Mutual Relationship With Cows | Can We Get Milk Without Hurting Cows? | Q & A | Veganism

Is there such a thing called as Ahimsa milk? :
Just replace the word cow in a sentence with female human and see if it makes any sense. If a woman was made pregnant naturally, child get's it first milk and then we consume. If it doesn't make sense, then the question to ask is "Why do we look and treat animals differently when they are no different than us in the all ways that matter". A female mammal produces milk only for her child and not for anyone else. We would not drink milk from another human, why from another species? It is not needed.
The Vegan argument is not about how we USE animals but that USING in itself is incorrect.
Calling her a mother makes no sense when we support industries that treat her and her kind worse than garbage. There is no right way to do the wrong thing. Ask yourself this, would you tie up your own human mother and treat her the way you would ideally want to treat a cow? If you say no, then do not call cow as your mother. If you say yes, then you don't deserve to call cow as your mother. Let us please do the right thing and just leave the animals alone.
Here are also some points to consider :
1. How does the cow get pregnant?
2. What happens to the male child?
3. What happens to the cow once she can no longer produce milk?
4. If someone asked the same question you did but instead of cow they said "human". Would you call it as farming or slavery? Why do you consider enslaving cows any different from humans when animals are the same in the all ways that matter?
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
Supporting my work :
UPDATE : You can now support my work via Google Pay as well : arvindanimalactivist@oksbi
Patreon Link : / arvindanimalactivist
For the Vegans out there who want to and are in a position to financially support my work, please read the following. If you like the work we do and feel you can support us when it to comes to the maintenance, repair of our equipment and also our overhead charges please consider supporting our Patreon. There are tiers that range from $1 a month to $15 a month. You can choose any tier you want to, but please note that I will not be making any exclusive content for Patreon as me and my partner are too occupied making content for our current social media handles. Thanks in advance.
Also if you are non vegan please do not become a donor. Don't give money for a cause that tries to abolish animal exploitation while exploiting animals yourself in order to cancel out your guilt. Please do not support me financially if you are not a Vegan yourself.
Thanks!
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
You can also choose to follow me on :
Facebook : / arvindanimal. .
Instagram : / arvindanima. .

[@arvindanimalactivist8192]

For the Vegans out there who want to and are in a position to financially support my work, please read the following. If you like the work we do and feel you can support us when it to comes to the maintenance, repair of our equipment and also our overhead charges please consider supporting our Patreon. There are tiers that range from $1 a month to $15 a month. You can choose any tier you want to, but please note that I will not be making any exclusive content for Patreon as me and my partner are too occupied making content for our current social media handles. Thanks in advance. Also if you are non vegan please do not become a donor. Don't give money for a cause that tries to abolish animal exploitation while exploiting animals yourself in order to cancel out your guilt. Please do not support me financially if you are not a Vegan yourself. Thanks! Patreon Link : www.patreon.com/ArvindAnimalActivist You can now support my work via Google Pay as well : arvindanimalactivist@oksbi

[@ReverendDr.Thomas]

There are two reasons why vegans comprise a fraction of one percent of the population: The main reason is due to humans’ failure to care about what they put into their own bodies - as long as it tastes good, who gives a damn about the consequences to one’s own health or the ethical concerns regarding other creatures or the environment? The other reason is due to vegan advocates and animal rights activists being inept in their understanding of morality as well as their abysmal grasp of human physiology. Almost every single vegan activist I know of wrongly believes that we are omnivores, and they are clueless in respect to metaethics and applied ethics. But that is not the most unfortunate thing about the matter. The saddest thing is that there is hardly a single vegan activist even willing to spend an hour or so to learn proper diet and meta-ethics with the World Teacher Himself, Jagadguru Svāmī Vegānanda, despite him freely offering to do so on his social media platforms. 😩

[@LouisGedo]

*Create a Better 🌎 and a Better You by............Living Vegan* 💜

[@ReverendDr.Thomas]

@@LouisGedo 👶

[@ReverendDr.Thomas]

@@wh_6087 no.

[@Devenderkumar-pv6ti]

Tomorrow u will say we should not force horses to carry our luggage 😂bcz it's not moral

[@akkibhal2007]

I was vegetarian as I always thought Indian dairy is kind to cows and is different from the western dairy where they breed cows purely for exploitation.. After research and getting aware of the fact that India is 2nd largest exporter of beef and researching Indian government SOP on dairy, I came to know that we as an Indian are no different than the west.. Dairy sees cows as an milking machine and that's the truth.. Vegeterianism was considered best in ancient times probably because that time people didn't see it as a business and were ethical to cows but in today's modern world, empathy doesn't exist sadly😢😢.. PS: Now I am trying hard to be vegan since 1 month and so far I have been successful..

[@user-fy8hm2px4t]

same

[@isabellezablocki7447]

Huge congrats!

[@HumanBeing-jj3mc]

Bro what did you do ro replace milk? I also tried to be vegan for a month, but then I developed nails deformity and hair fall. I don't know the reason, then I started using milk again and I became fine again. So I want to use supplements and all and need knowledge to be vegan. Help me out.

