NURIT PELED : Palestinians do not exist in Israelis' consciousness.

Nurit Peled-Elhanan is an Israeli philologist, professor of language and education at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, translator, and activist. She is a 2001 co-laureate of the Sakharov Prize for Freedom of Thought awarded by the European Parliament.
In 1997, Nurit's daughter, Smadar, was killed during the Ben Yehuda street Palestinian suicide attack.
We speak today about the silencing of internal critics in Israel, the Israeli education system and the propaganda in place in Israel from a very early age, to the "Where do we go now?" question.

[@FrankBarat77]

If you liked the video, please subscribe to the channel and give it a thumbs up, thanks!

[@chief_9938]

you are delusional if you believe there is such as "israelis' consciousness"

[@marleneamry4258]

This is a very important disclosure that reveals sll that is wrong in attitudes in Israeli society, and the reasons for it, bringing about violence and continuous strife and conflicts. Please continue your much appreciated work - and take care.

[@helly31]

What if I hate it?

[@lizlawne3924]

Thank you to all Israelis that are speaking out. Your bravery against the government propaganda is so necessary right now.

[@helly31]

​@@richardlaurie2198 You are next

[@27boof]

Thank you so much for having Nurit on your show, and Thank you to Nurit for your wise, wise words which are so much needed in these times. Thank you ❤

[@lauriewinestock4195]

NURIT THANK YOU! You are brave and a truth teller. The Myths of Israeli society run deep. The erasure of Palestinians and what they live with, either under military occupation or as third class citizens of Israel, day after day, year after year, is so enormous. As a former Israeli I commend your deep understanding, honesty, and dedication towards helping us all to be more compassionate, honest and human in the face of brutality and dehumanization.

[@nafisabireche3806]

Qui est humains quand une armée tue femmes et l'enfant

[@annabaldi9262]

Thank you!!❤

[@malikba8048]

Thank you sister❤Allah bless you

[@omarnajjar8485]

Respect; Nurit lost her daughter and did not lose her moral compass; this lady's mother would not accept a house that was given to her saying something to the tune of "I will not make my home on the ruins of another family".

[@knowledgeispower6726]

And her brother is Miko Peled, author of The Generals Son. He also speaks out against Israel's wrongdoings.

[@r.arieff6222]

Yes, I remember that story. I have admired her for a long time. She is an amazing and formidable person.

[@ispeiz]

Dr. Peled was my professor for a course at Tel Aviv University nearly 20 years ago. She told a story of a Haitian author who jumped off a bridge with his leg tied to an unabridged French dictionary. The idea that language and money have such power to subjugate people is undeniable. I am grateful for the way she continues to challenge me to consider the value of human life.

[@ElKoubi1975]

Do you know if she is related to Miko Peled? Strange that we don't get to hear much about her

[@ElKoubi1975]

Do you know if she is related to Miko Peled? Strange that we don't get to hear much about her

[@natnat4383]

​@@ElKoubi1975she is Miko Peled's sister. She is the one who lost her daughter in a suicide bombing I believe.

[@ElKoubi1975]

@@natnat4383 Thank you for your reply. I've just finished Miko Peled's book yesterday - I cried reading it and it gave me so much hope that despite the odds, thee are good people from the 'other side', who recognise injustice when they see one. I am hopeful that one day, there would be Peleds in both side of the devide and both Jews, Arabs And Christians can live in peace together

[@natnat4383]

@@ElKoubi1975 thats really good to hear. I'm listening to the book right now. Up to chapter 7 :)

[@sandrajensen497]

Nurit Peled is brilliant and a true human being. Thank you for a great interview.

[@lisasmith7066]

❤

[@Tom21356]

I never heard of this great lady before. She is a saint. May god bless her 🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@harune6594]

Enlightening. Thank you for introducing me to this respectable woman.

[@TheJDWyatt]

What a highly-intelligent, ethical and brave woman. She’s amazing. She’s on the right side of history, and her legend will live on.

[@fabiengerard8142]

She’s a very close relative of Miko Peled, the renown author of the best-selling Memoirs ‘The Son of the General’. A must-read for the Palestinian cause, from an Israeli family who’s precisely lost a teenager child in a terrorist attack (in the early 2000s, as far as I remember).

