Obvious Suspect in Reporter's Mysterious Murder is Never Charged | Sarah Greenhalgh Case Analysis

[@Steven-rp8zo]

Sentenced to 90 days in jail and only served 4. "Compassion for criminals is cruelty for their victims."

[@jessieyork4508]

You can thank George & Alex Soros for this "Hug A Thug" mentality.

[@ojgsk8ter]

I don’t think this is true. We can and should have compassion for both. Having compassion for a criminal doesn’t mean we need to let them off the hook. It’s very possible to feel compassion for someone who commits a crime but still believe they need to go to prison for a long time. We should try to find it in our hearts to see the humanity in everyone regardless of what they’ve done or whether they need to be in prison for the benefit of society. As a Christian I believe this is one of the most difficult but also most important lessons that Christ taught us. If a criminal took a loved one away from me I’d of course be furious and probably hate them and I can’t blame anyone for feeling that way. I’d still try to let go of that hate, for the sake of my own heart, however, regardless of how difficult it might be.

[@Meh-j9s]

Thanks democrats

[@Meh-j9s]

@@ojgsk8terstupid is stupid. Compassion is compassion. You seem to confuse this

[@aaronblank2318]

​@@jessieyork4508 10000000%

[@theresalafrance8383]

I love Dr. Grande's very subtle sense of humor. I crack right up, but somehow he does it with a completely straight face.

[@Katarina-ds5mj]

He tortured animals?! Well I hate him. I already thought he was guilty of murder.

[@MooseGuy1]

I hate the idea of torturing animals, too, but I have an honest question. Why do some people seem to be considerably more appalled by hurting animals than hurting people? I think both are horrible but to me hurting a person is worse. I see this over and over in comment sections and I'm truly puzzled. I'm asking out of a true curiosity, not to be a troll. Thanks, and have a great day, Katarina.

[@johnryder557]

​@MooseGuy1 yea I agree I think some people are perverse in that way.

[@patriciafeehan7732]

Never a good sign.

[@LevelEarthWD]

For me animals are innocents like babies and children. Thats what i find appalling about it. No one should harm anything or anyone. But those hurting animals are the worst of mankind​@MooseGuy1

[@eyeforiron9819]

@@MooseGuy1 How humans treat animals is the easiest way to see at what level the child/adult has social feeling. Cruelty at any stage indicates a lack of empathy, hence why it is important to socialize our children with other children and animal's if possible. If empathy is stunted or missing a warped sense of social feeling can develop into later sociopathy or psychopathy.

[@felonious_c]

I hope Dr. Grande never has to speculate on a situation like mine, if he starts giving his opinion on you, you've done something very wrong.

[@Cerbera66]

And then you are perhaps exeedingly creepy 😬

[@martins.7060]

@@Cerbera66 I was just going to say the same thing.

[@Cerbera66]

​@@martins.7060😂😆

[@JohnathanFireeater]

I'd like to see him speculate on our resident spambot in the comments section

[@piotrekski-420]

So what did you do? What is a situation like yours? Was it animal abuse that time you put sunglasses on your cat for your profile pic? Or an actual crime perhaps? You do use the handle "felonious_c". Are you a felon then? Is your cat a felon? I have so many questions... Come on, tell us tell us tell us... please?

[@sjohnson65456]

Only about 4 minutes in, but this woman seriously posted a Facebook post announcing that her windows would be wide open?!

[@enjoystraveling]

I think she wanted fresh air and she was out in the countryside, but of course it’s not a good idea to announce it on Facebook.

[@alltheliliesbloomed]

Shocking that single people too need oxygen and ventilate their homes, isn't it? 😱

[@jena.alexia]

I think the same when some of my friends/acquaintances on FB announce that the whole family has gone camping - great! You've just announced to the world your house is vacant for several days or weeks.

[@enjoystraveling]

@ but their address is not on Facebook. Also, I hope.

[@michaelwelch9123]

​@@alltheliliesbloomedyou ok dude? The surprise is not about being single or leaving windows open, it's about announcing your vulnerability to the world.