[@lauroaranha]

@HumanBeing-jj3mc try eating carrots, sweet potatoes, kale and other leafy greens to get vitamin A. Brazil nuts and other types of nuts to get zinc and healthy oils. Don't go for more than 2 brazil nuts a day, as they're really full of selenium.

[@akkibhal2007]

@@HumanBeing-jj3mc Sure bro.. first thing is get yourself tested where are you deficient at.. from the symptoms it looks like you might be deficient in vit B7, B12, calcium and vit D but I suggest get tested dont just assume.. I dont take any supplements.. but I use Oatley oat milk for tea or for milk replacement.. that has a vit b12 added in it check the nutrition side of oatley oat milk to know more I eat silk's vegan yogurt it is easily available in US here but I m not sure about India.. just search in supermarket it should be there..! That yogurt has curd like bacteria culture for gut health these bacteria are important For vit D simply standing in early morning sun for 20 mins is enough if no sun, then go for any vegan supplements For calcium I eat spinach, dill, chana, chole, flaxseed almost everyday Proteins I eat pumpkin seeds, mushroom, tofu instead of paneer At least 8 soaked almonds (soak it overnight) and 8 walnuts will help you to stop hairfall Nutrition yeast I eat it because it has good nutrition see if you get it in India.. plan your diet properly you won't need supplements I am not a doctor just telling you what I do as I have just turned vegan.. I suggest still get an advice from your doctor before

[@isabellezablocki7447]

This guy is doing it. Changing India's mentality about dairy.

[@VeganSemihCyprus33]

Veganism is the moral obligation! Keep up the great work Arvind!

[@ReverendDr.Thomas]

Good Girl! 👌 There are two reasons why vegans comprise a fraction of one percent of the population: The main reason is due to humans’ failure to care about what they put into their own bodies - as long as it tastes good, who gives a damn about the consequences to one’s own health or the ethical concerns regarding other creatures or the environment? The other reason is due to vegan advocates and animal rights activists being inept in their understanding of morality as well as their abysmal grasp of human physiology. Almost every single vegan activist I know of wrongly believes that we are omnivores, and they are clueless in respect to metaethics and applied ethics. But that is not the most unfortunate thing about the matter. The saddest thing is that there is hardly a single vegan activist even willing to spend an hour or so to learn proper diet and meta-ethics with the World Teacher Himself, Jagadguru Svāmī Vegānanda, despite him freely offering to do so on his social media platforms. 😩

[@dontdiefornyash2609]

Veganism is extremism the life of a cow is not worth the same as a human

[@shrin210]

​@@ReverendDr.Thomas World teacher himself 😂😂

[@ReverendDr.Thomas]

@@shrin210, Good Girl! 👌 Incidentally, Slave, are you VEGAN? 🌱

[@rewananadar1547]

Well said🌱

[@TheHurikane2010]

Amazing Arvind, I turned vegan from vegetarian because of you and also became animal rights activist in UK because of you and Gary!!! Long live vegan revolution

[@Glikokuyo]

I don't know when Indians will understand these problems and start solving them by any kind of solution,, but people like you are really important these days. Keep going 👍🏼

[@jonjonwp]

Arvind knows his stuff. Brilliant work.

[@madhavjha1]

I have changed completely from non vegetarian to vegan, after seeing your videos. Thanks a lot.

[@animalsareherewithusnotforus]

amazing work. 🌱💚veganism, and nothing less, for the animals are not ours to use.💚🌱

[@DreamingConcepts]

Open discussions and clarity for a better world.

[@payojaaa]

i love how arvind always answers questions so intellectually!! GO VEGAN!

[@prabha927]

It's an eye opener, most of us are not aware of anything like that.

[@shoban1520]

You aced the answer, Arvind. Keep shining!

[@RojiVerdeVgn]

Arvind. I love your videos. Your explanations are accurate and pursuasive. Thank you for your work. You are making more people vegan every day. Our movement is stronger than ever. Always 🌱💚

[@clarence3494]

It's truly heartbreaking to share that male calves often face a distressing fate, as they are either sent to slaughterhouses, sometimes even through temples, or left without food for the first 10 days before being killed. This is an unfortunate reality. It's a situation where mothers are treated as mere machines, continuously giving birth to babies and milk. This cruelty may make one wonder if, in some ways, slaughter might be a more merciful fate. Let's work together to bring more awareness and change to this heartbreaking issue.

[@natureskylover]

Superb wonderful explanation Arvind Sir

[@Yeagerdesu]

Keep doing the good work brother!! I was vegan on the day i saw your first video ! ☘️

[@mayank9885]

Arvind I agree. I just ordered 1 litre Soya milk which cost me 130 rupee which is 2.6 times costlier than Verka milk. I will try it. I just hope if ur right and if animals have to go through so much of cruelty to produce milk then we should be drinking vegan milk and it should be cheap. Very cheap.

