LIVE: ID v. Chad Daybell Day 27 - Doomsday Prophet Murder Trial | COURT TV

LIVE COURT WEBEX: Day 27 - The Defense case continues for the so-called "Doomsday Prophet" Chad Daybell. Daybell is facing the death penalty for the murders of his first wife, Tammy Daybell, and Tylee Ryan, 17, and JJ Vallow, 7, the youngest children of his second wife, Lori Vallow Daybell. He is a self-published author and prosecutors have described him as the leader of a 'Doomsday' cult.
00:00:00 ID v Chad Daybell Day 27
00:26:20 CONT. DEFENSE’S WITNESS #4 Joseph Murray, Chad and Tammy Daybell’s Son-In-Law and Emma’s Husband
00:55:26 DEFENSE’S WITNESS #5 Dr. Katherine Raven, Forensic Pathologist
01:44:17 BREAK
02:10:08 DEFENSE’S WITNESS #7 Investigator Asmir Kararic, Idaho State Attorney’s Office
02:38:19 BREAK
04:17:56 DEFENSE’S WITNESS #8 Detective Rick Schmidt, Rexburg Police Department (RET)
#CourtTV Catch up on the case against #ChadDaybell in the #DoomsdayProphetMurderTrial. ⚖️ MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/chad-dayb...
Watch 24/7 Court TV LIVE Stream Today www.courttv.com/
Join the Investigation Newsletter www.courttv.com/email/
Court TV Podcast www.courttv.com/podcast/
FOLLOW THE CASE:
Facebook / courttv
Twitter/X / courttv
Instagram / courttvnetwork
TikTok / courttvlive
KZbin / courttv
WATCH +140 FREE TRIALS IN THE COURT TV ARCHIVE
www.courttv.com/trials/
HOW TO FIND COURT TV
www.courttv.com/where-to-watch/

[@COURTTV]

00:00:00 ID v Chad Daybell Day 27 00:26:20 CONT. DEFENSE’S WITNESS #4 Joseph Murray, Chad and Tammy Daybell’s Son-In-Law and Emma’s Husband 00:55:26 DEFENSE’S WITNESS #5 Dr. Katherine Raven, Forensic Pathologist 01:44:17 BREAK 02:10:08 DEFENSE’S WITNESS #7 Investigator Asmir Kararic, Idaho State Attorney’s Office 02:38:19 BREAK 04:17:56 DEFENSE’S WITNESS #8 Detective Rick Schmidt, Rexburg Police Department (RET) #CourtTV Catch up on the case against #ChadDaybell in the #DoomsdayProphetMurderTrial. ⚖ MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/chad-daybell/?

[@kimberlythomas1286]

Joe Murray is DISGUSTING. JOE, is mad at the lead detective because he kept driving past Chads house?. The detective KNEW Tylee & J.J. were dead and buried in Chads backyard. The detective is a HERO. Joe Murray, you lost ALL credibility.

[@karieschneider746]

When I counseled recidivists in Western Maryland, they LOVED to go back to the scene of their crimes. It was a huge high for them, to relive the exhiliaration of committing a crime. They would take pictures of where they had been, for pleasure, and delighted in sneaking back to the scene and acting like a normal person, fooling everyone. Their eyes glowed and they breathed faster when they talked about it. That's just one of the reasons Police visit crime scenes...because they KNOW that heinous criminals usually return to the scene of the crime. Or, they could be checking to see that outsiders had not come and vandalized. There are a lot of reasons to return to a murder scene. Hard to believe that anyone would complain about police driving by Chad's house. If that were my house, and an attempted murder, and THREE actual murders had occurred there, I would be glad to see police presence, IF I was innocent...

[@kimward5746]

Yeah he didn’t go over well you know with the jury. What’s with that slam on cops’ jobs being the “last thing he would ever do”? Well Joe, you would prostitute yourself satisfying lonely old men before being a cop? Okay. Let it be known! And Chad better hope that not one juror has a cop loved one, because that disrespect on LE was dumb, arrogant, and rude.

