Most Hyped Speaker of the Year? Buchardt S400ii Review - Does it Live Up?

[@garywright8137]

I bought these speakers and they are wonderful, however I had to return them due to ill health. Buchardt were AMAZING in helping me out with the return and I honestly cannot speak highly enough of them. These are good people who care about their customers, and the speakers are incredible for the price.

[@davidjurney]

Sorry to hear about the ill health, but it's great to hear about your experience with them. I really wish the mark II’s had been released before I bought my current speakers.

[@lifeevent88]

How's your health now?

[@mjstealey9100]

Happy to see some more expensive gear trickling into your reviews. Not because I'll ever be in the position to afford it, but rather to have established data points when you're making comparisons to more value minded options. If the Buchardt's hit like a leather baseball bat on the Mcintosh setup, then I might be happy with a naugahyde whiffle ball bat when something at my price point comes along. Appreciated as always Randy, Thanks!

[@williameuler8056]

I’m in love with these, but can’t do 2 grand atm. I’ve watched all reviews on these, all very good, but your review, Randy, was the most insightful and honest, you actually pointed out a few flaws. One day I hope to be listening to these speakers. Keep it up Randy, your killing it.

[@briancampbell7712]

I purchased on reviews also...after hooking them up I was very disappointed...they definitely lack detail...I packed them right back up and paid Buchardt €100 as they require for return...You don't see many reviews here on Dali because they are harder to come by in America...they are designed and made in Denmark...I wouldn't bother with there lower end speakers but the Rubicon and the Epicon are fabulous!!... there's a private owners review here on KZbin on the Epicon...I imagine best possible for any set up would be a great integrated tube amp and the Epicon 2 - I can only imagine pure bliss!!

[@yaniv-nos-tubes]

the p300 b stock are 1100$. i got the se version make sure to pair with a warm lively amp.

[@oohmeconkers1968]

I’ve recently purchased the P300’s. I went for the 300 in place of these as I read a review saying that the 400’s only worked better with superior sources and amplification.. I agree with everything you say. My room is medium sized and the speakers are probably not in the best place… however they really do open up the music. Love the channel Randy and greetings from the UK

[@gewamser]

I don’t know if you get a chance to read these, but I just wanted you to know, that the $15 DAC I bought on your recommendation continues to amaze me! Especially when I record a “hi-def” album off Amazon Music onto CD on a TEAC professional grade recorder. Then play back on a good blue-ray through the DAC: the improved sound all across the board is palatable. 10% to 15% gain in fidelity at least. I have a great vintage system: Kyrocera 561 into 4 Heresy’s…the highs like cymbals ring more, sound more “real” the voices and horns crisp and clear, the bass deeper and more thumpy. I am a serious listener, but retired on a fixed income so the $ saved here and the result represents an incredible audio value. Thanks!

[@tailgator5483]

Which dac would that be?

[@gewamser]

@@tailgator5483 The Prozor.

[@tailgator5483]

@@gewamser Thanks for the response.

[@robertorodriguez2609]

I have always believed there is no serious difference between DACs no matter the price.

[@gewamser]

@@robertorodriguez2609 I honestly don’t know, this is the only one I have experience with, but I would like to hear a few more to learn.

[@stevelewis9529]

Thanks!

[@cheapaudioman]

Steve! thank you so much!

[@mcjonner]

Would like a comparison with the critons in that video :) I think it's fair game to start comparing diy once the speakers get to be more expensive than the kit to showcase the quality of the kit. I don't think it'll steal alot of business away from manufacturers, whoever decides to build the kit was probably somewhat interested in diy already and not understanding how they compare is what holds many back so those videos and comparisons could be very inspiring for the right person to finally pull the trigger on a project.

[@patrickalfonso2374]

Agreed, I think it's great discussion on value-proposition... Even if it's just a brief, one-line comparison. I am always curious what a little elbow-grease can get me in the audio market. It's possible Randy is moving out of that market though, since it blocks out some people without tools, ability, etc.

[@ufarkingicehole]

Yes!!!!!

[@terryhk99leung36]

Totally agree..

[@BatMan-to8im]

I have the Crittons and I don't like them too much, every reviewer has liked them a lot but I find them to have be slightly unnatural sounding. I don't have the upgraded crossovers. That could make all the difference to my ears but it's too expensive to experiment with.

