LIVE: MA v. Karen Read Day 28 - Killer Or Cover-Up Murder Trial | COURT TV

[@CourtTV]

00:00:00 MA v Karen Read Day 28 00:06:49 ON THE RECORD - MA v. Karen Read 00:20:46 Judge Rules on Discovery & Defense Witnesses 00:26:59 COMMONWEALTH WITNESS #66) Trooper Nicholas Guarino, Mass State Police 01:43:17 Break 02:22:05 OJP - Defense wants to exclude Karen Read's DUI attorney internet search 02:31:38 CROSS BY DAVID YANETTI of #66) Trooper Nicholas Guarino, Mass State Police 03:42:40 REDIRECT BY Assistant District Attorney Adam Lally 03:57:48 LUNCH BREAK 04:56:59 #67) DR. RENEE STONEBRIDGE, Director of cardiac & neuropathology at the office of the medical examiner. 05:31:25 #68) Dr. Irini Scordi-Bello - Medical Examiner #CourtTV Catch up on all the facts of the case against #KarenRead, Killer Or Cover-Up #MurderTrial. ⚖👇 MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/karen-read/?

[@robinh.7958]

Prayers for the family and friends of John . They deserve Justice,Truth and Peace.

[@denisemunoz8735]

Amen

[@SherriRosebud]

Not going to happen here

[@VictoriaGray-yq2gd]

How do you know that are you the jurors and the judge

[@keriissovery9566]

@@VictoriaGray-yq2gd​​⁠​⁠What do you mean? Do they not deserve truth, justice and peace?

[@espencarlsen]

Of course, just put the right person behind bars . . . . . . . . . . . .

[@truthseeker444]

12.23 Ryan Nagal and his 2 friends see Karen alone in her vehicle outside the Albert house. 12.31 - 12.36 John takes his last 36 steps 12.36 Karen is home and turned into home wifi, remains there the rest of the night. 12.45 Trooper Paul says Karen reversed into John outside Albert house. 12.45 Jen McCabe looks outside the window of the Albert House and see's Karen outside. This is the prosecutions time line, can anyone see a problem?

[@CountessKitten]

Y E S

[@ROBINstrawBERRYwine]

A blind person could see it

[@SherriRosebud]

Happen to see on the screen and hear the Trooper yesterday mention that 3 point turn that Karen made turning around with John before getting to 34 Fairview? He called it a 3 point turn straight up. Hmmm They missed the street and it looked a lot like the turn around and reverse that Trooper Paul claims was when she hit him with the vehicle. I don't think so Expert Trooper Paul.🤔

[@sciencefirst7880]

She left her phone at home.

[@truthseeker444]

@@sciencefirst7880 You have clearly not even been watching the trial, she was on her phone for hours after she came home, texting, messaging, leaving voice messages!

[@letiziapassanisi9967]

The incidence of rib fractures after CPR is reported in over 70% of CPR cases, with a mean number of 7.6 broken ribs per person. PERIOD!

[@Lildarlin1]

Well it's time for the Defence case now with their own experts. I know one thing. The prosecution did not meet the burden beyond a reasonable doubt. Especially not the intent for second degree murder. Their case was a complete mess!

[@SherryKrieg]

Absolutely agree!

[@Nielak-dg8nj]

Ya, not going to lie but I don't care if she did it or not at this point. They can't prove it.

[@letiziapassanisi9967]

A complete and utter WASTE of time…(8 weeks!) And accomplished absolutely NOTHING from the CW. Yet, I heard the judge tell the jurors, they should be wrapping up and getting to deliberations next week. I’m sure the Jury will be relieved to not have to be any part of this entire charade once this is finally over.

[@letiziapassanisi9967]

Hold up….am I trippin? Or did I NOT hear the medical examiner say that OJO had any broken ribs from life the attempted saving measures…🤔🤔 He was a fairly big guy… which would require quite a bit of force for chest compressions. Yet, there wasn’t. That’s just very odd to me. Statistically, (and especially in the condition of which he was found) there’s typically some damage to the ribs with CPR. Shits just bonkers. And just doesn’t add up in the least.

[@keriissovery9566]

Agreed! I have never seen such a botched case.

[@joannephillips4110]

Not another cop who left out information to give to the defense. How do you look into some phones and not the phone of Jennifer MCabe who was with Karen Read before and after the body was found and was related to the people in the home where the body was found. Why did he not look at her phone?

[@Warfarenuggetz]

Corruption 😊👌

[@hotpinkthread]

Did any of them call their elderly parents between 1 and 4 am that night? Did any of them Google DUI attorneys the next day?

[@Warfarenuggetz]

@@hotpinkthread explain how that makes her guilty of murder

[@Nielak-dg8nj]

@@Warfarenuggetz Ya sounds like she thought she would get charged with a dui? Crazy.... Did she delete data and butt dial people? Now if the prosecution can prove she attended Hogwarts or had a looney toons extendable boxing glove to make him fly 30 ft. They may have a case.

[@denisemunoz8735]

​@@Warfarenuggetzbecause she's claiming he was attacked and killed by his friends inside if the house and not by her.

[@XxLindsLou]

John’s phone shows 36 steps (or 85 feet) taken at 12:32am, yet Karen is connected to the Wi-Fi at John’s house by 12:36am. Google maps says it’s a 6 to 7 minute drive between the homes (in good weather).

[@espencarlsen]

Well that night it was anything but "good weather". Blizzard and wind.

[@Electricbootsmohairsuit]

@@espencarlsen I don't think it was that bad at that point

[@chrislanciani1165]

@@kc-wk1kz SPOT ON ...Not to mention the prosecutor and their witnesses suck. 3 phones ruined, floor removed, casing to bulkhead removal. Really making sure if it is a fight that none of them go down for it. MOST OF ALL WHERE IS THE DOG!!

[@shazzasees]

Could the times be off by a few minutes, just in error, or is that a perfect science? Just wondering.

[@shazzasees]

​@@chrislanciani1165"most of all"? Biggest question is not about the dog, but instead is what really caused this man's death? What happened that night during that time period?