[@ahmedjaad4940]

@@fabiengerard8142 she’s not a relative lol, she’s his sister 😂 and this woman is the one who lost her daughter in the suicide attack

[@marleneamry4258]

And yet, she believes in peaceful existence between Palestinians and Israelis.

[@farahdeeba2993]

Thanks Nurit for your voice of honesty n humanity! Free Palestine!

[@collins48lc]

What honesty She's a propagandist for HAMAS

[@farahdeeba2993]

@@collins48lc educate yourself n try to see things through the lens of truth if you claim to be worthy of a human being. Otherwise, there is no point just throwing gibberish to each other.

[@hayabarakat7889]

​@@collins48lcI'm sure she held the same values even before Hamas was established. "Hamas propaganda" 😂😂😂 tell me you're an indoctrinated ignorant without telling me you're an indoctrinated ignorant 😂

[@irondoc1251]

@@collins48lc🤦🏻‍♂️

[@stephaniecarrow4898]

After reading "Apeirogon" last year, it is very special finally to hear Nurit's own words and reflections. I look forward to reading her books. Thank you both for this thoughtful interview and for your courage. It is most admirable when people turn their own suffering and loss into a force for good in the world.

[@yasararif8292]

When people like this speak, I can see a one state solution with people living in harmony and working together to make the most successful country in the world regardless of their ethnicity but rather their humanity.

[@Margarita_Margarita]

Thank you so much Dr.Peled, as a citizen of a country at war, your words are very important to me.

[@greenworld1184]

War with which Country? Israel freedom fighters.

[@orangetara4268]

This lady has such a wonderful spirit. I agree with her words and sentiments. Please listen to her as it’s the only way out of this catastrophe for everyone involved 🙏

[@maryannechilds6459]

Israeli education only serves to seed their greed for revenge n violence to palestinians n she gvs examples. Its the zionist program !!

[@MA-sk4fg]

Urit has a lot of compassion and she let’s her conscience speak. Wonderful human being. God bless you.

[@MA-sk4fg]

@@michalhaddadlevy965 Michal, she conquered hatred and let her compassion speak because hatred will lead you nowhere except to more killings of innocent people on all sides. Every human being has mixed emotions . They can lead us to bad or good acts . I opt for compassion .

[@rodrigodezubiria2007]

The world owes both of you an immeasurable debt of gratitude. I know the story of Nurits daughter and inspire of that tragedy she remains a steadfast humanist. I’m looking forward to reading her books

[@Daniel-pr4uk]

Thank you from the bottom of my heart. May Israelis wake up from the nationalist fascist trance and actually be able to hear the pain and profound trauma inflicted on the local people (of course there was also trauma the other way around, from the resistence of the local people to the cruelty, aggrsssion and taking-over project of the new zionist arrivals). May there be listening and real humanity on this planet.

[@collins48lc]

May you grow a working brain cell She's nothing more than a propagandist for HAMAS

[@lisasmith7066]

Wow. This woman is amazing, brilliant and brave. Thank you for having her on your show. I would like to find her books.

[@bksja6791]

I am a Palestinian. My family history goes back centuries in Jaffa. The Paestinians are a people and my ancestors lived on that land and both sides of family were rooted out in 1948. There is no other reality. There is only truth. My father was born in a tent in Gaza beacuse my grandparents were disspossed. This is reality. There is no excuse for terrorism. Dispossession and oppression breeds violent uprising.

[@pascalpoussin1209]

I agree that there is no excuse to terrorism, but was the 7th of October a terrorist act, a resistance act or an act of desperation? I think it's the 3rd, for it was violence against civilian Israelis. This said, from what I see and hear, by far most Israelis or Zionists are terrorists of the worse sort.

[@shaunigothictv1003]

Wrong. You need to learn your history. Palestinians are Judean Farmers who CONVERTED to Islam when the sunni Arabs invaded Palestine in 700ad. Palestinians were originally JEWS. They later mixed with sunni Arabs and learnt Arabic. The Palestinians are the true JEWS.

[@bksja6791]

I actually agree that Palestinians have a genetic link to Cannan and the Isrealtes. This changes nothing from my statement or the ongoing conflict. in fact, this supports my idea of a single democratic state for both religious and ethnic jews and Palestinains. Which I know is nothing but a dream

[@shaunigothictv1003]

@@bksja6791 OK cool.

