3 Internet ads with Sinister Backstories

[@BeingScared]

“Can’t wait to get a new roommate in here to terrorize. They have no idea what they’re in for. I hope they’re okay with murder. Hahahaha!! No smoking though. That shi*s nasty.”

[@leecebby7056]

🗣😂

[@tylerhollenbeck4276]

Now remember those are wine stains

[@lukebingus9432]

Being Scared is so dope!!!!

[@Vomikaust]

Glad to see you on here bro

[@dennis.bonner]

The fact that i drove passed the house a few weeks ago is crazy

[@amandahoffman6912]

That mother from the last story is beyond stupid. She should’ve met the person in a public place instead of giving her address to a stranger🤦🏻‍♀️

[@hkpmeme]

No frfr I thought I was the only one that was confused 🤔 because that’s common sense…

[@BrownEyes96]

Seriously. There's no way I would give out my address like that, ESPECIALLY with children in the house. Fuck, I wouldn't even be on Craigslist looking for child care.

[@mendingwall3823]

The whole purpose of meeting the person first is to vet them and make sure it is safe. Everyone should know to do that in a public place. I swear some people shouldn't breed.

[@carljohnson2194]

Yeah

[@KezVanBeck]

@@carljohnson2194 ain’t you Beverly Johnson’s boy ?

[@ramstab]

Hey! Nice vid as always! You should contact the PC guy who had a crazy landlord and threw his rig in the tub, would make for a great story! The landlord basically thought the guy, who basically lived with a friend of his, were government agents and were spying on him. And after days with internet cuts and such, the guy broke into his room and trashed everything!

[@agentcorgi2995]

The fact that he had 2 rooms for storage is a hell of a red flag…

[@MsTinkerbelle87]

I forgot your name for the longest time hahaha I’m so happy I found your stories again!! I watch way too many of these channels, anyone have this “problem” lol it doesn’t help that all spooky stories have the same look to them 😆

[@The-Rose-and-the-Cross]

'and even invited them around for dinner' Oh boy.

[@intervein1]

lol

[@miaseiler26]

*tastes meats* oh! What meat is this? I haven't had this meat before.....

[@ThatLoud3v]

@@miaseiler26 lol

[@nate8525]

😂😂

[@The-Rose-and-the-Cross]

@@miaseiler26It was 'long pig'

[@heatherkline3048]

I will NEVER understand why anyone would go to Craigslist looking for someone to watch their kids…NEVER! I get that some people don’t have family or anyone to help them, but Craigslist?? Come on!! 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@navillion]

The first one could have easily just been a misconception. The red could have easily been wine, the belongings in his room could be chalked up to something laundry related and him getting mad at the roommate going into his room could just be privacy concerns. It would’ve been confirmed if the person actually checked out the basement before leaving.

[@wisygirlywopitty770]

If horror movie told me one thing : Never. Go. In. The. Basement. Better stay alive with a misunderstanding than dead with the truth....

[@avalasialove]

I agree that the red stains could have been wine especially since Todd was acting intoxicated. But what about the midnight curfew?

[@squashedshibber2684]

yeah the guy being drunk seems like maybe the dude is just an alcoholic possibly

[@beethovenpalattao2770]

Still feel suspicious especially in that 12:00 curfew rule!And the fact that he go to he’s room and angrily telling him that he knew that he wondered into the basement!He should’ve called the police in the first place because it’s so fishy!!!

[@jesselewin2096]

The scariest thing is to see a craigslist ad then go to the person's house with them planning to kill you when you least expect it

[@fulltimecatholic1994]

its hard to comprehend though.

[@jesselewin2096]

@@fulltimecatholic1994 ye but ya know you gotta be on guard to protect yourself

[@fulltimecatholic1994]

@@jesselewin2096 Yeah..except I don't use a craigslist.

[@jesselewin2096]

@@fulltimecatholic1994 o ok lol

[@fulltimecatholic1994]

@@jesselewin2096 I wouldn't use that thing because I feel scarier after seeing this one.

[@SalusFuturistics]

Unlocking a Door with a Fingernail... Is that the creepiest looking Nail, or the flimsiest Lock?

[@SunBunz]

Can you imagine being at your neighbor’s house for dinner, and later found out they were a murderer and cannibal?! I’d be like, “WTF DID WE EAT?!??”

[@ZeXiOn26]

If you ever need a good excuse to move, just reply to a sketchy Craigslist ad

[@bunniesarecutel0l250]

Thank you for getting me through hours of studying (:

[@harleyhoffman4752]

"infant care available" "i do not deal with babies" um an infant is a baby lol

[@fenudel2734]

Fun fact: there‘s a Rammstein song about the cannibalism incident (Mein Teil). It‘s really good, esp live.