[@NatalieFromCA]

Haha! Love Karen’s face, right at the 3:00 mark! If she could, I bet she would have jumped out of her seat and screamed, “Told ya”!!! 👏 Proof is getting better and better by the day!! 💯😉

[@Piat65]

😂😏🤔

[@NatalieFromCA]

@Mine.photos it was right at the 3 hour mark

[@KathyCyr-dg7bv]

Shes guilty as hell

[@NatalieFromCA]

@@KathyCyr-dg7bv I thought so too, until I really started watching the trial! I’m not into conspiracy theories and I didn’t think any of her defenses would fly! Now, I’m convinced that there was some really shady stuff going on in this police force and the investigation was completely botched! Not to mention the dog bites we are learning about that happened BEFORE John died, according to the experts testimony!! Then the cop gets rid of the dog right after the death?! It’s crazy!!!

[@lifeon2wheelsbostonma806]

Not guilty 💯 I use to support the blue until they made me black & blue let her go on with her life

[@VictoriaGray-yq2gd]

I feel it for Paul O’keeffe, he had to relive seeing his brothers photos very sad

[@SAMMYBAMBAM24]

And look at the narcissist everyday. The one who killed John out of anger.

[@Zebragirl1111]

He's very handsome, but sad 😿

[@VictoriaGray-yq2gd]

Exactly I pray she’s gets the full guilty verdict that she deserves

[@SAMMYBAMBAM24]

@@Zebragirl1111 you can see the pain while she’s sitting a foot away smiling.

[@Lauraldixon0514]

That is because no video so people start making up their own evidence. Most absurd thing ever; when evidence proves she hit him. Witnesses are not going to lie on stand. Shows what money can do if you are a defendant; paid blogger says everyone is lying except Karen!?.

[@loomson]

Her voicemails do not demonstrate any awareness of having hit Officer John O'Keefe with her vehicle. They reveal an anger typical of a feuding couple.

[@VictoriaLynn59]

He didn't go home left her again babysitting his niece and nephew. I'd be mad thinking here we go again. She has no kids why babysit his adopted children.

[@heliciamaree]

Or any awareness of where she apparently dropped him off 30 mins prior to leaving the messages...Oh my soul..

[@JustLikeJulia9]

@@VictoriaLynn59 only the niece was there… she lies about everything!!

[@Piat65]

@@VictoriaLynn59 she was just a nanny and a convenient drop in the sack

[@SherryKrieg]

@@JustLikeJulia9she didn’t lie . She said it was the niece, and the nephew was on an overnight!

[@chrislanciani1165]

Why is she calling him a pervert?? That's kinda weird.

[@Elsley12]

Cuz he took advantage of her that morning then smashed a pillow into her face. Ssso she felt used and cheap and she deserves it, foolish woman.

[@mathninjamrsgriffith]

Same. I feel like there is something there we don’t know and may never know.

[@keleighcrooks5035]

She probably caught him cheating! Rage got the best of her

[@KathyCyr-dg7bv]

Cause shes a drunk and cussed him like a dog. She hit him open your eyes

[@WhenwillUlearn]

It's common with a religious upbringing to consider cheating a perverted behavior. I'm not saying he was cheating just that that was her state of mind at the time

[@oliverjenkins5200]

Many instances of reasonable doubt has been raised in this case

[@KristenNicole616]

Anyone else lost when the trooper was acting like he's a damn celebrite expert how was he able to even testify about that. It should be outside of his scope

[@janetwiseman5698]

I didn't understand why he was laughing and not answering questions.

[@ankitapatel1]

He sounded very unprofessional, arrogant many times during his cross examination, reminded me of Jennifer McCabe.

[@Piat65]

@@janetwiseman5698 Arrogant like so many others

[@shazzasees]

Lots of "celebrity" types in this drama.

[@ellen5088]

Any drunk leaving that house could have hit him , not just KR all of them should have been suspects. They put it on her because she was technically an outsider

[@AnnMcHale]

yes but no one else could have- as poor John O'Keefe was already lying injured on the lawn

[@zsazsabear9643]

​@AnnMcHale Yet no one saw him ?

[@Piat65]

@@zsazsabear9643pitch black outside

[@MissCherryBomb69]

💯

[@SherriRosebud]

Lally's own witnesses are getting annoyed with his numerous worthless questions. Omg! Shut up! Although any points he makes in favor of the CW get lost in all the endless irrelevant questions. Helps the defense.

[@sciencefirst7880]

Get Proctor back on the stand and confront him with the evidence!!!

[@MissCherryBomb69]

He fuckin knows!!!

[@GenX1968]

Those creeps beat the crap out of this poor man. I hope they pay. They are already exposed.

[@KathyCyr-dg7bv]

Your crazy the drunk ran over him follow the evidense

[@tiffanystrouse9210]

@@KathyCyr-dg7bv are you watching the same trial everyone else is🤦🏻‍♀️ if u believe that, i already know the answer. Smh

[@MissCherryBomb69]

​@@KathyCyr-dg7bvya why dont you look at his injuries, thats what the evidence is!!!! Watch a ufc fight and see what they look like after.

[@MissCherryBomb69]

​@@tiffanystrouse9210she's probably a MCAlbert

[@letiziapassanisi9967]

(5:21:30) Many Surfaces that were pressing on the brain?…. Well that certainly does not sound like a hit and run. 🤔 What if any parts of the suv were pressing on his brain…? Sounds more to me like several things. objects, or people…but definitely does not sound like a motor vehicle accident.

[@ROBINstrawBERRYwine]

Yea and the M.E. Said due to her findings this is based on some sort of trauma…..WELL DUAH 🙂‍↔️🫨

[@heatherharrington6579]

​@@ROBINstrawBERRYwineshe also said the injuries were not consistent with getting hit by a car

[@taynathibault9752]

is Lally testifying for the defence??

[@Piat65]

She needs to add liquor to her sidebarS

[@MissCherryBomb69]

Sounds like it

[@ChristineFilippo]

I googled searched several articles…..In the same web browser …..IT CHANGES TIME EACH TIME!!!!!!

