Why is Pakistan Interfering in India's Affairs?: The Newshour Debate (17th May 2016)

Watch Arnab Goswami's Debate on India Vs Pakistan On NSG Bid ►bit.ly/28RpAkC
Watch Arnab Goswami's Latest Debate where he & his panelists discuss about Pakistan's Interference in India's Legislation.
On THE NEWSHOUR, TIMES NOW's Editor-in-Chief Arnab Goswami, and panelists -- Maroof Raza, Consulting Editor, Strategic Affairs; Rashneek Kher, Founder Member, Roots in Kashmir; Maj Gen G D Bakshi(Retd), Editor, Indian Military Review; Sheshadri Chari, Member, Natl Executive & Convenor, Foreign Affairs Cell, BJP; Lt Col Shafqat Saeed (Retd), Defence Analyst; Air Vice Marshall Abid Rao (Retd), Defence Analyst; and Fawad Choudhry, Political Analyst & Former Adviser to the Fmr PM of Pakistan (Adviser to Syed Yousuf Raza Gillani) -- discuss Islamabad getting angry with India's assertion on Kashmir on the map, the geospatial info regulation draft bill giving Pakistan government a nightmare, Pakistan asking for UN interference, and as to why Pakistan is meddling in Indian legislation.
Subscribe to NewsHour Debate | Click Here ► goo.gl/LfNgFF
Share this Debate on Facebook ►bit.ly/22fKqz6
‘Download the official TIMES NOW mobile app - Give a missed call on 1800 4190 300. Stay updated, stay ahead.’
Subscribe Now To Our Network Channels
ET Now : goo.gl/5XreUq
Times Now : goo.gl/U9ibPb
To Stay Updated Download the Times Now App :-
Android Google Play : goo.gl/zJhWjC
Apple App Store : goo.gl/d7QBQZ
Social Media Links :-
Twitter - goo.gl/FzJIpz
Facebook - goo.gl/CC7rGc
G+ - goo.gl/O1iEp5
Also visit our website - goo.gl/XPUXe8

[@slimjijo123]

"These are my assertions, the questions havent started yet." Thug life Arnab.

[@indianrapbiatch]

Kashmir is in india and will be in india.. Forever..

[@aa2398a]

+indianrapbiatch tell that to Kashmiris who wave the Pakistani flag with pride and JOY

[@indianrapbiatch]

+Tahir Chaudhry don't get me started with balochistan.. Just fuck off.. And keep dreaming.. Kashmir is and will be a part of india forever..

[@indianrapbiatch]

+Tahir Chaudhry fuck off .. Kashmir is and will be in india forever.. If u got balls take it... 😆

[@aa2398a]

actually its 64% of indians have no toilets LOL

[@jayparekh7574]

41 million pakistanis also don't have toilets as well as pakistan still not able to do census since 18 years

[@stevemavros8892]

Some epic quotes out there by Arnab :) - Pakistan: You are not a nation, instead you are just a bunch of real estate agents who sell of their gifted lands to Chinese.

[@aa2398a]

+Steve Mavros I guess that makes you guys pirates - target practice for Italian navy

[@srajanvishwakarma26]

+Diesel_Nut84 don't push us to do target practice on u....

[@aa2398a]

+Srajan Vishwakarma another "Cold Start Doctrine" in the pipeline? The lines get old dude, come up with new material soon

[@srajanvishwakarma26]

+Diesel_Nut84 4 times u got ur ass kicked nd was torn in half nd still arguing...may god bless u...

[@MrDreamer121]

+true man No one cares

[@TheYogmishra]

Pakistan was shouting for Kashmir in 1971. They Lost Bangladesh. Pakistan was shouting for Kashmir in 1980's. They Lost Siachin. Pakistan is shouting for Kashmir now. Next What !!! They may loose Baluchistaan

[@ManishYadav-ij2kh]

+Yog Mishra no buddy this time they will loose pakistan.

[@dayanand8919]

Bharat Mata ki Jai Akhand Bharat Mata ki Jai Har Har महादेव Shiv Linga ki Jai, Pakistan is in, Indo-Australian Tectonic plate.

[@aa2398a]

+Yog Mishra 1971 had nothing to do with Kashmir you ignorant dot-head

[@aa2398a]

+Yog Mishra Siachen? An ice shelf where your soldiers commit suicide and fracticide. We captured Point 5353 in 1999 and have excellent forward looking positions over the only crucial logistics route that connects Leh-Sri Nagar. A few RBS-70 and Panther 155 mm arty guns is enough to prematurely cremate any moving vehicle with an indian flag on it

[@cmann2255]

+Diesel_Nut84 SHUT Up!

