Making a Song in 57 Minutes

Writing and recording a song from scratch in 57 minutes.
When calling out other youtubers, I always think R.A.D.
Roomie: / roomieofficial
Andrew: / andrewhuang
Dave: / boyinaband
The bass I'm using is Davie504's signature bass with Chowny.
chownybass.com/
The guitar is my signature model with Chapman Guitars :)
USA (Guitar Center, nationwide) - bit.ly/2BpBOQh
USA (Riff City Guitar, MN/SD) -
Argentina - bit.ly/2BwKmEW
Australia (Music Junction, Melbourne) - bit.ly/2Ckse2M
Australia (Better Music, Canberra) - bit.ly/2POMdue
Chile - bit.ly/2Ex0Pfu
Czech Republic - bit.ly/2Ewhu2Q
Germany - bit.ly/2A7BplX
Israel - bit.ly/2GuDe1V
New Zealand - bit.ly/2S4tjkO
Norway - bit.ly/2EuU4uJ
Philippines - bit.ly/2R0bl5V
Slovakia - bit.ly/2EF3LHM
Sweden (Malmö Musikaffär, Malmö) - bit.ly/2POAnA9
Sweden (Musikanten, Umeå) - bit.ly/2CmOqcx
Switzerland - bit.ly/2GsjsE9
Thailand - bit.ly/2Gs3byY
UK - bit.ly/2QKPrnW
Shot by Sam Grant of The Good Stuff: / thegoodstuff
Sam also did the first rough edit if you want to watch a much longer version including all the even less funny jokes in it: • 57 minute song - UBER...
Here's the Wheezywaiter video I mentioned: • My Wife Lists My Top 5...
Mixed by Ryan "Fluff" Bruce: / fluff191
My guitar courses are available within the Guitareo membership :)
www.guitareo.com
Also, my beginner course, GuitarQuest, is still available on it's own too
www.guitareo.c...
The gear that I use: imp.i114863.ne...
Win $1000s in FREE Gear at Sweetwater: imp.i114863.ne...
Sweetwater’s deals page: imp.i114863.ne...
The channel is supported in part by Sweetwater’s affiliate program. Thanks for that!
Commentary, song stems, and early access to videos when you super-subscribe on Patreon: / robscallon
This video was made possible because of Patreon support from Rob Harper, Hypergnome, Fabio, Ben Swan, Isaac Briefer, ricin, rd1994, Sheldon Bird, Yaroslav Yermilov, Jack Cahillane, Denis Lachapelle, Kevin Harris, Jonathan Olejniczak, Fuad Ghazali, and many other awesome people on my Patreon page: / robscallon
Big videos go on this channel. Everything and anything else is on the 2nd: / robscallon2
Also...
Vinyls/Merch: store.dftba.com...
Instagram: / robscallon
TikTok: / robscallon
Facebook:
Twitter: tinyurl.com/twi...

[@svenjohnson6629]

I like how Rob starts with "I should just focus on structure and lyrics first" and then immediately doesn't do anything like that.

[@cinforammi8543]

Sven Johnson same with how he said he didn't want it to be a comedy...lol

[@RoomieOfficial]

I have 11 toes, so I find this song offensive. PS. I think I can do this faster...

[@zoombronco]

RoomieOfficial Undoubtedly. 😆

[@g.hmusicc]

Here comes drama

[@justinbouchard]

As soon as I saw the notification I'm wondering on how many minutes you might go down by this time :D

[@obamagaming5611]

bluf

[@coolowlman]

RoomieOfficial ps Rob is a better singer

[@firewordsparkler]

Rob at the beginning: "I don't want to do another joke song" Rob at the end: "I'M GONNA HANG WITH MY BROS. WE'RE GONNA EAT SOME NACHOS. ROCKET LEAGUE."

[@Ragnarockalypse]

OH YEAH

[@ihH6053]

Beggining: I don’t wanna make a joke song Timer starts: ok what we got here oh I know I HAVE A HEAD AND NINE TOES OH YEAH perfect

[@akasquid1763]

I was gonna Say that

[@SplotchTheCatThing]

Honestly it's kinda awesome anyway.

[@tripleforcium8003]

OH NO I READ THIS AS I’M GONNA HANG MY BROS AND GOT REALLY CONFUSED FOR A SECOND.