[@panna5324]

Yes! Exactly. To be expected!

[@bud6745]

Wonder why only 2 of the Daybell Kids were called......🤔

[@ginalloyd858]

Tammy committed her life to her husband and kids and this is her reward. Unbelievable. Chad should fess up and let his kids deal with the truth.

[@cheryl5994]

WELL SAID GINA.

[@BrandySunnenberg]

I agree, well said. It's disgusting how those kids show no emotion or remorse for anyone who is dead in this including their own supposed beloved mother. It's absolutely unbelievable.

[@alisasewell]

Proving Chad’s kid got $8k each was NOT the “a ha!” moment that Prior thought it was.😂 it just made Chad look worse. He knew he was going down and was preparing for it.

[@BrandySunnenberg]

Paying them off probably is part of it as well.

[@Hal-jc9pz]

Yes, it also demonstrated they all had 8,000 reasons to lie for their father.

[@LLLLLB]

He really is an awful advocate

[@sharonsparks07]

Joe can see cops driving past the house but didn’t notice a Bonfire at chads or graves being dug or Alex hanging about?!

[@carolinagirl740]

I thought the same thing

[@lynetteleier3012]

💯 %. Seems his memory is selective

[@victoriabrown7566]

am I the only one who believes the defense has no case!

[@heathers794]

100% no case, it's time wasting!

[@RyanBlackhawke]

Yes. You are. 😄

[@juliemcalister2557]

💯 NO case period.

[@juliemcalister2557]

@@RyanBlackhawke no she ain't 🍄

[@kcotis]

It's a flimsy defense at best. Not to mention that it must appear to the jury that Prior is having a hard time getting his defense witnesses to court in a timely manner. The jury may take as though he doesn't have his ducks in a row. It's not a good look for the defense. It seems like pulling teeth for his witnesses to ever get there. That has to frustrate the jury.

[@janetwright5326]

Lmao did anyone else get on to john pryor calling it a murder not someone dying 😅to the forensic dr near the end at 1hr 40 mins lol

[@Twistypoo]

Sure did.

[@LionCome]

Freudian slip.

[@emptynestmom1479]

I about spit out my drink ..😮

[@megganmckenzie9542]

1:39:00 “is that an example of confirmation biased when you take into account all these other reports, documents and statements of people who are not present at the murder” - John prior

[@aimeefriedman822]

Well how can Tylee and JJ's deaths NOT be murders? You mean Pryor was trying to prove they weren't murders? If so, he did such a shtty job that I didn't even pick that up! The ONLY death that seems even possible to argue is Tammy's and thankfully, 99.9% of us watching know Pryor has done a horrendous job with ALL the people that he called for the defense. I mean come on, he's a sharp guy and he didn't forsee that showing ABSOLUTELY NO EMOTION TOWARDS THEIR MOTHERS DEATH WAS GOING TO MAKE EMMA IN PARTICULAR, LOOK LIKE A MONSTER? I'm wondering if Pryor DID warn Chad that Emma might blow the case and Chad, being such a narcissist, disagreed. Then Garth couldn't keep his story straight and lacked all confidence, possibly bc as this trial progressed, he was seeing the light.

[@doroteyaagayna5714]

That's what I call a bad day for the defense.

[@Twistypoo]

When your witness refers to a “natural death” as “the incident”… and then you go on to later call it “the murder”… your client might be guilty. Here’s your sign. 🪧

[@lynnsteffen4476]

😂😂😂

[@kcotis]

Exactly....

[@elizabethhamilton6924]

I was sooo pissed when Joe said that he wouldn't be in Law Enforcement

[@kimward5746]

Said he would be a gay prostitute before being a cop. 😅 ( that’s what he means if cop is the last work he would ever do.)

[@CrimeAuditors]

A totally unnecessary remark and should have been struck out.