[@jenniferyant7265]

Same!! The only thing I found on my google history that was off was if I opened my phone and the last app I was on was for example, Facebook. It would look like I opened it but I was just getting back on my phone. All of my google searches were the exact time they should be.

[@CountessKitten]

Absolutely

[@kate47ish]

Yes they need to just ask google!!

[@sandrabecht4489]

search "SandraBirchmore" and you find out about this prosecution "witness"....

[@letiziapassanisi9967]

Sure DOES!

[@FelipeArtista]

The more I watch this trial the more I lean in favor of the defense. I have a theory though, what if the DA knows that they don't have a case, and that there is some merit to the Defense's argument; but instead of throwing the LEO's under the bus, given that they have to work with them on a daily basis, they instead allow the trial to go on. With the Justice Department also investigating, it would only be a matter of time before the folks at the party fall under the microscope.

[@VictoriaLynn59]

Could be however dirty cops don't belong I'm uniform. The DA has no integrity not to out them its their job. I have no doubt it's a cop cover up. Shame on the departments they work for that they haven't been fired. The lies are never ending.

[@guadalupelazar2384]

I pray that john will get some justice. God never fail to listen!

[@CountessKitten]

That's exactly what is happening.

[@katiecouture1739]

I was also wondering that!!

[@AnnMcHale]

DO YOU REALISE THAT IN THE VERY FIRST INSTANCE, THE POLICE HAD TO HAVE REACHED THE THRESH HOLD OF PROBABLE CAUSE TO BRING CHARGES AGAINST HER AND THE GRAND JURY CONVENED HAD TO ASSESS THE EVIDENCE BEFORE THEY COULD HAVE INDICTED HER. THE EVIDENCE IPRESENED IN COURT SHOWS KAREN READ IS RESPONSIBLE FOR JOHN O'KEEFE'S DEATH.PERIOD.

[@joannephillips4110]

When the Defense wants to show a chart or enter evidence why does the judge ask the Prosecution if they want to object? If they want to object they will! "Sustained"

[@loriknight6993]

First time you have watched a trial?

[@rosannepalladino8230]

I agree and yes, I've watch many, many cases from every state. Massachusetts should be embarrassed and liberated that the corruption is being exposed

[@BH-1964]

Timothy (Shanda Vander Ark, son who died from starving and hypothermia) had spots described in the stomach lining the autopsy

[@taynathibault9752]

I'm not educated in this field. but this testimony doesn't look like it's a smoking gun for Prosecution??

[@LegendLength]

The only clear smoking gun so far is mass corruption (just incompetence for Lally though)

[@CountessKitten]

It's not, in fact, it's not even close, even a little. This should not have came this far. Karen Read is innocent.

[@StephSilva-qw1lm]

Then why did yanetti’s original twitter statement say this was a terrible tragedy and not a crime? He didn’t say she didn’t do it!

[@Alohabrianna14]

I’m starting to wonder if she hit him by accident and then some how Chloe was out in front saw something moving and went after John…. That’s why they are like oh no… we don’t want to be part of this. Either way still messed up.

[@taynathibault9752]

I don't know what the prosecutions end game is here.the jury must be confused by this.

[@jenmar001]

Agreed!! Tell the jury exactly what they need to know. Keep it simple, especially in an incredibly hot courtroom.

[@guadalupelazar2384]

FOR THE LOVE IF GOD PLEASE JURY GET THIS RIGHT!

[@loriknight6993]

​@@guadalupelazar2384 guilty

[@letiziapassanisi9967]

Omg!!!! I’m sure this medical examiner could’ve fairly gotten to the point without all of Lallys 18,000 questions. 🙄🤦🏼‍♀️

[@Electricbootsmohairsuit]

It was so annoying! I was begging him to stop from my home!!

[@MikeWilliams-pk6oz]

As much as I would love to see her go to jail I just don’t understand why they got rid of the house and the dog. To me that’s highly suspicious and not a coincidence 😳

[@keleighcrooks5035]

If I was a detective who put a lot of cartel related people in prison, I wouldn't want my address and house aired out for the public..

[@chrislanciani1165]

Got rid of the basement floor and the doors and trim of the bulkhead plus 3 people not only getting rid of phones but 1 literally destroying and put in several dumpsters 🤔

[@katrinat.3032]

Is it the accent? I find this to be the most painful trial I’ve ever watched

[@helenfong3339]

I grew up in Boston but try my best to not have the accent. Cringe

[@Piat65]

@@helenfong3339 Mr. Shepard Wonnnnda ran ova ya dawgggg.🤦‍♀️

[@madelynferez]

nothing wrong with having an accent.

[@shazzasees]

​@@helenfong3339This is the "south shore" of Boston accent. Defendant's accent is closer to that of Rhode Island.

[@HerbieCassidy]

I'm very old but I heard the rage it takes to do this today

[@MValleysMostWanted91]

It wasn't premeditated, I don't think she wanted him dead? But in a moment of rage ? That's what happened. Why do you think she called him right after? At first , praying to God he answered and was still alive. When she realized he wasn't answering? She started covering her own tracks. People have KR mapped out all wrong. While I do not believe she meant to kill him? I do believe her methods she took after she hit him , were calculated.

[@AA-rl7hu]

If she killed him and was trying to cover it up she wouldn’t have left him nasty voicemails and she wouldn’t have suggested she hit him the next day. Her voicemails actually prove she didn’t know he was hurt or dead and was upset because he hadn’t answered or came home. She thought he was cheating on her.

[@wayneevans2605]

​@@AA-rl7huthat's the point.. She was cheating wit Mr Higgins

[@christine6205]

​@@AA-rl7hu maybe her VM were a cover up on her part placing those shows she didn't know he was hit or he passed away it's just a theory Idk it's probably not the case at all but

[@christine6205]

​@@MValleysMostWanted91 Yes jim u said it perfectly

[@janetwiseman5698]

Wonder if his head injury came from the fire hydrant? It was close by.

