Johnny Depp trial fireworks: Amber Heard expert combative during fiery cross-examination

Johnny Depp's attorney put Amber Heard's expert psychiatrist Dr. David Spiegel on the hot seat during cross-examination in the former couple's defamation trial. Dr. Spiegel appeared to get very frustrated with the line of questioning and accused the lawyer of going around in circles. The attorney and witness went back and forth and appeared to get combative with each other.
Subscribe to LiveNOW from FOX! kzbin.info?su...
Where to watch LiveNOW from FOX: www.livenowfox.com/
Follow us @LiveNOWFOX on Twitter: / livenowfox
Raw and unfiltered. Watch a non-stop stream of breaking news, live events and stories across the nation. Limited commentary. No opinion. Experience LiveNOW from FOX.

[@Siri_Duffa]

This guy is exactly what I imagine a mad scientist to look like.

[@karCot]

Both comments are right lol.

[@kandireid4207]

He can of reminds of the guy in the movie with Michael J Fox back to the future

[@cosmicremix311]

@@kandireid4207 Doctor Emmet Brown, or Doc, for short. Played by Christopher Lloyd

[@kandireid4207]

@@cosmicremix311 yes couldn't remember the name

[@MighelAkando]

Lmfaoo

[@Mr.Firebrand]

The thing is, this guy is perfect for treating other people's mental health issues. Because when they see him they know they're fine.

[@hamdanjantan3462]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@shahirlaskar6401]

😂🤣 most underrated comment..

[@nirlamejia]

😂😂😂

[@khiljinagor8976]

Lol such a golden comment.

[@khiljinagor8976]

Also someone googled him and found his practice and bad reviews about how he literally let a suicidal patient of his die as a result of his malpractice. How he ignored the guardians of his patients, their calls and just gave the patient Meds instead of treating the illness. I haven't googled him myself but saw/read this review about him from another site.

[@Chris-vq5vr]

I once met a psychiatrist who said that the only difference between me & my patients is that I have a key to the building.

[@JamesD-iw6pr]

I love this Judge. 'Yes, you have to answer questions' you could almost hear her eyes roll when she said it.

[@gamegreed9105]

She was pretty blunt but I guess that wasn't necessary comment it's probably certain questions he didn't want to answer maybe he could skip certain answers just like when the lawyers objects Johnny or Amber from making comments but obviously it's different he's a witness

[@wsbygt]

sure

[@janesajenkins3246]

At what time was that?

[@JamesD-iw6pr]

@@janesajenkins3246 24:34 it is after the Charlie & The Chocolate factory question.

[@feathersrestored3691]

You don't need an expert to tell this man is more patient than a psychiatrist.

[@wilheminanehumba]

Exactly!!!

[@stonecoldsteveaustin9353]

he's a lunatic

[@siaersw2338]

Yesssssss

[@sarahtaylor7737]

Please don’t disrespect mental health patients!!

[@kerrijotehuia7773]

My thoughts exactly scary

[@chrishirst-bartlett8571]

It's terrifying that this man is responsible for people's mental wellbeing.

[@suzmac1526]

Yup, you walk in, talk to him and promptly realise there is bugger all wrong with you by comparison.

[@MKULTRA1701]

He seems ligit.

[@suzmac1526]

@@MKULTRA1701 🤣🤣

[@Brayden2004x]

What's his name

[@DirtySanchez943]

Y? He has healed many ppl.

[@lisalepore1449]

This "professional expert" is clearly in dire need of his own psychiatric assistance. This is shameful.

[@newguy3588]

He reminds me of the scientist from Independence day, but an even more lunatic then the character.

[@chrisjenkins203]

@@newguy3588 someone else had mentioned that he reminds them of “Dr. Doom” from “Who Framed Roger Rabbit”. Yes, this guy is just an absolute trainwreck. And to think, he is diagnosing sick patients and pumping them with random medications. This guy belongs in a padded room of his own.

[@DjMeow]

Actually, quite entertaining 😅

[@lidiasimoes5516]

🤣 🤣 🤣

[@neelstinadambuka7284]

I am a psychiatrist myself and I feel ashamed of this spectacle. It makes me worry about the portrayal of our profession. Please know that most psychiatrists are decent, trustworthy doctors, especially the ones who have had their training more recently (the quality of training has improved hugely over the last decades). Most of us have had excellent, diligent training and we work in accordance with the highest ethical standards. This is one of those old bad apples in our field who make things more difficult for younger generations of psychiatrists. I hope he retires soon.

[@argr]

One madman says of the other that he is mad.

[@dfreeman120]

Shrinks are extremely smug in my opinion !

[@bobboonah]

Always worth remembering that the highest membership of the Nazi part was among medical practitioners.

[@willmeinhardt8212]

This guy just proves that people that have a doctorate doesn’t mean they’re great or sane.

[@sharonladd-campbell37]

Yes it's means they have a LICENSE TO PRACTICE

[@FizzedAye]

I think he's 200 iq

[@kprak2324]

Oops! That hits hard. I am about to get a doctorate in psychiatry 😁 Anyways, this guy is horrible at its best.

[@ArtistinDeadlight777]

I see a few kinds of intelligences and I do not associate deduction/induction and ethics with mathematics and memory. You can be good for the last two and abysmal for the first two. We would see fewer of these clowns If we had mandatory philosophy classes instead of English.

[@jadjason6053]

I mean just look at Dr. Robotnik

[@GG-yn6jw]

This "expert" looks like he needs a psychiatrist himself! He is sarcastic, has anger issues, rude, unprofessional, and extremely combative! What a freaking jerk!

