What Would Happen If Gear 5 Luffy Was At Marineford?

[@JustEpik]

I think the 2 year timeskip would still happen because either Luffy or Rayleigh would realize that the rest of the crew is way less powerful than Luffy. But i think this time Luffy would train his fruit to an even higher power level and would learn to control gear 5 even better while the straw hats train much harder to be somewhat as strong as Luffy. Rayleigh might come up with the idea of the 2 year timeskip but i could also see Luffy coming up with it since i don't think he would be blinded by his strength and think that he could protect his crew without them having to train.

[@Renno802]

okay ohara need to make a continuation to this video but instead the strawhat have 2 year timeskip

[@Youngsickbacchus]

Since he gave luffy his haki as well he really doesn’t need Rayleighs training, which means Zoro and Sanji would get it instead. Maybe even chopper and Brook, although be may still go on tour

[@justsomeguywithnoeyes7303]

part of the reason why his crewmates trained so hard was because they saw the news that luffy suffered and lost his brother so they wanted to be strong for their captains sake

[@2araromi]

THIS VIDEO IS AN BANGER!!!

[@ultradragon3404]

You know that you're talking about a yonko right !

[@cayde69]

Ace's death was sad, but necessary for the character development of Luffy. The realisation that he couldn't protect his brother completely changed him for good.

[@nikamaxaradze4122]

thats why oda agenius

[@abhisheknethnya7119]

It was a canon event

[@iam-v8498]

@@nikamaxaradze4122 no the way he killed ace was kinda dumb no offense if you're a hardcore fan

[@nikamaxaradze4122]

@@iam-v8498 yeah but the show would be less fun man, let's just not argue. This was a Canon event.

[@lesliemariearcilla3236]

@@abhisheknethnya7119 bro watched spiderman ATSV too much transformers ROTB>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ATSV MILES IS A BLACK N*GGA

If Whitebeard could use advanced conqueror's haki coating at Marineford, he would use it against Akainu. His health didn't allow it.

[@zoro_lost69]

If he did not get betrayed he would have been able to use haki

@@zoro_lost69 nope. he was already sick. also he got lots of bullets and even cannon balls but they couldn't stop him. that sword attack didn't disabled his adv. CoH.

[@Joker-ik1sp]

The main reason he didn't use it I think is that haki wasn't nearly truly implemented at the point certainly not advanced conquerers

[@AnonTDegenerate]

@Joker-ik1sp you say that, but the Admirals used some form of Haki to stop the debris hitting them, while making no contact. I doubt Whitebeard had CoC, maybe advanced armourment, but not CoC. Even if he did tho, 3 Admirals is too much Edit: I meant old whiteboard didn't have CoC. That's my b

[@redeyexxx1841]

@@AnonTDegenerate Didn't WB already showed CoC in clash against Roger & Shanks? So what do you mean by didn't have CoC??

[@sanketgadge9060]

Having seen glimpse of shanks's power, divine departure, my respect for Mihawk is increased exponentially.

[@nick5839]

I think shanks and mihawks duels don’t go to that extreme, but they can if needed. I imagine their duels are kinda more like Dorry and Brogy, they clash equally until they reach a mutual point of stopping but never go full power, as shown when they kill the sea king together with their true power using Hakoku sovereignty

[@daedae2500]

@@nick5839 why wouldn't 2 rivals fight with all they're full power trying o defeat the other

[@nick5839]

@@daedae2500 it’s more so duels, like a genuine sword fight since they’re friends id like to imagine. No haki other than potentially observation needed in one. I’d like to believe that shanks haki can beat mihawks any day, but swordplay wise mihawk wins. That’s why mihawk doesn’t want to duel shanks with one arm, it’s an unfair duel of the swords, given that idea I don’t think they go all out when dueling. It’s different completely because id also like to reference aokiji vs akainu. They were effectively equals and rivals, their all out battle lasted days, so do you think this was the same for shanks and mihawk

[@daedae2500]

@@nick5839 doubt that since each other wanted out due each other

[@williamd9939]

@@sanketgadge9060 why ? Because he fought a dude who lost his arm against a fish ? 💀

[@BabuReyes]

Ohara's "What if's" storiesare pretty great. Tbh, I was devastated because of Ace's death. I was literally crying while denying the fact that he died but then it was indeed necessary for the character development of Luffy. I think Oda did great in writing One Piece.

[@joshshrum2764]

It definitely changed him, but then i feel like he still was rocked enough during waters 7, and post Sabaody, since it helped him be a better person, if anything the only thing Ace dying did was trigger training for 2 years, but then again wouldn’t he wanna train with the crew, or still do the Rayleigh plan after the war i feel like it could.

[@faizoktoraa]

I think even though Luffy's crewmate are underpowered, Some of his crew are also competitive and also Nami did ask usopp to make her a weapon to protect herself and to not be useless

[@osonhouston]

Nami and Usopp are best used as long-range attacks. She is best at taking out huge groups of targets, while Usopp is the next best thing to having the Sniper King on your crew.

[@durgeshchaturvedi9172]

that is why one piece better than naruto females in one piece are not trash like sakura

[@osonhouston]

@durgeshchaturvedi9172 argument is so old. One poorly written character doesn't negate the entire story.