[@indraneilbiswas]

he called candy crush "candy crash" thank god for partition :D

[@manishk3740]

I wish Tarek Fatah was there on your show.

[@Winner1985]

true man do you guys even spare your own sisters ???? hahahhaha

[@lifeinthecosmos90]

or swamy :P

[@roshanthapa6916]

True.. Tarek Fateh should have been here.

[@satire2black838]

+rockysikander... so... fucking agree brother..

[@RajKumar-bn2du]

'Half literate military dictators' ...lol

[@adisura9904]

Yes we don't have "a" language, we have many, we don't have "a" religion, we have many and we certainly have a History. What does Pakistan has to say? Yes you're a Muslim nation. Perhaps the only country formed on the basis of religion. Pakistan's roots are that of War. You're a fort to protect a religion, not the people. We have more Muslims in India, and Atleast they are proud of a Secular country and not a Demented Idea.

[@TheSayV]

word .

[@PUBGCHALLENGERS]

Nice speech for books. Yaar dono countries ka ek hi haal hai... garib hindi/urdu mein suffer kerta hai Ameer forign mein.

[@BalkaranSinghSidhu]

Arnab Goswami is a legend

[@Manishsainwar]

I have just joined the debate but a big clap at 5:36 . Lets see what more masala we have on the menu tonight .

[@deepatlolla]

I Never Knew So Many Countries Have Lashed Out At Pakistan .... (Which Arnab Says In Between This Debate).... If I were in Pakistan's Place , I Would Have Buried My self right there in that interview.

[@aa2398a]

+deepatlolla consider some beef in your diet - it's good for you

[@riteshsabbarwal2350]

+Diesel_Nut84 Just like you avid eaters of Pork...no wonder why you talk shit ;)

[@roheetmalhotra1287]

Well said Mahroof Raza !!! 🇮🇳💪

[@shivamtewari2576]

the actual competition is who shouts louder...and we will always win because we have arnab on our side..!!! :p

[@sarthakmehta2420]

its not cashmir, its kashmir...

[@Manishsainwar]

+ritesh sabbarwal Ya Raacket XD

[@anilkumarahuja6841]

+ritesh sabbarwal hahahaha . . .. . this is one of the funniest but true comment I have read in recent times.

[@palamol]

Maroof is awesome......

[@saravananperiyasamy5730]

Maroof raza is one among world best defence analyst..

[@tilottamachakrabarti7555]

Mr. Arnab G, with his brilliant participation, both as moderator and active participant, always illuminates the debates with Pakistan..Mr. Fawad, sorry brother, your behaviour, (playing games and constant interruption) was not in good taste.You can judge the quality of his debate as per ur standard but of course with needed gentility. Aum Shanti

[@darshanchhajed1969]

I am playing candy crush - Fawad lol :P

[@supersaiyan3704]

Playing Candy crush 😂😂

[@ishaansinghchadha]

Well said MAROOF!!

[@ajaybansode8455]

omg!! arnab great job! that fawad seriously need some education

[@munindragaur]

Maroof.. the man with real guts !!

[@scramjet7466]

junagarh and hyderabad taken by force? wtf is he talking about? but the kings of these 2 kingdoms wanted to be separate however the people wanted to be with India

[@tutikandi1]

Maroof Raza--great logic

[@rohitler87]

47.50.. You are not allowing me to speak so I am playing my game.. WTF.. 😂😂

[@swatitiwari6903]

Nice

[@vijaynair906]

arnob really rocking

[@vishalraj8215]

Ohhh man Maroof was At Fired Awesome

[@asifpasha9766]

No match between india and pakistan. India is growing power in all aspects.and world largest democracy.

[@PawanNogariya]

I am not with Pakistan but this is not the way to talk to the guests on national television. If you want to debate, then debate with dignity. Arnab started the debate by insulting Pakistanis, if you don't like them don't call them but calling them and then insulting is not at all good, it gives a wrong impression of India as well as Indians.

+Pawan Nogariya fuck off bleeding heart. They created a ruckus the entire length. And that's how they behave in all debates.

[@PawanNogariya]

+bammbamm Hahaha... From your reply your heart seems more bleeding than mine. BTW mine was not bleeding for them, I was just talking about being gentle when you call someone just to put a good image of yourself. But I know you cannot understand the meaning of being gentle, your reply show that as well as your fake id.