[@rakeshmehra6321]

Hey, make sure soya milk doesn't have any other ingredients that are not good for health. Commercial soy milk is not good. Please read the lables Or you can easily make soy milk at home and make sure Soy is dairy free.

[@cyrusp100]

You don't need to drink any milk at all. Milk is for babies...

[@mayank9885]

@@cyrusp100 but I like milk.

[@cyrusp100]

@@mayank9885 And some people like to eat beef. Are you happy if they eat beef?

[@mayank9885]

@@cyrusp100 they will face Karma I believe if Karma exists. Personally I can understand why it's difficult for Non vegetarian to stop eating non veg because they have been eating it from 10-20-25 years. Old habits. I have been drinking milk eating paneer Desi ghee from last 26 years not suddenly I cannot stop it. I can decrease consumption. In India you have panner + Desi ghee sweets + milk sweets so already so so many products. Anyway on the reason I still consume milk is because I still have doubts about how milk kills cows + buffaloes.

[@bookbiteshorts]

Excellent. You are very well spoken and drive your point convincingly. I am mostly a vegetarian but definitely thinking about going vegan.

[@sonalisreenivasan2606]

You are doing excellent work Arvind.. more power to you . Pls keep up the good work.

[@ashachhapolia3913]

This is the perfect answer .👍❤️

[@bauabh]

Great work Arvind

[@ninjanerdstudent6937]

This is the next big vegan KZbin channel. I was subscribed when you had about 50,000 subscribers. Congrats on 6 figures! Keep fighting the good fight!

[@bishantkumar4464]

Thanks bro for this explaination, I'm from a village in bihar and i always had this question.

[@user-zu1pm2hz7f]

Bro nevere losse youself you inspired many people

[@jjradV]

Arwind, simply the best ! Such an asset to the vegan community, thank you for everything you are doing for the Animals ! There is no justification for not being vegan unless you like to abuse and murder kind,innocent, defenceless sentient beings. If you are an ethical vegan you have a responsibility to speak up for the rights of Animals, tell everyone you know everything you know about the Animal Holocaust, remaining silent does nothing to help the Animals.

[@bohditony]

A dose of truth hard to swallow.

[@headyBC]

Hero! Thanks for addressing this! Haribol!

[@abirdsmw]

"Milk doesn't come from Cows, Milk comes from Mothers." Thats all I needed to hear ❤

[@sudiptakar9157]

God has sent you Arvind ❤❤❤Thank you always for spreading these❤❤❤

[@-ux7vg]

Great work brother

[@optimumwellnessofficial]

Legendary! 💥💥

[@benjamindsouza6736]

Great arguments as always! Indeed we do not live in the yuga that Lord Krishna lived in, when conditions for cows were very different.

[@howdadogdoin729]

Well said Arvind!!

[@basavarajkamatar6268]

Arvind you are the true Hero..🔥🔥

[@ppowell1212]

Thank you for the content

[@mcc5295]

amazing video bro

[@jaybolt100]

I’m a an organic farmer… I need cow dung as manure, cow urine for jeevamrutha, agniastra earth worm for vermicompost… what’s your solution for organic manure… should we start using chemical fertilizers, pesticides?.😂

[@soumyadeepdash4805]

If you need dung, just keep them as pet and they'll give you that lifelong. You dont have to force them to shit.....just feed them

[@cyrusp100]

I am an organic farmer and gardener too. I never use cow dung. Compost and worm castings are far far better for the soil than manure. For jeevamrutha look up compost tea - again far better for soil and plants.

[@hhhbbb6239]

1) sarso ki khali 2)alphalfa 3)neem Khali 4)seaweed fertilizer 5)plant made compost ( vegetables peels ) 6)home made fertilizer ( kele ke chhilke + barish ki pani + cocumber ke chhilke + chai pati )

[@Msjasmine187]

Please don't support animal cruelty for our benefits

[@SSStofu008]

You can use compost instead it’s a lot safer for human health too

[@SimbasPawsomeFamily]

I'm from Trichy, at first I was happy ok we are buying milk from local people. But the way people rear cows calfs the same way he says in the video. They only look at them as money, but to us they put up a very genuine remarkable show that how much they care for their cows. ! N the calves are mostly put up away in a separate enclosure away from their mom's, 2nd thankfully evening some owners allow them to graze n u should see the scenes where the little ones & their mom running towards each other .. it is ❤ &💔 together. 3rd I have seen men catching old cows with ropes , to take them to slaughterhouse!!! It's heartbreaking to see the cows running or resisting them cos they know they are harming them. It's all bs when it comes to animal agriculture. Wish people have more heart, than act smart with traditional accepted conventions to be more socially acceptable

[@sarthakmukhopadhyay3226]

Lord Krishna lived in dwapara yuga ❤

[@rushabhshah4334]

Dude u are doing a great job, hope everyone understands and get vegan so cruelty to animals can be stopped.... Salute to u for speaking out so much for the poor suffering animals.