[@alpuzzuoli6111]

Even if you're not comfortable with DIY, this would be a very valuable comparison. I just bought a Criton 1TD-X Fully Finished Pair. With tax and shipping, they cost about $2500 to my door, so definitely in the same ballpark I would say.

[@1mctous]

Polk R700 towers vs. Buchardt S400 Mk. II would be a good shootout, both just over $2K/pr.

[@weezydeezy9854]

I second that request. For the second time. Lol

[@cheapaudioman]

I haven't heard those. would love to though. I really like the reserve series

[@rianredfield5252]

Also, PSB Passif 50, please

[@jimx1169]

You're best review to date IMO. Nicely done!

[@jonuiuc]

The big camparo I think people would wanna see is the CSS audio.

[@4thewinir344]

Please Please do this comparo!

[@kohnfutner9637]

also the goldenear brx

[@orwhat24]

Buying speakers is such a tough thing, but these reviews help a lot. Running them off the Macs is almost not playing fair. A Mac fan once told me he could power a pair of Dixie cups connected with strings and it would sound great. 🤨

[@NeilBlanchard]

I'll bet they sound just as good on the AkitikA GT-102 Z4. 🙂 Which is $400 as a kit, or $575 built and tested. Damn fine amp - the *best* I have ever heard, in my 40+ years of music listening.

[@gokhanersan8561]

Agreed.

[@leoalex2001]

Oh my god I love the warning in the beginning 😂

[@ibassnote]

Cowboy briefcase. Another descriptive gem. I own Buchardt A500. Different animal but some of what you said is transferable. Impressive bass, clear forward mid, airy highs, never fatiguing. With the right amp…magic.

[@lukeizze]

Amp pairing please? What do you reccomend?

[@wegardfjeld3789]

Buchardts I150 with room correction. Vincent 237 mk2. Class A amps. Just a few paths

[@wegardfjeld3789]

Advanced Paris A10 is good with them. , Black Ice Audio F35 V2 should also be pretty great with them. I'm getting one soon. Home trial them 😉.

[@MrTabacon]

Nice review, and glad to see that for the money they performed as well as they did. Info on the crossover was helpful, was hoping to see how they were braced internally since I'm sure that's a piece of the puzzle.

[@jungtarcph]

they have been criticized for not having a middle braze but Mads answered they did a test with a brace and they did not perform better...

[@Creativity4John]

Great video. Loads of information, clearly expressed. And, you crack me up so it all adds up to an informative entertaining few minutes.

[@philhughes765]

Leather baseball bat. 5 stars. Another honest and very helpful review, sir.

[@kevinbroderick9488]

Boy, would I love to see these pitted against the current darling of the blogosphere - the Polk R700. At $2000/pair for the R700s it shapes up as a battle of the titans.

[@weezydeezy9854]

I second that request.

[@tomat4135]

I think Jay compared these to the R700 in his review. If I can remember it right, the R700s have the bass scale and loads the room better at the cost of top-end finesse and clarity.

[@weezydeezy9854]

@@tomat4135 You might be right. I'll have to go back and take a look. Bookshelves usually soundstage and image a bit better. Hard choice between the S400's and a nice sub and the R700's(no sub). Good time to into the hobby with so many great choices. Not good for the wallet though. Lol

[@weezydeezy9854]

@@tomat4135 Jay compared these to Tektons. Your comment did get me to enter Jay's giveaway though.

[@tomat4135]

@@weezydeezy9854 That is great! :) At 6:30 he spends a minute and some to describe the difference between floorstanders like the R700 and the "Buchardt etc". Apples and oranges wrt scale. Then a minute later he says "decent but not great" mids and high. Then later on (Soundstage and imaging) he compares to the R200, i then took that and went to the R200 review to get the delta towards B400mkII. So as I gahter, the R700s are awesome "large speakers" for the price and the Buchardt/Criton are awesome "small speakers". Refinement and imaging accuracy go to the small speakers and scale and bass texture go to the R700.

[@twistyflora]

I'd get the finished/upgraded CSS Criton 1-TDX from Michigan, long before I got the Bucharest S400ii. Similarly priced, easy to replace parts, and much more affordable to power since the CSS is an 8 ohm load.

[@twistyflora]

These Buchardt speakers just need a bunch of $ to make them sound good. 2K speaker? Sure. But it sounds like you've got to throw about 3-5K worth of equipment to make them work. Not a value in my book. Not when the CSS (and the KLH Model 5) is available.