[@FroggyBarnett]

Good morning, Dr G. Happy Sunday (and Australia Day) here on Sydney. Have an awesome day

[@RullVox]

Sentenced to 90 days in jail and only had to serve 4. This shows how these protective orders are worthless words on paper, and how too many judges don't take them seriously.

[@Riley_sd]

Have a wonderful weekend Dr.and Mrs. Grande.

[@rickh3714]

I await his so far absent analysis of that 'salute'. The one that so upset my WW2 Blitz survivor mother.

[@Surfnyolly]

May she RIP and I hope justice is served. Thank you for sharing this story.

[@KenOath42]

Happy Australia Day all you beautiful Aussies!

[@janecee5499]

Thank you for the kind wish... But you may want to do a bit of reading regarding the controversy of the day/date.... It's not a positive for all Australians...

[@KenOath42]

@@janecee5499I'm a 5th gen Australian. Done all the reading I need to do. If you don't love Australia fck off. If you don't love our freedom fck off. If you don't love our way of life fck off. And most importantly, if you don't love Vegemite fck off!

[@michellesartori6695]

​@janecee5499 As an Aboriginal Australian, I concur! We consider it a day of mourning. Take care now.

[@piotrekski-420]

@@janecee5499 Jane I'll bet pretty much EVERYTHING is "problematic" to you. You must be so happy with your life, and so much fun to hang out with too.

[@piotrekski-420]

Cheers Mate! And a very happy Australia Day to you too!

[@zeronzemesh7718]

This lady posted to Facebook that she was home alone with the windows open? Then she gets killed? Suspect pool is endless after that stupid post.

[@alltheliliesbloomed]

So you're not supposed to ventilate your house if you live alone? The lenghts some of you people go with your bs victim-blaming is truly appalling..

[@Itshellonheels]

@@alltheliliesbloomedI think the observation of the victim posting that, then being murdered … makes people feel *sad* … not “wow, how stupid”.. 🥱

[@michaelwelch9123]

​@@alltheliliesbloomeddude, seriously are you OK?

[@thecatatemyhomework]

​​@@alltheliliesbloomedyou can ventilate your house all you want but don't be dumb enough to post it for the world to see that your windows are open, come and get me.

[@MrNelsonButterscotch]

@@alltheliliesbloomed Yeaah don't post online that you're going to be sleeping alone with all the windows open in your house. Who needs to know that about you?

[@scottnance2200]

For those who aren't familiar with it, Upperville is one of the wealthiest small communities in the United States. It's where people move when they think Middleburg is too plebian.

[@thelocalmaladroit8873]

If the name fits…

[@mikejohnson2098]

Glad your here to educate we red necks.

[@MG-ot2yr]

It is, I'm in Leesburg and have been looking at property there, not because its wealthy but its very pretty. Middleburg would be fine too.

[@markiangooley]

Strikes me as a real Downerville!

[@WayneAugustine-r4v]

take me to flavor town

[@SwordsmanScrapper]

The OJ Simpson and Casey Anthony joke was brutal! Haha

[@ambergriffes6122]

Good Afternoon Dr. Grande, thank you for your informative analysis on this case. It's always appreciated

[@LBdreamin]

Dr. Grande gang, my dog Georgie says, “hi” (but in woof form). We hope you’re all doing well out there. We love ya Dr. Grande. Thanks for the consistent content :)

[@liliannaogrady1391]

My shih tzu Leah says woof back. Maybe they can be paw pals. lol

[@jamesoncross7494]

Emails and text messages can be retrieved. Why wouldn't they retrieve them?

[@coldbringer9545]

Wouldn't they have access to all of them from Sarah's side of the exchange? John deleting his account contents doesn't quite fix it the way he may think. They would need a search warrant to recover something of his, but not Sarah's.

[@plinden]

Imagine having an argument with Dr Grande and get a description of your personality. How do you ever recover?

[@LoveOneAnotherHeSaid]

One beer at a time.