[@DivsDiv]

Jus started seeing ur videos during my pregnancy time & I was a vegetarian & nw trying to b a vegan & I don't have any fear f losing nutrients or abt health issues to me & to my expecting baby.Though i m at right age f becoming pregnant i face lot f prblms so i dont want to trouble these animal mothers who face so much f pregnancy prblms....Long Live Veganism 🔥🔥

[@eyesofequality4273]

I am a Hare Krishna devotee who has recently made the choice to be vegan. My question is how easy (or difficult) is it to be vegan in India? My impression is that just about everything uses ghee. I am asking because I intend to return to India, this winter as I try to go once a year, but this will be the first time I am going as a vegan. Is it possible to find vegan options in places like Vrindavan where consuming dairy is considered to be almost sacred? Thank you.

[@shubhanshi8693]

What is the position of cows in vrindavan ? I mean are they exploited there too?

[@-harry-5737]

​@@shubhanshi8693few days back I was in vrindavan and ate all my meals at Iskcon, they use milk and milk products from their Gau Shala👍..... idk about rest of vrindavan(and yes they are not artificially inseminated there and milk is available for the cow's child first)

[@slutforgojosatoru2697]

​@@shubhanshi8693iskon is like one of the biggest organization to provide cows to beef industry lol there is no ethical consumption of dairy no matter the place however religious

[@eyesofequality4273]

@@shubhanshi8693 Strict vegans would say that if the milk is being taken from the cow it is being stolen, so in that sense yes they are being exploited. However, it seems at least the milk that is used in Iskcon comes from the ahimsa practice. I am a bit on the fence at this point about whether or not I believe that it is possible to have a true ahimsa dairy. I think for now, it is best to maybe just not take dairy at all

[@eyesofequality4273]

@aishwaryakathuripally2579 thank you very helpful 🙏🏼

[@Bhakta.Andrew.Devananda]

In the Gośālas, where indigenous cows are all cared for, regardless of sex or age, and allowed to live full natural lives & naturally reproduce, and calves given priority to the milk, as per the Śāstric injunctions, would you agree that this is an ethical way to obtain milk products? The reality is that due to kali-yuga, the consumption of milk will not decline, not for another 3000-5000 years, during the middle of the Golden Age of Kali, so it is important to try to establish concessions and advocate for this ethical, Śāstrically sanctioned Gośāla derived milk products to those devotees who consume them as religious sacrament --Establish a middle ground in this way, where cows are well taken care of given all respect and needs. I've been vegan since 2011, but I have found as I have become more immersed in Vedic Culture that advocating for this middle ground is highly important. I have managed to find at least 3 companies that advertise ahimsāk produced ghee, although I've only sampled 2: GirOrganic and Shree Radhey. Both are high quality although the GirOrganic seems to be of even higher quality. Although I've sometimes utilized this ghee, I don't feel any less vegan than before I tried it last year, either physically, mentally, or spiritually. But currently I cannot afford to order more of this ahimsāk ghee, which is an obligatory criteria standard for me, I just resumed utilizing only sesame oil for cooking masāla dishes without issue. I don't really care for other milk products that contain lactose, casein and other milk proteins. I only took ghee as sacrament to offer to the deities and take as Prasādam. Lord Śrī Kṛṣṇa appeared in Dvāpara-yuga, by the way. It was Śrī Rāma who appeared in Tretā-yuga. Thank you for your service to humanity, to cows, and all other living entities. May all of humanity be purified of adharmic activities. Jaya Śrī Rādhe 🙏🏼🌸🌺🏵📿🪔(((🐚)))🐂🐂🐂🦚

[@akkibhal2007]

Just curious as reading through all this it seems impossible to imaging you will be having enough milk to sell to people?? Also What happens when cows stop producing milk? It is financially burdensome to keep the non milk producing cows right?

[@kaushiksunapu5657]

Yes, good point made about the middle ground!

[@Bhakta.Andrew.Devananda]

@@akkibhal2007 check out GirOrganic Farms' channel, they have a very nice system going year round.

[@Bhakta.Andrew.Devananda]

@kaushiksunapu5657 Right, because in this way, we can actually persuade industrial milk drinkers to opt for ahimsāk milk products & refine their lives, rather than reject the idea of abstaining from non-ahimsā milk products because they're being pressured to give up milk altogether..

[@dd21]

why can't you post full session here on youtube?

[@riyakasturi8855]

Arvind ji ive completely now understood your point but now you need to help me solve just one problem ive bought more than 30 kgs of ghee for my use etc and today ive decided and turned vegan what should i do with that ghee ive started feeling pukish by thought of violence and dairy products but if i give it to someone or use it its still painful to me by the way this ghee is coming from sri sri ravi shankar so i dont know how they do the process their as they are very kind i feel they keep cows nicely and most probably dont send anyone out but how you explaining it im confused on that too but major reason is i now feel its not my right to take something from cow herself or even touch her reproductive parts ......what can i do with all this ghee ive already searched vegan ghee but what ive bought what can i do....help n answer

[@9unapologeticsanatani]

the lord krishna part .. i liked it .. i will try now onwards .. not sure how...but definitely try.