[@PawanNogariya]

Let me assert that again, I am not on Pakistan side. I hate Pakistan as much as every Indian hate that nation. I was just saying that don't call them if we hate them, but calling them and then insulting is not Indian culture. We are giving them fitting reply on borders, but this debate is not LOC where you have to fight. We should counter them with fitting logical replies to make them speechless but trying to defeat them by insult is a cheap thing and we Indians are not cheap.

[@radhikashah2419]

absolutely right

[@chursibudmaash4667]

i am shocked to see that there are people in india who see it this way , i salute you , this anchor is doing a great job of spreading hate and showing real face of india to the world

[@1995abhijeet]

Maj Gen. G D Bakshi aced it.... Frankly u got the balls then come and get it.... 😂😂

[@paramagan]

They got nothing better to do...they don't have industries to run......

[@ARShanker]

Some many facts unsaid so much untruth said So much pains & loss So much unfair to the history india & indians So much silence on ourselves We r saddened by ourselves As we couldn't rise to it

[@anshusharma11]

We Kashmiri hindus are also part of kashmir. Though our muslim brothers are the reason for our mass exodus. So please ask kashmiri hindus before saying that kashmiris are with pakistan

[@kunalmehta8961]

Maroof is the man

[@romaramsha8635]

i dont knw from where arnab gets his news...he was so wrong all the time and yet aggresive & confident...he barks a lot...& when u peopl stop interfering in our issues...will see what we can do....

[@saishprabhudesai3998]

Roma Khan Ur so beautiful

[@sanjayrakshit8797]

GD Bakshi steals the show :)

[@faheemmohammad9743]

Call dozens of participants and make controversial statements ,never let anyone talk,Keep interrupt and never let anyone complete their argument. This is the real face of Indian media. We Pakistani and Indian are too naive to see that and start fight with foul language.

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

India since 1947 , even in 1972, made any effort to recover Azad Kashmir or Gilgit Baltistan or Balochistan. according to the Adverse Possession Law of India, these areas have gone; india cannot get back these areas without a war.

[@sajivdoley6949]

7:35 what's that guy on top left doing with his shaking finger? Creepy old man😂

[@mohanudiavar]

Pak. was created on 14/08/1947 out of the Great Indian Peninsula and the astrological chart indicates a life span of about 71 years

[@aa2398a]

no thats a tradition you dot-heads do

[@tapemaj]

Kashmir , Kashmir - BELONGS to BHARAT . Full stop . Forget, Hindu Jammu , even Kashmir HAMARA HINDUSTANI hai . Forget China ,Bhool jaaao , China ko Bhool jaao . Hamarah , Kashmir hamesha Hamara Hindustan ka rahega . RESPECT to this ex General of the Indian army . Jai Hind . Mera Bharat , Akhand Bharat , Mahaaan Bharat .

[@PUBGCHALLENGERS]

Sahi kaam per media ne lagaya hai hindustanio aur Pakistanio ko. Yehi dono coutries ke log ek doosray ke saath sab se ziada acha salook kertein hai western countries mein. Hindustanio aur Pakistanio se sawal hai.. Agar peace between the two most alike nations is not the solution than what is the solution ??? Hindustan Zindabad 🇮🇳 Pakistan Zindabad 🇵🇰

[@ankitpatra5042]

when asked about the origin of the word "Kashmir" ,they started to explain post-independance history of kashmir. LOL!!!!!!!!!

[@ravi2510.]

India is running from KASHMIR from KANYAKUMARI :)

[@surbhigupta3848]

maharoof raza steal d show ...great.....asum man

[@ryanowen3026]

i cant believe they were part of india once.

[@thelibrarian8630]

haha the second pakistani panelist was conflicted between saying Kashmir and CASHmir

[@amitavabhatt343]

The British united India, where was Pakistan then not even in existence.they forget that they were part of that 5000 year old history which they lost when they separated, their sorry history is of 70 years only!

[@amitavabhatt343]

True that really is their tragedy

[@bachajamoora8916]

Look BASELESS Emotions of Indian participants specially Gen. Bakshi -

[@mercilesshunt9935]

Dear arnab , plz ask your government officials why they are interfering in nepal's affairs

[@anshusharma11]

People of jammu and kashmir still stand with india..Only kashmiri Muslims are standing with the pakistan...so correct your facts

[@sudarshans226]

I am so disappointed in hearing screaming in this program. There are ten people talking at the same time.

