We Explored the Legend of CAVEBOY. We Should Have Followed the Rules.

[@sandart8508]

I spent the entire time expecting someone to have a gold/silver filling.

[@bgamer4203]

Haha me to

[@erikmckoul2478]

Electronics have gold in them too.

[@karenroot450]

I also thought that!

[@wadd8813]

Here's a reminder of the rhyme No names, no laughter No silver or gold No coming back after No tales untold

[@youtubeconnollyfamily]

I started following your channel. I believe it was 2015. Why you’re my favorite is because you always come out with a new video. There’s other channels out there that come out with a video like once a week and then two months later they come out with a new video. No consistency. With you, we can always rely on a video. That’s hard work right there.

[@MrCreeps]

Thanks for noticing the consistency. I try to make sure there's always something spooky to listen to!

[@youtubeconnollyfamily]

@@MrCreeps I give you a lot of respect for that because you’re the only person out there who uploads consistently year by year. It’s not easy so much respect👍

[@SierraSix5840]

You're the best man. A lot of people do jobs and it doesn't make a difference to many people. What you do daily makes the difference in many, many peoples life's. While I work or relax at home I listen to your videos. It's a way to get lost from the day to day struggle. And brings me happiness. Thank you man I really truly hope you continue to do this for a long time coming. I'm truly grateful for you. ​@@MrCreeps

[@smithproductions1120]

This is my favorite channel. Thank you for the hours of stories.

[@MrCreeps]

This story really gives some old school creepypasta vibes. Hope you all enjoy!

[@connorreece4990]

I miss the old school

[@meatworkshop4740]

i love you (no homo)

[@Summer-tc8bf]

Feeling sentimental. Mr. Creeps, your narrations and stories have been a saving grace in my life. Its easy to get lost in them like your really in the stories. Helped get me sober. THANK YOU!!!

[@MrCreeps]

Thanks so much for listening and enjoying them!

[@j.tormey4392]

WOW, congratulations on getting sober. Do (& listen to) whatever you need to, to stay strong. I'm just some stranger out in the world, but I want you to know that I'm proud of you & rooting for you 🫶

[@Ooh_PieceOfCandy]

KZbin narrators have KEPT me sober. On January 31st I'll hit 8 whole years. Grats on your sobriety ❤❤

[@karenroot450]

Mr Creeps this one was such a wild horrific roller coaster! I loved it! It always gets me when you say such tender endearing things like, she brushed her hair away from her face! Or after I touched her shoulder, she covered my hand with hers! Just notice is all. Thank you very much.

[@Azraelleah]

🚫🚫 SPOILER BLOCKER! 🚫🚫

[@dragoscisteian8002]

Tnx

[@ki.7050]

every time i see one of these i KNOW it's bout to be a good story😂

[@Landaftertime]

hell yeah ❤

[@MegaBubbles25]

It's a trap!

[@chelewhof]

Doing the Lords work 💯

[@ItzYeboiGamez]

Spoiler!!!! So for those who are kinda confused about the whole thing, 3 and 5 (OP and MATT) were the only two to escape, number 2 left them there for the sake of his dad, which could be CM, as it is stated he knocked up some of the girls…which could be that CM is #2s father.. which makes more sense as to why the detail of him knocking up those women come into play. All of the deaths are in sequential order with the rhyme. Now for the others. Jeremy died due to him breaking the rules, obviously coming back, saying the names, and maybe laughter (maniacal?). His death was from his obsession and desire for being a “legend”. Jeremy died due to being the first one to break the rules. He is the outlier. Now for the true sequence, cave boy targeted #7 first because she said the names out loud, breaking the first rule, and also laughing. Those two got broken by her (assuming cave boy deemed it laughing). Afterwards we come forth with the next kill, #6 which goes with the rhyme “no gold, no silver”. What should mention is she was one with the pictures (if not mistaken) which gives her phone the “silver” and the golden earrings which makes her break that rhyme. Brianna, or #4 dies because she breaks the last and final rule, no tales left untold. When going down there, no secrets should be hidden, and which she was cheating on the OC. Caveboy may have known due to the talking by Jeremy and #2 when they previously came down. Which could help understand why caveboy knew. He can talk and understand so maybe that happened. As for the two survivors? Why didn’t they get caught, he could’ve attacked them. Mind you out of all of them they both never once broke the rules. #3 almost did a few times but caught him in the act, which is probably why he attacked #3 but didn’t actually go for him, maybe as a warning to be careful or if he messed up then he’s next. As for 5, he didn’t really do anything bad. Didn’t break the rules at all, although one may argue right at the beginning when he gets backpack duty….but the rules only apply once you truly read the rules, in that cave. As for those who don’t know, it would be dishonorable to harm them for breaking a rule they didn’t know they have. (Obviously they talked about the rhyme before going down but it was a legend rhyme, things could’ve been twisted up which I think caveboy gave to anyone coming down.) If everyone (minus Jeremy obviously and #2) had followed the rules at the beginning, they wouldn’t have been killed, like #6 taking off the earrings way before, or #7 shutting up about saying names, and even #4 being dishonest. None deserved death but it shows that this creature doesn’t hunt randomly but instead in the order to which breaks the rules and what rule is broken on the list, being closer to #1 being the top priority. (Maybe?) just a theory. TL:DR; the creature killed all of those who broke the rules in a specific order going with the rhyme and who broke it first. The two survivors got away because the creature willed it as they both didn’t break any rules. (Although #3 came close)