[@RR-ps1mt]

I was thinking the same

[@lynadamson9079]

Close by, wouldnt he be next to it if he fell on it?

[@ot4462]

This is my theory, I think he approached the yard gate instead of the front door got attacked by the dog and while he was running on the slippery snow he fell and the fire hydrant hit his head

[@Sallylilly1812]

@@ot4462that actually makes the most sense.

[@MissCherryBomb69]

​@@Sallylilly1812 No ot doesn't. Me said that blow on the back of his head were from multiple impacts. That doesn't happen when you supposedly land from getting hit by a car.

[@user-oh9rs8vg9i]

There’s something about this judge that’s off; can’t quite describe it but she’s definitely off-putting. Also, KR’s demeanor and various media comments is off- she’s too arrogant and above all else, does not have any regard whatsoever for what the O’Keefe’s are going through. The grief his family, who are in the courtroom daily, are experiencing is heartbreaking and I pray for them to have the truth and have a measure of peace so they can turn the page for future days… the kids 💔… (JO’s niece and nephew)… I pray they are in therapy and if so, I hope it’s helping. This is all just such a tragedy. RIP John O’Keefe.

[@lindavieira364]

I 100% agree with you...KR....VERY ARROGANT AND FULL OF HERSELF....SHE SHOWS NO EMOTIONS FOR JO,s family ....and he saw rite through her screaming dirty mouth...and wanted to end the relationship....I DO NOT LIKE HER AT ALL...

[@WhenwillUlearn]

How would you react if you were framed for your boyfriend's murder. She is now fighting for her life because she had a normal couples argument. The arrogant ones put her in this position!!!! And of course they will never be tried for their crimes

[@user-oh9rs8vg9i]

A “normal” couples argument doesn’t include hitting your significant other with your vehicle- intentionally and within a fit of anger. She may have not meant to kill him but good intentions weren’t the main theme of that action. I understand she’s fighting for her life but apparently, so was he. I am not saying she’s guilty of killing him. I am not saying she’s innocent either. What I said is her demeanor is arrogant and she hit him with her vehicle. In her hubris, she has not exuded any regard for his family, nor him. “Normally” if you suspect your partner is not being faithful to you and you no longer trust them, one would just break from the relationship and ensure the partner is alive and unharmed when doing so. Not hitting him with your vehicle and taking off in a fit of anger that had been simmering for at least that entire day. I mean, who does that?! Apparently, KR does. How about just having a conversation when heads cool off, like “normal” couples do. What she did was certainly not normal by any logical and moral means.

[@lindavieira364]

@user-oh9rs8vg9i agreed...but she can't hv a normal chat...she's a screamer and very aggressive...with her tone and words

[@WhenwillUlearn]

@@user-oh9rs8vg9i She did not hit him with her vehicle! She has been framed and has to watch her name dragged through the mud so the guilty parties can get away scott free. Huge disservice to Brian O'Keefe to his family and to the people of Canton MA. Pretty arrogant of you to cast your judgement on Karen for how she looks in the courtroom!

[@Mel-ct1vv]

Did anyone conduct any evidence off the fire hydrant that was put in the yard ? I haven’t nothing about that yet.

[@SherriRosebud]

I wonder how annoyed the jurors are by now with "LALLY-GAGGER" wasting sooooo much time with worthless questions and repeat questions of every witness that prove nothing and are irrelevant!!! He is so boring as well.

[@WhenwillUlearn]

He's just trying to run out the clock so The jury will have nothing left in them by the time The defense gets to call a witness. It seems like the jury has been seeing right through him though. It only takes a couple days of truth to undo Weeks and weeks and weeks of constant lies.

[@jaygunny8402]

I wonder how is the defense gonna argue against the phone GPS showing it was outside the whole time? That evidence is not good for the defense

[@MValleysMostWanted91]

It wasn't premeditated, I don't think she wanted him dead? But in a moment of rage ? That's what happened. Why do you think she called him right after? At first , praying to God he answered and was still alive. When she realized he wasn't answering? She started covering her own tracks. People have KR mapped out all wrong. While I do not believe she meant to kill him? I do believe her methods she took after she hit him , were calculated.

[@pennymoon8113]

I’m questioning the three flight of stairs it showed John took once on Fairview!

[@FelipeArtista]

GPS tracking isn't that accurate. We have 3 phones in our household with location sharing turned on, and sometimes my family members' phones ping on the patio or on the lawn, when in reality they are all charging on the kitchen counter. Also, GPS location isn't constant, it usually updates every few seconds or minutes, and if it can't get enough GPS signals to calculate the new location it will continue to report the last location. This is why in aviation GPS is not considered precise enough to allow an aircraft to land if the runway is obscured by clouds etc.

[@josephinedimercurio5012]

@@FelipeArtistastop making excuses for crazy Karen Read she’s GIULTY!

[@jaygunny8402]

@@FelipeArtista when they pinged his phone it showed the exact path before they pulled up to the house and showed that his phone never went inside and stayed outside exactly where his body was found. That's pretty accurate to me

[@taynathibault9752]

where is the testimony that Karen read hit Him????

[@josephinedimercurio5012]

Herself she said I hit him

[@Warfarenuggetz]

​@josephinedimercurio5012 no she didn't. Stop making stuff up. She asked a question to someone about the possibility because some one suggested it.

[@heliciamaree]

​@@Warfarenuggetz😂😂Yeah that's the obvious thought to have right? Whether she said "did I hit him" or "I hit him" does not matter. She knew what she did. Ya'll getting fooled by good attorneys creating doubt, but she is guilty af.

[@debraronan8389]

​@@heliciamareeCORRUPTION FROM THE TOP!!! Dead police officer on your lawn and you don't come out to see what is going on....Where is Chloe... Let's test her DNA????