[@filipefigueiredo9847]

​@@LoveOneAnotherHeSaid not if he were to describe you as "exceedingly creepy"; there's absolutely no way to come back from that and no amount of beer would ever be able to lift such a curse

[@patriciafeehan7732]

Describe his personality. Dr. Grande is not above criticism.

[@297banu]

Well, I'd count my blessings. I may have a myriad of negative qualities but at least I'm not "exceedingly creepy".

[@fishhuntadventure]

It bothers me that people worry about being speculated over. If your hands are clean it wouldn’t matter, now, would it?

[@allegraeknight-byrnes883]

Sarah was blunt but never obnoxious. She was beloved by all. Her funeral was standing room only. Suspicious thing you neglect to mention: the fire was started in her office and that is where the greatest damage was done. Why would a lover want to destroy work product?

[@matthew.stevick]

ur channel is one of the best on u-tube, all categories. fan for years and never miss a video. thx snd love from ur favorite states _new jersey_ 🇺🇸

[@willwong1234]

This is a typical case of being not guilty does not mean being innocent.

[@thomas_2285]

I was waiting for the sword of Damocles reference and wasn't disappointed! 😄

[@eyeforiron9819]

What about Sarah's comment on being an accessory to something he said.. that begs a serious question.

[@d.jensen5153]

She might have considered herself an accessory-after-the-fact simply by knowing what he'd done but not taking action.

[@Forgottenworlds777]

I wish she just reported him after that knowledge

[@Stelutza100]

Always looking forward to Dr. Grande's daily uploads!

[@maryrichardson6029]

I've to busy listening to your old pod casts. Always interesting Thank you❤

[@amandaduerk5866]

Just had to come here and say I saw you on the Bryan Johnson documentary “Don’t Die!” Look at how famous you are!!!!! Was very proud, and shouted at the tv, “oh look!!! It’s my guy!!!!” Cuz I watch your KZbin videos all the time! 😜☺️🥰

[@gabrieloak9852]

Doctor Large has such a calm voice.

[@LarissaSimpson]

Why would anyone familiar with true crime sleep with the windows open, much less post on Facebook for the whole world to see that she was doing so? Not to blame the victim.

[@CarnivoreStork]

Did the detectives check for gun residue on his hands/underneath nails. Did the detectives check ring cameras in her neighborhood for his car during the murder time period? Police departments are getting more & more lazy.

[@allegraeknight-byrnes883]

Unfortunately this was 13 years ago before Ring cameras were prevalent.

[@Steve-Pitt]

Too much reasonable doubt. But it seems pretty likely he did it

[@amandawilson9555]

Good one, Dr. Grande. I like how you added further observations about why Sarah chased after this man, as her love interest. Your point is very valid. Some key points in society seem broken, where women have to desperately struggle to take care of themselves and then might find themselves with an undesirable person.

[@mademsoisellerhapsody]

Sarah may have been attracted by his bad boy persona. When someone tells you who they are, believe them.

[@MJFish]

As someone with an overly bold personality, yes, it is helpful, and yes, it can be isolating.

[@Bonnie-cu5hx]

Thank you Dr.Grande very informative analysis enjoyed and looking forward to your next video. Stay safe 🦋

[@Peel420]

A word thrown around a lot, maybe too much these days, is toxic. However, in this case the word certainly seems to fit this relationship. Two loud, opinionated, outspoken individuals, who don't want to back down and are accustomed to getting their own way and it's a recipe for disaster. Add to that that one of them has a history of harmful, violent behaviours and arson and it would appear quite clear what happened. 🙏🏻 That solid evidence can be found. Justice for Sarah. RIP.

[@MooseGuy1]

Facingbooking the fact that a single woman is leaving all the windows open is reasonable doubt by itself.

[@johnpomerville7398]

@@georgiegirl8345 It's like an open invitation for trouble. The post was sent out before the murder. It is a great way to buy a "Get Out of Jail Free" card for the real murderer. Literally anyone and everyone could've seen this. She might as well have added, "The door is open, too. I'm wearing a sexy negligee, and my house is full of untraceable cash."