[@AndreaBoccarusso]

the more I see of these challanges, the more I'm tempted to try. it's too inspiring

[@louiscarrollmusic-lcm5331]

Andrea! Huge fan dude!

[@_massmanipulation]

@@louiscarrollmusic-lcm5331 same here!

[@PoonCrusher]

Glad to see weezer is still releasing some good music

[@fritzholsteen598]

My heart. I wish.

[@fritzholsteen598]

Alcide Cloridrix Honestly though, as sad as it is to say. Raditude > Pacific Daydream

[@cvoo5369]

Van Weezer?

[@johnlemon8689]

Cvoo van weezer is sick

[@benjaminhaley3780]

@@johnlemon8689 Ok Human is amazing.

[@island965]

Rob: An actual song, not comedy *five seconds later* Also Rob: My name's Sam and I'm behind the camera and I like to do stuff *slaps guitar* 😂

[@bigmaczukno]

97% of this video is just rob saying 'no'.

[@anndynegative]

This is escalating at a reasonable pace

[@thomasruiz9083]

This is good memetic

[@DevilWearsAdidas]

Im telling you the next one is gonna be like 10 minutes

[@Carina5707]

Best comment

[@rhysjones9771]

rob scallon, because “rock” and “not rock” are the only two genres.

[@davischalmers4245]

There are more genres?

[@johnlemon8689]

What about kinda rock

[@myidentityisamystery5142]

@@davischalmers4245 r/woooooooosh

[@davischalmers4245]

Piano Impro how?

[@naiverphilosophy]

@@myidentityisamystery5142 that was the worst attempt as a woooosh I think I've ever seen

[@NikTTABU]

0:53 : "I also want this song to be not comedy.. Hopefully? I don't know" 10:18 : "YEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA ROCKETLEAGUE!"

[@Anteaterman23]

One year later: "Making a Song in 4.5 Seconds"

[@oibattery3198]

Anteaterman23 there's actually a song that lasts 2 seconds by NoFX

[@wedgesalad3163]

There are 58 songs by Tool that are less than a second

[@Pickleccine]

Wedge Salad Nice lie.

[@Simoran]

This is how "You Suffer" by Napalm Death gets created.

[@Gummibri]

It would be Stevie T with a midi guitar

[@WillSmith-fg8be]

My favorite weezer song

[@wasabiwaffle]

Its so Weezer

[@alexmaciel6825]

thats totally weezer

[@kurtgally526]

I thought it sounded like Andrew W.K.

[@archenemy24]

I only hear Brian Posehn

[@peteplaysmusic]

"Party Harder Than Andrew Records" lol. Rob is now official World Record holder in speed songwriting! :)

[@michal26691]

Wait... Is there such thing as "world record in speed songwriting"? If so, where can I find some previous record holders?

[@soundninja99]

No one said it was an officially recorded title.

[@ArthurKowales]

Fact Magazine has a series called "Against the Clock" where producers have 10 minutes do develop a whole track...

[@pablorandri6459]

V'yell Gohl there couldn't be because anything can be considered a song, you could just go on any sound editor, generate 4 minutes of white noise and call that a song, and that takes about 10 seconds

[@crivillion9337]

Pete Cottrell II

[@rometlempu4839]

why does he have 3 mouses and 2 keyboards?

[@Oli420X]

Apple

[@AngusBeefington]

Because he has a head and 10 toes

[@tsarbear4191]

@@AngusBeefington oh yeah..

[@attempt58]

apple mouse has a weird system that doesn't allow it to charge while in use but not sure about the two keyboards

[@eirikramsfjell5008]

He can type two times faster scroll three times faster its all about efficiency

[@christhedewott7024]

Sounds like something Mordecai and the Rigbys would play

[@TylerOath]

Chris Koford so glad I'm not the only one!

[@eddiejohansson1949]

How can a show be so terrible and so amazing at the same time

[@ripmo3503]

Eddie Johansson well terrible and amazing cancel out to regular, lol

[@spacey4216]

ripmo best comment ever

[@ostapchovgan1115]

Mustache Cash Stash 😎

[@BadgerStyler]

I'd love it if this became a regular series

[@Pipoy_99]

Nick Powell lmao these guy will do I until they make a video about making a song in 1 minute😂

[@ihH6053]

S͟͟a͟͟m͟͟e͟͟

[@Trunxz]

1st of October: “Am I a joke to a you”

[@joshyalan]

Rob writes a song about Rocket League and Rocket League goes on Steam sale the same day... Conspiracy!

