MARILYN MANSON One Assassination Under God REVIEW + Albums RANKED

[@MetalTrenches]

Forgive some of the cutting on the clips. Ran into some claim issues. More Alternative Rankings: kzbin.info/aero/PLGt4fzX5jyueWT-fVHUsyIJ6ubuvqu69O&si=sjIgrfh-U7_tr-Qx ...or some Nu Metal Rankings: kzbin.info/aero/PLGt4fzX5jyuepFXkwmILRFkL8-XgQytt-&si=547nVuAXLfhEa1KK

[@jaimeyoung2012]

Can you please make a rob zombie tierlist. By the way great video!❤❤❤❤❤

[@MetalTrenches]

When they do a new one

[@thiagopena3258]

Hey Metal Trenches, what’s your favorite cover song by a rock or metal band?

[@GeneralCba]

OAUG is the best song I have heard in a VERY long time. This album is insane.

[@tony.g20]

I love it also

[@hg1651]

i do like that one a lot !

[@Matthew19Vexthem]

Agreed ...reminds me of ACS!!

[@NK-uu2vt]

OAUG part 1 was masterful, I'm so glad he's back.

[@NK-uu2vt]

Dude, I absolutely loved Sacrifice of the mass 😭 I always loved these types of sad songs from him.

[@owl509]

Glad to see some people are still talking about Marilyn Manson. I know he's not for everyone but after these allegations (which are verifiably false) he could've easily been blacklisted from channels like this one here

[@RoguSpanish]

Nah dude is guilty as fuck, you can still be a fan if you want but don't pretend he's innocent just cause you like his music.

[@owl509]

@RoguSpanish how is he guilty when Ilma Gore (one of his accusers) literally came out and said it was a false lawsuit spearheaded by Evan Rachel Wood via email? There's a reason why people had to try and get him prosecuted on an "a$$ault" charge from (at the time) almost six years ago after he spit on a camera at a concert and got some of it on the cameraman. Which was also a frivolous case as the guy had to sign a waiver before getting the job.

[@666_N_94]

💯

[@Cattledecap4life]

@@RoguSpanishwhat’s the evidence then?

[@densereaper]

@@owl509 That was Ashley Morgan Smithline, not Illma Gore. Illma Gore is the one who helped Evan Rachel Wood orchestrate the whole thing.

[@Milo-it1tf]

Antichrist superstar is actually the ending of the story, holywood is the prequel, holywood is about a character named Adam Cadmon starting a rebellion against the society that has beaten him down, mechanical animals is about an alien named Omega getting thrusted into fame and dealing with the isolation, drug abuse, and sex, antichrist superstar is about a character named the worm who becomes a celebrity to destroy the beautiful people that have treated him like trash

[@AzorAhai224]

Holy Wood will always be my fave Manson album, it’s fantastic.

[@nealcrabtree3647]

Manson has been a staple for me for decades.

[@prescribeddrone]

One Assassination Under God - Chapter 1 is truly a masterpiece, and I'm not just saying that because I'm a die-hard fan. This album legitimately feels like a follow-up to Holy Wood. As much as I enjoyed all the previous albums, nothing will top Portrait of An American Family to Holy Wood. The band's first four studio albums are masterpieces. However, this might be my fourth favorite album. It has my favorite opening song since "GodeatGod" and perhaps my favorite album closing song since EAT ME, DRINK ME. At this point, I can't pinpoint a particular favorite song because the entire album is perfect. All killer, no filler here. It's like a more cinematic version of Holy Wood/darker Mechanical Animals, with traces of fury from Antichrist Superstar, a dash of his last few albums, combining into a more evolved version of the traditional Manson sound that made us fall in love with his music. His voice sounds as good as it did in his prime. Nothing sounds rushed or like a first take recording. This album has beautiful layers of melodies, a good dose of aggression, and amazing guitar playing, with Tyler Bates tapping into his inner Daisy Berkowitz, capturing the soul of a Marilyn Manson guitar, with his own spin on writing, as heard in Funeral Without Applause, especially the outro. The album covers a range of styles, including industrial metal, cinematic synth arrangements, goth glam rock, industrial punk rock, and new wave, capturing the essence of Marilyn Manson and beyond. It's objectively the best album since Holy Wood, with a more refined version of the last few albums. This is a Marilyn Manson with something to say again; a refreshed and focused Marilyn Manson, fueled by the hypocrisy of modern society, with a concept and story to tell, just like when he first started the band.