[@durgeshchaturvedi9172]

@@osonhouston still all the characters in one piece get a story arc amd development and in naruto it's just naruto sasuke and akatsuki no one else

[@osonhouston]

@durgeshchaturvedi9172 Shikamaru, Gaara, Tamari, Kakashi, Tsunade, Neji, Sai, A, Iruka, and Ebisu had character growing. You praise Oda for all the time he gives to his characters, but that is one of the reasons the story rambles at time. Could Kishimoto have given some more time to his female characters? Yes, but there are things Oda can improve at as well.

[@djsreja1]

If Nika was at Marineford, ain't no chance Shanks is stopping Kaido, so there would be Luffy, Shanks, Whitebeard and Kaido fighting with marines and BB

[@bilogskii2216]

Why wouldn't Shanks be able to stop Kaido?

[@Cringeneth]

Change the k in "Nika" to gg.

[@anyuondeng2833]

@@Cringeneth 💀

[@9hundun516]

@@bilogskii2216 bc he stopped kaido from going to marineford why wouldn’t he be able to do it again😂

[@bilogskii2216]

@@9hundun516 That's why I'm saying. Luffy unlocking the Nika fruit doesn't change Shanks capabilities to stop Kaido.

[@PortgasDPale]

I absolutely love the "What if" videos you put out. Thanks for all the hard work, Manu. It really shows!

[@danielmogotsi7293]

Honestly 👌🏾🔥👑 keep them coming O-Dawg

[@July-gj1st]

Tbh, I think Golden Budha vs Gear 5 would be an awesome clash. Remember that Gear 5 is technically still Sun God Nika so it would be two literal god-like beings clashing.

[@dinotaim]

I mean ye that would be AWESOME

[@allshipper2158]

But was Sengoku as strong or stronger than he was at his younger age? That's a question.

[@ok-6732]

@@allshipper2158 like basically everyone in one piece , they are always stronger when they are young (in their thirties to fourties)

[@dontknowhat743]

They also have the same DF, just different models.

[@1nfinity513]

can old garp beat nika luffy? if answer is yes Sengoku can too. that's my take.

[@flighteldgar]

small correction on the what if. if he had successfully rescued ace and went immediately to the new world to do the things he is currently doing, he wouldn't meet kin'emon and the others because 20 years hasn't passed yet.

[@Madfootball-928]

I was about to say that

[@ryanhobbs6407]

I believe with Blackbeard, he may take the second, far scarier gamble of just grabbing ANY strong Devil Fruit (Akinu) who would have been severely beaten enough to possibly put down.

[@TheProphetLot]

bruh what your joking

[@Contemplatingspider]

Knowing black beard he would of swooped in and took it

[@strawhatchoji2535]

Nah there’s no way Akainu loses to bb before wb fruit

[@ryanhobbs6407]

@@strawhatchoji2535 Not in any kind of good condition, but after having his ass handed to him literally by Gear 5 and Whiteboard on the "Don't you dare touch Ace" train? He may be down bad enough that the impel down group and Blackbeard could manage.

[@zohaibahmed9738]

@@ryanhobbs6407 i mean there is a possibility considering akainu seems to be dependent on his devil fruit with the highest devil fruit ap but bb could just absorb it but still idk if he would lose considering whitebeard near death could have easily killed bb if he didnt use his gun

[@Bazorki]

I was just thinking the main reason Nami's punches hurt Luffy is not because of Haki but because Luffy imagined it would hurt!

[@AK-qq7cr]

Agree, Garp also

[@obmis_arraid21]

Nah it's just a gag, it's not that deep. Also luffy power doesn't works that way lol.

[@BurningVengeance]

@@obmis_arraid21 it does

[@thegoat4360]

@@BurningVengeance no it doesnt

[@thegoat4360]

@@AK-qq7cr garp uses haki on him

[@griffinmadsen1286]

Really cool idea! I love these ‘what if’ situations. One thing I can’t get off my mind though, would Luffy have learned/created moves like Red Hawk and Red Roc had Ace not been killed? Cause it seems like he kinda made them in memory of/in reference to Ace. Either way though, g5 Luffy would dominate this war for sure

[@nadrewod999]

Ace's death was a tragedy, but Jinbei helped Luffy pick the pieces back up and keep moving forward. It pushed him to stop flying by the seat of his pants and actually focus purely on training for the first time since his voyage started, while hearing about Ace's death in the newspaper made all of the Strawhats realize how much suffering their captain was going through because of how weak they all still were. Without Ace's death, Luffy would not have had the time to master his three kinds of Haki enough to have Gear 4 stable in time for Dressrosa (not to mention Luffy likely avoiding Dressrosa if Doflamingo hadn't announced Ace's Devil Fruit as the tournament prize), and he wouldn't have had enough experience with both Gear 4 and fighting Awakened Devil Fruit users to unleash Gear 5 on Kaido. Luffy simply didn't have enough battle experience or training to pull off anything close to Gear 5 by the time of Marineford. He already spent years training on Grey Terminal's island just getting used to his Devil Fruit, so if he had started his journey earlier, he would have been even less reliable in a fight, and would have likely missed the golden recruiting opportunities for many of his current crew (Zoro not being set up for a firing squad execution, Ussop not having the courage to follow his dreams without seeing the Strawhats' capabilities defending the island from a pirate invasion, Nami still being a few years away from having enough money for Arlong to have the Navy rat steal it, Chopper not being encountered if Nami wasn't terminally ill with a disease from Little Garden, Robin still being a few years away from Crocodile's "Project Utopia" coming to fruition, Franky not recognizing the determination and integrity of the Strawhat crew without Ussop or his hometown's Going Merry ship). Also, the earlier Luffy gets on the Navy's radar, the closer all of their Old Guard will be to their physical primes, meaning that they'd be even stronger. Realistically, there's no way this is possible without the kind of time travel shenanigans you only see in bad filler arcs or complex sci-fi stories.