[@ItzYeboiGamez]

Apologies for the mistakes in writing, it is 1:00 AM

[@destynidavis2920]

I hate to be devils advocate, but when #3 said “we don’t belong down here in the dark” and cave boy responded with “neither do I” it made me feel bad for him like what’s his story?

[@kamrynwinstead3507]

That's what i was wondering, like is there more to the story of caveboy. How did he come to be?

[@jackleith3502]

When he handed him the mushrooms, I thought he was trying to make him eat them so he would become the next caveboy.

[@ezekieltaylor5333]

12:22 you know the rules, and so do I... top rick roll of all time

[@T.Rizzle]

Love the narration! Been a long time fan! If i were in this story i would probably end up getting myself stuck in the cave hole like winnie the pooh and everyone has to go home, a true hero haha

[@SpaceSpuddd]

Awh yes!! Gimmie 5 and I’m sticking this on for bed. I Love your content, genuinely can’t sleep without it!

[@Z-A-C]

I would like a creepy pasta about being an overnight grocery stocker, since I am one myself

[@MrCreeps]

I’ve done a few recently! Search ‘Mr. creeps grocery’ and they should pop up.

[@Z-A-C]

Ok, thank you so much

[@jackdurden466]

Oh there are some really good ones about just that! Great ones actually, definitely find them and you’ll be glad you did.

[@DamonNomad82]

I guess I'm lucky that way. I've been an overnight security guard for the past several years, so there are plenty of creepypasta stories about people in my profession. What's REALLY trippy is listening to one while I'm on duty at night, though the small college in a small town where I work isn't the creepiest place, with the possible exception of the oldest building on campus, which is rumored to be haunted and is infested by bats...

[@RonaldLivingston-n2d]

Same here !

[@LeeroyPorkins]

Tune in next week for "I Downloaded An Adblocker. It Refuses To Block The Single Older Women Nearby."

[@MrCreeps]

This one could be spooky

[@Anonymous-rj2lk]

YOU!

[@chainbenwa2713]

LOL

[@danthesausage1235]

​@@MrCreepsholy guacamole Mr creeps replys to leeroy, make a Creepypasta of leeroy 🙏

[@Peanut_butter_man0326]

PLEASE TELL ME WHO IS THIS GUY

[@TheWorldWideHemmy]

I love when I make theories about the stories and they turn out true lol

[@zenonking2840]

I hit a cell head point once they revealed the mushrooms were making them hallucinate

[@patburrell1027]

Man it started to get really scary.

[@kentworch]

Thank you Mr Creeps for another awesome pasta. Excellent story and narration as always, and definitely loved this one. Thank you for making my night.🖤🖤🖤🖤

[@sherribuschman2079]

This was so scary, I would have had a heart attack and probably been eaten. This was so intense. Thank you, Mr. Creeps I just started listening to you a few weeks ago and you are so good at what you do and can't wait to hear more

[@MrCreeps]

Thanks for listening and I'm glad you enjoyed it!

[@Russhelle70]

Thanks!

[@MrCreeps]

Thanks so much!

[@fskwasted6764]

I just finished the debt video was running out of videos to listen to came out at a good time

[@heavenlycrow3961]

Had a bunch of lame ass AI channels being recommended, happy too to see this!

[@fskwasted6764]

@ seriously like I’ve been tempted to go to other channels but Mr creeps just tickles that part of my brain

[@MrCreeps]

Haha good timing!

[@obsidiansythe8432]

Been a long time fan, always appreciate the good stories and the fact you use your voice and not AI. Thank you so much!

[@M1n0rXxXthr3aT]

Perfect timing Creeps. Getting ready for bed and I needed a good Creepypasta

[@MrCreeps]

Hope you enjoy the story!

[@M1n0rXxXthr3aT]

​@@MrCreepsLoved it!