[@TheLinuxExpert]

Boss, your ideas apply only to the commercial dairy farms or commercial minded farmers. In the villages we don't tie the cow to inseminate her. They follow natural cycle. Bulls and cows live together happily until they age and die naturally. Not a theory - I have many cows grazing in natural surroundings, living naturally. We have them in the farm for using the cow dung and urine as fertilizers in the farm.

[@saralvashishta]

​@vanshkoshti3126 agar thodi si ayurveda padha hota to smjh ata ki dudh mei kitni visheshtaye hoti hai. What we need is not to stop drinking milk, but to stop abuse, murder of cows and bulls.

[@saralvashishta]

@@vanshkoshti3126 haa to tum apne aur apne bacho ko Karo kuposhit. Bullshit moral policing mat kro

[@user-hz4qc4sx2s]

​@@saralvashishtamoral achi hai ....bas tume bullshit lag rha hai....insan apne comfort ke liye kuch bhi kar sakta hai

[@theoneaboveaall]

What you do after they stop giving milk? Dont you just abandon them to die and get beaten by farmers and vendors ?

[@theoneaboveaall]

@@saralvashishta you are really selfish here, milk has nothing extraordinary ... all the proteins and calcium it has can be found in other plant based foods

[@chesswithsagar]

Hey Arvind, I am influenced by your videos. I have some questions related to milk. Is there any email or telegram I’d where I can put my questions? Leaving milk is troublesome for me, I tried it twice. I need to ask some nutrition related questions.

[@ponnamy]

Please read the book "Becoming Vegan: The Complete Reference to Plant-Based Nutrition (Comprehensive Edition)" by Brenda Davis, RD and Vesanto Melina, MS RD for proper vegan nutrition guidance before becoming a vegan. Happy vegan journey!

[@lauratanln]

You can also ask your questions on Google like "why is milk unnecessary for health" , "oxidised cholesterol in milk", "side effects of milk", for example. But your results will definitely be outnumbered by articles from the multi billion dollar milk industries extolling the benefits of milk they're selling. So look out.

[@riti267]

that "little bit' had me all outraged !!!!!

[@rainsray]

Im vegan. At least mostly. I am a pet parent to an indie . I do feed him nonveg food becaause i believe that thats what he is supposed to eat. Am i justified in doing so? I dont think of chicken as sentinent beings and feeling pain and going through a horrible death when it is to feed my dog

[@ramapriya12]

Humble correction Lord Krishna's time period is Dwapara yuga not Thretha yuga.

[@akkibhal2007]

Correct 😀😀 but please forgive him and focus on the overall meaning or purpose

[@goodfoodeverywhere]

Cow willingly gives milk that is it's blood to humans and not it's kid

[@blazingsanjay]

bro when did you come to trichy

[@manaspradhan4168]

God Jagannath🙏 bless you Arvind brother 💕💕🌹

[@amigos87]

Bhai, Chai peena kysa hai?? Mana hai vegan mein?

[@aditya_asundi]

Nice message, but the audio is a little feeble. please take care.

[@deisepolo]

Vegan is the only way . Compassion for the animals.

[@utkarshsingh6876]

What about street dogs, how do they get pregnant?

[@Sar_vesh]

Why did you delete previous video of jihadi where he exposed himself? 🤣😂

[@seshadrisarkar3785]

Long live Arvind

[@sweetsriju06]

Lord Krishna was born in dwapar yuga not in treta yuga.

[@mohanvenkata4321]

Hi, bro, in my village we leave the bulls to roam around the village, each village will have atleast 4 or 5 bulls which will roam free no one will hurt them, every one will feed them when ever that bull visits the home ,bulls fight among themself sometimes , they will mate with the cows whey they are in open fields, this happens atleast 50% of the houses who own cows, they are treated with so much care still tied up most of the times , the people who raise those cows don't raise them mostly for milk and they won't sell those milk to others as well even if they milk them, is this considerred ahimsa milk ? , this is one side of coin and the other side due to demand for milk some people are bringing in jersey cows and doing all the inseminations etc.. same goes for buffaloes, so what is the solution to this ? going vegan can reduce the milk demand and eventually people will sell these cows or buffaloes to again to slaughter houses and no one will care to protect them and people became greedy they won't protect or care about something if it doesn't matter to them, one solution I think is we should promote vegan along with some natural farming techniques like ones which subhash palaker are following where cows are raised only for their dung to fertilize the land and his techniques are great which are followed in ancient times in india which are ahimsa and it helps in dealing with some more problems like pesticides and plastic pollutions caused by detergents, soups, and clothes, and also helps in diverting farmers focus to grow various fruits , and crops other than just rice, it would impact planet in a better way if followed on large scale

[@aryangupta9913]

happy bakrid madarsachaap abdul

[@mohanvenkata4321]

@@aryangupta9913 hi, dude what do you mean ?

