Minecraft Java Vs Bedrock Edition - Analysis

[@FizzyBanger]

Just a friendly reminder for everyone to not turn this comment section into a warzone! Civil discussion and debate is welcomed tho!

[@arielle1244]

I play both 😳

[@SepticLoser]

@@arielle1244 same

[@suyungsgamingschannelsytzi8611]

Me no

[@RDJpower]

I really hate that bedrock players never get to respond to these, like java users are attacking bedrock users for no reason. MINECRAFT IS MINECRAFT

[@SepticLoser]

@@RDJpower truuuuueeeee

[@user-el1gx2ve8c]

I've got both. I use Bedrock to play with friends as it is much easier to join each other but I use Java for mods or playing on servers.

[@kingnutlog8206]

I do the same thing but the other way round

[@Summie_]

@@kingnutlog8206 same.

[@Spian45]

Same

[@L-Lawliet14]

Same

[@flierby]

Same

[@jaeda6th]

Java- For content creators, and more technical/dedicated players. Bedrock- For casual players who just want to play Minecraft Edit: To clarify, a lot of people in the replies are shouting "There's content creators on Bedrock too!!1!1", yes I'm aware. This comment was made to merely point out what versions are best optimized for what- Bedrock for its easy multi-player, perfect for casuals and Java for its nearly unlimited capabilities and customization options.

[@FizzyBanger]

Exactly! Thats the main point of this analysis :)) Plus there is so much overlap between the two. Minecraft is just Minecraft in the end.

[@finnbarm]

Sorta, I think that PvP is better on bedrock, so some dedicated players may prefer bedrock.

[@EliteCheese]

@@finnbarm bro you gotta be kidding me no one in the history of minecraft has ever said that, no offence or anything bro but u got a screw lose or something?

[@JoeEnderman]

@@EliteCheese I would have to agree though, I think Bedrock pvp is balanced between 1.8 and 1.9 pvp. But if you like 1.9 pvp, Java is better.

[@EliteCheese]

@@JoeEnderman java is better in 1.9 and 1.8 both it is not debatable...

[@luisjogos821]

Two things that i love about Bedrock are: - Placing blocks in front of you (an old MCPE leftover) - Big Salmon

[@sheereenaali8448]

Big Salmon, the toycat meme?

[@luisjogos821]

@@sheereenaali8448 Yes,that Big Salmon.

[@northwastaken]

Wither boss in bedrock is better than the java one Bedrock is harder but java one just wiggles And wither was MENT to be hard

[@luisjogos821]

@@northwastaken Bedrock Wither is better **only for strong devices.** Because if you don't have a good phone or pc, don't even try fighting it. It will crash your world hard.

[@manjularanjan6608]

As a bedrock player I aprove this

[@akarim21]

Also, fighting the wither on bedrock is wayyy harder than java. The first time I fought the wither was on bedrock and I only died once luckily!

[@cvkaustubh7521]

@Jackson Cassell but wither is hard on bedrock, although both r good

[@goldenmakerz144]

Yeah in java people kill the wither very easy and they're always like "oh no im gonna die" and in bedrock is out of control and the onky way you can kill it is under the end portal that brings you back to the overworld

[@akarim21]

@@goldenmakerz144 ikr

[@lightning_7]

@Jackson Cassell bedrock wither has 600 hp but java wither has 300 hp so it's so much harder

[@omnispork12]

You are correct when I first fought the wither I died like 3 times

[@vibe3063]

My grandma got me Java and it was fun but she died and now her computer doesnt work and I think its because the actual battery is dead and needs replacement and im locked out of her minecraft Thanks Grandma for giving me different experiences and making me into the middle schooler I am today.

[@icommandyew8221]

Rip to your grandma man hope she rests well 🕊💙

[@extendedreal]

Rip bro she was probably great

[@theshowman22]

You know your grandma is great when she knows not to get bedrock over Java, R.I.P Edit 6 months later: I said this as a joke but I really believe Java is better. Sure I might've been a bit disrespectful but I'm constantly getting harrased by 5 year olds in all caps calling me dumb which is actually hallarious. This is blowing up my phone and I'm gonna delete all my comments on this video except this one. Once again you're allowed to have an opinion, I'm allowed to have an opinion and we shouldn't fight over it since we will never change the other person's view on the topic. Another edit: Everybody is acting like op's grandma died from this comment. Which is really stupid.

[@jpx2133]

Sorry for your loss 🙏

[@tegarfauzi1265]

Ur grandma is a gamer

[@mrminiyo4295]

dont matter which one you play because its still minecraft -ghandi

[@nrismeyt]

Still a game but 1.17 is on java frist

[@theultrafish9884]

♓︎⧫︎🕯︎⬧︎ ❍︎♋︎⧫︎⧫︎♏︎❒︎

[@s-manedits9268]

It's Gandhi I think

[@s-manedits9268]

Because I am Indian

[@ieatshortpeople6825]

@@theultrafish9884 what

[@Big_.Marv8025]

Bedrock has an option to increase “simulation distance” which if maximized, can be the same as Java. So when you said that bedrock has higher render distance but there are less chunks where ticks are active, can be changed.

[@xorve6088]

yeah i hate how they pull stuff out of their a** and dont even know if its true

[@rubixtheslime]

Ehh this is still not entirely true. While it is possible to reach 12 chunk sim distance on bedrock, it forms a (roughly) diamond shape. So 12 chunk sim distance on java loads twice as many things as 12 chunk sim distance on bedrock. Also, realms (good luck using a normal server to play with your friends on console) are strictly limited to 4 chunk sim distance. But it looks like they're making efforts to change that last part, thankfully. But that being said bedrock also gets random ticks (and ice generation) across all loaded chunks, and redstone is far less likely to break on chunk borders.

[@ktrain2201]

@@rubixtheslime you can still play normal servers on consoles. Just, you need to adjust a few technical things

[@rubixtheslime]

@@ktrain2201 yeah we've been using a server for a while now actually lol. Turns out a single Dell latitude (a business laptop) from 2006 seems to out-perform realms. Though I still wish they added native support.