[@Blutreaktoroffical]

Such a great album

[@HunterShark300]

Absolutely. The album sounds like the perfect mix of the classic triptych era, especially Mechanical Animals and Holy Wood (with songs like No Funeral Without Applause, Death Is Not a Costume, One Assassination Under God, As Sick As the Secrets Within and Sacrifice of the Mass), as well as a continuation of We Are Chaos (Sacrilegious, Raise the Red Flag, Meet Me in Purgatory). I think the cherry on top is Nod If You Understand. Or even more, Front Toward Enemy, which is not on the album (I really wonder when and where he's going to put it). These songs sound like they came straight from Antichrist Superstar, especially the latter.

[@Cyber_Crows]

Anti-Christ Superstar is still an absolutely insane album. There’s just so little filler. It’s banger after banger after banger.

[@Jaryuki07]

In my opinion there wasn't any bad songs on this album. 9,8 album. Never would have imagined it would be as good as it is. Perfect!

[@sharjesm]

One of the best rock albums of the year.

[@astridallenmand917]

when I was a teen I mostly enjoyed antichrist superstar and tGAoG, but now since I've grown up I appreciate more of Eat me Drink me, Mechanical Animals and Pale Emperor

[@Manson1990]

Personally, The Golden Age of Grotesque was my first rock/metal album ever and the one that made me a fan, always will have an special place in my heart and the sound of the album take me back to that age in my life, even if it's not its best album. For some reason, as I grew up, I find myself enjoying more the funky/weird and raw sounds of Portrait of an American Family and Antichrist Superstar.

[@Milo-it1tf]

Yeah eat me drink me slaps hard, but the high end of low doesn’t slap, to me it’s just kind of immature and there isn’t any deep cryptic meaning in those lyrics

[@astridallenmand917]

@@Milo-it1tf tHEOL and for some would be a shock holy wood are my least favorite albums I don't know where I place OAUG in my heart, old albums really grown deep. I'd agree it's mid but comparison makes it hard since it's not that flawless as I wish to see it

[@Amzingred]

1. Holywood 2. Antichrist Superstar 3. Mechanical Animals 4. Pale Emperor 5. Golden Age of Grotrsque 6. Portrait of American Family 7. We Are Chaos 8. One Assasination Under God Chpt. 1 9. Eat Me Drink Me 10. High End of the Low 11. Born Villain 12. Heaven Upside Down

[@Clintob]

I agree with the top, as most do. But yeah I would have to agree with your buddy, I LOVED We Are Chaos, I thought It was his best album since the golden age. Really looking forward to listening to the new one tonight.

[@timgonzales2891]

Manson was foundational to me and my musical journey. Regardless of what he does or doesn't do in his personal life.

[@nl3064]

For Me, 1. Holy Wood 2. One Assassination Under God: Chapter 1 3. Antichrist Superstar 4. Mechanical Animals 5. We Are Chaos 6. Golden Age of Grotesque 7. High End of Low 8. Eat Me, Drink Me 9. Heaven Upside Down 10. Pale Emperor 11. Portrait of An American Family 12. Born Villain

[@scollurio]

Sacrifice of the Mass made me cry every single time I listened to it so far (20 times)

[@dekadenser]

Solid ranking! Made me happy to see you put Pale Emperor high, really love that album. Really happy with the new album, definitely the best since Pale Emperor for me!

[@Dusty338]

Happy to see Manson back and better than ever!