[@Warfarenuggetz]

@@heliciamaree a suggestion of a possible scenario is not an admission. Get over it

[@pennymoon8113]

IMO, there were so many intoxicated people leaving and coming from the Albert’s house that night, anyone could have hit John O’keefe. Did the investigators check all their vehicles for any damage? I’m also questioning the phone data guy that talked about the number steps John took and such once on Fairview. What about the 3 flight of stairs that he mentioned. Where were those stairs that John took on Fairview,, hmm…..

[@LoveFree333]

To the basement...the one that the Alberts replaced the flooring in before selling the house 😮

[@heliciamaree]

Watch the testimony before making comments pls. They arrived at the house at 00:24 shown on JOK phone location and 1 min later at 00:25 JOK phone stopped moving until after 6 in the morning when they found it underneath his body. He never went into that house!

[@StephSilva-qw1lm]

10 witnesses swore he never went in

[@Electricbootsmohairsuit]

​@StephSilva-qw1lm some of those witnesses sat in thw dining room and couldn't see if he entered the basement

[@Lildarlin1]

Not at all. Undetermined can be anything. I always thought Chloe the dog jumped on him, scratched his arm, and he fell back and hit his head hard. Remember Brian Albert took the dog out. The dog was just on the other side of that fence and can get out at times. That would be the same direction right down where John was.

[@christine6205]

No DNA for a dog was found though from the CW...who's expert testified to me it looks like the blade maybe from the snow plow? Or her car idfk

[@christinab3019]

I've thought this since his testimony

[@stevenprice6957]

😂😂😂

[@Elsley12]

Oh Yaa…blame it on the dog. 🙄

[@christine6205]

@@Elsley12 Lol there was no DNA found for a dog anyway 😄

[@Gypsyvibes1218]

I feel so bad for Karen, I have borderline personality disorder and I've definitely left drunk messages for boyfriends before like this, I feel her pain

[@jeanlynch16]

I have, too

[@AnnMcHale]

@@jeanlynch16 THANK YOU FOR SHARING. HOWEVER KAREN DOES NOT APPEAR TO SHARE/CARE ABOUT THE O'KEEFE'S PAIN AT THE LOSS OF THEIR LOVED ONE

[@KathyCyr-dg7bv]

Oh please sorry for karen? Shes a drunken nut case. She needs prison for sure. She killed this man drunk angy jealious he didnt want her anymore he knew she was nuts. Poor family of this man she is guilty wait and see.😂😂😂

[@robinh.7958]

Drs testimony is very Pertinent .

[@chrislanciani1165]

80.1 core temperature at 6:57 am is pretty warn if a body is out since 1230 am wouldn't his core temperature be much colder??

[@paulfornaro6320]

This is a shameful framing of an innocent person. This could be any one of us who happens to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. It is imperative that Governor Healy of Massachusetts clean house in the twin pillars of corruption: the Norfolk County D.A.’s office and the Mass. State Police.

[@joannamccaffrey2992]

😂😂😂seriously lol...

[@joannamccaffrey2992]

Nothing innocent about that batsht crazer

[@Piat65]

It would never be me, I don’t get trashed and get behind the wheel of a vehicle ever. For every action there’s a reaction . .Tragic all the way around and there are no winners in this situation

[@KathyCyr-dg7bv]

Shes not framed wake tf up she hit him

[@vivienneandersson6019]

I want Jessica Hyde back to tell the judge she used three split infinitives and misused the past participle, I love her!

[@JustLikeJulia9]

I love her, too! ❤️. She had a great disposition and she was so sweet and gracious… not to mention very articulate and versed in her field!

[@vivienneandersson6019]

@@JustLikeJulia9 Absolutely!

[@JohnHoffman-xb7kr]

I actually feel sorry for Karen having to be judged in today's society.

[@Piat65]

She will eventually kill herself or someone else with a drunk driving incident

[@Elsley12]

Another Amber Heard. Feel sorry for the victim and his family, not the murderer.

[@kingduran007]

What about John’s family

[@Piat65]

@@kingduran007 Exactly…I don’t feel sorry for people that choose to drink and drive.

[@Kallie4378]

I’m looking at the first comment with the time stamps and it says “ Defense wants to exclude Karen’s DUI attorney internet search “!!! I haven’t heard anything about that! Did she search it that same night?

[@tinalouise4]

I think it was the following afternoon about 1pm. I think

[@SherriRosebud]

After she was contacted by phone by Trooper Proctor. Attorney search was not exclusive to DUI but was included. Was not admissible because it is typical when contacted by law enforcement for an interview.

[@Piat65]

We need Georgia on this case.😂

[@LoveFree333]

Right?!?!

[@LoveFree333]

But really we need her to take Wendi first ...

[@bridgetives359]

OMG! Imagine?!

[@Piat65]

@@LoveFree333 Bigtime

[@loriknight6993]

No DA, she searched for a DUI attorney

[@timrobinson6573]

@5:01:28 The Medical Examiner looks like a street walker

[@MFC7625]

I hope the Feds are/will investigate Sarah Birchmore and Walh cases.

[@kennywoo9012]

Now we are talkin!!!!

[@jeanlynch16]

Why did guarino say “kill me” the other day?

[@annarose4828]

He didn't want 2 read the texts imo,.

[@JustLikeJulia9]

@@annarose4828 they are a bit awkward… I get it!

[@CountessKitten]

About having to read the texts, imo

[@sherribudka8104]

That was so unprofessional, just like every single cop in this case!

[@annarose4828]

@@JustLikeJulia9 that's for sure!! Thanks for comment!!

[@chrislanciani1165]

BECAUSE HE GOT BEAT UP! THAT'S WHY ALL THE TEMPORAL LOBES ARE DAMAGED!

[@Julia3wcd]

Curious if ME would check JO’s face for skin cells belonging to someone that could have punched JO. If he was in a fight I doubt gloves were used. If his face was wiped clean, no touch dna that would be weird as well.

[@Elsley12]

That’s because he was hit by KR vehicle. He wasn’t punched in the face.

[@926paaja]

@@Elsley12explain all the injuries to his head front and back with one hit of a car and how did she hit him with the car when he is 6 -1 tall??

[@taynathibault9752]

this is getting ridiculous. what point is he trying to get out of the witness. enough is enough.

