Not Settling Up

The plaintiff charged Christmas supplies on her credit card for the defendant, but he hasn’t paid her back as promised, so the plaintiff is suing. The defendant claims the plaintiff made the orders while he was at work, so he didn’t agree to everything the plaintiff purchased.
Case #27358
#PeoplesCourt #RealityTV #Court

[@damnnerves24]

Based on the defendant’s attitude, he paid her more than I expected! No good deed goes unpunished.

[@PHOENIX1699]

Oh these two are a deep deep ocean of issues and secrets.

[@janetdickerson3170]

I don't think there is , I just think she was genuinely trying to help those kids out!!

[@redapol5678]

@@janetdickerson3170the deep deep ocean of issues and secrets probably exist from the little we heard, it’s just they’re irrelevant to the case 😅

[@janetdickerson3170]

That might be true

[@PutterJack]

This case makes me so happy I didn't get a quote tattooed across my chest😂😂😂😂

[@Leckibaby]

I got a little Harry Potter one on the left side of my chest that says “Always” and I love it but now I’m kinda feeling some type of way. 😂😂

[@veronicastigger7947]

Girl I have no tats and I’m happy they have temporary tattoos which I love lol

[@veronicastigger7947]

@@Leckibabydon’t fe

[@steelwheels327]

Hopefully you were joking , right ? Chest tatts or sleeves on women look really trashy !!

[@Leckibaby]

@@veronicastigger7947 I am assuming that was going to be positive even though it got cut off, so thank you. lol.

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

She's a "soldier" as in a gang member. It's not hard to see.

[@YoungBlaze]

Ahhh just our type ❤

[@adyh3004]

She's a soldier of gang members, 💯💯💯💯💯

[@iris-nx1wt]

She looked really nervous when he told the judge he knew what it meant.

[@daynasafranek7807]

Motorcycle club… girl, we know! 😅

[@NubianP6]

3:40 Judge Judy: *UNCROSS YOUR ARMS!* 😂

[@LeeLee-nz1kq]

Real lol 😂

[@kerrywhite5253]

People have no integrity. Even if you were working and unaware of the order being placed,your girlfriend was aware. Be grateful enough to pay her back. Instead,he has to come to court, and the world knows his kids had no shoes or beds for his 4 daughters. 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@elaine462]

My heart hurts to think four precious children are going to be raised by that loser defendant. Poor kids.

[@erinnorwood6124]

I wouldn't buy all that for myself or my own family if I couldn't afford it.

[@SamuelGSherman]

Good rule to live by: don’t give/loan to someone expecting to get it back. Always asssume u won’t or just don’t give it

[@pheonyxjohnson5966]

My father taught me that, little did I know how many adults ask for loans.

[@rosej5029]

Add if no one is asking for the money, don't offer the money. This and other episodes the defendant didn't ask for any money. It's on plaintiff not to fall for the "dry begging" & keep their mouth shut. The plaintiff herself said she offered to lend money. He didn't ask her for it. On his side, he could have turned her down.

[@atrocchia]

You are absolutely correct. You will never see the money back. Give it as a gift. If you should happen to get some $ back, consider yourself lucky.

[@rosej5029]

JM's sarcasm about "necessity" went over plaintiff's head😅

[@mmm_1927]

People really act like Christmas presents and a tree are mandatory. Geez….

[@WhiteTheRealQueens]

In some cultures, it is very important. Just like some cultures, the lashes and hair hats are!

[@Elanastonee]

💯💯💯

[@Elanastonee]

​@@WhiteTheRealQueens iktr! Just like tanning beds & spray on tans!! 😂

[@WhiteTheRealQueens]

@Elanastonee just the Natural sun I love in the summer, I'm all natural! Perfect tan, Not burnt!

[@Bih1stOfAll]

@@WhiteTheRealQueens Your name is telling. Get your thrills online bc in person u would NEVAAAA

[@LawsonPatterson]

Wow, the defendant seems like such a quality person…lol God, please look after his children 🙏

[@MusicTennis]

Amen to that. Four daughters so how much dough does mom earn to help support them? It didn't come up and might be relevant.

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

​@@MusicTennishe said he's got sole custody, I kind of doubt the mom is involved in supporting them in any way

[@maryelaine-blinstrubchambe6083]

There are a lot of deadbeat moms who have walked away from their kids.