[@sandistokes4920]

Clearly Emma doesn't want to believe her mother's 'declining ' health was due to her father's affair with Loser Vallow... what a crap show

[@karieschneider746]

So, Prior asks The Expert a question about preconceived judgment: "...people who were not present at the murder?" Did John Prior say, "murder", instead of "death"? Freudian Slip?

[@KL-ou9jj]

Pay a doctor enough they will say what you want! This doctor didn’t impress me!

[@shallowsleep15]

Why do we care what this pathologist says? She’s not the one who did the autopsy on Tammy and worked her case. Showing all her experience doesn’t matter. She’s not the one who ruled this a homicide. She can’t be giving us a hypothetical when Tammy’s cause of death was determined. It wasn’t “undetermined.” 🤦‍♀️

[@shelleyklapwyk7687]

Why did the prosecutor not say "did you see Tammy's body? Did you do the autopsy?" Or did I miss that part?

[@shallowsleep15]

@@shelleyklapwyk7687They didn’t say that. Maybe they should’ve, but maybe they can’t because it’s known she didn’t work on Tammy’s case. I’m surprised they allowed this witness and defense to keep talking about the bruising. Because a different medical examiner/pathologist said that there was no indication Tammy’s body had started trying to break these bruises down, meaning they weren’t old and likely happened around the time of death.

[@Hal-jc9pz]

Joe Murray's testimony demonstrates that Chad's kids 'know' Chad buried JJ & Tylee's on the property. 'IF' they believed that someone other than Chad had 'planted' the bodies on Chad's property & the person/persons had still not been apprehended (Alex Cox was still alive at this time) they would have no objection to LE continuing to monitor the property.

[@aimeefriedman822]

If Pryor is not mad now, he will be when Chad tries to appeal based on ineffective council!!

[@eucliduschaumeau8813]

You can always tell when Pryor is losing or angry. His face turns beet red and gets slick with perspiration.

[@emptynestmom1479]

What was up with him calling someone to testify he was told to use a shovel? How else are they going to find buried human remains?

[@megganmckenzie9542]

1:39:00 “is that an example of confirmation biased when you take into account all these other reports, documents and statements of people who are not present at the murder” - John prior

[@Javanka]

So many Freudian slipups. They all know, even Prior does.

[@KL-ou9jj]

lol yep!!!

[@monybony8807]

I love Miss Blake!! Sharp prosecutor!!!

[@TheNarcissus666]

The sharpest. She has been on fire on this trial. Lyndsey Blake has brought this What a star she has been at every direct and cross. X

[@camillem823]

I LOVE her!!!! And the other 3! And the Officers. They are some of my hero’s! Justice for Tylee, JJ, Tammy, and Charles!

[@shelleyklapwyk7687]

Anyone catch Pryor at the beginning of this trial say 3-4 of Dumbells kids would be testifying? Lol only two of his kids showed up, and they made it worst for dumbbell lol

[@ravenrozeb3790]

Ms Blake is the "brains" in the Prosecutor's office. She is awesome and knows just where to and how to hit back at Prior's ridiculousness. One thing though, Prior is sure earning his money. Still there is something weird about him. He appears to be "friends" with Chad. Does anyone else see it? I believe Chad has put a light/dark spell on him.

[@CrimeAuditors]

I agree about Ms Blake. Her delivery is excellent and timed correctly. It is a skill to do that.

[@SusanRidyard]

Looking at the witnesses for the Defense has proven to me, that not a 1 has an ounce of sadness that there mother/mother-in-law was murdered by that animal sat at that desk. Hes GUILTY OF 3 OF THE MURDERS and to HELL hes going

[@marshawohltman8580]

At 53:50 on fox 10 broadcast of the testimony of Emma daybell she said “seeing her die was very traumatic”. SEEING her die! Not knowing she died or any other way but SEEING HER DIE!

[@Javanka]

That was big, hope the jury noticed.

[@cheryl5994]

THAT WILL LIVE TO HAUNT HER, I BET CHAD WET HIS PANTS AT THAT.