[@MrCrompz]

They just added simulation distance to java :O

[@fridayhawks-spangenberg8979]

For xp farms, you neglected the single best feature/bug: trident killers. You can use them to automatically kill mobs with tridents regardless of the item in hand.

[@RavenGaminghaven1]

I also called the drowns trident killers bc they spawn in the river and kill me

[@nothingherezero7182]

Also Looting sword are in effect

[@kenldailable]

Its not a bug when you realize that an arrow shot at a block above a mob then dropped when that same block is destroyed does damage. In bedrock the trident killer os more logical.

[@jacara1981]

Xp orbs can also be funneled to you through water streams. I don't think they can be on Java

[@cloudmeadoww]

@@kenldailable It was a bug, but like quasi connectivity on java, mojang arent going to remove it

[@whyyoumadbro2370]

Bedrock's bridging is horrifying. Literally saw someone seemingly go from one island to another in a few seconds on skywars to hunt for some of the players camping in their spawns.

[@zoid8494]

Ikr! It's Hella easy to bridge in bedrock.

[@whyyoumadbro2370]

@@zoid8494 That’s why I hesitate opening chests in skywars nowadays lol. Would never know if the guy from the nearby island would be jump bridging to me and knocking me off the moment I open the chest.

[@natures1285]

Wdym it's terrible? It's fine and easy to bridge for mobile players what do you expect?

[@nathanielbean3119]

@@natures1285 yea

[@nonamesaretaken5616]

@@natures1285 he meant it in the opposite way

[@karmainstant1954]

I have grown up playing the bedrock version for years and when I talk to people about the difference between java and bedrock, I would usually say bedrock has better gameplay experience (I like never played the java edition before) and that I'm jealous of java having all these redstone possibilities that I cant use that I need. Oh and also in bedrock, you can place a block in front of you while bridging so that is a big plus.

[@FizzyBanger]

Yeah, theres lots of little features Bedrock and Java that I couldn't cover in the video. Things like dyed water in cauldrons just didn't fit into the main discussion, cos I wouldn't buy Bedrock over Java for the little stuff. Its nice to have those things tho

[@krishivraj2361]

Actually, there is a way to do it in Java, only a select few people know about it. All in all, both editions have their pros and cons. In the end, they are Minecraft,

[@bellamywestbrook3257]

Alot of false

[@OverCAT83]

@@bellamywestbrook3257 Bruh why this immediately

[@natsuchoseki]

Only my opinion, but to be honest the bridging feature on bedrock is a little too overpowered. Just imagine you’re just opening your chests on Skywars and you look to a right and a guy is scaffolding towards you as fast as possible. It’s scary haha

[@bluefoxgaming396]

I love that he used a screenshot of Philza when he talked about hardcore lmao rip those 5 years of hardcore season 2

[@yanlina.l.6013]

RIP. At least I'm not the only one that noticed Phil in the video lol

[@lizalingping]

That feeling when you see a junp bridger bridging towards you on phone edition is uncomparable

[@blueflame939]

lol i just ran and he caught me

[@evrodrill]

@@blueflame939 and i was able to do the speed bridging in bedrock just 3 days ago

[@nfsmw1560]

Bro it's POCKET EDITION not Phone Edition

[@thatladliam580]

@@nfsmw1560 calm down Jamal

[@sussyamogussus]

@@thatladliam580 bedrock*

[@creptoid]

I am personally a fan of Java! But Bedrock is really awsome too!

[@Sqeedys]

WAIT, YI_NK? LMAO HOW DO I FIND YOU ON A RANDOM COMMENT SECTION

[@creptoid]

@@Sqeedys WHAT LOL

[@theactualpoopooman7086]

I agree

[@descendantgaming5410]

I'm relieved to hear that.

[@nfsmw1560]

You mean both are GOOD

[@muizzahmed2047]

On bedrock you loose hunger wayyyy quicker. And armor is very op, me and my friend were 1v1ing with prot 4 netherite. He had a sharp 5 sword and strength 2 and was only doing half a heart.

[@negitivebike3169]

Strength only gives two extra damage on bedrock

[@score_pion28]

axes are just not stupidly op on bedrock

[@nathanielbean3119]

@@score_pion28 yea because the combat is different

[@justatalkingnetheriteingot8532]

But potions in bedrock are way more OP. A single witch almost killed me with full enchanted netherite armor.

[@muizzahmed2047]

@@justatalkingnetheriteingot8532 that was a harming 2 potion prob and it goes through armour and does like 8 hearts

[@OverCAT83]

I just want to clarify to people who don't know that there is other sources of modifications to the bedrock version of the game other than the marketplace and most of them are free.

[@dee23gaming]

Mcpedl.com is basically Bedrock's "Planet Minecraft"

[@Danny15]

@@dee23gaming yep

[@ozzy424]

There is also monster-mcpe.com or something like that

[@haroldinho9930]

Yeah I got x ray (didn’t use it on servers don’t worry)

[@cannibalcats4266]

@@sttsparks2421 yup I've done it. I have faithful and a special form of shaders for console.

[@Romvlvs]

If you’re a more casual player I’d recommend bedrock as it’s a lot easier to join friends and the game is runs really well. Bedrock is also great because of its cross compatibility with different consoles mobile pc etc. I’d recommend Java if you’re more interested in cooler mods resource and texture packs shaders a larger variety of servers the ability to make you’re own server red stone custom capes and skins instead of paying for pre made ones and if u wanna build on the nether roof.

[@LunaticNikbro]

every bedrock account getting a cool cape when they make it. mods, shaders and more from mcpedl. redstone is not complicated etc....

[@tezlatower2362]

@@LunaticNikbro it is. For some reason certain setups in Java are far harder to make in Bedrock, so it needs different tutorials.