[@scheme39]

Very happy with my 1TDX so far.

[@JukeboxAlley]

My thoughts exactly.

[@henriksrensen3220]

Audiovector R1 arrete is one of the best standmount speakers under 10000 €

[@gklinger]

@@henriksrensen3220 They're like $5000 or $6000, right? That's quite a leap.

[@dimachesebastian6407]

One BIG question....From all the speakers you have testes wich was the most beautiful sounding at low volume?.. i mean late night listening mode.

[@shanediaz8298]

Would be curious to hear these up against Monitor Audio SIlver 100 7G -

[@therealboofighter]

3:53 the perspective is wild in that shot. With the slope of the bottom and the angle that they are sitting at. Tripping

[@cheapaudioman]

wide angle lens trickery

[@Ivy13276]

Thank you Randy for your hard work, your reviews are a real value!

[@GuitarSpotTV]

Those or KEF R3 Metas ? Dillemma....

[@Feliciano12v]

Sounds like a great speaker. Keep them coming! Can’t wait for the speaker shoot out!

[@thisisnev]

I have an idea, Randy - to appease the price critics, how about another vintage gear review? It's been a while, and they're always instructive.

[@4thewinir344]

I’ll throw my vote for a Criton 1TDX comparison! Your videos probably sold hundreds of kits for CSS, me included-it would be awesome to hear your thoughts!

[@briancampbell7712]

After it's all said and done...It's all about sound...returned these back for refund and had to pay Buchardt $100...they had no detail or character...finally found my end game after testing many speakers on my new Marantz 40n...the Dali Rubicon 2 is end game for me...best non tube stand mount set up for sound...simplicity at its best!!

[@jonathanmarmol327]

I am thinking of the S400 and the Dali rubicon 2. Tell us more details about these speakers. Help me decide. Thanks.

[@briancampbell7712]

@@jonathanmarmol327 I purchased a Marantz model 40n and was searching for speakers that would pair well...I ordered KEF R3, Buchardt S400 MK ll, Wharfdale 4.1, Polk es20...I sent all of them back...out of those I liked the KEF R3 the best, however there was something I was missing...the Buchardt S400 MKll didn't have the detail I wanted...finally after all that and dealing with returns and getting refunded, I went to a local private Hifi store to audition many speakers...Wharfdale Linton-& Denton, Sonus Faber & Dali Oberon 3 the line under Dali Rubicon...The Rubicon 2 stand mount speakers sounds like a floor speakers...they are by far the best I've heard for a stand mount...the detail, midrange and bass are so good...the sound stage is unbelievable...they are 4 ohms but drive easily with my Marantz model 40n...what a match these are!! Great set up for best sound and simplicity...this will hold me over for a while...one day I hope to get a great integrated tube amplifier...I hope there will be a very good one coming out soon that has a great built in DAC w/ HDMI ARC...if someone knows of one, please advise...thank you!!...and NO IM NOT Affiliated with Dali at all!! Just an audio enthusiast like all of you!

[@briancampbell7712]

...Oh, forgot to mention the Rubicon 2 sound very good at low level listening...you don't have to crank it up to get decent sound like some other speakers...however I think I could get even better performance from the Rubicon 2 if the model 40n had a little more power output.

[@gokhanersan8561]

Yeah. From the sound tests I heard, it’s going to be Rubicon 2 or Sonetto II.

[@briancampbell7712]

@@gokhanersan8561 hope you got the rubicon 2...all this time later and i've purchased other gear...i can tell tou wven though epixon 2 is supposed to be dali best standmount...at 6000🤪that i also tried out and sold...the rubicon 2 sounds way better and open sound...even a guy at dali said those are the best without trying to put down the epicon since he works there...🤣...epicon are so so closed off...it's like putting them inside a plastic trash bag and listening🤣🤣😁🤣🤣

[@rlowes]

Great review Randy. Love the change up in format, and the B-roll looked very nice indeed. Would be curious to compare with the 1TD-X as well if that’s possible. Thanks.

[@jefferycostner2636]

Add the Please compact with the 1TDX! I am ready for my best music set up ever and am torn over a few bookshelf speakers and amps.

[@cheapaudioman]

been getting this a couple of times. very similar to the 1tdx with upgraded crossover. I don't have them here to A/B directly but they have a similar vibe to me.

