NHL Network Countdown: Top Goalies All-Time

[@nthdegree1269]

Well, I know one record that will *NEVER* be broken. Glenn Hall's 502 consecutive complete games, *Without a Mask*

[@charleynewman4783]

Which is impressive

[@Fissey_Gaming]

We all know Scott Foster is the best goalie of all time with his GAA at 0.00 and his SVS% at 1.000!

[@DYZ_971]

Idk dude David Ayres is way better

[@neelmehta9069]

@@DYZ_971 Nah, he gave up two goals, Shutout foster is better, though I would love to see a game between them!

[@DYZ_971]

@@neelmehta9069 The best of the best goalies would be interesting to see

[@neelmehta9069]

@@DYZ_971 Agreed!

[@waynejohanson1083]

Statistically that would be true.

[@dannydevito2989]

Did I just see the NHL network call Corey Crawford the 26th best goalie of all time

[@TheCrazyCloon]

I laughed hard when I saw that. It's like they have a quota of current goalies they try to shoehorn in for people who are new to hockey.

[@thegreaterone7305]

Trev Mac comment of the year 🥇

[@Kmartsmart]

I agree. Crawford was great but not that good

[@5000jetadam]

@@trevmac8362 Shows some insecurity in that you feel the need to call someone out out. And based on the first five words in your comment, aren't you showing some weakness as well??

[@Pensfan5919]

​@@KmartsmartWhen you look at total career stats without the trophy case, his equal is Greg Millen. I wish I was joking.

[@jigzjood]

To bad Vladislav Tretiak never played in the Nhl .....

[@j.peters1222]

If he had, he'd have been the best all time. He did get drafted by Montreal in 1983 but he obviously never made it across the pond to take up the offer. Him and Valeri Kharlamov are the only two Hockey Hall of Fame players that never played in a North American league.

[@bam68]

@@j.peters1222 My God Montreal would have more than 24 cups

[@jwiese100]

Why couldn’t they just include him on this list? I mean he basically was the best goalie in the world NHL included.

[@frankiek2269]

@@jwiese100 Never heard of him. Is he the Russian Olympic goaltender? That’s the only thing that makes sense to me after reading y’all’s comments.

[@jwiese100]

@@frankiek2269 yes

[@TristanLockamy]

The fact that Pekka Rinne isn’t on a list called the “40 Best Goalies of All Time” makes me think that these people must have something against him. It’s too hard to believe that they’re just that stupid not to put him in the freakin list!!

[@DrZaius]

No Rinne and no Rask makes this list pure trash

[@jtp2007]

@@DrZaius There is no one on this list that they are better than, sorry. Recency bias?

[@massivecumshot]

Fantastic tribute to the legends. I grew up idolizing Terry Sawchuk and Gump Worsley in the Original 6 era. After 4 lost teeth and 3 broken noses, I got a cage mask, which changed everything about the game. I believe there are THREE ERAS of goaltending that should be judged on their own criteria: Pre-Mask, Post-Mask and the BUTTERFLY era.

[@PumaTomten]

Hasek carried teams.. he was the best solo performer in NHL after Gretzky. He even won Olympic gold single handedly vs Canada and Russia. Hasek nr1 easy

[@Jacks2022]

PumaTomten thanks from a sabres fan

[@thetute59]

iirc in nhl99 (the videogame) he also did awesome saves, he lunged at pucks :D what a beast

[@Murdock1]

Single handedly are you serious? He was huge part of our success, no doubt. But we had very quality team in front of him. The most deadly czech duo of all time Prochazka, Patera. Great defenders like Slegr, Svoboda, Spacek, Hamrlik. Great attackers JAGR, Straka, Rucinsky Reichel, Lang, Hejduk. Team chemistry and determination is reason why we won. Our team played like one man.

[@mightytaco14]

So vič he’s talking about the Sabres

[@Murdock1]

@@mightytaco14 no he is not. Read it one more time please.

[@bobkloth57]

Do you remember the Master Card TV commercial featuring Dominik Hasek, “Having a slinky for a spine, priceless”?

[@tysonleblanc8862]

Patrick Roy won 4 cups, 3 different decades, 2 different teams, twice each conference. 3 playoff MVPs in 3 decades. No one and I mean no one in any sport will ever do that.

