Killer Assassin Snails - Shrimp Keeping Myths

[@LupDiesel]

Check out our collection of snails on our website. flipaquatics.com/collections/all-snails

[@louieryder7106]

I realize it is pretty randomly asking but does anyone know a good site to watch newly released series online ?

[@kingstonroland7371]

@Louie Ryder Flixportal :D

[@louieryder7106]

@Kingston Roland thanks, I signed up and it seems to work :D Appreciate it!

[@kingstonroland7371]

@Louie Ryder You are welcome =)

[@HyPn0o]

Been keeping Assasin Snails for years in my tanks, never seen them attack any living shrimp or suffered strange losses within tanks stocked with Assasins. They only eat dead shrimp, dead fish, but most random was to find one eating a dead houselfy; which somehow managed to get under the aquarium hood, then drowned and sunk...

[@AquaPeet]

11:51 A-HA! They ate those shrimp because the shrimp were theirs... see? I eat my shrimp too. If it were my wife's shrimp, oh boy, I'd be in trouble... so I won't eat those. LOL Great video!!! I love hearing these Myth buster stories from an experienced shrimp keeper/breeder. And you tell it very entertainingly... if that's an existing word.

[@xanderkaz8927]

Maybe the assassin snails were eating the weak shrimp so that's why the colony was the best

[@StevesRealWorld]

Very good point!

[@sofiakaos5278]

That was my first tought at first but no the snails prob ate plenty of baby shrimps in between the bigger ones whatever comes close to them they eat if its meat

[@sasori144]

PreciousMetalStacker 2000 or maybe the left over bois bonded together stronger through mutual loss

[@markvickery5894]

Sasori my fav comment lol

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Loving these shrimp-keeping myths videos! Learning a lot about shrimp.

[@chevy1514]

Good video. I have been keeping shrimp for less than a year, and you have answered a lot of good questions/myths i have been reading about.

[@stealthjoe]

Exactly! Agree with you. I recently put 2 Assassin's snails inside my shrimp only tank. A few days later, I had a hollowed out shrimp with water fully inside. Tried querying about this in a few forums and didn't get any response. A week later noted another shrimp dead. This time noted that the shrimp was stuck to a goo or mucus like substance. I remember seeing this on the foot of the snails. Promptly removed the snails for good. So it is a myth that Assassin's snail cant catch a shrimp. It can do so if it wanted to - using its goo.

[@saundrabush236]

Great information. Not a shrimp owner but really enjoy watching them, they're beautiful and interesting.

[@rodneythompson3913]

That's why it's important to feed a powdered food so the food goes to the young and they don't have to fight for food

[@PRJsince1990]

I keep Reds, Oranges and Amano Shrimp in a tank with Trumpet snails and Assassin Snails. Heavily planted low tech tank, no issues whatsoever. I've seen the video where one attacks a shrimp but that shrimp was mid-molt (or dying, I forget exactly) so it was a unique circumstance they blew out of proportion.

[@davidch8040]

Is it ideal if you keep three types in the same tank.? Mix breeding happens.?

[@purplelovebetta1030]

Awesome video. Thanks for sharing the facts and clearing out the most controversial myths :)

[@matthewray5954]

Thanks Flip. Great video as always 👍

[@jokubasjankauskas]

AWESOME !!!! good work diesel :) ,i always wondered about the assasin snails :) , thanks for the help.

[@breedingfauna3732]

If you want to prevent this aggression between shrimps, I witness it too in my CRS tanks, try to crush your food. Do it with a spoon or something, and place the food on an oak leaf or something if you have a soil so it doesnt sink into your bottom. This really helps. Food for babies needs to be dust, I do it 2/3x a day and it really helps. I have had like 300 shrimp now from 5 CRS females within 3 months... All have grown up nicely and are nearly adult.