[@chloe42000]

Lyrically one of the most metal rammstein songs of all

[@manasvibarthwal5249]

Mr nightmare start those series like top 10 horror stories series ( ghost encounters , paranormal )

[@pumkin54]

I really don't understand why the first guy would go into the bedroom, take his stuff, and then lock the door again behind him. He might as well have written a note that said, "Heyo, I was in here!"

[@joshuastreet6056]

Shit; it’s been months for me since I last watched or heard a mr nightmare horror story and being back with the mr nightmare fan squad. Good to be back and finally listening to these stories like I used to.

[@austinmckeen9910]

"unlocked the door with his fingernail" excuse me, how long is your fingernail?

[@ChristelVinot]

I used to use craigslist all the time in the early 2000s. Found some great living situations. No complaints.

[@-timestar-]

In including the kitchen"like boi you hungry?

[@tiffany-tn7ue]

idk if it counts for the cannibal guy bc technically the victims were .. consenting ? and agreed to be eaten 😭

[@Dragneels_--]

I use to watch these with my mom and brother when I was younger my mom ended up leaving us

[@OllzOGloc]

Who else waits for him to upload a few vids so when you come back you can binge them for at least a hour or 2 💯🤔😂

[@JoeleReeves-zq8qd]

Another amazing upload

[@ShortHax]

What’s more unsettling than the ads is how the Craigslist site practically hasn’t changed from a decade ago

[@DavidCrypt]

yea fr whats up with that

[@jambo360]

Yea

[@dizzy_mon8777]

Yep

[@reeceschrock396]

Nooo

[@notmaru]

over 2 decades at this point lmao

[@elem_nt]

Even as an 18 year old guy I could never understand wanting a completely random person to babysit your children, nonetheless a sketchy craigslist ad.

[@MustacheCashStash125]

Exactly, she should’ve had a family member or friend babysit them. Also some red flags are that it said “infant care provider”, “I’ve had 7+ years of experience looking after babies and toddlers”, and “I’ll only babaysit kid between 5-9 years old”. If an add has mistakes in it, that often means it’s bad.

[@DreemyDreemz]

I'm 17 and have absolutely no way to become pregnant or a plan to, but I completely agree. Why tf would you let a complete stranger watch your children?? I get not having family members, but idk maybe have your friends watch them???.

[@DreemyDreemz]

@@MustacheCashStash125 yeah that's sus

[@MustacheCashStash125]

@@DreemyDreemz kzbin.info/www/bejne/g4HMdnR_areHga8

[@southeastindependentsocial330]

@@DreemyDreemz Craigslist babysitter is imp lol

[@isitoveryet9525]

“Infant care available” “Must be between 5-9 years old, I do not deal with with toddlers or young babies”

[@cottoncandace7704]

Lol

[@mirukosimp6072]

exactly i was like -_-

[@cardhoncho9878]

Yeah even that was a red flag to me

[@haranguemeringue8957]

Yeah, that threw me too. Definite red flag. 😬

[@Yew_chube]

She’s into shota and loli

[@Kresteloona]

“Infant childcare available” “I do not deal with babies”

[@MrBob2212]

Glad I’m not the only one

[@samb7370]

Yep I wondered if anyone else noticed… red flag missed. poor woman.

[@ExplorerDS6789]

Guess they don't like changing diapers.

[@MarvinEnigma]

Ikr! Red Flag! Lol :)👌

[@MyPS4IsOnFirePleaseHelp]

10/10 IGN, Recommended babysitter 100%

[@nono-yg3ip]

The scariest part is actually how James somehow locks and unlocks doors WITH HIS FINGERNAIL.

[@BZR330]

Right?!?

[@Synth466]

I do that when my nails get real long 😭

[@onthefridge-w7p]

Its not that hard if its one of those weird slit locks

[@SphericalNervousSystem]

I have like one of those slit locks on my bathroom door, but it long since been a little damaged. It can be done but it takes a lot of effort and it’ll scratch up my nail real bad. So I just use a coin to get it open.

[@rosalamariposa]

had these locks in my house but i used a penny. if i was deadass lazy i could easily unlock doors with a fingernail, so yeah, it's literally a common lock. inside the house. not outside. obviously outside the house we had real locks

[@logicsinatra134]

if i’m paying $900 for renting a room, there’s no way in hell i’m letting my roommate give me a curfew…

[@Shadowwind4]

That’s the real horror of this whole video

[@TheArmedNurse]

100% Like I would've been like "Excuse me? I am paying $900/month for a ROOM and you're telling me when I need to be in bed? Thank you, but no thank you."

[@tafsibhuiyan8730]

@@Shadowwind4 fr 😂😭🤣😆

[@inctz2627]

900 for a room is absolute bollocks 💀😂 that’s how much I pay for my house a week

[@Diablothefurry]

I will gladly if random “wine” stains was leading from the basement ☠️

[@jjust8220]

“Lets not inform the police about this, I guess we will never know what happened” - probably the guy from the first story

[@rbmiddleton1979]

Exactly

[@juliuskingsley4434]

That's usually the easiest way to tell real stories vs made up ones.