[@ahmadbintang9697]

jinbei da goat

[@siaupenggan3973]

Bro wrote a whole essay just for marinefort 💀

[@Wakozi]

To be honest, I think if the events had played out this way during the Marineford arc, the manga would have ended much quicker, but not in a satisfying manner. If Luffy had appeared as G5 at Marineford, Imu and the Gorosei would have caught wind of it much faster than they did during the events of Wano. Remember, when they learned about G5, they reacted by sending one of the Gorosei over to Egghead to deal with it (ofc due to Vegapunk's involvement along with Luffy being there). However, this information came from a somewhat unreliable CP0 agent's report. But if Luffy had shown up as G5 at Marineford, there would have been no doubt in their minds that G5 Luffy was, in fact, Joyboy. I wouldn't even be surprised if all 5 Gorosei had immediately rushed to Marineford. Despite Luffy and his allies' strength, I believe the Gorosei would have eventually overcome them. Alternatively, if the Gorosei didn't go to Marineford, they might have chosen to bide their time and target him when he and his crew were alone. In that scenario, it would have been a lost cause because the other Straw Hats wouldn't stand a chance against them.

[@elitealpha3206]

😂 "Cause Because" 😂 dang!

[@24k_hallowen]

I ain't reading all that lol

[@24k_hallowen]

Holy yapp

[@edmonimcdaniel7700]

Ohara I just wanna say you put a lot of effort into your videos great job man 👊

[@Ohara-the-Fox]

Glad you like them!

[@Konsu08]

The biggest question that wasn't asked, is Sabo going to get his memories back? Because in the original the reason why he did was because Ace died. Would he show up? Eventually. But he wouldn't know who Ace or Luffy is and he wouldn't care. It would be an interesting meeting

[@indiantony8640]

it's little tricky cause if you assume they manage to free ace and this news spread like a fire staying that , luffy free his brother ace and probably luffy get even higher bounty and i thing this news far enough to bring sabo's memories back

[@jonsonatlas6649]

There should be an Arc, Specifically for Luffy. Luffy has been there for each and every member of the StrawHats Pirates difficult time. Especially, After the time Ace died.

[@mamtaskitchen3867]

Yes ur right

[@jonsonatlas6649]

@@Kayonde9994 Mf that's not what I mean🤦🏽‍♂️Obviously Luffy is the protagonist. Those arcs are centered to save his brother from execution. Did you seriously mention flashback? You donut. Luffy, needs an arc obviously in the present. Where his crew are there to burden his pain, not just Zoro🤦🏽‍♂️😂For example. Shanks dies or betrays Luffy. His crew are there just like Ace and Sabo was for Luffy.

[@paulooneeightthree9418]

@@Kayonde9994 I think your missing the point here. Read his comment again.

[@star-rock6466]

​@@jonsonatlas6649 you really had to act like an ass, huh ?

[@somebodythatisnobodyo9737]

The rest of the crew- That one overleveled starter.

[@bilal.khan1211]

Sabo’s story would be different as well cuz he wouldn’t have regained his memories and also wouldn’t have gotten the flare flare fruit cuz ace is still alive, so he would probably end up dying at marie joise

[@arjunwali9885]

Great video! Personally, I agree that Ace turns down pirate king but instead he and ALL of the whitebeard pirates go to war with the newly formed blackbeard pirates. Could be a great idea for a sequel video to see how that would turn out!

[@HakiKingRayleigh]

Just imagine the BEAST Whitebeard would've been with his awakening. Like, what would that even look like!?!

[@Mr.Death56]

I think Whitebeard's awakening can make the Earth destroyed quite badly

[@Iwillwinthis11]

​@@Mr.Death56 maybe it's already awakened

[@Mr.Death56]

@@Iwillwinthis11 Yes, I'm sure Prime WB has awakened his devil fruit, But Whitebeard has never shown his devil fruit awakening.

[@tyonteblack]

@@Mr.Death56 yea u rite, because Blackbeard as soon is he got it, he was able to use the fruit kinda like whitebeard.

[@c.h.3135]

@@Mr.Death56 It wouldn’t make sense for WB to use it since he’s trying to save Ace, and if his DF lives up to the factual statements he would kill Ace along with everyone else in one attack

[@sfkidstv216]

2:17 the sandals pointed out made me laugh to death Also luffy's scream was equally funny

[@gamerthings2559]

Marineford: Good Ending

[@Mrsausge]

The thumbnail is crazy Akainu is protecting ace now wow donut maker is the donut wow donut mess with donut maker number 2

[@bakshev]

Gear 5 Luffy in Marineford means that the pirates win. At this point he's stronger than Whitebeard was at Marineford.

[@mariusgiurgila2595]

Old Whitebeard yes. Peak whitebeard not yet

[@BeastBoy557]

@@mariusgiurgila2595 he literally said Whitebeard at Marineford. Nobody is stupid enough to say that current Luffy is beating prime WB. It’ll be a good fight though

[@why7763]

@@mariusgiurgila2595 can't you read bruh?

[@qedproqwo1634]

@@BeastBoy557 I'm not saying current Luffy beats prime white beard, but I don't think prime white beard beats current Luffy either.

[@Harem__King]

? Couldn’t hear you from all the bjs you’re giving luffy lol you main character 304.