[@nicolejoyce2398]

Home Girl is smitten with Alan Jackson! He better keep an eye open if she gets off.

[@CountessKitten]

Umm, no way. I suppose people like yourself, who are consumed with (completely wrong) judgement and bitterness towards a woman who you do not know may think you know all this from simply looking at a situation, but I'd wager, just like in this instance, your judgment is always way off, hence why you're so miserable to be that way publicly. Ugh

[@Piat65]

I said that from day one

[@yawninggap2328]

And Jackson is smitten with home girl. Watch their borderline PDA in first days of trial before they were noticed by social media.

[@Elsley12]

@@yawninggap2328 nah…he’s just reciprocating extra nice guy to her because he’s getting paid and has to play her game. KR is psycho.

[@helenfong3339]

@@Elsley12 She craves attention! Couldn't take it that John's 1st priority were the kids. When she did the Nightline interview, she seemed angry at John with no remorse at all.

[@lynadamson9079]

Have i missed something, rear fracture to skull from falling backwards onto a lawn/snow? considering he was allegedly hit by a car. If the car hit the back of the head he'd of landed face into the lawn/snow?

[@Alohabrianna14]

Yes but he could have rolled over before he passed and I believe the one officer/car accident reconstruction expert said he could have turned before landing

[@peggychamberlain9515]

Lally is trying sooooooo hard!!!

[@DeniseHonest]

Lol. He is but he lost!

[@Piat65]

She needs to head on over to the shuffleboard

[@MValleysMostWanted91]

It wasn't premeditated, I don't think she wanted him dead? But in a moment of rage ? That's what happened. Why do you think she called him right after? At first , praying to God he answered and was still alive. When she realized he wasn't answering? She started covering her own tracks. People have KR mapped out all wrong. While I do not believe she meant to kill him? I do believe her methods she took after she hit him , were calculated. Karen Read is no victim. She will blame anyone she can . She would blame me or you if she could. Sad sad lady , serious mental health issues.

[@TheTruth-kh2im]

Agree 💯

[@stars0716]

Then how did the dog bites, or animal bites, get on his arm?

[@christine6205]

​@@stars0716 There was no dog DNA found on John witness testified to that the CW witness that is 😊

[@RR-ps1mt]

Spot on

[@RR-ps1mt]

​@@stars0716 those are not dog bites. Have you actually seen dog bites? Or been bitten?

[@1pariah67]

the what if anything prosecution

[@GabaSaminu]

Your number 1 subscriber for sure!

[@phoenix8846]

🤔@ 17:14...the lady sitting next to Mr O'Keefe's brother signing something??

[@Kab958]

"You would agree that injuries don't manifest out of nowhere?" What a pathetic question to ask an experienced Medical Examiner. The sarcasm. aggression and caustic remarks of this defense team throughout this trial, whenever the witness isn't saying what they want ot hear, is so predictable and exhausting. If I were a juror it would totally put me off and I'd switch off.

[@beverlystover3987]

Is it just me or does Karen reads attorney look red faced and flush when reading the texts and hearing the voice mails???

[@silvamedina9188]

I noticed too.

[@joannamccaffrey2992]

Yeah she's batsht crazy

[@basicbetty72]

Oh yeah - jaw was clenching

[@holylandfan3275]

That moving ceiling fan is the WORSE spot to have for a break. It messes with my eyes within seconds and nearly makes a person nauseous.

[@reavanante2160]

The broadcast voice mail featured, was quite plainly, "John, where the f*** are you?". It's also quite obvious that the voice mails aren't rage but FEAR. What is wrong with people that they can't distinguish the two?

[@RR-ps1mt]

The first couple were rage. How could you not tell that?

[@robinh.7958]

Rage

[@Piat65]

😂😂😂

[@michellesolis4856]

Omg voice mail messages are so sad to listen to😢

[@Sheila-hw4us]

For both parties

[@taynathibault9752]

ya like I said this is rediculous. agree with judge let it go. prosecution witness is making a fool of himself .like Wow. took the judge to stop his endless going No wear questioning..

[@barbarapeers7946]

This defence attorney in the cross examination is so rude.

[@mervihelles2981]

I hope the O'Keefe family gets justice.

[@ChristineFilippo]

Using same opened Web browser still changes time stamp!!! I just did it on my phone!!!!

[@CountessKitten]

Yes. The 2:27 search happened. 1,000,000%!

[@StephSilva-qw1lm]

Two forensic experts say 6am I’ll go with that

[@PamJacksom-xq5rx]

This case is about creating doubt, not the truth. A cover up, and to point the blame on others. It was so far fetched, and yet they convinced some it was a real scenario. It was bizarre and unreal. My hope is still for justice for John O'Keefe and his family. Karen Read has no compassion for him or his family. He was her boyfriend, she acted like she barely knew him.

[@Warfarenuggetz]

Is anyone else disappointed that the defense didn't question the ME? I know i am!

[@Lildarlin1]

No because they have their own experts coming up. Jackson has 3-4 experts on this.

[@Warfarenuggetz]

@@Lildarlin1 I know but I have questions. And I don't think they're going to be answered. But I guess we'll see. So much darn reasonable doubt I'd be shocked if she was convicted. Even w out the defense experts.

[@Piat65]

@@Lildarlin1 everybody seems to be an expert when it comes to this case

[@truthseeker444]

The medical examiner looks like she would rather be anywhere else in the world than that witness stand, she looks like she has a gun to her head! Ummm, aummmmm, ummmmm!

[@ROBINstrawBERRYwine]

And she said based on her findings this was caused from some kinda trauma…..”REALLY,I MEAN SERIOUSLY MA’AM,TELL US SOMETHING WE DONT KNOW!!!!!

[@jeanlynch16]

How did today go?

