Netas Demoralizing Army Forces By Asking 'PROOF' Of Surgical Strike: The Newshour Debate (5th Oct)

Watch Arnab's Latest Debate On Arvind Kejriwal Vs Surgical Strike ►bit.ly/2dvWbPP
On The Newshour, TIMES NOW's Editor-in-Chief Arnab Goswami, and panelists -- Dr Sudhanshu Trivedi, National Spokesperson, BJP & Political Advisor to Rajnath Singh; Maroof Raza, Consulting Editor, Strategic Affairs; Sushant Sareen, Senior Fellow, Vivekananda International Foundation; Lt Gen (Retd) B S Jaswal, Former Army Commander, Northern Command; Air Marshal (Retd) P K Barbora, Former Vice Chief of Air Staff; Shabnam Lone, Advocate, SC; Syed Asim Waqar, Leader, SP; Alimuddin Khan, Political Analyst; Prof Ashok Sinha, Spokesperson, RJD; and Dr Tasleem Ahmed Rehmani, President, Muslim Political Council of India -- discussed whether the politicians are not demoralizing army forces when they ask for ‘proof’ of surgical strikes.
Subscribe to NewsHour Debate | Click Here ► goo.gl/LfNgFF
‘Download the official TIMES NOW mobile app - Give a missed call on 1800 4190 300. Stay updated, stay ahead.’
Subscribe Now To Our Network Channels
ET Now : goo.gl/5XreUq
Times Now : goo.gl/U9ibPb
To Stay Updated Download the Times Now App :-
Android Google Play : goo.gl/zJhWjC
Apple App Store : goo.gl/d7QBQZ
Social Media Links :-
Twitter - goo.gl/FzJIpz
Facebook - goo.gl/CC7rGc
G+ - goo.gl/O1iEp5
Also visit our website - goo.gl/XPUXe8

[@ashishrai3069]

Leaders raising questions over strikes should be sent across LoC to witness future strikes...

[@parthasarathycommon1289]

ashish, do the surgical strikes on the doubting leaders themselves, then , the families of the leaders will get convinced

[@sandy00720]

I support!!

[@vimalmishra3915]

sahi bola mast comment and reply to those doubting

[@Rohitsingh9199]

lol ur nation is fake lol failed state hahahahahahahahah dead economy and fucked up nation

[@varunsharma902]

man your nation is running on foreign funding which is comes as the aid to pakistan ..your economy has collaspe.. if saction apply on pakistan ..whole of your nation will become next somalia...politician will leave the country ...wake up man ..u r in 2016

[@mentplc]

Pakistani released spy pigeon in Punjab = Called Ghutarghoon Khan Pakistani released spy pigeon in Delhi = Called *Arvind Kejruddhin* *Punjab Police arrested Ghutarghoon Khan's but Arvind Kejruddhin is still roaming freely*

[@rolandoober6094]

+kannykanny1 Sooper Bhai.right question

[@MrMani035]

Air Marshal Barbora!!! Big salute to you! Sir for your address from heart like a soldier..... Overwhelmed to meet you after long lull......I was lucky to serve under you in Hindon 1990-1993

[@jaifen1]

guys who ever reading comments iam kej fan but i feel shamed my self today. idnt know, when i type this msg my tears comming out. luv army salute u. wht u made us safe today because of ur protection.

[@manjurazdan]

+Jaifen Tonny You are sad and disappointed because you had put your loyalty at the wrong place. Arvind Kejriwal have shown his true colors many times before but now he has crossed every limit. He is the most dangerous power hungry politician. Worse than Lallu. Because Lallu is obvious but kajriwal is very screwed. Glad you could see that now.

[@KamatShivani]

hahaha

[@jaifen1]

Shivani Kamat y my comment make u laugh miss.

[@KamatShivani]

+Jaifen Tonny no sir mr. avidi arshid's statement made me laugh... it was true to every word... looks really like Pak like keju more than us Indians

[@lavishpabbi11]

Be proud and support Indian Army !!

[@sankarpatar]

Wow...Sabnam Lome.......... can't believe what she said m damn shocked................ she supported army........... ..................thnq...👍👍👍👍

[@satchitananda8836]

Did you forget her last U-turn within couple of days..