[@krystalmoore8943]

Based on his actions, body language, responses (or lack thereof) and tone, he is a classic narcissist himself. And what person gets on the witness stand with messed up hair then takes two extended breaks and comes back with the same wack job disheveled hair? How can you even take him seriously when he looks and acts like that?

[@domzbu]

All shrinks got into the business via needing shrinks themselves. They recognise the gravy train and fancy trying it out themselves. They also go from a position of dependence to a position of power.

[@Drusille]

he looks like he's on drugs, it0s sooo unsettling to watch

[@rachelweyenberg9574]

Exactly.

[@lovelambs8870]

@@krystalmoore8943 Not the body language experts coming through. pure delusion, get off youtube bruh

[@Wissle]

Am I the only one who's literally scared by this guy?

[@thedisturbedpreist]

This is real life, where the worst people go for the jobs that give them the most power over other people

[@wsbygt]

yes

[@craigmorgan4676]

Scared of what,he's a psych!🤔🤯🤔🤔🤔

[@xxnirvandabossxx8304]

Why?

[@interycreeper1152]

He is ridiciculous to me. No way I would be afraid of this "doctor" and APA "fellow"

[@robovac3557]

One of the best characters of the series. Very well written and acted. Pity he was only a one off. Would have thought he should have been a recurring character as there was still lots of comedy gold to mine.

[@letstalk7961]

This comment is gold 😂😂

[@farahcastic]

johnny vs amber’s imdb page

[@David.Sky.Walker]

Hopefully he'll be back for Season 2.

[@aleisterandrews5025]

A+++ content

[@21mushroomcupcakes33]

"What a villain, truly unlikable."

[@jaywilldoit]

Imagine going to this guy for psychiatric help, and then realizing he needs it more than you do.

[@Darthmaul756]

😂😂😂

[@namastewellness]

😂

[@francesagoncillo7918]

Truly 💀🥴

[@waitasecond...]

Yeah, flip your hair and walk away. Cos ain't nobody should get into the mess of this guy.

[@carriewhite2809]

lol

[@summerleigh5316]

My mind is blown. He’s really going around giving clinical evaluations without face to face assessment and no authorization. VERY UNETHICAL

[@coci2729]

This is how they have been getting over on people

[@matios6013]

Oh my god..🙄

[@emmasisson5205]

They paid him the right amount of money to act the fool. I don’t feel sorry for anyone on Amber’s side (including her). I look forward to seeing karma catch up with each of them.

[@jackiemarini3203]

Agree 💯

[@yusifamda]

he's giving expect evaluation based on $$$$s that is promised to him. i'm not sure he was ever paid by AH's team 🤣

[@carolleslie2673]

How can you say someone has mental health difficulties if you have never spoken to them!! That’s just ridiculous

[@allisworld1isme]

"under this rule, have you acted unethically?" This guy: ONCE UPON A TIME...

[@lostinpa-dadenduro7555]

When the psychiatrist is a crazy person. Omg

[@just_earth]

24:40

[@Cryptoversity]

I have only known 4 and they are all loop-nuts.

[@juliusjustin4813]

😅😅😅🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@AnOwlfie]

Imagine you're alone in a room with a guy like him and he's the one who's supposed to help you. The stuff of nightmares.

[@sharronpettis384]

😂👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻😳 YIKES!!!😵‍💫

[@amethyst5538]

As a psych patient that is the way I honestly feel watching this.....I am glad my psych is not like this. He has his quirks, but Lord Almighty.....

[@WalterWhite-hv7mk]

this is how you end up with a prescription that changes your brain chemistry at age 16

[@podnolej7784]

😆

[@kwilliams3094]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@deeestuary]

What I love about this lawyer is that he is always calm, polite and very knowledgeable about whatever subject the witness he’s questioning is supposed to be an expert in. So he starts slowly and you can see the witness relaxing thinking this is going to be easy - until, bang, he starts with the searching and pertinent questions! Compare that to 15 minutes of fame Elaine and did I read that right Rottenborn.

[@AAA-kr7nh]

Having his hands in pockets while questioning a witness is not polite.

[@CNCTEMATIC]

Jesus, Heard's team did a horrible job choosing experts. This guy comes across the exact opposite of an objective observer.

[@kristybarker924]

Maybe he's all they could afford 🤔.

[@normie2716]

Yes. He could be the most qualified person in his field, but if he comes across on the stand like a sloppy mess, that's exactly what the jury is going to think of him.

[@lilyparfait5789]

He’s exactly who comes to mind when someone says “evil scientist”

[@camillechandler4431]

What’s even more disturbing is that this man can prescribe medication to people….what kind of psychiatric treatment has he given???

[@kelseashifflett5457]

Dr Doofenshmirtz from Phineas & Ferb

[@zashiworld]

@@kelseashifflett5457 OMG i’ve been trying to figure out who he reminds me of & it’s exactly this

[@aleena7497]

you can talk about how obnoxious he acts without bringing up his appearance

[@queti1828]

😂

[@Leonardodeurena]

Imagine that this guy is your psychologist. You would leave his office feeling crazier than you went in. He's gaslighting the entire courtroom.

[@wolfwolf3741]

He is creepy

[@monicawaigwa8215]

Someone said he drove a patient to suicide and I can believe it.

[@erickaedwards4124]

He looks like he needs professional help 🤣 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@natizeethiopia7456]

😂😂 that's hilarious and good comment

[@saverespectlovebabiesanima7325]

Poor students!!!

