MARIAH CAREY - CAUTION [Musician's] Reaction & Review

[@marie-louisedauvergne5708]

Mariah's new album Caution is the best pop r&b album of the last decade. Her vocals are phenomenal, her lyrics are witty and poetically composed, the musical arrangements are flawless and the production is amazing. The music industry is substantially better off with Mariah in play. Congratulations Mariah on a job well done.

[@everydaymarvin2490]

what were some of your favorite tracks from #caution?

[@azzarobertson95]

Marie- Louise d' Auvergne No its not lmfao, guess you don’t listen to music a lot huh

[@chelseawilliams491]

Fun fact: Mariah played the violin part towards the end of portrait.

[@ninaschofield]

wow i didn't know that!

[@ReubenWalton]

Wow really?

[@HH-kv3gv]

Reuben Walton yes! she posted a picture of her in practice too

[@alexayres6250]

Same here I did not know she could play violin. Her talents have no limit. Writing, producing, singing and instrumental. She is a true artist. Love her🥰

[@cmt89497]

Mariah performed The Distance on the Jimmy Fallon Show a couple days ago, you should react to it!!

[@kevinverarivera9603]

yeah, react to it and to "with you_" live on GMA

[@heymikkao]

ugh queen of live performances

[@charlescavanagh9140]

Yessss please!

[@handryantan]

She also perform it on her concert in Indonesia at Borobudur

[@MegaTron01111]

@@kevinverarivera9603 That performance was messy, IMO, but The Distance performance was GREAT!!!

[@jacobdu1215]

that is very great and accurate comment from you after listening to the whole album. Mariah has been evolving all the time with the trend and her voice situation. She is a master of music. She really knows everything of music in my opinion.

[@Internalharmony92]

Ur review made me listen to the songs a bit more. I love Mariah and all the new songs. You just brought more attention to certain areas that most reviewers didnt. I believe Mariahs music always takes me back in time. Love It Great Review

[@Trylica]

Giving me life is a masterpiece 🖤🖤🖤

[@TheArtofBeingReacts]

FACTS babe.

[@Xdianaandini]

ART

[@Trylica]

@@TheArtofBeingReacts 😘😘

[@Trylica]

@@Xdianaandini 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@3BuckHead]

That song is so freaking beautiful!!

[@boeyyikming]

YASSS someone with actual music production knowledge + good vocals reacting to Mariah!! Really enjoyed this review. Also, I found it funny how the words for "One More Gen" came up at 8:30 when you said you needed to listen to the previous song again lol

[@karenlawler4043]

She has knowledge but totally misses Lil Kim based track.. "A no no". Lots of people seem to miss it. It's not a sample, she just put a vocal on Kim's track. Maybe I'm just older than her Lol. It sounds 90's cause it is 90's.

[@kaih2470]

tomás lil kim has never really been big here

[@ronniejupiter]

You review is legit! It’s Cohesive, in depth, observant and detailed! Your musicianship is astounding! Kudos and Subbed! Caution is truly a great masterpiece!!

[@Miguelperry411]

This is by far the best reaction video i've seen of this album. 👏👏👏👏

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you!

[@IWeasel]

Agreed the whole album was amazing but this last song made you truly feel the essence of Mariah Carey and who she really is as a artist and a person. She was really chill for this entire album yet she still managed to let people know and never forget she's Mariah Carey simply beautiful! We couldn't asked for a better album she took her time and has made truly another classic album in my opinion.

[@Xdianaandini]

FINALLYYYY!!! I'm waiting for this. i know u genius musician, The Distance produced by Skrillex so smoothhhh, Givin me Live ft. Slick Rick sounds so 80s right?

[@J33-k3s]

I like how you described her vocals as shimmering in with you, that's a good word for it.

[@Trylica]

It's like a movie - literally mariah's essence : transcendental ⚡⚡

[@themasterflexG]

Please check out her bonus track, Runway. She sampled herself and it’s probably one of her strongest songs on the album.

[@IWeasel]

I'm upset we didn't get it here US

[@themasterflexG]

J&M right?! But if I remember correctly MC said it will be included on the deluxe edition. I’m in love with that song.

[@axelito6342]

themasterflexG can you tell me where she said that please ? Was it on a interview ?

[@themasterflexG]

Mr. Tv shows yes she said it on an interview from the past week. I don’t remember which one though sorry babe

[@themasterflexG]

Angelic Deville anytime baby. I thought she mistook it for the japan edit but she didn’t correct herself. The track is amazing. Have u checked it out yet?

[@nashonwesonga4480]

Watching you reviewing this Album put tears in my eyes cause of your honest truth and the last part was just incredible.great reviewer hope Mariah gets the credit for this masterpiece.