[@vitnemec8365]

You can make a solid case for all the top 3 guys. Hašek for Vezinas, Harts, dominating the decade with his unique style and carrying a weak team long into playoffs, Brodeur for keeping his super high standard for so many years, Roy for all the reasons you mentioned. All legit.

[@pastapuck8342]

Roy at number1... Roy revolutionized the position and has 4 Cups! While Hasek was definitely entertaining and could get on a hot streak he, and nobody was a complete a goalie as Roy. Broduer was also great and for my money I’d put him ahead of Hasek. Roy was a big game goalie and performed unlike any other under pressure. He has 4 Stanley Cups and 3 Conn Smythe Trophies to his name.

[@richiejosephmazumder7632]

Lebron maybe😂

[@bradleyhenry2411]

@@richiejosephmazumder7632 Jordan? Brady?

[@alextimemit9454]

Yogi Berra won 8 world series in 3 different decades and 5 more as a Manager

[@johnnyslokes2712]

Hasek lost 7 seasons for non NHL reasons and his stats are still top tier

[@bennyrobinson6110]

How does quick rank above the king

[@PoXPuLar]

I think solely because of Quick’s Stanley cups and poor Hank not being able to carry his teams.. :(

[@Mrazarian]

Poor hank did nothing but carry the rangers. Hank over Quick every day

[@joesynk6883]

Well quick Has more playoff experience and has more cups and made it to Later Round

[@joesynk6883]

But they are close because quick as a 2.400 goals against average and Henrik Lundqvist has A 2.430 goes against average and a .917 save percentage quick has a .913 Save percentage

[@joesynk6883]

Jonathan quick has 331 wins 244 losses 69 overtime losses and Henrik long quest has 459 wins 310 losses 96 overtime losses and in the playoffs quick has a 46Wins 39 losses zero overtime losses and Henrik long quest has 61 wins 66 losses one overtime losses

[@bilalmallick8428]

Ken Dryden had a crazy run in just 8 years. Only goalie to win Conn Smythe and Stanley Cup before losing a regular season game.

[@ratboy717]

wait what

[@ross7825]

@@ratboy717 yep. He was brought up at the end of 1971, went 6-0-0 with as sub 2.00 GAA, and in a surprise was tasked with starting the playoffs against the defending Stanley Cup champions Boston. Even captain and HOFer Jean Beliveau acknowledged that the Canadiens don't beat Boston and go on to win that Cup without Dryden

[@billsandiego3385]

Old goalies are so much fun to watch!

[@father042]

I was worried Cujo would be left out, definitely the most underrated goalie of all time

[@billsandiego3385]

Hope he gets into the HHOF one day! He's been snubbed yet again

[@raj2007ca]

cujo could lnever win the big games. He woujld make 50 saves game 1 then in game 7 would let in 6 goals on 20 shots. That was the knock on his whole career. Mike keenan came to st louis and cujo was awful in the playoffs against vancouver and he knew right away i cant win with this guy.

[@kev27kev27]

@@raj2007ca Cujo was one of the best ever in big games. He was known as a money goaltender. He just never played on the best teams.

[@johnnyslokes2712]

​@@kev27kev27 Until he played with the Red Wings and he sucked. He was washed up by that time though

[@kev27kev27]

@Johnny Slokes what? 2003-04 playoffs .939 save percentage 1.39 gaa. Cujo was money his whole career. Easily the best goalie to never lift the cup.

[@normhudson4982]

Jacques Plante. Introduced the goalie mask. Was the first goalie to leave the net to handle the puck for his defencemen. 6 Stanley cups. 6 Vezinas. 437 wins. .920 lifetime goals against average. 82 shutouts. Should be #1. In 68-69 a 1.96 GAA with the expansion St. Louis Blues.

[@rikbite7191]

Man the top 3 just depends on what you think is more valuable. Brodeur was the most consistent top 2-3 goalie in league history. When hasek had a great game he was probably better than any goalie ever. Roy seemed to have a competitive dial he could turn up more than anyone else when the games were really important. As an avs fan I’m very biased towards Roy. If my team was playing one game and it’s literally life or death...give me patrick!