[@hisham2k9]

"The code is more what you’d call ‘guidelines’ than actual rules" -Barbosa, Pirates of carribean. This guy's words reminded me of this dialog. 🤣

[@phily8093]

Instead of just answering the question, he is awkwardly and confusingly making it into The People vs Psychiatry.

[@reginaornelas3033]

This guy needs an evaluation I wouldn't want him as my doctor he's insane

[@joyous5507]

I totally agree !!

[@mymi6581]

I m french it s seem so strange!😱

[@Gmadeit]

Me tooooo

[@sarahsangi6505]

I totally agree

[@clairethingstobe6260]

Agreed 😆

[@sarahshah7932]

How in the world did Heard manage to surround herself with like minded individuals? I am absolutely astounded!!!

[@Hannah77ist]

Turds attract flies

[@xkrzilla]

Real recognise real 😂

[@ohslimgoody]

Birds of a feather syndrome 🤣

[@Evelinestv]

@@xkrzilla more like fake 😂😂😂

[@serfanishalostangi2452]

Rumours has it that her super rich baby daddy is financing all this

[@fijay2400]

This lawyer was excellent - knew when to let him ramble on, when to cut off and such precise questions.

[@deeestuary]

Yes - polite, calm and very knowledgable.

[@zak526]

The reason that her lawyers, experts, etc are so terrible is because she is lying. Any top lawyer would know in two seconds that she's lying. Who wants to work on a high profile case representing her besides the low hanging fruit.

[@tennesseeheckler3014]

It's amazing how every single lawyer and witness for Heard, are all a very similar type of person. Aggressive, arrogant, vain, and narcissistic.

[@chrismargaritis5297]

Including Amber as well 😂

[@purpleangel4]

100% Spot on lol birds of a feather flock together and all that 😂

[@luisapena3232]

Just like Amber💩

[@latetecita]

As well as LIARS.

[@The-Portland-Daily-Blink]

Very good observation, yes, yes, and yes!!

[@stephaniemccord6100]

He's a hostile witness and should be ignored.

[@firstlast8258]

witless

[@Django0324]

It's entertaining tho

[@janetallison4233]

Why so hostile and argumentive and on edge at the same time

[@weenfain2321]

I’ve held off commenting I watched this live and now rewatching. As someone whose diagnosed PTSD agoraphobia and anxiety disorder he made me almost bust my teeth grinding so nervous. I had a doctor/psychologist like this man years ago. I’m also type 1 diabetic really sick at one point and quite literally in complete renal failure (kidney failure) which will absolutely cause you to be confused weak etc. he told me it was just my PTSD and anxiety. Nothing more. Fast forward a week later I was rushed to the ER almost died stayed there almost 2 weeks was in complete renal failure at only 23 years old. But I trusted him and THAT is what is so dangerous about “professionals” like this guy. Now 35 and so thankful to find someone the exact opposite of this guy.

[@darlenehelisek5042]

Thank God you found good doctors that helped you.

[@BiggerFatterBlog]

This liar is a dangerous evil man and there’s no way he should be allowed to prescribe medication.

[@kimmyfreak200]

i kept thinking disney villain disney villain when he testified... then i knew what it was...his eyebrows, face, eyes and nose look similar to the witch from 1937 SNOW WHITE,...the apple witch

[@hfm1368]

His aggressiveness just confirmed his lack of credibility, honestly.

[@chrisbrantley_]

Hmmmm, seems familiar. Oh I know, just like AH. Yep that's it.

[@charleshudson2589]

He’s like a psycho

[@charleshudson2589]

Agreed

[@shanghunter7697]

In other words, the man IS a complete wack job. The man IS so stressed out he looks 85 instead of his 59. Stress = Stress.......The silent killer

[@jonbank7569]

CORRECT!!! 👍🏼

[@austinholmes751]

Starting to believe that Amber's team are getting their "experts" off of craigslist. I don't think a single one of them has either acted professionally or unbiased in this proceeding. It's actually insane.

[@lilithabunni]

while i’m starting to believe they are all actually on JD’s payroll 😂

[@beautyngadgets4947]

Nah im sure its from wish lmao

[@jonathandavidwilliam9154]

Hahahaha craiglist underrated comment

[@nardaboodram308]

Same here

[@realburglazofficial2613]

Either that, or they have trawled through the lists of medical professionals that have been struck off or fired for malpractice and got their ‘experts’ from there.

[@deadsexyears]

So creepy he refers to patients as victims

[@fabiof.8152]

He looks like a goddamn Disney villain, how ironic 😂

[@grey3414]

I imagine him to be a white older Jafar

[@JOMAR3]

LMAO

[@eh-i1841]

He’s like the bad brother of the doc in Back to the Future.

[@nataliebagshaw2773]

@@grey3414 😂😂😂😂

[@nataliebagshaw2773]

@@eh-i1841 😂😂😂😂

[@MsCammy22]

This case has really opened my eyes to how many “professional” people out there who are completely unethical and biased in their line of work. Lord knows how many regular folk these doctors have screwed over

[@43warriormode98]

Agree!!!

[@emp9413]

There's corrupt ppl in every industry. With enough money you can always find a puppy!

[@emp9413]

Puppet*

[@anoodalhasan7305]

Yeah it's scary

[@yanina6491]

you propably never lived with a junkie. so how can you tell his knowledge?

[@Leigh3420]

The look on Johnnys face is EPIC! Good for him for pursuing JUSTICE and doing it in the most professional way!!! I’m beyond happy for him, his lawyers, his children and all of his colleagues and fans!!!

[@colleenbrander8506]

I can't even imagine anyone going to this guy for help. He's seems like a nut case.