I said from the get go that those scratches on John are from a dog. I have a German shepherd and have seen what their scratches look like 😮. Another point is why we’re these ppl all getting rid of their cell phones. Etc

[@KathyCyr-dg7bv]

Lol u are so ignorant

[@Warfarenuggetz]

So basically only the front of the face and one arm is where damage was done. And hit several times! Sounds like he was beat up. Not hit. And if he had hemeraging then why was only a light damaged but nothing else? Cuz a damn light would NOT cause all thai damage. Also his head is at 6.1 feet high. Where is the light in conjuction of the head? Was he bent over? If hes bent over then his arm would not be at his side in the air. This in of itself causes reasonable doubt. Along with about 50 other things. This is a sham.

[@AnnMcHale]

I am sorry but the poor guy sustained blunt force trauma, skull fracture, internal bleed in his head and injury to arm as he was sent spinning counter clockwise and landing gravely injured on that lawn. John O'Keefe was out cold, The biggest tragedy remains the reality that HE was left there, injured and alone. The only phone call Karen Read did not make, was to 911.

[@Warfarenuggetz]

@@AnnMcHale no. U obviously didn't hear the testimony. He had MULTIPLE points of contact. Her words. Meaning he was struck multiple times. What do u not get on that? U don't get multiple points of contact to a head injury w one vehicle hit! The MEs testimony sealed it for me. If u believe the nonsense coming out of these lying cops u are delusional. They are clearly lying. And have been caught in less several times and contradict them as well. How did he get put on the lawn at 245 when she was at johns house at 1236? U are def not paying attention

[@kingwoodguyatgmail]

The DA hung Lally out. Put his worst prosecutor on the case, had pitiful “experts”, instead of charging accidental death they went for intentional, it’s just amateur all-around! The McCabes, though? They know exactly what happened.

[@kingwoodguyatgmail]

These messages are actually evidence which helps her. Does Lally think she intentionally killed him then left messages which point to murder?!! 😂idiot. The pervert talk has more to the story!

[@sallyolsen-ug1mz]

People are so excusing of her actions!!! Her voice and her voicemail tells it all!! Guilty

[@christinab3019]

I argue with my spouse. It doesn't make me a killer. Just saying🤷🏻‍♀️

[@kingwoodguyatgmail]

I honestly do not see mirderous intent there. What planet do you live on?

[@AnnMcHale]

She clearly experiences ANGER MANAGEMENT issues, horrible the way She drags the kids into it-as to best of everybody's knowledge, She was not asked to babysit Kayleigh or Patrick (who was on a sleep over with his friend). JUST DONT GET IT-WHY WAS SHE SO ANGRY THAT HE WAS GOING FOR DRINK WITH FRIENDS? SHE TOO HAD BEEN INVITED-SO WHY ALL of a sudden is SHE BEREATING HIM FOR wanting to CONTINUE THE NIGHT WITH SAME FRIENDS? ADMONISHING HIM FOR BEING OUT AT 1 AM?

[@Piat65]

@@christinab3019 I think she did it, but I don’t think it was intentional

[@VictoriaLynn59]

​@@AnnMcHalethey AREN'T her children and she was not responsible for them JO was. When you're a parent you don't get to be carefree and party all the time. You're home being a parent. He adopted the kids NOT her.

[@janetter2236]

What’s up with the fan?😅

[@peggychamberlain9515]

John was beat up!!!

[@joannamccaffrey2992]

Yeah beatup with fool cows truck thing

[@AnnMcHale]

THE MEDICAL EXAMINER STATED HIS INJURIES NOT AS A RESULT OF AN ALTERCATION.

[@Piat65]

By Karen???

[@Piat65]

@@AnnMcHaleOr vehicle so the fire hydrant did it🤦‍♀️

[@remnant0888]

@courttv I came here to see what I missed. No live feed. 😢

[@carylpark7192]

On a break.

[@SAMMYBAMBAM24]

You can scroll back.

[@annjanovsky8054]

Court has ended for today.

[@jovicrazed]

I really don't care for Yanetti's questioning style. He makes his questions too convoluted and "you would agree with me" does not have to be said for every single question.

[@debraronan8389]

How about Lally ..If any?????

[@jovicrazed]

@@debraronan8389 Agreed. It's annoying too but he does it so as to not be leading.

[@debraronan8389]

@@jovicrazed Lullaby Lally😴😴

[@AnnMcHale]

I don't care for Yanetti at all-found him Initially after his opening statement I considered him as a "strong" attorney but that is ALL history now. considered him marginally better than Jackson but am repulsed by the both of them now. Both have behaved in ways that can best be described as ILL Conceived and Ill TEMPERED, OUTRAGEOUS AND IN CONTEMPT OF COURT. BOTH HAVE BEEN SO VERY DISRESPECTFUL TO EVERYONE IN THAT COURTROOM-ALAN JACKSON "PIROQUETTE" IN REFERENCE TO THE VICTIM -INJURED STATE HAVING BEEN HIT WITH DEFENDANTS SUV BEYOND REPROACH-TOTALLY DISRESPECTFUL TO THE DECEASED AND HIS LOVED ONES IN COURT.

[@SAMMYBAMBAM24]

So many comments about tattoos but this woman has more schooling and intellect that all of you Karen lovers who are judging her and just be obnoxious!! Tells who you really are.. disrespect judges, etc..keyboard warriors…she’s GUILTY..didn’t like being dumped did she?!!!

[@DeniseHonest]

Lol

[@lilzabug]

I don't see any comments about tattoos. The Dr. does sound intelligent. And I don't care which way the verdict goes. I'm just watching the trial. But I will tell you this: I have a smallish tat of flowers and a butterfly on my upper arm. I am now 70 yrs old and that tat does NOT look attractive on a70 yr old upper arm. I always wonder what people who get so many tats on their faces and sleeves like this will think of them when they're in their 70's. They most definitely won't have the same shape or color.

[@DeniseHonest]

I commented incorrectly. I’m 66 years old. I have no tattoos. One of my daughters has two tattoos. I think they are beautiful. My husband got two tattoos later in life. Both my husband and daughter are beautiful decent special humans. Please please do not judge people on tattoos as they used to do back in the day. Tattoos are a beautiful form of Art. Please live and not judge.