[@davidl570]

Just read my friggin' mind! I dunno.........................it's a nice creepy story but I think it's fabricated...................overall it seems too implausible for me. Gotta take some of these stories with a grain of salt, after all.

[@carpeomniavisuals3780]

exactly like if this were true why wouldnt you call the police lol

[@Uriejkdks]

@Ah vamo nessa - and the fact he waited to leave two days after finding the blood anyone in there right mind would leave immediately or at least the next morning

[@morganbrick9837]

"I saw red stains on the floor-" GET THE HECK OUT OF THAT HOUSE!!!

[@vl2663]

Yeah for real I would’ve just gotten my stuff and got out through the window

[@zachschannel6161]

@@vl2663you think that only in the movies people are so dumb and naive when it comes to sensing real danger. But no, there really are morons out there like this smh🤦‍♂️

[@john_toss]

I would expect every ad on Craigslist or Marketplace to be on some level of sketchiness

[@billymays5072]

You may be right... But come on... It's free.

[@john_toss]

@@billymays5072 that free ps5 pictured in a dirty basement do be tempting

[@schemar17]

@D wow you got the good ending bro

[@Arizmi]

@D based reference

[@MrScalzo13]

it's like walking into a pawn shop

[@Fujiforker]

I think the scariest part of story 1 was that someone was willing to pay $900 to rent a damn bedroom

[@davidl570]

Yeah, no kidding! What a ripoff--the guy must've been loaded.

[@lrobinbrown6522]

It happens especially in a city. It’s criminal. Just can’t live alone unless high paying six figure job

[@bleh3039]

That’s super cheap in Los Angeles I wish rent was that cheap here, most apartments are between 1500 to 2000 a month.

[@chloel.8007]

This story probably took place in California lol

[@Joolenplus]

Probably took place in NYC or Cali

[@Solitude1990]

What’s truly terrifying is that there are people out there trusting strangers they hired on Craigslist to take care of their young children. Parents seriously need to stop trusting strangers with their young kids

[@TheOmniMic]

... and sometimes people they know.

[@AmBeruSPriMeX]

"And she was looking for an affordable trustworthy babysitter. She found this ad on Craigslist..." mistake number one 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@PunishMeDaddy]

2nd was giving her address before even meeting the person especially someone from craigslist

[@rbmiddleton1979]

The third was when the heffa actually came to the house and she waited until the person left to call the police instead of then and there when the incident was happening smh

[@katiechisholm]

Right?! Exactly. Y’all need to stay your asses off of Craigslist. I’d rather find my babysitter on Facebook marketplace than Craigslist

[@yhmanwag1]

@@katiechisholm i actually kinda trust facebook marketplace wierdly

[@ariell6489]

Some ppl are unbelievably stupid.

[@kai-ug4os]

"the house was a modest size" *proceeds to show a spacious house*

[@cassidyingersoll6081]

The third guy be like: “looking to provide care for infants and toddlers but also between the ages of 5-9 because I don’t like babies”

[@weewooweewoo906]

yeah i was reading that like ??? your title literally says infant care available and then halfway through your listing you say 5-9 year olds only. sketch from the getgo

[@STVNR]

@@weewooweewoo906 what does the get go mean

[@PunishMeDaddy]

@Jocelyn Bokano getgos are small lizards

[@weewooweewoo906]

@@STVNR from the beginning

[@bluepearl4624]

@@PunishMeDaddy Sir that’s a Gecko-

[@silentyandere9704]

it's very disturbing once it sinks and you realize how horrifying it actually is

[@reokagro]

its more funny then scary

[@222wesker]

@@reokagro huh

[@ellarose2044]

@@reokagro how

[@riahawks]

@@reokagro ikr!

[@callitfatecallitkarma]

@@reokagro ur edgy we get it

[@chunkertv3940]

Sadly, I’ve heard a story about a man who wanted to have a roommate. The man that showed up was very creepy, but the man already accepted. A few days later, the creepy man left and the guy was never seen again. This happened 3 blocks from my house.

[@beethovenpalattao2770]

What happened now?Did the police investigated this?!

[@taavi948]

@@beethovenpalattao2770these stories are real?

[@carinarosales6899]

Wow did the police ever investigate what happened to the guy?

[@hkpmeme]

Im not trying to judge the lady that went through Craigslist for a baby sitter, but it’s really hard not to….. 👁👄👁

[@katielynn8093]

It’s hard getting a job nowadays might as well post an ad🤣

[@ComaLies225]

I'm on the same boat. I really wanted to shake her like "WHY WOULD YOU GIVE THIS RANDO YOU HAVEN"T EVEN VETTED YOUR FRIGGIN ADDRESS!?!?!?!?"