[@justindecker9282]

Exactly Marty a hasek should be everyone’s one and two on talent it’s hasek on everything overall it’s Marty, Roy a great goalie but he’s wort statically then them

[@tonybleau6219]

That is my main argument every time I debate someone about the best goalie. Roy is the only player, nevermind goalie, to win 3 Conn Smythe awards. Hasek may be the best regular season goalie ever but if you combine reg seasons and playoffs, it's Roy without a shadow of a doubt. The way he carried Montreal to a cup with all those OT wins as a ROOKIE vs a Gretzky led team was something to behold

[@lukehall5308]

Glenn Hall selected to 7 first Allstar teams, more then any other goalie in his era. Back then the Vezina was awarded to the lowest GAA which is now the Jennings trophy. Also played in a record 13 allstar games. He was very ahead of his time with the butterfly and pre game visualization. So many great goalies on this list!!

[@sportsfix6975]

His last name was his destiny!

[@Stresside]

How is Tuukka Rask not in this list? Second best all time save%, just 0,02% behind Hasek. Has won Stanley Cup and Vezina. Just beat Tiny Thompson in most wins as a Bruin.

[@Apple30braski]

Stresside cup as basically part of the equipment staff..

[@ItzTrollRoadTo400Subscribers]

uhm hasek has .913% sv percentage alltime

[@Stresside]

1 Dominik Hasek 1990‑08 .9223 2 Tuukka Rask 2007‑19 .9221

[@Stresside]

@@Apple30braski So what is Price doing in the list? Luongo? Basically won nothing.

[@Apple30braski]

@@Stresside You used winning a cup to help your argument... So I commented on that. And being a Boston fan PRice has been Montreals best player for his whole career... Tuukka wasn't even our best goalie in 2011. He has been out played or evenly matched up with by our last 3 "backups". Even Cassidy trusted Halak more for a while...

[@jeffmcgovern5674]

These lists are always fun. It truly is tough to rank greats of a game. When they played and who they played with often makes the discussion interesting.

[@MultiCappie]

I like how they put contemporaneous music along with each guy's montage. Awesome that Grant Fuhr gets the heavy metal! 27:30 And yes, he's the answer to NHL network's teaser: All time scoring leader among goalies, with a 14 point season!

[@drewhutchison8052]

Sawchuck will always be the best no matter what the list says

[@user-gt8mp3ct3v]

!Spoilers! 40. Georges Vezina 39. Ron Hextall 38. Braden Holtby 37. Mike Richter 36. Andy Moog 35. Mike Vernon 34. Tom Barrasso 33. Nikolai Khabibulin 32. Miikka Kiprusoff 31. Michel Larocque --------------------------------------- 30. Chris Osgood 29. Gerry Cheevers 28. Cecil Thompson 27. Tim Thomas 26. Corey Crawford 25. Rogatien Vachon 24. Carey Price 23. Frank Brimsek 22. Billy Smith 21. Mark-Andre Fleury ---------------------------------------- 20. Lorne Worsley 19. Curtis Joseph 18. Roberto Luongo 17. Henrik Lundqvist 16. Jonathan Quick 15. Walter Broda 14. Johnny Bower 13. Tony Esposito 12. Bernie Parent 11. Grant Fuhr ---------------------------------------- 10. George Hainsworth 9. Bill Durnan 8. Glenn Hall 7. Ken Dryden 6. Eddie Belfour 5. Jacques Plante 4. Terry Sawchuk 3. Patrick Roy 2. Dominik Hasek 1. Martin Brodeur

[@erinadrian4148]

Hasek is better

[@erinadrian4148]

Hasek is better

[@tyler9023]

your the best

[@simonbellavigna2160]

life saver

[@comment_guy6306]

Price should be top 15 atleast

[@debra53]

Did I miss Tukka Rask? I think he is easily top 30 or top 25 of all time

[@sst6601]

seeing Crawford at 26th alone makes the list invalid and the fact that there is no Nabby, Beezer, Rinne makes this list a complete joke

[@IJustPlayedOfficial]

Crawfords just one of the most disrespected goalies of all time he easily deserves to be on this list. Tbh Rinne was sick but when you compare career sv%, Crow and Rinne line up pretty well, even individual awards are pretty similar. However, Crow was a playoff beast and won two cups. that kinda puts him ahead of Rinne imo. And don’t say the whole “team award argument” because Crow literally was a top 5 player for the Hawks every run while Rinne was kinda known for falling apart in the playoffs at time

[@thedimers]

before watching, wasnt even a question in my mind of who was in the top 3. And it was exactly who i thought it was gonna be.