[@markeumir]

agree

[@wsbygt]

sure

[@who5542]

He is very analytical, that is exactly what you need in a psychiatrist. They objectively assess based on observation. I imagine he is great at his job but like many highly intellectual people with high IQs he seemingly lacks an equivalent EQ.

[@kimmyfreak200]

so what you are saying then miss is we might as well not ever get any help cuz they all have to be perfect right thats essentially what u are saying miss...(me doin' a speigel)

[@TheDOC18379]

I'm a consultant child and adolescent psychiatrist in the UK. We are not, I repeat, not allowed to prescribe medication, formulate or diagnose anyone without a face to face assessment. This guy and the American psychiatric association need to reevaluate how they conduct interventions.

[@holymoley6019]

In your expert experience would someone with tendencies like Amber have their 1 year old child removed from them?

[@bpxl53yewz29]

He's not abiding by the Amer Psychiatric Assoc's guidelines. He basically said they were wrong.

[@joyous5507]

Here here. Thank you for your input. 👍🏻

[@biscuit4259]

Love how many psychs of various fields are fascinated by this case.

[@leahcasell1487]

He is a nut job

[@fabhairwithbritt980]

This lawyer was genius. He let the witness make himself look like a narcissistic douche. His testimony about Johnny has no credibility.

[@deepz513]

Exactly....he is perfect display of narcissist.

[@Claudia-lq3ns]

He totally handed this dweeb a shovel and said "dig your own grave"...and he completely fell for it.

[@marinda3262]

Had the exact same thought

[@cacauvarela9347]

Yes. 👏👏

[@rwilson7197]

I hope so.

[@dannusmk1578]

Victims! He calls clients VICTIMS! “and by the way, I’ve testified to this before. I don’t expect perfection from my Victims” NOW THAT STATEMENT IS PROBLEMATIC!

[@kimmyfreak200]

exactly...they are patients

[@traceykibble7518]

Scary realisation of his mindset!

[@thumbwitch4607]

I'm embarrassed for him. He has made an utter fool of himself on the stand here, and it will be around for a long time. I'd say he's trashed his career by this testimony.

[@SW_investor]

Dear God, 25 years as a medical health professional, I can attest that this man should in fact be a patient himself. This was cringy and unbearable and I don’t recall him answering a single question legitimately.

[@reereno9178]

Do the world a favor and turn him in!!!!!

[@aliciasantos9694]

That's right, nothing got answered 😜🤪😳

[@DJSouthFlorida]

I don’t know why people get hung up when a person cringe themself. I take it as the perfect time to get some popcorn 🍿 going and have some cold 🥶 grape soda on stand by.

[@sweetestaphrodite]

@@DJSouthFlorida Yeak okay, it’s entertaining to watch but these are real people and this is a very real thing. This guy is a “professional” psychiatrist. He actually works with vulnerable people when he’s this type of person? It’s wrong and concerning-to put it mildly.

[@despawned39]

He's probably just coked out of his mind and has problems following his own train of thought and keeping it structured 😂

[@bpxl53yewz29]

This guy is only 59 but looks 90. He's so belligerent and arrogant. How can he diagnose someone he has never seen or talked to, just based on hearsay from media and AH's team?

[@helensandberg]

Wierd and wrong!!

[@lynnegullion-realtor2880]

he sounds like an old insane a$$ arrogant and not mentally well - wow - matches the ah side completely

[@deniseochoa3817]

Could be the THOUSANDS of DOLLARS he receives for his testimony

[@lynnegullion-realtor2880]

exactly - what an insane man

[@kathyverderame3641]

When he said he is 59 I thought I must have misheard this. He looks closer to 75.

[@chrisjenkins203]

If I was on this jury, I would be dismissing ANYTHING this narcissistic “Doctor” says and dismiss his answers from being credible. He is one of the most arrogant and unlikeable people I’ve ever seen or listened to.

[@amandalerouxpeters2684]

Thank you for calling him a narcissist! Omg this is hard to listen to.

[@weenfain2321]

They always think they’re the smartest people in the room cannot stand being confronted or told they’re wrong. THIS is what happens when you confront a narcissist and it’s wild to me almost every witness her team had are so much like her. Even her lawyers.

[@morgancox5241]

This man is part of the reason why many people do not get help with mental health.

[@BHappy2Day]

This "Dr" is using the strategy "if you can't convince them, confuse them"

[@Black-bn6ic]

Wild Old Man used confusion. But it failed. Wild Old Man is now confused. It hurt itself in it's confusion. Wild Old Man fainted. Johnny Depp gained 50 million exp. What!? Johnny Depp is evolving! Duu Duu Duu DuDuDuDuDuDu Duduu! Congratulations! Your Johnny Depp evolved into Jack Sparrow! Do you want to rename Jack Sparrow? It's now Captain Jack Sparrow!

[@Darci3333]

Yes....the if you can't dazzle them with brilliance baffle them with BS🙃🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@daddytheman9957]

This guy is a perfect example of everything that is wrong with my field and why so many psychologists and psychiatrists are perceived as nut jobs. What a disservice to our profession.

[@bigbusiness7035]

Okay Daddy the Man

[@lots33ml]

Bingo

[@Boca7289]

Just a little bit.. 😅 But in your defence, it can’t be easy either to deal with some very challenging people on a daily basis…

[@howarddavies136]

However the psychologist that served as Depp's witness was pure professionalism and class.

[@goreyboyz8564]

To be fair, this guy looks crazy as hell. The way he glares at the camera

[@marieb3630]

He’s the doctor to tell you you’re wrong about what you’re feeling. How does this man help anyone? The craziest thing is that he’s getting paid for this.

