and Harry were such a hopeful family in such a dark time. How destroyed Sirius must have felt when he was seen as the person who betrayed the Potters. Thank you so much for your time/thought

[@Taya-fq9bi]

Stop everyone stop I am crying 😭

[@nuzeee_k]

Harry potter theory is a part if my daily life 😂😂

[@venessapiutti3199]

Same

[@katana7186]

@Ultimate Information stop self promoting

[@nuzeee_k]

@Pizzanator I'm not a star wars fan

[@markhenry9112]

Same

[@theROOOOK2662]

same

[@sh1xk356]

Man I cry every time whenever I watch or hear about the friendship of marauders and the death of the potters due to pettigrew

[@arc4751]

@Ultimate Information yeah I know like such a good video *cough*not*cough* stop scamming ya stupid bot

[@nola3963]

And to realize all 4 friends were killed because of Voldemort 💔

[@juliie007]

I avoid rereading Lily and James Potter stories coz it’s so tragic how they died betrayed by a friend and their best friend takes the rap and is sent to prison for 12 yrs only to die protecting Harry two years later😢.

[@mercuriology45]

Lily being 22 when she died makes me feel really sad

[@jacobeirikson6999]

@Ultimate Information stop spamming and self-promoting. Your vid isn’t even funny.

[@laurensvanderveer8367]

Oh shit since when am i older Then Lily Potter

[@Alt-yg5ng]

I thought she was 21?

[@hssenpai16]

Apparently During the events of the Deathly Hallows, when Harry's parents, Sirius and Lupin appeared out of Resurrection Stone, Harry was around 4-5 years younger than his parents

[@mercuriology45]

@@Alt-yg5ng omg i dont remember but she was between 21-22 still sad :(

[@hidingtk2860]

When I came across this note in the books (not sure was it in the movie) I thought it was very nicely done by JKR. Brilliant in fact. It leads to so many stories like: the beginning of Peter's betrayal, Batilda's story of Dumbledore's past wit Grendelwald, Black's closeness to Harry and more. Brilliant pen stroke by JKR...Great video guys!

[@rishithkumar8523]

It was the confirmation of Dumbledore's past with Grindelwald and that Bathilda really knew the Dumbledores. Dumbledore and Grindelwald's history started in the middle of DH. The last part was revealed in Snape's memories.

[@marynalchadzian6135]

@@rishithkumar8523 can you go in more detail about it??

[@rishithkumar8523]

@@marynalchadzian6135 what details do you want?

[@LastMemoriesMusic]

‘And next, Snape was kneeling in Sirius's old bedroom. Tears were dripping from the end of his hooked nose as he read the old letter from Lily. The second page carried only a few words: could ever have been friends with Gellert Grindelwald. I think her mind's going, personally! Lots of love, Lily Snape took the page bearing Lily's signature, and her love, and tucked it inside his robes.’

[@AndersWatches]

I think I cried when I first read that letter. The existence of toy brooms is adorable, and even more so that Sirius got baby Harry one. So sad to think of the loving family Harry should have had.

[@forn8473]

"As long as the Secret-Keeper refused to speak, You-Know-Who could search the village where Lily and James were staying for years and never find them, not even if he had his nose pressed against their sitting room window!" So that's why Voldemort got rid of his nose, to be able to press his entire face against the window.

[@supersayainshinobi1910]

Either that or he didn't want Harry sticking a wand up his nose like he was a troll in a girls bathroom 🤔🤔🤔

[@mayankyadav2099]

Lol

[@stef2090]

lmao

[@Lina321_]

I recently knew Lupin was not trusted during the first war because he was a werewolf. So he was kinda excluded from the plan, which means that he lost four of his closest friends, Lily, James, Sirius and Peter, in just one night without knowing any truth. I feel really sad about this.

[@anjum3847]

He knew that Sirius was made the secret keeper, but not when they switched it with Peter. Even Dumbledore didn't knew that part

[@limiv5272]

It wasn't because he was a werewolf, everyone knew what he was for years and nobody cared. The books never specify how he came to be suspected, but I always thought Wormtail planted some evidence against him.

[@ricardoquintero8502]

Yes, it was found by Harry in Sirius's room in Number 12 Grimmauld Place while they lived there after the wedding of Fleur and Bill, we know after that Snape took the picture with Lily in it and left the one with Harry zooming on the broom. That was a touching part to read, actually...

[@MaikeruO]

Touching?, How tf is that "touching", Snivellus literally torned and stole the picture of the Potter family and stole the part of the letter where it said "Lots of love, Lily", so he could imagine that it was for him. How do you find that touching?, that's disturbingly awful.

[@Jonathan-A.C.]

@@MaikeruO Because he cares so deeply about Lily, and later on, about Harry. His care for Lily, and actions resulting from that, are part of his entire character, and the specific example here adds to what is shown in his memories

[@billyt.7306]

6:46 is when Sirius roasted that man to ashes 😂

[@desislavaandreeva4359]

I remember Snape found it along with the picture of Lily, James, and baby Harry and kept that part where Lily is...so much pain at that moment! I`m sure Snape has dreamt of being in James's place his whole life...

[@cjg8763]

About the prophecy, it is interesting to think that if Snape hadn't been standing there listening, and only heard what he did and no more, the prophecy wouldn't have been fulfilled.

[@Jonathan-A.C.]

I mean that's kind of the way time travel and prophecies work in HP. You literally *fulfill* them in order for them to work, as it's more just the way the entire time stream flows out

[@Microspectrophotometer]

6:04 His.. what?

[@MiepMiep14]

HA😂

[@angelluna13666]

I always learn new things when listening to your videos. And I love it! I love learning new things about the franchise that was/is my youth. Keeps it alive. Thank you so much for all your amazing theory videos ♥️

[@cookiemonster6468]

I love the way you narrate your videos, thank you for making them

[@bookworm7076]

So cool that I'm here early! A touching video, Harry Potter Theory. Great work!

[@HarryPotterTheory]

Thanks for watching!

[@silentprincess6478]

I started reading Philosophers stone for the first time today. I’m enjoying it so far :D

[@atab6555]

You have wacthed the mocies right?

[@silentprincess6478]

@@atab6555 movies? Yes I have

[@desislavaandreeva4359]

@@silentprincess6478 books are much more enjoyable :)

[@mrsdixon3524]

Why the heck didn't Nevilles parents go into hiding also...

[@Dave2801epic]

Snape told dumbledore he took it as the potters

[@mrsdixon3524]

@@Dave2801epic You'd think they'd still be cautious though as a precaution..

[@armelle4295]

@@mrsdixon3524 they did went into hiding and used the fidelius charms as well but when the potters died and Voldemort disappeared, they thought the threat was over and thats why they came out of hiding and bellatrix and co was able to find nevilles parents and torture them

[@Danversdiary]

I don't think the Order realised that their son was also a target because Harry was born on the 31st where Neville wasn't so it wasn't to them as obvious I guess

[@Chess_Master60]

I'm starting my channel trying to learn some HP history thanks for your hard work and always making me smile

[@AnaxErik4ever]

This was one of my favorite bits of Deathly Hallows, proving once and for all that Dumbledore WAS NOT the infallible, all good, grandfather figure we saw for most of the books. Same from the testimony from Aberforth and anything about Gellert Grindelwald included in the Deathly Hallows.