[@aleksandertrap-jensen8486]

I own the Wharfedale Linton's and love them to bits! The star of the show just like with the Buchardt's, is also the midrange, which together with excellent bass and a decent treble, produce a nice full-bodied sound with great dynamics and articulation. Sounds like they have a lot in common with the Buchardt's when it comes to their overall sound signature. How do you think the Buchardt's perform in direct comparison with the Linton's which I remember you also liked a lot? And do you think the Buchardt's are worth more than twice the cost of the Linton's? I assume the Buchardt's might beat them in midrange and treble clarity. But due to the share size of the Linton's, I assume the Linton's on the other hand, must have more body and stronger bass presence? What is your take on it Randy?

[@flashhog01]

Great review Randy!! You gave the CSS Audio Criton 1TD really high praise. I wonder how you feel it stacks up to the Buchardt S400ii??

[@JoeGsPizza]

Really enjoying these listening session reviews, Randy!

[@wollymolly]

Awesome review, but i think you should have tried these with some cheaper integrated amps as well. I'd love to know what are some of the cheaper amps that can drive these and still give decent performance at average volume?

[@ginom407]

I'd love to hear these speakers. They really look amazing, and I don't usually care how a speaker looks. These seem to cheak all the boxes! Great Review Randy 👍.

[@cheapaudioman]

thanks, G

[@jonuiuc]

Crazy I was just watching your Buchardt amplifier review. I think $3k-$4k speakers/components are a good ceiling for your channel, lots more to look at. You pretty much covered most of the lower cost stuff, and its not like you ignore it when it comes out. Can't make video reviews of nothing.

[@mrgringo7289]

For me personally 1k per component is really the limit but I watch up2 like 2 to 2.5k because mayybee il find a insane deal or second hand deal and il want to know the value. But over 2.5k is really pushing it.

[@orwhat24]

@@mrgringo7289 All kidding aside, I am exactly where you are there in terms of money. There can be some real gems and some real dogs in any price range I suppose. I always wished someone one would do a price/quality matrix, but hey…

[@jonuiuc]

@@mrgringo7289 I'm kinda in the same boat, I had the same speakers for 15 years when I pulled the trigger on the KLH model 5s when they first came out (I had some height/looks requirements in my house). They were $2k at the time and it was a little insane, but I was shopping Tekton mini lores at the time (needed it to be 34" or lower) which was less than half the price, but I just bit the bullet. I always wanted 3 ways anyway. I say $3k ish cause a lot of the non class D amps with power in the 100wpc range (I have large room) are around $2k, so might as well push it to see whats a little beyond the horizon and with inflation it will all get there someday lol.

[@noahdase]

Looking forward to the comparison video!

[@qbaqban]

Thanks a lot for the review. How do you compare it to the ELAC Uni-Fi 2.0 UB52? Can you please do a comparison?

[@odwatchguy]

Thanks Randy, it is nice to know that some of the more expensive equipment uses higher quality components in making their speakers. I think this is the perfect cheapaudioman review, knowing what is good at the higher end. I will be watching for the pair that someone's ex is selling cheap to get back at her husband. Score!

[@Linacan146]

Really appreciate your no nonsense review. Easy to understand and concise at the same time. I concur with you regarding the assessment of the speakers. Overall a bit expensive but very very enticing bass and midrange. The upper frequency could use a bit more air. I found the treble response to be a little dull but you can not expect to go too far with those cheap soft dome tweeters. I think Buchardt should reconsider using higher end tweeters in the next iteration. I don't think they could improve too much on the mid range or the bass department.

[@RoselynNY]

👌☺️

[@yaniv-nos-tubes]

i got the mk 2 se. make sure to pair with a warm lively amp.

[@aceofspades6667]

Nice to see Randy finally reviewing some Booky bookies !

[@scottiffanimccord1509]

Thx for your reviews. I feel you should tell us the ohm load and leave it at that. Because after impedance rise or "box rise" the power source will not see 4-ohms while playing music. If you or anyone thinks I'm wrong, go borrow or buy this tool and prove me right. SMD Audio Multi-Meter AMM-1 or go watch some of Williston Audio Labs video's where he shows ohm loads during music.