[@NK-uu2vt]

My ranking: 1. Mechanical Animals 2. Holy Wood 3. Antichrist Superstar 4. Pale Emperor 5. One Assassination Under God Part 1 6. We Are Chaos 7. The Golden Age of Grotesque 8. High End of Low 9. Portrait of an American Family 10. Heaven Upside Down 11. Born Villain 12. Eat Me, Drink Me

[@n1kkmoviezz463]

Some Of these songs sound like his 90’s era & also modern 🔥

[@douglas5097]

I thought I was the only one that really disliked "Don't chase the dead"! Despite of that, I would rate this album as "Fantastic". I would also push Heaven Upside Down album to "Great", push down The Pale Emperor to "Great" and also down the Born Villain to "Good". His latest album, I'm not so sure yet even though I liked the singles a lot. I would probably rate this as "Fantastic" due its phenomenal comeback. By the way, the "perfect" at the top are spot on haha. I don't think he will ever surpass those!

[@opal8]

I'm actually very surprised to see We Are Chaos and One Assassination Under God not being higher on the list. Imo those are one of his strongest ever, right up there with the classics. Although I definitely agree with your take on Born Villain, a lot of people consider it to be his worst which I really just don't get. Overall though great list, and the Manson tier list is something I've wanted for a while. Good stuff!

[@blacksunshine9995]

Who in their right mind thinks Born Villain is his worst album?? That album brought Manson back from the edge of obscurity and made him dangerous again. It's top 5 easily.

[@opal8]

@blacksunshine9995 It's all over Reddit and Rate Your Music. To be fair RYM is extremely biased against anything that isn't indie/folk/hiphop but it's still quite a large group.

[@blacksunshine9995]

@opal8 I only check out reddit rankings for new bands and have no idea where to start but for Manson, if BV is ranked any lower than GAOG or the 2 albums in between, then someone has lost their mind. We all know the trilogy will forever reign supreme for the top 3, but to round out 4 and 5 we have to look at albums that reshaped Manson and made him a force to be reckoned with again and BV was one of those albums.

[@desanctisapostata]

Very fair assesment of Eat me drink me. I think as years go by people will soften more and more towards the album until people apreciate it for what it is. Underrated album, and the title track is still an absolute sleeper IMO, very unique sound, composition, very abstract texture and super dark sounding, still don't get how is not more like

[@FingerpointerBobby2121]

The song Eat Me, Drink Me is insanely good. I love this album.

[@hg1651]

A tier list often fails to adequately rank Marilyn Manson's albums because his discography is less about a linear progression of quality and more about exploring a spectrum of diverse sounds and themes. Each album serves as a distinct chapter in his artistic journey, offering listeners unique "flavors" that cater to different moods, tastes, and interpretations. Manson's work spans various styles, from the industrial grit of Antichrist Superstar, the glam-rock theatrics of Mechanical Animals, and the introspective darkness of Holy Wood, to the experimental and gothic tones of The Pale Emperor and We Are Chaos. These albums aren't just products of their time but are also deeply tied to the listener's state of mind and personal experiences. Instead of judging them against one another in a static hierarchy, it’s more fitting to see them as an interactive "choose-your-own-adventure" anthology. For example: If you're in the mood for unrelenting anger and rebellion, Antichrist Superstar might resonate. For a reflective and poetic exploration of vulnerability, The Pale Emperor provides a more mature, stripped-down sound. Feeling theatrical and alienated? Mechanical Animals invites you to its glittering dystopia. This fluid and subjective nature makes the "best" Manson album depend on individual tastes rather than any objective measure of quality. Tier lists, by contrast, impose rigid structures that can diminish the multifaceted nature of his artistry, reducing the deeply personal and experiential way fans connect with his music.

[@Dokkeabi]

My favorite artist of all time, Tommorow the boxset is coming in so i’m super stoked to listin to the new album

[@jordanstuck747]

Antichrist is such an amazing album. My dad still says his favorite concert is seeing Manson in Indiana on that tour

[@tony.g20]

I tell people to this day that seeing him on that tour was like being invited to the dirtiest, creepiest Halloween party of the year with 5,000 of the best friends you never met.