[@fxlcon2647]

Video Ideas (will come back and edit if I think of more): - How were the Death Eaters able to apperate/disapperate within Hogwarts during Deathly Hallows? - What Harry's thoughts and feelings were towards Snape after the Deathly Hallows? - Are Paintings almost like a spirit or a ghost of their former self or just a picture that has been bewitched to act like themselves? (Asking this because in Deathly Hallows and Cursed Child Harry speaks with the Dumbledore painting and it feels like he is talking to the real Dumbledore) - What happens when a witch/wizard dies? - Why didn't the Death Eaters use Avada Kedavra in every fight instead of duelling? (Spell can't be blocked so seems logical from a Death Eaters standpoint to always use the spell) - Why didn't Umbridge use Imperio when interrogating harry in The Order Of The Phoenix? (She already expressed that she is comfortable with using Unforgivable curses so wouldn't it be logical and a lot less messy then Crucio) - Why did McGonagall decide to send all Slytherins to the dungeons? (Surely she knew that a battle was to soon break out as the weren't handing over Harry so why would she keep students locked up and in harms way) - What happened to Voldemort's wand after he was defeated both 1st and 2nd times? - Could wizards/witches become as trained and powerful in wandless magic as they were with a wand? - Is the killing curse effective against all living beings? (Does it work with dementors, giants, spiders etc.) - What were the other Ministries doing when Voldemort was at the height of his power? (could be 1st or 2nd wizarding war) - Why was Merlin the most powerful wizard? Apologies if you've made videos on these points in the past, just a few ideas I had in case you hadn't

[@AlyssMa7rin]

Harry has had training to resist the Imperious curse, thanks to Barty Crouch Jr. Plus, the Imperious curse requires calm, whereas crucio requires rage

[@crystalgammon3761]

I follow very few of my subscriptions closely. I never miss an upload from Harry Potter Theory.

[@juliannabeesley4230]

what did it mean when lupin said to harry "Lilly was there for me at one of my darkest times" (can't remember the exact words lol) what was Lillys and lupins history?

[@juliannabeesley4230]

@Oof Oooof69 ty!!! that makes sense

[@amandajones9370]

I think she also made the wolfsbane potion for him during and after school as snape did in POA. She was very good at potions and I’m sure she would want to make it for him after she learned he was a werewolf. That’s just the first thing I thought of when he said that line.

[@chromeshellking]

@@amandajones9370 Couldnt have, Wolfsbane was a later discovery. I think meaning Lily didnt reject lupin for being a werewolf and the stigma that went with it.

[@madspriphansen1365]

Amazing video, this channel deserves more than 200k subs

[@miguelmoreno6175]

this channel opens things up that I didn't even know I needed to be, but I do

[@rayblair3933]

Love the background music

[@lainie5590]

And I watch your videos as soon as they come out

[@sebj7]

Another great hp vid!

[@carloserivera1058]

Thank you for this video fr, I love the whole world of Harry Potter so much🖤⚡️brings me happiness 💯🪄

[@Dragonlove3]

Great job

[@airchunk2621]

I do not remember the letter honestly as the last time I read the books was probably in 2008...this channel is reigniting my love for hp, keep up the good work! Would be nice to see a mini series of the prophecy making the potters go into hiding and pettigrew ratting on them!

[@hollyerorabaugh4406]

This is an amazing find while searching youtube! New sub

[@lainie5590]

I really like this channel.

[@Xavier-hc6qs]

I LOVE THESE VIDEOS

[@MrsIsabelLau]

VIDEO IDEA: YOU MAY NEVR READ THIS, BUT COULD YOU TRY AND EXPLAIN WHAT THE 'HOT WHIP LIKE CURSE' WAS THAT HERMOINE GOT HIT WITH IN THE ORDER OF THE PHEONIX AT THE MINISTRY AND HARRY GOT HIT BY SNAPE SHORTLY AFTER DUMBLEDORES DEATH. HOPE YOU DO THIS BECAUSE IVE BEEN WONDERING WHAT IT WAS FOR A WHILE..

[@jennapflug8330]

It was a compression curse or a crushing curse.

[@MinistryOfMagic_DoM]

Uh.... He beat you to it homie. He was wrong anyway.

[@indiacretermc718]

Very awesome channel I subscribed almost like a month ago and watched almost 14 videos

[@amirhosseinvahdati4968]

love ur videos .can u explain whats the difference between dark magic and regular magic?

[@tylersmith9465]

Great job 👍

[@anasahmed4253]

Can you make a video about how Ron’s mum interrupted sirus when he was talking about a secret weapon in the order of the Phoenix .

[@movieedits6845]

OMG yesss this one is one of my fav

[@blessingxhakaza5439]

I love this channel 🙏

[@JuanMataCFC]

good video, but u should've included how Harry found two parts of the letter separately, and what made of the first part when he found it. :)

[@thephilmeister5918]

One of Great Legends Of Theory’s

[@lowe6996]

good video i found it really intresting

[@scottpetersen6209]

I always get chills when i hear the quote from sirius at 6:45

[@abintomy5176]

Very interesting❤️

[@Rymar101]

Pettigrew was definitely the wrong choice for Secret Keeper

[@Bitter.nemesis..]

You are dead pettigrew

[@Artura4_]

I have always wonder why James and lily couldn’t be their own secret keeper.

[@ethanquirk28]

Or at least make Dumbledore the secret keeper. If you want one person to know where you are, one person to be able to find and help you if you need it, on person that could stand up to any attempt Voldemort could make to force them out of hiding, it would be Dumbledore

[@RichMoneyLTD]

Dumbledore offered to...

[@Atomistry]

300k let’s goooo

[@azenboi5315]

Been subbing since like 20 k...

[@azenboi5315]

Weird flex ik

[@gacha_moonlight4090]

Can you please do a video on what will Sirius black boggart be I enjoy your vidoes

[@mochigurl]

when the video says voldemort's NOSE pressed against their sitting room window, I really didnt know if he still had a nose at the time...

[@wackboatxxx2348]

Can you do a video about all the horcruxes and especially why voldemort chose them (and why he didn't just chose a random grain of sand or something like it)

[@swaggeditz5315]

Harry potter folklore and movie flame did that kind of video

[@cjg8763]

I wonder who the 5th boy in the marauders' dormitory was. Hopefully someone who just prefers to keep to himself or he'd probably feel very left out. Wonder if he noticed being the only one in the dorm on many nights or just slept through their absence unaware every time haha.

[@monicabowen6204]

I literally sleep to these videos 🤣

[@tylersmith9465]

So emotional 😭

[@Danversdiary]

Video idea: may you please explain how the Secret Keeper works? I don't fully understand it, it sort of confuses me

[@tylersmith9465]

Awesome 🤩 😎 👏🏿

[@tylersmith9465]

Great 😌 😊 👍

[@benchristianb.agonia2276]

"Ouch"

[@eee5448]

Maybe you could do a ranking video of the most powerful Headmasters of Hogwarts

[@Jojoairlines]

“Ouch.” 😂😂😂😂😂

[@virien13]

Rereading Harry Potter books is amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@m.i.n.a]

Yes it is! And every time I read the first few sentences I fall straight into the HP universe. It's like coming home. Since 1999, when I was 9 😊

[@davidcarney1533]

Wait a sec. If the Potters got any visitors, then Wormtail had to tell them. Bathilda would have known Sirius was not secret keeper and so would Dumbledore

[@anntecz]

OH MY GOD. You're right!! J.K. Rowling definitely missed that part... and so that means Dumbledore knew Sirius was innocent and wanted him to be kept in Azkaban.... Oh but wait, she could've read the address from a piece of paper just like Harry did in OTP and therefore not have known that Wormtail was the secret keeper because she didn't whose hanwriting that was. And the Potters didn't tell her that it was Wormtails because they wanted everyone to believe Sirius was the secret keeper?