[@deborahsuely7]

I love your reaction, it’s really from somebody that understands.

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you!

[@Rasfa]

Best review. No wonder its by a musician.

Amazing reaction!! I love your attention to detail and your expertise makes me more appreciative of Mariah’s new album and musicianship.

[@TheArtofBeingReacts]

You said, "whistle notes, get em out" LOL!!! I love that the album has you moving! You have quiet the ear.

[@ronviray8367]

Exactly she knows how to use her instrument she doesnt hit the super high notes all the time all notes are in proper places even on her live adlibs that how you knowa person is a musician and who is just a singer

[@lloydlester5402]

The Musicianship and production value of the album is unparalleled and no other artists comes close.. I truly hope this album gets the recognition it deserves at the Grammy Awards

[@jancosworld9571]

Please react to mariah carey the distance live on jimmy fallon

[@eneskans7483]

I love Mariah Carey.

[@instasingingvids3529]

I am so proud of this album the hate she suffers in the media is unfortunate but I’m glad she keeps doin her thing she already sang the distance live on jimmy Fallon you should watch it! I always love your perspective you have a great ear for things I would never notice

[@mrhcry]

8th grade and Portrait are my favourites.. Thanks for this great reaction video..

[@ninaschofield]

great choices, you're welcome!

[@rodmclean3578]

FINALLY! A review from someone with talent. Great and knowledgeable review. You and Mariah sound great.

[@Bleuxman]

8th grade is my absolute fav. My jam. On repeat.

[@jockmaraisasmr5700]

I’ve been bopping to this album for a year and it’s so cool how you pick up things, musically, in the production and vocalization that I never really noticed. You’re very clearly an expert on this stuff and have an ear for music.

[@Trylica]

This album is so goooooood💜🧡💛💚

[@tonymullenix9281]

Nina I really agree with your honest review of CAUTION! After your review I went back and relistened to each song and you were spot on! A true lady that knows her stuff! CAUTION is the best pop/rnb album of this decade, hands down!!!

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you!

[@mohammadmuhieddine8598]

I loved the album and I absolutely adored this review. Great job!! My fav songs are Caution, With You and Portrait.

[@lucianofreitasjr]

There's also Runway, this bonus track she released on the Japanese version of this album. It's one of the best tracks on this project.

[@abdulrahmanabdulaziz8742]

This album is so underrated. It's her best album since e=mc2. I loved every song in it especially giving me life & portrait.. EXCELLENT reaction, thank you very much.

[@robertover4059]

I loved your review. Hearing technical commentary helps me appreciate Mariah and her craft so much more.

[@vanessam.mpantig886]

japanese edition has 12 tracks 11.runway 12.runway remix feat. Kohh (Japanese rapper)

[@ReubenWalton]

Vanessa M.M Pantig no really?

[@instasingingvids3529]

Reuben Walton yes I have runway downloaded on my iPhone and I love it. I downloaded it from online it samples butterfly and was produced by skrillix if I am correct

[@bronchitisyt4755]

@@instasingingvids3529 fun fact: people started speculating that the panio ish sound in the background is from we belong together. Dont know for sure tho

[@SS-su3lw]

OMG you snapped with this review!!! The best one I've seen so far, amazing! Your musical knowledge shook me here 💜💜

[@frenchanthony2226]

Mariah is truly a one of a kind artist! No one can layer vocals the way she does. She is also a tremendous song writer. There is NOTHING Mariah Carey can't do. She could sing the phone book and make is SPECIAL!!!

[@veee9769]

you are literally me!! i got really emotional at the end of the album, the entire album is just a master piece

[@princeclarke2010]

The best album of this decade 😍 BTW she did perform The Distance live ❤on Jimmy💖 8th Grade is that shid 💞

[@paulsselection]

I like your informative and analytical reaction instead of typical pure emotion. Thank you.

[@everydaymarvin2490]

I appreciated her point of view too! what were some of your favorite tracks off the album?

[@murillocesar263]

Not gonna lie it's hard to pick just one coz I like the entire album, but Portrait , 8th Grade and With You these ones I fell in love at the very first listening haha. Anyways, TYSM for your review, fair and respectful. Don't forget to check Mariah performing The Distance on Jimmy Fallon ❤😸

[@caloiboi]

Been putting off watching this but was pleasantly surprised since you were able to point out a lot of things that I would've not paid attention. Thanks for the love for Mariah!

[@Izzy-sg1kg]

Finally a honest review from a person who knows what they are talking about ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you!

[@ant1171984]

I love this review! Love this album!! It's sad it wasn't more of a commercial success. At least we have a work of art to enjoy

[@danhaff1366]

Love your reviews

[@barnokog4744]

Hands down best reviewer in YT! I went to check your music newest single in Spotify. Love it! Will be listening more of your back catalogue. New fan here. I hope you get the break you deserve.