[@akkibhal2007]

@@mohanvenkata4321 1) no cow should be made forcefully pregnant either artificially or by mounting bull against her will. They must mate among themselves natuarally. 2) after calf birth he or she shouldn't be separated. Only the surplus milk can be taken so that cows dont get mastitis 3) this milk will be so little, no farmer can make a business out of it... It could feed only to one family 4) male calf must not be sold to slaughterhouse or anywhere where he could end up getting hurt or starved or killed in accident etc once he is grown up, 4) Bulls can be used in farms but some vegans might debate it as this is kind of exploitation but I feel it is just a hardwork that human farmer is also doing the same along with that bull but they need to be cared and treated when sick .. 5) once cow stops producing milk, she shouldn't be killed and must be treated with reapect, treated when ill.. This will be ideal definition of Ahimsa milk.. but if you think logically, it is highly impossible for any small scale farmer to implement this because it will burden him financially without any return and it will be super expensive to keep this running forever without constant funds.. and think about the population of the cattle growing exponentially and associated expenses today

[@Trueneutron]

how did your mind came up to that ? you seems frustrated@@aryangupta9913

[@akkibhal2007]

@@mohanvenkata4321 ahimsa milk can only exist when you have a very wealthy background and constant supply of funds and also 99% people living in cities, they consume dairy milk not from the scenario you mentioned.. in fact it is impossible to do so because of expenses.. so vegans are against the dairy industry and milk and other dairy products..

[@ateen1]

❤❤❤

[@darwinsiu3913]

thank you for caring for God creation i hope that more people go vegan💚

[@nikhilpratap2826]

आपकी जितनी तारीफ की जाए उतनी कम है

[@beyondtheendfilms5602]

Arvind sir, I have a request for you. And I request others to like the comment if you agree so arvind sie notice it. Nowadays people use AI to translate english to hindi in youtube videos. If you can also do that with your videos it will reach out to more audience. My mother also give me same argument and I can show this video to her but she don't understand english that much and I believe their is large audience who you can reach out my using AI based language translation that many foreign youtubers are doing.

[@cp_sparrow]

Small farma sell nahi karte hee dudh 40 saal pehle Ho aapne gar ke liyee hii palte the cow Aabhi urbanization ho rahaa he tabhi ye sab problem aa rahi hee

[@varshavora7390]

🙏🙏🙏

[@faijulaman7937]

❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

[@user-kt2yh4pn2c]

please make videos in Hindi. It will help many Hindi speaking people understand these.

[@veerambhattdande8324]

We must support using bulls for oil refinery old method Milk must come from village not dairy farm and bulls must be used for different needs in village

[@HumanBeing-jj3mc]

What should I do to replace milk? I tried to be vegan for a month, but then I developed nail deformities and hair fall. I don't know the reason, then I started using milk again and I became fine again. So I want to use supplements and all and need knowledge to be vegan. Help me out.

[@siddhanthravichandran3245]

Depends on what u want to replace It for? If u want the protein and calcium....i would suggest tofu.....it's very cheap also

[@ponnamy]

You sound like TROLL!

[@BharatSharma-of9du]

Look for a nutritionist and take help from him

[@ramapriya12]

Hi Arvind, I highly respect your concern for cows not to hurt them through killing , artificial insemination etc etc. Question is assuming a village family follows all the ahimsa ways to get milk as per the dharmic guidance do you have any concern in drinking the milk - milk obtained through mutual relationship with utmost love and care which we are suppossed to do as per guidance from our ancestors?

[@akkibhal2007]

1) no cow should be made forcefully pregnant either artificially or by mounting bull against her will. They must mate among themselves natuarally. 2) after calf birth he or she shouldn't be separated. Only the surplus milk can be taken so that cows dont get mastitis 3) this milk will be so little, no farmer can make a business out of it... It could feed only to one family 4) male calf must not be sold to slaughterhouse or anywhere where he could end up getting hurt or starved or killed in accident etc once he is grown up, 4) Bulls can be used in farms but some vegans might debate it as this is kind of exploitation but I feel it is just a hardwork that human farmer is also doing the same along with that bull but they need to be cared and treated when sick .. 5) once cow stops producing milk, she shouldn't be killed and must be treated with reapect, treated when ill.. This will be ideal definition of Ahimsa milk.. but if you think logically, it is highly impossible for any small scale farmer to implement this because it will burden him financially without any return and it will be super expensive to keep this running forever without constant funds.. and think about the population of the cattle growing exponentially and associated expenses today

[@akkibhal2007]

This ahimsa milk can only exist when you have a very wealthy background and constant supply of funds and also 99% people living in cities, they consume dairy milk not from the scenario you mentioned.. in fact it is impossible to do so because of expenses.. so vegans are against the dairy industry and milk and other dairy products..

[@ponnamy]

@@akkibhal2007 Well said! It's impossible.