[@ravikumar-dv8lh]

Sabnam is not so bad, her mostly of her thinking is without force there can be a peace in Kashmir, but she don't know its Pak who break the peace.

[@bharathcitizen8451]

As a true Indians, we firmly believe that surgical strikes happened beyond doubt. We strongly condemn those people who demand for proofs. This country doesn't need them.

[@rajinderprabhakar518]

Maroof you are BRILLIANT. My salute

[@deepatlolla]

Shabnam lone ki fatt gayi itne saare army men ko debate mein dekh ke.Today she is being nice & polite.

[@abbujaan]

hahaha aaj bolti to g..d faad dete army wale

[@parthasarathycommon1289]

if she said anything, kal court mein iski kapde phad dete.... izzat bhi lut jati....

[@manjurazdan]

ARNAV WE ARE WATCHING THESE POWER HUNGRY POLITICIAN S. PLEASE NEVER GIVE UP AS YOU ARE OUR VOICE. WITH MUCH LOVE AND REGARDS TO YOU SiR!!

[@lavishpabbi11]

I do support free thinking, but in this case questioning Indian Army is as close as you can get to belittle their great sacrifices done for 1.3 billion people.

[@drravivenkat]

Tasleem Rahmani should be transported to Pakistan

[@becautious5658]

How dare these ppl question da credibility of our invincible army.

[@rajachari8156]

Tasleem should be send in the border...

[@rajachari8156]

Marrof reza sir ur great

[@pranavs3087]

Raj Achari no doubt bro he is one man show

[@anmol_goel]

Salute to our Army that they never couped despite these ultra cheap and shitty political class.

[@juhiwazir1138]

Asiaonfocus thts what all of us think

[@nareshtanwar6713]

Rehmani learn to respect the Generals & the Fauj. Don't open your hole in between.

[@dinkardeo1257]

Mahroof is real taste of India.

[@shri6323]

Maroof you rock !!!!! Arnab you rock !!!!!!

[@prankstereddy]

50 years from today the time we are living in will be remembered as the AGE OF NATIONALISM

[@Surajkumar0770]

Nationalism is Immortal. It exist as nation does

[@tiffles3890]

So? I see nothing wrong with putting nation and its people first, regardless of party. Since when did being a patriot become something to be ashamed of instead of a virtue? Plus its not as if we have an immature, warmongering government that is about to precipitate war. The strike was done on terrorists, not Pakistanis and the army rapidly detached and made it clear that it wont pursue any further action. Instead of a careless knee jerk reaction, it was patient, planned and professionally done, with ample steps taken to avoid escalation.

[@ShashankPangam]

Air Marshal Barbora summed it up pretty well in the end.

[@AHEAD30]

A request to Times Now...dont even call these so called stupid netas on your show for debate. They open their gutter mouth and demoralize our brave soldiers.

[@AS-nc6gb]

we did surgical strikes . We will clean Pok too , and we will make balochistan free as well ! *DUM HAI TO KUCH UKHAD K DIKHAO*

[@Zee_news_Events]

dear take care of your health

[@ameerakbar9019]

haha Wagah border per tu khare ho nahi sakte ... samne atay he peshab nikal jata hai our surgical strike ? 2 bando se aik jaga 4 din tak chura nhi pae ,,, ae bara hamla kerne ,, ager himmat ha tu hamla kero na ,, phir maza aega darpok sale

[@AS-nc6gb]

*Pakistaniyon ki gannd mein dum nai hai war k liye INDIA se, 5 min mein gayab ho jayega world map se ! soch samagh kar panga lena* ..... Vaise b china ki personal raannd hai pakistan .

[@luminous787]

By questioning the Government what these traitors have done is united and brought the rest of the Indians together. The entire nation unanimously is spitting on them. We salute our soldiers and our PM.

[@yogesh85d]

By raising this issue Congress wants to hide its failure in dealing with terrorists and Pak army. I stand by Indian army and PM Modi, they have successfully replied terrorists in a language they understand.