[@gamegreed9105]

And good for him he should be getting paid for this maybe not $1,000 an hour like the other doctors have got paid..

[@marieb3630]

@@gamegreed9105 hopefully you won’t have a doctor like him. Ever behave in this manner

[@gamegreed9105]

@@marieb3630 yeah I think it's common for people that have mental health problems to become a psychiatrist I think he needs a psychiatrist himself

[@mzmartin8115]

And he thinks he's good at it

[@marieb3630]

@@mzmartin8115 yes,

[@dreavanscott7876]

If he is so argumentative and aggressive to people in court, imagine how abusive he is to vulnerable people coming to him for treatment. I bet he has a lot of suicides i his patients. He is not coming across as calm, helpful, caring or professional. He should be struck off ASAP

[@cheerybb5247]

Either a lot of suicides or the other kicker he sends everyone who seems “off” immediately to the psychiatric ward because he can neither tell whether they’re truly at risk of harming themselves or he doesn’t give 1 fk and sends them to the mental hospital to save his skin from anyone committing suicide under his care :))))

[@cheerybb5247]

People like him have actively harmed me and my mental health with this exact kind of attitude and treatment. He should NOT be practicing.

[@khiljinagor8976]

Actually I saw in another site that he was googled and his practice is full of bad reviews including one of the guardians of his victims, who was a suicidal patient and they died and during the last days he was not responding to their calls and ignoring their cries for help and the victim died in the end, and how he doesn't cure them but just puts them on Meds.

[@jamesmckellar2784]

I am a clinical psychologist, and I do quite a bit of forensic work. I cannot imagine any circumstance in which I would diagnose a client I have not personally evaluated. He is blatantly incorrect to testify that such actions are appropriate, he is laughable.

[@ekb6212]

Thanks James. I was look for a voice of reason and searched comments for it. :)

[@pianogal879]

So it isn’t a standard practice? I am clueless in that regard. I would have thought in order to testify that an expert would need to evaluate a person. Why would he be allowed to testify if he is just looking at opinions?

[@DelphinesHandcrafted]

Thank you for the weigh in. Any of us within the mental health field should not diagnose without personally evaluating.

[@rogeriopenna9014]

the argument seems to be the difference between evaluating and diagnosing. but he uses do many double negatives i dont even know anymore "if you are not saying that you are not considering that I may or may not be diagnosing or not diagnosing, then under no circumstance i will not disagree to agree with what you were not saying, quite the contrary" needs a dialogue map to be understood

[@reinaldodesouza2355]

There is already a mechanism in place where the court would order an evaluation if it deems appropriate, in which case this "expert witness" would be able to make a more accurate statement. What he is arguing about surely amounts to defending hearsay being taken as valid evidence

[@TheMegakwan123]

6 minutes in and I am already shocked by the level of unprofessionalism and aggression projected by this “doctor”

[@anaishac.2884]

I’m 6 minutes in and I’m like 😳 how is this allowed

[@janettelloyd1551]

The Judge keeps warning him just to answer the question but he literally cant help himself.

[@GrifoStelle]

I'm at the 4 minute mark and the snark and hostility is stunning. The lawyer is incredibly anxious.

[@irenesantos2205]

Maybe he’s the one taking those drugs with Amber or he’s one of those men inside the elevator wt Amber like Elon and Franco😉

[@Martina-Kosicanka]

He acts like if they dressed a homeless alcoholic into a suit on their way to the court

[@oliviax4165]

The audiences reactions are killing me 😭😭

[@brockbaker3able]

One thing I know about trials is a lawyer never lets a witness go on like this unless they are digging themselves a hole. They stick to yes or no unless they know the witness it harming their own case.

[@eagledude5353]

This was low key genius. This lawyer could of shut him down but they let him act like an argumentative jerk and go on rants about nothing. No way does anyone take anything he said seriously after that display

[@piggdrimz]

I honestly didn't understand a thing. 😭 he gives me anxiety with his delivery

[@BuckleBunny]

@@piggdrimz you would need therapy after going to him for therapy.

[@firsttogo8371]

He may have even talked himself out of his professional licenses, or at least his reputation

[@eagledude5353]

Dude used Pirate movies to diagnose Depp and got mad when asked if he also watched Wonka 🤣

[@lea-anne9133]

Just like the woman he testifying for.. he reminded me ALOT of her!!!

[@truffleshuffl]

Really hope this trial opens peoples eyes as to what it means to have a doctorate. If you don’t like your doctor and suspect he’s an idiot, get a new doctor.

[@kenosabi]

Yep and always seek a second opinion when something comes across as strange. These people aren't geniuses- many of them like this guy are coked out ego maniacs.

[@shantiestrife1727]

Ahahaha

[@jv-ep2tc]

I have said much the same thing on another page on YT....I said I interview a doctor if I am seeing someone new like a dermatologist. If I do not like their personality or if they are disrespectful, I cancel. I literally walked out on a doctor in Swampscott MA after sitting in a small room for 20 minutes and being well beyond my appointment time. He called me on my cell phone when I was driving home. I told him "you know I own a business and I cannot be late to this extent, Others are waiting for me". I never went back. I also do not follow their advice [sometimes] and have signed many a waiver. I got major blow back for these remarks.

[@Virgo-zx3ez]

👏 👏 👏 👏

[@tina7151]

And good doctors actually want you to have second opinion

[@PawpkornVisuals]

LOL Imagine the judge ordered for this Dr. to have his license evaluated after this.. This is embarrassing

[@jmltorres6659]

This psychiatrist is a complete joke! I think the jury was having a blast at this whole cross-examination. It's unbelievable!