[@m.xke_v]

minecraft bedrock's texture, mobs, gameplay etc. are just dead lol

[@GAMER32231]

how 2 achieve bedrock multiplayer in java: 1 essential mod 2 essential mod 3 ESSENTIAL MOD

[@vsequity]

​@@m.xke_vSuper untrue btw

[@Mythical620]

In my opinion (pls don’t start a war on me) I used to play bedrock now I play Java and I can easily say Java is better it has more options clients and better combat in my opinion Java requires more skill which is why it’s more rewarding in my opinion

[@skellington1103]

Honestly i think both are good but because Bedrock is still in the process of evolving it tends to be crapped on by java bois

[@Napoleon_e2]

that's just what he said tho, all these are more technical points of the game, not very casual gaming.

[@alexanderjames4176]

Internet: Java vs Bedrock Me: Minecraft!!!!! Is Minecraft!!!!!!! Press like if over 200 likes

[@FizzyBanger]

Yessir!

[@takashi.mizuiro]

yes

[@mcbe357]

minecraft bedrock is minecraft, have name only minecraft

[@alexanderjames4176]

@@mcbe357 He's speaking the language of God's

[@theearthburner6159]

@@alexanderjames4176 he actually means to say that Minecraft bedrock's title says "Minecraft" and Java's title screen says "Minecraft Java"

[@thegunn7526]

My only gripe with bedrock is that it took out the best legacy console features like custom superflats

[@FizzyBanger]

yeah I didn't like making the switch from Legacy to Bedrock (i'm a ps4 player). legacy edition is still available for me, but now i'm used to bedrock

[@hazzabomb707]

@@FizzyBanger yeah same

[@10gamer64]

But Java still has them

[@nothingherezero7182]

@@10gamer64 Phones are the most likely to blame and Supporting older devices

[@10gamer64]

@@nothingherezero7182 True

[@venomousfrog5546]

I will ALWAYS hold that the Java vs Bedrock debate mirrors that of PC vs console: the first of both pairs are leaps and bounds more feature-complete and customizable, while the latter is substantially more accessible for a causal audience. Neither is wholly better than the other; it depends on what you are looking for.

[@ASCYTHERITE]

Personally I like both. I played PE (Bedrock) for 5years now and playing on Win10 is quite easy for me. I started playing Java Last year March, and now I am more familiarize on the controls and shortcuts. In short, I prefer both. I am more used to Bedrock but I also like how Java works

[@FizzyBanger]

I'm more on Java because my PC can record better than my PS4. Plus I started with Java, and I guess the one you start with is the one you play more.

[@ASCYTHERITE]

Yes true

[@nfsmw1560]

Noice

[@Motivationalviirus]

Minecraft education edition is better

[@dry4smash946]

Same zen :)

[@josephparsons6986]

I want to buy Java but I don’t want to waste my money for it turn out that bedrock introduces things like Hardcore and Hypixel...

[@FizzyBanger]

Bedrock is probably going to be a while before Hardcore mode releases. If you have friends on Bedrock, I'd recommend that over Java

[@gassedup]

hypixel chose to not do bedrock and they wont any time soon

[@mutatednut]

Bedrock has much more limitations when it comes to developing a server, but it’s easier to play with your friends.

[@veryhotricke8657]

I prefer Java yet I only played bedrock, just because shaders and mods work better on java.

[@FizzyBanger]

Thats fair enough. Theres more mods on Java too

[@warriorcreeper2941]

@@FizzyBanger did u meant bedrock bruh

[@behradlol5474]

@@warriorcreeper2941 no

[@pinheadlarry5167]

@@warriorcreeper2941 no lol, there's only the ones in the marketplace, on java literally anyone can make one for free, don't bruh at people unless you actually know what ur talking about

[@warriorcreeper2941]

@@pinheadlarry5167 u can make free add-on and can download free bruh r u noob noone uses marketplace in bedrock lol I'm using em client and also PvP texture packs everything for free

[@gottalivehappy]

The UI and player animations are kind of one of the big things for me. Also blinking is just stupid, but not that big of a deal

[@rosecarter5597]

I have a serious bias against animated UI. It makes me feel really sick.

[@callyral]

@@rosecarter5597 iirc you can turn it off on bedrock

[@arsonexc]

5:00 Mob spawner tip, funnel the spawned mobs up a water way with soul sand and keep them in a 1x1 holding bay, the spawner will count the transported mobs as dead so it will spawn more. This makes you able to afk while mobs continue to spawn, then if your done to the holding area and kill them all, or in my case flick a lever to drop them from a height just barely enough to kill them land them in the killzone, eqquiped with droppers and an auto sorter.

[@i_likemen5614]

Things I like about Java: -Hypixel/servers -More features like the off-hand, combat, and being able to switch between versions -mods(mainly optifine I haven't played modded minecraft too much bc I'm dumb) -Menus seem so much nicer -more customizability Things I like about Bedrock: -playing with friends is soo much easier -certain features in Bedrock are just amazing(leads can go on boats) -more optimised -easier to import stuff like maps

[@jaeda6th]

For me, I always believed Bedrock was pocket edition ported to consoles, some computers, and switch. Being a PS4 player I never thought it was very optimized, because Bedrock was initially created for mobile.

[@richardsainz4762]

on jave you can get everything such as resource packs, shaders, maps, etc for free

[@Ashlercu]

Java has better pvp and more fair

[@noonesarino7913]

@@richardsainz4762 oh No You can add resource packs Dude Hell search foxy no tail resource packs I mean he did amazing stuff with what limited

[@noonesarino7913]

@@Ashlercu ehh that divided

[@bouirot]

Bedrock render distance could go 120+ but really you really don’t wanna play in that

[@krakenkrafted5122]

On what engine?

[@beansontoast3566]

@@krakenkrafted5122 Well it goes to 256 chunks on my pc. It doesn't really matter tho.