[@lilzabug]

@@DeniseHonest I got mine when I was 48 yrs old. I never pictured myself getting "old". And then I did, and along with that came the sagging, crepey skin. I don't wear sleeveless shirts anymore. Not because of the tat, but because my arms aren't the "guns" they used to be. Everybody ages differently. But at some point it happens. My tat was vibrantly colored. Now not so much. It's a consideration that I don't think many young people think of. I didn't. I don't regret it, but it's not all over my face either.

[@yawninggap2328]

Agree

[@outoftime7740]

Did everyone catch that. Karen did not give the police the passcode to her phone. Jen and Kerry gave their phones right away to LE. It took 6 months, until August for LE to get the passcode to Karen's phone. In August, they finally got it

[@sherribudka8104]

But Jen and Kerry had already deleted things on their phones before they handed them over!

[@SherryKrieg]

That’s not true! They took her phone when they went to her parents’ house to interview her and take the vehicle.

[@AnnMcHale]

HEARD THAT LOUD AND CLEAR.

[@StephSilva-qw1lm]

She did not give pass code. They had to put phone on some sort of system and it took quite awhile to crack it open. I think months.

[@SherryKrieg]

@@StephSilva-qw1lm How was he looking for nudes that same night? And saying nasty stuff to his buddies?

[@taynathibault9752]

it's called Frost bite Dude!!

[@lifeon2wheelsbostonma806]

The fan is back

[@christineeaton4985]

So now online classes are not equal in credibility to an in person class or certificates are worthless also to this defense team.

[@sharonharrison3611]

It's clear Karen Read is a liar. She told John on her voicemail to him that she was at her home in Mansfield but she was at his house.

[@keriissovery9566]

Yeah but she could have been just trying to get him to come home. Like if she told him she left and the kids were alone, he would have called her or went home right away.

[@leedavison5307]

Everyone has lied

[@SWsideChicago]

Guarino said today John’s phone never made in to Alberts house. Well it wouldn’t show in the house if John didn’t connect to Alberts WiFi.

[@SWsideChicago]

My point being John O’Keefe was in the house.

[@giigity]

The state cop is a joke. 😂😂

[@Trina_White]

Why couldn’t i talk during live? You make people pay for this?

[@JBfromFL]

No, they ban or restrict a certain amount of people. God forbid that we talk to one another and come to agreements on anything 🙏

[@devenbergeron155]

There are other channels that you can talk on.. if everybody was able to live chat there would be over 20k people commenting at a time

[@Trina_White]

@@JBfromFL ohhhhh, i see, tyvm!

[@Trina_White]

@@devenbergeron155 that is ridiculous but i get it now, ty

[@Trina_White]

@@devenbergeron155 I thought I got banned yesterday for saying i think she is guilty🤭

[@chrislanciani1165]

How would this car just hit his face? Just one arm? It truly looks like a fight and dog attack. That's it. He hit back of his head on cement. Because they hit his temple that's what killed him.

[@jcmate1692]

1:10:20 tec tools to calculate all this other stuff but no EDM just one of those big windee things yer that's right a tape measure.

[@veragreen9725]

That’s it … the victim never went into the house … end of story …

[@jcmate1692]

1:08:02 Signal strength, does this not depend on many factors, the brand of the receiver in the phone the brand of the phone itself the makeup of its shape and materials it made out of as well as any external phone case or cover. The ph location inside a residents can affect signal strength the GPS would tell me my old ph was 60 to 80 meters away from where it actually was where more expensive phones will ping your ph location far closer depending on time of day and cloud & rain cover, has anyone else had this experience when playing with their find my ph app

[@lindafinch1520]

Great cross by Mr. Yanetti and Trooper Guarino proves himself to be yet another bumbling, biased, idiot cop.

[@samernabeel7822]

Is it break ?

[@sharonharrison3611]

Karen Read is GUILTY! She is so childish, jealous, drunk, furious. I believe she is very GUILTY!

[@debraronan8389]

You must be related to the McAlberts!

[@ellen5088]

Every female that’s ever been in love has had a moment of crazy and every guy also

[@Elsley12]

consistent with a forceful vehicle impact that threw him causing blunt trauma as he hit the ground on his right side. How horrible!

[@926paaja]

That’s not what she said lollo The guys from arcca will say the facts

[@ot4462]

How could a glass not fall from the hand in a car accident? The prosecution claims that the shattered glass was found next to John’s head

[@926paaja]

@@ot4462 and how did he hold his phone and glass and fly 30 feet spinning mid air ? Thats what the state “expert” said 🤪🤪

[@northerngirl2010]

A guy 6-1 how does he get hit by a tail light even if it happened he would of have to be sitting down .. and then she would of driven over him would more damage to lower body and body can’t fly so many feet while at a sitting down hit..they would of been squashed right there.. that’s my thinking .. 💭

[@Elsley12]

@@northerngirl2010 watch some slo motion videos online of pedestrian dummies getting struck by a vehicle. It gives some insight as to speed, distance the pedestrian can be flown and how the body is injured. I was hit once and had a fracture and stitches to my head but no injury to the rest of body…and I flew quite a distance into a ditch. So Yaa, don’t know why the head is always so prone to car accidents.

[@Cissi2009]

Wow these doctors are quite accomplished.

[@guadalupelazar2384]

My opinion he got bit up!

[@peggychamberlain9515]

And beat up!!

[@MFC7625]

He could have punched the dog with the back of his hand or he was pushed in the staircase, putting his hands above his head to protect himself from the punches. Nitall said he had a bump on his forehaed, right side, from hitting the wall in the staircase, injuries to his knee while falling or being punched.

[@RR-ps1mt]

Have you ever been bitten or attacked by a dog? Those are not dog bites

[@Warfarenuggetz]

​@RR-ps1mt yes they are! I can promise they're not from the light. It's just not possible

[@heliciamaree]

Ya'll should maybe actually watch the trial and not just throw out these random comments.🤦🏼‍♀️

[@chrislanciani1165]

Bro if it says DELETED ...no REASON. DELETED PERIOD