[@falconx4803]

@@shaunigothictv1003 actually it's the christians who are the ppl of the land and are closest to canaan, like jesus was a palestinian jew that's for sure, but the muslims today were back then palestinians jews

[@banjosqueezebox]

Great interview! I am a 71 year old Canadian. We got our first television when i was 8 or 9 years old and one of the earliest memories I have is a TV documentary about the so-called “holocaust”….in which we were encouraged to never, never, never forget. I was very emotionally moved and thought “I will never forget!” Now i can clearly see that that was trauma based mind control, and we have been subjected to that propaganda all our lives. This is pure evil and we need to resist.

[@ruthokelley5833]

An extremely intelligent woman who has been paying attention! Thank you so much for giving this revealing interview! I celebrate your courage…❤️

[@robertpirsig5011]

She is a very brave woman. I am humbled by her understanding.

[@Himmelhauser]

Humanity is here. A noble human being.

[@MuhammadMuhammad-yz7je]

May ALLAH Rabul Allamin bless all those who speek truth and respect humanity

[@kolosos35]

"The world will not be destroyed by those who do evil, but by those who watch them without doing anything." - Albert Einstein

[@nosheenraza1424]

How she can be so clear headed given her personal history is amazing. Respect for Nurit.

[@petercohen5563]

The phrase “a land without a people” refers to the idea that Palestinians aren’t “a people,” but merely Arabs who can just as well go to 22 other countries. The answer is that even if they weren’t “a people,” they’re still people and have every right to live on their land as free and equal citizens.

[@scarletm9091]

מאיפה אתם מביאים את השטויות האלה אני נדפקת אם אתם גזענים אל תשליכו את זה על כל עם ישראל

[@joycegifford8826]

WRONG

[@khaderlander2429]

Right

[@petercohen5563]

@@joycegifford8826 what is the meaning then?

[@TheFaro2011]

You know this phrase was coined by Zionist Christians that was later taken on by Jewish Zionist

[@mansoorasgerally2828]

"The other 'WE' & to educate our children to refuse to obey the oppressors" Wow !!!! what a phrase. Great great LADY. 👍

[@AdelHerik]

For me, there is a striking similarity between the situation of the French settlers in Algeria before 1962 and the situation of the Israelis. Both refuse to see the reality and live in a bubble. In the end, the French settlers lost everything.

[@malikba8048]

in 1930 French government celebrated the 100th year of conquest of Algeria. Even after May 8th 1945 massacre on which dozens of thousand Algerian civilians were killed, settlers believed they would rule for ever ! They were backed by a powerful army. The situation is exactly the same in Palestine. One day 7th October will be regarded as the beginning of the end of zionist colonial project. Just a matter of years now, and Aipac and nuclear weapons will be of no help

[@NafisaD-vo3vz]

Very courageous to speak in truth in time like that!! Israeli Gov doesn’t want anyone to speak truth to power…

[@mansoornaqvi5933]

It takes a great mind to retain its own objectivity in the face of continuous propaganda being fed into it. Thanks Nutin for keeping intact your analytical powers and humanity.

[@harune6594]

I wish I could listen to many more of her opinions, as an Israeli who recognizes this colonial occupation and the suffering it causes all.

[@davidbarraco2045]

It hurts me worse when people who are informed have to suffer the anguish of people who Refuse to be present Bless this woman I am with her.

[@mehdinajari4830]

We love Nurit, Miko , Peled & Elhanan families and never forget Smadar.

[@malenedietl3369]

What it must be like to reach the point where you can only answer: I don't know what they want..blood!" To realize that your land is lead by a bunch of lying murders.....What a woman, she really is strong.

[@paulglobus9999]

Thank you for this excellent interview. This lady is an example to us all.

[@yoyit-realtor]

Today we talk of Oct 7, 2023 as the starting point of hostilities. But we forget Israel has subjected Palestinians to decades of abuse, occupation, humiliation, indiscriminate killings and unfair treatment . Though the action of Hamas was deplorable, Israel 's response is collective punishments and genocide. Isn't it just proper that in condemning Hamas, we should also condemn Israel.. #FreePalestine Thank you for your voice dear Lady.

[@janetmartin341]

Thank you for indeed this started at least 75 years ago. We must never let history be erased.