[@HunterLikesSoda]

100%, that's the holy trinity of great goaltending. gonna be a while before that changes. tbh, i'd actually have marty at #3, then say hasek or roy are damn near interchangeable for #1. but you can't go wrong with any order

[@Jeneric81]

This list is a good example of why people should watch games more and stats sheets less.

[@remilarose-debilly8047]

What would you change?

[@gonuts4donuts]

Osgood and Vernon are quite too low when you consider some of the other goalies that are ahead of them on this list

[@rileywalsh9567]

@@gonuts4donuts isn’t price I little low on the list?

[@alexmurphy5289]

This is really inspiring to watch as a goalie, thanks NHL

[@Sanderus]

Hasek>Brodeur, other than that great video. Brodeur was an excellent goaltender, actually my favourite one, but man, Hasek was something else - in a league of his own. What hurts Hasek in such tops is the fact that for the most part he did not have great defense to help him, unlike Brodeur.

[@BillsFan2024]

My 2 favorite goalies and my 2 favorite teams!

[@billsandiego3385]

Durnan is too high. Sure he was good, but he played during the war years when most of the best players were off fighting WWII. Also Ed Giacomin really needs to be here. Vezina winner, several all star games, was named best goalie of the year several times and he's a hall of famer.

[@nicolelala10]

as a life long Devils fan, and a goalie, Hasek is 1. His style, or lack, thereof, lended itself to stopping the puck at whatever cost. That's how played as an uncoached student of the game. Hasek was amazing in every way, the type of goalie I aspired to be.

[@SerrLou]

How is Roy only 3? The only reason he doesnt have more wins during his time was because there were ties. Broduer played a long time in the NHL where there is no ties. Roy reinvented the game with his butterfly technique. He has more Stanley Cups with multiple teams than Hasek and Brodeur. He also has more Conn Smyth trophies than anybody in NHL history.

[@canuckereh5646]

The butterfly style was not Roy's technique. Glenn Hall (Mr. Goalie) popularized that style of play, originally called the V style. Tretiak, Esposito and others also incorporated it into their game.

[@troutbros3237]

But it took broduer longer to beat his wins record

[@ryanhammock1181]

You could also argue that brodeur’s hybrid style also reinvented the game, btw Roy didn’t invent butterfly, orthodox has been the go to for goalies long before roy

[@brianframe1]

i am goalie .. and with out a shadow of a doubt Hasek and Roy will always in my mind be the best ever,,, Roy 's hart..... Hasek's unbelievable stile there will never be better,, i am from Ireland , and i play in a roller hockey league in Ireland,,,, THATS RIGHT,,,, Ireland lol..... and i find it better if you play DRUNK,, if you play and love Hockey then MY FREIND YOU ARE A LEGEND and i love you

[@WeKeepItSlickAllNite]

Roy

[@rossogden9920]

Once you told us you were from Ireland, it wasn't necessary to tell us that you like to play drunk.

[@debbiesharp9651]

Hextall was fun to watch. Never quite knew how he was going to react...

[@mi_schulz19]

DOMINATOR !!!

[@1521Palm]

Beezer and Felix Potvin should be in the top 40 for sure.

[@elliotrook8118]

Tom Barrasso, brilliant tendy brilliant Coach for the Sheffield Steelers

[@markkoerber6366]

Andy Moog and Mike Vernon surprised me. I also feel Hextall is to low

[@billsandiego3385]

Why both were excellent goalies?

[@klarafiserova8297]

Forget all the stats. Hasek was the best goalie of all time without any questions. And He was the most exciting goalie to watch. He was a game changer. Complete monster!!! No other goalie was in heads of top forwards as Hasek was. When they asked Gretzky of his biggest hockey nightmare... his response was Hasek stealing my dream in Nagano 1998. If Hasek would be able to come to NHL at his early age. He would be number one in all stats among gollies without doubt.