[@jesshavok1015]

He's so lucky to have gone to that show!!! I envy anyone who did! I would have been 6 years old when it was happening, so way too young, lol. That said, I did get see Manson live for the first time, this past September. And honestly, he did great, solid comeback!

[@wadehill116]

Thanks for doing this one 🤘

[@Grimmoon1998]

This is by far one of my favorite albums now ❤

[@Manson1990]

The Golden Age of Grotesque was my first rock/metal album ever and the one that made me a fan, always will have an special place in my heart and the sound of the album take me back to that age in my life, even if it's not its best album. But the trilogy will always be f-amazing, it's like a trip. And for some reason Portrait of an American Family nowadays it's the one that resonates with me the most. Something about its weird funky decadent sound plus the rawness of the guitars and vocals, it's like being on drugs, but not that much, just enough to not care about the world and not having morals or wanting to be likeable, living your own inner desires even if they scare the world.

[@Marco-gk9gr]

i've been listening to the album. i've been a fan since antichrist superstar. and the album is certainly going in a very good direction. however, i'm still struggling with his ‘autotune’ voice. what do you think?

[@baaltroth1957]

I've always had a soft spot for Manson. He's an intelligent individual that knew how to make an impact and difference in the way people think via music. I respect that. I think Antichrist is one of the best albums ever created with Mechanical Animals not far behind it. Eat Me Drink ME is up there too. Looking forward to listening to the new album after work today

[@ameerulehsan5616]

The new album are the best for me. and its pure and gold. the last song. 🔥💀.

[@brentruvio6556]

Having seen him on tour with FFDP earlier this year, he sounds fantastic, on the album and live. It's great to see the antichrist superstar continue to make great music.

[@brianirving3420]

Oof! I loved We Are Chaos. I thought it was his best in a long time. I was also a bit disappointed with the new album after hearing how good the singles were. Raise the Red Flag is so damn good.

[@quickflash2studios232]

I really love all of his albums, I’ve realised that it’s very difficult for me to dislike things lol. My favourites are Eat Me Drink Me, Portrait, MA and HEoL

[@liat0full982]

I Agree, expect for We are Caos, which is... great!

[@phoenixdown5181]

The new album is very good, especially the lyrics. It feels like he actually gives a shit this time around.

[@rowhaus5478]

New album is great

[@rudy679]

I agree.

[@TheJML1975]

Great video.. and I’d personally move the high end of low up to fantastic, and the golden age of grotesque, down to ok.. I kinda liked that album when it came out, but it was the beginning of manson, writing less interesting verses, in favour of repeating.. dare I say, poppy choruses, with the odd exception.

[@666_N_94]

Mostly agree with your list (though I think WAC is a bit underrated)but have to say OAUG has to be in at least fantastic category for me personally. I just feel so much influence from the Triptych and return to form with this one. I agree that I always crave some of his more speed driven aggression, but I just really love the vibe of this album.

[@plague877]

Assassination is in the top tier especially when part 2 comes round to complete it.

[@Batrico99]

Thanks for the video. Antichrist to Holywood was my favouitite manson era. I am glad i got to see Manson live once and it was an experience i enjoyed(im in Ireland so i don't know how many times hes played here ) His early stufff would have got him blacklisted from this country if the churcjh had their way.. Out of the later albums born villain is the only one I remember songs from ,I havent listened to the new album yet but I lll give it a try.

[@tommoconstantly]

Aw that’s a shame, I actually really liked We Are Chaos

[@MetalTrenches]

That's totally fine. So does Chris.

[@tommoconstantly]

@ haha thanks man, Great vid btw!

[@Bigbigvoodoo]

I love the album. It is much cleaner and less messy sounding than some of his last couple albums. Very focused & the vocals are less of the drunk groaning he was doing since Pale Emperor.