[@druidmeats]

*rob takes 20 minutes for one instrument*

[@drewgauthier1521]

me

[@rawrguys6053]

Art Of Doggos yep roomies was better sorry😅😅😅😅

[@candyninja2722]

yep.. he is losing time and then his vocals have no autotune and it ruins the song!

[@dde553]

Roomies all song is about autotune so....

[@strat-oq1hx]

Idiot music is win spent 50 minutes at least at the guitar and the song was the best out of every music youtube r challenge

[@Hellboy-ge6po]

This song actually turned put really well. Also, I hadn't even heard of Rocket League until this video but now I really want to get it and play it with my bros.

[@PoGoX7]

Symbolic Leprosy the game rules, it's very addicting...

[@perox9695]

AND EAT NACHOS

[@AndyCompston]

Oh Yeah!

[@jaykstah]

This is something I'd actually have listened to in the early/mid 2000's lmao.

[@generalh1044]

but rocket league did not exist in the early/mid 2000's

[@crispybacon4240]

+Blocky_Games Missing the point...

[@generalh1044]

Crispy Bacon i was making a joke

[@adwagmusic]

Honestly, I could see listening to this and some Aquabats

[@cassygauthier5967]

We're still in the 2000's lol

[@seaurchin5500]

I'm just waiting until you make songs in less than one minute.

[@thebatman1482]

Buttard That's an amazing idea for a quality video. He should upload that to the 2nd Channel. The quality one.

[@seaurchin5500]

The second channel wouldn't be high quality enough to handle that video, i'd say he should put it on the fourth channel.

[@thebatman1482]

Buttard Rob's fourth channel: god level achieved

[@yattasuccess9212]

The fifth channel seems a little more developed

[@seaurchin5500]

2PaperVG Yeah, i guess you're right.

[@Torzelan]

"He's not even in a band. So stupid." GOTTEM 🔥

[@ibdgonzo]

Torzelan I died

[@Gzzmss]

Torzelan OOOOOO EXPOSE HIM EXPOSE HIM

[@SeaTurtle1122]

Where is Dave?

[@EPrimeify]

NO! GOD DAMN IT ROB! THIS WAS SUPPOSED TO BE DAVE'S VIDEO!

[@Bradley_Exworthy]

EPrimeify he'll just have to do it in 56 minutes then

[@John-ot8rw]

Yeah where is Dave?

[@intofourths]

Dave is MIA

[@elliott7268]

EPrimeify dave is dead. He hasnt uploaded anything in like 5 moths. Hes obvious not gonna do any thing now.

[@SKATE87410]

Nobody likes Dave anyways

[@ChoppedCarrots1]

I'd love to see what would happen if you all made a song together in under 1 hour!

[@ТатьянаАлешкина-б3с]

Rob, thank you very much! Three years ago I stopped playing music. This happened after an unsuccessful attempt at the examination at a music school. So, after watching your video, I was overwhelmed by the desire to once again plunge into music. You are awesome. Thank you for inspiring me!

[@harastid]

"I want the song to be not comedy" Immediately writes about Rocked League.

[@ArtemMironenko]

1 month later: "Making a Song in 1 Minute"

[@momoreview5555]

Artem Mironenko lol

[@saidoterodiseno]

Artem Mironenko O H ! Y E A H !

[@anton.vechakes]

did you wanna say after 1 month?

[@joonaojala4231]

nice english tho

[@ezpzjayzaar]

you both succ: *1 month later*

[@Billybillybillyrocking]

This is basically a weezer blink song haha

[@rickfeith6372]

Andrew WK is like this for real. They even have a song called Party Hard...lol

[@merrickbaskie7941]

Love how he casually just made it in 10/8 time

[@doncaplays]

Isn’t it 10/4?

[@merrickbaskie7941]

@@doncaplays yea I always mix up the bottom metre

[@marinezxxlgaming]

Andrew: gonna take you to the stars Roomie: Own you Rob Scallon: IVE GOT A HEAD AND 10 TOEEES OH YEAH

[@chrisdemetriou8593]

This challenge is fun but I would also like to see you guys allow yourselves to rework the songs you write in such a haste. Just do the fine-tuning and re-recording you need, until you are satisfied. It seems that the time constraint makes you come up with some fun ideas, but then you never have the time to bring it up to your standards! So do another video where you finish the song, or just release the finished track or smth. Great work!