[@davidcarney1533]

@@anntecz Very good point

[@emeriemallard3100]

I love these harry poter theory

[@leahluostarinen]

It's potter

[@emeriemallard3100]

@@leahluostarinen oops yeah. Ha ha.trust me I am a serious harry potter fan.

[@lukedarren5452]

Harry Potter folklore is a part of my life now

[@Daniel-sb3gv]

I read the part of the letter almost 1000 times and trying to understand what’s the other part of the letter and now I finally now what’s the other part of the letter; and also where did you find the other part??

[@scottwhyley1699]

OK, so I have a question regarding this letter...... Would the fact that Lily mentions to Sirius in it that Bathilda visits regularly not be a HUGE red flag that they are hiding in Godrics Hollow? Plus would this not be a big plot hole as to the fact that no other person except the Secret Keeper should be aware of the hiding place location? I feel like this does lead to a few issues as everyone seemed to know that Bathilda lived in Godrics Hollow and that there would be absolutely no reason for her to visit them at all apart from living right next to them? Just doesn't add up to me but I'm sure there is a valid magical reason that could explain this away? Love your chanel and really enjoy all the work you do!

[@scottwhyley1699]

@Oof Oooof69 That doesn't make sense to me. The whole reason you have a secret keeper, especially in this part, is so that no one knows where they were hiding! If the secret keeper is the only one who can tell you where they are hiding, why would he have told Bathilda? And like I stated in my comment, everyone knew Bathilda as she was a famous historian and Grindlewalds Aunt and everyone knew where she lived, so if that letter was intercepted, how would the fact that Bathilda visits not lead them straight to Godrics Hollow? If you look at the rules of being a secret keeper, once the secret keeper tells you where they are, you become a secret keeper yourself and the secret dies, so no, not everyone can know where they are because in order for you to know where they are, you would have needed to be told which then means you yourself become a secret keeper. This obviously then just means that Bathilda now also becomes a secret keeper and even worse, Lily is basically telling Sirius and anyone else who reads that letter exactly who to find and torture for the information (Bathilda) and pretty much exactly where to find them (Godrics Hollow).

[@rameenac.m5909]

They could have made Remus lupin the secret keeper

[@nuzeee_k]

Sirius was doubting remus Cuz he's werewolf and voldy promised a better life for werewolves once he's in power of the ministry That's why sirius didn't let remus know that they swapped the secret keeper

[@rameenac.m5909]

@@nuzeee_k yes someone did a video on it in youtube

[@rameenac.m5909]

@Oof Oooof69 what mission

[@nuzeee_k]

@@rameenac.m5909 we don't know exactly what but he was probably up in North somewhere doing some work for the order. Maybe he was collecting some evidence about other werewolves. But I don't think that's why he wasn't chosen as the secret keeper, I think it's mainly bcuz he was a werewolf, when Dumbledore said the traitor was someone among them everyone thought it was remus, bcuz Peter appears to be dumb to do such a thing. And we can't blame sirius for suspecting remus Cuz all he cared was potter fam and potter fam only and in return remus suspected sirius was a murder The marauders' fate is so cruel

[@andrewrosansky3721]

Anybody have any theories as to why Lily or James were not their own secret keeper? I heard this criticism recently and I’m having a little trouble getting over it.

[@jbc9812]

I think it’s mainly because they needed to keep a connection with the order one way or another, maybe they needed a secret keeper because if they were their own secret keepers, there wouldn’t be a way for them to unhide (if that makes sense), but it’s just an idea though, I have always thought the same thing.

[@jadea2594]

Where do you find all this information about the marauders

[@lorthomas160]

Why didn’t they use the unbreakable vow so that wormtail wouldn’t tell of their whereabouts? Hmmmm.

[@KariSuttle]

No wait Albus DID know that Severus overheard! Aberforth caught him spying and brought him into the room. That's part of what just doesn't make sense about the whole situation....I've always wondered about the extent to which they were in hiding for Harry's birthday. Book 3 says they didn't put up the Fidelius until a week prior to the murders after someone (presumably Severus Snape) tipped them off that they were being targetted. Which explains why no one even considered the secret keepers would've been switched and why they felt safe - it'd only been a week. However, if they knew enough to be in hiding and avoiding going out already....its just confusing. Anyone who knew who they were could have their minds read or otherwise be interrogated. Like that old lady.

[@theb.i.gnotorious9127]

That's impossible no one could get their mind read and if they were interrogated they'd not be able to say a word even if they wanted, only, i repeat only the secret keeper could have handed 'em over and on purpose o' course

[@KariSuttle]

@@theb.i.gnotorious9127 I meant before the fidelius charm was applied. Harry wasn't even born when the prophecy was made, but he's 14 almost 15 months old when they go into hiding. I'm amazed it took that long for them to be put into hiding under the fidelius charm when Albus knew of the prophecy for a long time.

[@nicotaljaard9059]

Maybe more detail about everything Dumbledore did with the Cloak?

[@ryanb5066]

Does anyone know why they didn't see the last spell Sirius used during his duel with Peter Pettigrew. I would think that would have cleared his name? because I would assume the last spell Sirius cast during that duel wasn't a curse that killed all those muggles. Therefore clearing his name for their deaths.

[@joemerlin152]

He was guilty beyond doubt and didn't even get a trial. Had he gotten a trial I'm sure he would of been cleared.

[@junehorsch7041]

Where do you find these letters?

[@bradleythomas3]

I think the most interesting part of the letter is she mentions a Christmas gift from Petunia. Sort of reinforces that maybe Petunia did love her sister deep down. Even if it was a deliberately ugly gift, she could have just not sent anything. I wonder if they were closer than the books let on.

[@tylersmith9465]

Very interesting 🤔 🧐 🤨

[@sheep9546]

I feel bad for harry, but James and lily got there just karma especially lily

[@heatherL4834]

What did Lily do?

[@Sonmmmxuan]

Uhm even if James was a bully he deserves some reality check, not death. And Lily? what has she ever done? Not responding love from a death-eater

[@petaldraws6826]

@@Sonmmmxuan I think they mean good karma it’s the opposite of bad karma, when Voldemort died that was the good karma

[@petaldraws6826]

@@heatherL4834 She didn’t do anything what they meant was that she got her good karma when Voldemort died

[@heatherL4834]

@@petaldraws6826 Oh ok. Thanks for clearing that up

[@BLAZEgaming19790100]

Funny how the other kid born in July was nevil and voldi didn't even acknowledge the idea of him being the chosen one and was the one to kill nagini

[@jacenskywalker507]