[@infinidominion]

Feel like I just woke up in some other timeline where MM has like 50 albums after 2000 😂

[@CraigMader]

On the Cheerleaders In Rock tip, it's only worked in FAITH NO MORE'S"Be Aggressive" & TING TING's "That's Not My Name". Nice overview, btw.

[@CraigMader]

Ah shit, I forgot TONY BASIL's "Mickey" and the punk cheerleaders from the NIRVANA video.

[@evgenykorelin3277]

Thank you for your reviews!

[@joelwhite2830]

Loved his work on Wonder Years 🤣🤣

[@MetalTrenches]

I understood that reference

[@joelwhite2830]

@MetalTrenches thanks! Now I was going to have ribs for dinner but some of them seem to be missing...lol

[@tony.g20]

I agree with most of your tear list except EMDM...I actually love that record....not quite perfect and I won't say fantastic but only because I prefer tighter fully committed concept records...he was loosely playing around with Alice in Wonderland, and while I think its better executrd than his Vaudeville Weimer era "art is dying" motif I would put it at the very top of my great list...Skolds solo on Just a Car Crash Away is almost as good Zim Zum on Fundamentally Loathsome... lastly I actually liked We Are Chaos alot..

[@bleepblorpp]

I just HATE the weird autotune. He has a great voice & it takes me out of it completely. I'm really bummed because I've been waiting for this album so long.

[@SlayerMasterPWI]

I feel like I'm the only one that loves The High End of Low frome beginning to end.

[@AlanBaltimoreBirds]

Loved that album as well and only ever could get others into We’re From America and Arma-Goddamn-Motherfuckin-Geddon lol.

[@NK-uu2vt]

I really love some of the songs on it like "Four rusted horses" and "Into the fire". The guitar solo in into the fire is so good imo.

[@AlanBaltimoreBirds]

@@NK-uu2vt Leave A Scar, too. 💜🖤

[@philippe4623]

PERFECTION : Machenical GREAT: All the other except "Heaven upside" and Portrait (i don't like). Eat me & We are chaos : These are special but good albums.

[@afinch93]

Portrait was recorded at cielo drive. Acss was recorded in new orleans

[@Kered-9]

I agree with mostly everything. I would place Born Villain a bit lower.

[@Mau13-m7q]

That album trilogy starts with Holy Wood and ends with Antichrist.

[@MetalTrenches]

🙄 Oi storywise yes. We are talking chronological in terms of release. Let’s not nitpick.

[@JoeHartman80]

My favorite artist. Seen them 32 times and been a fan for decades. Loving the new album so far.

[@adamaneve22]

Ummm.....the new album is AWESOME!!!! And the songs you don't like off of them are my favorite ones! I like every song off of the new album. Just my opinion though.

[@Mau13-m7q]

Eat me, Drink Me should be at great with everything afterwards below it.

[@hellawesomoff]

"EAT ME, DRINK ME" my favorive album.

[@danielbecerra2230]

i love that record but i fucking hated it when it came out

[@hellawesomoff]

@@danielbecerra2230 I can understand why, it's okay.

[@nl3064]

​@danielbecerra2230 ditto. First couple listens, most tracks sound like boring filler (though They Said That Hell's Not Hot is easily one of my favorite songs from Manson), but after a while a few of them grow on you.

[@danielbecerra2230]

@@nl3064 some of the songs there are among his best imo ( vampire, putting holes, evidence, the title track) but at the time I wanted heavy shit, I hated NINs year zero too

[@MaciejDomański-y1i]

i agree with you in that Perfection is : POAF'94 (because of rawness), AS'96 (because of darkness), MA'98 (because of blankness) they are my no. 1, rest is worth only a little mention... before 2000 world was different now it is only money making

[@Izanami17]

Well, I am enjoying the new album. But the hype was kinda under-lived for me. It wasn't the Holy Wood Pt2 that I was seeing hyped up. But it's good. The vocal effects are a bit much sometimes. Overall 3/5. Marilyn Manson is one of my favorite bands ever. mechanical animals is my personal favorite album

[@Jayagebee]

One of those artists I never cared cared about.