[@jetjazz05]

There's a couple videos on this channel about Bacter AE, that stuff is pretty awesome, my shrimp all love it and it's a fine white powder that's supposedly dried up biofilm, when you put it in the water it clouds it up with dust sized particles and the shrimp literally don't even have to move, they just catch it as it drifts through the water or as it lands at their feet. This food in particular has been impressive to me because I haven't seen a single shrimp on shrimp aggression since I got the food. It's expensive, 25-30 us dollars depending on where and when you get it, but a 70 gram jar will do ~140 spoon full feedings, although unless you've got more than 50 shrimp you really only need half a spoonful, so you can get 250 or so days out of $30 worth of it, so for me it's worth it.

[@alixxworkshop846]

WOOW!!! I didnt know that Anatome Helena eat shrimps... I've seen mini puffer fish eating them and Molly's nut snails? This is a good to know,THANK YOU!

[@nickk4010]

Thanks for the video Rob, Lots of great info, I learned a lot!

[@michaelmathes1991]

Thanks I just learned a lot about shrimp. Started a 15 gallon with about 17 Cherry Shrimp. It has a few cory's in it and 7 emperor tetras. My newest will have only have Shrimp and is 7.5 gallons.

[@OutlawCaliber13]

I had about 15-20 ghost shrimp. Had 4 assassin snails. Or I thought I did. Turned out to be around 10. I put in feeder snails for the assassins. I figured it would be enough to keep them going for a while. Also had some mystery snails. My assassins cleared out all of the feeders(ramshorn), three mystery snails, then my ghost shrimp started disappearing. Yeah, they'll eat shrimp. I've been told it's rare. Apparently I got the aggressive gene pool in my tank.

[@himlolo]

You can’t say for sure that it was from the assassin snails.

[@OutlawCaliber13]

@@himlolo I can, actually, cause I've seen it.

[@himlolo]

@@OutlawCaliber13 could be already about to die shrimp. There is 0 way a healthy shrimp can be caught from an assassin snail. They don’t have a paralyzing venom. The only way they catch other snails is because they’re too slow to get away. If a ghost shrimp gets caught by an assassin snail it was already too far gone.

[@OutlawCaliber13]

@@himlolo kzbin.info/www/bejne/hYGWXoOLd8SNpbs&ab_channel=ProfilesAquatica

[@OutlawCaliber13]

@@himlolo kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y6mtZoeQnbOgiNE&ab_channel=ShrimpMania

[@saraking7007]

I have assassin snails and red cherry shrimp haven't had any problems

[@swagatosidbanerjee]

IM GONA ALSO KEEP THEM TOGETHER SHOULD I KEEP ASSASIAN SNAIL AND MINE SMALL ASSASIAN DIDNT COME OUT FOR 1 WEEK IS HE DEAD HOW CAN I MEND ALL THESE

[@TheNielsAlmelo]

WHY T F DO YOU TYPE ALL CAPS

[@josevargas2345]

Assaying snails will only eat shrimp if they don’t get enough snails to eat

[@geist41334]

@@josevargas2345 They have no chance to catch a healthy, living shrimp. They don't have paralyzing venom or any other instrument to keep the shrimp from escaping and get through their chitin shell. If you know how they actually kill snails, you understand that they are no danger to active animals like shrimp or fish. They do eat dead or dying shrimp, which actually is a good thing.

[@kapil509]

My red shrimps clean the shells of my assassin snails... How about that... One was even pregnant I didn't see the youngs though bc there are neon tetra too may be they ate them

[@tapewormsandstoplights2868]

In my 55 gallon I had a huge breeding colony of RCS. Farther along the road I had a very large bladder snail explosion so I got 3 assassin snails. The assassin snails laid eggs and there were over a hundred of them. After a short amount of time all of the bladder snails were dead and the assassins needed some food, so they started going for the shrimp. There were lots of plants that the snails had trouble navigating, so they struggled to get the shrimp and almost all of the snails died. I actually ended up making some necklaces with the shells of the dead snails. Even after all of that my shrimp are doing better than ever.