[@slash-brand1145]

The anchor is no an anchor, he should be neutral,,, the anchor #the thug

[@muhammadhabib2795]

great

[@bickslow6221]

If Raja Hari Singh signed the instrument of accession, the pressure put on him was done by the Pakistan Army attacking Kashmir. This guy talks about history saying, "We don't have a united people in History." I'd like to say this to you sir, You don't have a history prior to 1947 because it was Indian history before that. There is no Pakistani History. The history of region is and always will be Indian history and you can go all the way back to the BC. And another guy says we don't own our people. It's true! Indians are free!! Finally we agree on something.

[@punjabigundaa]

hhahaha "fawad are you looking for facts on the internet" "we don't need nukes to destroy pakistan as pakistan is ticking bomb destroying itself" HAHAHHAHA made me laugh so hard

[@aishik5127]

"u dont have water...u dont have money...u dont have democracy".. boom mike drop :D

[@TheRkmusic75]

If I train your son for studies during his childhood... And asks for his custody later arguing that his knowledge is mine.. His tone is mine..he speaks my language.. Would you give him to me ? Is "authority of fatherhood" nothing here... ? Are you putting in front such a shallow argument ?

[@wackydawgcoptyltd8282]

You should bring that chutiya Fawad and joker Peerzada into one debate

[@kunalmehta8961]

+A Bogan Oh man the scenes xD

[@wackydawgcoptyltd8282]

Kunal Mehta I know right

[@palamol]

+A Bogan yeh peerzada has high blood pressure now.....he cant come lol he he

[@Logictrumpssuperstition]

I was playing candy crush ahhahaahahhaa what a fool

[@drzaib1093]

fawad is great. i mean he is acting equally as arnab act...

[@vedprakash6648]

Because modi went to pakistan and directly handed over his love letter. During UPA they were posting it but modi directly went and gave it in hand.

[@sakthivel-ex5gc]

thanks to jinna,ghandhi and the british.if pakistan is not separated that time you can not imagine a peaceful india.

[@sanju2105]

Pak is obsessed with India even after separation like ex boyfriend

[@cyb-m]

I think the map bill by India is a bad idea. We shouldn't claim the land to which we have no access, even though legally it might be ours, especially since it is held by a banana republic like Pakistan. The fact is that our troops are in Kargil and not in Skardu, they are in Poonch not in Muzaffarabad. The day our troop can roam about free in Baltistan and Gilgit just like they do in Jammu and Kashmir valley, we can redo our maps. Until then our maps need to show the LoC as border with PoK as disputed. What if tomorrow there is another terrorist incident in India (or worse, in the west) and the perpetrators are traced back to Skardu or Muzaffarabad? We can't go accuse Pakistan with it, because they will retort saying "it is your internal problem or homegrown terrorist, after all your official maps shows Skardu to be in India". What are we going to do then? This is why I think this bill is a bad idea!!

[@MrMigti]

Another comment from Arnab: You can keep playing Candy because your arguments are crushed :)

[@freakishlyfeline4917]

Candy Crush....LOL..

[@lifewithahmed81]

yeah we will get it inshah ALlah

[@SunnyD189]

+ahmed raza Yes u all will get it in your Arse, full Aloo!!

[@lifewithahmed81]

i thought yr army had some weapons good to know its just its aloo, uske french fries bana ke tujhe khila dainge

[@SunnyD189]

ahmed raza LMAO , we got all kinda of fries, including Chillie fries!!

[@lifewithahmed81]

Sunny Singh this is gonna fry yr ass now

[@lifewithahmed81]

Sunny Singh www.ibtimes.co.uk/indian-police-hunt-chennai-youth-who-burnt-national-flag-posted-picture-facebook-1541194

[@nuwave2008]

Three cheers to the English speaking audience !!

[@younisbaloch2744]

Fawad rocked Indian panel shocked hahahaj

[@G2nesh2s]

I saw the entire debate and the Pakistani guests are totally on defence. which seshadri chari predicted the altered Pakistani map is the highlight of the debate

[@faheemmohammad9743]

Arnab talking about diplomatic literacy....... irony isn't.

[@noahchase295]

20 minutes into debate, and understood only 2 things.....seriously, don't waste people's time with such so called debate

[@sudarshans226]

Baluchistan Zindabad.

[@najeeb3579]

+Ali Baloch there is more zinda bad on the way ! first of all you never get kashmir at any cause.second you tried everything to snatch it from India. UN has adopted that kashmir not a disputed territory since 2010.nobody stand with you in this regard. you don't need kashmir now you need jobs development universities hospitals gas electricity and drinking water. focus on that. You can't beat India at any level it's the fact.