[@s.o.n.]

MM is great, a fan since Portrait. Lost me with Eat Me Drink Me.. then High End of Low, seemed like they repurposed Goon Moon songs... lost me again with Born Villain.. his vocals lacked dynamics. this new record seems interesting, got my attention again; also completely agree on the title of the album. This was a great video/review

[@gonzaloalcantara5565]

I think Manson needs a good producer, who is detailed, where are those guitars, in some songs you could hear up to 3 guitars, synthesizers, those hidden and dark sounds, the panning of several of Manson's voices that seemed to be speaking in one ear and in the other there was another of Manson's voices, the whispers of the man you fear are in the past, it took a long time for his return and they sincerely set the bar very high compared to albums like Antichrist Superstar, Portrait of an American, and Mechanical Animals, I like the details and that is what I capture in Manson's music in his first albums, as I said before, he needs a good producer and I don't know if there are any left, someone from the old school, Sean Bean, Trent Reznor, Dave Ogilvie, producers and industrial monsters.

[@randomnerd3402]

Trent hates his guts and rightfully so that ain't ever happening

[@snarkymcsnarkface1863]

I stopped paying attention after holy wood... doesn't look like I missed that much. My reason for stopping paying attention had nothing to do with the band. The friend that introduced me to Manson and skinny puppy. Did a self exit stage left no encore possible. When music was the thing we bonded over... It makes life interesting. I have not touched my clarinet since. Still play both of my saxophones, the piano and the guitar. But the clarinet has been sitting in the case since 2001... cork is probably shot, pads probably need to be replaced. I know there is no reeds in there.

[@MetalTrenches]

My sister played clarinet

[@FingerpointerBobby2121]

Eat Me, Drink Me is underrated while Born Villain is too high, IMO. Thinking about these albums again -- his closing tracks are insanely good. Man That You Fear, Coma White, Vodevil, Eat Me Drink Me, Odds of Even … WOW.

[@exalcooliconaoanonimo966]

The Golden Age (Fantastic)

[@someonewithsomename]

Eat Me, Drink Me and We Are Chaos the best albums prove me wrong

[@tomahawk148]

After 10 years I was able to taste Holy Wood, although I liked the sound right away. before I skipped some of the heavy and depressive ones, now they are like new to me but what the hell Portrait doing in fantastic?..

[@DrProfessorMD]

I stopped after Holywood. Not really missing his music in my life but I definitely spent my time replaying antichrist over and over back in the day.

[@kidbonesonline]

I'm so glad Manson is back. His music genuinely saved this year from overabundance and self-indulgence.

[@Milo-it1tf]

He’s also sober now

[@noahcody5986]

Antichrist or bust

[@Grimmoon1998]

I’m just curious as to why a longer album is seen in a negative way in this breakdown. Is it because of a shorter attention span ? I’ve always been extremely excited when a artist I love and appreciate releases a double album or a longer one at that. More material to enjoy and take comfort in for me.

[@MetalTrenches]

People love to jump to attention span… that’s not it at all. I have some long albums I LOVE. To me it’s how you justify the time. If not every track is a banger, you’re making filler, and I factor that into the overall experience of the album.

[@Grimmoon1998]

@ that’s fair , I just really enjoy the idea of going on a journey with the artist. I can see some albums adding fillers for the sake of maybe a label wanting a certain amount of tracks . But I’ve always found that a lot of my favorite albums aren’t my favorites at first and it tends to be the ones that take me on that journey. Thanks for the response 🤘

[@jokerquinnhahaiwest2475]

Loved the ranking. I do have to laugh though when you use words like edgelord like your not on camera in a dollar store skull mask 😂

[@MetalTrenches]

When have I ever denied it?