[@T0tenkampf]

I love all the comments here of dudes with a 20 gallon aquarium telling this guy that he is wrong about assassin snails right after he mentions he has 100 shrimp tanks and 30 assassin tanks.

[@PedroGomez-eq3sn]

Nice video, I like this serie a lot, very interesting. Thanks for sharing mate !!!!

[@mammav2]

Thanks for clarifying the water changing issue!

[@JohnT2088]

They do kill and eat shrimp but rarely happens since they are too slow to catch them. The one got eaten are Mainly the slower and weaker shrimp. Seen it before.

[@StevesRealWorld]

I like to remind people that Assassin snails do not need other snails to eat to survive. They will eat different things including spirulina pellets. They also never bother my larger Nerite snails. Great video!

[@HappyAquatic]

Great video! Question is it advisable to remove dead shrimps in a 10 gallons tank with about 30+ live shrimps or just leave it there for the rest to feed on?

[@Andrew-mm5qn]

Thank you for making then stream at 6:30. the walking dead is at 9 so I wont miss it !lol

[@kapil509]

RCS and assassin go along just fine. Assassin snails are widely misunderstood they only eat what is dead or dying and of course other live snails.. My snails don't attack my RCS ...this is a fact I had 8 shrimp and three died due to water parameters I added snails after that and I have not seen a dead shrimp since then. The hollow skin which he discussed is actually exoskeleton which shrimps keep on removing from time to time and yes assassin snails will eat those exoskeletons

[@Tobikitty]

I have a 3 gallon nano with cherry shrimp and about 10 assign snails. The have cohabitated for two years without any issues. I do have a ton of plants and a piece of wood.

[@Sea-cucumber1151]

Did you find molts, like when they were the weakest? I have so many ramshorn, so I don’t think mine ever have because they have too many snails.

[@VaporsChoiceMrTestIt]

I Subscribe and hit the bell. I am a fan sor shrimps. I have 30 red shrimpsand I want to start to breed them with different different shrips. If you have any idea on which color I should get to make blue and spotted white please let me know. I'm willing to buy a couple to try to get started. Please respond and help me on this mission. Thank you.

[@Crustahuis]

Thanks nice video! I do keep anatome helena in my shrimp tank for now just one. The other anatome helenas are moved to the big fishtank. I keep my eye on that snail :-)

[@neilcox2739]

Really helpful video. Thanks!

[@animestop95]

Not only was this useful information, but you are adorable! Win-win

[@VintageXV]

Straight facts

[@bojohannesen4352]

Ok, creep

[@sirpfa]

Which of the cleaning snails do get a long the best with shrimps?

[@tizok100]

I have guppies with shrimp, so nitrates will build, what is the highest nitrates should climb I my tank ?

[@travishemming3783]

I've only had shrimp for 11 days now. I got a neocaridina mix of about 80 shrimp, and some came berried. On day 8, I noticed the first babies. The next day, I had just fed and was enjoying watching them eat. A large one comes along on a leaf and picks up a baby, and it looks like it's rolling it around near its mouth. Having read that neos don't eat the babies unless they're really starving, I keep watching, expecting the little one to appear somewhere close by. I never saw it again. With all those legs moving, it was hard to make out the details of what was happening. So while I'm not completely sure it was eaten, it sure looked like that's what happened.

[@xSean145]

The Anubias myth came from a youtube video where a guy had a tank stock full of CRS and he rescaped with ALOT of anubias cuttings and then the day after hes tank was a total graveyard. Dunno wether it was the anubias or someting else but it was sad to se.

[@heatherwanderer777]

guess it depends on if he bought the anubias from someone, and it might have been contaminated, or if he had it in another of his own nonshrimp tanks and he was using non shrimp safe ferts on it in the other tank. Lots of ways that it could have happened that had nothing to do with the plant cuttings themselves. But thanks for sharing cause I'd never heard about the Anubias myth til today.