[@MartinWilhelmjr]

Thanks Mr creeps. Much love and I hope all is well bro.

[@MrCreeps]

Same to you!

[@docter.pepper]

i love the underground/water stories, they really make the story 10x creepier !!

[@mommakat900]

❤❤❤❤❤❤ All our needs are fulfilled right here on this channel. Blessed with such incredible content!

[@tech_mazter2768]

Put this on for bed like i do everynight mr creeps and sleeps but this story was so good is 12am now and im still awake amiring how good this story is

[@horizon592]

Thanks again Mr Creeps, you narrations are just about all I look forward to these days. 🙂🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@MrCreeps]

My pleasure!

[@Scary_gainz]

"I now know cryptids are real. I got carjacked by a wendigo."

[@Spyderoicu812]

Wow! Excellent story my friend, and as always, great narration!❤

[@deadpool2334]

Matt's the real dawg 🔥🔥🔥

[@blokefieri]

I fell asleep about half way through this one but I was so invested that I had to start again from the beginning when I woke up!

[@corwynnagee6771]

Lets go perfect time for another video from Mr. Creeps

[@NightmaresEcho1]

He is good yeah but i will do better

[@pheenixalexander]

Amazing story choice again! This one deserves a re-listen!❤

[@haloawsome1017]

Thank you, Mr. Creeps, for always having a video for me to listen to so I can regularly experience that spooky factor.

[@aprilwilliams1918]

Perfect timing ❤

[@TheVirtualBlobfish]

They might have been in danger anyway because it is likely that their phones have a bit of gold in them

[@blackonyx66]

That was a crazy good story!!!!

[@dreggy-x1k]

Thank you!

[@JUSTICEshsyedZaC]

absolutely epic 🎉💀☠️👹💤

[@brianhouse6675]

Great story

[@ElderGodAzathoth]

I'm glad you went quieter with the names at the end

[@rogerwilliams977]

Another banger😮❤

[@Cat-Benatar]

This was really good!! 5⭐

[@MrCreeps]

Hooray!

[@twistedwitchery7091]

I love your channel, and this was one of the best stories,I'm absofeckingloutly never going caving, and the closest I'll be getting to any holes leading to the sea is the murder hole in Donegal☘️🖤

[@MrCreeps]

Glad you liked it! Thanks for listening

[@benjaminmercy1071]

This story was amazing !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@MrCreeps]

Glad you liked it

[@austinburke1317]

I love the stories with rules

[@kimparris4965]

This one was really good

[@kieranwoods7131]

SPOILER WARNING out of the two possibilities,, who thinks cave boy was real and all that happened was true, and who believes they started hallucinating due to the fungus? the carvings could have been created by CM when he went down, hallucinated, got freaked out and thus the legend was born; and when the group went down, started hallucinating with the legend and stories playing on their minds which could explain the moments where number 3 caught glimpse of cave boy, up until the point the hallucinations became more and more severe with the group members dying naturally. however I believe cave boy is real simply due to the rescue teams not finding any evidence anywhere and the true sense of fear and belief from the characters.

[@designationc6042]

Spoiler Well I did feel bad for Brianna but NOOOOPE as soon as I hear cheating I immediately lost all my empathy for her.

[@MrDuneedon]

Nintendo Caveboy.

[@pmsavv1659]

Tune in next week for “ I flushed myself down the toilet. Here’s what I saw”

[@BryceLK]

I can't believe OP and Matt are the only ones who survive. 🙄

[@AR-bl6ng]

Has there always been background music? That was nice

[@joeangel8960]

Hey Mr creeps ! Will you ever start posting short stories like 15-30 min ones? I like those to fall asleep too , not a big deal i just love the new stories ❤️‍🔥

[@MrCreeps]

I try to post shorter stories on my third channel Mr. Creeps Crypt. With the algorithm doing what it does I kind of have to post longer stories on this channel.

[@joeangel8960]

@ WHAAAA i didn’t know about that Channel; gonna check it out tonight thank you creeps

[@Ooh_PieceOfCandy]

It's been a while since I've heard from this author ❤❤

[@heavenlycrow3961]

Oh I’m so excited for a posting! Was stuck with AI shitty channels being recommended! Happy to have good fucking narration to eat!

[@MrCreeps]

Hope you enjoy this one!

[@heavenlycrow3961]

@ Was amazing!!