The Potters wouldn't've been murdered if Dumbles hadn't taken (or rather, in my mind, stole) James's Invisibility Cloak which was a Potter Family heirloom and would've saved their lives that night; Dumbles had gotten off his ass and stopped Snivellus from escaping as surely the wizard who *'supposedly'* (I don't believe that he did any of that, just more lies from the Master Manipulator, chess master, and puppet master) beat Grindelwald should've been able to stop the Walking Talking Greaseball Death Eater, unless he wanted the prophecy to get out, have Lily and James murdered, Sirius imprisoned, and Harry abused and under his manipulation and control; and Dumbles had realized that no one is a perfect, Heavenly, angelic saint and deserves infinite second chances from him like he thinks he knows more and better than God Himself. The entire Harry Potter Wizarding World franchise (books and films) is all completely Dumbles's fault. He's at fault for all of the suffering, blood, murder, death, corruption, and violence of the Wizarding World and, when he could've done something to change it into something better, decided to sit on his ass, suck on his lemon drops, and think everything was all hunky-dory. Harry was an abused and neglected orphan of war because of him and I don't, for one second, believe that Harry wouldn't, realistically, hate the old man for everything that he did to his life, put him through, and made him suffer. Dumbles is the real villain of Harry Potter, the evil, black-hearted, Satanic monster who hurt and killed so many all for his sacred *"Greater Good"* bullshit. There's a special place in the ninth level of Hell for people like that. Here's more of what I think about him (continued in next comments):

[@jacenskywalker507]

Part 1: It's really sad that by the end of Book 7 we learned that Harry was no *"great wizard."* or really even a hero at all. He was just a naïve boy/teenager brainwashed and manipulated by Dumbles into suicide for a cause. It proved no different than any other child brainwashed and manipulated by religious extremists (almost always Islamic) into strapping explosives to themselves and blowing themselves up along with, *"the enemy."* After all, in those adults' minds, it too is for, *"the greater good."* I hope you'll excuse my extreme disgust with any adults using children in a war and knowingly setting them up to die. It's an ultimate evil to use a child like that, no matter what the cause or reasons may be, and it *DEFINITELY* makes Dumbles every bit as much a monster as Voldy. *OotP, Chapter 37, Dumbles to Harry:* *"Five years ago you arrived at Hogwarts, Harry, safe and whole, as I had planned and intended, well - not quite whole. You had suffered. I knew you would when I left you on your aunt's and uncle's doorstep. I knew I was condemning you to ten dark and difficult years."* *HBP, Chapter 3, Dumbles to the Dursleys:* *"He has known nothing but neglect and often cruelty at your hands."* *"The magic I evoked fifteen years ago means that Harry has powerful protection while he can still call this house 'home'. However miserable he has been here, however unwelcome, however badly treated, you have at least, grudgingly, allowed him houseroom."* What Dumbles did was no different than kidnapping an African-American infant and forcing the poor child onto a family of Ku Klux Klan supporters with a threat to provide the child a home. Harry received the same treatment you'd expect for that poor child assuming (s)he wasn't killed outright, don't you think? Sure, he survived, but as nothing more than a horribly abused slave of the Dursleys. It was stated clearly that Harry's abuse was physical as well as mental and emotional. There was mention of Petunia striking him over the head with a hot frying pan in the kitchen as well as Vernon's comment about nothing being impossible to *'beat'* out of the *"freak."* implying that beatings were common. Then of course they also encouraged Dudley's *'Harry Hunting'* and attacks on the *"freak."* Dumbles could've done something to ensure that Harry's childhood wasn't dark and difficult but instead chose not to and, in so doing, he proved that *'dark and difficult'* childhood was, in fact, precisely what he really wanted Harry to suffer through. The Wizarding World is full of spells and potions compelling particular behavior. It would've definitely been preferable and much happier for both Harry and the Dursleys if Dumbles had at the very least used a Compulsion Ward or Charm to ensure Harry was at least accepted, if not loved, by the Dursleys. After all, his living with them was deemed by Dumbles to be necessary regardless of them clearly not wanting Harry. Thus he proved, by forcing Harry upon them, that they lacked any real free-will in the matter; that what they wanted was unimportant, anyway, in the much greater need for Harry's safety. (Dumbles's Howler to Petunia, *"REMEMBER MY LAST!"* when the Dursleys were about to throw Harry out along with prior statements scattered throughout earlier books proved that Harry's residence with the Dursleys was coerced upon the Dursleys in some way by Dumbles). So why then didn't he take the added step to ensure Harry grew up well, since the Dursleys' free-will didn't matter to him anyway? In fact, his coercion absolutely ensured the Dursleys would take out their resentment and hatred upon Harry. It was abundantly clear that he fully intended Harry's suffering through an abusive and enslaved childhood because he needed the boy (and prophesied weapon) meek, weak, and fully obedient to easy control by adults. After all, Dumbles fully admits that he knowingly subjected Harry to more than a decade of abuse and enslavement by his relatives with no such effort to ensure Harry's well-being. Is it any wonder that Harry trashed the old bastard's office afterwards (and I don't blame him)? It might be confusing to some, how later, Harry did a 180 and was again *"Dumbles's man"* despite the evil Dumbles knowingly inflicted upon him. But all that was needed to fully regain and seal Harry's loyalty was Dumbles paralyzing and forcing Harry into watching the old bastard intentionally martyr himself. He was dying already, but was careful not to tell Harry that. He made Harry believe that he sacrificed himself to protect Harry and thus forever sealed Harry's zealous loyalty. It's a tactic called *"martyrdom"* and it's been used to seal complete and zealous loyalty to a cause or person very successfully for more than a thousand years by cultists and also historically by Islamists. It was also the very fate he had planned for Harry - to die as a martyr. I strongly encourage everyone to read up on the subjects of brainwashing children, the effects of neglect and abuse on a child's personality, and also children brought up in cults with figures and followings (such as Dumbles was in the Wizarding World). Only then could you truly understand how horrific of a monster Dumbles really was in not only what he did to Harry, but also how he used his position as Headmaster of the premier wizarding school in Britain to ensure generations of children's (and later adults') awe of him and belief in his apparent goodness and infallibility. That belief allowed him to do virtually whatever he wanted under the Sun (ignoring laws at whim and even enslaving the infant hero of the Wizarding World to hateful and abusive Muggles) with little or no question from anyone. The only one who would've questioned Harry's placement was conveniently thrown in prison without a trial by Crouch Senior of the DMLE and Bagnold of the Ministry, with the *ASSISTANCE* of Dumbles as the Chief Warlock. He admitted that he gave the DMLE, *"evidence that Sirius Black was the Potter's Secret-Keeper."* to ensure Sirius was sent to Azkaban. This is interesting since any such evidence would have to've been fabricated or exaggerated by Dumbles since, not only was Sirius NOT the Secret-Keeper, but according to the canon, Dumbles himself actually cast the charm to *'hide'* the Potters. It was later revealed that it was the *'Fidelius Charm'* that hid the Potters, so Dumbles would've most definitely known who was the real Secret-Keeper. It's a very stupid and very corrupt judge that sends people off to life-imprisonment and torture (Dementors are torture) without a trial. It was awfully convenient that the *ONLY* suspected Death Eater that was mentioned to've been sent to Azkaban without a trial just so happened to be the legal guardian of Harry Potter and Dumbles's only obstacle to control of the prophesied weapon. Especially when known and confirmed Death Eaters walked away free and were cleared without effort by Dumbles to ensure justice for them either. Also, particularly take note of the effect and effectiveness of isolating a child that's been exposed to extreme trauma - limiting their access only to an environment of people who hate and abuse them with the sole outside *"friendly"* contact and source of information being the one person who wants to control them. He ordered Hermione to cut off all contact for *"security"* reasons but there was *NO* reason whatsoever Hermione couldn't've remained in contact via phone or Muggle mail or that the Order guards couldn't've passed messages on for him at Grimmauld Place - *EXCEPT* that it would've given Harry other people he could trust and rely upon in his time of need. Dumbles couldn't have that. He needed complete control over Harry and so he blocked Harry from *ALL* other outside *"friendly"* influence except his own when Harry needed Hermione most in order to keep Harry dependent on him. In essence all of this proved Dumbles to be much like a Wizarding World equivalent of Charles Manson (a complete f*cking nutjob, if you ask me) or perhaps closer to being like Jim Jones (another complete f*cking nutjob) with a touch of mafia behavior in ensuring obstacles to his plans are *"out of the way."* The sole difference being that instead of getting his followers to murder for him like Charles Manson and Voldy had done, Dumbles instead got them to die for him and his cause like Jim Jones. Harry and so many others essentially committed suicide at Dumbles's mere *"asking"* and all. Anyone up for some Kool-Aid? Do you deny that Dumbles could've convinced a significant number of people in the Wizarding World (especially many of the children) to drink? (If you're not familiar with the reference, google *"Jonestown"* and brace yourself should you choose to view any of the images, because trust me, they're f*cking sick and I hope Jones is burning in Hell). This old coot would be dumb enough to think The Devil himself deserves infinite second chances. You know The Devil, right? Formerly Samael, the Light Bringer and Son of the Bright Morning Star. Wisest, most beautiful, highest ranking, and most powerful of all the Angelic Host. The High Seraphim who stood at the left-hand side of God's golden throne, and was the third highest ranking authority in Heaven. Later stripped of his place among the Angelic Host, given the name of Lucifer, and cast down to Earth with the Sons of Darkness, the fallen angels who followed him in rebellion. Who then tempted Adam and Eve to eat a piece of the Forbidden Fruit from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, and led to their committing the Original Sin and tainting the bloodline of humanity. And finally by his name as the Enemy, Satan, The Devil, who is the source of all evil in existence. I bet that old crackpot fool would think that The Devil might still have good in him, that he could reach Samael, and that he deserves, as I said before, *"infinite second chances."*