[@willnill7946]

As obvious as it is he did it, that’s how innocent people end up in prison. Many DAs have no problem charging people whom they feel are obviously guilty

[@ReComy-h8f]

You're an absolute machine Dr. Grande.

[@Wanderlust246]

I don’t ever want my name passing through Dr. Grande’s lips because that means I’m either dead or in big trouble.

[@WorldOfEnchantment44]

I got hit and run by a drunk driver the night before last. I caught the whole thing on camera, the video allowed the CHP to go directly to the persons house. They never arrested the driver. I asked why. Even though they have a suspended license, no insurance, hit my vehicle with my children in it and drove away, all on film, I was told because they chose not to answer the door when they knocked, they can’t prove the person was drunk at the time. They gave no mind to the fact the drunk driver has a prior that is the reason they have no insurance, has been in 6 drunken vehicle incidents that involved the need for police to arrive and, I later found out, is well known as the town drunk and is banned from all but 2 bars in town. The video I provided showed law enforcement the person in the act of committing the crime and it also showed they were clearly impaired in some way by their strange behavior. All of this and law enforcement told be last night as I left the Emergency Room, they were not going to pursue charges. I am so sorry to this family. She deserves justice! Apparently even committing crimes on camera will not motivate law enforcement to do their job and protect the community from deadly people. What a world we lived in. Her death could have been preventable and at the very least, they should have dug a lot harder for answers to find the killer. I’m sorry and I understand the frustration you as her family must have with the lack of motivation from law enforcement to solve your crime.

[@jgc0160]

That's crazy. Yeah, they can't prove the guy was drunk, but I don't understand how they can't charge him with a hit and run still. Also, if they know the guy is in the house. They should be able to get an arrest warrant for the hit and run. Which would then allow them to also find out he was drunk.

[@fran-gx3kf]

Crazy. Like Sarah's case, nothing seems to move and get done. A lot could be pursued but poor department management/staff detective work and morale? Having proof and practically being "ignored" is not right.

[@PyrPupMom]

Civil suit? You don't have to be drunk to be guilty of a hit and run!!!

[@PyrPupMom]

Take it to the paper, might get some coverage and attention.

[@bugeater16]

Sending Sarah away because you are expecting a booty call arriving exactly around the time of the murder is actually an alibi. The fact that this lady didn’t show up is very interesting. I wonder what her alibi was.

[@CatharinePizzarello]

This was beautiful, Dr Grande!

[@zrwz66]

His motive was silencing her bc she had knowledge of prior serious felonies he'd committed.

[@sugarsnap7883]

You're The Best Grande !

[@Brittany25-j6f]

By "outspoken" and "abrasive," I assume you mean "rude."

[@tuvia4082]

Thank you Dr. Grande.

[@ExpandingHeart]

Love the "O.J. Simpson & Casey Anthony Detective Agency"! You always entertain while also informing, and it's appreciated. I hope that you are your wife are well, and I look forward to more of your content.

[@carlyrennae3963]

Happy Australia Day feels Dr G 🇦🇺

[@LúciaKitten]

Great analysis, Dr. Grande!

[@oldsteve4291]

I went for a job interview and was asked, 'Which three words best describe your personality.' Having been raised to be honest, I replied, ' Opinionated, abrasive, angry.' They did not get back to me.

[@maremacd]

She posted on Facebook that her windows were open. Somebody else may have tried to exploit that opportunity.

[@shelleynobleart]

Insightful at the very end. Nice one.

[@HAMZAPINE]

Psychedelics are just an exceptional mental health breakthrough. It's quite fascinating how effective they are against depression and anxiety. Saved my life.

[@carly102982]

Can you help with the reliable source I would really appreciate it. Many people talk about mushrooms and psychedelics but nobody talks about where to get them. Very hard to get a reliable source here in Australia. Really need!

[@nathanfoss2838]

I'm calling the authorities on you guys. It's illegal in Australia

[@verotaylor]

1:40 for a split second I thought the firefighter was called 911

[@curoseba5363]

😅totally see why

[@BadYogiAGB]

I hope this is the dr grande video that leads to a conviction

[@jasonsmith373]

I live in this region - there are a lot of John's and a lot of Sarah's around here.