[@marys4565]

He doesn't appear to be an irresponsible Man. I know single parents and it's difficult sometimes to provide just basic necessities. Seems he hit a snag and his then girlfriend reached out. I understand him not believing he should have to pay for everything when his now ex took half of it. He should go after her. Who takes things from children!? Good luck to him. 4 girls? Yikes lol

[@evocharbonneau856]

Wonder how much time he's done.

[@tommyjones6866]

Dude is up there straight snitchin. He spillin all the beans over a few pairs of shoes from amazon and a bunk bed

[@vay_6148]

Don’t forget the PlayStation we didn’t get not to mention the set of bunk beds that we didn’t even get either there was only one

[@JayyThao]

Who ever has their alarms on in court, can they please cancel ALL of them? 😂

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

Right? 😅

[@kakishisfriend1126]

Lmao I thought my phone went off for a second

[@michellehawkins1027]

I didn't notice.🤷‍♀

[@shaydaslays]

It's probably a medication reminder, well I hope

[@Nm-pk6uh]

That iPhone alarm kept me thinking it was my phone messing up and rewinding 🤣

[@lolamaude3449]

The defendant is a loser. The gifts were extravigant for someone that had not money at all. She was very foolish to have placed all those goods on her credit and she certainly needed a promissory note.

[@uniquelyunique1]

The defendant doesn't need anymore kids, he's got enough. 🤭

[@christopherchance4860]

looks like he switched teams lol

[@alexiasmith3259]

There where ur wrong my dad was amazing father and he has custody of all his kids tho and that was a lie but nice try

[@vay_6148]

@@christopherchance4860he didn’t nice try

[@alexandermccall2416]

Wow what a wonderful and grateful person the defendant is. Someone else provided Christmas for HIS children and he’s just so thankful. Even with a judgement against him I doubt he will pay her back.

[@nadeawilliams7749]

Right he's a parent with kids and got a blessing and this is how he acts!! Acting all I didn't know until after it was ordered! They called you to get kids sizes!!

[@fantasiab.7917]

She’s knows what that tattoo means lol

[@dreasvonne]

Just like she knows what, " about to catch a case." Means!!!

[@daynasafranek7807]

Not many motorcycle clubs are on the “up and up” and these two had issues with theirs…. So, they then go on national tv and start spilling their mess. That’s wild. 😂

[@Monika-bc3dq]

I honestly read the tattoo just as "sometimes in life it sucks to be brave, to push through etc." Like being tough and shit. Because there are people who are afraid of being venerable and think being "like a soldier" is a way to go through life 🤷🏻‍♀️ But maybe I'm naive in that sense, as I know nothing about a motorcycle clubs aside from Sons of Anarchy 😂

[@BDogs10]

.got no idea what you’re talking about? 😂

[@jamieleigh3481]

That’s what I thought, she’s just soldiering through.

[@mikehart2555]

They were in a relationship "from October 2016 until January 2016". That doesn't sound right.[5:52]

[@ChristineDuval-cy5ck]

Never ever, ever believe anyone when they say they'll pay when they get their taxes back. When you do these type of things, you have to do it with the idea that you will not get money back.

[@ironfist7235]

Ohhh she def was in a gang, when he was explains the tattoo she looked guilty as hell lol

[@alexiasmith3259]

She was

[@ruthie7238]

Nobody is jealous of this guy. That's for sure. 😂😂

[@jennywinter3025]

You will be surprised he has kids too

[@janetdickerson3170]

You got that right!

[@albertol9654]

That defendant is the definition of a dead beat dad. But the plaintiff is so gullible to trust someone like that.

[@SusieGr187]

completely. What a loser.

[@akairiyahiko2602]

It seems the mom is the dead beat.

[@Sook995]

He’s not a dead beat’ he had full custody fool

[@bjvu9460]

define a dead beat dad or do you not know what the term mean and like most people use words that is bigger than their vocabulary. If you dont know i will post the meaning since you obviously too lazy to even google the meaning but I will do it for you if you can read A typical "deadbeat dad" is a term used to describe a father who neglects his financial and emotional responsibilities towards his children!!! Typical person on the internet....

[@spacepanda9037]

Dead beats don't have full custody of 4 girls

[@mysticalmuse333]

What a sweetheart person 😢… I’m the same way when it comes to children….. boy ole boy has life taught me a few lessons!

[@brittanyn5415]

Guys. It’s never “I need Christmas gifts for my children” it’s I need money for myself come on 😂😅

[@daynasafranek7807]

He probably sold the toys for cash

[@napastar100]

I can't believe people are still lending cars, credit cards, etc to strangers, like they are going to pay back! pure stupidity of people!