[@sdqsdq6274]

you do know crs is more sensitive then cherry shrimps , nanas release saps when trim

[@KaPika735]

This was really helpful to me as a new shrimp owner, thank you!

[@m1964c]

Am curious if there were other snails in the tank for the assassins to eat. I love them but I don’t trust them even w/other snails in my tank to eat w/my shrimp. Just my opinion.

[@katerinamanou8691]

Hello! Great info, love the channel!! I have a 45L aquarium, where I keep nano fish and neocaridinas. The fish don't hurt them but they keep dying. I have lots of plants, wood, moss, everything should be fine. I don't understand what goes wrong. Could weekly water changes kill them? I change about 20% every week. Hope you see this and answer. Many thanks!

[@CryMoreShrimps]

Another great video!!! Thx

[@wierdsnake]

With Amano Shrimp once the mothers eggs hatch the mother doesn't actively seek out her young and eat them. The mother will eat them if they stay to close and she picks up as nearby food. So I would say Shrimp end up eating their young by accident.

[@joey__4759]

My Assasin Snails just sit there. They barley move. Are they Dead? And will they eat Guppy fry?

[@mikeclayton2626]

Hello new at shrimp keeping I have a small nano 3 gallon take with small filter does the temperature fluctuates in such a small tank and about how many would you keep? Keeping the easiest shrimp in the neo end thank you mike.

[@BearNecessitiesOfLife]

Great info and awesome video as always! :)

[@MusingsFromTheDen]

Do you also keep shrimp in a peaceful community tank with fish? I just got my Amano's about 2 weeks ago and was wondering if there are particular rules that do and don't apply of you're keeping a community tank rather than one that's solely shrimp. 😊

[@elKachivache]

For the last 3 weeks, one every week I've been finding shrimp bodies, almost cut in half, the head and the rest of the body folded, the body all viscous and soft. My water parameters are fine, the rest of shrimps are shedding normally, I have a Helena Snail and I think it could be it, but the meat is not eaten is just bland, what could it be pls?

[@jimmygimbal]

Fantastic Rob.. Great shots too.. Is that the camerawoman at the helm of those shots?! Props to Pandalee. =) Keep it up Rob #TeamFLIP

[@pandalee7491]

Sashimi Whiskey yes it was me :)

[@marthanewsome6375]

My neo's are housed with my cardinia's and they fight over food and neo's always win. I have a suspicion that neo's can kill cardina's. I kept finding dead cardinia's right after feeding. So, now I give them food in several area's of the tank at once and also sprinkle some baby food in. Ever since I've done that, the fighting has cut right down and no dead cardina's. It was funny because I was blaming the endlers at first and were going to move them out, but it wasn't them at all and when I saw how powerful the fights got between the two species, it clicked that must be it and it was. The endlers stay at the top of the tank and eat flake food, they don't even bother with their own babies.

[@augustvukosovich4683]

Wow, that is fascinating. I've never seen food fights in my shrimp tank. I wonder if there is something that causes it?

[@ThisProvidencerocks]

Just removed my assassin from my yellow King Kong tank at 2 am 😂

[@siobhonphillips2295]

Hell yes Assassins eat shrimp :-( I introduced 11 assassins into my community tank after it got overrun with hundreds and hundreds of pest snails. I had a very healthy population of breeding Rili shrimp in the tank as well and they were constantly breeding. At any one time there were 3/4 different sizes of young shrimp in the tank. Same as you, I found one or two empty shrimp carcasses and did think about the assassins but brushed it off. Unfortunately I couldn't move the shrimp into my other tanks just as a precaution as they have fish in them that will definitely eat them. Long story short-they absolutely annihilated the pest snails, my tank was littered with many hundreds of tiny empty shells within a cpl of months. They have also completely destroyed every single shrimp in my tank!! There's lots of baby assassins of various sizes as well. Absolutely gutted as my shrimp were breeding so well! :-(

[@annhorn1190]

Are there any plants that should not be put in with shrimp?

