My Unpopular Martin Brodeur Opinion

Never have I stated that my opinion is gospel. I simply have a different opinion at times and am willing to explain why.
Support The Hockey Guy via Patreon / thehockeyguy
Follow me on Twitter
/ shansboomstick
Like and follow my page on Facebook
/ youtubehockeyguy
Contact me via snail mail at:
The Hockey Guy
PO Box 38
15038 Seven Oaks PO
Abbotsford, BC
V2S 8P1

[@andylee2174]

Nobody seems to remember Miikka Kiprusoff behind a horrible Calgary defense.

[@alwong604]

Luongo is the number 1 goaltender who played in games where they faced 40+ shots in a game.

[@matthewbarnaby9819]

Can't wait to see Sean Avery's opinion on this video.

[@blap5630]

I love luongo. Hes had such a legendary career, yet so unappreciated. I just hope he stays until the panthers cup run. Or at least gets traded to a cup winning team.

[@shadytnu24]

Honest question that no one seems to want to answer: why does Osgood get penalized by that perception when a guy like Ken Dryden seemingly gets a pass on the same thing?

[@sydisticsandman]

Would love a 2022 version for updated Stats since we've seen some great goalies leave and enter since this.

[@tomfagan674]

Two respectful counterpoints:

[@mattsayle]

Cujo is the man. Loved him in STL.

[@stefangamble2637]

How come Henrik Lundqvist never comes up as one of the best goaltenders of all time. Plays on a team with crap defense and is 8th all time in wins (and counting)

[@sabertheglaceon256]

all time leader is Terry Sawchuk with Wins-447 loss-330 Tides-172 2.51 GGA 103-SO

[@slauzon01]

How about we talk about Marty's best statistical years after the retirement of Stevens, the leave of Nierdermayer and Brian Rafalski.

[@aaronparsons5609]

Ya know, I’m the biggest Brodeur fan alive. He’s my childhood idol and I love him, but you’re right. Very rational evaluation and I admit he head great defence. Devils played trap and it benefited him hard. I still think he’s the best but I accept and respect your evaluation. To me he’s number one and Hasek number two.

[@JMac77441]

Great video! I love that stat.

[@paulg2103]

I’ve never felt that Martin Brodeur was the GOAT. A Hall of Famer? Yes, of course. But not the best.

[@Dormitator1]

"If he'd been drafted by the Winnipeg Jets, before they moved to Phoenix, I don't think we're having this conversation." Do you mean like Nikolai Khabibulin?

[@dr.aisaitl7439]

Glad to see Cujo being mentioned, one of my favourite players. Always put me at unease because of his wandering antics but great player

[@evanbrown2594]

I remember being a little boy and my dad out of the blue asking me if I wanted to go to the Halifax Moosheads game. A bit out of the blue..I remember him adding that Val D or had this fantastic goaltender who was just amazing to watch...Went to the game...saw him stop what felt like 50 shots and let in like two goals...still remember that feeling that he was going to stop whatever was thrown at him

[@Skeevee]

* repeatedly says he doesn't dislike brodeur*

[@jasoninseattlewa79]

Love that this channel popped up for me. Love debates like this.

[@STARPHASE]

Watching this in 2019 is amusing =P the comment about Miller not facing a lot of shots in Anaheim.