[@camillem823]

HUGE! And I guarantee they noticed!

[@lynetteleier3012]

☑️☑️☑️

[@marshawohltman8580]

What about prior calling Tammy’s death a MURDER today. I hope they noticed that too!

[@kathym7490]

Chad told people Tammy was going to pass away before her 50th birthday. He doesn't bother to tell Tammy, his wife of 28 years & 5 children, he just bumps up her life insurance & continues his affair with Lori while two children are buried in his backyard. Nothing suspicious about that at all.

[@susankennedy9598]

And gets married again 2 weeks later....

[@Carnivore1959]

He is NOT helping....when you denigrate the police.. "I'd do anything other than that' (being a law enforcement officer) wow ...just wow. And Emma's husband just sound so angry at the prosecution. He's a teacher too????

[@Javanka]

There was strong QAnon conspiracy theorist crazy vibe with Emmas husband, and he made himself even more unlikable and untrustworthy with that comment.

[@karenevans7366]

He and Emma came off as immature brats to me.

[@sharonsparks07]

Wouldn’t have the capabilities or intelligence to get into the police!

[@Carnivore1959]

😂😂..agree with that 👆

[@camillem823]

I get Josh Powell vibes from Garth and Joe! Ewe! Like these fools aren’t locked up? They are dangerously defending a murderer. It’s sickening.

[@KL-ou9jj]

“Who aren’t present at the murder” OOPS PRIOR

[@Carnivore1959]

😂😂😂....yep, my exact word. Oops

[@marybolen5595]

Emma and Joe Murray gained alot from Tammy Daybell's DEATH 😢

[@KL-ou9jj]

Yep! Car and house!

[@TheNarcissus666]

Heinous people with no morality or loyalty to a lovely woman and devoted mother they espoused to care for deeply. With kids like that who needs enemies. They disgust me.

[@camillem823]

Car, house, and $17,000!

[@panna5324]

Cash, car, house 💰

[@shelleyklapwyk7687]

If someone comes after Joe's family who's he going to call for help? The police? God? What a loser 😢

[@cskees9591]

I don’t believe that Tammy went to bed at 5 or 6 pm

[@camillem823]

Blake proved her lying then with her phone activate past 10pm. And she also proved her wrong by asking, “were you there”? Upon which Emma said “no”! She didn’t know anything but what chad told her.

[@cyndilagasse991]

prior just called tammy's death a murder 1:38:57

[@iloveamerica53]

Freudian slip?

[@cynthialandis4263]

He is guilty guilty guilty guilty guilty guilty guilty guilty in 100 guilties

[@wallymorgan2524]

They are all in on it wtf!!!

[@BrandySunnenberg]

I was thinking the same thing after hearing this. I thought they were just too traumatized to believe it of their dad but now I think more.

[@sharonsparks07]

How can chad sit there, no shame or any type of emotion knowing the truth of what he done?

[@camillem823]

Only thing I can think of is that he is heavily sedated.

[@ashbozhilov9025]

I really think he's delusional. He believes the lies that he's created & indoctrinated his children with.

[@aussie_chick]

Chad's kids are really working hard...for the Prosecution.

[@Carnivore1959]

That officer testifying not the brightest bulb in the box 😂. Didn't hurt nor help

[@cyndilagasse991]

ms price didn't help chad at all

[@Sin-D_]

John Prior is AT TIMES is a better trial attorney. He has some tactics in his back pocket such as saying things that he knows will be stricken from the record but says it anyway bc he knows the jury can’t “unhear” it. Luckily the evidence is so strong that it’s not a concern. But the prosecution needs to up their tactics and style a little for future cases or they could regret it. They don’t even seem prepared to feed off of the witness’s answers. Some answers should have led them to further questions. JMO.

[@ericabingham1418]

Does Prior think he’s charming or subtle when he makes his backhanded comments about the prosecution? I could nearly hear the eye rolls!