[@SergioLeonardoCornejo]

Craigslist is as reliable as a politician.

[@natalieshepp641]

Why TF would u look at craigslist for a babysitter??? Geezus!!

[@MrScalzo13]

aren't grandparents willing candidates anymore for babysitters?

[@richiegarciaflores3020]

Every day after a long stressful day at school and I see mr.nightmare posted I jump of excitement

[@sam-dh3vp]

he makes me forget i’m failing classes :D nooo but i love his stories :)

[@jushlastnameunknown7145]

Ikr, it’s the only thing that helps me after a stressful day after school.

[@savannahfrancois]

Same for realll

[@richiegarciaflores3020]

@@jushlastnameunknown7145 yes It helps me relax

[@gaigelocascio2846]

Same

[@SaraBethSingsxo]

My mom's reaction to Mr. Nightmare was much better than anticipated. She said they were very educational and she was glad we were watching them :) Seriously thinking of showing these to my kids someday and then discussing what the lessons were XD

[@greyscalejedi2151]

I think it’s a great idea. A ton of good lessons in these stories

[@FaxAboutBasketball]

Yeah bro. As a kid the videos teach you what to do if somebody’s trynna hurt you.

[@banderas2000]

THAT'S A good point. i mean some ppl need to listen .

[@rey469]

"infant care available" "i do not deal with babies"

[@MrTrombonebandgeek]

I mean in a scientific sense these are two different terms, baby 0-2 years toddler 2-4 years infant

[@jaebyrd4608]

@@MrTrombonebandgeek but the person also said they had experience with toddlers and babies but then I don't deal with toddlers or babies 🤦‍♀️

[@misterbearmore4633]

@@MrTrombonebandgeek But baby and infant are used interchangeably.

[@MrTrombonebandgeek]

@@misterbearmore4633 in a day to day sense yes

[@Keznen]

Instant contradiction

[@apinyasusai]

How could a mother trust a stranger on CL to babysit her twin. Gosh, how on earth is she thinking?

[@metamorphstorm]

My one Craigslist experience: I listed a guitar for $100, someone came to get it, they paid, all was fine, lol

[@davidl570]

Damn, that's scary! You should send your story to Mr. Nightmare.

[@robinpreston5358]

My one Craigslist experience was trying to buy an XBox and being spammed with CP videos from the guys email. I had to get a new email and call the police

[@lunachan1805]

@@robinpreston5358 yoooo wtf??

[@robinpreston5358]

@@lunachan1805 yep! Never have used Craigslist for even buying furniture after

[@Doodles1265]

@@robinpreston5358 *CRAIGLIST IS SO 2009!*

[@raynbowponicorn]

“There were no wood floors, it was all carpet. Even the living room and the bedrooms.” Has this dude ever been in a house? Which other rooms would be carpeted??

[@Takeninthelight]

I've seen uncarpeted living rooms to be fair. Probably meant that there wasn't ANY hardwood floors, just worded weirdly.

[@AshysWolfie19]

My room isn't carpeted 😅

[@tekbarrier]

The inside of my refrigerator is carpeted

[@t.g.7180]

It would make more sense to have linoleum floors. Easier to clean 😁

[@ravynsong5799]

My house has zero carpet, it's all hardwood or tile. But, yeah, plenty of homes have carpeted bedrooms and livingrooms. Not sure why that was weird enough for him to take note of and mention as part of the story. How many homes has this James guy ever been in???

[@hasysolo]

🍬 for anyone that sees this comment.

[@shessweepy]

6 likes top comment, bravo.

[@itzmchi3332]

YAAYYY

[@absolutenonsense6121]

The funniest thing is that Armin became a vegetarian while in prison.

[@isid902]

Noooo Armin Arlert eat Bertholt and became collosal titan😏😏

[@AshWillams]

@@isid902 kurapika

[@nexozeldris7707]

You guys still watch anime? It’s 2021 grow up.

[@dogeki113r]

@@nexozeldris7707 pp

[@Kc-rq9jp]

@@nexozeldris7707 you still worried about what others do? Time for you to grow up

[@catblack4000]

I'm impressed by first story he unlocked the door with his fingernail lol

[@JessCh_37]

Yah that honestly kinda sounds painful XD

[@tafsibhuiyan8730]

Same lol

[@Cooldudelol514]

Some doors in my house can be unlocked by a finger too

[@gracie3856]

if you have a longish nail then you can easily unlock doors, if not you just use a knife

[@JessCh_37]

@@porygina-s oh wow

[@cyn6123]

If I remember correctly, that Armen guy had total consent from the man he killed and consumed. I think he filmed the process, and even had one or two suitors before the actual guy he ate who, when they said they changed their mind he let them leave no harm no foul. And when the police came to him, he willingly gave them all of the evidence and showed them where he stored the meat. He could have been a worse guy.