[@Gring3]

When my Fps goes in the negatives

[@wilbertzhu6218]

@netherite sword he means win 10 I'm able to use 96 chunks

[@aytoad]

@@krakenkrafted5122 I ahve a laptop. It’s decent. Lags a bit sometimes but mostly stays above 60fps and it goes up to 80 chunk

[@idk44P]

I hate the fact that window 10 players can match with phone players on multiplayer servers in bedrock It ruins the experience for the phone players

[@Beetless]

yeah must suck

[@nfsmw1560]

Yea When i play on mobile i die because of PC player's it's Sucks 😡

[@lix1806]

Fr.. it's just annoying. Mobile controls aren't that good in-terms of pvp so imagine get bodied by a skilled player who's playing on pc. That just feels unfair lmao

[@mariaanafidelis5689]

It don't happen when u are playing at Nethergames

[@gearsgamer7115]

@@nfsmw1560 Get a rasberry pi and use optifine on java

[@qTINp]

Small correction you can play multiplayer with "add-ons" being the bedrock version of mods I can confirm first hand. Love your vids keep it up!

[@FizzyBanger]

True, I should've mentioned that. But add-ons are quite small compared to modpacks on Java. And they cost money, which is a rip

[@qTINp]

@@FizzyBanger there are some sites to download can made ones for free for Pocket. They usually also have texture packs

[@warriorcreeper2941]

@@FizzyBanger what they cost money????? I'm a bedrock player btw oh u were talking about mine coins none uses mine coins now a days download I use many add-ons free and as being a pvper I also have free PvP texture packs noone uses mine coins now a days

[@user-so4dp]

@@FizzyBanger you can get mods from mcpedl

[@ronalddendiego7303]

@@user-so4dp you are right

[@robertgdansk]

At last a great comparison that concentrates on high-level view and not minor details like the color of wool after the sheep is saved. Thanks a lot! Great job! :)

[@GdvideosHD]

I like how he said he’s not gonna add any timestamps, but the KZbin just hits him with the “Fine, I’ll do it myself.”

[@protozeus76]

Ngl I love test drive in the background

[@FizzyBanger]

joji is amazing :-)

[@Dandandandandandandandandanda1]

Bedrock has more glitches which means more exploits.

[@FizzyBanger]

truee, and exploits can be fun to mess with. but theres also some glitches that hurt the gameplay experience, like crashes. they don't happen much, but they do frequent more than Java

[@northwastaken]

@@FizzyBanger you can have a heart attack while pillaring in bedrock that's not a fun experience

[@_unfunnyhumour]

@@northwastaken don't you just hate it when you suddenly have a heart attack while playing a game

[@northwastaken]

@@_unfunnyhumour I do

[@lowhead_bread]

@@FizzyBanger speaking of exploits, there is an smp series in bedrock yt community called Xploits which is basically the bedrock equivalent of sci-craft, you should check it out

[@lelethesigma]

You really need more subscribers! You explain it clearly, doesnt go around the place, and even usually i dont like to watch these kinds of videos but your channel's are fun! Keep it up!

[@noddlelebowski1074]

There shouldn’t be different versions. Why cant we all play not Java edition not bedrock edition just Minecraft edition where every mechanics, redstone, farms, and features are same whether you play in a computer with 4K ultra ram or a phone with 1 kB of storage.

[@christiaanboshoff]

That's what they're doing though. Just not with Java.

[@noddlelebowski1074]

That’s what I am saying. Java has some advantages over bedrock and bedrock has some advantages over Java. So why not we combine them and just play Minecraft without bedrock or Java.

[@spO0ked]

It’s very difficult to make Java compatible with different devices, but I know what you’re saying though

[@OverCAT83]

How bout a new version pf minecraft that is not called Java nor bedrock

[@boredianz]

@@OverCAT83 So Just Minecraft?

[@Rocketcraft]

You make some good points. But quasi connectivity was considered a bug at first in java redstone but so many of the community made use of it so rather than face a massive backlash and potentially lose a part of that free promotion you mentioned, they were forced to leave it in the game. Hence why the bug tracker has been changed to say that it’s working as intended. I would go so far as to say that Bedrock redstone works as the devs intended. Think about it. Players were never meant to get up on the nether roof, let alone build up there! Which is why the devs made sure that it’s not possible to build up there on Bedrock as that is what was intended. But they can’t take it away from the java community now because again like with the redstone, they know they will lose players that freely promote their product. Same goes for the redstone differences, which is why quasi is not in Bedrock. But like you say, play the version that makes you happy, that’s what Minecraft is all about 😃

[@trebleclef9844]

ok but if you do something that people like even tho it is accident, isnt that good

[@The2FunBro]

Your right :)

[@HungryWarden]

This isn’t fair though. Apparently Horses in boats was a bug on bedrock, so they patched it out. WHY DID THEY REMOVED THIS?!?

[@yuhboyyoussef]

As a bedrock player (cause I’m on xbox) I respect the java community We might Play a different version of Minecraft But we all beat the ender dragon in creative and we made a diamond house before. But most importantly, we made memories 🙂

[@zaayowtheone]

Facts.

[@Kentang_Enak]

Yeah i used to play bedrock and after that moving to Java, still so many memories i've made with bedrock

[@mcpepro7744]

@@Kentang_Enak diamond house is so true

[@TorchOG]

This is a good video to eat cereal to

[@FizzyBanger]

yum :-)

[@r011ing_thunder6]

The ultimate compliment

[@Aastik0]

fizzy will NOT heart this comment

[@FizzyBanger]

you are incorrect

[@Aastik0]

@@FizzyBanger now that is called reverse psychology and I like how you are not biased :)

[@FinnishNationalist123]

@@Aastik0 lmao

[@shadowgamer7151]

Lol

[@James89227]

Wow, watching this 1 year later, almost all of these things have been changed for parity, they have come a long way…

[@mrcrazycrocs]

*why not both?*

[@adidevlol]

Dude quality editing awesome video earned a sub

[@InfraMC]

Btw why no youtuber talk about the trident killer for farm purposes(It makes the gold farm so muck efficient)

[@raxanimations7215]

They all are *MINECRAFT*

[@FizzyBanger]

Yes!

[@cvkaustubh7521]

True, forgot about wars

[@Zafbone]

*Always* *Has* *Been*

[@Kapullus]

Its more accurate as “Different versions of minecraft that has different advantages”. They are based around same game, but there are different types of editions or versions. So you are half right half wrong

[@T1RM_M8]

I know my favorite is legacy

[@janthedoodler]

The trident riptide and channeling sounds are also a difference between the editions

[@jaeda6th]

I can't tell the difference between the riptide sound effects but I know the textures are different.