[@ramapriya12]

​@waytoadventure1390 can you please explain why family cannot have enough milk , typically dharmic people will consume left over - howmuch over is left

[@ramapriya12]

​@@akkibhal2007why are you not including the benefits of cow dung and urine and more importantly divine presence of the cow? Please conside thise points and respond back. Arvind is mentioning Krishna was in Tretha yuga but actually belongs to dwapara yuga and he left just before Kaliyuga began. Please also note just few hundred years ago there was no artificial insemmination and most of our ancestors were taking care cows as part of their family and living. Why Arvind is mot pointing about that. Please ponder.

[@pb1248]

in olden days cows were a part of our house.....bulls were either given off or let out to starve to death on roads...that's why we can see in many villages many bulls on road.......if u see the present situation in dairy industry i guess pure vegetarians can start by eating beef😢

[@chaitanyareyansh6538]

Great to see people like you who are standing up for animals I am also an VEGAN.....👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 I am a lady so I know what we go through during pregnancy it’s tough in a way it better than animals coz we get help but ANIMALS Suffer... the guy who is asking this question.....please do a small experiment why don’t you tie a 10 kg weight on your stomach & keep it for 9 months then you will know...this is just one part of it I am sure not even for 1 hr you will be comfortable. Imagine your married & your wife is pregnant through out her life may be then you will understand....

[@Im_Sindhu_Not_Hindu]

This is Bitter truth and we Hindus shamelessly busy in making money ignoring Ancient Indian Culture.

[@challalakshmi6059]

I saw your video accidentally. Wondered what is the concept of vegan And saw some of your videos. I really realised what i were doing by drinking milk daily. Thank you. I decided to become a vegan step by step.

[@prasant825]

Yes dairy milk involves a lot of suffering to cows but there are goshalas who take care of old cows and male calfs. Secondly you can't make a cow pregnant on your wish, cow has to come to heat then only her body can receive semen. If cow is in heat and you are mating with a bull then I don't think it's wrong since cow naturally demands for mating when in heat.

[@subhajitdalai8991]

Is it your justification of drinking milk ?

[@siddhanthravichandran3245]

That's not how the reproductive system works..... artificial insemination dosent need the cow to be in heat. Also there are 300million cows in India according to statistics...and this is when we kill them at age 7 and kill all the males. If we took care of all them until age 25 and kept all the males....we would end up with Billions ! How are we to take care of them all? Imagine how much resources a single cow needs and multiply that by billions..... It's not sustainable

[@lauratanln]

If you wait for them to mate naturally, you will not get as much as you would like. Old cows cannot produce. Only very kind people will take care of them. Exploiters of cows and their products want to get the maximum out of them. So please take plant based foods to avoid causing them health problems from constant pregnancies and distress from having their babies taken away for sale so the milk can be taken as well.

[@prasant825]

@@subhajitdalai8991 where I said I'm drinking milk or not?

[@saiedm.a.6065]

Life as we know it cannot sustain without vitamin B12. Simple organisms like bacteria can synthesize this crucial vitamin, yet humans with all their advanced biology, cannot. We get it either through meat or dairy. How do you propose vegetarians get their B12 if you avoid dairy? If you answer "supplementation", aren't you going against very grain of what nature (or God) has intented for us? No vegan society anywhere in the world has existed and most individuals who do become vegan have had some kind of health complications later and had to revert. This is especially true in colder climates where the dietary requirements are different.

[@divyanshkashyap3938]

If God has not intended supplementation then he also hasn't intended the cruel exploitation of animals.

[@saiedm.a.6065]

Hahaha. You didn't reply to the main points and just talking about the periphery ​@@divyanshkashyap3938

[@Memerztamil]

Nice explanation but for our people even if you give lecture on Smoking, they are not going to give up. Expecting this society to go Vegan is not at all easy. I hope only handful of people are going to transform. Anyways Best of luck.

[@gallionlion6388]

The male calf is castrated to become ox

[@dipitbhatt7224]

What if I start my own dairy farm with no forced impregnation, no killing the male ones, and always prioritizing the cow's child's needs before mine. Also the cow's child would get stomach problem if he drinks all the 8-12 litres of cow from her mother, so after the cow's child is filled, I find it completely correct for us to use the milk. Will this still be considered cruelty?

[@saralvashishta]

No that isn't cruel. Infact this is what families used to do. Every bharatiya family used to have a female cow who was considered to Be a part of the family. Male bulls weren't sold off but were considered nandi bhagwan and equally valuable.

[@vijaymmahadevan8075]

Veganism is just a moral cover for future food market... If a veganist can tolerate animal cruelty happening in vaccine labs to ensure his survival then he can also tolerate other people having the food they want

[@vijaypithe9492]

What an answer! What an answer! Perfect answer. We have to go vegan. There is no other way to avoid cruelty. JUST GO VEGAN.