[@lordlorian81]

And Palestinians commit terror on israel for decades Its existential threat Combined together with other forces

[@naomideguyane]

For the very brave Prof. Nurit Peled & Frank Barat for this enlightening interview! May you be safe & continue your spiritual, so neccessary journey... THANK YOU!💚🙏🌿🕊🫒🌍 “Re-examine all you have been told in school or church or in any book, and dismiss whatever insults your own soul; and your very flesh shall be a great poem, and have the richest fluency, not only in its words, but in the silent lines of its lips and face, and between the lashes of your eyes, and in every motion and joint of your body." [From the preface to Leaves Grass]” ― Walt Whitman, Leaves of Grass

[@curtgomes]

As I listened to this lady, Dr. Peled-EIhanan, describe the blind obedience that the Israeli population has to a criminal regime in Tel Aviv and their willingness to support mass murder I couldn't help thinking about the mass obedience in our country to the criminal regime currently in Washington DC. It's truly insane.

[@pambennett8967]

They are one. CIA=MOSSAD

[@fatzo2328]

very important that Jews are speaking and denouncing! thank you for all of us.

[@imannajjia8030]

Thank u very much for this great, just and inspiring interview. We in the Arab world, appreciate people like u too a lot and we believe that your perspective and efforts will change things.

[@greenworld1184]

Yes she is real human beings. this teaching is in Scriptures. Arabs leadership has no guts stand up and rise their voice .they are puppets of western Governments.

[@victoriaparraga9646]

Looking always for Jewish voices I just discovered Professor Nurit Peled in this interview. Thank you, thank you, thank you, Brave Woman!!!

[@mafroodayasmin9634]

Such a great way of being honest. Takes a lot of courage to speak that explicitly against your own people. Respect for her all through.

[@KHABIB-TIME]

Professor Dean Phillip Bell, who is dean and professor of Jewish history at Spertus Institute of Jewish Studies in Chicago: “Jews under medieval Islam never suffered from the same general negative perception as in the Christian West. Despite regional variations and high medieval political instability, in medieval Islam multicultural environments, combined with active engagement in sciences and literature, led to something of an Islamic golden age for the Jews, at least according to most historical accounts. It has been primarily in the context of recent political developments that the once assumed positive views of Jewish life under medieval Islam have been seriously questioned.” Dean Phillip Bell, Jews in the Early Modern World. New York, 2008, p. 25.

[@AnAncient76]

Jewish history is a lie, fabrication! Israel is also a lie, a Masonic creation. If you want to know real history, read Anatoly Fomenko and David Ewing Jr!

[@KHABIB-TIME]

@@contact594 "For most of the Middle Ages the Jews of Islam comprised the greater and more active part of the Jewish people. The Jews who lived in Christian countries, that is in Europe, were a minority, and a relatively unimportant one at that. With few exceptions, whatever was creative and significant in Jewish life happened in Islamic lands. The Jewish communities of Europe formed a kind of cultural dependency on the Jews of the far more advanced and sophisticated Islamic world, extending from Muslim Spain in the west to Iraq, Iran, and Central Asia in the east." Bernard Lewis, a Jewish Historian, in his book: 'The Jews of Islam'

[@KHABIB-TIME]