[@jacenskywalker507]

Part 2: *BOTH* Dumbles and Voldy fought what's called a *"proxy war"* where they used others (cultish followers mostly, though, in Harry's case, he was simply a kidnapped and brainwashed child) to fight and die for them. *BOTH* of them manipulated, used and endangered, or outright sacrificed the lives of others, often innocents and children - without those people's knowledge or informed consent. Just because one's ends may be deemed noble doesn't mean that such evil methods are acceptable to reach those ends. The moment you commit an act that evil, you *are* evil, regardless of the *'supposed'* aims you committed the act for. Why is it to be any more tolerated for Dumbles and the *"Light"* to commit such atrocities than the *"Dark"* that're doing it? In fact, Dumbles always hypocritically used that very argument to discourage anyone from using lethal force against the Death Eaters, but yet all of his own actions and intentional inaction proved equally vile and evil in result, if not intent. It was the philosopher, Nietzsche, who said, *"Whoever fights monsters should see to it that, in the process, he does not become a monster. And when you look into an abyss, the abyss also looks into you."* Knowingly enslaving an innocent one-year-old infant to fifteen years of hatred and cruelty as a means of shaping that child's personality for easier influence and control is but only the tip of the proverbial iceberg. How about discouraging his followers from properly defending themselves but rather instead let the enemy kill them? His complete insistence upon stunning and releasing torturers, murderers, rapists, and terrorists only allowed them to be revived or released to later go off to torture and kill someone else. Something that's far more evil than putting down the rabid cat for what it is before it could hurt someone else. Note how the Malfoys among others were walking free at the end of DH despite the murders and tortures they'd done. How many others've since then likely been tortured and killed by them in the intervening nineteen years before the epilogue? Dumbles operated under the premise that the lives and well-being of everyone else, particularly future victims, are unimportant compared to his belief in giving infinite second chances of redemption to murderers, torturers, rapists, and terrorists, who're all people who don't at all desire or want redemption and repentance. (As I said before, the old man's so far gone he'd think that The Devil, the source of all evil in existence, deserves infinite second chances, like he (Dumbles) thinks he knows better than God himself). Many good people died unnecessarily all thanks to Dumbles's cult of personality. I think the most telling difference between Dumbles and Voldy though, was that Ol' No Nose's followers had the choice whether or not to serve him. Dumbles, on the other hand, kidnapped an infant boy and then conditioned (brainwashed) him through years of slavery and abuse followed by manipulation into suicide for Dumbles's cause. In other words, Moldyshort's followers had a choice while Dumblefuck enslaved innocent children into his service. You can't get much more vile and despicable than that. Ultimately Harry Potter was nothing more than a poor kid that was kidnapped and brainwashed by the *"good guys"* into being a suicide bomber. (I'd compare Harry to Jason Bourne, but Harry had absolutely no choice in the matter and no special training or preparation beyond the brainwashing to die for everyone else). By the end of DH there's a huge amount of suffering, blood, and death on Dumbles's hands (as much as or even more than on Voldy's and his Death Eaters') for his usage of others and refusal to use his own power (magical and political) to truly stop any of them from harming or killing others. It's a lot like a cop that chooses to stand by and merely watch while a scumbag guy rapes and murders an eight-year-old girl - refusing to help for whatever his own personal reasons. Who's the bigger monster? The sick f*ck doing the raping and murder or the person who's taken on the title, position, and responsibility - trusted by all to protect the victim - but instead refuses to do so as the girl's raped and murdered without a care? Dumbles even went so far as to not only protect such monsters from being rightfully killed in self-defense or justice, but even worse invited such monsters into a school full of children. Equally as horrific was knowingly enslaving children to hateful monsters as a means of brainwashing and control. Not just the Dursleys, but also Snape. Ask yourselves about the *"coincidence"* of the only long-term Professor being outright abusive of Harry who just so happened to be *"promoted"* to teaching Harry's best magical subject the year Harry would've left his influence in Potions class because he failed to meet the minimum grade Snivellus required. It was blatantly clear that Dumbles used Snivellus to keep Harry abused and beaten down while at Hogwarts and away from the Dursleys' abuse. Harry was never given a reprieve from the bullying and abuse because that's what Dumbles wanted and needed in order to shape him into a martyr who believed his own life had no value and was better to sacrifice for others more deserving of life and happiness. That's what disappointed me most about the canon. Ultimately, Harry was revealed to've never been a hero at all. Instead he was nothing more than a severely used and abused victim, kidnapped as an infant from his legal guardian and brainwashed into his role of suicide for Dumbles's cause. Those who read the books should heed its hidden warnings against adults in positions of authority over children exploiting children for their own purposes and ideals and the use of children in wars by adults.