[@randybehenna3081]

Hello cheapaudioman thank you again for having the give away .Waiting for delivery and not sure I can continue acting like an adult...................You frikkin rock dude .can't wait to compare them to the 2 sets of 15s as fronts and a set of 10s rear running a vintage Kenwood integrated so will take your advice on cheap amp to upgrade my sound .THANKS AGAIN

[@RdandTrk1]

Awesome review. It was great getting your take on these.

[@cheapaudioman]

Glad you enjoyed

[@therealmitch-a-palooza7262]

Are these speakers a solid upgrade from the SVS Ultra bookshelves? I have the Ultras currently...and am looking to potentially move up from the $1k to $2k tier level for my fronts, provided they actually *sound* like they cost $1,000 more. Don't want to lose that exciting, big sound, or the awesome amount of detail the Ultras are somehow able to throw.

[@TimSmith-db1iu]

Dont do it. Keep what you have if you enjoy it.

[@rosswarren436]

Great review. Your "shootout" between these, the ELACs, and the Golden Ear will be interesting. I wonder how the Buchardt S400 II would compare to the almost identically priced KEF R3? I know, I know. You've not had the KEF...But I still wonder if one would be a clear winner there? Thanks. Kind of odd that KEF doesn't get very many reviews.

[@DougMen1]

Huh? The R3, as well as the LS50 Metas, the Q150, Q350 and Q series floorstanders, as well as even more costly KEFs, like the Reference 3, have all been reviewed by many well known reviewers on YT. Another great sounding speaker that costs as much as the KRF R3 here in the US is the Focal Aria 906, although it only costs around $1000 US in Europe. Focal, and some other European speakers are much more here than in other parts of the world, but some American speakers, like Polk, are much more in Europe than they are here.

[@rosswarren436]

@@DougMen1 yes, they have been "reviewed" since they've been on the market for a while now, but I meant in comparison to the NEW Buchardt S400 II. Which is "better" and why? They are roughly the same size and shape with the R3 being a 3-way and likely has lesser quality crossover parts, but still how does it compare?

[@cheapaudioman]

I'd love to review KEF but I've never talked to them. I don't think they're interested in me reviewing their speakers. Everyone that I've done I've bought.

[@rosswarren436]

@@cheapaudioman Thanks! Seeing how the Buchardt stack up against the Golden Ear and ELAC will shed more light on them, so it's all good.

[@psyphonyxaudio]

Fantastic speaker. Looking forward to the next special edition version =) Thanks Randy!

[@williamdirks5805]

Yes. One grill please. Not two round ones. Looks goofy. (listening Mads?)

[@freakin13guy]

Most hyped speaker of the year? Yeah, It’s well on its way.. thus far Randy and Taran (British Audiophile) have provided the most balanced and real world perspective on this speaker without unnecessarily overhyping it. Yes, the speaker does a lot of good things but it has some serious competition.. The comparisons Randy has lined up should expose that as the Goldenear BRX IMHO, easily gives the S400 MK2 a run for its money and for me is a more enjoyable speaker for less money. Your upcoming comparisons/ shoot out should be interesting, Randy. Thanks.

[@net_news]

do you have the GoldenEar BRXs? I'm super interested in them. Thanks!

[@edwincartagena1560]

Would love to see a video reviewing the CSS Audio Criton 2TD-X MTM.

[@MisterJDee]

So happy you dropped this video today. I been waiting for your thoughts. I’m trying to decide if I buy the > Buchardt a 400ii, > SVS Ultra Bookshelf, or > CSS Criton 1TD-X I’m looking for a big rich warm full sound. They will be accompanied by an SVS sb-1000. Which of these three would be your pick of the bunch? Many thanks!

[@cheapaudioman]

SVS Ultra are incredible but I wouldn't describe them as warm. you can't go wrong with the Critons or the S400ii's. if you have the skillset the Critons are a great project

[@kevinmertel6108]

Absolutely love the Trigger Alert.

[@MrBravo143]

Would like to see your review of Amphion Argon 1 or Argon 3s. Wonder how it compares to the Buchardt.

[@gavinwagner1766]

Nice review Randy. I know you said you had to get the Critons and Encores out of your house, but I wonder as your journey continues with all these speakers how they compare to those.

[@tomat4135]

Randy, I think you need to throw the 1TD-X into the comparison (ca 2000 usd built). To my understanding, they both offer staggering value as well as "high-end" finesse (whatever that means). I believe that both are outstandingly good, but I'd like to understand the different strengths they possess.