[@djdj2231]

Hašek was maybe the most dominant regular season statistically but he was never the best goalie because he never carried the team to the Stanley Cup titleg Hašek was maybe the most dominant regular season statistically but he was never the best goalie because he never carried the team to the Stanley Cup title

[@JohnnyMnemonic.]

@@djdj2231 with Detroit in 2002 yes. He was the best.

[@ahriman935]

@@yoholmes273 Stats are fueled by the raw number of games played and Hasek was overlooked for several years mostly on account of being Czech. Brodeur has a lot more games to his belt so of course he will be "better" looking at things like number of shootouts or wins.

[@ahriman935]

@@yoholmes273 You have no idea whatsoever what you're talking about. He was drafted in 1983 and the Hawks didn't want to give him a regular spot on the roster because they feared he could be recalled back to Czech Republic (then under Soviet rule) at any moment. It was the case with every other player from "behind the iron curtain". He was first allowed in the NHL game in 1990, when Soviet Union was all but gone and Hasek was already 28 years old. So yes, he was in fact literally overlooked because he was a Czech.

[@ahriman935]

@@yoholmes273 Yeah, sure let's go with that. He was looked. Looked so much he didn't play in NHL until he was almost 30. What's your point?

[@matthurley9236]

I think Hasek is better than Brodeur just brodeur had the much better stats and teams.

[@wuhanjohn4900]

Hasek's stats are light years ahead performance wise

[@matthurley9236]

@@wuhanjohn4900 very true but in his prime I think only Roy in the playoffs was better

[@juanvillamil5950]

All I hear is excuses... Marty is da Goat

[@ulzzangloverxD]

@@juanvillamil5950 Marty isn't even Top 5 man. The most overrated goalie in NHL history is actually Martin Brodeur. Too many people put him at #1 while he is not that if you ask me.

[@ESCfromNome]

Aww, how is Roy not number 1? His ego alone should've won it!

[@erikwaugh1800]

Patrick roy is the greatest goalie of all time

[@114MrCool]

Holtby 2nd fastest to 250 wins and only 38?!

[@dumbdumb572]

You do know these kind of lists aren't set in stone and definitive, right?

[@pierre-ql8yf]

This is probably a couple years old.

[@doaftheloaf]

wait until he's near the end, he'll be higher.

[@UltraViolence90]

Washed up

[@pierrem1381]

They forgot to mention Vladislav Tretiak

[@bigsteed007]

It might not be in the title but it should be assumed that an NHL production would be referring to goalies that played in the NHL.

[@kevmac1230]

Old time goalies should get extra credit for the tiny and crappy equipment they wore.

[@SJSOmar]

Wow no Evgeni Nabokov :(

[@letsgooilers]

He was underrated

[@CKr14]

@@matthewcervino9205 Do you know what underrated means?

[@BOBT3AM]

@@matthewcervino9205 lol the jerk Seth Rollins

[@piratetycollectorguy5608]

The sharks suck. So there's probably the biggest reason there is no Evgeni.

[@malkinmalone]

I hate the ducks but i thought giguere should be on there somewhere. He was the best in the league for a few years.

[@randomdumbness3312]

This video definitely shows why i love the detriot red wings. Im a goalie and i love watching the detroit goalies.

[@realmofjohn]

Roy should be number 1 because no goalie was more clutch and he won stanley cup as the most important player in the 80’s, 90’s and 00’s. He is the greatest goaltender of all time!

[@bb-gc2tx]

billy smith is greatest clutch goalie of all time 4 straight cups and he won 19 straight playoff series no goalie will ever come close to doing that.

[@hellbound64]

Luongo at 18 is a sick joke... Should be in the top 10 for sure, and easily better than quick... Luongo carried the Panthers for years, and the Canucks when he first went there.. flopped in the playoffs a couple times unfortunately but he truly is one of the greats

[@skl4189]

iTz G Banger luongo is not better than quick or hank I’m sorry that’s just insulting to even say that. The guy has also been injured for half of his career so the fact that he’s at 18 is honestly pretty high

[@fredericopinto2943]

Tim Thomas turned Luongo into a puddle

[@billsandiego3385]

Damn, it's insane how Sawchuck managed 100 shutouts in the Era he played in given the equipment, nutrition, physical conditioning, etc. Imagine how dominant he could have been had he played in the 90s.