[@jacenskywalker507]

Part 3: I think the excuse of, *"Dumbledore, who has made some bad mistakes, is doing his best to rectify them."* and all, is just a cheap cop-out/get-out-of-jail-free card for the old man. He made dumb mistakes and how he tries to rectify them, he does a pretty piss-poor job at that. When given the opportunity to fix all his mistakes, he just uses that as an open door to make the same damn mistakes all over again, or make new ones as well. He clearly makes the dumbest decisions I think a human being could make, my new girlfriend even wonders if he's just flat-out stupid. It's stupid and annoying as all f*cking hell when he keeps constantly saying that he's made *"a lot of mistakes"* and that they were *"an old man's mistakes"* over, and over, and over again. No, you dumbass old idiot, what you did weren't an old man's accidental mistakes...what you did was fully and completely intentional. A wise being (Yoda) once said, *"Lessons learned too late, mistakes are."* and that a mistake is only an accidental mistake when you don't know what the outcome'll be in the future and feel horrible about the action that you took, and actually are sympathetic about your regret and guilt, not lying to others only to save and cover your own ass. However, if you intentionally know what the outcome's gonna be...then it's not an, *'accidental mistake'* at all, it was an intentional, deliberate action, regardless of what the outcome would be following the action taken and made, meaning that the person didn't f*cking care. If mistakes were cookies, then Oprah Winfrey would still be fat as all hell like she was still on hiatus. I once accidentally spilled my orange juice all over the floor at the kitchen table because I was distracted by watching the TV, *THAT* was an accidental mistake because I didn't know the outcome of me spilling the juice because I thought I wasn't distracted and was aware enough that I wouldn't knock over my glass when I was putting it down on the table. Accidentally stepping on someone's foot in a dark movie theater, that's a mistake. Intentionally setting up a teenage boy to martyr himself through intentional, sacrificial suicide and only being raised in an abusive household just to die as a sacrificial lamb scapegoat, that's *DEFINITELY NOT* a mistake, and is the work of an evil, heartless, and black-hearted Satanic monster. Dumb-as-a-motherf*cking-door Dumblef*ck can lie all he wants that he actually cared about Harry and was only doing the best that he could to protect him...but I know that's complete and utter bullshit, and can perfectly, clearly, see through the old bastard's lies. He wanted Harry to completely weaken Voldy Moldyshorts after destroying all of his Lucky Charms Horcrux prizes, get killed in the process in the final battle of the war, and Dumblef*ck would step in and kill the completely weakened Voldy once and for all in front of the entire Wizarding World, thus taking all the fame, glory, and credit himself for vanquishing the two most powerful Dark Wizards of modern times (Voldy and Grindelwald) (and two of some of the most powerful wizards to have ever lived), which would cement his fame in the history books and have him arrogantly and egotistically declare himself to be the most powerful wizard and most powerful user of magic to have ever lived to the entire Wizarding World (supposedly thinking himself to be more powerful and greater than Merlin and even surpassing Merlin). Dumblef*ck was a lying f*cking piece of sh*t ever since the first book and film when, at the end when Harry was in the Hospital Wing, he told Harry, and I quote from the book, *"I shall not, of course lie"* from his own mouth, and *yet* all the f*cking old man does is lie throughout the rest of the entire book and film franchise. Just like Krazy Kuntleen Kennedy, the way to know when Dumb-as-a-motherf*cking-door Dumbass Dumblef*ck is lying is when he opens his fucking mouth, just like with knowing when KKK is lying is when she opens her f*cking mouth. The old man says he believes in and tries to do justice, and yet, all he does is lie...which goes against the meaning of justice. To quote Paul Dano's Edward Nashton a.k.a. Riddler from Matt Reeves's *'The Batman'* film, *"If you're justice, please don't lie."* because if you do lie then you deserve to have, to quote Emo Peter/Bully Maguire from Spider-Man 3 (2007), *"some dirt in your eye."* Dumblef*ck thinks that whatever *'supposed' "wisdom"* he spouts out is all that and is something important that everybody has to hear, but in reality, the real reason why he spouts out all of his bullshit is so that he has, to quote Chris Rock, *"an excuse to run his f@cking mouth."* and spout out all of his lying, cheating, stealing, manipulating, and controlling bullshit like he's giving the fucking Sermon on the Mount or something like that along those lines to his brain-dead, idiotic, brainless, and obedient sheep followers who would follow their *"almighty leader"* off a f*cking cliff. Obi-Wan Kenobi loved Luke Skywalker due to the fact that he was his best friend's and brother-in-all-but-blood's son and was like an honorary nephew to him, but he *NEVER* set up Luke to die against Darth Vader and Darth Sidious. Professor Charles Xavier a.k.a. Professor X kindly and selflessly took in hundreds of teenage Mutants and, by his own generosity, gave them a place to live in his own home where he and other members of the X-Men taught them to control their powers so that they could protect the Earth for the betterment of mankind, but he *NEVER* set up any of the students under his guidance, tutelage, and protection to die. He also allowed normal humans to attend his school alongside their Mutant counterparts and peers, and didn't discriminate against non-powered regular humans attending his school, like Dumbles discriminated against Muggles and Squibs attending Hogwarts (even being responsible for Petunia hating her younger sister's guts for the rest of her life, just because he wouldn't allow Petunia to go with Lily to Hogwarts and allow her to make her decision if she really belonged in and wanted to be part of the Wizarding World, by her own choice). He can lie all he wants and say he isn't racist, prejudiced, bigoted, and discriminates against others all he wants, but he really *IS* a racist, prejudiced, bigoted, and discriminating person underneath, while Charles wasn't. Gandalf didn't force Frodo to become the Ring-bearer of the One Ring and go on the quest with the Fellowship to Mordor to destroy the Ring in Mount Doom, Frodo chose by his own right, accord, opinion, and choice during the Council of Elrond to be the Ring-bearer and to take the Ring to Mordor to destroy it when the other members of the Council were arguing and debating among themselves. Gandalf asked Frodo if he (Frodo) was sure that he wanted to take the Ring himself to Mordor as the Ring-bearer, and that it was his (Frodo's) choice and his alone if he wanted to do it. When Frodo became the Ring-bearer of the One Ring Gandalf accompanied him and the other seven members of the Fellowship of the Ring to aid Frodo in his quest to take the Ring to Mordor, cast the Ring into the Crack of Doom, and bring an end to Sauron once and for all. Gandalf gave the life of his physical body to protect Frodo and the Fellowship from the Balrog, Durin's Bane, and battled against the Balrog atop the White Mountains where he struck down the demonic, fallen Maia, at the cost of his physical body's life. Gandalf did everything in his power to protect Frodo and his friends of the Fellowship, but he *NEVER* set up Frodo or any of the other members of the Fellowship to die, as they chose to go on the quest even though they knew they could most likely die, but, again, that was *THEIR CHOICE* and theirs alone. Gandalf didn't make it for them. In First Year, he decides to hide the Stone in a school full of children knowing that a homicidal maniac and terrorist is after it. Why doesn't he just shoot fireworks up in the air to spell out, *'THE STONE IS HERE, VOLDEMORT.'* and all? Next, he has the Stone guarded by a giant, killer three-headed dog that could get loose and kill somebody. I won't take the excuse that he's harmless, he nearly took Harry's and Hermione's heads off when he tried to bite them. Yeah, really harmless there. He then literally decides to go into detail about the third floor corridor, knowingly enticing students to check it out instead of not saying anything that'd peak their curiosity. But instead, he's literally almost baiting kids to go there. The only thing between a curious student and Fluffy, was a *locked door* and that was it, which Hermione or any other First Year, with barely a month of being at school, was/would be able to open! The old, bearded, dumbass made the oldest, stupidest mistake in the book. From what Holly's sister and brother-in-law told Holly and I about their reactions to the old man's sheer stupidity is that: *Tell a whole school of children not to go somewhere, and most, if not all, of them will/would, just to find out why they shouldn't!* Next, he says that the Forbidden Forest is also off-limits, yet has Harry, Hermione, and Neville go in there for detention (I don't care about Malfoy, since he could've been gutted like a fish by a Werewolf and I wouldn't care). Well, why don't you just blindfold them and have them walk head-first into a minefield while you're at it, you idiot? And finally, the very clever Dumbles has the Stone guarded by traps that're so pathetically simple that a pair of First Years were able to navigate through them, no problem. He should've placed a Fidelius Charm on the Stone and made himself the Secret-Keeper to make sure it was completely safe.