[@baxtersmom279]

Casefile podcast did an episode about that case and yes, if I recall, it was an agreement between the two. Still effed up, though.

[@carinarosales6899]

That guy must of been suffering from mental problems

[@pascalreturns]

Never disappointing. Another amazing upload!

[@khalidhassan9423]

a

[@sladetuner8661]

i would agree! #MrNightmare

[@petra1220]

checkmark

[@V8ZN]

Dead KZbin channel.

[@mysticsaru8577]

Upload more

[@redheadwithafierytemper5668]

I have always wondered how people can have roommates. Way to creepy to live with strangers. I can barely live with people I love,much less creepy or annoying strangers. No thanks.

[@ladycountess2972]

I think youd seriously dig RezTKF if ur into scary stories an stuff like that at night 💯😺🔥🔥🔥👍

[@M50A1]

Not to like give you shit but??? Sus

[@mattwalters6834]

Some people are comfortable with it; I’m personally not a fan of it but I guess I would if I had to.

[@saturnsextilevenus]

it's awkward at first tbfh and somewhat scary but of they're good people and you get along then you become friends quickly and then its chill

[@redheadwithafierytemper5668]

@@saturnsextilevenus I'm hard to live with aside from my kids so I can't even imagine how it would be for a stranger to have to live with me. Plus I would probably end up with someone even worse than me.

[@jazminharris6699]

“Infant care available” + “experience caring for infants/toddlers” “Children must be between the ages 5-9 years old” That could’ve been a little bit of a red flag. Infants and toddler are ages 0-3 years. So why would she limit the age from 5-9 years. That is A HUGE difference in age and development within a child.

[@hyperion3145]

I mean, it's relevant experience and people are allowed to hate babies and toddlers. My question is why offer infant care for non infants

[@amirgarcia547]

Moral of the story: always be super dubious of Criagslist ads since 85% of the time, they are sketch as hell.

[@scee8474]

@Chillbayne okay?

[@scee8474]

@Chillbayne the fact that you didn’t get what I meant lol

[@scee8474]

@Chillbayne the fact that you didn’t get what I meant lol

[@scee8474]

@Chillbayne the fact that you didn’t get what I meant lol

[@scee8474]

@Chillbayne the fact that you didn’t get what I meant lol

[@SoCalRegisteredNurse]

There really needs to be a change in stalking and harassment laws. I hear far too often that police won’t help until the perpetrator actually physically does something. How about going and talking to the perp and getting them on your radar?

[@Taylor.Nicole]

I completely agree.

[@t.g.7180]

And even when they’ve been physically assaulted, cops still have some reason not to do anything.

[@AC-os1he]

Cops never have the time to help anyone, they do however have time to spend 8 hours a day parked in a corner just waiting to give out a ticket.

[@RipleysSanatorium]

Contact your local congressman, they make the state laws.

[@Deathtank75]

sounds easy right? well, it's not! what can you do when you have nothing to know the location of such person????

[@LamborghiniDiabloSVPursuit]

Giving your actual address to a stranger you have literally never met, on the shadiest part of the internet. That woman strikes me as the same person who'd fall for the "Apple automatically censors your credit card details" joke.

[@billyt8868]

“hey i totally saw blood stains but i’m not going to do anything about it. feel sorry for me”

[@aj.1103]

I cant wait for his Halloween horror stories

[@stretch6954]

Sick pfp man 🤟🏻

[@aj.1103]

@@stretch6954 thanks

[@CorvetteZO6.]

Me too Buddy

[@t.g.7180]

Ikr? Why do we like to scare ourselves 😂

[@sladetuner8661]

I believe the next video that Mr.Nightmare should do should be Scary Labor Day/ and or Weekend Stories #MrNightmare #ScaryStories

[@jeffreese1828]

The cannibal : " This is just something I wanted to do for a long time." Bucket List 1. See Paris 2. Visit Yosemite 3. Eat someone

[@chamberlainallman3242]

Who's in Paris?

[@xtrasaucy7079]

Who is in Paris?

[@jeffreese1828]

@Xtra Saucy Just this little number I met online named Mona Lisa . I've just been dying to eat her....I mean meet her , meet her ! Did I say eat ? Lol

[@Koko24250]

4. Taking a hike 5. Dumping the remains 6. Go skydiving

[@DustyChannel517]

Tbf he was pretty much as ethical as a cannibal can be. Before the guy he actually ate, someone else responded to ad and went to his house. The volunteer backed out once he was actually there and homeboy let him leave no questions asked. He only was willing to go through with someone who was 100% willing. The most ethical cannibal would be the dude who had tacos made out of his foot.

[@otterinaballgown3703]

Cannibal Ad: "Possibly offensive." That's a safe bet, dude.