@@contact594 Jewish historian, Prof Amnon Cohen, from Hebrew University of Jerusalem studied the 16th century documents stored in the archives of the Shari’ah religious court of Jerusalem (commonly known as sijill), whereby he found 1000 Jewish cases filed from the year 1530 to 1601 CE. Cohen published his research in 1994 during which he made some astonishing discoveries, as he himself states: ‘Cases concerning Jews cover a very wide spectrum of topics. If we bear in mind that the Jews of Jerusalem had their own separate courts, the number of cases brought to Muslim court (which actually meant putting themselves at the mercy of a judge outside the pale of their communal and religious identity) is quite impressive[1]…The Jews went to the Muslim court for a variety of reasons, but the overwhelming fact was their ongoing and almost permanent presence there. This indicates that they went there not only in search of justice, but did so hoping, or rather knowing, that more often than not they would attain redress when wronged…The Jews went to court to resolve much more than their conflicts with Muslim or Christian neighbours. They turned to Shari’a authorities to seek redress with respect to internal differences, and even in matters within their immediate family (intimate relations between husband and wife, nafaqa maintenance payments to divorcees, support of infants etc.).’[2] Cohen further elaborates upon the Jewish condition in the 16th century Ottoman Jerusalem: ‘Their possessions were protected, although they might have had to pay for extra protection at night for their houses and commercial properties. Their title deeds and other official documents indicating their rights were honoured when presented to the court, being treated like those of their Muslim neighbours[3]…The picture emerging from the sijill documents is baffling. On the one hand we encounter recurring Sultanic decrees sent to Jerusalem - in response to pleas of the Jews - to the effect that “nothing should be done to stop them from applying their own law” regarding a variety of matters. There are also many explicit references to the overriding importance of applying Shari’a law to them only if they so choose. On the other hand, if we look closely at some of the inheritance lists, we see that the local court allocated to female members of Jewish families half the share given to male members, exactly as in Islamic law. This meant, ipso facto, a significant improvement in the status of Jewish women with respect to legacies over that accorded them by Jewish tradition, although it actually meant the application of Islamic law in an internal Jewish context [4]…he [the Muslim Judge] defended Jewish causes jeopardized by high-handed behaviour of local governors; he enabled Jewish business people and craftsmen to lease properties from Muslim endowments on an equal footing with Muslim bidders; more generally, he respected their rituals and places of worship and guarded them against encroachment even when the perpetrators were other Muslim dignitaries.[5]’ And finally Amnon Cohen describes the effectiveness of Islamic law for Jewish interests: ‘No one interfered with their internal organisation or their external cultural and economic activities…In a world where civil and political equality, or positive social change affecting the group or even the individual were not the norms, the Sultan’s Jewish subjects had no reason to mourn their status or begrudge their conditions of life. The Jews of Ottoman Jerusalem enjoyed religious and administrative autonomy within an Islamic state, and as a constructive, dynamic element of the local economy and society they could - and actually did - contribute to its functioning.’[6] [1] Amnon Cohen, A World Within: Jewish Life as Reflected in Muslim Court Documents from the Sijill of Jerusalem (XVIth Century). Part One, 1994, Pennsylvania, p. 8. [2] Ibid, p. 17. [3] Ibid, p. 18. [4] Ibid, p. 20-21. [5] Ibid, p. 22. [6] Ibid, p. 22-23.

[@sabinereynaudsf]

Christians tended to blame Jews for the death of Jesus. I don't think there was a similar issue between Muslims and Jews.

[@noahburstein7541]

Don't go back to the "Golden Age of the medieval period to prove how wonderful life was infor the Jews under Islam. Jews and Christians were "dhimmis", protected by the Muslim rulers (very occasionally) because their holy books, the Torah andf the Gospels, were believed by the Muslims to contain partial truth, although not comparable to the full truth of the Quran. In the modern period, the 19th and 20th centuries, the position of Jews deteriorated, as the Muslim political and military powere in the world deteriorated. Each Arab Muslim country had its events of persecution, not to mention the usual condescension and humiliation handed out to non-Muslims. Every current Arab state, except Lebanon, states in its constitution that the religion of the state is Islam. Nobody seems to care that all Arab and Muslim states declare themselves Muslim states. The one Jewish state, which does not have an established religion (Judaism is not an established religion in Israel. The Ministry of Religious Affairs provides services to Jews, Christians, Muslims and Druze alike. although obviously the greatest share of its budget is for religious services for Jews) Israel is a parliamentary democracy, with the rule of law, the right of all citizens to vote and to be elected, an independent Supreme Court (so far), a free press and media and an open society. The Arab states, each and every one of them, is a dictatotship. Speak to any Arab or Palestinian in a quiet place and they will confirm all the above. You don't have to take my word for it. They will all acknowledge that the only place in the Middle East where Arab people have political rights is the State of Israel. Palestinians will tell you "sad, but true."

[@rhonda6791]

What an extraordinary woman. What an extraordinary family. Thank you for your intelligence and strength of character Nurit.

[@123lna]

I would love to see this Woman as a guest lecturer in Balkan Umiversities, she is amazing

[@mjxsh3lm]

Thank you Nurit Peled 🙏 She speaks with so much humanity and clarity.

[@JRJackman-qs8ph]

Thank you Frank and Nurit for speaking the truth.

[@noahburstein7541]

How do you know she is speaking the truth? Is she being challenged by another point of view?