[@CarlosDiezAquatics]

Nice video! Specific tanks are the best tanks if you want to produce more offspring, no matter if you are breeding shrimps or most of the fish species (there are some exceptions with some cichlids and some other fish).

[@stevenluitjens1348]

I got 2 dwarf gouramis 3 Mm platies and 2 amano shrimp in a 10 gal. With 0 ammonia, nitrite, and nitrates with 0 aggression in the tank especially towards the shrimp and both my shrimp died in the first day I got them. I saw one swimming upside down and banging into everything and then landed and just layed upside down and died. Any idea why?

[@mistibrown715]

I seen my ghost shrimp climbing the walls of my tank trying to get at the freshly born fry.

[@christopherhawkins2359]

Super great video 🤓

[@blitzmedia2016]

got 4 assassin snails an 1 shrimp and never seen them go for them at infact they all sit next to each other eating and never once has a snail gone for the shrimp

[@JohnT2088]

blitz lol hes saying can they. Of course they can. It rarely happens if they are fed and they are to slow to catch up. But i seen them eat them before on the slower and weaker shrimp. You dont see it doesnt meant it dont happens

[@JohnnyRelentless]

Just when you thought it was safe to keep shrimp again, comes Peter Benchley's Assassin Snail. Coming soon to an aquarium near you.

[@laketuna]

if you do 10% water change over a period of a month, how much nitrate accumulates in the tank? is high nitrate a non-issue?

[@KevinNathanael390]

There's a fish store near me that kept both assassin snail and yellow cherry shrimp together in a same tank, so i don't think cherry shrimp would be in danger. I'll go and tell the store owner about this lol

[@chelseas2884]

I kept an assassin snail up until today when I walked in on it eating one of my new chocolate shrimp! I couldn't believe it but there had been mystery disappearances. Won't be keeping them with shrimp anymore thats for sure.

[@pavelsmirnov7138]

thank you man, really good information!

[@FlynnsFishForum]

Great Job Rob!!

[@1dowsey]

Hi from Liverpool UK very informative thank you

[@darrenfrancis2002]

Just saw my snail feast on one of my shrimps.

[@BigCajun]

Do you think that it would be a problem to place Bumble Bee Fish in with my shrimp?

[@shngsam8777]

thanks for sharing my shrimp do better with 10% or less water change per month， compare to last time when i doing water change every week

[@royalcitizen6101]

Great video🦐😄

[@eugenewagas3679]

Is Amano Shrimp and red cherry shrimp eat Guppy?

[@ckfpv9365]

Will u be brining any types of shrimp to the EAS meeting this friday, I am amember in the area.

[@Kingpirate0]

I had 30 new baby shrimps and alot of shrimps in my assasin snail tank, i noticed that my shrimps numbers starts to decrease then i saw this video, well im gonna take the snails out soon now.

[@clippertae]

Hi just found your channel - loving it! I am really new to keeping a tank and need advice, thank you in advance; its 70lt 2 months old i had a really small one and only one black moor. i decided to go big lol. substrates, plants and good filter. one week ago i added four amano shrimp and 2 assassin snails. They were bought from the same shop and the exact same tank.The shrimp have completely disappeared, where are they? Can anyone advice me. Ive just watched your other video on shrimp escaping and have just checked all around the outside of the tank

[@GTBoats]

Do you know if assassin snails will attack rabbit snails? I have 1 assassin snail in my shrimp tank with 4 rabbit snails are they at risk?

[@robertomontoya5658]

What do you feed your shrimp

[@haroonarif3640]

Yes, few days back i saw my assassin snail eating a quite big cherry shrimp'

[@undan8917]

How long do ghost shrimps live?