[@yo-js1kd]

You should make a video on what would happen if current luffy (somehow) was sent back in time to when he was a kid. Not only does he have his memories of the future, but he is as strong as his current day self meaning he has access to all his gears

[@little_darknoah]

now that would be sick

[@Violet_Odorata]

Luffy would never need to be rescued by Ace and Sabo, and they'd never become brothers.

[@bcbloxxer9734]

Wouldn’t he have known the future allowing him to act weak now to have the sake brother pact made later?

[@chrisgrad9004]

​@@Violet_Odorata He said luffy retains future memories meaning he values Ace and Sabo already he would just become friends with them again.

[@Malik_Onepiece]

Bro you wanna make One punch Piece 😂

[@weebgeek98]

Ohara never disappoints 🔥🔥

[@YoAqua560]

If this happens I think that after they rescue Ace someone in the crew might suggest for a 2 year training so that the crew can develop and learn basic Haki

[@carso1500]

Honestly i think the biggest diference is simple, instead of focusing on killing ace the gorosei would likely order that now killing luffy is the most important thing since he awakened the nika nika fruit

[@bruhdj]

it would be pretty cool to see a full spin off of shank's crew from the time he gave luffy the straw hat until present day. fights with Mihawk and probably many other pirates. beating any marines that dared try, lots of drinking and parties. and just their thoughts. Also learning more about their connection to the Giants. i have a lot of questions about that. that might not be put into the actual Manga. i feel as though they were waiting for luffy for a long to time. not just Shanks.

[@aimx0205]

"Luffy's Conquerors haki infused sandals" Idk that rly cracked me up

[@iSeer_]

Ohara love your "What If" videos and other stuffs Keep up the great work❤️

[@dominiccampbell181]

I think it might be time to do an updated version of this considering the new information we have. 1. His Conquerors is knocking out way more people. 2. The moment he goes Gear 5, Kuma is going to recognize Nika, and once that gets revealed, at least half the Warlords are immediately switching sides. 3. Akainu, being the hothead he is, is probably not going to survive Marineford, especially if he keeps pursuing. Garp, Luffy, Whitebeard, Shanks and Ace all have more than enough reason to end him, especially if he tries to kill Koby.

[@gan1]

it won't end up like this. two admirals would easy diffuse luffy (low-mid diff) and then the war would play as usual, with the admirals barely damaged, even if there are less placeholder men. i don't see the warlords switching sides either, besides kuma

[@dominiccampbell181]

@@gan1 I don't think barely damaged or low diff are any comments I'd make about that fight, especially since it likely wouldn't just be a 2 on 1 for very long. Even then, the biggest difference is that Luffy has Observation and Armament Haki, so he could avoid attacks, and actually hurt the Marines this time. Especially combined with the power he's capable of generating in Gear 5. If Luffy used Conquerors before or at any point during this fight, especially now that he can actually target with it, every Marine below Vice Admiral is probably dropping. Guaranteed everyone that doesn't have Admiral of some form in their rank (rear, vice, etc.) are out. This means most of the damage Whitebeard was taking doesn't happen. As for Warlords, half of them already switched in the original. Blackbeard left before the battle even started. Jinbe had already flipped beforehand in Impel Down. Boa already flipped in canon. Crocodile, who had been helping the Marines also switched sides. Nika is going to cause Kuma to flip, and that just leaves Moria, Doflamingo and Mihawk. Mihawk is literally the only threat amongst the Warlards, and the gap between Gear 2 and 5 is massive.

[@BLLH-ih6hh]

Akainu is destroying everyone at marineford if he goes all out

[@dominiccampbell181]

@@BLLH-ih6hh No, he's not. Considering where they're fighting at, too many people would be obligated to stop him. Sengoku and Garp would have been forced into action especially where they were and the fact that Marineford was being broadcast.

[@BLLH-ih6hh]

@@dominiccampbell181 Still, Luffy wouldn’t have been able to cause that much of a difference in the war, yeah he might be able to make sure an Admiral is unable to help in the war by fighting him, but he still is too weak even now to take on any Admiral

[@someone.....]

Ace: were rivals now Luffy: rivals? Nah bro ur fodder 💀

[@someone.....]

@Abbas Alqattan Luffy: I still have haki 💀

[@KingMorgh]

The big problem I see is that Luffy would have never gotten as strong as he is without Aces death.

[@H3ndr1x]

Not really he might have been really mad but if ace never died he would still be at the same amount of strength maybe even stronger because he wouldn't be thinking about ace all the time and he could have helped them defeat kaido and luffy could train with him so he gets stronger

[@vipvip-tf9rw]

@@H3ndr1x he became strong because he got clapped by admirals, if he didn't he would try to speed run one piece

[@momentaryretrospect5967]

@@H3ndr1x Aces death was motivation and the straw that broke the camel's back for Luffy. Its what made him realize he wasn't ready for the world yet and that he needed to be stronger. He was definitely under the impression of "My crew was defeated but they're ok now I'll just meet up with them at another point and we can sail again." But Ace's death showed Luffy that he wasn't strong enough or prepared enough for the world ahead, if ace was saved then he would probably think he could handle the new world at his current level.

[@wafflepatty]

That’s why this is a hypothetical situation, a what if. If you want to make a quick custom scenario you’ll need to bend the plot a bit to fit the main idea. It’s not meant to be taken seriously

[@TR3YLovinEm]

Yeah he probably wouldn’t have haki and that’s a big part of one piece

[@SamoGonzalez_]

Love the content! Keep up the amazing work! :D

[@SGN_Maximo]

I know that Shanks might die for Luffy's character development in a way. But , a part of me really wishes that this never happens! Like seriously!!