[@gg0297]

Great review! I'd compare these to the Ascend Acoustics Sierra 2ex. That would be interesting, but I know you don't have them. The Lintons, maybe? Lookin' forward to the comparison, no matter what the other models will be.

[@eattoast6378]

God these things are so pretty from every angle. For 2 grand id rather go with something like BMRs, but these are really just pleasant to look at.

[@cheapaudioman]

they are pretty. The golden ear brx's are also something else to look at

[@eattoast6378]

@@cheapaudioman The audacity of these bots.

[@MrEvhel83]

why is there no one that reviews Elac's 403?? i don't understand it. they are amazing!

[@matsudakodo]

They just don't have a tipped up treble - and that's a good thing! Also, good selection of tracks.

[@redstang5150]

Speakers like this always make me wonder about straight price comparisons. No doubt these are awesome bookshelf speakers. But strictly considering price - at $2k, would you prefer these over, say, the Emotiva T2+ towers for only $1100? Or maybe a pair of JBL 590's on sale for a mere $800? I just have a hard time thinking they are going to out perform full size speakers at half to the same price.

[@augustinvaclavik6282]

You cannot say that a tower is full size compared to a bookshelf, their sound singature, especially when sound stage is concerned. Yes, you don't need a sub as much with towers, but it still helps... even towers don't have actually good sub base, well idk about the astronomically expensive stuff

[@jmcott14]

Love this "real-time reaction" format. Would be cool to have a second view from behind you so we can see what you see as you listen. Just to break it up. I hope I grow up to be just like you, but slightly better musical taste, haha /s

[@cheapaudioman]

thanks. I have a lot more fun when I do them somewhat "real time". and never grow up!

[@jmcott14]

@@cheapaudioman as a doctor at a large hospital I have to at least pretend to be grown up. But then I come home and make my kids listen to all my cool music.

[@cyberathlete]

Thanks Randy for this video. How do these compare to the Concept 300?

[@vickivaughn1305]

I will be looking forward to the comparison. I've had my eye on the Golden Ears for a while.

[@henrychan6982]

Thanks Randy, I listen to the MK II as well and thought the same. The tweeters wasn't for me.

[@hansschmitt9725]

You do fantastic informative videos really appreciate your hard work 🤘🏻

[@ttownscott]

Look really futuristic with the grills on

[@Trollberg]

how does it compare to JBL HDI 1600 ? they are on sale for 800/pair

[@JukeboxAlley]

This calls for a shootout between these against DIY critons and maxxed on upgrades xls encores.

[@williammorales8204]

I had a chance to listen to these and I think 15 other ones all under 3k, same similar rooms same amp setup. It was really neat, that said I had high expectations. I was let down, as much as the rings of power. Ones I did hear that I liked better, keep i mind I'm just a joker who likes music. I prefer the bmr, the atc 11, triangle, and even the totem sky over these. I know it's personal taste so don't take my word at value which I'd say is about 1800 worth.

[@Stan_the_Belgian]

Appreciate the trigger alert, was just going to ask how I'm supposed to pay for those speakers as all my money is going straight to nasdaq, buying the DIP

[@knobbshots]

Good stuff man. Golden Ear BRX one of my dream speaks, curious to hear how you think they compare. Im gonna guess ahead of time and say they are just “different “, one not necessarily better than the other. Could be wrong though, thx again

[@cheapaudioman]

You’re probably right. I will say which ones I prefer. I’ll also try to let people know which ones I feel are better in different categories

[@erics.4113]

My guess is randy would take the buchs over most others. He has stated multiple times he isn't much of a subwoofer guy so any bookshelf with solid bass performance may get his attention more.

[@cheapaudioman]

@@erics.4113 I have subs but when I review speakers I review them without. Well see though. I’m excited for the comparison

[@erics.4113]

@@cheapaudioman thanks for clarifying. For some reason I was under the impression that you didn't like to run subs with your bookies. For sake of reviewing a pair I absolutely see why you would do so without a sub!

[@cheapaudioman]

@@erics.4113 I think the best set someone can get is a pair of bookshelves with a sub. Better than towers in my opinion

[@franktrgovich7911]

Great review! Looking forward to the comparison with Elac and Golden Ear.

[@dilbyjones]

Great call ,u know your speakers.

[@ThePalle44]

I ordered them today 👍 Own Bushardt s300mk ll for some years.