[@Gring3]

Can we talk about how amazing it is that you turn into a drill with the riptide

[@Mockedarche_old]

Biggest thing I love about bedrock is ticking areas. It allows you to have 10 4 chunk areas that run all the time. So far the only thing that doesn't work with it seems to be mob spawning.

[@Loctorak]

How do you do that? Is it some kind of server command and you set the chunks or...? Reason i ask is we have this bonemeal generator that works by keeping a sand block with kelp planted on it in basically 2 states at once with a sticky piston. But this means the whole thing relies on the chunk that its in being loaded and running because if it unloads at all, when loaded back the sand won't be in its correct state of perpetual movement between the two states. To fix this, the generator needs to be dismantled a bit and reconstructed such that we can turn it on again. So basically what happens is we'll get it going, walk like 30m away to check our furnaces and then come back and the whole contraption has stalled and needs surgery to be started again. Super annoying. But if we could elect a chunk that is loaded on the server and set it to be permanently online, then that would fix everything 😂

[@Beefbouillon]

I really enjoyed the atmosphere of this video. Keep up the great work.

[@wafflebell]

I’m absolutely shocked how you have 12K subs this video is really good! I subbed

[@FizzyBanger]

aw thankyou!!

[@PufferFishXx4]

I was always used to minecraft console edition. I remember when my friend showed me bedrock for the first time I turned to him and said, “why does it look like pocket edition?”

[@nfsmw1560]

Because Pocket edition Bedrock edition & also Console edition are same now days

[@Henry-kp6qs]

PS3 edition was my first like memory of Minecraft

[@nfsmw1560]

@@Henry-kp6qs Mine is Pocket

[@riot9179]

It just have the same main menù. The whole game is compl. Different from the old Pocket Edition.

[@philipboll7443]

This guy deserves all the subs in the world. I subbed!

[@mrerichoodc6835]

I have both. Redstone for Java and playing with friends on Bedrock

[@Mariosc007gr]

bro you are right in all of the topics except one in Bedrock edition my GPU usage was at 2% cpu 3% and the ram consumption at 400 mb in java though almost every component was thermothroteling my CPU usage was AT 70% only for Minecraft the GPU AT 87% and the ram usage was set on 3gb and I was running at 50fps at most (Ryzen 3 GTX 1050 ram 12gb ddr4)

[@YogurtSnipe]

How did this guy find so many bugs in Bedrock? I’ve been playing for so many years and never have seen game changing bugs ever since 2014.

[@remaks3929]

@rexmexx99 no

[@Ordlnary_Gamer]

no it was made along time ago in 2011 the start of pe

[@haroldinho9930]

Why doesn’t anyone else have the same problem as me? Every 15 minutes it crashes, even worse it turns my Xbox off and it takes 10 minutes to get back into the world

[@YogurtSnipe]

@@haroldinho9930 That’s not even a problem anymore because of how much it happens.

[@haroldinho9930]

@@YogurtSnipe oh and I’m not joking about the 15 minutes bit, sometimes even 10

[@gabrielhenry7237]

At one point in time I would say one was better than the other and vice versa but now I just love em both.

[@azzym]

i want to build only in minecraft, and i want getting shaders, cool graphics etc which one i should get java or bedrock?

[@jamarianhall2701]

5:32 what about the cactus XP** farm in bedrock, that’s overpowered as heck also

[@Mimikyu7372]

my view is java is more feature based and i enjoy the lack of minecoins and modding community however Bedrock is more optimsed and better for more casual multiplayer especially if your friends are cross platform

[@sxmmie._6887]

ok so question pls excuse my grammar but its my 1st time to play mc on a laptop and i dont rlly know if java is better or bedrock ive only played mc on my phone

[@Mimikyu7372]

@@sxmmie._6887 I'd say I'd you have Minecraft on your phone (Bedrock) play Java

[@ablejester5588]

only people who get a say in which is better are people who have and play both versions

[@GigaGs]

Everyone gangsta untill Mojang tells that they are making both of the versions identical ;)

[@MichaelK1710]

They said they want to achieve 100% parity

[@whygoogle5977]

Hopefully that doesn’t mean Java gets microtransactions, I despise those. I like my free skins, maps and mods. If it wasn’t for that stuff I would’ve switched to bedrock long ago

[@MichaelK1710]

@@whygoogle5977 yes the marketplace is bs

[@Gring3]

I don't want them to be the same personally, cause then there's a reason to play both.

[@Gring3]

Also as long as Axolotls are in both they are both the same game already the best one that has existed.

[@Igorovič6254]

Fizzy Banger: The top minecraft youtubers are playing java Me: No ALL Minecraft youtubers play on java.

[@chanbricks4461]

ibxtoycat, Silentwhisperer and a handful of other Ytbers:

[@anjanagowda5604]

@@chanbricks4461 literally only ibxtoycat, silent whisperer eystreem and jc plays

[@lilruni]

On my phone, i can only get 10 chunks render distance max, and it doesnt even run smoothly, not until 6 CHUNKS!!!

[@timecrashv5wu709]

Bedrock is fun with friends and crossplay and easy to play Java has awesome mods, texture pack and server

[@gearsgamer7115]

and ive seen better preformace on java servers. As java is more optmized especially with optifine. If you got a lot of firneds, use java

[@corruptedplayer]

one thing i respect about bedrock is, everyone who has a console bedrock game can play evenly me with my not so good pc can't even play java on 20 fps (on a normal world) meanwhile my friend can run it at 60+ fps

[@hodaabusbha2350]

Get optifine

[@negitivebike3169]

@@hodaabusbha2350 redstone's too hard just download a mod

[@Napoleon_e2]

@@hodaabusbha2350 optifine also breaks the game quite a bit, it does for example, stop chunks from loading in in some instances

[@lpfan4491]

My biggest draw towards Bedrock and Legacy Console is that for me, playing with a controller is much easier and more fun than to play with keyboard and mouse. I am aware that there is a mod for Java edition, but I'd like to stay modfree for my current casual experience...well, besides that mods don't update alongside the game and I just don't want to deal with it. Otherwise, I think Java would be overall better because the features and details exclusive to it simply matter more. A very drastic example would be flat vs superflat, which are exclusive to the respective games. Flat being exclusive to bedrock really doesn't matter if superflat can perfectly replicate the flat-experience and has a lot more to offer ontop of it. Sure, there are a lot of examples that are less unfair towards bedrock, but it really puts it into perspective how Bedrock still has a decent way to go. However, I agree with the video that it really doesn't matter in the end. They already support an environment where people play both, because both are sold together on PC and everyone should just play what they want at the end of the day. I previously mentioned that I personally still play Legacy Console, despite it not getting updated anymore.