[@elliswestbrook2172]

Great advise thanks a bunch

[@TheFunkytrapper]

Hi Rob i get a lot of trouble with high nitrates what ca changesn i do to reduce this without water ?

[@jamiem5364]

@@LupDiesel That is extremely bad advice. A fully cycled tank will always have nitrates! Ammonia is converted to nitrite, which is then converted to nitrate. you do water changes or add alot of plants etc to help lower the nitrate level.

[@LupDiesel]

Oh how times have changed hahaha plants will reduce nitrates :D

[@pernilsson7194]

im new whit shrimps and have the red ones and the red and white ones how do i do to make them mate

[@rurutuM]

i just feed crushed up fish flake and micro pellets, get it all over the tank so shrimp aren't in a ball fighting

[@KaizokuPim]

72*F is 22*C for anyone wondering :D 10 procent water change a month, wow now I don't have to worry for the holidays :P

[@sarazorz]

How do snails catch the shrimp when the shrimp are so much faster!?

[@00XZero]

awesome channel any word on when you'll have mk breed cheeseburger on stock thanks

[@jetjazz05]

I've got two assassin snails in a tank with that's got a few cherry shrimp and some CRS, it's heavily planted and there's also some endler fry in the tank so I feed it pretty heavily, that being said there's PLENTY of food to keep a big colony of snails... I bought the assassin snails specifically to keep the population under check, but they are LAZY! They eat maybe two snails a week each, I've had them for about 4 months now, and to be honest if they went rogue and started killing everything in the tank I might root for them lol, they just seem so easy going and lathargic. The only time I've ever even caught them eating was when I first got them and I introduced them to the tank, they'd been in transit a couple of days and they were hungry enough that they hunted down a snail right away. Wasn't hard... the snails wanted to see who the new guys were, so it was pretty much home delivery.

[@aysjelow7168]

Will Amano shrimp eat fish fry?

[@charliebrown9188]

Big time yes: Assassin snails eat shrimp and if I didn't remove them, they would decimate my red cherry shrimp colony

[@mikecarlin3396]

Which fish kills the cone snails that people don’t like. I have at least 50 in my 120 gallon freshwater tank. I am constantly removing them. I have Amano shrimp. Thank you.

[@MasterBlek]

I bought some moss idk if it's java moss but I put it in a small tank and added some poison for worms that basically can also kill snails... Why? Well there are basically assassin snail eggs on it and I don't want to lose my other snails because of that pest. That's right I think the assassin snail is a pest cause it kills every other snail even the rabbit snails that are barely breeding. I hope the poison can finish off the eggs so I can put the moss in the tank for my shrimp and guppies to breed in.

[@urbanrat84]

You make the young mum shrimp sound super cute

[@dwainkitchel1316]

thx for the info Rob!!!!!

[@elitephantom9690]

Will they eat giant African shrimps?

[@fishguygobies3932]

You should start a big breeding colony of Amazon river prawns. They are spectacular, but not common.

[@Nois3boy]

If you cut like 10 anubias at the same time in a 15liters tank, you will change water chemistry and you can lost some shrimps.

[@nayanshakhawath6543]

Is Anubias plant harmful for shrimp?

[@sofiakaos5278]

How about mug sized water changes?

[@sofiakaos5278]

Daily water changes*

[@MarcuxRyan]

I should have filmed when I actually saw my assassin snail ate my shrimp during a shrimp ball frenzy..

[@Boss-zo4lw]

Ive just seen a Assasin kill and eat a shrimp, i could see the shrimp legs still moving, was horrible, and my Shrimp stock has dropped, so yes they certainly do.

[@Nemesis0513]

the assins ate all of mine, and shrimp won't brutalize their young unless you don't feed them. You could just put the food everywhere so they'll chase it.

[@mrsgamer9218]

i have a 60L tank, around 60 shrimps and 3 assassin snails. So if they pick a shrimp from time to time i dont mind. they breed like rabbits