[@Abhishek-zd7ln]

Arvind kejriwal is no doubt a person who stoops low but it was still a surprise when proof was demanded because it was not expected from AAM AADMI party, they joined politics on basis that the common man(AAM AADMI) will be protected Kejriwal should know that the army at the borders protects common people like us, After this Kejrwial should change his party name to Chutiye Logon ki Party.

[@kutty1234]

we felt so pained by these political people

[@AnubhavSingh259]

Love the way how Arnab respects and does not interrupt Colonel while he shuts these illiterate politicians!

[@amirbhat6143]

I can't stop laughing OMG this show can beat comedy NIGHT of kapil 😄

[@radhatripathi]

such jealousy for BJP when everyone needs to be on one page. disgusting

[@prateekprateek1]

HAHA...The guy in white dress is HYSTERICAL!!

[@AAR0208]

The fact that they are doubting whether a military operation which was reported to be successful actually happened is a slap to the face of soldiers who put their lives at risk. Some of these politicians should be ashamed of themselves

[@AAR0208]

The fact that they are doing it because they belong to the opposition and want to undermine the ruling party just makes them bigger idiots, what is a politician who can't see the bigger picture, a jackass that's what

[@becautious5658]

Do not make mockery of freedom of speech and right to know wrt nation. Indian army is invincible, don't you dare question their credibility.

[@MahendraSingh-fm8wb]

गद्दारों के अच्छे दिन तो वाकई आ गए है भाई ! जय हिन्द |

[@arewe0103]

Salute to arnab goswami.... You are the best

[@nirobh9244]

Why should we only see dead armies body ?? Cant we see their bravery ?? Army should be proud of that..and yes keeping their execution confidential

[@meenakumari963]

all jelious with modi ji

[@juhiwazir1138]

Yes arnab we feel pain when political party doubts on our best army😪😭

[@sathiyansekaran]

Next time Arvind Kejriwal will be elected again as a CM on Indian capital ???? Delhi people need to think twice....

[@yamraajxxxx]

Sayed asim talks hypocrisy. Plse make him shut his mouth He is disbeliever of Army 's action as if Pakistani general.

[@petermoore5750]

It is a shame that these ignorant Politicians are questioning the Military. SHAME! SHAME!

[@randheerkumar8840]

well said arunab in hindi. ur hindi is also strong

[@harishbuddhdev8683]

CONGRESS CHAIR PERSONS ARE NOT HAVING COURAGES KICK OF MAN LIKE DIGVIJAY , CHIDRUM AND SANJAY NIRUPM

[@yatendrakumar4336]

Today congress is saying that BJP taking the avail of surgical strike. My question to congress & AAP party leaders- when the pathan cot terror attack happen then they were blaming the BJP govt. ??? If BJP is taking the avail of surgical strike they are doing nothing wrong.

[@hitesharyan4831]

I am ASHAMED that WE THE PEOPLE have elected such sick REPRESENTATIVES. Mr. Rehmani and Mr. Khan, SHAME...

[@kshitijchauhan1548]

proud of the Indian army

[@candiddirector1711]

Arnab asking where's that Grace Gone? It's gone the moment arvind kejriwal came into the power.. Delhites (besides a few) have gone completely nuts and what amazes me they have been fooled twice by the same person..

[@gauravverma8384]

Indian politician are doing the same, what Pakistani Army doing with their own country : Both squeezing their country for personal interest.

[@becautious5658]

Well said Gen! Politicians must refrain from meddling in Army matters.

[@vijaykumar-dz2lj]

stupid politician peoples r watching ur fights I salute indian soldiers

[@rohitnikalje409]

I will not be surprised tomorrow if these politicians will say to the DGMO to create a What's App group and add them so they can receive updates. Shame on these Politicians . Salute of the #IndianArmy. Jay Hind.

[@OlahuUber_29]

love Maroof MRF tyre. he is rock solid with powerful grip.

[@saurabhghosh7956]

I AM FEELING PAIN TODAY

[@sidhant611]

when maroof talks, I feel motivated to join the Indian army immediately

[@logan89ism]

If some1 passes an exam, do you ever ask for proof that he/she appeared for the same?????