[@ItsTeaTimeCommentary]

for the performance test you should have done bedrock on pc and java with the same specs, because i can get around 100-140 fps with 22-24 render distance on java.

[@joebob3683]

For me on the newest version on both I get low but steady frame rate on max render distance, BUT on java I have to wait for things to load if I crank it. Thats 72 chunks on bedrock vs 30 something on JAVA (been playing mods so I forget). Bedrock defently runs better when considering render distance. But the Trident killer farms are so efficient that it may start to lag do to the shear amount of entities that can exist. I got a Iron farm, an expanded gold farm, a villiger trading hall and a sugar cane farm. If I postion my self to AFK all 4 the trident killer generates enough XP orbs in about 5 minuets to start lagging the game (the hopper system doesn't seem fast enough to pull the items out fast enough but the lag stops when I collect the xp)

[@ItsTeaTimeCommentary]

@finler ram is that with or without optifine?

[@leohe2594]

@@ItsTeaTimeCommentary use sodium/(iris+sodium) +lithium+starlight dude you get way more fps

[@nabukun]

Gonna sit down relax and get popcorn and watch this c:

[@razorwave2250]

The modding Community on bedrock isn't necessarily not as active as the java community, the only reason the mods (or should I say addons) are not as good on bedrock edition is because mojang limits what the modding community are able to do. For example, the bedrock community isn't able to get custom dimensions yet. However, every update mojang programs upgrades the modding capabilities so it gets better.

[@errorbrine3036]

True, you can't even edit vanilla items and vanilla blocks.

[@jacobkennedy3588]

People: *fighting over which is better, console or PC* Me: *Thinking they're both lucky because i play on mobile* OOF!!!!!

[@jamkb9266]

I play on mobile

[@proudamerican183]

I play mcpe/mobile.

[@jamkb9266]

Bridging in Mobile is 1000x easier than javs

[@anjanagowda5604]

@@jamkb9266 that's what a mobile player would say

[@anjanagowda5604]

mcpe is bedrock edition

[@darq_music4780]

As a Minecraft player that plays both version, I would say that Java is better

[@a.m.jsSTATS]

I’m a bedrock player and i respect your opinion

[@sobanya_228]

I just started on Java and I just hate that there are two versions and they can't focus on one. They could if they had full parity, which is probably impossible by now.

[@MCdotMCPlays]

I play both. I use Java to make videos, to play server with my friends and to play on my survival world. I use bedrock for making builds and redstones because my bedrock is on mobile

[@sheereenaali8448]

"Java Gets Updates First." Texture Update: *Am I a Joke to You?*

[@nfsmw1560]

What?

[@sheereenaali8448]

@@nfsmw1560 Well, you know the current 2019 textures, right? Well those were released on Bedrock over a month before Java.

[@sheereenaali8448]

@@nfsmw1560 Btw I'm an NFS Fan

[@sheereenaali8448]

@@nfsmw1560 I also became your 4th Subscriber.

[@nfsmw1560]

@@sheereenaali8448 Oh Thx

[@rubixtheslime]

To quote Navy Nexus, a popular technical bedrock player, "bedrock redstone isn't bad, it's just different." As one of the people who's working to understand the technical side of bedrock, honestly I find technical java almost boring at this point. But I especially hate how so many java players complain about differences in bedrock without realizing how that change can be used. So many people complain that there's no Quasi-Connectivity in bedrock, but conveniently leave out Soft Inversion because they either don't know about it or don't realize how useful it is. I'd even argue that SI is _more_ useful than QC, as it never gets in the way. If you play both with and without QC for long enough, you'd realize that it doesn't actually help a lot more than it hinders. But SI is never detrimental, and compacts so many things that can't be compacted on Java (such as item filters and SR latches). People also complain about the inability to bud pistons. Once again, piston budding breaks almost as much as it helps. Can you make a flying machine that doesn't break when flying into unloaded chunks? You can on bedrock! And then there's the railstone. Railstone is much slower on bedrock, and rails can't be budded. But rails became popular on java because redstone dust causes extreme amounts of lag. That lag is not present on bedrock, so how bad is it really all that bad that railstone is slower when we don't need it in order to not crash the game? Same story with block dropping. Yes it's useful, but it also breaks things. Try doing technical things for a year or two without it and you'll realize just how annoying block dropping can be. Same story with comparators and two tick pulses. Breaks a few, helps a few. And that's not even getting into the bedrock exclusives, like trident grinders, C and P pulses, force ticking lava, mobs take fall damage if entering and immediately exiting a minecart, and faster piston bolts. And in my opinion some of the java exclusives make it a little boring sometimes. Intricate system that tricks ghasts or creepers into blowing up the farmed blocks vs use the same old duplication machine to get infinite TNT. Design new flying machine dedicated for a given task vs use the exact same 6 blocks every single time. If you read the whole thing, congratulations.

[@FizzyBanger]

I did read this all, and in hindsight, I could've used this really good insight when making my video. I haven't even heard of Soft Inversion, but from doing a quick search of it online, its really got some great capabilities. I should have made the point that wanting Java and Bedrock redstone parity is unreasonable. In fact its probably preferred to have two different sets of redstone mechanics to stoke more creativity for technical players.