[@adityasricharanillindala4547]

He could easily kill all the Admirals in Gear 5 form. Like in Egghead, just a hard grip was enough to make even Kizaru bleed.

[@Preddang]

This is before egg head

[@angelvillegas9604]

@@adityasricharanillindala4547 he can't beat 3 admirals at the same time

[@Rig870]

this what if is one of my favorites keep going i hope you will hit 1M

[@arhen7635]

If Luffy heard Whitebeard say ''One Piece is real'' he would quit being a pirate

[@joybwoy]

How more likely it would hype him up more do find it

[@arhen7635]

@@joybwoy when Usopp asked Rayleigh about One Piece Luffy said if he finds out anything about it he quits

[@joybwoy]

@@arhen7635 That's different he didn't told them he just say he knows where it is

[@henryjewl4885]

Bro if I heard that I would quit

[@kingcrimson8325]

@@arhen7635 the difference is that ussopp was straight up asking where it was which would deeat the purpose of "finding" the one piece thats why he said hed quit if ussopp asked

[@jules1691]

Hey Manu, Danke für das tolle Video! Eine kleine inhaltliche Anmerkung: Ohne Timeskip sind Kinemon Momo & Co noch nicht auf PH bzw generell in der timeline, sondern erst zwei Jahre später, sprich da gibts ein plot hole Auch ist die Frage offen: wann sich sie SHB auf Sabaody wieder trifft, da Kuma immernoch alle weggeschickt hat, mE könntest du da noch vorher ansetzen, dass Luffy schon auf Sabaody G5 hatte und der Clash mit Kizaru vlt anders ausging, das aber natürlich zur Folge, dass es nie zur Kooperation mit Boa & Jinbe, Ivankov und allen anderen in Impel DOwn käme. Spannendes Thema auf jeden Fall!

[@Nightsu]

Curious but do you think Luffy can warp Haki coated weapons like Yoru with gear 5? Just bend it into a knot 😂 Also think Luffys Conq haki would take out almost everyone instead of just the few like in the original war. Whitebeard still wasn't able to because of his health. The 5 Elders would also now know Luffy had the Sun God Nika fruit! Wonder what their response would be?

[@venomgaming7014]

Gear 5 luffy turned kaido into a jump rope and caught a lightning bolt. Turning a sword into a knot is little work.

[@Nightsu]

@@venomgaming7014 violating a supreme grade sword like that is rude 😂

[@venomgaming7014]

@@Nightsu 4 words: toon force is stupid.

[@Sa.D.B0]

@BigBroCook Facts It brings back creativity and the playful nature of luffy we haven't seen for a while, G5 is the perfect power up not just because of the reality altering and bending powers but from a writing standpoint as well, crocodile vs luffy and luffy vs katakuri was one of the best, honorable mention to doflamingo as well, G5 is perfect for luffy

[@Sa.D.B0]

@BigBroCook Facts It brings back creativity and the playful nature of luffy we haven't seen for a while, G5 is the perfect power up not just because of the reality altering and bending powers but from a writing standpoint as well, crocodile vs luffy and luffy vs katakuri was one of the best, honorable mention to doflamingo as well, G5 is perfect for luffy

[@GlastianEnzoKalilSMPPLJK-ko4jh]

The thumbnail looks amazing

[@AmericanGovernment274]

0:24 this to this

[@EBSD_PDB_OGFISHH]

I have oil

[@teddysama5745]

I don’t know why folks imagine a gauntlet like situation in this scenario. I don’t think that’s how it goes. Luffy simply goes gear 5 and destroys the island. Jimbei jumps in water and gets Ace. Not a single fight. It is over. They go back home.

[@obmis_arraid21]

Whitebeard could do that too, it's not that simple bruh. Whitebeard fruit is even more suited for p Mass destruction than luffy's.

[@-_-JZ]

I think there would still be a time skip but instead Luffy helps them train making the crew at least as powerful as they were at the end of the dress Rosa ark.

[@mereal5331]

After reading egghead and Luffy vs Kizaru and Saint Saturn I think Luffy wipes the floor with Aokiji and Kizaru and Akainu can't kill Ace with Luffy present. If this happens Luffy will kill Akainu very easily.

[@fonn7]

Bro if Luffy had his power from timeskip in Marineford arc. The famous Donutmaker Akainu didn't exist.

[@andriciner5428]

nice sandals drip

[@c.h.3135]

If Luffy were to join Marineford with Gear 5th, I really think they should simply have all of the WBP retreat other than the strongest of the strongest Impel Down escapees/commanders, and allow Luffy and Whitebeard to go all out with their attacks

[@Swift_Jr]

G5 without haki = the exact same outcome

[@ScalingMythos]

I think Luffy is going to teach and/or atleast showcase his power to the rest of the crew so that they can learn (I definitely see it with at least Zoro and Sanji, because Zoro was showcasing swordsmanship skills to Luffy in Wano, and Sanji is just, gonna learn. Luffy isn't capable of teaching, but once they learn the basics, they should be able to train themselves and discover new aspects). If that doesn't happen, I'd kinda like to see Luffy lose his whole crew (like in Sabaody) and then get a villain Arc. Like how Deku is in his vigilante Arc right now.