[@malkinmalone]

Bill Sandiego Yeah i never understand when people talk about how much more athletic guys are now. Its a product of their environment. Theyre still human beings. If Gretzky played today he would be stronger and faster because guys train and diet better now.

[@billsandiego3385]

@@malkinmalone definitely. Today's game is made for guys like Gretzky. With his IQ he'd do very well.

[@dotandme]

Every time I watch these guys at almost 60 years of age all I can think of is your joints are going to kill you in 30 years. You’re great at what you do and you’re fabulous to watch but there’s a price

[@emileplante]

No way belfour should be higher then dryden. Also it’s hard to compare different eras, but i think plante and sawchuk should also both be higher

[@gtfour1462]

Where is Pekka Rinne? IMO he is way better than Holtby

[@Dude-nz6kh]

Holtby’s won more of pretty much everything

[@brandonsartor6150]

And better than kiprusoff and Crawford

[@kristenhoetzel-go1089]

Viljami Mattinen I thought he’d be on the list

[@doaftheloaf]

@@brandonsartor6150 i hope you're kidding.

[@doaftheloaf]

he's too good right now.

[@qwwupp4763]

ya quick is not better than the king 🤷‍♂️

[@RangersCentral]

Facts

[@waderice1499]

Your king has 0 cups, while quick has 2...

[@Kavybtw]

Stanley cup 2014 who won I like both but im a little more of a kings fan

[@spongy508]

QWWUPP he beat him though, didn’t he?

[@qwwupp4763]

Floopaze 97 the kings roster as a whole was far better than the rangers....

[@andrewclarke8630]

NHL record for most saves by a goaltender in their playoff debut (63)? All-time, best-of-seven-series low of ONE goal allowed in entire series (vs MN Wild)? Playoff shutout streak of 217 mins 54 seconds? All-time playoff OT shutout streak of 168 mins 27 seconds? 15-6 record, 1.62 GAA & .945 sv% first season in playoffs? First goaltender since Ron Hextall in '87 & only 5th player *ever* to be awarded the Conn Smythe as member of losing team in SCF? 262-216-25-50, 38 SO, 2.53 GAA, .913 SV% and 33-17 in playoffs with 6 SO 2.08 GAA .925 SV%? Not to mention 2007 Stanley Cup Champion? ...yet not on this invalid list!? J.S. Giguere!!!

[@ItzTrollRoadTo400Subscribers]

Andrew Clarke giguere shouldve been really high i agree prolly before quick

[@seandaly2829]

Roy was why they changed the equipment size rules. I still remember that playoff series against Detroit where we had 70 shots a game and nothing got by him. He was a stud for sure.

[@jtp2007]

Giguere is not one of the best 40 of all time.

[@andrewclarke8630]

@@jtp2007 so where would you rank him then?

[@Sjp977]

Hasek is without a doubt number 1. Even if I wasn’t a lifelong Sabres fan, I’d still think that. Brodeur, Roy and all other goalies will never even be on the same level as the dominator

[@evolancer211]

For me Roy is hands down the best goalie.

[@wesleydevoss135]

Crawford also won in 2010, he was Niemi's backup.

[@jogman262]

No, Cris Huet was.

[@jogman262]

Crawford was called up from Rockford in 2009-2010 and played only one game a loss and then was sent back down. Huet actually started the season as the starting goalie, slumped and Niemi took over as starting goalie.

[@aidenrebel720]

Marc Andre Fleury is my all time idol. Glad to see his well deserved spot on this list.

[@nickrankin6666]

How are Corey Crawford and Tim Thomas ahead of Mike Richter Gary Cheevers and Mike Vernon?

[@TG-nhl]

Because Tim Thomas was a beast

[@ShinAkuma204]

Patrick Roy has to be top 2, if not number 1. He's the only player at any position to win 3 Conn Smythe trophies in 3 different decades.