[@nourxnf]

That clown did NOT answer one question from Johnny’s lawyer, he was literally attacking the lawyer and being so aggressive towards him, this is a very horrible person, once he lost his cool he exposed himself to the jury, and never looked at them again until the end, we can thank him for his service for Johnny depp.

[@cubemissy]

Cue Black Widow: "Thank you for your cooperation."

[@optimusprime3413]

"Clown" best describes this witness....

[@BigRenz69]

Depp is a rapist. He should be in jail

[@Claudia-lq3ns]

"Clown" is the best descriptor for this dweeb.

[@cordingkarma1139]

"Clown" is the best analogy for this Einstein wannabe

[@doriskovalcik442]

This dude thinks he’s smarter than anyone else. He is arrogant and his word is the only one that is correct. And he likes the sound of his own voice.

[@karenwarren8650]

isn't that a trait of being a narcissist?

[@teresalovelove1677]

HEAR HEAR ..Soo true!!

[@alisonmoulton9939]

Just like AH. He was that arrogant and obnoxious that the judge even reprimanded him twice

[@marypoppins5146]

Just like Amber 😁

[@rebus1993]

Like my friend who is psychologist, exactly same..threyre always right this career destroyed him as a person

[@TChighbury]

"Doc, I need to talk" "Sure, tell me what happened" "Well I was rehearsing a play..." "What the hell are you talking about?"

[@matthewcordscott2066]

I’m on Johnny’s side 100%. If Amber wants to sue anyone when this is over, she should sue her legal team-because these expert witnesses are making her look a damn idiot-they are defaming her more than anyone 🤣🤣🤣

[@killyourtelevision999]

CONSIDER: someone on Heard’s team thought it a good idea to hire this witness. Incredible.

[@MultitudeOfChaos]

THIS. As I commented on this video before. Why does amber heards lawyer never take character likability in consideration when choosing their witnesses? Do they not understand that they have to appeal to a jury, a group of people that are going to develop opinions based off not just information but also impression? All of their witnesses, except for maybe doctor Moore have acted entitled, rough and just rude sometimes. All of this is taken into account when taking a decision. As much as we try to be impartial, as humans it’s impossible not to be a bit biased. These witnesses are not working in her favor.

[@kathydulac8820]

😂 so true!

[@hatsuzuki_9610]

who does not want a Rick in their team😉

[@blazednlovinit]

He should have been with JD in fear and loathing, he has that kind of "professional fallen to the dark side" kind of vibe to him.

[@lumutu6479]

I think it's more like "This witness is the only one who accepted our bribery and is willingly to commit perjury". They don't choose their witnesses really, they just have to use what they got. Which is not much, considering most people would find Amber's side unethical.

[@lovelovelove3735]

THIS DOCTOR IS TRYING TO IMPRESS AMBER AND HER TEAM BUT COMING OUT LIKE A CRAZY PERSON!? HOW IRONIC...

[@undefinedsaika]

and Crazy is the benchmark to impress them

[@cherylpinnock6313]

You are so right ✅

[@Anisky123]

Bahahahaha and he looks like he hasn’t showered or is crazy I can’t tell..

[@kandacenfoster53]

🤣

[@joanasangma4818]

Hahaha how true ,I find him like a crazy Dr from some Psycho movies.

[@MrC8025]

depp's assistant was working hard holding in the laughter.

[@400_billion_suns]

This guy is an embarrassment to his profession. With a personality like his, he should not be treating anyone.

[@Belliger1991]

You missed this: 20:57 "I don't expect perfection from my victims" Where the hell does that come from oO

[@darma99]

I can't believe this person have a patient. Are that patients survive?

[@markusaralius]

He looks, and talks and acts like the person that should be "under treatment".

[@liadown9052]

Psychiatrists don't treat. They're drug dealers.

[@markusaralius]

@@liadown9052 I absolutely agree with you, but apparently KZbin does not, they've dissapeared your comment. It's getting worse (their hysterical censorship) by the hour. I'm sure this reply will probably be ghosted as well.

[@JonnyHicksNZ]

This guy is unstable. Great job by the lawyer showing the jury he’s not a credible witness.

[@jv-ep2tc]

credible. agreed, he isn't

[@exmachin3926]

The lawyer asked simple questions, the witness tip toed around each question like he was playing the floor is lava. Dude was also noticeably passive aggressive and arrogant.

[@pattyLOVE0815]

@@exmachin3926 no, the lawyers use sensationalism. they basically just ask "if you were killing a person, would you then be a murderer?" lawyer wants to make him say "yes". so that the dumbos who are listening think he said "yes" to being a murderer.

[@3dmodelguy21]

Someone needs to give him a drug test....

[@markharbour5175]

The simple rule is. Ask not what your doctor can do for you, ask him what he thinks of you

[@jessicaj2000]

My partner was seeing a therapist. She told him he didn’t have a drinking problem. Now he is in AA. Keep your head up! There is help out there just keep looking and don’t give up.

[@brenchengbrencheng4794]

I dont understand. She told who that HE DIDNT HAVE A DRINKING PROBLEM? Why does it has anything to do with this man or the interview anyway by all means?

[@kristyanderson9394]

I’m incredulous that this man is actually a professional in psychiatry. Wow!

[@cklounge2096]

Johnny’s psychologist was straight to the point, factual, kind, and respectful. Ambers psychologist just comes off as one sided, aggressive and incredibly disrespectful. Her entire argument is a huge joke.