[@notreallydavek7237]

Portrait, antichrist, mechanical, golden age and pale empire are all equally Great for me. I don't really enjoy anything else. Golden age was alright when it came out but listening to it as i got older the lyrics are just so im 14 and my life is deep stupid.

[@NebLleb]

*GARBAGE DAY?!* -the bad guy from Silent Night Deadly Night 2

[@quentinbringthenumetalchil5125]

I’m not keen on what Manson represents (Satanism and all that. Sorry.), but I can’t deny that he and his band made a lot tunes from the earlier days. AntiChrist Superstar and Holy Wood are phenomenal front to back records, from the musical standpoint to the structure. Mechanical Animals and The Age of Grotesque had their moments, as well.

[@exalcooliconaoanonimo966]

Seven upside down (Okay)

[@samuelblinne6040]

Wow

[@nukritik2933]

1. Holywood 2. Antichrist Superstar 3. The Golden Age Of Grotesque 4. Mechanical Animals 5. Born Villain 6. We Are Chaos 7. One Assassination Under God Chapter 1 8. Eat Me, Drink Me 9. Heavy Upside Down 10. The Pale Emperor 11. The High End Of Low 12. Portrait Of An American Family

[@Markko82-je6cq]

1. Antichrist Superstar 2. Holywood 3. Mechanical Animals 4. The Pale Emperor 5. One Assassination Under God Chapter 1 6. We Are Chaos 7. The Golden Age Of Grotesque 8. Portrait Of An American Family 9. Born Villain 10. Heavy Upside Down 11. Eat Me, Drink Me 12. The High End Of Low

[@exalcooliconaoanonimo966]

Eat me drink me (Fantastic)

[@conradbarnard5807]

Although I haven't listened to the new album yet I agree with your list except that that I would swop places with Mechanical and Portrait

[@TheDemonicHorseman]

I think 'One Assassination Under God' is genuinely the worst album title I've ever seen (dethroning Ministry's 'AmeriKKKant'), but I think the album is fantastic. Definitely in my top 3 of this year.

[@MetalTrenches]

Yeah. Never judge a book by its cover... or title.

[@TheDemonicHorseman]

@@MetalTrenches Preach.

[@AndrewJSmall]

POAAF AND mechanical animals are the best. The first album is so grimy and weird, nothing like it really at the time and the musicianship is so much better than antichrist Superstar. Zim Zum sucks. Just my two cents. Another cool tier list though.

[@adamaneve22]

Also, the new album name is perfect! You're just being petty, I think.

[@MetalTrenches]

Being petty? That's a strange cope. It's just my opinion. It's corny. He's more clever than that.

[@danielbecerra2230]

Even if its sounds like shit Born Villain is the best album post Holy Wood

[@exalcooliconaoanonimo966]

The pale Emperor (Okay) no fantastic kkkkkcrazy

[@BLSfan2000]

I'm watching this now. What about the album before Antichrist Superstar, Smells Like Children? It has the cover of Sweet Dreams on it. You missed an entire album

[@Maciej-wc5kg]

it's not an album, it's EP and contains remixes and covers only

[@IzunaSlap]

Mobscene ripped off Faith No More's "Be Aggressive", change my mind.

[@adamaneve22]

"Ripped off" borrowed buddy

[@giovannimangiante1502]

Dude called one MMs most personal, and vulnerable songs "Sacrifice Of The Mass" mediocre and put yet another very personal album like "WE ARE CHAOS" at the bottom. What a tool. "hurr duuurr I want gutarrss and bangorzzz!!"

[@MetalTrenches]

People like you want to turn supposed nonconformity into just a new version of conformity lol. No self awareness. I don’t think a guy like Manson would ever want his fans to have a lock-step opinion of his art. It’s subjective by design you dolt. 😂

[@giovannimangiante1502]

@MetalTrenches No self awareness says the abandoned radioactive chunk of phlegm at the bottom of a dumpster in Baltimore who uploaded this L. Bozo.