[@kunalmehta8961]

"Apko Kashmir chahiye.....? LEKE DIKHAIYE!" _/\_ GD BAKSHI

[@kundankumar-wn5zw]

habid rav looks perplexed,he has no place to hide

[@TheYogeshkashalkar]

This debate sounds how people fight on twitter ...Dont stoop down to this level of debates on national tv with senior people talkin like this...

[@coolsinghjii]

actually it's Kashmir V/s Cashmir.... lol...

[@supratikgoswami2736]

Im indian and i think saying pakistan is not a nation is really offensive

[@SunnyD189]

+supratik goswami Offensive??>>..It's so true that ,we Indians are so conscious in being politically correct, we start hurting ourselves..That's if your not a false flagger..:-)

[@supratikgoswami2736]

Guys im just saying that if youre gonna have foreign nationals as guests on your TV show, then beginning with saying that their nation is not a country is probably not the best way to start the program. Anyone would be offended by that kind of a remark

[@utsavsingh7961]

how vice arnab is that pakistan is not a nation........vahvah.....pakistani guest is also at some point think that pakistan is not a nation and to prove pakistan is nation they are shouting on arnab......really arnab sir u r really great ...

[@kundankumar-wn5zw]

watch the face of habid rav when Kashmiri spokesperson is representing statistical figure of minority status in India at last segment of debate.

[@edwardjade620]

Indian have to sow the seeds of love in Pakistani brothers heart not haters. Cause 90% of them are converted from hindu to Muslims they are using hindu family or cast name like,Patel,Chaska,rajpoot,ratore,batty,and many others stop fighting think positive bring brothers home. sorry if it's offensive for someone

[@roheetmalhotra1287]

Kashmir will always be apart of INDIA

[@romaramsha8635]

lol....dont loss ur temper...look who is saying...

[@seanawake]

Doodh maango kheer denge. Kashmir maango cheer denge.

[@Shahidaliwal211]

Indians are too frustrated because they are loosing on evry ground like yesterday Pakistan slaps in the UNO

[@sominmukherji5512]

Air Marshall says - To have a country, you need to have a national language, religion etc etc? Is USA not a country ?

[@Beutifulsoul1234]

love u Pakistan, From inian occupied kashmir

[@WaseemAdil]

Indian bravery record in Kashmir Total Innocent Killings 94,345 Custodial Killings 7,046 Civilians Arrested 134,115 Structures Arsoned/Destroyed 106,064 Women Widowed 22,813 Children Orphaned 107,566 Women gang-raped / Molested 10,181 Civilians Disappearance cases in custody 10000 approx

[@jaiparashuram8682]

After watching the video i can confirm that Arnab's name is on ISI and LET/JEM hit list :) but seriously arnab....please conduct the debate more peacefully....we want to hear all the statements made by Guest pakistanis and not a chaos....

[@sanju2105]

Pakistan is outside country but what about Indian Muslims?why are they uniting with them?country live and security is at stake

[@adityamazumdar7544]

Best part of the debate. 34:17. You want J&K come and get it. Aa jao BC. Dekhte hai kaise lete ho.

[@inaaaam1]

if indians understands themselves a democratic state ,allow kashmiries to vote wether to b live wd india or pk,wht d hell 8 lac indian army doing in kashmir?

[@y2j249]

okay you know what quick question. any kashmiris in the comment section? please tell me if you want to merge with india or Pakistan and why. and people its more about the people than us and im an indian.

[@edwardjade620]

a few comments in English but seams Indian are so frustrated why? what is the matter

[@deepakzany5667]

+Edward Jade Cause we got neighbours with serious inferiority complex!

[@riteshsabbarwal2350]

Bravo Gen Bakshi... U want Kashmir, come n get it. Dum hai to leke dikhao 👍🏻

[@tanny786]

when indians are pissed of it must mean Pakistan is doing something right

[@ali15340]

Kashmir is part of pakistan not india part

[@mirzainayathali443]

come n get it. failed in 4 attempts try 5 th too.

[@ASHOK251058]

+Murtaza Ali this time you will loose baluchistan.

[@robinvarma6361]

well done arnav. made this irrational ppakistani spoof and, left him with sham and tawdry smile by a series of question.

[@rohitler87]

31.40 to 32.10.. hahahahaha.. 😂😂