[@MonroesArtStudio]

If she paid for things without your knowledge, that you didn't agree to.... Give it back. Don't even entertain the idea

[@judithgeiger6992]

He's despicable. I feel for those kids.

[@Sook995]

The mom is the dead beat, he has custody,

[@vixxter3099]

Nobody should be doing favors for anybody else on their credit cards because this is the ending result most times

[@lauracurtin631]

The defendant is LOSER. He will ALWAYS be a loser until he takes responsibility for his problems. HE is THE PROBLEM.

[@bjvu9460]

what is the problem and I bet you are no better off than him financially. Its a fact that 85 % of all bank accounts in the US have less than 5 000 dollars and I bet you are one of those so what makes this guy a loser ? he didnt ask her for the money and she volunteered it with his ex and his ex kept the items that they bought so why should he pay for something he didnt ask for, they volunteered and he doesnt have the item? If you had noticed non of this ordeal started with him borrowing money but two women wanting to spend money and that they did and one of them for some reason got to keep half the stuff that she had ordered.

[@TESLA-fc6wm]

Well,,X-mas is NOT about toys or gifts,,thats just brain washing you to spend ,spend,and spend money,,every Holiday you have to spend money,,really???

[@Cali4life818]

Who produced children by this dude? And he’s the better parent! 😮

[@YoungBlaze]

Awww certain women love fixer up men with attitudes like this

[@wandabellamy6120]

So u can just imagine the mom must be a Prize 😂😂

[@Cali4life818]

@@wandabellamy6120 that’s not my assumption, it’s the opposite. Ever heard of sarcasm? 🙄🤐

[@wandabellamy6120]

@@Cali4life818 that's my sarcasm 😂

[@Cali4life818]

@@wandabellamy6120 Ooo got you. 😂

[@links89a]

Oh no, the never ending I pay you when I get my taxes promise.

[@BDogs10]

..‘by the way She hates you’ 😂

[@JloveLamar]

Why did the judge keep pushing about the tattoo? He must've said something in the response to the complaint that caught the Judge's attention, because she would not let it go😂

[@markquarto8159]

Love how the women say the defendant is a “loser”, but the plaintiff is shady herself

[@vay_6148]

THANK YOU SAY IT LOUDER FOR THE PEOPLE IN THE BACK

[@Jms3424]

Sometimes it sucks to get a horrible tattoo that stays on you forever

[@kimricautumn6918]

she's wearing clothes that show it off, though. She must still be in love with the life. Screw that. It's terrible for kids.

[@tommyjones6866]

I dunno why JM is up there acting so dense. He clearly explained the meaning behind her tattoo, yet JM keeps acting like she doesn't understand.

[@christophernunn77]

These messy humans always have a bunch of children. Sad.

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

And they vote 😬

[@maryelaine-blinstrubchambe6083]

At least the defendant stepped up and is taking care of his children. I commended him for that.

[@keiariabailey8739]

The bare minimum..

[@mythiac696]

​@mls2023 the relationship was less than 6 months. No shoes and new shoes are very different.

[@modernretroradio993]

02:21 ... Judge Mathis calls that "dry begging."

[@KayB-l5h]

If a person is taking out loans for Christmas gifts then their priorities are not in order. They're in debt for the very reason. Gifts are not priority.

[@TESLA-fc6wm]

Just look at those 2..

[@meghanwilliams4295]

Baby, if you had to provide Christmas for HIS kids, what did he get you???🤔🤔🤔🤔

[@mariehotmomma1371]

His poor children

[@skalin2345]

knowing there are people like this in the world makes me want to stay in my home and never leave. is it shocking that children were murdered and died under there care? tragically no. very sad.

[@sph1226]

The defendant was wrong, but I don't think he's as bad as most of these comments. He just needs to go after his ex-girlfriend for keeping the things if he paid for them.

[@moosah1027]

1000% agree, i keep reading “deadbeat” in the comments referring to him and I’m lost like… did we watch the same case? He just owes her money.. and I’m so confused by the judgement total 🙈

[@kcfraser]

Some people shouldn't breed.

[@lulusgm1]

The fact that he had full custody.... their mother must be a horrible women

[@simpleexpressionscrafts4574]

Your struggling?! Don't have more children, don't get more tattoos, lay off the booze...etc......don't help people that don't make smart decisions!!

[@Johnfisher12345]

Excellent advice. Shame so many people ignore it and make excuses for their bad behavior all the while.

[@vay_6148]

He didn’t really drink

[@michaelmagill45]

Defendant is a low life , and glad she won , he shook his head in disbelief when he lost , glad the judge saw through him, he deserved to lose .