[@SS-xv7xf]

@@noahburstein7541Yes, she is speaking the truth from experience.She was born and raised in Israel and has come to know tragedy first hand relating to the occupation.She is a survivor of the Israeli collateral damage machine.

[@radhikaschwartz3499]

This is not truth.this is one opinion.

[@stephaniecarrow4898]

​@@noahburstein7541 She quotes the soldiers from "Breaking the Silence." She quotes the textbooks. She references the trips to Auschwitz that precede military service. What parts of that do you deny, and what is your evidence?

[@jeffreyJavad]

@@stephaniecarrow4898 jus trying to weasel out of the corner

[@msin43]

Brave honest lady. What’s right is always right whether the state tries to shut it down or not.

[@khaderlander2429]

The courage it takes to speak the bitter truth takes iron determination and deep self reflection, she is someone who integrated her shadow and feels at peace.

[@collins48lc]

You mean Hamas propagandist

[@penyarol83]

@@collins48lcgo take your tired nonsense somewhere else

[@jullietmburu9672]

​@@collins48lclol... That line has been used to shreds.. it's a badge og honour at this point! It shows that someone is thinking for his/herself..

[@iamthenews5624]

“Nazism is a state with an army to exterminate minorities” -Nurit Peled

[@emmaslyons]

in this case - Israel

[@onerider808]

Like Ukraine, except they are not just theoretical nazis, but proud and unapologetic ones.

[@gregkle9384]

@@emmaslyonsIsrael must be doing poor job if population of Palestinian Arabs just grows

[@AnnAnsley]

No, like the entire Middle East and North Africa that is a Muslim, Arabic colony where there are no Jews, Christians, or any others since Islam is completely intolerant of others. There were all of these groups and pagans before the Islamic invasions!

[@AnnAnsley]

What does she think that Hamas wants, if not EXACTLY THAT? I am amazed that this is a professor since she lacks any logic, and seems to be as ignorant as the Woke crowd.

[@angelagladstone8863]

Thank you for this interview and a much much needed voice for the world to hear!

[@victormeidan1062]

A voice of an extremely mentally sick woman.

[@sorayavanderschyff937]

As a muslim myself, i stand with Palestine. I find this so heartwarming that a Jewish person speaking up against Israeli genocide in Palestine. Thank you There is justice in this world Alhamdullilah

[@j.m.johnson9970]

There are Jews in Israel who don't want to genocide the Palestinians. The lame-stream media won't give these people a voice.

[@kfelb8676]

Thankyou Frank and Nurit. This is vital journalism.

[@julierozo]

Yes! We need to stop teaching obedience! Thank you for this interview.

[@maymunahsydow6276]

What an amazing interview of an amazing women so honest and identifiable and i dare say revolutionary makes me almost want to go out there and educate and implement immediately! For both adults and children! Suffer little children that are taught to have this blind obedience to adults who do not deserve it and adults who expect them to! And children who do not inherently subscribe to that blindness are often victimised! Cos children know they know but it is largely suppressed so when an adult speaks they trust often to the putting them in great danger even they feel it! Hats off to u Proffessor from the bottom of my heart! Will follow ur advice indeed! Not everybody has their total well being at heart! Ot is notably the very young male and female that man these checkpoints often brutalising the Palestinians what will happen one day when they wake up how will they ever live with themselves! So the system is not only cruel to the Palestinians but to them to!

[@joegunner1702]

Good people still exist.thank you Nurit

[@happydays4302]

Fantastic. Thank you. Shows why representation is SO important in education and at home. I grew up in an all white area of the world but i had dolls of colour as a child. Its not just feeling we are represented, but also that we humanise minorities that may not be represented in that environment. So pleased to see lego has started to include figures with limb differences for example.

[@olivejam]

A brave Jewish scholar that makes a great roll model for a Palestinian. If everyone put their humanity ahead of any other allegiance the world would be a better place

[@pleajin6014]

Yes she is a great model like other of her friends that kidnapped or tortured and slaughtered even that Hamas terrorists knew who they are. They came with exact information who lives in each house.