[@creepypastaarchiver3088]

Sound like a ritual first 2mins like df lol the wording

[@OgreKillr]

Nah bro 2 gotta answer for that. No part 2? 😢

[@ismaelvaldiviezo3619]

I noticed there is are some stories that are connected with each other in some ways, for example "Im a monster created by the government " that goes into the horrors of the back rooms. Would you be able to link all the stories that cross over into each other as one story combined? Ive been trying to set up your stories in my own personal play lists that have the same time characters and time frame that play back to back but I am unsure if i got the correct order or not. Another 2 stories that cross over into each other that I've noticed is "I worked on a super soldier project for the government" and "A guide from a monster hunter" . Or maybe even continue on, on where they left off?

[@h1ckjam3s]

MR CREEPS FTW!!!

[@AngloLee]

39:42 Hue hue hue

[@captainnepnep1139]

Song at 51:30 ?

[@gloomheartvondravmor8525]

Poor cave boy......

[@heavenlycrow3961]

My name is Brianne 💀 First time I hear my name (Brianna is a letter off and also a name I answer to) in one of these and Spoil The character dies. 😂

[@mandiblecalavera]

Boy that story pissed me off, MC dragged his feet quite literally.

[@king81992]

Thumbnail Image- A park ranger discovers the legendary Caveboy's identity in the woods: Mr. Bones in a really bad mood. I like how MC and his friends set out to follow the rules instead of deliberately breaking them like characters in other stories. Is this story connected to the one about the group who discovered a random elevator in the middle of the woods? That story also involved strange mushrooms. The skeleton and true nature of the mushrooms raise more questions.

[@jacobhawkinsmusic]

I think you may be right. Same author of both. Or he just has a thing for shrooms

[@debrapoirier4435]

🖤🖤🖤

[@mygod598]

Am i the only one who hears rhe vrchat game called huanted aslyum bgm

[@imtired3715]

27:00

[@Mathieu140297]

Day one of asking for more sea creatures horror stories

[@MrCreeps]

Working on something right now!

[@soggyslopster6800]

What rule did one break?

[@komododragon410]

He came back

[@martingibson1000]

great story but the rules didnt't seem to matter much aside from the gold.

[@jghostinuzuka2695]

I hope #2 got what his kummupets

[@bonniesbeautifulchaos1763]

I’m not crazy. Did anyone else notice the leg with a boot and a hand, left of the bridge?😱🤷‍♀️

[@DinkCatcher]

Hell ye

[@b0gusbum124]

he was a women hater 😞

[@ApocalypticTruthTeller]

You’re literally a clown. The first person the monster attacked was a male. If the scummy women followed the rules they would’ve been safe. Weird how that works……

[@MADBD619]

If only they had followed the rules……………

[@likeyoucare381]

"caveboy' sounds like a really crappy sidekick name😅

[@hurricaneheather1420]

😊😊😊😊😊❤❤❤❤

[@ettapage-]

👌🏻💜

[@Obliterat3]

So, the rules where for nothing? cave boy would have kill them regardles?

[@ProfOak-ci2cc]

He only killed people that broke the rules. Brianna cheated on MC, thats supposed to be "tales untold" rule broken, although who knows how it knew that lol

[@AzeUwish-cupidsconfidant]

8.5

[@EDDJOECORR]

😮😯

[@rhio-ohki6107]

PLEASE, can you up the volume when you upload vid, as I have to turn up volume to max just to still just hear you. Then having to quickly turn down volume when nxt story on list comes up, esp when I'm just about to sleep or doing stuff 🫤 Anyone else have this prob 🤔 🤷‍♀️😂👻👻

[@jghostinuzuka2695]

D*mmit which caleb got what was coming to him

[@alanfisk9166]

Comment

[@MrCreeps]

Thank you for the comment!

[@fskwasted6764]

First comment?

[@justinsparda-wn5tq]

First view baby

[@blacktornado5212]

We Explored The Legend Of CAVEBOY. We Should Have Followed The Rules* Stop using broken casing.

[@JRooso]

Some people tells a story an it paints a picture in your head, but when this dood speaks it's just so dull it sounds like a man who's out of energy, maybe it's his voice idk I really don't know, sorry if I sound like a hater it's just my opinion on things

[@ChristopheRobyn]

Did anyone else find it extremely annoying that he kept calling her his girlfriend?? I mean did she not have a name?? Was she a blowup doll??😂😂 This story was terrible 😂

[@mason7067]

Codename Kids Nextdoor mission C.A.V.E.B.O.Y. Capture Any Verifiable Evidence Boy Offers You

[@MrCreeps]

Loved this show

[@mason7067]

@MrCreeps As soon as the characters started referring to each other by numbers it jumped to my mind.

[@cohnermullinswrestling902]

I hope this man knows how many people he helps every day. Mad respect for your niche role in society. You’re a blessing Mr. Creeps 🫡