[@katherinepeace3564]

5:00 WHY? Why does I have to remain a mystery why couldn't he report it to the authorities

[@rebelbby2002]

fun fact, there is actually a song based on Armin and his cannibal case! it's called Mein Teil and it's from the German band Rammstein it's a pretty good song actually and eerie lyrics too.

[@nightmarishcompositions4536]

Metal bands always make horror stories sound awesome haha.

[@moocyfarus8549]

I have loved Rammstein four decades and for that reason stay away from all the potential politics and media about their music, but I have to say I've always loved that song and this fun fact is very interesting thank you for sharing

[@heavymetalredneck7973]

Slayer wrote the 213 song about Jeffrey Dahmer..

[@m00nrac00n]

@@moocyfarus8549 Good call, as a native german - there are some goofy news about them out there, especially the lead singer...

[@ladycountess2972]

Omg girl if u like scary stories check out RezTKF his channel is amazing an his voice is perfect for horror narration I swear its one of my new faves for sure 😺👌❤🔥🔥🔥💯

[@Hopischwopi]

When that guy admited in german (my native language) that he murdered, slaughtered and ate his victim I felt a chill down my spine. Like hearing about it before was unsetteling but hearing him say that in the language I grew up with made it kinda more real. Brains are weird.

[@inctz2627]

How do you mean exactly?

[@Hopischwopi]

@Iron Guard HH that must feel weird right?

[@m00nrac00n]

Ja, true. Der Typ ist so scary, man merkt 0 Reue oder so, wie kann man so jemanden frei rumlaufen lassen ?! Richtig klassischer Psychopath, 0 Emphatie.

[@johnhigbie1038]

That story is actually real though, and cannibal cafe was a real dark web forum

[@Hopischwopi]

@@johnhigbie1038 I know it was real. And probably something similar still is real or multiple things like that. Humans are just scary.

[@Matmul_]

Me: *literally in the process of laying down* Mr. Nightmare: no

[@Lunni-toonies]

Same-

[@Opana223]

You can do both

[@fletcher667]

Nice pfp

[@yourfriendlyneighbourhoodb7585]

@@Opana223 do you know the consequences that would unleash.

[@tomtom2142]

You should do Omegle stories I swear I can’t even count the number of times that I ran into pedos on that site

[@sususaleh8589]

he should do shein ones 2

[@veeishotter5641]

ohh definitely

[@AnguishedMan]

like discord mods

[@thatmadlad5381]

Yes, experienced it myself, and I counted 6 in a few days time, but that was months ago

[@tomtom2142]

@@AnguishedMan yeah same discord can be pretty creepy especially if you join a public server

[@humanmusic]

"easily unlocked by his fingernail". My GOD! This is the work of Shakespeare himself! BRAVO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@davidl570]

Move over, Macgyver!

[@decereignsantiago1795]

Pls don't use God's name in vain even in expression, even if you don't believe in him..what you say can still be sensitive to us, pls use another expression thank u✝️✝️

[@nikklaus6333]

@@decereignsantiago1795 Not to start a war... but religious people are known for not caring much about other people's sensitivity (or lives, for the matter) so yeah, I'll keep saying god's name in vain

[@lumenla]

@@nikklaus6333 that’s quite the generalization. not all Of us are like that sister or brother , no hate at all but please don’t use gods name 💗

[@white52]

@@lumenla yahweh lmao

[@Kingkillersstripe632]

James should have went down the basement and saw what was down there and it wouldn't have to be a mystery at all

[@crit1kal_z]

Or called the police

[@carljohnson2194]

Or called the police

[@joshku7488]

I'm sure the old guy was prepared for snooping people. Probably had cameras in there.

[@nate8525]

Naw he should of called the cops 🤦🏾‍♀️🤦🏾‍♀️

[@carljohnson2194]

@@nate8525 he can explore if he is brave enough

[@LeakyTrees]

“He was always so nice” - everyone who’s ever known a murderer ever

[@elansleazebaggano429]

The best feeling ever is chilling on a Friday night listening to mr nightmare:

[@12nothugs]

how about nexpo

[@Doodles1265]

@@12nothugs *YES-* It's a great feeling.

[@crizpychicken8125]

POV it’s October and mr night mare posted a vid

[@Fins17]

me: planning a peaceful night mr nightmare: i’m bout to end this mans whole night

[@outsxder]

Wow you had this copy and pasted ready lol

[@wryzx]

Shut up

[@EphemeralProductions]

lmao! love it. :)

[@Tori-zk2di]

Yesssss😭

[@doodlemanz8679]

Rip peaceful night

[@leogeck7350]

To be "fair", Armin's victim gave consent and Armin knows he is disturbed. There's a very interesting documentary about his case. Honestly, I have more empathy for this guy than for many, many, many other killers/abusers who got a slap on the wrist for their crimes.