[@olivejam]

@@pleajin6014 it seems that you misunderstood what I meant. what I meant is as a Palestinian decadent she is a roll model for me to speak out against the wrong that my people do. if everyone have her courage to speak against the grip they belong to the world would be a better place. Peace to all

[@pleajin6014]

@@olivejam This is exactly the point. When you have a terrorist entity that its all existence stands on slaughtering another. Read the Hamas declarations. Any , but any excuse to their cause is like throwing oil into the fire. Fire will die only when people like her will start to understand that she is part of the problem not part of the solution.

[@jullietmburu9672]

​@@pleajin6014given that women & Children are the main casualties, how many pregnant women and toddlers took the information to hamas.. there's no excuse for the retaliation killings Israel is still committing.

[@MR-dm1gx]

This is incredible, I am just floored of what they are doing. Unbelievable.

[@TDIA8]

Thank you Frank! A much needed most realistic articulation which covers all the aspects of the ongoing conflict.

[@ideas5663]

I always wonder why the Palestinians are paying the price for what the German did. The Palestinians didn't hurt the jews, it was Europe, right?

[@uriburstein4309]

When ur friend in Israel , the great Arab leader Hussein flew to Berlin to have tea with Hitler , well strange bedfellows indeed .

[@loneranger4469]

​@@uriburstein4309Lots of people met each other those days...and lots changed over those years of war. Non-aggression pacts were signed with Hitler and then broken for bloody wars. Fact still remains...Palestinians are paying price for Europe's crimes.

[@traceybaldwin6509]

I dare say that it was the Zionists all along who hurt the Jews (going back to at least WWI). Israel wouldn’t exist except for the Holocaust. The Zionists needed Jewish death and suffering. They needed them kept from immigrating to other countries (by having those borders closed and forcing them to Palestine). Jewish banking supported Hitler’s rise. Hitler agreed to Jews transfer to Palestine. Zionists leaders refused to help get many Jews to safety because they needed the collective Jewish suffering (ends justifies the means). I think this is one reason why it’s illegal to question/research the Holocaust in many European countries.

[@penyarol83]

That’s the illogic of scapegoating and displaced blame

[@uriburstein4309]

My bad , it was a typo. Husseini .

[@ESO529]

What a great human being - my highest respect for Nurid Peled especially also in view of what she must have gone through when she lost her daughter due to the action of freedom fighter. Yet she and her brother Miko are steadfast in fighting for justice for an oppressed people - absolutely incredible. Thank you!!

[@halimawaley]

Thank you Nurit for your stand and humanity. Thank you Frank for arranging the interview. Peace and May God Bless you.

[@imad54321]

Intelligent conversation. We thirst for this.

[@nl04uq]

Thank you for this interview. Nurit Peled is an amazing human being. The world would be a better place if there were more people with her empathy and humanity. After everything she has been through, she has the intelligence and morality to objectively analyze what others claim is a “complex” situation and humanize Palestinians.

[@jdlotus8253]

Wonderful talk, thank you. A joy to find it, just as I'm finishing reading her brother's book.

[@amtulhafeez3149]

Thank you so much Nurit for speaking publicly about the problem. It's going to be people like you who give hope to people who are so distressed atm.

[@dottester3039]

Nurit how marvellous to hear your expression experience views analysis. Much appreciated, love from Yorkshire England

[@Halcyontimes]

Great interview! Thanks for sharing your insights on the matter, Ms. Peled_Elhanan, and thx to Frank for hosting and conducting. Greetings from Berlin.

[@mareemacpherson9454]

Dr. Peled - a rational intelligent humane woman. Thank you!

[@OneBlurryLens]

They will never show this on main stream US and UK news media.

[@KhalidMedani-fs8us]

Profound and chilling. She is a heroine of truth.

[@patriziatrevisan921]

What a strong and incredible wonderful woman!!!!!

[@theLORDGod_G450]

Thank you both for this great conversation. Texas, USA, here. I agree!

[@MagdiNonDuality]

Very wise lady. She is clear that Oct 7 was not the beginning of the conflict.

[@noahburstein7541]

Correct. The Palestinian leaders have failed for many decades to acknowledge a simple truth. There is an Israeli nation with the right of self determination just as their is a Palestinian nation with the right of self determination. Ergo, don't shoot, talk.

[@MagdiNonDuality]

@@noahburstein7541 Noah, you speak without verifying whether what you are saying is fiction or truth. In 1993 the PLO fully recognized Israel. What followed is that Israel did not follow up by ceasing the occupation of the territories occupied in 1967. It is so frustrating to meet people like you who speak without having done their homework. Please refer to the historians. I recommend Norman Finkelstein Ilan Pappe Avi Shlaim Benni Morris Do your homework.