[@jacenskywalker507]

Part 4: Dumbles, to me, has got the IQ of a chicken club. Dumbles is the worst mentor in fiction since he did the absolutely dumbest things and made the stupidest decisions ever that Obi-Wan, Qui-Gon, Yoda, Gandalf, Zordon, Professor X, Might Guy, Uncle Ben, Alfred, and Odin would only be able to roll their eyes (eye in Odin's case) in annoyance at the old man's sheer stupidity, and all would probably commit suicide at how dumb Dumbles is. I'm just saying this, I hate Dumbles and there are absolutely *NO* redeeming qualities about him. Everything about him just makes me hate him and roll my eyes at how somebody who's supposedly said to be so *"old, wise, clever, smart, and brilliant"* trips over himself and falls over on his ass like a drunk guy in a bar. He was a horrible, dumbass mentor when we first saw him in Philosopher's Stone (I'm American), and he was a horrible, dumbass mentor when we last saw him in Deathly Hallows. The Old Brainless Bearded Wonder Blunder One is always spouting, *"It is for the Greater Good."* But is always working to ensure that the Dark families benefit. The old man wasn't doing, as many people claim he was, *"more harm than good."* Instead, he was doing, as I like to perfectly claim and say it was, *"All harm and no good."* with his actions. F*ck Jo with her saying that, *"Dumbledore is the epitome of good."* No *'good'* man with *'good'* intentions would *EVER* stoop down to even half as far down to that level, nor commit even half of those evil, monstrous actions and decisions without even so much as batting an eye or vomiting for hours on end and feeling sick on the inside, as well as filthy on the outside and knowing that no amount of bathing in existence would *EVER* make them feel clean or like a human being ever again. They'd know that nobody, not even God himself, would forgive them, and that Hell was no less than they deserved, as they more than anything understood that they deserved to rot and burn in the fiery, brimstone pits of Satan's domain of damnation for eternity for their sins against others. As the saying goes, *"The road to Hell is paved with good intentions."* Next in Second Year, he decides not to close the school despite the great danger that the students are in. Whoopdie doo all five of the victims are only petrified, it's not like anyone got killed this time. Um, so he's keeping the school open and only riding on that idea? What happens when the kids, especially even the Pure-Bloods, start getting killed because Tommy boy shows how unstable he is since he kills like he's giving out free samples? What about the Basilisk? Dumblef*ck was around the first time the Chamber was opened and it was released onto the student population of the school. That was in the forties, fifty years prior to CoS...surely in such a time he could've made sure that it'd never happen again! With the fifty years of time that Dumblef*ck had at his disposal, you would've thought that, as one of the *'supposed'* wisest and brightest users of magic in the history of Wizardkind, that the brainless, bearded, pedophile would've been able to deduce and find out the identity of Slytherin's Monster, and would've killed the Basilisk to put an end to all of its terror. But, once again, *HE. DID. NOTHING.* It was only through sheer, pure luck that Harry survived in the first place and lived to tell Hermione the tale. Dumbledork will be responsible for hundreds of students getting killed because he didn't listen to rhyme or reason and got hundreds of dead students now with hundreds of pissed off parents wanting to rip him a new one. Next in Third Year, he doesn't decide to chase the Dementors off the campus grounds and instead lets dozens of students get attacked by the wraiths and get forced to experience their greatest fears and nightmares. And I don't care about the excuse of, *"He warned the students."* It was only a way to cover his ass, so if something happened, he could make it seem like it was the student's/students' fault(s). Demonic, wraith-like creatures that guard Azkaban Prison, one of, if not, the *WORST* Wizarding prison(s) in the Wizarding World *DON'T* belong anywhere near a school full of children! Ol' Dumbass Dumblef*ck is lucky that none of the students died or were killed by the Dementors that were stationed on the castle grounds, just waiting to suck any student's/students' soul(s) out after torturing them by making them relive their deepest, darkest memories, fears, and nightmares! And, once again, *HE...DID...NOTHING!* Next in Fourth Year, he decides to just let Harry compete in a deadly, life-threatening Hunger Games style sport for amusement, despite the fact that he's underage and doesn't have the skills. Instead of just, you know, getting him out of it. Not content with allowing every single child in the dumb, bearded, bastard's care to be endangered, he then brings back the Triwizard Tournament that's killed almost all of its competitors in the past. Why the *HELL* didn't he water down the Tasks to take into account Harry's age, hell, the ages of the other three Champions (Fleur, Cedric, and Krum, actually, I don't give a fuck about that Communist, Krum, (due to the fact that *TO ME* Harry took Hermione as his date to the Yule Ball), and I *DON'T* give a *F@CK* what Jo says)?! Facing full-grown, nesting mother Dragons?! Would that dumb, bearded, old idiot normally send Hogwarts students out to do that in the wild?! Then...he had the audacity to have Hermione (whom Harry would miss most, and, *AGAIN* I might add, I *DON'T* give a *SH%T* what the f*ck Jo says), chained to the bottom of the Black Lake, to act as a hostage! Dumb-as-a-motherfucker had *NO MONITORING* of her at all! Anything could've happened to her at the bottom of the lake! And he wouldn't've known *AT ALL* what the *HELL* was happening to Harry's best friend during the Task! He also hired a terrorist that he was dumb enough to believe was an old friend of his. He also didn't even bother, give a damn, and/or even try to figure how Harry's name was put into and came out of the Goblet, as well as *who* put Harry's name into said Goblet to begin with. He just did nothing, sat on his wrinkled, old ass, sucked on his lemon drops, and jerked-off thinking about Grindelwald naked or going down on him and sucking his d%ck. Finally, after Cedric is murdered right in front of Harry, he (Harry) sees the one (Ol' No Nose) who killed his parents and tried to do the same to himself. Harry suffers torture and injury, but manages to, not only escape, but also brings Cedric's body back with him to the school. What does the dumb, bearded, evil Master Manipulator do, you might ask? He sends Harry off to the Dursleys'...who beat him, starve him, and abuse him! Not a word from Ol' Dumblef*ck to poor Harry for over a month, all while the poor kid has PTSD and is getting the shit beaten outta him. All the events that Harry went through were traumatic; no ifs, ands, or buts about it. Harry needed Hermione (his best friend) and concerned adults around him to come to grips with what he'd seen. Dumb-as-shit Dumblef*ck did nothing more than pat Harry on the head before exiling the poor kid to Durskaban to be beaten, abused, and tortured.