[@HarmonyHomeInspectionServices]

How are they working out for you Patrik?

[@mikecampbell5856]

I'm glad you're reviewing more expensive gear. There is a finite number of low cost components, and you would run out of gear to review, and no one wants that.

[@Firbolgwarrior]

Do you rekon these would work well with the Yamaha rn 1000a? I’m new to all this an it’s a serious rabbit hole to go down about the gear .

[@mnfv77]

Hi. Your thoughts are spot on with my experience. Do you think you could live with this speakers? I’m thinking on the lack of air on the treble.

[@MrHolmgren194]

Treble should never be heard, if it`s "just there", me thinks that is a good thing :)

[@sidesup8286]

In reply to your audio post comment that treble shouldn't be heard, it's just there. "It HAS to be heard for it to be there"....Socrates- sometime before Jesus I think? You're not related to HP from TAS are you? He always used "me thinks" too. I do think I know what you mean though. If its stands out too much it sounds too hi fi. Then again I just heard a marching band go by, and when they crashed the symbols together, having the kind of balance you're talking about, you wouldn't hear even 1/3 as much of a crash as what everyone lined up on the sidewalk heard.

[@MrBenherrmann]

Please allow me to offer an opposing viewpoint here. Some of the many allures that this channel has (had?) are: 1. The subject matter at hand - that is, focusing on inexpensive, yet high-performing audio gear (a buyer category to which most of us tend to belong. 2. Randy's wonderful (hilarious), off-the-cuff humor that belies the fact that he's an exceptionally intelligent person who was seemingly born to do these kinds of videos. Having said that (and I hope I'm wrong here), what I see happening here - through a gradual transition perhaps - is a shift to more expensive gear reviews. This occurs with many audio review channels and after a period of time, they tend to review the expensive stuff more often than not. Personally (my opinion only), I'd prefer to see Randy continue to focus on the "Cheap Audioman" format and target the myriad of inexpensive audio components (of which there are many out there) that offer exceptionally high value, coupled with excellent audio capabilities. Additionally, Randy's foray into modifying (improving) inexpensive gear through the changing out of components such as op-amps, cross-over networks, and more, provides invaluable suggestions to improve specific audio gear even more. Just my two cents worth here...

[@unknownspectre]

I agree, but also think around $2k is a nice ceiling... Eventually he WILL run out of quality affordable gear, and be left with affordable shitty gear

[@stevezeidman7224]

There are just so many $100 Chifi amps to review. If he devotes a couple of episodes to more expensive components, I really don’t care. He’s got to be able to compare these more expensive components to cheaper ones anyway. It’s the only way for him to be able to make recommendations.

[@ramondelgado6778]

100 percent agree with you both!!!! this $2k ish ceiling is great and we need to know about this level of gear to really understand and appreciate the value stuff. For example, I've heard these speakers. they are wonderful and built super well. budget option, the Polk R200 and the Wharfedale Denton 85 th edition.

[@orwhat24]

As a datapoint these reviews are helpful. I like the way Randy compares gear, which is one reason I joined his Patreon. (He has earned some support, imho) If you think about what’s available at this range - and I think we could aspire to - There are a ton of interesting g options. Maggie’s. R700 Polk - new, these Bucharest, Monitor, etc. It’s helpful to hear one guy cover the range. And I may be wrong but it seems like his success is motivating other folks to review less expensive gear more often.

[@robertorodriguez2609]

I agree he will run out of cheap amplifiers but there are still a lot of under 1k spkrs. anyway it's good to know about somewhat higher priced items in case one comes across a great deal.

[@bencarignan2711]

Another solid review amigo. On a side note, can you recommend a few affordable CD players that have the digital out? I'm finding that most lack that feature these days. Maybe a 15min video on a list of the makes/models of those cd players, as well as various affordable dacs to pair them with? Keep grinding brother!

[@cheapaudioman]

sure. usually I'd just recommend a bleary player with a Digital out. There's not a ton out there that are reasonably priced anymore. There's not a ton of bleary players out anymore either.

[@robertorodriguez2609]

@@cheapaudioman maybe adding a good cd-drive to a laptop? 🤔

[@TrainSuplexer]

Currently saving up for my "endgame" heirloom speakers. It's a toss up between these sexy Danes and the KLH Model 5s. Hoping Randy can get his hands on those in the future too.