[@mademsoisellerhapsody]

😅😅😅

[@garyw9164]

If I was a detective and working on a case, having Dr. Grande in on the case would be of great value and time saved.

[@zenawarrior7442]

I agree with your analysis. He has time on his side & he is guilty. Great points & funny quips on the detective agency names. Thanks Dr G😊💜🤍

[@bettinabarry8423]

I hope Dr. Grande's analysis brings back interest in the case, and perhaps it will be solved.

[@puspavelai8353]

As a reporter, she was the least favorable choice for a man with a bad behavior history. Also, may be she was, uhm taunting him with exposing his un lawful actions as a way of keeping him from straying too far - so, he ended it permanently.

[@susansandler8429]

My favorite part of the video was your wisdom at the end.

[@ankejacobs4649]

Thank you Dr G ❤

[@timothywenzel5020]

Just checking in to see if Dr. Grande uses miles or minutes to measure distance this time.

[@TrustMe55]

I went back and listened to your analysis all over again and took notes. Sarah like solving mysteries so she created her own mystery framing her boyfriend that was finished with her as her murderer when she committed suicide m. a day earlier they were at the apartment. Arguing left him messages saying I’ve always been there for you.Stating she could get 25 to life for an accessory probably to her own crime. then leaves a message on Facebook for everybody to see that she’s gonna leave her windows open. What sense does that make? They find some of her personal items probably some she want to save from the fire in her trunk. Another clue she probably knew John’s history. I think Sarah was suicidal but didn’t wanna let John off so easily, so framed him for her death. Mystery solved.!

[@cplmpcocptcl6306]

After she was fatally injured where did she hide the gun that was shot 12xs?

[@MegaTinni]

No CCTV?

[@DEPARTMENTOFREDUNDANCYDEPT]

"The sword of Damoclese!" Nice classical reference, Dr. Grande!

[@thelocalmaladroit8873]

I agree completely with you Dr Grande, there’s just not enough here to arrest John. More speculation than anything else.

[@edwardwong654]

He did it. Charge and convict him.

[@MimiRAM0NE]

Announcing that you are going to sleep with all your windows open in the same post about being bothered by a crazy man sounds bizzare to me. Kinda like a set up?

[@ProudCanadian-vv6bk]

What about the 'other woman' who didn't show up at his house that night?

[@divinorum3328]

Dr. Grande For President

[@ShonaPeterson13]

I’m a fellow big cactus fan I love the big guy in the background I keep expecting him to chime in into his mic there with his opinion on the case 😂 maybe because here in Aberdeen Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 we have a famous talking cactus called spike at a local park he’s so cool

[@LoveOneAnotherHeSaid]

Dear Shona, does that Aberdeen cactus have an accent? - Ev.

[@vickislominski7618]

Shona, is "local park" code for local pub? Cuz I could see that happening. 😉

[@ShonaPeterson13]

@ it’s voiced by volunteers and local radio presenters so it’s pretty Aberdonian but I really feel he should have an accent eh it’s just lazy that he doesn’t imo lol he’s called spike 😜 🌵

[@ShonaPeterson13]

@@vickislominski7618 lol no that would be so much more fun! it’s actually a place called the winter gardens where it’s supposed to be a recreation of the desert but as it’s run by the local council the budget is extremely low it’s hot and has cactus in it that’s about the only similarities 😆

[@kittenclawsguitarvideos6147]

Could it be Joanne? I think it's most likely John but one needs concrete evidence.

[@Kerry-od4cl]

Torturing animals is a huge sign of a sadistic person; she should have recognized that with her penchant for true crime; perhaps her emotional need for a partner overrode her spidey sense!

[@derpherpp3]

Emails doesn’t goes deleted when you deleted them and emptied trashes because they are being stored for years by google. But still the recipients still have copies of his emails, but I’m sure there’s more to just he deleted emails since they got a whole cyber forensic teams

[@briancoleman971]

Definitely something he told her about and her reaction was why he would have a motive to kill her.