[@jacenskywalker507]

Part 5: Next in Fifth Year, he avoided Harry like he was the plague and made him think his best and closest friend, Hermione, had forgotten about him and didn't wanna talk to him even though he had PTSD and needed the support. He also sent Harry to take classes with Snivellus where he would have his mind invaded for The Greaseball's amusement. And, he decided to *FINALLY* let Harry know the reason why all of this crazy shit has been happening and tells him that was the reason why he had to experience fourteen years of domestic abuse and possibly was almost killed dozens of times over before then. He also allowed that *filth* Umb*tch to torture almost all of the students at the school (even the *'good'* Slytherin students who aren't racist, prejudiced, and bigoted Pure-Blood supremacists like Daphne and Astoria Greengrass as well as Tracey Davis, etc.) with the exception of the racist, prejudiced, and bigoted Pure-Blood supremacist Slytherins who were *ALL* members of her Inquisitorial Squad. Dumblefuck just sat on his ass and, *"DID. NOTHING."* when Umb*tch singled-out Harry and tortured him through making Harry torture and injure himself by using the Blood Quill for her own sick, twisted, evil amusement. What the *FUCK* was that dumb fucking old man thinking?! Has he lost all common sense and compassion (although, I *KNOW* he had neither to begin with)?! Does he even understand people anymore, or did he *ever* understand people at all to begin with?! As to Harry and PTSD...I think he must've suffered from some form of it at the end of First and Second Years. Following Cedric's death and Voldemort's resurrection in Fourth Year, severe PTSD was obvious to anyone with a functioning brain, leading me to wonder what kind of idiot Dumbles really was to isolate Harry with the Dursleys after such an experience. This impression was reinforced by his treatment of Harry throughout Fifth Year, which was further punctuated by him allowing Umb*tch to torture Harry indiscriminately. The miracle of it all was that Harry remained sane. His cordial behavior to Ol' Dumbass Dumblef*ck at the beginning of HBP has always seemed unrealistic to me. One doesn't get over such rage, anger, pain, and hurt, aided or unaided, in two short weeks. And finally in Sixth Year, he reveals to Harry that he knew and was aware of Tommy's childhood and gave him the knowledge of magic and allowed him to attend Hogwarts and gave him the tools he needed to become a complete fucking maniac. He could've just kept his mouth shut and stayed out of it, then Tommy wouldn't know and his, still in my eyes weak compared to other villains, powers wouldn't've grown at all. But he also let him return back to the orphanage and allowed the little maniac Hitler and Charles Manson Junior to continue being a nutjob and torture and torment all of the other kids there. So it's all Dumbles's fault, if he was actually a smart human being he would've seen that the kid was trouble from the start and erase his mind and memory of everything that happened since he first used magic as a young kid. Seriously, I would've preferred Harry setting Dumbles's downfall clearly as a duty that should've been done, also Harry revealing all of the old man's dirty laundry and allowing his dirt-covered skeletons to come tumbling outta the closet after he was told the truth by Dumbles himself, as the dumb old man was aware of Tommy's childhood and allowed it to happen, causing the rise of a Dork Lard (Ol' Moldyshorts is nowhere cool enough to deserve that title or even be referred to by said title), and let's not forget what Dumbles was planning with Grindelwald. I personally think that The Old Brainless Bearded Wonder Blunder One isn't at all a good person while Umbitch and Tommy aren't at all the darkest and most evil in the story, but a close second and third, respectively. I say that Dumbles is darker and more evil than both of them, combined! I mean, he selfishly craved power and was a narcissist that only cared about himself. He killed his own sister when she got in the way of him trying to stop his brother from arguing with his *"lover"* and all. He abandoned a fifteen-month-old baby at the earliest opportunity and left him on a doorstep all night in November and knew he was going to be mistreated, but simply didn't care, because it was, *"For the Greater Good."* What the hell gives that old man the power, right, and authority to make that call? He's got a God and Messiah Complex, and thinks that he's the only person who can make a call because he's a, *"wise, clever, and powerful old Light Wizard"* and it's, *"My way or Hell's highway."* He said that he craved power when he was younger, but doesn't crave it now because it's his greatest weakness and that's why he never wanted to be Minister of Magic. Yet he's the Headmaster of Hogwarts, Chief Warlock of the Wizengamot, and Supreme Mugwump of the International Confederation of Wizards, as well as being the owner of the Elder Wand, and not destroying it because he craved its power for himself. All of that offers him great amounts of power. So, he's a complete hypocrite. And he also hired Snivellus, a mind-raping murderer and terrorist, and allows him to keep teaching at the school despite the fact he mentally, emotionally, physically, and internally harassed, bullied, and demeaned the students. But, Dumbles doesn't care what the man does to students. Hell, he doesn't do jackshit when the evil Snakes (Malfoy and his racist, prejudiced, and bigoted Pure-Blood supremacist Junior Death Eaters, not the *'good'* Slytherins that consist of Daphne and Astoria Greengrass, as well as Tracey Davis, etc.) commit atrocious actions by bullying, harassing, physically harming, and using magic to harm other students. If he truly did care for the students, he would've never hired the man in the first place, and would've cracked down on the bullying! There's also the fact that he's hiding and protecting a wanted terrorist and the man directly responsible for Tommy murdering James and Lily Potter. It was Snivellus after all who eavesdropped at the door as The Old Brainless Bearded Wonder Blunder One was interviewing for the Divination position in an unsecure room in a bar known for where evil customers hung out. After hearing only half of that supposed prophecy and being thrown out of said bar after being caught, he went running to tell his boss. No, it's all just too convenient. That image of Dumbles in DH was only a part of Harry's subconscious, he wasn't there, but instead, my new girlfriend, Holly, believes so, burning in the pits of Hell. He did a Cain and Abel and he paid for it. Murder is one of the worst sins in existence, and Dumbles committed it, and received his punishment. The punishment fit the crime. He didn't repent for his sins, he never learned from his mistakes, and, when given a second chance, he used it as an open door to do the same sins all over again and commit new ones. I mean, this is the guy who gave infinite second chances to mass murderers, serial killers, rapists, torturers, terrorists, etc. I mean, seriously?! Again, I say this guy, *"would be stupid enough to think that The Devil himself deserves infinite second chances."* This old coot is so far past senile, they haven't even created the word or term for it yet. I don't know who's mixing this fool's Kool-Aid, or what they're even putting in it. Hell, the bearded old coot's got his head shoved so far up his ass he can taste his food again right after swallowing it.

[@Jake-hw9kp]

Crazy upload time for an Englishman! Fair play for the overtime!

[@tylersmith9465]

Very musical🎵 🎼 🎶

[@tylersmith9465]

Cool 😎

[@Expo-ser]

I would be crazy if hpt collabed with movie flame😱

[@tylersmith9465]

Very musical🎼🎶🎵🎤

[@davehultermans7238]

Hey a question. Is it you that puts the subtitles automatically on? Your videos always have subtitles on automatically. And its not the worst but its annoying. Anyway love the vids. Bye

[@diyabobbynair5475]

Hey, can you make a video on, 'Who was Hogwarts headmaster when Harry, Ron and Hermione's childern went to school' thx❤️

[@diyabobbynair5475]

I was just giving this guy content lmao🤣🤣

[@blueberryhearts4820]

@@diyabobbynair5475 Thats no use- nearly everyone knows

[@blueberryhearts4820]

@@diyabobbynair5475 Nobody would watch it

[@katarzynachmura6440]

Im wondering why James wasnt the Keeper of this charm? I understand why wasnt it Sirius or Dumbledore, but why not James himself?

[@candacecassidy9341]

That's the first time I ever heard of it.

[@kaylacoughlan7449]

Can you make a vidio on what will happen in fantastic beasts 3 Harry Potter theory

[@tylersmith9465]

Enjoy ☺️ 😊 😉

[@shakeelabrahams3366]

I dont even watch harry potter that often, but im here everyday! Keep it up!

[@KnobleSloth]

Idk, i ate taco bell for 2 days straight recently, i created an explosion to rival this.

[@miket3827]

I honestly don't remember this letter. I remember the description of the ripped photo tho. It's been so long since I last read the books.

[@alejandrotirado6224]

Song name

[@tylersmith9465]

Family business back in swing on the road so far

[@bonniesplanet]

You said Voldemort could not find the Potters even if he had his NOSE right next to there windows HE HAS NO NOSE