[@kirkaparty4143]

The s400 are very good all purpose speakers, and easy to set up, it fits and works well in most rooms. They sound great even when moving around. My friends KLH works better in a dedicated room or space in a center listing position. Just my experience

[@TrainSuplexer]

@@kirkaparty4143 Thank you for the tip! The s400 certainly get extra brownie points for sounding good all over the room as opposed to just having a very specific sweet spot when sitting down. Must be that crazy good waveguide and the passive radiatior doing magic.

[@stevenzurn8070]

I like it when you comment write after playing the music. Looking forward to the Elac Uni-Fi Reference comparison since I have those and I'm curious to know how they stack up. I might consider upgrading to the S400's.

[@net_news]

Randy, these or the 1TD-X? Thanks!

[@aurelianmarin6494]

Hi Randy, how would they perform at low volumes? I own the first gen of S400 and I miss the sparkle at late night listening sessions. Wondering if MKII is better in this regard. Thanks

[@ChaiBearProductions]

S400MKII is much better for low volume listening than MKI. You can listen quietly and still hear the detail and dynamics. This is one of the areas Mads Buchardt said they focused on because it was an issue a lot of people brought up.

[@stefanfrankel8157]

My Marantz amp supposedly won't drive pairs of 4Ω and 8Ω speakers at the same time, but it has no trouble with my 8Ω Klipsches and 4Ω Buchardts.

[@stevenpatterson794]

*!* "Formerly known as the Cheap Audio Channel"

[@cheapaudioman]

#5

[@jaredpmoser]

Randy would love to see a review on the active.

[@bingdong8571]

How much do these cost at retailer in denmark?

[@mrenlightened]

How does this compare to the 1TDX?

[@cheapaudioman]

Very similar sound signature

[@davidread4342]

Hi Randy. I am enjoying your reviews. If you could only listen to one speaker between the Buchardt or the Wharfdale Lintons which would you choose and why? Thanks.David

[@alvina9338]

Heard you saying that you cant wait to compare this Buchardt S400 Mk2 to the Elac Unifi Reference. Yes, please...... Though they are not on a similar price range, but I really would want your opinion on it. Hope to see that video soon Randy ( @cheapaudioman ). Best of days ahead for you..

[@yeahright3733]

So the cheap now stands for high value audio reviews?

[@cheapaudioman]

judges... yes. acceptable.... he used cheap... #6!

[@yeahright3733]

@@cheapaudioman thanks for your review of these speakers! Your perspective is appreciated!

[@dal2258]

These or Dynaudio Evoke's?

[@DougMen1]

Hey Randy, I know everyone is going to review the new Klipsch RP600M II (Andrew and Erin have already), but some of us liked the original RP500M more than the 600M, because the 500 was better balanced, and didn't have the midrange dip and elevated tweeter that the 600 had. So, I was wondering if you had any intention of getting the new RP500M II for review, as well as the cheaper version, the new R50M, to see how it compares to both the RP500M II and the R51M, the model that it replaces. Thanks

[@youtubiers]

Have they got grills?

[@marcuswilson999]

Quality video editing 👌

[@BADEAU011]

Hi,i am a big fan of your vidéos and your good taste, for now I own the Elac Unifi 2.0 , I have the opportunity to buy the Buchardt S400mk2 , its-it a good upgrade ? my amp ia Rega Mira and I have a sub JL 8" , Thank's

[@StefanUrkel]

new to this channel.. did you already compare with KLH Model 5 and KEF LS50?

[@emokidsparade8126]

can the aiyima A07 power the s400 mk II?

[@Humppa800]

I have those speakers 3 months now, i think they sound every day event better, what speaker cables you use on them Randy?, i use cheap Mogami w3103 and Denon Pma-110 amp. 🥰

[@camiloramirezphoto]

Hey Randy. I just finish my Ultimate crossover mod on the CS5. And the base improves a lot!!!, I made it with the option of leave more tweeter with the lowest resistor. I compare them with a second pair of the sony's that I have and are a very different speakers. I hear them for a couple of hours with a speaker switch that I have and at the begining I feel the originals have more detaile than the modified, but after a couple of songs I realized that the modified pair are a lot way better in terms of balance. I was used to the original ones, but the modified ones invites you to keep listening more and more. As this ones I feel them more "creamy as you say", this Buchardt description is close to what I hear on my modified sony's, right?