[@0101-r5f]

Chris Demetriou they can do this later when theyre at 1min ;)

[@chromaticswing9199]

I prefer the lack of time they have with the songwriting process. It forces them to be happy and confident with their musical choices.

[@chrisdemetriou8593]

cmooon dont you want to hear a legit finished version of "hang with my bros"?? I know I do!! (I guess if they get the chance to actually finesse the songs they'll probably end up much less silly and fun :P )

[@bardfinn]

"Brocket League"

[@Karlgolden]

Need to try this! \m/

[@mabotv8155]

Karl Golden please!!!! I love your channel!!!

[@nestacz1447]

Oh YEAH!

[@yattasuccess9212]

Please do mate you musically in tune with yourself son of a female

[@mrdavorisin]

Oh god, please!

[@mackerydelic1638]

Shut up NERD

[@jeff49605]

soon we'll see a song in less than 14 minutes, and i can't wait to see that

[@KingHeadbang]

That's how you get grindcore micro songs.

[@rumbachumba330]

You Suffer-Napalm Death.

[@epic690sucks]

kmac made a song in one second

[@taronsmith8091]

Or you know, 30 seconds lol

[@LAkadian]

Or better yet: (and hear me out) what if we take our time and see how good we can make the lyrics?! Could be fun!

[@igotboomed]

I broke to long cry laughing with the line "it's that kind of night I'm going to jump twice". The thought of a grown respectable guy randomly jumping not once, but twice in excitement was too much to handle lol

[@slimkt]

When you also have a head but only nine toes 😔

[@xenontesla122]

Screaming Match I audibly started to say that when I saw your comment.

[@2ethefirst318]

Daniel Romeiro you're mom gei

[@Chump1]

2E the first no u

[@theepicslayer7sss101]

better than half or no head and 10 toes...

[@jorgedominguez2256]

slimkt damn your channels old

[@DrDaveWrestling]

Rocket League should actually commission this for some in-game music, it would be hilarious

[@lfox02]

David Boyd Yeah... Imagine opening Rocket League one day and you hear Rob. Amazing.

[@N4m43]

OH YEAH

[@Robbay363]

PLEASE omg that would be amazing.

[@Thomas0661]

11:31 I know why Rob. I have the Roland TD-4kx2, with the same hihat. Sometimes on the rim you dont get every single hit, you have to hit on top of the "cymbal". Best Regards Thomas (Its simply because of use. ;) )

[@DadRockAndGuitars]

Yeah, I have an old TD-3 and the hi-hat is a constant struggle - especially if I hit the rim.

[@johnoakley4537]

That ad timer is the best thing I've ever seen. Keep it up Rob, love you! Song is awesome too

[@benapsley9552]

That's what I'm talking about Bill!

[@negativespace8358]

Is nobody going to comment about why Rob has 3 mice and 2 keyboards?

[@nathanhunt9105]

I was wondering the same thing!

[@Ithorn110]

I guess he just can't trust apple products

[@n-tiger4539]

8:15 Yea we get it, when there is a bass solo, EVERYBODY starts talking. Thanks for another bass joke!

[@adamhajnal4758]

How to make a blink-182 song in 57 minutes

[@djsubliminalreeve]

sounds more like sum 41 imo

[@ShayanGivehchian]

How there still hasn't been a mandolin video is absolutely beyond me

[@christianhopkins1867]

Weezer's new track is fire!!

[@johnlemon8689]

RCT God I know hero is a bop

[@Carina5707]

This actually isn’t half bad 😂

[@ahhh440]

Juce true

[@weldin]

"It ain't half good either" Animaniacs anyone?

[@fatal2urhealth36]

Cinestar Productions *bodom crash*

[@jacksonsmith15]

Lol it’s cancer at the same time too😂 I kinda like it😂

[@TheShachattack13]

Rob truly is the voice of our generation

[@jacobschwartz4940]

I challenge you to write a song on a hurdy-gurdy

[@mcblahflooper94]

Jacob Schwartz I challenge anyone to get the money for a hurdy gurdy

[@piyushpriya6973]

He can now.