[@bonkobonko6707]

Very true,

[@briannamendoza7405]

Likewise. I’ve watched his interviews and he’s very aware of his mental state. Personally, I don’t think he should’ve been arrested since it was consensual but then again 🤷‍♀️

[@marquisdelafayette1929]

@@briannamendoza7405 Same. I can’t believe he got LWOP considering that in most of Europe it seems if he abducted someone and murdered him he would have been given a lighter sentence with parole. I have no doubt this was a political “career maker” case and when the government is determined to get you, they will get you.

[@vsnature7146]

Assisted suiside is also a crime. Therefor it makes sense that murdering someone, and eating them even if the victim had requested this, would still be a crime.

[@Utubesanarc]

@@vsnature7146 right? What's wrong with these people? This was just too creepy and the guy gave me a bad feeling 🤮

[@Apocketfullofbs]

8:47 huh? She titled her ad INFANT CARE, then proceeded to say she doesn’t deal with babies. What an absolute jackal. She doesn’t know what an infant is obviously. She looks disgusting and scary imho.

[@annaelisavettavonnedozza9607]

I think it’s important to point out that as absolutely horrific as his crime was, it was completely consensual b/w Armin & Berndt. Asfaik, Berndt even had a few failed incidents prior to Brandeis. He had 1 or 2 men come over who chickened out, & Armin, who did not want an unwilling victim, took them home.

[@susi-emily]

"chickened out"? Yeah, because it's really cowardly to decide you don't want to be killed and eaten by a cannibal, no matter how reasonable said cannibal is about it.

[@rosyrue6400]

@@susi-emily LOL I was about to say the same thing. Chickened out? Like it was a dare? Homie we’re talking about consenting to be Jeffrey Dahmer-ed. I don’t think so

[@a_34222]

"Chickened out"? Really?🤐

[@littlegiantj8761]

Imagine fleeing the home of a potential psycho killer without going to the cops. This message brought to you by the "this story is a crock-of-bull" gang.

[@ChristinaFromYoutube]

I wouldn't call the cops. I get the impression you're not American based on that "everyone would snitch even though they weren't even sure" mindset British?

[@ChristinaFromYoutube]

What would you tell the cops anyway? "Well my roommate may have spilled his wine but he might also be a serial killer. I just wanted to let you know i saw a red spot on the carpet. K thanks have a good evening fellas!"

[@littlegiantj8761]

@@ChristinaFromKZbin I'm Texan

[@ChristinaFromYoutube]

@@littlegiantj8761 oh wow lol I didn't realize Texas was known for calling the cops when you're not even sure a crime has been committed. Wild

[@ChristinaFromYoutube]

@@littlegiantj8761 i live in rural western NC and not one person where i live would call the cops over "potential red wine stain" even if the guy was creepy af

[@lovelygirl1730]

For the third story this is why you don’t give out your dam address to strangers on the Internet you meet them in public and do background checks I hope you learned your lesson woman.

[@mendingwall3823]

Exactly. Who would take a chance with 2 young kids at home?

[@bubbaXzone]

@@mendingwall3823 the person in the story did? Some people just don't have trust issues. ME on the other hand question everything!

[@gigachad562]

@@bubbaXzone bro I thought you said you were to busy to answer the phone but you can watch yt all day, I see how it is

[@bubbaXzone]

@@gigachad562 who dis?

[@gigachad562]

@@bubbaXzone it James idiot, loose my #

[@justhaze4855]

One name that seems to pop up alot in these storys is 'Todd" Moral of the story: Don't trust anyone named Todd

[@Meme-zc4cw]

Or Dale. I see that one alot.

[@Joseph-jx9uo]

What's up Todd?:-)

[@zayne_the_anime_boy]

my dads name is Todd lmao

[@that1pokemonYT]

@@zayne_the_anime_boy run. Now.

[@random_fustf733]

I don’t know why, it even seems weird for me personally, but hearing these horror stories helps me deal with stress a lot.

[@pasqualilebowitz7866]

It helps me too

[@goodday2826]

" Ha look at those idiots, glad I'm not as dumb as all of them "

[@random_fustf733]

@@goodday2826 Hmm... yeah that is kinda what I think when I hear these stories. Another thing though, is that the fear that I feel from these stories also soothes me a bit, if that makes sense.

[@xlbpb93]

I think part of it is that it makes me feel like my life's not so bad lol

[@arkham5940]

U just realize there are others that have way more difficulties in their life

[@Avarice297]

I like these more realistic stories or at least the ones that feel more real Mr.Nightmare. Also, long-time subscriber here! Four years and I still love your videos! ^ ^

[@skepticthegreat979]

Same here. The more realistic ones are scarier. 👍

[@applejuice9468]

@@skepticthegreat979 The ones that are plausible are the most scary because probability can happen to you.

[@skepticthegreat979]

@@applejuice9468 That is true

[@halle82is]

I’ve have never been contemplating child care, and thought…. “ Craigslist, that will work!”