[@baldjadapickettsmith2529]

Bro I think majority of Manson fans or music lovers would disagree with most of your rankings on this.

[@MetalTrenches]

And? I can't imagine a fanbase being so un-self-aware that they'd love a band all about DEFYING the status quo... and yet give people grief for doing exactly that lol. Should we all just have the same opinion? Let's not turn non-conformity into just another version of conformity, people.

[@baldjadapickettsmith2529]

@ u gave your opinion. I gave mine. Nothing wrong with that. Didn’t give you grief. I gave my opinion

[@baldjadapickettsmith2529]

And cool to share your personal rankings. But u showed the internet to get reactions and responses. This is my response. My opinion is my response. I didn’t agree with you. So what. I think most will disagree. You gonna reply to everyone? Lol

[@MetalTrenches]

I like to reply to as many people as possible. I'm just sick of the mentality about caring what the "majority opinion" is. It can be interesting to consider, but far too often I get comments using it as a means to try to delegitimize any sort of OPPOSING opinion. And that just feels completely antithetical to discussion of music... especially counter-culture type music. I get it from black metal people too, which is just HILARIOUS.

[@baldjadapickettsmith2529]

@@MetalTrenches oh I get it. It’s good that you’re showing what you like whether the majority will agree or not. Was not trying to take shots at you. Just saying you might be going against the grain with the rankings. But that’s totally fine. I admit when I go against the grain too. Because this is YOUR rankings. No one else’s

[@jackburns3607]

Why are his album covers so freaking creepy

[@Cyborg-su6rd]

Because it’s part of the aesthetics of the band.

[@BornHeadless96]

Why not?

[@Hellenicheavymetal]

He's a shock rocker. It's not supposed to be something your grandma likes to listen to but then he has been around for awhile so I'm sure there are grandmas who like him.

[@Mercury_Shadow]

I can not get past the fact that MM went Christian. Makes me question everything I ever thought about him and makes me also think the things he is accused of are more true than not. I loved him in the old days and now am having a hard time separating art from artist and have no respect left for him.

[@owl509]

Shiver me timbers....

[@Mercury_Shadow]

@@owl509 Okay if you insist. Consider your timbers shived...

[@Maciej-wc5kg]

he went christian? where did you get this information? lol

[@goblina_subpeona]

Yeah doing a sunday mass with Kanye West and Kat Von D is like yelling “im guilty and I want the upcoming Trump administration to pardon me.” He’s a grifter of the worst kind

[@owl509]

@@goblina_subpeona why would he need to be pardoned when the allegations are verifiably false and he hasn't been convicted after all these years? Lmfao

[@mikeealig]

Try hard ? Says this long hair with a skull mask with shadessssss

[@MetalTrenches]

lol so sensitive. I praise the band you clearly also enjoy for most of this 15 minutes and yet you're gonna get hung up on this? I'll bet you are one of those guys that says this stuff all the time and then makes surprised Pikachu face when no one wants to make friends...

[@RoguSpanish]

Oh yeah, clearly he tried really hard with this look. Not cutting his hair, putting on a mask...and glasses. Jeez it must take him all of 30 seconds to put those 2 things on, what a diva!

[@alexanderivanov8850]

Marilyn Manson is a top candidate for your "Cringiest metal & rock bands/stars"!

[@MetalPersonJ]

Yeah, you wanna talk about something that didn't age well, yikes. Not to mention Mad Mike hit it on the head that Slipknot owe their entire success to him that "Manson fans wanted something to listen to other than Manson." I do kinda like "Fight Song" though.

[@goblina_subpeona]

Prochrist superstar is at it again! The accusations are one thing but for him to become christian ruins the discography for me

[@adamaneve22]

Ummmmmm.....he's not Christian. Stay off of the internet please!

[@PriestOfOn]

It's a great title. Grow up.

[@MetalTrenches]

lol... step outside of yourself and reread your own comment... You literally just did a 10 year old "No U." XD