[@srisathvikvarma9new358]

Lord Krishna lived in the Dwapar Yuga please get your facts right Mr.Arvind

[@vijaymmahadevan8075]

Even this fellow lecturing here surely got his shots corona vaccine which is also a animal tested. He wants to live so he can be ok with all those he blabers

[@monversity]

That's just a very sad reality

[@monversity]

I'll become vegan in the future

[@pratyushavakkalagadda7172]

I really appreciate your work. but I didn't like the approach and the attitude with which you are showing towards plants in some of the videos. I don't think one need documented evidence to say that someone is alive. the same happens with plants too. in fact, with many other organisms. each and every organism is equally important be it ant or a plant. they feel pain and fear. plants do release certain hormones into the ground when they are in fear, and they communicate with other plants just like us and tell other plants what's happening to them. there are lots of videos online and the same happens with bacteria also. you check out videos on quorum sensing. it shows how cells communicate and live. our life is no different from them. they kill to live. it has its own role on the earth. if you are differentiating and saying that killing plants is okay because they don't feel pain because they don't have neurons then it is totally a wrong argument because then it means that you haven't understood the evolution in the right. and you know what? you see yourself different from animals, plants, microbes but at the end of the day you are no different from them. you have just more cells than a microbe and all the cells have collective consciousness, and they are automated, and the body is being protected. and yes, the unnecessary pain and suffering should be condemned and to prove your point you don't need to downgrade other organisms. can you feed a lion grass, that's not possible right. even if it eats it can't digest it. and there are many reasons why people shifted their diet to meat. it is because of the climate and drought etc. Kashmiris eat meat even brahmins eat meat because their terrain can't support agriculture. but what is important is the intention behind killing. if someone is killing it for food then it is their food. but it is definitely wrong to kill animal just for the sake of killing and enjoying killing. that needs to be stopped. you can't just consider people living in cities or towns and address the whole mass. people have their own conditions.

[@veganashish7927]

Go vegan

[@dipitbhatt7224]

If you are against animal cruelty, then you must not have any pets or encourage someone else to have them.

[@user-lp6by8pg8p]

Vegan is the only way

[@jaybolt100]

Vegan here since 15 years… but it’s peoples choice to eat whatever they want… there are 75 million Indian farmers dependent on dairy, meat industry because not every piece of land in India is irrigated land…but livestock farmers in arid areas can procure fodder in the form of hay, silage from irrigated lands to feed the livestock… I agree with empathy to animals… but what if unemployment rises and in turn crime rate increases because of unemployment…people who live in arid areas, depend on livestock for livelihood… so unless u have a practical plan for those farmers stop preaching this non-sense… also growing vegetables and fruits is a labour intensive occupation… these days it’s nearly impossible to find labours to plant seeds, maintain weeds, control pests, harvest the yield… even though the farmer manages to harvest, the market price doesn’t even cover the money he spent on labour and other maintenance… where as single farmers family can maintain around 30 cows, 100 sheeps, 500 chicken.. livestock assures a promised income for farmers… also the farmer’s vegetables & fruits can be destroyed by wild animals like wild boars, elephants… the machinery used for agriculture is very expensive… whereas livestock doesn’t need much of the machinery… if a farmer has to start growing fruits he has to wait 4-5 years for the harvest… livestock has constant prices… for example in Karnataka a farmer gets ₹35 for a litre of milk, ₹400 for country chicken, ₹10 for country eggs, ₹600 for mutton… where as vegetables like tomato, onions prices will ₹60 one day, ₹5 the next day… so if u try to mess with the farmers dynamics, all the unemployed rural population will flood to cities and imagine the cities generating slums… what’s the other alternative for farmers? To work in industries that create even more pollution … meat and beef get exported… what vegetables get exported from India and how much does the farmer earn from that? The government and farmers have worked hard for decades to bring white revolution in India… don’t try to disrupt the rural economy just because u have fantasies of being mother Teresa of animal kingdom… here’s a link of how most of the dairy farmer work kzbin.info/www/bejne/moawY4qdipKod6csi=pYsBsPFDlCLbYpM5

[@khushiayaan4990]

After knowing this I want to become vegan from vegetarian 🙏

[@user-zx1to1id7y]

Great answer. A small correction, Lord Krishna was in the fringe of Dwapara Yuga, not Treta Yuga

[@studyingapple5994]

Veganism is not a moral obligation, but reducing the pain of a living being like humans , cows , goat , plants , forests , etc is necessary for us humans , as we have divine scriptures that are sent by God to earth through different means , that guides us to such moral duties.

[@abhishekkar6837]

That's the reason ancient india never had industrial revolution though we had immense knowledge about different aspects.. Our culture thought to respect animals like cow, develop mutual love toward animal and human beings, and get nourished by cows milk without misusing the cows...

[@saralvashishta]

Industrial revolution is a hoax. There was no profit motive in Bharat despite being an urban society.

[@prajjawal4148]

6:24 brother i agree with you 100% but I want just a little correction that lord krishn lived in Dwapar yug...Shree Ram was in Treta Yug... Otherwise all the points made by u r correct...

[@ruthraenjoy8362]

I feel the question is not answered..dont know..i might be wrong..but i think the answer was slightly off the track..thanks

[@ananthucprabhu5933]

so instead of stopping small scale dairy farms why dont you stop slaughtering