[@itzelouise8714]

@@noahburstein7541blah blah blah bullshit

[@OneCash]

@@noahburstein7541 the world that you think exists, doesn't exist. you've been lied to. a lot.

[@meganbaker9116]

This must be Miko Peled’s sister, no? She’s sharp!

[@concreteisland2024]

Yes, his sister. Both wonderful, intelligent and decent people.

[@sidraali9967]

Mr. Barat and Ms. Peled thank you so much for this interview. I learned alot and I have so much to read and educate myself. But I really want to thank you for this insightful conversation. I hope you are both well and we can hear more from Professor Peled. ❤❤

[@nolacollins5889]

Non-compliance with evil!! Best advice ever from this amazing Educator. Thank you Nurit Peled Elhanan 🙏

[@ernestovalladares198]

Thank you Frank for the program because the people I hate to talk to seem honest, frank and it is not the typical propaganda of Israel, ordinary people, thanks from Chile

[@concreteisland2024]

Thank you for this excellent interview. Nurit is wonderful.

[@iamthenews5624]

“How come he cannot recognize his own cruelty now turned against him? How come he can't see his own savagery as a colonist in the savagery of these oppressed peasants who have absorbed it through every pore and for which they can find no cure? The answer is simple: this arrogant individual, whose power of authority and fear of losing it has gone to his head, has difficulty remembering he was once a man; he thinks he is a whip or a gun; he is convinced that the domestication of the "inferior races" is obtained by governing their reflexes. He disregards the human memory, the indelible reminders; and then, above all, there is this that perhaps he never know: we only become what we are by radically negating deep down what others have done to us.” Jean-Paul Sartre,

[@harune6594]

I think giving a platform to voices of internal dissidents such as Ms. Peled is extremely valuable.

[@yosri617]

Thank you for this interview. I know quite a bit about the Palestinian issue, but this was still eye opening to me.

[@mariapetrova9259]

What an amazing, wise, honest and compassionate lady! And so very brave. I am speechless with admiration ❤

[@fadatty2756]

I never knew that I would hear a great Jewish woman as Nurit. Im so impressed by the level of your humanity. Its important to differentiate between jews and colonial zionists. Three religions existed on this land with all respect and understanding until the zionists came and destroyed everything and killed the indigenous people of Palestine.

[@dragtherapy]

absolutely brilliant! and eye opening

[@gulliegulliver4546]

Excellent, thank you both.

[@yasararif8292]

From the river to the sea humanity, humanity will prevail.

[@maurarodrigues1348]

Que mulher corajosa, não tem medo de disser, o seu ponto de vista obrigada

[@nads5907]

Great guest, great host.

[@LornaC474]

Thank you for this video! It sheds a lot of light on the situation!

[@baderel-safadi6603]

So beautiful. Thank you for standing with the truth. May your soul and life be always blessed.

[@mridwansyah1198]

Thanks for sharing truth voice ❤

[@kathleenborsch1312]

Current discussions about invasion, colonialism, and apartheid of Palestine and other countries around the world should also include the Americas! I am aware more than ever of the actions done to the Native peoples in the history of what is now called the United States of America, of which I am an older proud citizen and Army veteran, and yet now so much more aware of the horrific things done in our own "land without a people", with plenty of room for Europeans to fill it up, the idea we had as children. Now as I join my voice with others for the Palestinian people, I realize I must also help with the immense amount of work to do here back home. I really enjoyed listening to your interview. This discussion gives more insight to the situation. I am joining with a large church group, within the international community, to confront our leaders about their complicity with the policies of the state of Israel, and to inform more Americans of the truth. Thank you both!

[@1960Reem]

Thank you for this video

[@sun10lion]

Nurit, I want to thank-you for showing such courage in speaking publicly at what must be a re-traumatizing time for you.

[@ZelM-hz1ob]

I wish USA EU UK Politicians could listen and learn from Ms Nurit Peled instead of listening to psychopath Netanyahu

[@AliceWatts-d3v]

Thank you, thank you, thank you 🙏 for this wonderful, enlightening & ending on the strength of another way from the UK