[@reyjusuf]

Roy's 3 Conn Smythe and 4 Stanley Cups are better than Hasek's 2 Harts and 2 Stanley Cups. Legends are made in the playoffs, not in the regular season.

[@bradleyhenry2411]

Cups is a team award. Roy's 3 Conn Smythes & 3 Vezinas vs Hasek's 2 Harts, 2 Lester Pearsons, & 6 Vezinas... and you'd still choose Roy?

[@bradleyhenry2411]

@Murphy Habs I acknowledge that Roy revolutionized the position, but Hasek literally carried the Sabres to playoff positions hence the 2 Harts and Lester Pearson's. Also carried Czech to a gold on olympics. He has the best goalie stats too. Roy has pretty much always had the better team in front of him, so he's never really had to carried.

[@bradleyhenry2411]

@Murphy Habs both 86 and 93 Habs teams were better than any Sabres team Hasek had though. Everyone agrees those Sabres teams weren't playoff teams without Hasek. Hasek even came into the league late and still put up monster stats.

[@michaelgriffiths8068]

How is Grant Fuhr not in the top 10?? He was regarded almost unanimously as the best goaltender of the 1980s.

[@mattgrant57]

Marty...in 93-94 he walked into the Devil's office and did the same job over and over again almost to ad nauseam, sometimes. Loyal, Company man.

[@matthewhiggins8851]

Bunny LaRocque was a backup goalie!

[@splotbang8296]

Gilles Villemure, Gilles Gilbert, Eddie Johnston and a few others could take Bunny's place on this list.

[@harryballz9486]

This list can be argued about all day, but tretiak should be on it regardless that he didn’t play in the nhl. He’s in the hhof!!

[@broadstreetbullies849]

Im glad my idol Tim Thomas made the list. But I honestly think Tuukka Rask should have made it too

[@francoispitre6292]

Jacques Plante should be first not only did he changed the game he had an unbeleivable career and was good in 2 era also few people remember that Jacques Plante first game comeback after a 2 year retirement was vs the Soviets for a Canadian team made of Montreal Juniors and a couple of NHL players. they beat the Soviets 2 to 1 Plante was simply miraculous in that game stopping 3 consecutive breakaways in the final minutes.

[@STNeish]

Great list... though I think I'd rate a few lower (eg. Barrasso, Osgood, etc.) simply because they were great because of their team. For instance, Barrasso had a whole plethora of hall of famers in front of him, from Lemieux and Jagr, to Francis and more.

[@STNeish]

Oh, and Price and Fleury should have placed higher on this list. They're both utterly incredible goalies.

[@letsgooilers]

Eventough i am a oilers fan i got to say Kiprusoff should have been higher. He was so underrated and I think the biggest reason why he was so low on this list is because he didnt win a cup.

[@bobkloth57]

It’s crazy to think that the goalies used to play without a face mask. Gump Worsley had a face that only his mother could love.

[@dominicgoudos5859]

putting Tim thomas before Chris Osgood is absurd

[@joshmeads]

Should have showed the Kipper Kid doing his pre game impression. 👍😊

[@MarcoCostantini33]

Grant fuhr is the most underrated goalie of all time

[@billsandiego3385]

In my opinion Terry Sawchuk is the best because he managed 100 shutouts while battling physical and mental issues his entire career l

[@rediscoveryrecords1348]

How can anyone of rhe goalies from 39-32 who played some 15-20 years be behind a backup goalie for 8 years??

[@calebowman9782]

If I had to pick a backstop for 4 rounds of playoffs, it'd be Roy

[@patrickdouglas2171]

Brodeur doesn't even belong in the top 5. He played a long time, which is why he has great stats, but he rarely had any real shots against him. He has some of the lowest shots against of any goalie. He played behind one of the best defensive systems of all time. Not to say he wasn't great, he was. But he is not a top 5 goalie.

[@CaptainNoah0512]

Best comment on here

[@StarfighterTV]

Finally some love for my man luongo

[@billsandiego3385]

Dude is a future hall of famer for sure

[@ShadowSabrewulf]

Hey congrats to Fleury becoming the third goaltender in NHL History to 500 Wins

[@charleynewman4783]

Definitely a hall of famer

[@tyvla3192]

I think that’s a pretty great ranking

[@skl4189]

Alex Vela agreed. Most unbiased I think nhl network has been in a ranking list

[@yadamsurensh4003]

Where’s Vladislav Tretyak? He’s all time best in history of ice hockey

[@mdsupreme1776]

Osgood was a boss

[@dmonsef]

Not even close! Osgood won Cups with some super loaded Red Wings teams. Wings could have won some of their Cups with a backup goalie.