[@scottc95]

Dr. Grande can you take a look at the Jared Dicus case , please and give your analysis. ( young man who ended his wifes life in dec. 2024) I see some videos on it but none that really dive into it. Thanks

[@gypsydildopunks7083]

Have you done a video on the disappearance of Kara kopetsky? It was another obvious case. They knew who the killer was but didn't put enough pressure on him until he killed again. Maybe more dead we do not know about. Suburban KCMO Metropolitan area.

[@j.c.curnes]

Well I don't like that he has my name.

[@yasminenazarine1629]

We used to live in Virginia and worked in fall church

[@MichaelLucas-c6u]

In the wrong place at the wrong time.

[@jabrowski_]

I feel like John thinks he's John Cena sometimes. Great episode, Doc

[@Flamsterette]

Thanks for the upload, Dr. Grande! Your TRUE fans love your humor and sarcasm. January 25 is Macintosh Computer Day again, Cookie Legend Day, Fluoride Day, Tatiana Day, National Irish Coffee Day, and Opposite Day.

[@JohnathanFireeater]

Out of curiosity what does this have to do with the video? Looks like anything a spambot would post.

[@FroggyBarnett]

It’s also Rum Rebellion Day (jokingly) here in Australia 😂

[@Flamsterette]

@@FroggyBarnett Ha! That's a nice one!

[@FroggyBarnett]

@ about as much as most other comments, including yours

[@FroggyBarnett]

@ true story 🤭 “The Rum Rebellion was a military coup in 1808 that overthrew the government of New South Wales, Australia. It was the only time in Australian history that a military coup was used to overthrow a government. “

[@kirpalani-griffin3706]

It's difficult to not conclude that this man was responsible and also is a psychopath. But of course the evidence is needed.

[@andrews527]

When you come from better, stay away from the Joey Buttafuoco guy.

[@coldbringer9545]

Maybe it was the off-duty fireman who reported the fire.

[@_Kittensworth]

You know when Dr. Grande pronounces someone's full name, it's a bad sign.

[@JDoe001]

Narcissistic control freaks do not hesitate to destroy people they very much desire to but cannot control. I have family like that.

[@StacySanseverino]

That’s some harsh conjecture about her personality and how no one likes her for it

[@MissMiaAfroGoddess]

Not the Casey Anthony detective agency 🤣🤣🤣

[@tod3msn]

No statute of limitations for murder. Why rush a charge without enough evidence for trial?

[@mrazik131]

What was she writing about being accomplice and get 25to life ? Did not get that .

[@JoseAntoniocastilhosvolcatovol]

Neither did the cops.

[@marycleary-qe5ou]

Maybe he disclosed being involved in another crime

[@lizh6420]

CA & OJ associates law firm, funny, not funny, but kinda funny!

[@CMD4WP]

She accused him of having her involved as an accomplice in a very serious crime, right before her murder and in text, and also for the fact that anything sets him off (a motorcycle incident). Could have resulted in him having a large motive. (The method used is his trademark.) (Is burning someone's personal things so dear as photos or wedding dress a normal thing there in the US?) Or maybe what she accused him of having her involved in also involved/involves a policeman? May we know sooner than later, and may she RIP.

[@bobzelley5100]

Is that a Brooks brothers plaid shirt ?

[@johnmurphy7953]

A good job in walking a tightrope - guilty or not guilty - a gutsy call on naming the investigative firm. Take care not to open yourself up to lawsuits. We would miss your commentaries and analysis.

[@jolandasteffen3578]

She dsnt come across as a stupid woman who will post about leaving her windows open.the boyfriend posted that msg

[@captainsleeman9787]

It's not that she posted a silly post on Facebook, it's that she would use it at all.

[@DenieGayle]

Were cell phone pings investigated that would have placed him near her home?

[@vickilawrence7207]

OMG 😱 im loving it! She's telling him when and where the muskrat can go in the white house! I'll bet he is fit to be tied! 😮😂😂😂😅😊

[@joshuabradshaw2238]

#4!

[@sharonhoyt2133]

Whose DNA was on Sarah's clothes packed in the car?