[@juststeveschannel]

Now I am really curious to see what it would look like if three or four of you worked TOGETHER to put together a song. Would it be a help, or would the need to find consensus make it even more challenging? Would it still take 57-60 minutes? Would three people take three hours, or wrap it up in twenty minutes? I know I'd watch the video.

[@andrewfaraday8918]

He totally misses "I'm gonna play Rocket Leauge for the rest of my life", which is such an obvious line, there.

[@GabeMillerMusic]

That solo was actually pretty dope.

[@mitchazj]

Gabe Miller Music It's Gabe! Hullo :)

[@user-ct8pd1pw2n]

I wonder who will make the next video "Making a song in 56 Minutes"

[@gefen314]

I Write A Song A Day i hope dave will

[@Happyginger5307]

I Write A Song A Day probably Rob

[@seanchristopher4019]

Andrew 56 min Roomie 55 min Then magic happens Boyinaband shows up with a 'making a song under 50 min'

[@Roter_reis]

I Write A Song A Day R a. M iii

[@tonksdude]

Boyinaband: "57 minutes, hmm?" *makes song in 10*

[@hhhebry]

Can't wait until we get to 10 second songs, get it haaaaa

[@cfoscoop]

Rob: "I want to start with the structure and the lyrics" *Immediately picks up the guitar* Rob: "I don't want this to be a comedy song" *I've got a head and ten toes*

[@DrMcFly28]

57 minutes left "I don't want to do a comedy song" 1 minute left "ROCKET LEAGUE!!"

[@thisguy8943]

Ad during bass part...fuck yeah.

[@miggys4856]

8:12 well I guess not showering gets you this big

[@MarkArandjus]

_"Song was great, he's a great singer :T "_ I don't know why you're so upset Rob. It's good for you that he's a great singer, because everybody knows you're a better singer than Roomie :B

[@TheGabyNya]

I honestly just stumbled upon both Rob and Roomie's channels today and they both have their own unique qualities that make them both good in their own ways :) This has been entertaining!

[@canman87]

LOL, the lyrics for this song are so damn funny. Well done, Rob! I know I certainly couldn't have come up with anything nearly as good as this in under an hour.

[@AlessandrodiTria]

This is getting ridiculously hilarious in a few weeks

[@Sky3RN]

Well, I'm gonna play Rocket League now.

[@grungar3x7]

Skyern Aklea And I want nachos, for some reason.

[@Klexup]

Dope add me on steam

[@homopoly]

Available on iTunes right about now.

[@Riley88990]

"I'm a better singer than Roomie"

[@SheepHairOG]

I think Rob needs to work on his lyrics.

[@Robbay363]

strongly disagree

[@SheepHairOG]

Understandable.

[@grungeblud5278]

@@SheepHairOG Hes undeniably expressive and intelligent. If he doesn't already have some amazing lyrics written somewhere, he definitely could if he wanted to.

[@caffienatedcorvid7273]

Idk man, it slaps tbh. The "jump twice" part did catch me off-guard tho

[@cobain_92]

This us going out of hand.. Next week: "Song instantly"

[@diom00]

00:00 - 00:02 the best 2 seconds in my Life

[@MAX-tu7dd]

Back at it again with bill :D

[@vallik1760]

He doesn't know that in a year he'll be making a full album in a day, avery year

[@Jack_L]

I watched this for the first time on a Friday night after working (felt alright after), eating nachos, and playing Rocket League with my bros. Why is this the most relatable song that I have ever heard? Why did it have to be this one?

[@zoombronco]

You are a next level guitarist, sir. ✌️😃👍 Lyricist? Uh... Well... Umm... ♥️ u, bro. ✋😂👍

Hey rob why do you have a herd of mice and keyboard on your desk? Are they like for standby or do they serve a different purpose?

[@dustbunnys]

7:22 sick tenacious D reference!

[@joshhewitt2257]

"Hi my name is Dave and I'm lame... he's not even in a band" 😂😂

[@javierlarreboure]

This is so much better than the other one! Congrats, it's really good in my opinion :)

[@gemhart82]

OH YEAH

[@Vaempirehagen]

The timing!! I read the comment and clicked read more when he said it

[@gemhart82]

nice. I have this song stuck in my head xD

[@gemhart82]

THIS IS STUCK IN MY HEAD I LOVE IT

[@CrysisMusic]

No love for your 10 fingers ? Didn't see your toes playing a guitar (possible song challenge there haha)

[@FreazyTek]

It doesn't rime with bros unfortunately :D

[@THRASHMETALFUNRIFFS]

There's dudes on KZbin playing with their feet!