[@AuskaDezjArdamaath]

He comes off as needing a psychiatrist himself 🤦

[@yolieswitzer9466]

He is pompous!

[@carolynbell7403]

These are the ppl AH keeps company with.

[@Beansprout.2131]

@@AuskaDezjArdamaath 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@amandajohnson691]

Narcissist say what? lol I didn't get to see the entire testimony because I had work I needed to finish. :( It was pure entertainment.

[@marcusthompson548]

That lawyer is smart. He allowed the guy to speak so everyone could see how "unhinged" he appeared to be.

[@ItsLikeFerrari]

Exactly!!!!!

[@britneedee88]

It’s crazy this man is a psych dr. He’s clearly tweaking on something and is not all sane to have people under his care. The inmates are officially running the asylum.

[@CptDallas]

Great hair for trying to say your sane and an expert! 😄😅🤣😂

[@jenniferbaker9697]

This is horrifying. This man did not answer a question, at all. He’s angry, argumentative AND perjured himself! No one in that jury box is going to take anything he said as relevant, or comprehensible.

[@BeelzeBob420]

& may need a psychiatric evaluation himself. ?

[@jasonspades5628]

He actually did answer the question. A few times. And people who don't study syllogistic structure, propositional logic or law wouldn't be able to identify what a logical fallacy is. Imagine if I asked you, "When did you stop beating up children?" You notice how the question also makes an assertion that forces you to agree with it in order to answer it? It's called a presuppositional fallacy.

[@aimeeevoliowlsaresocutewhe9121]

I agree. He is talking in medical terms. Not in lay terms that everyone can understand.

[@microspect]

Like Biden

[@OnlyThe1Son]

you can bring 1000 experts in his field and they will answer the same..

[@nathalielima2184]

The best part of this was when the judge said “Doctor, you’re gonna just have to answer the question.” I’m so glad someone said it

[@miaaa333_x]

Time stamp ? Sorry I just want to watch it over and over again with a smile on my face

[@dinoclimaco3780]

@@miaaa333_x 13:09

[@milenka4782]

Isn't it? Wtf is he talking about??? So aggressive! -"AGAIN!!!! WELL again!!!"

[@joincoffee9383]

The judge should kick him out of the court room. He wasn’t talking with logic and reasoning. He’s just Mad making all the time.

[@TjMoon91]

@@miaaa333_x and again at 19:10

[@firewalker1372]

This guy has absolutely no business doing what he is doing. Wow, this guy is a real piece of work. He placed his ignorance on display for the whole world to see. Hope his patients seen this and decided to see someone else.

[@OliverMoore1973]

Or become cured...🙃

[@Lucifer-fj7mg]

it’s his victim not patient

[@khiljinagor8976]

That's if his victims are still alive.

[@firewalker1372]

@@Lucifer-fj7mg Thanks for the correction 😂.

[@jetroar17]

He singlehandedly discredited all of Amber's "expert witnesses" as paid guns for hire that will say anything for their client's money. Completely dishonest, biased and unprofessional! He should be ashamed....

[@lovelyb6140]

Bulls eye... My thoughts exactly

[@Le0Nocapri0]

Every person that’s on “her side” is in someway, unhinged. “Birds of a feather”

[@macdieter23558]

Flog them together!!!

[@lindabell5534]

It's very much happens that when you have a narcissistic control they collect that type of person to support them.

[@giddensb1]

He is an odd bird for sure

[@alf3071]

best comment of the week award goes to K D

[@joincoffee9383]

@@lindabell5534 that’s called flying monkeys of the narcissist “OZ”.

[@whatduck943]

I am genuinely impressed by the amount of 'experts' that are damaging their professional reputations for AH.

[@maxp6174]

so true

[@TheCherrykye]

It's shining a light on these unethical medical professionals, it's good stuff, hope their patients get proper help they need and go to a decent doctor cause it scares me that people like him and those other doctors diagnose other people.

[@thevarraajsmuniandy2821]

Maybe they the experts failed to sold their entire career

[@Leon-mw4bf]

Totally agree.

[@indigowolf8712]

Remember the Opiod Crisis when medical professionals were drug dealers? Or how they have treated Black people including disgusting experiments, or the fact that they havent all gone on strike due to medical insurance and insulin prices etc. I believe it.

[@rjlchristie]

This was the guy who always argued with the teacher at school and university because he knew better than the teacher. Everybody has met him at some stage in their lives..

[@icantthinkofacooname3025]

He is the kind of guy that walks around and says to people I’m an expert witness.

[@nikhilchandra9258]

This doctor looks like he is on trial himself for something miserable the way he is so animated while defending his point

[@lostinpa-dadenduro7555]

He gravy train of getting money for quack testimony is threatened. That seems to be his main concern.

[@bhuvanpathak6205]

🤣🤣🤣

[@marcobhuachalla9814]

Because he's lying and cracking under the pressure!

[@nourzaher2168]

Soooo Right 😂😂😂😂

[@ch0wned]

@@lostinpa-dadenduro7555 KA-BOOM It’s called Professional Witnessing.

[@sameenarif657]

imagine a person with anxiety going to him, the way he speaks would actually make him worse than getting better 😭

[@lucialangs6402]

I get anxious just trying to listen to him... Agg

[@kc3654]

I am so triggered just watching him that i need to turn it off before it even finishes

[@ellie.M.mae.]

@@kc3654 oh gosh! Me too! I can't watch it any longer. I feel so uncomfortable, and idk why😭😑😖

[@delilakiss7058]

He is like a walking trigger for my anxiety, so aggressive and unsettling by simply watching him speak

[@jacobsed6665]

OMG THIS GUY MAKES ME FEEL SO ANXIOUS. How is he even able to practice?