[@pranavpratheekmalleboyina4483]

Yes...certificate /mark sheet/hall ticket

[@sauravpanditcfgrapher]

Yes I am feeling pain

[@jitendrabhosale3400]

arnab said i want shaban loan hahahahahaha

[@moderniteverma8780]

This country is going from bad to worse in morals , in thinking , in reason and dignity, and all human values.....and all that is civilised and right

[@samirbhatnagar4062]

Sushant Sareen - voice of wisdom

[@suhaibhaider5792]

I love arnab Goswami he is great detrimental to his own nation,,,,,keep it up

[@ANILKUMAR-dy2th]

Every time a terror strike happens against us Indian public expected a retaliation as always stated by the so called leaders - but for 26 years it never came. Only now the Indian public feels satisfied - thanks to the brave army men and also the PM who gave a blanket authority it - To hell with these filthy politicians who could not stand it.

[@maniksingh1677]

People asking for proof and all should know that this makes our country looks weak....

[@sunayanayadav2804]

केजरीवाल राम के समय का वही धोबी है जिसने सीता माता की पवित्रता का सबूत मागा था

[@MahendraSingh-fm8wb]

मारूफ राजा सोच रहे हैं, कैसे कैसे तुचिये है इस देश में !!

[@aravindgowda2770]

Sorry Not all Muslims..But few of them in this panel...

[@alokpagare8315]

i love you Arnab ji

[@sujatanangare545]

Those who asking Proof of surgical strike must be "" fired with big turret ""

[@karthikraja7941]

These Muslim Politician in the panel are spoiling the real Patriotic Muslims peoples in India................ mad peoples ........................

[@mayurmundhe1205]

All the nation needs is educated Politicians ... Who can give credit to a Government that did good

[@shakti1390]

Bloody hell see the passion in the eyes of the Mr. maroof raja. Salute to you sir. Jai HInd

[@vikramtomar3609]

we do not want such leaders anymore

[@647546]

First things first, it makes no sense when someone says "it pains me". Grammatically it's absolutely wrong, the correct way is "it hurts me".

[@ankursaha7636]

very painful to hear our politicians.they are worst than any thing in this world.

[@DevduttasharmaDevduttasharma30]

AREY!!! TODAY HOW COME SHABNAM LONE JOINING THE DEBATE?😂😂😂

[@ilovetoto-thebabycheetah3227]

Here I am reproducing the best message I received on whatsapp : 'We appeal our armed forces: next time take Kejriwal and Nirupam along with you and leave them in POK as an evidence' This way everyone will get evidence and even POK will be freed because once these two land there even terrorists will get fed up of their allegations and will run away from POK. Joke apart but I hope both have understood our National sentiments on this issue.

[@vimalmishra3915]

maroof raza is my idol and hero i salute you sir you are so good and well informed respect respect respect respect respect respect respect i am your follower

[@snehsrivastava2373]

Pathetic Congress and AAP... Congress- apse (army) koi sawal nahi kr ra.... lekin hme limited proof chahie... hme pata nahi hum kya bolte hai but hme bolte rehna chahie.... :D :D Hilarious!!!

[@bhupen008]

Great Mr Barbora!

[@rajeshjha8697]

Mr maroof you have won every Indian haert you make us proud give us hope ,just raise your every proud Indian will rally behind you and it will make us proud thank you sir India needs you this is time

[@moonsurfer3915]

The raid in Abbotabad was telecast live. The US President was seen with his security team watching the raid. Hence no controversy. Same is expected by people opposed to Arnob's point of view

[@rubiccuber1448]

MODI HAS NOT TAKEN THE MOST FAVOURED NATION'S STATUE FROM PAKISTAN YET THAT PROVES HE IS NO WHATTT WE

[@rohitkrishnamurti7098]

how any politics can be done on surgical strike shame shame shame

[@moderniteverma8780]

he is a unofficial spokesman of modi and a shame on all independent journalism,I living in Australia is amazed at the Popularity of this channel, surely something must be psychologically wron with the people of that country to.like thismchannel