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much

[@corbintreadwell8386]

Your review is so technical! Definitely my favorite reaction. FOLLOWED. You should definitely react to more of her albums. I think you’d like the Daydream or Butterfly albums!

[@Just-Kamal]

The way you were breaking down her music craftsmanship gave me goose bumps. She always delivers a timeless music. And you are such a beauty with a melodious voice. I subscribed

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much

[@dereka.b.8136]

This review is what made me subscribe to your channel! It's refreshing to see a real review and not someone's opinion but 100% real honest facts ! #Amazing

[@mijalakis3]

When I heard this album I felt so proud about being a lamb. She really reminded us subtly why she is a songstress, full of perfection, uniqueness and special. She makes music because she loves it and wants everybody else to do the same and she is master at conveying that by simply making a cohesive album. I wish Mariah read this so she knows that she made us proud and that her status as a diva and living legend is well deserved. Nowadays only Adele kinda gets this thing but sometimes her music all sounds the same unlike Mariah and don't get me wrong I love Adele and I know every single lyric to her music but Mariah is simply a superior musician, songwriter and producer. You get a standing ovation by me Mariah as humble as it may be but it's full of admiration

[@jockmaraisasmr5700]

Your reviews are so cohesive and informative. Thank you. This is one of Mariah’s best albums and to think she put it out 30 years into her career. Amazing.

[@bippityboppityboo]

You’re so genius with your reaction. Thank you for reacting to Caution (it should be 2019’s AOTY tho) (it’s still AOTY in my heart lol) 🖤

[@mikeygee16]

I love the way you broke down the songs and talked about the production. You gained a new subscriber! If you can find the Japanese bonus track “Runway”, I’d love to hear what you think of it.

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you, i definitely need to listen to Runway!

[@nadrobles8945]

Lyrically, Portrait of my life is the best. Simple melody but powerful message.

[@MeMe-m3m3]

Firstly you have an amazing singing voice. Thankyou for showing us Mariah Fans the technical part of her voice and music production. You Have the best Reaction Video to Mariahs new album CAUTION . It's nice to see The British People appreciate Mariah as well.

[@coreypattinson]

Love your review of Caution Giving Me Life is my favourite track but love the whole album 🥰

[@trustme4903]

The fact that she actually writes and produces her songs as well as sings is incredible. And in portrait she does the strings. She’s amazing 😍😍👸

[@cmt89497]

Yay!! Was waiting for this

[@paulwatson1495]

Great review and totally agree with everything she said. Portrait stands out it’s gorgeous. Really good to get a review from such an informed intelligent lovely lady

[@navyforeveryoungjean-phili5940]

Ughhh you are spot on with your comprehensive review. So many technical elements throughout this whole album. It’s not just slapped together quickly. You can feel and hear the ingenuity behind every song. I still feel that Mariah is recognized enough for her production and vocal arrangement abilities.

[@hatchibyebye]

Your mannerisms as you communicate remind me of Natasha bedingfield

[@bluesyproduction9908]

Mariah is QUEEEEEEEN this album is no different I only have 2 albums with every song downloaded caution and thank you next and Mariah is everything 😵♥️

[@marvinnewbill6470]

Awesome Album Definitely a 8 out 10 stars. Welcome back Mariah! I think u get number 19 number one

[@minnmingolding]

Marvin Newbill 10.9/10

[@Xdianaandini]

Sadly this albun not good at billboard chart :(((((

[@minnmingolding]

its still new.. wait and see.. it will be no 1 album..

[@Xdianaandini]

@@minnmingolding I hope soooooo. It deserves #1 for sure! People should listen the pure art of "Giving me life"

[@minnmingolding]

Dicky Martin Giving Me Life is AMAZING.. I love love love that song.. i hope people will love that song too..

[@danielrush9268]

I love when you suddenly start singing because this unexpectantly amazing voice comes out so casually (not to say your speaking voice isn't flawless)

[@nurishaways4138]

This is such an amazing review!!! I love how much you love music and how much this masterpiece excites you!! I felt like we were listening to it together as in I felt very similarly abt the chord changes,arrangements and beauty of it all! Giving me life is my favorite because it’s so different especially the breakdown at the end and as you said opera style she brings! Well and Portrait is everything and that’s how one closes an amazing album! Thank you so much for this awesome video!

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much for watching!

[@TimothyJazzy]

Well said, dahhhhhling.. We all can tell, You know what you’re saying.. It’s one of the most honest & exact (100% same with my thought when i first heard it) review of the album.. THANK YOU! Love all the way from Indonesia ❤️

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much for watching!