[@THRASHMETALFUNRIFFS]

SHRUB PLAYS channel plays upside down!!

[@ROOKIE_IX]

That was giving me Andrew W.K. vibes lmao

[@Kompoth]

Oh yeah, and I've been 16 years old again for a couple of minutes =)

[@lorenzomarchi8055]

Much better result than the last time, i think. Keep it up man!

[@andre22501]

When you know how bad the lyrics are but you could totally see the song on a radio station....

[@7xppgngrmj22jhx7enubvnw5grndiy]

it's too good for radio though

[@slightlybaked779]

better than what's on the radio tbh

[@daleftuprightatsoldierfield]

0:29 you shouldn’t be talking. We’re still waiting for you to do “Fast Rap: 303 Words in 50 Seconds.”

[@kcheban]

"I recorded it this time. It's pretty important part of a process there" haha :D

[@DEE-jk3rb]

Bruhhh that solo was amazing. Not to mention that sweet accidental pinch harmonic

[@J4rmo78]

I think we need this tune to be available for download ;) Really good raw punk-rock rally

[@CronicGaming94]

Super dope lol me and some of my friends will challenge each other with how much of a song we can make in a short time span such as this.

[@RebelQueenAmelia]

I should do it with my bandmates someday.

[@gabe_o_verse]

A much MUCH better song...but I kinda miss one from Dave...but he didn't posted anything since 4 Months or so and i really miss him as well :/

[@MarsLos10]

It's your turn Daveeeeeeeee you've been hiding enoughhh show us your skills :D

[@noorazraq2245]

MarsLos10 I doubt he could do it.

[@SuperInab]

Minutes side, your song is the best by far, the least commercial one and truly entertaining!

[@gewuerzgurkeev]

7:59 everybody starts talking during a bass part

[@nandakoryaaa]

You advertise dollar shave but you are not shaved. Or... wait a minute...

[@trentblaser-welch9436]

He's in it for the butt wipes

[@HaloFrk44]

Trent Blaser-Welch HAHAHAHA

[@larryarnemann7274]

dollar shave being sold by a guy who doesn't shave

[@andyjames5388]

😂😂😂

[@garlicandsapphire5718]

pubes brah

[@benjaminvroman5553]

Rob 1v1 me in rocket league I dare you

[@bobbob3630]

Dm me

[@michal26691]

Me too

[@MatthewAndThings]

I'll 1v1 you

[@jaki505]

final destination, fox only, no items

[@fidorfsmf6349]

BETTER THEN ESPACITO

[@antonionsfw]

what the fuck is "espacito"

[@pandorasboxofstuff186]

2

[@SlyHikari03]

Fidorf SMF true

[@Bulbiesaur]

Alexa, play espacito

[@ThatsOk83]

It's decpacito...

[@ZzzOfficialMusic]

what i can see from all these videos is that MACS CRASH A LOT! My PC never crashes FL12

[@_nurmi06]

I also use fl12

[@faiththeresa5155]

My Mac doesn’t crash at all. His is probably old

[@mikrokosmos-pluto]

What could you recommend for a reasonable price?

[@KaoswareMetal]

Who's up for a 56 minutes challenge?

[@ShadowMantraSteve]

Don't tempt me.... haha

[@woodypearce4379]

Me

[@evanuel23]

"NOT 6, 7!!"

[@dylansee7290]

This song's actually pretty damn rocking

[@disfiguringthegoddess1102]

Talks over bass part. Bass player here feeling betrayed

[@namenotfound34]

Oh no not only did he talk he inserted the ad over the bass part, that made me laugh, fuck the bass players tbh

[@nickamosmusic]

Andrew WK needs to hear this. I smell a collab.

[@kuroninjaofshadows]

Now you should do a collab with Roomie and Andrew, and maybe on more person! Four man band, 60 minutes. One song. You on guitar, Roomie vocals, Andrew Bass, Someone drums! Maybe a pianist?