[@yonko728]

What would he show them ? I mean they cant turn into his transformation

[@ScalingMythos]

@@yonko728 I mean haki

[@IAMINSIDEYOURWALLS604]

They still can't catch up as Luffys haki growth is monstrously huge this condom boy is already top tier right now his free ain't catching up any time soon.

[@horatiuscocles8052]

@@IAMINSIDEYOURWALLS604 🤣lmao at condom boy

[@BimberTheGreat]

Ohara never fails to tear into our skin and eat our insides

[@RH10RL]

My boy is looking fresh with that buzz cut

[@IricAlexis]

i think this is already discussed a lot and most conclusion ace might survived but WB still get KO ed, since their ending/death purpose are different.

[@allout1159]

It would be interesting to see if the current Straw Hats were in Marineford

[@Cornexium]

What if Mugiwara no Goofy was in Marineford? Truly one of the theories of all time

[@Ala_tus]

That would be crazy

[@AshtonWarren]

😮

[@anthonyarbolino1260]

I’d love a “what if” video of sabo joining the war at marineford

[@chrisfit365]

These videos are addicting

[@Ascendedude]

i dont think that shanks would actually come, since people speculate that shanks can see in the future much longer than other pirates he wouldnt come since he would know that luffy was still there so koby would either just die or get saved by some other guy

[@Rystar13]

2:08 press to skip sponsor

[@creepershh4727]

Your the goat

[@catalinaserrano8930]

The most goated man in history

[@ginnungagapabyss5639]

In the one-piece red movie (spoiler alert), Shanks and Luffy decided not to face each other, even though Luffy had gear 5, so I feel like Shanks wouldn't want to face him yet. He would probably meet up with his friends, visit the same islands, and maybe defeat the same foes. It's tricky since the time skip didn't happen. So he would probably master his devil fruit before arriving at Wano, and when he first faced Kaido, instead of Kaido one shoting him, he would get up, and use gear 5 beating him, with Momo arriving on punkhazard 2 years later, too become shogun, but the land of Wano would probably reject him, since he's a child, and they probably made a new shogun within the 2 years. Sanji wouldn't be worried about big mom killing his friends, but he would probably still go to protect his restaurant family, and Luffy would defeat big mom with 2 years of mastering his power's, unless Luffy beat her before the 2 years passed by. Honestly I feel bad for the rest of the straw hats, Zoro could probably quickly catch up, and master his haki, but Sanji wouldn't have his suit to help him catch up, and the effects of the suit wouldn't evolve him. So far Jimbe would be fine, but I'm not sure if he would join, Luffy easily beating the new gen Fishman pirates wouldn't win him over, and the proficy of Luffy destroying the island will probably make him reject the idea. I guess Carrot and Yamato would join his crew. Since Momo will not be back for 2 years, and Wano is safe, the Marines would probably stay away since Luffy defeated Kaido in their first fight, and CP0 didn't show up until 2 years later. Egghead Island wouldn't have any conflict, and Luffy would probably only have Shanks and Ace as rivals going after the one piece.

[@homer4340]

So you made a whole ass theory about something non-canon

[@ginnungagapabyss5639]

@Homer the movie being Canon or non Canon was not really explained. Both the anime and manga made hints that Shanks daughter was a part of the timeline. Also, you sound like the people saying the Sanji grooming Nami moment didn't count because the movie is not a part of the main storyline, when the characters are exactly the same, just new situations.

[@ginnungagapabyss5639]

@Homer also how is it a theory, the straw hat's would be dead weight most of the journey, Luffy's fights would be far easier, and he would master his power more, and more as the time passes. Not to mention the Wano stuff, with Momo not appearing for 2 years.

[@ThepumpkinMPGOfficial]

Ace: WTF LUFFY Luffy: 😂😂😂 Pretend sabo is also here Sabo: ... The otherz:😮 Garp: what?? The admirals: WTF

[@Another_Madell]

If we consider what Vegapunk and Lucci said, Luffy could pretty much awaken Gear 5 by his will of liberating Ace and matching the wills of Nika, the liberation, so my own what if is that: Everything would go pretty much the same but, instead of being Ace the one who receives Akainu is Luffy the one that dies, Ace ends up in shock by seeing his little brother dying at Akainu’s hands and still in shock,Jinbe would try to take him and escaped together but a furious Ace would try to avenge his brother, failing in the process and keeping exposed to Akainu’s attack, a dying Luffy would see all of this and with his full will of saving Ace from being killed, the drums would start to sound, Gear 5 Luffy appears with a smile on his face, seemingly healed from his fatal injure and attacking Akainu by surprise, he would then turn him into rubber and just like with Kizaru in Egghead, Luffy would launch Akainu through the air direct to the sea, still laughing, to then take Ace and Jinbe and get has far as possible from Marineford in a ridiculous way, losing his transformation at middle of the sea, but Jinbe would take both brothers to safety. This would change some things for example, Whitebeard wouldn’t have to fight Akainu because he was yeet to the ocean by Gear 5 Luffy, but still I think Whitebeard would have died and would make Ace both angry and sad, by getting taked out of the battle by Luffy Gear 5 and couldn’t be able of doing something for his captain, this would be a huge argue between the brothers and making two timelines, in one Ace go by his way trying to preserved the ideology of Whitebeard by becoming himself in a Yonko and chasing Blackbeard for revenge and keeping distance from Luffy (because he is hothead and he would be upset with the person that saved his life) or in the other, the brothers overcome this problem together and decide to stay joined, becoming Ace an official Straw hat member, in both of this timelines Luffy would disolved temporarily the group and send them the message to reunited in three years (just like in the original, showing again in Marineford to pay respects to the fallen pirates, especially Whitebeard and then escaping along with Jinbe and Rayleigh). Passing the time skip, both brothers would reach similar strengths and in the first timeline, just like Marco and Izou, Ace becames a later ally for the Straw Hats in Wano has one of the last crewmembers from Whitebeard and still loyal to the promise that he made to Yamato, in the second Ace would be one of Luffy’s commanders and probably have a great chemistry with the other members and playing and important role during the next arcs of the story and having dominated all the types of haki and training lot more with his fruit alongside his brother, and both timelines Luffy would need a lot more time to dominate Gear 5, but instead, he would perfected Gear 4 in all his forms, dominated the types of haki and then in Wano, learn to totally control the Gear 5 just like it happen in the original timeline (just to not make everything to easy for the straw hats and to keep everyone balanced) obviously from this experience both Ace and Luffy learned a lot and matured to be a better version of themselves, becoming Ace a more pacient guy and less hotheaded (because that almost kill him and Luffy) and Luffy would tear apart (just like in the original) by the fact he literally died and is still alive just because of his devil fruit, and would be for time in constant fear of an attack from the marines and losing Ace in the process, to later grow up and overcome his fears to complete his dream, became the Pirate King!