[@FizzyBanger]

By the way, thank you for this comment. You took a lot of time into it, and I appreciate that :)

[@rubixtheslime]

@@FizzyBanger some parity is good, but I definitely like the diversity. There's a reason I didn't mention movable block entities, it's confirmed that is eventually coming to java. Sorry I was a bit negative, I was a bit tired at the time, and also used to most people immediately jumping to flaming. I'm glad you appreciate it!

[@cpeir8460]

Hey bedrock edition has something called behavior packs and I make them. Bedrock is just easier to play bc you can join a world so it’s more easier

[@FizzyBanger]

I've never heard of behavior packs. Are they like datapacks?

[@Chris-es4dg]

@@FizzyBanger they are like mods on java

[@cpeir8460]

@@Chris-es4dg not exactly Behavior packs are more like data packs and plugins

[@cvkaustubh7521]

Behaviour & resource packs under addons

[@spranzo1483]

I’ve had played both Java and bedrock. I’ve had two survival worlds that got super late game one on Java and the other on bedrock. Java I made huge farms for stuff and redstone contraptions. Bedrock I duped and used glitches for stuff and building was way better. I love both versions of Minecraft because I like duping and exploiting stuff and doing technical stuff. I go to bedrock for glitches and better building and I go to Java for great redstone and farms. There are some cons to both versions bedrock can get very laggy for me personally and glitches that are not beneficial can happen. Java‘s cons are the combat sucks in my opinion and none of the cool bedrock features.

[@Tripod9648]

I’ll never owned a PC, nor have I played Java up until recently. Every since i was little, I have played on my iPad demo version. From their, i ended up getting a PS4 after getting rid of my Cbox one. And from their, all i have ever known was bedrock. Is it good? yes and no. Their are a lot of ups and downs to bedrock but ultimately, my ps4 was plagued with glitches, lags, poor rendering, and bad import soundtracks that would crash my game. I am sure someone who plays in bedrock on a PC would have a much better experience then a inferior playstation. But i found Java so much more fun and enjoyable. PC is the way to go if you want to fully experience both versions of Minecraft.

[@sandstrom534]

Me: Just enjoying the little swing animation with my sword in Java edition and thinking that Java is bettet then bedrock becuse of that

[@Rocketcraft]

One word - Cool-down (or is that two words?) 😂 Anyway, enjoy taking twice as long to kill anything in java while I’m spamming the hell out of the attack button on Bedrock 😉

[@franciscagemegah7831]

@@Rocketcraft ha gottem

[@ralphkhan9664]

K... That's just one thing

[@gottalivehappy]

Probably not

[@Rocketcraft]

@ItsRedPanda Best make sure you don’t fluff that crit then! But it must get annoying having to jump every time you want to hit a mob?!

[@henryz5104]

Normally I would of chose Java, but all my friends play on Bedrock, and I would like to play with them.

[@henryz5104]

@i hit fortnite kids I got bedrock 2-3 weeks ago!

[@Gring3]

Friends always win.

[@henryz5104]

@@Gring3 Yes

[@Beetless]

A shame the way your friends HATE minecraft

[@StormerrXI]

4:38 Isn’t that normal? I thought a glitch in java was that wasn’t happening

[@JL_online]

I personally prefer bedrock edition, everything is a lot more difficult but it’s worth it to be able to play with my mobile friends :) ...and I like the poses on the armor stands

[@kapa_nitori]

i wish we dont have to get datapacks or mods to do that on java... :(

[@jairodominguez04]

I want to play on switch because it’s more comfortable, but I heard it runs horribly. Bummer.

[@rae6659]

As a switch player, for me it runs quite well. Lag is minimal, pretty much only on servers. Maybe it's my console itself, but who knows? I'd recommend trying it!

[@rae6659]

@finler ram true. I don't bother about my skin that much but I agree

[@throwthebeaver298]

12:12 You are almost correct, but people can play Minecraft Beta/ Minecraft Preview to try out the new features. Bonus to your conclusion: If a player have Win 10, they can download the version they like, OR download both :)

[@Quantexture]

Yes! Finally somone smart like you also figured this thing! ( uhhh I am sorry for sounding really weird.. )

[@mczackgaming]

Latest Minecraft W10 Has Some issue in Intel HD Graphics Card Tho I Can't Play :/

[@Sinfoniia]

Yeah I use a Radeon amd and it is much more lagged than java edition

[@FizzyBanger]

I did not know about this. Maybe I should've bought W10 Edition to test it out on my PC

[@frooty9508]

Bedrock is hardcore. Tons of bugs, unreliable redstone, and strong af wither.

[@ninjii1236]

I was waiting for someone to bring up the wither it always happens we get the bugs, good and bad

[@El_Mince]

Why does the wither have twice as much health

[@pawned0645]

Mm the redstone there is better than java lol

[@mogenvonbogel7342]

@@pawned0645 how is it better u can’t do half the stuff u can in java

[@blankxd5837]

It's not "unreliable redstone". It's just different from java.

[@insert05]

the only thing I like about java is because of the 1.9 combat update, being able to hold any item in your offhand, and that you can do a small amount of more stuff.

[@insert05]

well now I have java and my worries are over

[@happyszzzzs2173]

reason minecraft bedrock is popular in Philippines and India is because its really cheap And and you can use mcpe on your mobile So yah thats the reason it's more popular in India and Philippines

[@FizzyBanger]

Thats true, those devices are more available to use compared to an expensive PC build

[@ItsMeYunii]

As someone who live in the philippines I can confirm this is truee cuz almost all of my classmates and cousins including me have mcpe and we use to play multiplayer all the time sometimes if there is free time in class, we use mobile since we can't buy java..