[@BrandySunnenberg]

Mine rolls every time

[@jenniferdavis8313]

I’ve always thought the defense didn’t have a case from day 1! But I thought that with OJ trial also!

[@jenniferdavis8313]

@@zcam1969 well Trump will be honey!!! The glove does fit!! They claim your their love Slave.

[@jenniferdavis8313]

I am so mad right now!

[@cyndilagasse991]

how does he not know how to push play

[@OneStepAhead94]

how many more sidebars do they need

[@chantallennox1201]

What about red foam in mouth…? Isn’t that an indication ?

[@SYoung-sd4ub]

I think when Prior told Emma if she needs a break for water or a tissue that was the clue to be emotional and it went over her head lol

[@BrandySunnenberg]

Why is anyone marrying into this family? Id be too scared for my life

[@cyndilagasse991]

tell prior that no anatomical cause of death means she wasn't ill or dying from disease

[@marybolen5595]

Court TV is the trail over for today?

[@brandyannsaunders6298]

This family is so delusional the fact that some are teaching our youth is scary

[@johnsmith4219]

you did a good job Pryer but toss in the towel.

[@carolinagirl740]

Not an expert at all, just someone agreeing with Pryor's narrative

[@amandafisher4706]

All flock of the same coocoo bird😒🙄Let's get this GUILTY verdict in already & rid the world of this SUPER dark being, Justice for all the victims ❤

[@cyndilagasse991]

joe almost said death of tammy was absolutely not traumatic

[@maeolaogden5223]

I drew my breathe in when the defense attorney said when people are confirming documents are not present at the murder. Oops

[@jenniferdavis8313]

@courtney, thanks. Do you know any handsome lonesome men? That like wine?

[@MonicaJacobs-ix2sl]

Big mistake to cross examine Joseph Murray in such detail. The prosecutor did not have control and wasn’t a good examiner! He could have done much better.

[@Sp00kyQueen]

Are we watching the same case? He dismantled Joe’s testimony by calling into question whether he is a credible witness or not.

[@elizabethhamilton6924]

Is it over for today

[@lisehelledie]

I miss the subtiteles 🇩🇰🇩🇰

[@LLLLLB]

Prior introducing the subject of poisoning 😂 - mate, you’re not making the point you think you’re making!! He is a terrible advocate

[@leftyfromtx3401]

Prior is relentless in his quest to exonerate Dumbell, but I don't think it's doing much good. There's just too much evidence to the contrary.

[@Cynt12345]

@1:40:00 Prior F up big time!!!

[@carbetheil1293]

PINK FOAM PINK FOAM!!!

[@MonicaJacobs-ix2sl]

I think the prosecutor has a weak case on Tammy’s murder. So many people dropped the ball on that case especially the coroner!

[@ravenrozeb3790]

Agreed. Although Chad will likely get away with her murder, the state can't prove without reasonable doubt he killed her. Purely circumstantial.

[@Sp00kyQueen]

Weak case? Please expound.

[@camillem823]

Not weak! They have proved beyond a reasonable doubt his guilt. No question in my mind.

[@Sp00kyQueen]

@@camillem823 thank you. She’s out here making baseless comments, sounding silly. 😆

[@Ilikerainydayz]

It's scary to think, that these people look to have some semblance of normalcy, untill they start to speak, Emma, her husband and Garth, not to mentione Chad. They give me this "the hills have eyes" vibe.😬

[@Ilikerainydayz]

Ms Blake rocks!! ❤❤❤

[@Ilikerainydayz]

Why? Why, aren't the giving the redirect to Ms Blake, 😫..... my notion is she nails the liars on the spot!!! These liar have a sudden case of amnesia when questioned by the prosecution. Bastards!

[@Ilikerainydayz]

Prior is sitting there after the pathologists testimony, all proud like he's solved the murder of Tammy and like he actually put doubt to thd jury. He's so pompous. And no none of her testimony sounded like she knew what she was saying, or that the manner of death as homicide could be refuted.

[@Ilikerainydayz]

These people are all so frumpy😅