[@vitnemec8365]

@@dmonsef Ozz was no AAA superstar, but definitely a reliable workhorse. (Also, funnily enough, Wings did won their last cup with a backup goalie.)

[@master5990]

Yeah my boy Price in the top 25!! Shoulda be higher but it's ok! Still good guy!

[@skl4189]

saeed patel over rated

[@tonybleau6219]

@2021Alexis Mahoney he never had a team with the ability to do so. It's a team game and he has an MVP award which is insane for a goalie and much more rare than a cup

[@johnnyslokes2712]

Why isn't Chris Osgood in the Hall of Fame if he's considered an all time great goalie?

[@mikekeeler6362]

If Ken Dryden would have played 20 years it would have won 600 games

[@AviLOrkQ]

10 on 40 for the Habs!💪 We developp goalies!

[@womensrightsgaming9795]

Then why are u so bad bruins fan Btw this is a joke

[@justindecker9282]

Ur one of the oldest teams u had plenty of time

[@AviLOrkQ]

@@justindecker9282 Montréal Canadiens is not A hockey club, it's THE hockey club. Club older than the league they play in! We even won cups before NHL even exist. There is 2 clubs in hockey world, Canadiens and CSKA Moscow. Half of history of that sport comes from those clubs.

[@conbomb4877]

Skipped till the end just to make sure Marty was #1. And of course he was, who else is better.

[@sofiafiore3596]

How does quick make it but not Pekka Rinne

[@string7135]

Sofia Fiore yeah

[@glennhagstedt]

Pekka should be on the list but cmon Quick has two SICK stanley cup runs.

[@doaftheloaf]

because quick was better than rinne. this isn't a debate.

[@CaptainNoah0512]

The real way to settle this debate is if you had a one game winner wins all, who are you putting in front of the net? I'm going with Hasek.

[@justindecker9282]

Actually make it make sense and I got Marty

[@Lige]

Sawchuk

[@The_Architekt]

1 Hasek 2 Brodeur 3 Roy

[@davidmeyer6500]

Vote: Brodeur

[@SonicDX22]

3 and 1 are mixed up

[@sharangoalvich]

SonicDX22 stop joking

[@codylambert7539]

Make room for Marc Andre

[@jordangoulet6536]

Patrick Roy should be number 1 in my opinion but love brodeur.

[@tyronewhite918]

What sucks for Price, is he was/is such a good goaly, and he played with people who tooked him for granted.

[@bb-gc2tx]

best goalie ive ever see at anticipating where the shot would be coming from

[@justindestafney]

Hasek and Roy were better than Brodeur. I'd put Hasek at 1 and Roy at 2 . After that it's hard to rank.

[@lucarossi8913]

JustinD98 no they weren’t

[@justindestafney]

@@lucarossi8913 Brodeur is a legend definitely top 10 probably even top 5, but he only faced 40+ shots 31 times in his career which is only ranked 40th.No disrespect but, Brodeur benefited from a good defense and his stats were high because of a long career. At least I'll say he's the best stick handling goalie of all-time.

[@sharangoalvich]

JustinD98 You Are Stupid

[@justindestafney]

@@sharangoalvich I meant no disrespect to Marty, it's just a matter what style I prefer.

[@helloface001]

"They hated him because he told the truth"

[@donaldjacques7962]

I don't know the judges, but I think a lot of fans who actually seen most of these goalers, would put Jacques plante first.

[@iTzPommer]

Ryan Miller

[@adcpf1844]

Chris Osgood should be higher on this list. He doesn't get the respect he deserves. Cujo is way too high on this list.

[@louisrobitaille5810]

#40 Ahhh c'est lui le comcombre dans Le But de Loco Locass 😮 (For Non-French Speakers: Ohhh, that's the "comcombre"(cucumber) in the song "Le But by Loco Locass")