[@iOnRX9]

i think there is a reason, akainu didn’t go after shanks marine-ford, i think shanks is far scarier than kamisari, and akainu knows it

[@TheProphetLot]

I agree

[@dddmemaybe]

I think in this case it's pretty likely Blackbeard would lose his opportunity on Whitebeard and gain one on a far-chasing Akainu in the reversal of outcomes. A sole Akainu would likely be running desperately to kill off a freed Ace just as before. But failing to do so quickly and cleanly, he would chase further and further and become isolated from the rest of the marine forces. I think he'd be assassinated by the Blackbeard crew, who lost their original target but, found a devil fruit of equal power and vulnerability out in no-man's land; caught with enemies on all sides. Imagine the damage Akainu would build up from recklessly chasing a Yonko Luffy, it can't be small as a preface to an attack sequence that could finish off Whitebeard. No pirate would help Akainu, and no marine is close enough to do anything.

[@Gamerboy-qy9tn]

Infused sandals xd

[@tonytes7336]

Spider 2099 a hops in the story and just makes ace a donut

[@FilomenaFaller-j7j]

Bro is bold😂😂😂😂

[@leonidas231]

Akainu lost to an Old Whitebeard, until he does more we cant really say how strong he is And the fact BB would stay while Ace, G5 Luffy and Whitebeard are there would lead to BBs death for sure

[@TheProphetLot]

He was suppressed when he fought an Old Wb and plus he didn't lose to Wb.

[@niagolezi]

I think that the time skip will still happen, because Kuma sent them all flying out to different area. they would need the 2 years to train and get back to sabody.

[@lesliemariearcilla3236]

nah time skip wont happen g5 luffy would absolutely clap kuma if luffy can clap akainu with g5 why not kuma? LOL A SCRAP METAL ROBOT STRONGER THAN VOLCANO BOY?

[@ghost.of.the.sharingan]

Pull alkune back in the HQ what HQ it's gone

[@Lucay9281]

Marine 1: what you doing Bro? Marine 2: Nothing, Just preparing my grave

[@imodis]

true

[@SqrlGMZ]

"shanks for watching" always gets me lol

[@WilderPierre782]

I wondering what the Marines will think about Akainu in this alternate timeline would they give him fleet admiral position🧐🧐🧐

[@blessinganwana9854]

Yes

[@TheProphetLot]

he's already fleet admiral

[@blessinganwana9854]

@@TheProphetLot not in main storyline were talking about this storyline

[@TheProphetLot]

@@blessinganwana9854 oh ok

[@fhsd1998]

If only this happened Dressrosa wouldn't have been a 200 episode long shitshow.

[@TCDdemon]

Literally

[@Meliodas-uv1tp]

G4 luffy(post wano) is beating any big the og admirals so gear 5 is more than enough for 1 or 2 of them. The real problem is garp and sengoku. Even 2 years later, garp was able to slam aokiji. A stronger garp would definitely be a threat, and luffy would definitely be a bit injured after a fight with an admiral and pretty fatigued from using gear 5. However, Marco could heal him. Garp would most likely refuse to fight luffy or at least heavily hold back and he would get tossed out of the way. That just leaves sengoku(akainu busy with whitebeard, kizaru busy with Marco and this time marco is winning because kizaru is injured by luffy and Kuzan dead or severely injured after his fight with luffy(this is bloodlusted luffy because he is fighting to save ace)). Sengoku is definitely going to be a problem(about equal to garp) even if he holds back a little. After a hard fight, luffy takes down sengoku and frees ace. At this point whitebeard is having some massive problems with akainu. Luffy rushes in but he is a bit injured and pretty tired so akainu is able to keep up, but with whitebeard helping him, luffy takes down akainu. They save ace and shanks shows up to a destroyed marine ford and a lot of dead marines. Blackbeard never gets whitebeards devil fruit because luffy helps whitebeards with akainu and whitebeard would be in much better condition since he would have to deal with all the guns and cannons(luffy could take out everyone below vice admiral with conquerors haki) so blackbeard either runs and wait for a Breyer chance, or tries to fight whitebeard and dies

[@lorddarkrai5753]

Well , this really didn't age well.