[@rammibear9649]

His anger might be why his ex is so bitter.

[@rayeguevara4880]

Yes I was thinking the same thing, you can tell he has major anger issues

[@crystalshaw8744]

​@marilynwillett804😂😂😂. Exactly.

[@stevelozano9523]

I can imagine that her tat is indicating that it sucks for things she had to do for the club she never wanted to do.

[@SoloLeaux]

I think you’re reaching, it’s very obviously a play on “God gives his toughest battles to his strongest soldiers”

[@Idontwantafuckinghandle588]

I think she thinks she bad…

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

It's not a club, it's a gang!

[@maryelaine-blinstrubchambe6083]

Who wants the word sucks on their chest. Classless.

[@stevelozano9523]

@@SoloLeaux think I'm reaching, not. Think logically based on the circumstances (or your mind, circus-dances)😅

[@MH-yj4qq]

This guy is such a dork

[@Black0bsidian]

He’s a lil sassy actin at he?….

[@nathanbabiuk6286]

?

[@jeromecummings47]

He went into a dark place after losing a child. So he abandoned his other children. Make it make sense.

[@bobbleheadmoe]

But have u ever lost a child.

[@jeromecummings47]

@@bobbleheadmoe he is just making excuses. But I’m sure somebody believes him. You are that somebody I guess.

[@chickychang1]

But he still had custody of all the kids?

[@mmmfun77]

I THOUGHT THE SAME THING

[@kitaboo2245]

he never abandoned his kids lol

[@amberhaught4428]

I feel like I need a shower after watching this case. Especially the defendant. 😒

[@gooberbeans7972]

Why would anyone want this kind of life?

[@kakishisfriend1126]

I thought her tattoo was "God gives his toughest battles, to his strongest soldiers". So she hates being a soldier because she has to deal with all these tough battles

[@tashacraig4999]

Sis should’ve covered her tat for court…

[@jovaanmills2968]

He look sketchy af

[@lesliemassey-or6cv]

What he is paying for that he doesn’t have is between him and his ex- he just needs to try to sue her 🤷‍♀️or stop grumbling about it

[@sakutasu]

The true meaning of being a soldier is, A soldier is the man or woman who fights for their government and carries the weapons, risking their life in the process. Her tattoo should've said, " Sometimes i sucks to be an Old Lady." 😂

[@jamesfetherston1190]

I thought the plaintiffs’ tattoo said “It sometime sucks to be an addict”.

[@Noname-wi8xp]

I did too lol Weird lettering

[@Absaalookemensch]

Don't Leave it to Beaver. Doesn't have money for the bills but has money for tattoos. Bad priorities.

[@vay_6148]

Those tattoos were decades old luv get it right

[@Absaalookemensch]

@@vay_6148 That's even worse. That money put into paying off bills back them would multiply in money now. Even a Starbucks daily at work over a 50 year career, with tax and tip is over $130,000. Plan for the future or your plan is to fail.

[@cassandra6710]

You can't help people that don't want to help themselves. I have been broke and I go to the dollar tree and make holidays work. You don't need a lot. That's not what holidays are about. People are ungrateful after you help. That was nice of her but they didn't need all that fancy expensive stuff. If someone did this for my family I would be so grateful, even pay $20 a month. Just so ungrateful. If you can't afford to lose the money your lending or giving them don't do it. People change after you help them.

[@Bebe-og3bc]

I know a lot of bikers and he would not be considered man enough to be a "Club Member"!

[@kay22100]

I probably would’ve paid it myself if I was her if he was nicer and had a better attitude. Single father trying to take care of the kids. Also you are not helping anyone by loaning them a large amount of money if you know they’re struggling. Should’ve got them air mattresses, a tree and a few gifts.

[@navynick7307]

Those poor children.

[@zuritribe4844]

HE IS SO SASSY!!!

[@Black0bsidian]

Omg I just said this!!!! I knew it wasn’t just me!!!!!

[@82windows82]

This case needs more tattoos!

[@sherryn39455]

It never ceases to amaze me how you have a whole year to put away money for your kids for Christmas, but they wait till the last minute then start poor mouth and everybody feel sorry for the kids not getting nothing for Christmas, pitiful, Then I expect somebody else to help him with the money for Christmas

[@Red-lu3ku]

Why would she think he was going to pay her $250 monthly if he has no money at all the time? Very foolish of her.

[@RexDavis415]

Yep. She's very giving, she needs to learn to say no. It's not her problem he can't provide for his children.