[@happyszzzzs2173]

@@ItsMeYunii lol I live in india

[@crownhouses2296]

Minecraft Java is my all time favorite, one of the reasons being red stone. I used to play bedrock on my console, & the PE version. But You can do such crazy awesome things in Java, I’ve done cool stuff but consider myself a novice compared to what others can do. My favorite command block build though, was a huge capture the flag map. I set up command blocks that let you press a button to change the color (wool & stained clay blocks, actually fairly simple /fill commands) your towers flag, your armor (just a /give command for dyed leather) & the floor of your half of the arena. When a player won by “holding” the enemy flag for 10 seconds, the arena erupted with fireworks and everything changed to the color of the wining team. I also love using the /title command to make text appear on screen. Like “Welcome to Capture the Flag”! It made me feel like I had a server in vanilla XD. It was on my sisters first ever realm and I hate myself for not downloading backup of the map Lol. Also I’m subscribing because not only was this video was great but that comment about 7billion people not being subscribed had me cracking up. Please ignore my typos, I’m not illiterate I’m just on mobile and it’s 6am lmao

[@FizzyBanger]

this comment made me happy :) I'm glad to hear how much you enjoy Java, and also how much you enjoyed this video! btw that command block stuff impresses me, the only command I know well is /gamemode ... 🙃

[@crownhouses2296]

@@FizzyBanger to be honest I’m still a little upset that they changed it from /gamemode 0, 1, 2, 3 to /gamemode survival, creative, etc. I mean I know I can press tab but it still feels like more work 😂😭

[@FizzyBanger]

wait, does tab change gamemode?? :o

[@crownhouses2296]

@@FizzyBanger no no haha sorry that was vague. when you use the command /gamemode you can hit tab and it auto fills the word for you, same with any command. So if I hit tab it’ll say /gamemode survival, and I’d I tap it again Itll change to creative, etc. I feel like I made that more complicated than I needed to but it’s too late now XD

[@Cherno_Lad]

as a fellow australian, im definetly subbing

[@highnoon3838]

Why don't they have Java on Mobile with a warning on the game that says: Only for high-end devices)?

[@vincecarterlover911]

Cuz java is a flex that you have a good pc

[@Beetless]

Because there’s no java for iOS if your jailbroken I know there’s a way but for Android it should exist I guess

[@gearsgamer7115]

acully you can search it up

[@natures1285]

Because java isn't good on phones and also consoles.

[@highnoon3838]

@@natures1285 Not even for the new IPad Pro M1?

[@rafhaeltanedo]

silentwhisperer and bowtieman there are really good at redstone

[@issamelkonian963]

do you know that the weither boss is more powerful in bedrock edition ?

[@KingOskar4]

This was AMAZING!!! I loved the conclusion "Choose Bedrock if you have a console or smartphone only. Choose Java for more Technical playstyle (commands & mods)" THIS IS AWESOME conclusion. But I can enhance it only with my, anecdotal, subjective opinion: What I seek in Minecraft is Scuba Diving! Fish, treasures, underwater enviroment. For this, Java is better for having command blocks that can be set to give infinite water breathing OR turn of drowning damage altogether in game rules, become a FISH!! (That is weird). In Bedrock, if you want to scuba dive, your best choice is to BUY a diving themed map or mash-up pack (there are couple, I bought and used Deep Sea Mash Up Pack).. The problem came with Scuba Diving: On PC Java, it was free. On my smartphone's Bedrock, it was paid/premium.

[@FizzyBanger]

I actually get what you mean. I enjoyed deep oceans a lot in Minecraft, so I found a datapack which extended the oceans really far down so you could explore reallyyy far down. You simply can't get that from Bedrock, which may change in the future, but for now its not as avidly modded yet.

[@aytoad]

Incorrect. You can do this in bedrock. The reason why you “can’t” do this is because command syntax is different.

[@KingOskar4]

@@aytoad Indeed! I have found two things with commands that work in bedrock: One is /effect (name) water_breathing 1200 0 that gives an air time o 20 minutes, works as a command line or command block. Another option was /gamerule doDrowningDamage false which disabled Air time altogether but made bubbles appear around every few second. You are "drowning" in this way but you never "drown" and it plays the animation but not the effect nor does it hurt, making you a fish. So sorry AYTOAD I have not written this later

[@lix1806]

@@KingOskar4 i mean...u can make the effect(Water breathing) Last Infinitely using the command....

[@KingOskar4]

@@lix1806 Oh, that also works, I just never tried a time longer than 1200 or 2400 (20 minutes and 40 minutes respectively)

[@quinx5251]

Fizzy I want your honest opinion, in terms of combat, which version do you prefer? I want to know whether you like cooldown times on weapons rather than being able to infinitely spam left click.

[@FizzyBanger]

well I've kinda grown to like the cooldown times, cos it paces combat a lot better. It also adds more playstyles, with axe and sword play being different. Altho I still like Bedrock's combat, I'd prefer Java anyday.

[@neospearx4180]

I'd prefer java editions combat mechanics but I'd prefer playing bedrock edition. So I hope later they add a combat update to bedrock too

[@kapa_nitori]

i prefer 1.9 java pvp mechanics. it makes the game more balanced like, axes are stronger but theyre heavy af making it slower to damage your opponent. with swords, its lighter so it becomes faster yet weaker.

[@Gring3]

Oh god do not start up the 1.9 vs 1.8 war oh no

[@StormerrXI]

1:29 I normally play MCPE on pc, and it’s high compared to java. On laptops the max is probabaly like 50 or 60 or 70, on my desktop I got max 76 render. It didn’t really lag much. On java though, 32 render was..let’s just say not pleasant

[@mairin862]

"Bedrock is for more casual people" Also bedrock : Wither has double health, Some crafting recipes require more materials, Half of the game costs IRL money

[@UnCursed]

wdym "cost irl money" theres a way to avoid spending more money law xd

[@duckhuntdawg]

you aren’t required to buy anything but the game

[@LunaticNikbro]

i play bedrock edition on my phone with 22 chunk distance 😃. good performence

[@nelAjamZ]

Thats why Minecraft Bedrock edition on ps5 looks washed out...

[@zismale2505]

in my opinion,vannila bedrock is better then vannila java,but bedrock is worse because of minecoins and lack of somethings on java,but overall,java is better

[@fawlynramsey1858]

POV: you’re here just to see if people are arguing

[@SierNotsruht]

Your not wrong

[@yuzumete]

true