[@Meliodas-uv1tp]

@@lorddarkrai5753 luffy one shot him the second he used advanced conquerors

[@Theemptythroneistaken]

Garp would not fight luffy that's not happening sengoku would though.

[@shady30]

Gear 5 would think about wanting a donut and ace would still die

[@TheTrueMr.Chicken]

Finally, the donut maker is now the donut.

[@jaxa7550]

I think there would still be a time skip, most likely before wano, due to the lack of the strawhats strength, i think one if not more would die. Knowing Oda only one strawhat would die. That would still lead to the timeskip of the strawhats being late to having powerups so I think they would lose at Wano due to the strawhats only having post-time skip power.

[@shaneoleary9919]

Luffy would kill all 3 easy yawns

[@AcerIDK]

Here's a fun fact Luffy actually is the one piece treasure that every one trying to find Explanation: Luffy have X mark in he's chest Like Treasures these and roger said (I wish I'm in your timeline joyboy) he main Luffy's timeline and roger actually find Luffy's statue when they find one piece that's why roger and he's crew laugh Because joyboy bring happiness and joy Because Luffy is the one that Gonna change The world of one piece.

[@elitealpha3206]

😂 I also have a similar theory.. Here's what I think. One Piece isn't actually a material kind of treasure but some kind of instruction on how to bring the world together hence making it One Piece! And It's Shanks who will go and claim that instruction or so, and bring it to Luffy because he already knew the real secret behind the Gomu Gomu DF (aka Hito Hito No Mi model Nika) and he might already know that to use the One Piece treasure one must possessed the Nika Fruit or must one be Joy Boy how did he knew about this? (Roger might have told him when they return from Laugh Tale, and hence Shanks cried, it might be because the person who will change the world isn't born yet or because he isn't a member of the D clan, and from that day onwards Shanks is doing what Roger instructed him to do. Roger might have also told Shanks to only go and claim the One Piece only after Joy Boy is reveal to the world, because the One Piece treasure is useless without Joy Boy) and yeah Luffy will definitely become the Pirate king, but not by going to Laugh Tale and claiming the One Piece treasure but by Destroying the Red Line and making the World One Piece and turning the world upside down, just like it's been said... 😂 I know it's funny but please don't jump on me since it's just a theory of mine that I came up with after smoking a Joint. 😂 I hope you all will agree with me to some extend. 😁 please be open-minded and tell me how you all (those who wasted their time by reading this) think about my Theory Theory No Mi? 😂❤

[@Kozkayn]

Can you do an "If Sengoku didn't stop Garp" next?

[@notreal5265]

that was a complete and total understatement😂 if whitebeard saw younger, “aces little brother,” pre timeskip luffy with a 300mil bounty go gear 5 he would do a full on shocked enel face😂😂😂

[@KimberlyRentillo28]

Luffy hold the lightning 😂

[@sydra6723]

Gear 5 would be able to save Ace from akainu

[@TheProphetLot]

yes if he can get ace quickly and get out of there then maybe

[@KingZolomon]

0:02 Spoilers

[@omarakrimi8906]

Lol bro marineford was at 2010 are u serious 😂

[@KingZolomon]

@@omarakrimi8906 clearly not being serious lmao

[@Savagecousin]

@@omarakrimi8906wait, marineford was over 10 years ago. I feel old now, and I’m still in high school

[@Klizuo]

@@KingZolomon maybe don’t watch something about marineford before u watched it 😂

[@KingZolomon]

@@Klizuo it was just a joke, I’ve been caught up to one piece since whole cake what’s still coming out?

[@Rookt00r]

Actually if Luffy had taken the hit from Akainu he would have awakened his devil fruit sooner !

[@TheProphetLot]

no if your talking about the main storyline

[@CHOESE-j8y]

“ luffy is a complete monster” 13:30 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Subzero-official523]

In bed

[@SidXd_07]

alternate title - What if current Luffy went in the past to save ace at Marineford

[@iamphatphobic7617]

It wasnt Luffys failure that Ace died, although he blames himself. That goofball Ace basically killed himself.

[@grssam]

If we are assuming that lufy gained the power of all of gear 4 + 5 + all haki without the timeskip, then its also fair to assume that other straw hats have as well.

[@Drdavdq]

Impossible bc gear 4 is also with haki

[@grssam]

@@Drdavdq i dont think that's the point of my comment.. what exactly is impossible?

[@H3ndr1x]

​@👋 bongour but if he got haki then he could use gear 4 which is what they said

[@Eric_Tc_He]

If luffy somehow awakened gear 5 then the crew would probably be pretty strong aswell. But even if they weren’t, luffy would obviously have common sense and train his team.

[@scottrandolph6465]

bro ohara looking snazzy

[@ThePotatoCommenter]

i remember that ace quote "what the fuck"

[@johnlindsay7301]

Bring back the iconic scene analysis series, please!!!!

[@teddybear1395]

The world: -ending -facing a horrible war Gear 5 Luffy: rolling around laughing

[@telo5551]

Trop stylé la piste audio wsh😂😂😂

[@Floatzilla]

Ayoo Ohara is a Bayern fan? That's huge, and so is this what if! I believe Luffy would successfully save Ace and could even stall until Shanks arrives too

[@Izar_Sirius]

If gear5 luffy went all out, most of the marine soldiers would get knocked out in an instant because of all the conquerors haki luffy would be using. This alone is a total game changer.