[@Meister_de_Nicts]

Sons of Bankruptcy edition...

[@MarySmith-lk4ss]

😂😂😂😂

[@DPhasely]

Next time, come into court with tats covered, especially gang tats.

[@vambo13257]

This creep has 4 daughters??

[@prayforthe_1644]

🙄

[@bellacee9358]

Is that the bad boy version of Billy Burr?

[@kerrywhite5253]

I feel sorry for his girls.

[@YoungBlaze]

Hell I feel sorry for Doug! Having to interview them

[@alexiasmith3259]

Don’t we were happy and he was wonderful person

[@brittanyn5415]

That looks like it says “soldiet” and it bothers me😂

[@hollyjames4622]

I actually believe him when he says he doesn't have all the stuff. He would have had to move out 2 bunk beds and 4 kids... he probably left one in her place when he and the kids left and she probably did keep the footware she could fit of the kids.... she sounded just as f'd up as him... u move a f'd up man like that in ur home with 4 kids... something is absolutely not right with you either.

[@Sayzwhoiknownotyou]

I agree

[@elisapierre-procope9177]

What a big child. I... I... I . You got 4 kids buddy. Figure it out.

[@Lifeslessons81]

Why would his ex leave with his children’s things 🤔 he knew bc it sucks not being able to give your children Christmas . I bet he cried and promised to pay back

[@blkcubwhtbear5361]

She is so irresponsible

[@KayB-l5h]

The plaintiff is a fool. The girlfriend a POS. The way she talked about those kids like that. I believe the defendant was doing the right thing by paying until the ex took the stuff. So now he needs to sue her.

[@sneakerfreak2002]

2003 called … Said keep the sweater. No charge :)

[@ReymundoCortez]

What war?? Life 🤦 so you did not serve in the military but yet you're a soldier.

[@brazilianfaceless2147]

Silly girl with weak personality went to court to be judged by the judge, it’s priceless

[@quianaxoxo1160]

Happy Friday yall!! 🎉

[@deannalawson9456]

Happy Friday!!!

[@matthewmorales94]

Lol she thinks shes a soldier, what a disgrace of the word.....

[@DreamWarriorPaige]

His last name is Beaver. . .he already lost from the start 😂

[@MusicTennis]

Change the title to "Leave it to Beaver" heehee.

[@DreamWarriorPaige]

@@MusicTennis you are a true person of culture

[@tracylangsley4064]

Her tat should've said sometimes it sucks to be a sucker🤣

[@WAffingFartz]

😂😂😂😂

[@RexDavis415]

Pretty much. Nobody respects a sucka, hopefully she learned her lesson.

[@serenaperry23]

WOW, the person he needs to be mad at is his ex not the person who helped him out at Xmas.

[@prayforthe_1644]

Neck tattoo says “No Ragrets” (The millers )🎥

[@David-wo9un]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@KSakamoto]

How’d they get two bunk beds and mattresses, tablets, shoes, and a PlayStation for $700?

[@darrylnelson05]

“Old Lady” are people still calling women that?

[@Mbheather88]

They’ve been watching too much Sons of Anarchy

[@Newwoman2023]

@mbheather88 😂😂

[@fitnessfocused]

Clearly.

[@ThePracticalDog]

Stands there during the intro rolling his eyes and looking like a tweaker - "friend" or not, I wouldn't have leant him a dime. Now I would have offered to take him and his kids to Christmas mass and have taken them food to make a nice Christmas dinner, but presents and a tree? Nope.

[@vay_6148]

Wasn’t a tweaked just was upset bc he was paying for stuff he didn’t have

[@melli2413]

It was his responsibility to pay her but if the ex has some of the items he should sue her

[@nyccowboy7563]

I looked up on Google what the term scumbag meant...it linked to his Facebook page!

[@vay_6148]

Lie again it’s probably attached to yours

[@camilleivy3830]

my goodness Judge cut him some slack 🤦🤦🤦 I believe the girlfriend owes also 🤦🤦

[@keiariabailey8739]

If he would have sent the messages saying he was gonna pay I’d be on your side but from the looks of it he said from the beginning he’d pay it all no questions asked

[@hollyjames4622]

I actually believe him when he says he doesn't have all the stuff. He would have had to move out 2 bunk beds and 4 kids... he probably left one in her place when he and the kids left and she probably did keep the footware she could fit of the kids.... she sounded just as f'd up as him... u move a f'd up man like that in ur home with 4 kids... something is absolutely not right with you either.