[@Emper0rH0rde]

"I've seen blood on the floor of my landlord's house after midnight, and I just discovered he's been stealing my things. I think I'll go to sleep in his house anyway."

[@itscamden8258]

I’ve literally been watching Mr Nightmare since 2016. When I was in 6th grade and now I’m about to graduate highschool. I love him and his videos so much

[@tafsibhuiyan8730]

Lol same except I’m going to HS

[@nightfuryaj7125]

Me too! So crazy how that time flies. I feel like I blinked and suddenly my high school days are almost over

[@man1_luv]

Omg same

[@dorkyllama9184]

Same except I started in 2016 my senior year and now I'm about to get my bachelors

[@nemoquodeus8119]

The idea of that cannibal guy walking around in public honestly doesn't bother me much. At least he cares about consent, that's a helluva lot better than any other killer I've heard of

[@alexanderadavar6439]

"Looking for a trustworthy babysitter" "Found an ad on craigslist"...

[@darthmarco1546]

Don't worry mr. Nightmare we are still staying loyal to you, you are the only person I would go to listen to scary stories

[@Enriquez520]

Much better than most real story channels.

[@Enriquez520]

@super colonel bingus Corpse had some good videos but he’s too busy playing that dumb among us game

[@lrobinbrown6522]

Totally agree

[@darthmarco1546]

I appreciate you guys agreeing with me :-)

[@Rollinstone6]

You freaking ROCK mr.nightmare whoever you may be in this strange world! Seeing a new post from you always adds excitement to my day!

[@RachelRaeRae]

oh my gosh.... your internet adopted too?? ig we r siblings then :)

[@scrow13crow52]

I'm sorry but when it comes to children answering a Craigslist post is probably not to the smartest thing to do. I dont trust alot of people to watch my children. Sad but true. To many sickos..

[@chickennuggets4387]

Even the ones you can trust end up being sick people sometimes which is so scary

[@alphawolf2455]

One of the scariest ads I’ve seen growing up were the Ad Council commercials with drunk driving and asthma attacks.

[@mrst7787]

Affordable infant care available. Only caring for children 5-9. Huh?

[@ellynmer7288]

Exactly. This should have been a red flag

[@gregkareem9824]

When Mr nightmare uploads he makes everyone's day better 💯🥶

[@gixerson8212]

Shut up greg

[@gregkareem9824]

@@gixerson8212 dang what did I do man 😭 that's not very nice

[@Terminal_Apotos]

@@gregkareem9824 Made a Generic ass Comment

[@karacarlson4687]

James should've called the cops! Sent them there to see what was going on.

[@the1p.b.937]

Nobody else finds the, “unlocked the door with his fingernail” thing kind of gross? Lol

[@budgiebirdy]

When you find out the neighbor that invited you over for dinner is a cannibal. 😳

[@Luffy-zj6vm]

And you ate meat that night

[@davidl570]

.....................and it turns out he likes Chantay and fava beans.

[@GiveMeMeatballsImHungry]

In the first one, it makes sense he didn’t allow pets, he didn’t want any pets to find it out.

[@Bluecat-es1km]

But what about the smokers?

[@matcharo]

@@Bluecat-es1km he's old, probably has respiratory issues.

[@beefzombiee]

@@Bluecat-es1km probably just because he’s older and didn’t smoke himself

[@Bluecat-es1km]

Fair point

[@bred8847]

*BUONG*

[@sandrasheets9185]

Every one of these ads had a red flag....and who goes on Craigslist looking for a sitter. Who pays $900 for a room...and the Cannibal...enough said

[@Timothy_ross_]

Mr Nightmare doesn’t know it but he just made my Friday night

[@jessicas6360]

mine tooooo

[@lovelygirl1730]

Cool

[@amandahoffman6912]

Oh ya, slaughtering a persons body and making schnitzel and steaks is very sensible🙄

[@1bingbongtingtong1]

Why would someone even want to die and be eaten like that? Like you could give your body to science when you die, but no, you give yourself to be killed and eaten by some weird mf.

[@jonathanlazauskas4244]

@@1bingbongtingtong1 probably a few screws loose

[@t.g.7180]

@@1bingbongtingtong1 I’ve come to realize that there are some very disturbed individuals in the world.

[@budgiebirdy]

Ad: Please respond if you want to be eaten Also ad: Looking for someone normal

[@raeburnoliver6334]

@@1bingbongtingtong1 likely a suicidal person who has attempted and failed to kill themselves. When you're that desperate to die, you don't care what happens to you after you're dead

[@tomcameron1770]

Why would the woman in the last story give her address to a complete stranger on Craigslist?? I’m sorry to be harsh, but if you play stupid games, you get stupid prizes.

[@viannccaa]

its pretty obvious why, but yeah it wasnt very smart

[@shakka76.]

I wouldn't give my address not even to Jesus Christ himself