[@marydeedempsey5081]

This psychiatrist's practicing license needs to be seriously questioned.

[@joek9743]

Johnny's legal team are definitely earning their money!! They've been incredibly professional and extremely well prepared for this whole case so far.

[@justpaul3451]

He seems like the kind of guy who was a patient in a high security psych ward, broke out and put on a suit, imitating the people who evaluating him, just to a higher extreme.

[@monicaperrin8178]

Please stop 🤣😂🤣😂

[@monicaperrin8178]

JustPaul you gave me a good laugh

[@elsaaryndale4014]

Another commenter said, the real psych is in his office chilling. He sent his worst patient to do the testimony. 😂😂😂

[@Islam_78681]

Lol 😂

[@mrssassy9324]

I said the same thing. He’s a nut job!!

[@japu2350]

Why is every single witness of AH team sound so arrogant, aggressive and in denial?

[@maddiehorror2698]

When you get payed of to lië in court you will get verry defensive and aggressive because you sh*t scared😂

[@joyous5507]

I don't know who is worse with dodging and manipulating questions.... Ms Heard or Dr. David Spiegel??????

[@RossAllaire]

Like attracts like.

[@the1only467]

@@maddiehorror2698, English can’t be your first language. I don’t even know how to read what you’ve written.

[@sarahsangi6505]

Because they are copy of her

[@bangcockdangerous7462]

It is people like this that make me believe that a doctorate must be fairly easy to get.

[@ditzygypsy]

Some places in the US do make it easy. But not in all countries. In Canada you have to have a master’s degree just to be a nurse. Anything less is an LPN or Candy Striper.

[@effervescentevanescenttran6331]

It actually is, just need time and money.

[@kristybarker924]

He keeps saying if you're reading it. He acts like he doesn't know what it says, unless he's reading it.

[@elaineng9714]

This is literally the best representation of the saying “if you can’t convince them, confuse them”.

[@HoneySun16]

Omg yes I was so confused 😐

[@pulengjoyce2785]

😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 seriously!!!

[@jesusloverjehovah3005]

😂😅🤣

[@eritreasunshine]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@dntwachmewachtv4644]

😭😭🤣😭🤣

[@MartineH1]

I am so amazed by the Amber's team capacity to destroy their own case finding this kind of people to "help" them.

[@ryshilicaproni2297]

People hire those that are an extension of themselves And wow does it speak volumes of Amber

[@reannamendenhall9475]

I honestly think they're trying to swing for a mistrial smh

[@marifollett]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@worddrivenwomenforjesus]

Yeah it really looks like they are secretly on JD's side... Or extremely stupid. No one can like this guy

[@sabinamakubo926]

@@ryshilicaproni2297 yes yes it does

[@common12]

Truly a very dangerous man! I pity his patients.

[@kegsmogsx2839]

Too many emotions…he’s irate, over excited, immature very unprofessional but believes we think he’s super smart🙄 so who’s deluded now Doc’? Disgrace to the profession 😒

[@scottyb.8710]

You never, ever make a diagnosis of someone without actually directly assessing them regardless of how much evidence exists.

[@tuforu4]

Very BRAINEY AMERICANS

[@SW-oy5zw]

Technically it is not required, and since doctors were not allowed to see patients face to face during the pandemic in many cases, I’m sure MANY diagnoses were made remotely. It is common practice for actors/elite to receive a remote consult.

[@indigowolf8712]

Ok, but what if you think you remember seeing them in a movie or commercial one time? /s lol

[@darma99]

Except diagnosis that doctor. I'm not even an expert on anything but I sure 100% he is crazy.

[@Belliger1991]

Wtf 20:57 "I don't expect perfection from my victims" I would not call it a diagnosis after that sentence at all...

[@toddhoward1498]

My man straight up walked into court, gave an opinion based off of how he felt about Pirates of the Caribbean and said it was his professional opinion. Dude just sabotaged his own career.

[@tested211]

I wonder if he thought the "mad professor" angle would make it ok?

[@adrikkrakhim1]

Hey.... IT... JUST...WORKS! ;)

[@Codduct]

@@tested211 don't start

[@MakeMagic]

He's probably only a few years from retirement and a fat pension. Probs just wanted a laugh.

[@paulod27]

Dr Spiegel acts like an eccentric character that Johnny Depp would play in the movies lol.

[@megantan6557]

Incredible lawyer

[@yanzi4555]

The degree of unprofessionalism demonstrated by this so-called expert is shocking. The fact that he was not afraid of presenting a baseless conclusion/opinion in court in such an unprofessional manner is mind-blowing.

[@hollyk7052]

And on such a public scale, with arrogance!

[@iclaudius2534]

15 minutes of fame.

[@amindha6224]

@@hollyk7052 he need some milk

[@hollyk7052]

@@iclaudius2534 infamy lol

[@AbeldeBetancourt]

Not shocking to me. So is everyone surrounding Miss Heard's defamation campaign.

[@joseh3564]

Just watching this doctor for a few minutes (fast talking, nervous movements, messy hair), I asked myself "What drugs is he on?" Wow!!!

[@gimsagogo]

time travel side effect bro..

[@Anonymous25248]

😂 right!

[@teresalovelove1677]

He really is disheveled..wild hair wild eyes over the top exaggerated movement...LMAO ..he's bobbing and weaving.

[@lrose1046]

right...definitely on drugs lol

[@lynnegullion-realtor2880]

right! did you the mouth thing he just did! he should be in a sick hospital!