[@sujitmohapatra4978]

This strategy is a new weapon in the arsenal of POLITICAL PARTIES. Kanhaiya Kumar is the chief architect of this new weapon. In a country, where 1.2 billion people say Bharat Jindabad, he just went in the opposite direction to get all attention from media and nation and he got it.He knew that saying Bharat jindabad will not bring any attention or fame. After getting all attention he just denied and rather said he was against the government. Again here the political leaders who had lost all their attention of media, since media's concentration was on INDIAN ARMY and government next step against terrorism decided to use their KKA (Kanhaiya Kumar Astra). They initially questioned the authenticity of surgical strike carried out by INDIAN ARMY. Now, they are declining it and said that they are always with the army but are against government. Thanks to KKA.......

[@moderniteverma8780]

I have always liked Om pure as an actor, and he has played an armyman , in the movies, and also said sorry for some unsavoury remarks, however he has bee insulated by all and sundry, shame on all those below who,still.abuse an elderly actor, spit on them

[@aravindgowda2770]

If BJP praises INDIAN ARMY will that become pawn for Congress and other Muslim Parties to make politics

[@dipinprakash6870]

now days it has become fashion to pretend themselves as nationalist and others are cheaters

[@chandansahoo4987]

FROM TODAY ONWORDS WE UNDERSTAND THAT CONGRESS IS FROM PAKISTAN NOT FROM INDIA . WE INDIANS PROMISE YOU THAT FROM TODAY WE NEVER GIVE VOTE TO CONGRESS AND AA PARTY........

[@MrAdityasinghvi]

just remove their z grade security for 1 day

[@0xFdeadc0de]

Shushant is man of steel.

[@PardeepSingh-le3op]

well said sushant

[@shashanktangwan6104]

Oppn: "Ye BJP ko iska Zara sa bhi credit kyu jaa raha hai????" Abe ullu ke patthon jab tum power me the to tab kar lete... janta poora poora credit deti.... magar nahi kiya to ab kyu pichwade me mirchi lagi hai tumhe????

[@abbujaan]

army should be given free hand on politicians as well.army would teach them lesson nicely.

[@rohitnikalje409]

Tell Shabnam Lone to listen Mann ki Baat on radio .

[@saifkashmiri2981]

Ghulam Akbar, Superintendent of Police (Special Branch) of the Mirpur Range in PoK, has admitted that the surgical strikes had indeed taken place at many sectors on the early hours of September 29. During the call with Gupta, he clearly stated that the Pakistani Army was caught unawares by the Indian attack and lost 5 of its soldiers (CNN News18 has their names) and that the bodies of unknown number of terrorists were quickly removed by the Pakistani military. CNN-News18’s Gupta called Akbar pretending to be ‘IG Mushtaq’ and sought details about the casualties of that night. The SP also said Pakistani Army put the dead bodies in ambulances and took them away, adding that many have been buried in villages and that his cops were evaluating the coffin boxes.

[@dilipsave428]

Had it not been for the wisdom of Indian electorate, these uncouth leaders would have

[@janvipandit9049]

No one should question the army. They are the only people are going to keep enemies out of the country, without a strong military india , will be open porous border like when india was invaded by greeks, Persians, british etc .. Jaihind

[@rahulghadi8856]

sayed waqar.. we believe ur army and we believe ur PM

[@user-qz9pj7pn2s]

It is the prerogative of the military, whether they want to release the evidence of surgical strikes in public. I do not doubt the veracity of the army's claim, but I would like the army to release the evidence in public. This will dispel the doubts of all these rogue political parties and it will also effectively demolish the false propaganda of Islam infected Northwest Bharat (Pakistan).

[@lakvade4740]

all 3 great men in uniform here, i am pained to see how you have to prove your point to these illiterate, stupid and nonsense people - they don't deserve to share the screen with you'll .... A million salutes !

[@dev840]

You have right to ask a political party for a proof, but definitely not to the defense forces. When Indian DGMO says it was a surgical attack, It means it was done, cmon DGMO is not elected by caste/religion voting idiots. Salute to Indian Army and defense forces. Anyone asking proof sucks.