[@mezmerized4lifejay654]

You reviews & reactions are the best. Yeah, Mariah already performed "The Distance" ft Ty $ign live on Jimmy Fallon

[@DOISMELLCUPCAKESYT]

Top review. Really liked hearing you talk bout it. Thank u

[@thequintessential5503]

I love that backgorund song after the tracklist at the end. It sounds like song Mariah would sing.

[@jordifernandez5539]

Love how you catch all the layers in the music and vocals right away! Loved your review!

[@Nardino]

Your reaction is “GIVING EVERYTHING”.... Thanks for breaking it down like a pro and letting your audience know what Mariah , The Queen, is all about! Love it! 👑 🔥

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much

[@mijalakis3]

2u8 years into her career and she released her best critical reviewed album ever. Her musicianship is flawless and it's gonna be very difficult to ever find another artist as consisten as her, 30 years and we have not seen another at her level.

[@lerc3690]

This review gave me life. SUBSCRIBED! I'm a musician too and I truly understand what Mimi did with this piece of art. I'm so glad you were able to notice how great Caution is. My favorite Mariah album so far, and I've heard all of them.

[@jibriljinno]

she is actually the producer here,, she mandates these musical directions,,, as she is song writer too anyway

[@sanyrub]

You really know music. Congrats. Mariah is one of the best to ever do it no doubt.

[@jamespaltinca4927]

Great Reaction! Thank You Nina ❤😍 #Caution

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you for watching

[@romella_karmey]

I'm sooooo sooooo excited to see the music videos for this whole album!!!!! If music is excellent, what more the videography! We have a sneak peak with GTFO and With You and both are great shots in videography!! What more my faves... Caution, Giving me Life, and Portrait!

[@shack6000]

The whole album is amazing🔥 Thnx for the nice review❤

[@lucasgsellier]

With You is my favorite, this song is incredible, love the piano and vocals and the video!

[@got2bjosh]

Returned to rewatch. The album is still fabulous. Still wish they had chosen stronger singles: The Distance, Caution, and Runway.

[@SunnySoroush]

I really enjoy your very detailed, and always on-point analysis and review of music and lyrics. You never let the subtle, muted notes go unnoticed, and that is a true talent. Giving Me Life was my favorite track on this album, closely followed by Portrait.

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much

[@KarenAbdul]

Mariah is the best singer all time ,she is an angel ,too bad that young people doesn ´t know how amazing she is

[@cocoapuff_x]

I need to listen to it again! *one more again- plays* -one mo gen

[@tremaine861]

Yay!!! Thank you for this lovely reaction and review Nina mwah!!

[@ninaschofield]

mwah

[@imfreed152]

Your reaction is very touching 🥰💕 I would have cried if I was Mariah and I watched your review 🥰😍💕💕

[@J33-k3s]

🎶How bout youu....How bout youu....🎶 Love the intro lines, the sound, the tone, the texture of her voice. Mariah is magic!

[@victorvyim]

Love your reaction Nina! You obviously know your stuff and really have offered your insights that not everyone can notice! Now I can appreciate even more to this already great album!

[@ninaschofield]

You're so welcome, thank you for watching!

[@Bridgje05]

you should hear runway too. It's a Japanese bonus track. it's my #1 fave song off the album. I also wanna hear your review for Me I Am Mariah The Elusive Chanteuse. Reaction videos are not that popular at that time and cant find a musicians opinion on it

[@romella_karmey]

Everyone! Lay the glittery crystal embroidered pink carpet with butterfly design for the Goddess of Music.... Mariah Carey!!! 💚💚💚😍

[@aspire2inspire91]

Amazing review! I really hope Mariah sees this reaction to see how much people really appreciate her musicianship.

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you, that would be a dream come true

[@ranranretro5609]

Very good review i realy love your high pitch voice too its perfect!

[@mcfanrobinhood]

The album is really great

[@jonjonmariah]

Your review is so profound and lots of knowledge. I love it! Caution is a masterpiece! Thank you for your genuine thoughts.

[@ninaschofield]

You're welcome, Thank you for watching!

[@seyboy21]

Thank you gor the reaction mariah give us life with this album 🙏

[@espag1327]

Really love your reaction. You know what you’re talkig about and shows how knowledgeable you are in music

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you!

[@jeromealve6321]

I love watching your reactions!! So observant and you really know what you're talking about.

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much

[@feedback7781]

Best review! This album is everything!

[@areneem87]

After the first listen Giving me Life and One Mo Gen were my favs! Now it’s 8th grade and Caution. Great review! You pointed out things I didn’t pay attention to until now

[@spencerjay3738]

I absolutely love your channel!!! You really understand music as a fan and on a academic side.

[@maickelvanheeswijk]

Best album in years ♥️ love every song ✨