2:17 - 2:25 "An amalgamation of the CGI, RWS and TV series depictions." Isn't CGI technically a part of the TV series? It's one of my Top 10 fandom peeves; treating the model and CGI eras as if they're two entirely different shows. Nobody separates the Wilbert and Christopher eras of the Railway Series, so there's no reason to do the same thing with the TV series. And before anyone mentions "Hiro being one of the first engines according to Hero of the Rails", bear in mind that at no point in the show prior to said special was it ever confirmed who the first engine on Sodor was. (Plus, HOTR was initially planned to be filmed with models with CGI elements per Series 12, so that would've happened regardless if the show had switched over to full CGI or not.) And as for The Adventure Begins? Retelling; simple. I can't understand that mindset of divorcing the CGI era from the TV series as a whole, and chances are I never will.
@Mr.Conductor134 ай бұрын
When I say TV series, I’m referring to the classic TV series with models. As for the CGI series, I consider that its own thing, since there are more than enough differences between the model and CGI continuity for me to consider them their own things similar, but separate from one another
@FictionalADDON3 ай бұрын
In my personal AU, he is rebuilt into a hybrid of a Fowler Baby Scots and a Stanier Jubilee. For visual purposes, he has a Jubilee’s Tender, firebox and frames, and has a Patriot’s boiler, chassis, valve gear, and cab.
@JubbinsJibbins4 ай бұрын
Amazing video as always mate!
@NathanChurchward4 ай бұрын
Awesome take on Henry! I always liked the idea of Henry being an Jubilee and that would explain why Henry has splashers in S2 onwards, tho I still prefer as an Black 5
@steamzilla954 ай бұрын
1. I think Sir Topham Hatt is like us when it comes to movie sequels. Good Sequel: I wanted an Shrek 2 and son of a jackass, I got an Shrek 2. Bad Sequel: I wanted a Mulan 2 and that son of a jackass send me that! 2. What exactly do you mean by ghostly encounter when Henry was at Crewe? 3. Henry 1 and Henry 2 are the same engine in my eyes. Richard Jordon’s A Part of Me Stayed Behind proves me enough. As for the theory itself, The events of The World’s Strongest Engine happens but it’s reveal as how Diesel was sent away from his first trial because he tells lies about two different Henry’s resulting Diesel to sent away by barge.
@Mr.Conductor134 ай бұрын
I agree that Henry is the same man. I just wanted to acknowledge the fact that that theory exists.
@SparklingJam2 ай бұрын
My ideal Henry is a c1 Atlantic however he was built with a 4-6-0 which messed up his firebox size
@TheRuinedBreakfastOfficial4 ай бұрын
Henry is a C1 in my au, but wore the mumber 1300, a real engine which looked nothing like the rest, it had a smaller firebox and when kipper happened he was rebuilt to a standard C1.
@auraknight10044 ай бұрын
Here’s two characters you should do, Edward and Gordon.